Fact-Checking Robert Spencer

Support Blogging Theology on Patreon:
/ bloggingtheology
My Paypal Link:
www.paypal.com/paypalme/blogg...

[@IsmailSarkaya-ll4ts]

🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:02 🔍 Introduction and context of the debate 01:10 📖 Deuteronomy 13:6-9 and its commandment 03:14 📚 Robert Spencer's claim on Old Testament law 06:03 📖 Jesus' stance on the Jewish law 09:43 📜 Matthew 5:17-20 and Dale B. Martin's interpretation 16:09 🕊 Paul's conflicting views on the law 18:01 📜 Acts 21 and James' adherence to the law 21:12 ⛪ Church views on the law through the centuries 24:38 🔥 Execution of Michael Services and Apostasy in Christianity 27:47 📜 The Upholding of Jewish Law in Early Christianity 29:06 🕊 Evolution of Christian Views on Apostasy and the Death Penalty 31:12 🌐 Diversity of Christian Beliefs and Practices - [00:02](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7c) 🔍 Introduction and context of the debate - Context of the video and the debate between Muslim and Christian participants. - Focus on Robert Spencer's statements and the need for fact-checking. - [01:10](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7c) 📖 Deuteronomy 13:6-9 and its commandment - Explanation of the commandment in Deuteronomy 13:6-9. - Emphasis on the severity of the punishment for apostasy as outlined in the Jewish Bible. - [03:14](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7c) 📚 Robert Spencer's claim on Old Testament law - Robert Spencer's assertion that Old Testament law doesn't apply to Christians. - The claim that Old Testament law was never applied to Christians. - [06:03](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7c) 📖 Jesus' stance on the Jewish law - Examination of Jesus' statements in Matthew 15 regarding the Jewish law. - Highlighting the conflict between Jesus' stance and Paul's view on the law. - [09:43](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7c) 📜 Matthew 5:17-20 and Dale B. Martin's interpretation - Detailed discussion of Matthew 5:17-20, where Jesus emphasizes the importance of the Jewish law. - Reference to Dale B. Martin's interpretation supporting the idea that Jesus upheld the law. - [16:09](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7c) 🕊 Paul's conflicting views on the law - Paul's contradictory stance on the Jewish law as seen in his writings. - Paul's teachings that the law, including food laws, was abolished. - [18:01](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7c) 📜 Acts 21 and James' adherence to the law - The historical account in Acts 21 where James and his followers upheld and practiced the Jewish law. - The contradiction between Paul's beliefs and his actions in Acts 21. - [21:12](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7c) ⛪ Church views on the law through the centuries - The endorsement of the death penalty for apostates by figures like Thomas Aquinas in the 13th century. - John Calvin's role in upholding the importance of the law in the 16th century. - [24:38](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7cm38s) 🔥 Execution of Michael Services and Apostasy in Christianity - Michael Services, influenced by Islamic and Jewish arguments, challenged the Trinity within Christianity. - John Calvin, a prominent Evangelical leader in Geneva, ordered Michael Services' execution for heresy and apostasy. - Calvin's execution of Michael Services illustrates that in the 16th century, leaders of major Christian denominations upheld the death penalty for apostasy. - [27:47](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7cm47s) 📜 The Upholding of Jewish Law in Early Christianity - Early Christianity, including leaders like James in the New Testament, upheld the Jewish law. - Matthew 15: Jesus criticizes the Pharisees for not upholding Jewish law, specifically citing the requirement to execute someone who speaks evil of their parents. - The New Testament suggests that Jesus himself upheld the Jewish law, including the laws found in Deuteronomy 13:6-9. - Thomas Aquinas in the Catholic Church and John Calvin also defended and implemented aspects of the Old Testament law in their teachings and actions. - [29:06](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7cm06s) 🕊 Evolution of Christian Views on Apostasy and the Death Penalty - In the 21st century, many Christian denominations no longer uphold the death penalty for apostasy. - The Second Vatican Council in the 1960s brought significant changes to Catholic Church teachings, moving away from endorsing death penalties. - Pope Francis updated the Catechism to reject the death penalty in any circumstances. - While contemporary Christianity has evolved its stance on apostasy and the death penalty, historical examples reveal that this wasn't always the case. - Modern shifts are often attributed to influences of secular liberalism and post-Enlightenment Western thought. - [31:12](kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3Wlm6Ooa86Ur7cm12s) 🌐 Diversity of Christian Beliefs and Practices - Christianity has a long history with a diversity of beliefs and practices, including the view on apostasy and the death penalty. - Contemporary Christian denominations can differ in their teachings and interpretations of biblical passages, resulting in a range of stances on issues like apostasy and the death penalty. - Understanding the historical context and evolution of Christian beliefs is essential when discussing complex theological topics. - Debates and changes in Christian doctrine have occurred over centuries, reflecting a dynamic and evolving religion. - Contemporary Christian views on apostasy and the death penalty may vary, but historical examples highlight the complexity of the issue within Christian history.

