Everything Wrong With The Village In 15 Minutes Or Less

[@Spencer18861]

M Night should make a movie with no twists, and that would be the biggest twist of all

[@liltree8382]

Spencer Brayman He did it’s called Avatar the Last Airbender

[@EchthelionII]

That movie had a twist, you find out about five minutes into the movie that he has never seen the show his movie was based on.

[@whitealliance9540]

His movie "after earth" was pretty straight forward. Never heard of it? Well then youre lucky af!

[@EchthelionII]

@@whitealliance9540 I thought it would be good, I was very wrong.

[@lukemacdermid2246]

@@EchthelionII I'd laugh at that joke if I wasn't so sad about Hollywood never giving that series another go because of that fucking travesty of a movie.

[@Gilgameshclone]

kale and cabbage are both winter harvest vegetables and they should be healthy full and green in autumn. It may or may not be a sin for a movie to have green fields in autumn, but it checks out horticulturally.

[@alexwolf3684]

And collard greens are best after the first frost. It cuts back some of the bitterness.

[@ashleytupper6049]

I came down to the comments so fast to see who called them out for this sin so I could I like it. This ‘sin’ alone should show people that, like most KZbin channels, they’re just playing a role with the whole ‘nit-pick movies to death’ since they don’t even bother to do any basic research; which to me is the difference between satire and real criticism. They know they’re just saying whatever comes to mind and may be proven wrong on some points within minutes of the videos going live

[@cdickson198]

Ashley Tupper ah yes. Welcome to the conclusion most everyone has come to by now. These are for fun, you’re not going to agree with all of them, and they’re not going to be perfectly accurate.

[@GmmBeast]

@@ashleytupper6049 Wow, you're upset over a wrong sin about vegetables. They're not critics, they're assholes.

[@ashleytupper6049]

Hope Morrison I’m a little confused, I never said I was upset about this sin, I just said this sin is a perfect example of why this is more of a comedy/satire channel than something to be taken seriously. And never once did I call them critics. Maybe you haven’t seen the latest trend of people making videos bashing this channel and others like it because apparently SOME people take what they say as the final word on a movie and “CinemaSins is ruining the movie industry and turning everyone negative!!” **eye roll** I just saw a good example of what I thought was this channel showing that they don’t take themselves seriously. It’s like people are not going to use CinemaSins as a source for a fact so why use it as a “critique/review” channel when it is clearly not. Ranted a little at the end there, I know 😉

[@DavidRay_40]

That last sin is invalid. Those bananas are still good. Use them to make banana bread.

[@defeqel6537]

Or just eat them like that.

[@DavidRay_40]

@@defeqel6537 that'll work, too. 😉

[@miaferrari958]

Contrary to popular belief (?) bananas are at their most edible when they have brown spots on them (these being caused by riping and not bruising, of course)

[@jayferguson9968]

I was going to type that, but waited to see if anyone else was going to. Thank you. :)

[@miaferrari958]

@@jayferguson9968 Apparently the banana-eating community was quite stirred by that comment 😂

[@fahrmboy]

8:55: Fall/Autumn IS kale and cabbage season! Maybe you've never grown anything in your entire life...

[@zaltmanbleroze]

Shots fired... now we wait for a comeback.

[@brokentombot]

Yeah, that was sinful.

[@loris466]

Oh, snap!

[@ILoveGrilledCheese]

It's not specifically kale and cabbage season, but it will grow in Autumn. So I'll partially agree.

[@prettyevil6662000]

Came looking for this comment a year later. I just planted my kale and was confused as fuck by that sin.

[@Plinnehboi]

"Looketh! It hath been Benjamin all along!", I don't know why that cracksed me up so much. But I love it.

[@connorgriffiths3174]

So, this was my first M. Night film, and at age 15, I actually quite enjoyed my first viewing it. I didn't know about his "twists" at the time, so I was actually taken aback by it.

[@Statalyzer]

But this one moved the first twist so early that it took all the drama out of the second half of the movie. The second twist was interesting, I'll give him that.

[@EchthelionII]

I only remember seeing this movie once and I didn't really like it, I thought it would be a scary/suspenseful movie, I was really disappointed that it wasn't.

[@seresimarta4436]

When I saw it I knew all along what the twist would be. I don't know why, maybe their way of speaking... I knew they were living in the present.

[@Hanibaltherogue]

İm sure you havent so go and watch Vanilla Sky, that one will blow your mind ^^

[@AngelMass]

Too bad your first shamalayan film was not sixth sense

[@inkmeal]

But if we talk about those of whom we do not speak, are we not speaking about those of whom we do not talk?

[@shaunarovinski4081]

I can't watch this movie without thinking about that one. 😂

[@Epsilon4]

Do not speak of that of about which we talk of not speaking.....about

[@americanpanda7489]

Just imagine if those of whom we do not speak met he who must not be named. Mind blown.

[@akufromthefuture7159]

I'll go ahead and say it since you wont... VOLDEMORT! ..bloody mary, bloody mary, bloody mary.. BEETLEJUICE BEETLEJUICE BEETLEJUICE!! Biggie smalls, biggie smalls, biggie smalls I just spoke of several people we dont speak of. It's going to be a nice little get together. Prolly play jenga, oujia, or dnd. Prolly dnd. The kids are asleep, so summoning more than one demon on a school night is prolly not wise..

[@jerotoro2021]

Kind of like the Jewish approach to god. They talk about him A LOT, yet are forbidden from pronouncing his name or even spelling out "god". Like a real life game of taboo lol.

[@MissCookieThief]

Not sure if anyone's pointed this out yet, but there was a book with pretty much this exact plot. I remember reading for a book report in middle school. A girl lives in an 1800s style village, but her mother tells her the truth, that it's actually the 1990s, and the protagonist has to leave the village to get modern medicine. I think stealing an idea should count as a sin, no?

[@cathydiane4802]

MissCookieThief the life of pi ripped off a short story similarly

[@Vincent_Beers]

The book was "Running Out of Time", many of Shyamalan's movies are ripped off from books or unpublished screenplays by other writers. He was even sued for stealing the script for Signs from Robert McIlhenny

[@tyleredwards1689]

MissCookieThief Running our of times the name of the book

[@illilya]

reading the plot on wikipedia for "glass", i realized it was ripping off the main elements of "final approach" as the premise, "videodrome" as the twist, and "the core" as the triumphant social ending.

[@allierawasserman675]

"Running out of Time"

[@MURFGAMING1228]

Shyamalan need to do one of two things: 1. Make a movie with no twist. Just absolutely nothing. We'll spend all our time looking for a twist that we'll watch and rewatch the film for days. 2. Make a film with his classic twists but omit his name from the credits until the end of the film.

[@dashtoroya2838]

No.1 already happened in the which is :- The Last airbender

[@Oturan20]

@@dashtoroya2838 There is no Last Airbender Movie.

[@dashtoroya2838]

@@Oturan20 I mean Nickelodeon's avatar live adaptation movie.

[@Oturan20]

@@dashtoroya2838 A significant portion of the cartoon's fandom denies it's existence, and I am one.

[@dashtoroya2838]

@@Oturan20 good for you. But as I who watched that movie, can't try to remove it out of my memory

[@JTisOneCrazyMan20]

His long sin of the twist is one of my favorite cinemasins moments. How fast he rattles off "what are there like, a hundred people here? When did the others arrive? How did they hear about it?" And "and what about noises? Anyone who's lived out in the boonies know you can hear sounds from miles away." And the fourth of July comment. Just brilliant

[@RedHeadKevin]

It's a good thing that pair of sisters grew apart, until one decided to send her kids to visit the other at her dinosaur park. Fortunately InGen also restored her sight.

[@DarthBiomech]

I saw The Village before I knew anything about M. Night, so i was spared of "saw the twist a mile away", so I genuinely enjoyed the movie. although, what would be cool is a double twist, that it would turned out that there REALLY IS something in the woods, and the rest of the humanity is extinct.

[@KryptosLounge]

thats a fun idea to play around with- that there really are creatures in the woods they were mimicking.

[@lanocty]

One of my absolute favourite movies!! Am I alone here?! Was completely creeped out when I watched it. Cried when Lucius was waiting on her porch. How can it not be released on BluRay yet?

[@twd8039]

Not alone! I was terrified when I first watched it and couldn't sleep for weeks!

[@gracehaven5459]

I liked it when I saw it, not necessarily a favorite but I still liked it enough to watch it twice so far

[@UnNuclear]

I feel like people were put off by the dialogue and a somewhat disappointing twist. I don't think it's a great (even that good tbh) movie, but I enjoyed it on my first viewing. It's also one of those movies that fun to watch with a group of friends.

[@coveruplies]

I did not think it was creepy but I love this movie :)

[@varadraigaonkar107]

I wasn't scared by the movie but I really liked it

[@kurtkyre]

There is a foreign film called Dogtooth. I think it was made in Greece. Anyway, it revolves around a father creating this completely false world for his children within the walled off house and yard where they live. The airplanes that fly overhead, are explained as being tiny toys, and the father will throw one on the other side of the yard, so the kids can find it. The rest of the film is pretty dark and creepy.

[@jamlym4974]

spoilers: I wasn't one of those people who went into this movie hoping for a horror film. But after watching it, I can't help but wish the creatures had been real. That would've been so cool.

[@locket0730]

Idk i thought it was a pretty good brain fuck

[@thatcousinshow6]

Remember when Split was a secret sequel to Unbreakable? What if The Village was a sequel to The Truman Show?

[@MOsesIcan]

That Cousin Show how so ?

[@thatcousinshow6]

@@MOsesIcan The movies have the same general premise

[@MOsesIcan]

That Cousin Show maybe the theme of the preservations of “ innocence”/ or something along the line of observing purity abstained from evil via the creation of a confined, prison like Utopia. But other than that the main character’s journey to the discovery of this lie, and what the lie is and of it self are completely different / but in compare and contrast there are certainly some similarities ... but how it could be a sequel I don’t see, not even in the right time frame, maybe a prequel? in which the director of the Truman show was raised in the village before it collapsed giving him the idea? But even then that’s a stretch

[@tomofrenchfries1793]

*X files music starts playing*

[@thatcousinshow6]

@@tomofrenchfries1793 hahahaha

[@ghostcityshelton9378]

At--2:23--- If those are Pine trees in the background then they stay green all year round.