[@BloggingTheology]

Many thanks!

[@IsmailSarkaya-ll4ts]

@@BloggingTheology always a pleasure brother Paul ❤️

[@dontdont7485]

@@BloggingTheology I hope you can collaborate in knowledge with Muslim converts in Indonesia who have a KZbin channel called Dondi Tan or Manachem Ali Official 🙏

[@David-kz2im]

@@BloggingTheology Paul, are you open to debating Seraphim Hamilton on this topic?

[@cosmicislamicmiracles7803]

Please pin my comment *Who searches for the truth? Be a logical, fair and serious man,If I give you miracles from the Qur’an in the language of numbers that cannot be lied, So that future generations may believe in Allah, which proves that Allah told us about the speed (velocity) of the Earth’s rotation around its axis of rotation 🌎1100 years before the English scientist Robert Hooke in 7th century, *Also the English scientist Joseph Priestley (1780).Who discovered the process of plant of photosynthesis,🌿 the properties and structure of the oxygen atom, Qur'an told us 1150 years before him, *If I give and prove that , Q : Do you have enough freedom to believe in Allah ? Or will you not believe unless Allah puts you in hell, so you say to Allah , “Bring me back again so that I may believe in you?” But Allah refuses, Why? Because you will do what you did before!!! , I wait for your response, or you will ignore my comment and change the Topic's point as usual ? To escape far away !! Or you will say : Qur’an 8:32 Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala said: "And [remember] when they said, O Allah, if this should be the truth from You, then rain down upon us stones from the sky or bring us a painful punishment." Virus Covid 19 Miracle in Qur'an by numbers too 😂 Allah is the greatest 🙏

[@disuser-lp3qv1tm8f]

Spencer never lived off his Christianity, he lived off his islamophobia.

[@emreduygun]

intertwined that scum made a career and living out of utter reprehensible nonsense and defamation, pure evil with no spine

[@solsak836]

Yeah he publishes lies in his dumb website

[@SalahdiatorDeenAyubi]

Facts 💯

[@mistymoor7114]

What do you mean by that? Do you mean for profit?

[@slickperspective2745]

True say. Basically his religion is Islamophobia.

[@hammadahmad6312]

Spencer is getting decimated left right and center. Literally getting intellectually crucified.

[@_H8ed_]

brutal fodderization

[@QashMaz]

Yes, he has been decimated, disheveled discombobulated and intellectually decapitated!

[@ibnmianal-buna3176]

Muslim brothers are decimating him, PBD roasted him, other Christians on KZbin vids and comment sections are refuting him, even Sam Shamoun of all people is refuting him lol

[@omom4248]

​@@QashMazquoting Mohamed hijab 😂

[@SalahdiatorDeenAyubi]

lol 😂

[@NasirAhmedApu]

Facts check and speaking it out about theological matter is not a easy task. It requires knowledge , wisdom, and a believer . Paul Williams did it .

[@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi]

so shouldn't jake be put to death for his apostasy?

[@aimanbabahmed7449]

@@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi maybe according to christianity.

[@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi]

@@aimanbabahmed7449 right. so daniel says he supports 'traditional christians'. so wouldn't that mean he supports their traditional laws? and jake pointed out there is death to apostates in the old testament. so does this channel. therefore jake should be put to death, right? or are muslims hypocrites? you get to kill your apostates, but no one else can impose the same law?

[@donhue4546]

@@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi YES BY ADOLLS LOGIC,THE ONLY CULT TO WASTE YOU FOR LEAVING IT,,,, THE MOST EVIL RELIGION CREATED BY SHAYTAIN

[@donhue4546]

@@aimanbabahmed7449 MAYBE,BUT NOT TRUE WHERE IN BIBLE DOES IT SAY SUCH B/S,BUT PROOF IN THE HOLEY CURRYANNE

[@abunusaybah1058]

Robot Spencer threw his whole Christianity and career under the bus!

[@mahomedakoon8363]

UNDER THE BUS AND TRAIN ROBBER SPICR

[@HK00088]

David wood did when he linked with Apus (atheist)

[@RSF0088]

Fables😂

[@azouitinesaad3856]

he didn't have one to begin with he was more anti muslim than Christian.