[@JimmyMon666]

And those are pine trees. He lives in Tennessee doesn't he? He should know this. I lived in Virginia when I was in the military and it was green all year round there because of the pine trees.

[@ghostcityshelton9378]

@@JimmyMon666 You are right, Pine Trees stay green all year round.

[@socialgarlic]

yeah evergreen trees are a thing in the south

[@Dargonhuman]

What if they're not Pine trees though? What if they're Evans trees or Hemsworth trees? You don't know.

[@cliftonjames785]

They dont look like your average pine trees, which would be ponderosa pine. They look more like spruce or Douglas fir

[@albinocadillac]

I love that rocking chair moment. Comedy gold

[@TheTheater4life]

One of the things that I loved about this movie was the real reason that Ivy was sent to cross the border. It wasn't just because she wanted to, it wasn't just because Lucius was HER fiance, it wasn't even about the fact that she hadn't taken the oath. She was sent BECAUSE she is blind. She can't see the modern towns once she climbs over the wall. She wouldn't be confused or tempted by what was outside the village. They can keep their lifestyle even if Ivy knows the monsters aren't real because she still believes that they COULD exist. The movie shows us that. (When she encounters "A creature" that attacks her & kills it but can't see what it really is.) It's really a great addition to the story & I'm kinda annoyed that CinemaSins just glosses over it & keeps repeating "Why send the Blind Girl???"

[@chuckgeek3637]

I know right ! I found this review video dumb af. Leaving people who never even watched the movie with bad assumptions.

[@dravidianking1298]

@@chuckgeek3637 I understand if people make fun of it because it is an absurd notion that deserves to be mocked, however clever it may be. It highlights the hypocrisy of the town founders when the dad is willing to possibly sacrifice one of his daughters (who is blind) in order to keep up the facade of “innocence” that benefits him and the other higher ups. The whole irony of the situation is reflected in the absolute ridiculousness and backwardness of the whole situation to the perspective of normal people like us. It was meant for the audience to be shocked at how disgusting the situation was; some people just express that by calling it stupid and making jokes.

[@mojmov6128]

But one thing he mentioned that kinda ruined the whole movie for me was that there's literally no reason that an elder cannot get the medicine. It would be the easiest most convenient option...

[@Utilizador-gs3lx]

I mean to be fair they could have sent an Elder to buy the medicine

[@nileverdeen3797]

@@Utilizador-gs3lx nope, they are bound by the oath.

[@fionabrennan9148]

People dismiss “The Village” ? Bro I freaking love this movie

[@causeeffect7624]

the premise, loved. the delivery, meh

[@monstergonzo6456]

You not only love this movie but freaking love this movie? That's worth a bunch of sins right there DING DING DING DING DING

[@GyeongmiBaeb]

Well he did say people and you're just one person

[@MsabResearch]

@@GyeongmiBaeb there's plenty others who praise it for what it really is. There's a few outstanding analysis out there that I recommend you to watch. It might change your view about this movie.

[@MovieDirector101]

Ikr everything people dis about this movie has a story behind it. Like in this video the guy says those ladies must hate roses but it reflects to us that we know that we aren’t supposed to have the colour red. Everything this guy says in the video has somethings behind it. I hate how people keep hating on the village, it’s my favourite movie

[@graham1035]

I was waiting for a "Discount Jesse Eisenb...oh shit!" At 0:36. For letting me down, I sin you. Also, I didn't notice that was Jesse Eisenberg until this video.

[@brokentombot]

That's the plot twist.

[@causeeffect7624]

i figured he'd point that out, too.

[@alexdelossantossubirats869]

14:43 those bananas are still in perfect shape, it is the ideal time to eat them. Throwing them would have been the sin

[@ronburgendy8394]

thank you. these were nowhere near bad. perfect time to eat them.

[@johnjsal]

Ha ha. I agree. I like them softer, and that's usually after they've started to darken.

[@GeryonM]

If you keep them until they are black they'll make a very delicious banana bread.

[@BlufLeather2892]

Just throwing in my lot with the folks who recognise good bananas.

[@WatchMeDIYIt]

👍🏽

[@ThyJebusBeDone]

I'm always going to have a soft spot for this movie because I first watched it when I was 11 and the monsters actually did scare the absolute fuck out of me. My dad had to explain the plot twist to me so I suppose 11 year old me grew up thinking it was an epic one. The monsters still give me the goosebumps.

[@Backinblackbunny009]

I was 20 when I saw it and very disappointed bc the design of the creatures was so cool.

[@hunterwilder9665]

Doesn’t calling the creatures “those we don’t speak of” technically count as speaking of them?

[@pog428]

Not if the purpose is to as seldom as possible name them

[@zotharr]

"Do not speak of that of about which we talk of not speaking... about."