[@xxCrimsonSpiritxx]

Even Rashid threw the Old Testament under the bus! Lol

[@diligoscientia]

Thank you Paul for all the hours you put in to educate the people.

[@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi]

so do you want the catholic church to kill apostates? should they start with jake?

[@danielanthony8373]

You mean lie to people

[@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi]

@@danielanthony8373 what is the lie?

[@xxCrimsonSpiritxx]

@@danielanthony8373 People like you just go around accusing others of lying while providing no evidence or context to "where the lie is", it's so disingenuous and pitiful honestly

[@Thomas20249]

The bible says if a child disobeys his parents he is to be put to death. It perfectly applies to Rashid Hamami who disobeyed his parents back home and brought them disgrace in the entire village where they live.... And , ironically, he pretends to uphold christian beliefs which denounce him, to begin with.... Leviticus 20.9

[@solsak836]

He needs a few slaps

[@TheMiddleWayDeen]

ironic@@solsak836

[@saphiasoofie3578]

Classic example of Allah replaces ingrates with someone better. He is no loss to Islam. There must have been numerous reverts to Islam at the time of his exit. Actually we should feel sorry for him, condemning himself to Hell.

[@ebakindeji5941]

Jesus says the same thing in Matthew 15:3-4.

[@NEVIMK]

@@ebakindeji5941it’s important to note when Jesus uses it he is quoting the hypocrisy in Pharisees and how they judged him for not doing the man made traditions while they loophole around respecting parents rule.

[@samianiamatullah2846]

Succinct, to the point, factual, respectful… interesting and excellent!

[@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi]

so do you want the catholic church to kill apostates? should they start with jake?

[@talharizvi4075]

paul did a great job - i do wish he had brought in some more info on christian history in europe - it is shocking how ignorant spencer expects his aid to be; the religious wars and bloodshed over heresies/blasphemies/apostasies eclipse anything in any other religion - there is a book called “Kill Them All: Cathars and Carnage in the Albigensian Crusade” which talks about the official crusade launched to put a bloody end to the cathar heresy in france (just as one example)

[@RalphEllis]

This Blogger does not even realise that Christianity did not come from the Church of Jesus and James. Christianity is the legacy of Saul and his evangelism to the Gentiles, which resulted in Rome-friendly Simple Judaism for Gentiles. Christianity is the Church if Saul, not the Church of Jesus. R

[@MuslimArab25]

Thank you for the video, jazak Allah khair, I just want to say you are so calm and collected, very respectful in your approach I admire your character and happy you are one of the Muslim Ummah

[@shienm635]

Alhamdulillahi Rabbil Alameen

[@mizzyuk8697]

What do u mean he is part of the ummah? Did he embrace islam?

[@MuslimArab25]

@@mizzyuk8697 long time ago! Brother Paul is Muslim alhamdulillah

[@mizzyuk8697]

@@MuslimArab25 SubhanAllah that's amazing Alhamdulillah

[@rkbuttonindrydenont]

Mahood was a pedophile. Islam is a death cult. The whole world can see that.

[@anouarelguil2843]

Robert Spencer has been laughed at because he knows nothing about his religion.

[@Truth_Seeker1]

Nor does he know about Islam. Christians don’t know anything about their own false religion.

[@mistymoor7114]

Thats a ridiculous thing to say !

[@kaiba8954]

⁠@@mistymoor7114 Not really. He clearly ignorant about the Bible.

[@ggghgf885]

​@@mistymoor7114May Allah guide you

[@starsian]

@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw It's actually the most read book in the world today. Not only that, it's also completely memorized by millions.

[@silverfoenix]

Epic debate, I called a Moroccan friend of mine & told him about what Rachid said about naming "Christian names", Can't perform Christian Rituals etc... I called him oppressed in a secular country 😂😂 I had no real intention of teasing him about it, only to make sure he was not oppressed. Turns out He saw it broadcasted live before me~ AND man was he pissed! (Only ever gets angry over football matches when I tease him GO EGYPT) Then replied "don't listen to the village idiots" !!!!! He even wondered whose idea is to bring two LIBERALS posing as Christians? He pretty much summed up the whole thing.

[@T-Dog-Mendez]

Seems to me that you two are the village idiots

[@riezan]

Thanks for sharing this. I mean anyone with sane mind can see tru their lies. Everything Rancid and Robert said are moral complaints and emotional rants. And every single Sharia (Law) in Islam can also be found in the Bible and Tanakh

[@T-Dog-Mendez]

@@riezan Oh look, a Muslim and liar.. how shocking.