[@TheREALBOJACK]

Some personal ideas to improve this movie, IMO: - *_All_* the parents know about the ruse - The secret is something you're clued into upon coming of age (Santa Claus rules, basically) - The monster and the woods are just a fact of life, completely accepted, not _really_ focused on, just more of a framing device/fantasy world (at first) - The story is told from the perspective of a kid (somewhere from 15-17) who doesn't know why everyone changes as soon as they turn 18 after going through some kind of "ritual" (where they're actually told the truth), and they have to stop hanging out with the younglings who they see as "immature", basically hating them for continuing to be fooled by it, instead of themselves for being fooled for so long - The main character sees their best friend basically start hating them, and doesn't want to just sit around and wait to be "changed" on _their_ 18th birthday, so they run away out into the woods, even though they still think the monster's totally real - Adventures for a while, maybe has to run from members of the village (looking for them in disguise as the monster so the ruse doesn't get ruined) and , when being chased by that elder (maybe even one of their parents) gets hit by the car, the twist reveal is complete, the "monster" takes off their mask revealing the parent, cut to black. *_BOOM_* Tell me that wouldn't be a better movie, lol.

[@TheMasterVictory]

bow, you just need founding

[@Seallussus]

It's not a bad idea but just not for THIS movie at all. Sure it's terrible but it was going for another story altogether.

[@AsDeft]

That wouldn't be a better movie, lol.

[@TheREALBOJACK]

@@AsDeft Shit, you got me.

[@85flintstone]

That’s a shit idea.

[@CatMuto]

"Those we don't speak of" - Oh, god, is it the spawns of Voldemort?

[@1SingleT]

No, it's evil M from Arthur

[@im1who84u]

No, it's the dreaded and feared..... Hildabeast! So feared that it drives its enemies to suicide.

[@ImNorman]

Wait, she is blind and has never seen, or assuming touched, one of those they don't speak of, so how, after one touch of a "claw", does she know it is one of them?

[@ChulsZFF]

A combo of myth description and the warning of the father about not screaming. Also, when they came into the village people saw them and probably described them.

[@AnthonySforza]

Yea... I was going to say something about the somber mood upon revealing the costume to her. I mean, I'd either think "Holy shit, it's one of the ones we don't speak of" or... I don't know, an eagle? Though given the nature of how everyone's terrified of them, that was probably the right place to knee jerk to.

[@Malidictus]

What was the point of making her blind in the first place? It only creates plot holes like this without serving an actual narrative purpose. Maybe it could work for some kind of self-important metaphor, but it's a millstone around this story. The actress doesn't act blind half the time, either.

[@AnthonySforza]

@@Malidictus I think the purpose of making her blind was to kind of give her an advantage in which to progress her story upon. Whereas she's never seen the color red or anything of the sort, so her not being able to see the "Monsters" much less the color red, it gives her more confidence to carry out the journey, whereas some other guy or woman would see the glade of red flowers and shit themselves, due to what red is supposed to mean in their culture. So it's kind of like the development of character to take something most people would find as a weakness and turn it into a superpower, so to speak.

[@GullibleTarget]

Ivy knows what things are, by touch. You can't fool her by for instance, placing a wooden pencil in her hand and say it's just a piece of wood. When she felt the claw, she realised it was all fake. On her way to the towns, she KNEW that the monster had to be fake but she has been brought up to believe that they were real. For the first time, she had to draw on her knowledge instead of her long held beliefs in order to survive. Lucius means 'enlightened'. Lucius knew the truth and was purposely made crazy in order to keep the secret going.

[@chuckcarter4251]

At this point I am willing to pay to see an interview with your college girlfriend .... seriously 😒 😂🤣

[@SupportMensMentalHealth]

Me too, that would be some epic sins

[@Bruh-hq1hx]

I believe the college girlfriend never existed jeremy definetly had or has a girlfriend but definetly not in college

[@roguishpaladin]

It would be a nice April Fools gimmick to get some actress or other female host to act as his girlfriend and sin a movie in his place.

[@SuperBeanson]

I've got to say that I absolutely love this movie.

[@HTPCYMC]

They charge too many emeralds for their products.

[@isakabrahamsson8776]

Agreed

[@vAqeii]

@HARPER DODD gasp

[@CreativeWorkflowHack]

DUDE STOP GETTING INTO ALL MY SHIT SERIOPSYÖXYLP KFÖJKLEismjöflgibahjypörl

[@RoboHobo9200]

there you are i found you!!

[@2000Meilen]

HRMMH (Villager Noise)

[@Transilvanian90]

I really enjoyed the Village, it creates a cool atmosphere throughout and raises some interesting questions.

[@DeadlyDanDaMan]

I think you mean "plot holes", not "questions". Smfh.

[@zotharr]

It's an atmosphere I never encountered before and ever since :)

[@spagetti001]

yeah, like "how the fuck did anyone think this was a good idea?"

[@pog428]

I believe that you have to have a God given soul to appreciate and like this movie

[@Transilvanian90]

@@pog428 Yeah, you have to be able to place yourself in the film, and see things from the characters' perspective. Some people sadly can't seem to do that...

[@the8jrfan]

I’ve been hit in the nuts plenty of times but I’ve never had them bruised. I couldn’t even imagine the pain.

[@conormurphy4328]

You have to be into a very specific kind of bdsm subcategory for that to be possible.

[@jasonblalock4429]

@@conormurphy4328 Or just a football player. *Ze cups! Zey do nothin-k!*

[@mystic_tacos]

It fucking hurts! And no, not BDSM, slipped climbing a fence out hunting... Enough said lol

[@tyronequinn]

It's more luck based tbh. Some cunt of a lad in my school kicked me as a "joke" got me put in hospital. They almost had to perform surgery on me. Scary shit

[@nitoyep3366]

I was riding a bike down a grassy hill, hit a rock, the bike stopped moving but i slid forward off the seat at full speed, slammed my nuts on the bike frame, they bruised

[@tracy406]

Take the sin away for the kale and cabbage in autumn. They're both cool weather plants and arent planted until July & are harvested in autumn. Have you never grown anything in your life?