[@samyengland7244]

إبن العبيطة بيقلك مضطهد ههههههههه إحنا العرب عارفين القصص دى... كان نفسى عربى يكون ضده مباشر ويظبطه لا وبيقوا لجيك أن الجلابية دى بتعتهم ومستكترها عليه وأصلها بربرى ههههههههه دخل القصص الداخلية عندهم بربر وامازيغ وقصص من دى... الكلب دا كلها أصلا علشان اللجوء والإقامة برا والشهرة والفلوس

[@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi]

so do you want the catholic church to kill apostates? should they start with jake?

[@wolverinescratch]

I've always said when these Racist and Xenophobic people are confronted they fall apart, hate never wins

[@alifiamd9963]

​@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uwthis victim playing is getting boring

[@Wilayaat]

​@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw - Compared to bombing Muslim nations on the flimsiest pretext leaving tens of thousands dead and millions homeless?

[@alifiamd9963]

​@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uwthe fact that the Muslim had to switch sides temporarily to defend Christianity against these liberals shows who the real hypocrites are. Cuz basically Christianity has the same values you guys detest in Islam.

[@alifiamd9963]

​@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uwgo ahead, throw your book under the bus again. 😊

[@haziq0007]

@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw proof?

[@nanashi7779]

What was left of spencers career disintegrated in less than a week

[@mentalismification]

As soon as I heard "Brother Rasheed", I had to search YT for that debate to see if it's the one I had in mind. If you are from the Middle East and grew up in the satellite era around the late 90's onwards, you must have come across this guy's show in Arabic, heard the kind of fallacies he and his guests were spreading, and know how much of a joke he is. No one took his nonsense seriously. His programs always aired out of Cyprus as much as I can remember, hosted dubious guests, fake audience calls. God knows who his funders were/are. Not a source of knowledge for sure.

[@silverfoenix]

He was exposed in the middle east, Now He is exposed WORLDWIDE.

[@solsak836]

I feel like boxing his face

[@azikazikazik]

Where did you live brother

[@mistymoor7114]

​@@solsak836....relgion of peace speaks!...and threatens violence !

[@numbseafun]

​@@mistymoor7114I think what he was trying to say is Brother Rashid have a punchable face, and I tend to agree.

[@saladdressing2176]

Hello Paul, I really enjoy listening to you, may Allah keep you steadfast in your deen. You are one of the many people here that gave my more imaan and faith to God. Allah humma barik. 💜💜 And Jazakhallah khair!

[@Ujang-NS]

Aamiinnn..

[@busterbiloxi3833]

All humus barks.

[@SS-zj1bt]

Yes I did watch that video I am so glad Paul for your clarification specially for our Christian families for all brothers in humanity 😊❤ From Canada Paul v Muslims r blessed to have u in the UMMAH 😊

[@talksense6648]

"fact check" great work by brother Paul Williams. I think we need him to "fact check" more videos like this. Very impactful.

[@mohammadalharbi2415]

Thank you brother Paul for the beautiful video! Many people lie about historical facts, trying to paint a new picture to deceive people by uttering lies against God. But fact checkers expose such lies. God bless you brother.

[@786humaira1]

Ameen God bless Br Paul Williams .

[@mam2286able]

Asalamu aleykum Just love the Weight of the facts that brother Paul brings to the table. May Allah swt accept from him. And guide others who had been misled by these wrong teachings to the straight path

[@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi]

so should christians be executing their apostates? should they start with jake? muslims are funny.

[@Historelic]

I not for a moment felt as if that podcast was a discussion between two Christian and two Muslim interlocutors it sounded more like two unprepared and lame atheists attacking Islam

[@thinkislamcheckmychannel]

2 Islamophobes

[@HabibiOmi91]

How true is that!

[@seanou2837]

These people have been attacking Islam for years, so to say they were unprepared is to take away for the greatness of brother Jake and daniel.

[@mindbodysoul9066]

Jake and Daniel have the advantage . Truth always prevail.

[@alifiamd9963]

I'd argue it was way better than any slaughtering bro Hijab would have brought on. Especially since Ali Dawah would just be dead weight. No disrespect intended. Just that bro Ali is nowhere near bro Hijab's level.

[@MJB0110]

Thank you for sharing this research Paul. I listened to the PBD debate & the Moslem brothers did really well. I hope PBD and his entire team watch this video or that someone like Mohammed Hijab (or others) sends it to him and his team, and I pray one day, that Patrick Bet David as a good honourable man and a decent Christian, who cares about traditional values and seeks to build bridges, invites you on his show to provide your unique insights, research and perspectives on Christianity & Islam. Inshallah.

[@AA123TD]

Yes I do think Paul would be an excellent guest for this.

[@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi]

so should the christians bring back imposing old testament law? execute their apostates? should jake be the first head on the chopping block?

[@shawnkay5462]

When Robert said the Bible is fairy tales, I knew his career was over.

[@user-np3cp2cb7u]

I'm baffled as well to know that a Christian says that their Holy Scriptures are fairy tales. what Christianity's school of thought teaches that?

[@seanou2837]

Fables

[@tbishop4961]

It is🙄😂

[@Ar021]

To be fair he isn’t lying about that

[@Noob-ng1of]

@@Ar021 He wasn't lying but he was supposed to defend Christianity. The Islam bois defended Islam, even the controversial stuff. Spencer folded as soon as they bring up the controversial Christian stuff.

[@little_laughs_family]

This channel under rated. It should have much more views and subscriptions.

[@nadasamman7590]

The best response I heard so far to Spencer’s claims.. I wish PBD invites brother Paul to his podcast

[@thepublicpotato3887]

Honestly PBD and his fan base is quite biased even the title he puts are generally Muslims Defending their religion never Christian’s defending it

[@nadasamman7590]

@@thepublicpotato3887 most are biased indeed but this one probably the least

[@SignsBehindScience]

Assalām-u-'Alaikum va rahmat ullāhi wa Barakātuh Mā shā Allāh, as always well devised content from you, Sir.

[@Zoroastriano]

Alhamdoli’llah for having knowledgeable Muslims like you in our side defending the truth with evidences against deceivers like Robert Spencer Rashid and David wood. May Allāh subhanahu wa ta’ala protect you ameen.

[@alifiamd9963]

​​@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uwwhat's wrong with it, I wonder? 😊 We don't just hate on people, or names for that matter, with no reason, unlike you people who hate without a proper reasonable excuse. I'd even argue you have no proper argument to refute anything bro Paul said. Parroting becomes you😊😊

[@seabookarno1664]

@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw Every name is fine in Islam as long it's not derogatory. Here in Indonesia majority of muslims still use local name from our country's tradition not "typical" muslim name you know. So yeah it's not wrong to use Paul as name neither there's command to change your name to the "Islamic" one when the person reverted into Islam. As long it have good meaning we all good.

[@seabookarno1664]

@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw as long it's not bad or derogatory name it's okay

[@Sunny-rn4dx]

Why do Christians like Robert think Jesus was some sort of 1960s hippie 😂

[@VigilantGuardian6750]

yeah or some east asian treehugger

[@fidelcatsro6948]

with blonde hair blue eyes and fair complexion

[@ShadedOne]

And that he's from America and he's friends with uncle Sam and Santa clause and of course the easter bunny with all those eggs

[@bakloulaya789]

@@fidelcatsro6948 I visited Rome as a Muslim because I was impressed with the buildings,I never understood why they presented Jesus peace upon him as a white guy ,he was from palestine

[@rejipaul2185]

Challenging question to the Blogging Theologist ? You are wrong. Please quote the correct verse from the Torah. I will quote it for you ? ✅ Deuteronomy 18:20; But the prophet who presumes to speak a word in my name that I have not commanded him to speak, or who speaks in the name of other gods, that same prophet shall die. ✅Q (1) Did Mohammed spoke in the name of other God’s, Yes, he spoke in the name of Allah? Was it a the name of a pre-Islamic pagan God ✅Q (2) Was the name of God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, the God of Israel. Can you prove from the Jewish texts that his name was Allah. No chance. ✅Q (3) Did God sent his prophets to Israelites and to Jerusalem or to Arabia, to Mecca and to Muslims ? ✍️ Luke 13:33-34; for IT CANNOT BE THAT A PROPHET SHOULD PERISH AWAY FROM JERUSALEM.’ O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it! ✍️ Jeremiah 35:15-16; I have spoken to you persistently, but you have not listened to me. I HAVE SENT TO YOU (Jews/Israel) ALL MY SERVANTS THE PROPHETS, sending them persistently ✍️ Mat 23:37; O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it! ✅Q (4) Do Muslims have any understanding of the The Hebrew Bible or Tanakh (/tɑːˈnɑːx/; the canonical collection of Hebrew scriptures, comprising the Torah, the Nevi'im, and the Ketuvim. Do they have any knowledge, understanding or insight of the New Covenant which God made with the Hebrews ✍️Jer 31:31-34; I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah, not like the covenant that I made with their fathers..For this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, declares the LORD: I will put my law within them, and I will write it on their hearts. And I will be their God, and they shall be my people. And no longer shall each one teach his neighbor and each his brother, saying, ‘Know the LORD,’ for they shall all know me, from the least of them to the greatest, declares the LORD. For I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more.” ✅ Q(5) So, once the New Covenant has come in, they shall all know me, from the least of them to the greatest, declares the LORD. For I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more.” If both Jews and Gentiles are given the opportunity to know God and the forgiveness of their sins, tell me Muslims, is it required for God to give the Jews and to the Gentiles , another new message, a final revelation from God, that too, one contrary to all his earlier messages. ✅ Q(6) Why are you so callous, stupid and foolish ? How can you believe and also teach others that Mohammed , 😇 a pure man, Mohammed was not a sinner, ⚔️did not kill anyone, did not covet another’s wife, 🧕🧕🧕🧕🏾🧕🏾 did not commit adultery, did not covet another’s property, a role person to be imitated by the whole mankind.✍️ God has commanded, you shall have no God other than me, you shall not murder, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not covet anything that belongs to another . How easily Satan and his servant bewitched you ? ✅ Having quoted so many references, IS THERE ANY 😇🇪🇭🧕 BRAVE MUSLIM, WHO COULD PROVE, from pre-Islamic written / archaeology sources that the name of God Is Allah and Mohammed was sent to Jerusalem, to the Jewish people and he died in Jerusalem ? JUST GIVE ONE REFERENCE. O Muslims, that is convincing to all people, that Mohammed is a prophet of God. TAKE IT AS A CHALLENGE and come forth with A reliable evidence / source. AGREE WITH GOD IN EVERYTHING, DO NOT REBEL, for THE GREATEST SIN IS REBELLION AGAINST YOUR CREATOR, but, AGREE IN EVERYTHING WITH THE WORD OF GOD. TO HIM SHALL BE THE OBEDIENCE OF THE PEOPLES. 2 Cor 1:19-20; IN HIM it is always Yes. For ALL THE PROMISES OF GOD FIND THEIR YES IN HIM.