[@renelagreze9351]

That is really a great movie, saw it several times and i do enjoy it, its probably the best from that director. The great ambient, the living reconstitution of the village with its residents, the mistery going thicker, the suspense, the incredible end, the hypnotic music with that aerial violin, its just great. And also, it brings a philosophical message: the people came here to isolate themselves from tresspassers and from their past, and it worked, but finally what they where running away from: the violence and insanity, came back, not from the exterior, but from inside their ideal world, showing that it was, in fact, useless to run away. But at the same time, from inside the village came also what human nature has in best: a loving community, a sincere and strong love between young people. Thus the phisolofical message is that you can't run away from reality of human nature, you cant run away from yourself, but you have to face reality of your nature, to manage the dark sides and magnify the beautifull ones. Thats what they do when Ivy survives her terrific trial, redemption beyong courage; thats what they realise and accept, in the end, when they all stand up to go on their adventure in the village, but the best and the worst. They become taller. Of course you can make a list of "fails" errors, etc, yes, but what is the interest? its a fiction, it doesnt have to be realistic, you enter and live the story and the movie or not, thats all. Got people in my family who found it boring, even ridiculous, why not? i just complain them because they didnt spend a great moment like i did and where not sensitive to the rightfull message it brings. They propably will enjoy another movie. Sorry for the approximative english, watch great movies! :)

[@ShadowAkatora]

"Little cult on the prairie" lol xD

[@PassTheMarmalade1957]

So true about this movie seeming kind of cool the first time you watch it, then stupid the second time. At first you think that it has to be Ivy who goes into the outside world because she can't see, so she won't be able to blow the whistle about what the outside world is really like. Then you realise that one of the Elders could have gone.

[@roguishpaladin]

I haven't watched the movie after my first viewing despite mildly enjoying it the first time around, and now I'm glad I haven't. Easy way they could've fixed that plothole, too - make all the elders actually elderly and unable to walk long distances. I like Hurt and Weaver a ton, but maybe this movie needed Christopher Lee and Maggie Smith instead.

[@JustKelso1993]

No, if I remember correctly it was forbidden to go past the borders, not even the Elders were supposed to. They would have let him die before they let the lie fall apart, that is why she went. They only allowed it at all because she was blind and would not have caught on. If I also remember correctly her father is a big reason that they even allowed it.

[@PassTheMarmalade1957]

@@JustKelso1993 Except it was forbidden for Ivy to go, too, hence why her father went against the other Elders and sent her himself. He also sent two escorts with her. Escorts *who could see.* Maybe he knew that they would end up abandoning her and wouldn't reach the park rangers, but that's a big gamble to take, plus it ensures that his blind daughter will end up alone and vulnerable in the middle of the woods. If he was willing to break the rules to send Ivy, he should have been willing to break the rules to do the sensible thing and just go himself.

[@JustKelso1993]

@@PassTheMarmalade1957 Not as obviously as you may think. He clearly loved his daughter, but I really think he would have let her die to keep the secret safe. Think about how hard it was to build that place and to keep it secret. Plus his other daughter was there. I always felt like it was one of those awful choices that had to be made one way or the other. I might be imagining this too, but I thought there was something mentioned at some point about if she didn't come back it would verify the story of the monsters, like they fully expected her to die and not come back, not sure though.

[@enigma1863]

I thought maybe the elders were famous since they clearly had a lot of money. The rangers might recognize them but I cant imagine them letting a blind girl go back in the middle of the woods. Even if she convinced them to let her go someone could follow a blind girl back to the village.

[@deja3963]

This man sinned the damn trees. Edit: Leafy greens grow well in the colder months lol

[@janinosaurus]

Deja W thank you! I grow kale and Swiss chard in the winter.

[@Alhalmeya]

his sins r terrible

[@kevk9306]

@@Alhalmeya why tf are you here then?

[@cannibalbunnygirl]

@@kevk9306 for your charming fkn company, obviously

[@Ocrilat]

Some trees have fall colors, and some trees have summer colors, which makes no sense. As far as the gardens, with no wire fences and no pesticides, those vegetables would not look so perfect...they look like they just got replanted from a greenhouse.

[@battymu]

I don't care what anyone says - I loved this movie. Sorry, not sorry

[@thischannelisabandoneditwa8994]

Yes. Exactly.

[@lartensgrill6106]

Me too. Amazing film

[@zacktyler485]

Definitely interesting cool concept

[@damian-.]

same

[@spagetti001]

but it's objectively bad

[@2Ten1Ryu]

Thank you for aknowledging the love story in this movie. Those are the scenes I rewatch the movie for. It's just beautiful, as is the soundtrack. I love it.

[@RhiffRhaff]

Those bananas are perfect for eating, why would you throw them out?

[@adventurebonni5]

Because they put banana on the refrigerator too long like 5 days still put here . Maybe will be fold , that why is a sin .

[@sharilshahed6106]

@@adventurebonni5 They look surprisingly fresh for "5 days old" bananas put on fridge, though.