[@alexferdinansyah757]

Two points I gather from Br Paul's video: 1. Spenser is actually severely lacking in knowledge of christianity or Islam. This tells you on the quality (or the lack of) of the 27 books he had written. 2. Learn a little about the laws and punishment of the bibles, makes me realize, the Qur'an actually eases-off laws brought by the bibles.

[@DA-jk8pk]

I hope you host Dr Wael Hallaq. He is brilliant in Islamic and Western history, Islamic conquests ,and Modernity and secularism It would be very great if you hosted him. He's very informative on these subjects.

[@unhingedconnoisseur164]

he had imam tom on and they did a series discussing his book, “the impossible state”

[@alsamp1982]

I admire this Man. after late Ahmad Deedat rahimallah we witness another intellectual warrior. now we have Daniel Masha'Allah! He is the Man. His conference defending the Qur'an and the Sunnah is superb. His like saying bring it on whatever false accusations, misinterpretations, manipulations, Stereotype etc. When ever he debate firstly you will see through his body language, the way he speak is confidence. Daniel trust Whatever written in the Quran and the Hadith is high-level. There is nothing can be ashame in the teaching of Islam. And we must not forget Bro. Jake too. I also sub. To his channel. He is intelligent too. I always watch his dabate with several athiest and Christian apologist.

[@publicpm8809]

Alhamdulillah

[@user-bw1dv3iq9x]

He also thinks it’s ok to have sex with children “if they show signs of maturity” he defends Mohammad marrying a 9 year old. He’s disgusting. Islam is a death cult who have the worst human rights in the world.

[@kumzarf]

Excellent response. Apt response to Islamophobes. Succinct, reasoned and knowledge based. Thank you for the effort brother Paul.

[@reg-pi1sr]

There is no such thing as islamophobia

[@Selahaddin33]

Once again brother Paul eloquently and with great sophistication delivers the goods. Brilliantly executed! *Pun intended.

[@BloggingTheology]

😆

[@khairt1731]

Very scholarly and interesting information straight from Bible Scholars.

[@NMarkeTech]

Excellent fact checking.

[@unhingedconnoisseur164]

bout to go to bed rn Insha Allah and just saw this video pop up! but i am very excited to see your take on this brother Paul

[@mustaphafikri45]

Bismillah ma chae ALLAH. I love your respectful approach to things.Always a pleasure listening to you. May ALLAH reward you here and in the hereafter. Amine.

[@publicpm8809]

Ameen

[@quantumrim3805]

well done brother. as usual very will presented and referenced

[@Ahmad-mc5hn]

This is a wonderful scholarly presentation. Please continue your work, Mr Paul. JazakaAllah.

[@lateeshamohammed624]

Thank you for this Paul. I hope Christians listen and recognise Robert Spencer for what he is

[@pramodwilson2354]

How blind all' of you are. Your eyes will be opened one' day. He wants salvation for all of you.

[@wonderworldearth4535]

Hi, Paul, i want to suggest that when you read something from Torah or new testament, you should put it on screen in text whether be a photo captured of book or screenshot. Because, it's easier for us to take notes just by taking a screenshot.

[@choudhury200991]

What a brilliant theologian. I admire you, Paul, and I wish you great contentment in this life, and the highest reward in the next life.

[@abdou.b3259]

We want to see you on pbd podcast ❤

[@DA-jk8pk]

In shaa allah 🤲

[@Imru_gamer]

Salam alakum brother, you are always doing a great job. I just thought of this now:a Wasn't the Crusades a direct representation of this verse from the Bible? Just curious. Love and respect to you sir and everyone. 🙏🙏💜

[@yoservs]

i've been waiting for your take on this Paul. thanks for a very satisfying discussion

[@InquisitiveImran]

Amazing paul, we need you to represent your insightful views in professional and large scale debates. You will surely help in uncovering the truth with your polite and professional "englishman" manners 😊

[@georgiacap9294]

Yes I agree. I’d like to see him debate Jay Dyer or Seraphim Hamilton. I’d pay money to see that.

[@ShayleneHaswarey]

I just finished reading “Lost Christianities” by Bart D. Herman. Your video reminded of of your commentary. If you haven’t read the book, I highly recommend it!

[@shadowcapital]

What disturb me more is Robert’s book, ‘The Truth about Muhammad’. I read that book, and thought Rasulullah is The Antichrist, a villain who pretends to be Messenger of God and mislead everyone who bevomes Muslim into hell. Now, I am a muslim. Yet, my loyalty is to truth, righteousness, goodness, kindness, not to religion. If somehow my religion is used to force me to become evil, i reject the idea.

[@VandalIO]

Thank you for this ! I was getting very upset that he made lots of hurtful claims and not all of them were being addressed !

[@mistymoor7114]

Lol, I think the claims that Apostates from Islam should be killed were just a tad more hurtful !!

[@YouBuyWeRush]

Thank you brother Paul. May Allah increase you in reward. Ameen.

[@plus182]

Hopefully Christians will watch this and the debate and realise that Muslims would like them to start enforcing these laws more strictly.

[@AA-SOM]

Well done brother, JazakhAllah ❤

[@shahdrah]

Salaam and Thank you Paul for taking the time to do the research and clarify. PDB needs to invite you next debate. Wahlaykum Assalam

[@BloggingTheology]

Wa-Alaikum-Salaam

[@peacebeuntoyou8934]

Excellent work, Paul.

[@NATURLIST]

This is my beloved big brother Paul, yes it is time for me to get the notepad and the pen maashaalaah

[@fidelcatsro6948]

my cat loves u too! 🐱♥️♥️♥️

[@_Calaven]

JazakhAllah Ustadh Paul

[@yassoulassou]

It is surprising and disappointing that no one (in the many reaction videos I watched and comments I read) challenged or even scrutinised the statements of the two Muslims as to the punishment for apostacy in Islam. Instead, the efforts seem to have gone into proving that Christianity was "as violent and intolerant as Islam". Where did the two Muslims get the idea that the punishment for apostacy in Islam was death? No verse in the Quran supports such claim. And the very few Hadiths pertaining to this matter do not support the claim either as they are specific about the condition of apostacy being accompanied by treason. Therefore, it is to be understood that the death penalty is the punishment for treason and not apostacy. I wish that PBD had invited knowledgeable Muslim scholars to this debate.

[@riahisama]

Thanks for sharing your immense knowledge with the world brother Paul, may Allah reward you to the fullerst.

[@ifthikarhassen1045]

Well presented and lucidly explained Paul. Christian apologists and evangelists will constantly weave and bob, twist and turn to portray the distorted Christian faith through the lens of modern secular sensibilities until eventually they are cornered by the truth. Yet they cannot see, hear or speak of the truth that hovers over them .

[@watiflappynounou3302]

All praise to Allahﷻ that brother Paul is here to educate us….may Allah reward you and your family and grant you Jannah….‎ Ameen 🤲🏼

[@khalilowd8153]

So clear and consistantly polite...then enriching ! Well done Mr Paul! May our Lord of Mercy reward you and all the people involved for every second of efforts 🙏🏾😊

[@Layth71]

God bless you brother Paul. Man of knowledge and intellect. Keep it up my brother.