[@adventurebonni5]

@@sharilshahed6106 I guess you're correct .

[@B3R_B0T]

Banana bread ftw

[@annebruecks7381]

Amber Shannon They can even get browner for banana bread, Exactly! Lol

[@orchidrose1410]

Remember there are several lies that the elders told; those we don’t speak of, the town is dangerous filled with murderers, and what century they are living in. Sending the blind girl for medicine was the smartest thing they could do and still maintain the ruse. Either way at least one of their lies will remain.

[@daffodil852]

Or an elder who already knows the secret could go. Like the rich Walker elder whose money was used to create their village

[@1Nice1Guy5]

Those bananas were perfectly edible what the frick man

[@perditusthornatus2718]

Did you know you can refrigerate bananas? Their peels turn brown FASTER, but the banana inside stays good longer. My point being, don't judge a banana by its peel.

[@pervyturtle2673]

"Germanic Pixie Dream Girl" I choked on my coffee

[@StuartLloyd]

I actually liked the Village.

[@stanj85]

I remember seeing this in a theater. I also remember regretting seeing this in a theater.

[@thatcousinshow6]

Hahahahaha

[@justjeffrson489]

I low-key love this movie but I would have left too If I were to have seen this in theaters.

[@MinscS2]

Same here. This movie is the closest I've ever been to walking out of the theater before the movie ends. Too bad that the movie was almost over at the time, so there was no point in leaving. If you've wasted 1h40 min, you might as well waste 5 more min...

[@GooseFlerken]

Now i remember me too regret buying ticket for this shitty movie

[@julz3tt3]

stanj85 So do I

[@NewMessage]

The Robot Chicken M. Night Shyamalan didn't pop out from behind a tree at the big reveal and shout "What a twist!" **DING**

[@roguishpaladin]

That was the real twist.

[@knowsgold2798]

I use this line all the time and no-one ever gets it

[@MarloSoBalJr]

LOTS AND LOTS OF AERIAL TWISTS!!

[@cabellero1120]

This movie was ...Strange, to say the least, it was eerie and yet captivating.

[@merenemo97]

The Village has been one of my favourite movies since as long as I can remember. . . However I have to applaud this video, it made me laugh and love the movie even more! Bravo man, bravo!

[@christinekoper2407]

I never noticed that ridiculous pants and belt situation and it’s KILLING ME 😂😂

[@zarinaa1135]

You guys are the best!!! Keep up the great work!!! Please do: 1) The Circle 2) Narnia 2 and 3 3) The Princess Bride 4) Speed 5) The Truman Show 6) Shrek 4 7) The Huntsman Winters War 8) Tropic Thunder 9) Back to the future 3 10) Re-post LOTR 3

[@bradensmith2907]

While I HATE some of M. Night's movies (After Earth, Last Airbender, The Happening ect cetera), I think the Village and Signs are really underrated.

[@JimmyMon666]

Agreed. And Unbreakable as well. He was in his prime back then. Not anymore sadly.

[@endlessevanescence3502]

@@JimmyMon666 He's kinda come out of his rut lately. _The Visit_ was decent, but _Split_ was amazing, in my opinion (and that's mostly thanks to the phenomenal actor who plays the beast, James Mckavoy). _Glass_ has got to keep up that kind of momentum.

[@Schwedeballz]

Split was really good

[@archmage7813]

Ugh. Both of those are terrible!

[@jakegwolford]

I'm in the minority, but I really enjoy this film. There's a nice balance between suspense and character interactions. And featuring a central character with a learning disability is pretty novel.

[@KidSnivy69]

I agree about character, I call complete bulllshit on the movie being suspenceful.

[@Alhalmeya]

i really like it too

[@llGarnettoll]

Jake Wolford I love this movie too! There’s a really beautiful love story in it. The porch scene is one of the best scenes ever! Very touching, and helped even further by the beautiful soundtrack. It’s a shame the silly “those we do not speak of” were more a central theme. It should have been marketed as a romantic drama and not a “horror.”

[@Swagtastic_sai]

Believe it or not, you're part of the majority.

[@beautyonabarnbudget]

This movie is one of my favorites ever!!! Just based on the visuals alone. Luv it so much

[@KabeerKishore]

“Zing away, Merrill. Zing away” is probably the best line I’ve ever heard.

[@MOsesIcan]

I personally like this movie / but above all I love the music for this film.

[@reneee.6076]

Moses Moon The music is phenomenal. I still listen to it.

[@MOsesIcan]

Renee Edwards thank you!

[@aquiline-eagle9669]

The music is better than the movie

[@reneee.6076]

Yep, much better than the movie. The ending was such a let down. I would have preferred if the monsters were real and the time period was really the 19th century (or whatever time period it was).

[@Garyllaz]

The ending credits track is one of the best pieces of violin music ever recorded...

[@wumbosaurus9121]

"His will to live is very strong." Glad he hasn't lost the will to live *Cough* padme *Cough*

[@CodyRushDriving]

4:56 I remember this scene causing a legit sense of fear. We were all expecting a twist, but not that the monsters were real! Honestly this is an underrated scene.

[@Sandrilyonaify]

I’ve always liked this movie) it is beautiful, with great soundtrack, good cast and good mythos. I never watched other Shamalan flicks before I saw it first so I wasn’t looking for a twist and it worked for me.

[@thehat2243]

10:06 You are literally leaving a blind girl alone in an icy forest to save your own skin. You sir are more evil than Darth Vader🤣

[@Wolfencreek]

This was the first M Night movie I watched and I didn't know anything about twist endings. So the ending was actually pretty interesting from my point of view.

[@aneru9396]

0:35 I didn't know Lex Luther and the FaceBook guy shared the same ancestor from the village.

[@COBfan1996]

The bananas were fine though

[@dontsubscribetothischannel8496]

True

[@andrewharvey3282]

>you don't love your daughter, you love creating dramatic movie moments... Just like your director! >He's Adrian Brody, a mentally disabled person, ahhh, this is what keeps me coming back

[@kimberleysmith818]

William Hurts voice has always been amazing. I need him and Paul Bettany to read me poetry.

[@sgz5256]

Pulp fiction or train spotting next!

[@theblackbaron4119]

;) there is nothing wrong with pulp fiction. I definitely would want to see an everything wrong :D

[@theblackbaron4119]

@thistubeisfucked I was obviously joking. I know

[@jamesgreen6430]

Lady in the water. Keep this Bryce Dallas Howard training going!

[@timeghost82]

Trainspotting is the perfect movie. Don't you dare

[@j9rd115]

'You wrote it for moments and gave logic and reason the finger while doing so'. Which kind of sums up the problem with 99% of hollywood's features

[@scriptosaurusrex]

Those Bananas are perfectly fine.

[@MST3Killa]

Yup.

[@ProductBasement]

10:58 Fun fact, her blindly touching something and having this reaction were originally shot for a deleted wedding night scene when Lucius first pulled down his pants

[@khaleesiamde6215]

The movie isn't meant to been believable. It's a statement on any society's willingness to accept anything at face value without question.

[@1236547899874563211]

No shortage of sins. But at least it's watchable. Can't say that for every M. Night movie!! That being said, "zing away merril" and "deus ex joaquina." INSTANT classics!

[@kq1337]

Wait... how you comment 21 hours ago say on god bruh lmao

[@Gumbus]

1236547899874563211 How Did You Comment 21 Hours Ago

[@infectionponch]

1236547899874563211 this is some M. Night Shyamalan shit.

[@nateeden258]

You know what that means right? ......A WITCH! BURN THE WITCH!!

[@dereklewis4321]

Early access

[@error13_genderexpunged]

This movie is actually one of my favorites. Ik it's a little unrealistic at times for the sake of suspense but personally I think the payoff is better, ig I just have a thing for slow burns, also im the only one who the end twist caught me TOTALLY off guard? I'm seeing everyone saying how obvious it was but it actually blew me away and left me scratching my head, it was the first movie I DIDN'T understand the first time I watched it. And I liked it. Personally I think this film was executed greatly. Maybe it was because I watched it with new eyes, I didn't see the bad and misleading promotion in 2004, I didn't see Night's "bad streak", I just saw the film for what it was standalone, which is what I think what alot of people hate it for, more so it's reputation and look at it how they did in 2004 without taking a fresh look at it. Anyways sorry for this silly tangent, just my 2 cents

[@Harkness78]

It's ok if you were suckered by this movie and thought you enjoyed it, but one of your favorites? Like top 20?

[@error13_genderexpunged]

@@Harkness78 yes, it is, no need to be condescending about it

[@JustKelso1993]

I liked it too. Watched it as a kid, it freaked me out.

[@luckybynn5788]

THEY ARE MAKING BANANA BREAD

[@emperorreign6154]

I saw the movie again for the first time in several years the other day and it was surprisingly better than I remember. I still thought the twist was lame and it would’ve been better if it turned out there WERE creatures in the woods after all. But it’s well acted, beautifully shot, and I appreciated how morally complex the story was. Ironically I remember HATING it when I was younger 😂😂But it’s a pretty good movie. It’s quite incredible how anyone can claim it’s in the ‘Lady in the water’ or ‘happening’ levels of bad.

[@danielcossey9118]

Personally I loved Lady in the Water when I watched it as a kid. But maybe thats because I didn't see any of the commercials that marketed it as a monster movie for some reason

[@kennethroberts8084]

I love me some Lady in the Water. I don't understand why people don't like it.... Now had you said After Earth or Avatar: The Last Airbender I would feel ya, bruh.

[@HuntingViolets]

I liked it until the twist.

[@MrArrylay]

7:55 LOL great line! I can actually picture Lucius doing CinemaSins. Wow he really pics this movie apart. Love your work.

[@thomatoman]

I actually enjoyed this movie a great amount. Definitely mostly because of how beautiful it's shot but I still thought it was solid

[@christopherjakel1049]

All the trees in the background appear to be Ever Greens. They are called Ever Green for a reason. "Sin yourself fool"

[@TawanaEvangeline]

The trees look like that in Georgia well into November so unless they specified what state the village was in, it’s possible

[@esta1ful]

Tawana Morvan pennsylvania

[@ocularnervosa]

Most of the trees in the background are oaks not pines. They would have lost their leaves around the same time as the one in the foreground.

[@franss94]

Those bananas are still good

[@jondw]

A possible explanation (granted I havn't seen the movie so I could be totally off) for the sounds of the 21st century could be explained as just noises the monster makes sometimes

[@riceracm]

“Satanface McPuppetmaster” is my new word 🤣🤣 fun fun fun

[@kimkall5350]

I love you plugged your own book for sin 18, Jeremy! That is freaking awesome!

[@FreshSpecimens]

Hahahahaha! He called Pitt “Murder By Numbers.” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@CodyCzar1]

Those are still perfectly edible bananas.

[@MST3Killa]

I guess these are the kinds of people who see a spot on a banana and immediately throw them away thinking they've turned poisonous or something.

[@just-a-silly-goofy-guy]

The village should have been a hamlet, it would’ve been easier to destroy

[@vAqeii]

_oh yes_

[@gracehaven5459]

Na Titus Andronicus

[@sagacity1071]

Slowly... Gently... That is how a sin is taken....

[@Yeraus]

@@sagacity1071 Curious is the sin-makers art... his efficacy unwitnessed by his own eyes.

[@ireneuszthesecretlifeofpet3881]

PASSENGERS 2 THE HAPPY STAR SCARE SPACE

[@felixkneidl2469]

05:21 "Looketh, it hath been Benjamin all along!!" I nearly died there :D

[@LadyOnikara]

Yep, if you live in a quiet area in the country, you can hear things miles away. Sometimes I hear our closest neighbors talking or listening to TV or the radio. It's not too clear sometimes but I am usually careful about what I say in our yard just in case.

[@brandonm5731]

"They only got two takes before it ate her" Thanks for making me choke on my drink hahahah

[@Mysteroo]

"This is the book of Romans boiled down into a single sentence" I'm a dude with a Biblical studies minor. Lol'd

[@richarddonohue4381]

Mysteroo glad you could find a use for a degree in biblical studies even tho just reading Romans is enough to understand the joke

[@amphibiangoddess]

@@richarddonohue4381 Rude. Leave this man alone, dang. At least he is seeking higher education. You feel better talking down to others?

[@richarddonohue4381]

@@amphibiangoddess yes. It's par for the course with Christianity.

[@amphibiangoddess]

@@richarddonohue4381 or maybe you're just a dick that makes KZbin a worse place for genuinely good people. And your comeback is garbage. If you're an atheist you make all of us look bad.

[@vaultrant2499]

The biblical studies minor vs the minor "studying" priest

[@peachesandcream.2612]

At some point into the film I suddenly thought that one of the actor's clothes looked strangely more like modern-day clothing than late 1800s - then it dawned on me!

[@Valen5878]

hey man, thanks for the scary images warning! i still like listening to jeremy's voice and it's nice to have a warning so i can do something else in the meantime

[@leland-bobpalmer4274]

Ok your humor shines in this..not in most per-se but in this. Most are Dad jokes but in this you combine wit with reference beyond the Kevin Smith Thresh-hold

[@leland-bobpalmer4274]

"Make the village great again" Hats off to you there sir! 1:04 Except in reality it is "all we speak of"

[@g0tm04]

Yo! Pants didn’t always have belt loops

[@Vampwars]

One of the best possible twists to this movie would’ve been for Those We Don’t Speak Of to have actually been real but always on the outskirts & to find out that they protected the villagers from the outside world. It would’ve also been a kind of beautiful payoff if they had come to Ivy when she was in the woods, scared & alone because she can’t see them & because she’s pure. They could’ve escorted her to the place she goes for help & then escorted her back to the village, telling her she could either tell them about the creatures or live as they always had. It would’ve been like the Big Bad Wolf safely escorting Little Red Riding Hood to Grandma’s house, you know? But then I’m probably adding that to it because I love sweet things because I was raised on Disney movies & like for things to end up with everyone being friends 🤣 Truth be told, I just wanted to SEE the actual Creatures because out of focus, the costumes kinda look like a Skeksis mixed with either Manbearpig or a Werewolf, depending on which costume is shown. Also, were they based off of Wendigos or multiple myths & legends combined? I liked this movie but it was mainly because of the brilliant performances of Joaquin Phoenix & Bryce Dallas Howard. But then again I also really enjoyed “Lady in the Water”, “The Visit”, “The Sixth Sense”, “Unbreakable”, “Split” & most of “Glass” (except that ending) 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@GeorgeCoghill]

When this first came out, there was a review for this movie on a message board that still makes me laugh to this day: “Amish Matrix”.

[@5117danielle]

This was the only movie that I wanted to walk out on.

[@Alyssa_Rayne]

This movie is amazing how dare youuuu😂

[@ponyworld1255]

Sin 65 at 9:00 mark. Um.... Cabbage is a winter crop. It grows in the fall and is harvested in late fall.early winter. Kale grows all summer and fall.

[@Jordan-vr7ip]

Holy shit i never even realized Mark Zuckaberg was in this 0:37

[@jbvader721]

I was so disappointed there was no "Discount Jesse Eisen-holy sh**!" Sin.

[@prayanklalan5138]

That "make the village great again" gag in itself earned you that ding on the like button. I generally reserve my likes until after a thorough viewing and assessment. Never have I ever hit the like button so impulsively!

[@judsongaiden9878]

Any society built on ignorance will eventually self-destruct. Innocence is a lack of experience and is therefore not a virtue, but ignorance is worse.