[@pnjwck]

Thank you, Paul for chipping in on the matter. I always find your explanations easy to understand and based on sound academics. On the matter of James, I think it would be fascinating to get to know him a bit more. And also, as a Muslim, how do we reconcile him with our faith? Did Maryam As, had a husband after Jesus As? Thank you 🙏🏽

[@georgiacap9294]

If you want to know about James then you need to speak to an orthodox Christian. James is a Saint in our church. He is not Jesus biological brother because the Virgin Mary remained a perpetual virgin after giving birth to Jesus. So, your friend Paul is not the right person to analysis St James.

[@bakloulaya789]

@@georgiacap9294 so Mary adopted James?just asking here

[@georgiacap9294]

@@bakloulaya789 According to church Tradition Joseph was a widower with children. He was a righteous man and was betrothed to Mary. Once Mary’s pregnancy was exposed to Joseph he wanted to secretly divorce her but an angel of the Lord appeared to him to take Mary as his wife. Mary was very holy, and favored by God hence why she was chosen to carry the ‘uncreated God’ the Son of God in her womb. Mary and Joseph never consummated the marriage, she remained a perpetual virgin, hence why even today we still call her the Virgin Mary.

[@bakloulaya789]

@@georgiacap9294 oh now I understand, as Muslims we see Mary as Virgin so when I heard of James I got confused but thank you for answering

[@hamdiorch1015]

Thank you brother Paul for this interesting video. May God reward you well for your good hard work. Your fan from Morocco.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

ameen

[@tahaali2732]

I would love to see brother Paul having debates (not in Speakers Corner but more formal debates) on specific topics that he's very well-versed in. I wonder if he would consider doing so?

[@robbiestones9447]

He wont beacause he would get demolished by experts...bob at speakers corners destroyed him and now he runs away from him LOL

[@fadelarshad5456]

Very interesting, Paul is very knowledgeable and good research and points

[@zuhaireone5463]

Excellent presentation and rebuttal. Well done Paul 👍🏻

[@hussynmuhammad8436]

May Allah reward your effort Br. Paul

[@alifiamd9963]

​@@LeutherGreengager-ip1uwSomeone's being xenophobic

[@fidelcatsro6948]

ameen

[@bewater6684]

Thank you so much for this speedy fact check video, it was stuck on my mind after watching the debate. May Allah grant you good rewards for speaking out on the truth of the matter!

[@ahmedibrahimgarba4990]

Salam alaikum Brother Paul! I'm always fascinated with your zeal for knowledge and also impressed with your library collections. I wish I could come and visit you in your library and share a lot of knowledge and information with you. Maasalam and jazakallahu Khair.

[@fouda2903]

Thanks alot sir for all of these precious information... May Allah bless you and grant you the highest degrees of Jannah.. ameen.

[@user-tt3dt9tk2c]

Thank you sir ! At Least you looking for the truth ✌🏼

[@zainabyahia2591]

Lol

[@TabrezJanjua]

@BloggingTheology A very important addition to the original debate. JazakAllah khayr Brother Paul

[@user-be1ip1yt5f]

Sir fascinating lecture. You bring the truth from the All The Divine Teachings together for anyone looking for truth. Jazakh Allah Khair. May God be pleased with You.

[@obaid1333]

Thanks for the wonderful vlog and the clarification.

[@aibish0]

Ty Paul for this commentary. Your content is brilliant Much love from California

[@BloggingTheology]

Much appreciated!

[@sirhumanoid4174]

Your insight is amazing, Paul. Very interesting.

[@nasarmohammed8129]

One good thing about these debates and their aftermath is that it's bringing the true Muslims and the true Christians even closer. The divide that's Deeping is between the haters and the hypocrites or those who don't want to see these 2 groups merging. I can understand now how practically all the Christians will become Muslims when the prophet Jesus will return. The truth will become undeniable.

[@786humaira1]

Long live Br. Paul Williams . Salaam Alaikum Br Paul . Thanks for your work .

[@ighmoraacen1167]

I watched the debate and wondered when Rasheed said that Jesus pbuh stopped the Torah.... I waited for the two Muslim brothers to mention Matthew5:17 as an argument but they did not... during the whole debate...

[@BloggingTheology]

Good point

[@David-kz2im]

Paul, are you open to debating Seraphim Hamilton on this topic?

[@bakloulaya789]

I am morrocan, I live next to a church, I couldn't stop laughing hearing his Islamophobia, I even had to meet my neighbor since he was a Christian and he wanted to live next to a church, man we had good laugh ,thank you Mister Paul, you made my day

[@iftibaber]

You have explained everything with details Weldon sir ❤

[@BasiraEducation]

Masha'Allah amazing and well organized fact check, Jazakum Allah Khayr for your efforts.

[@douglasbroccone3144]

Matthew 15 suggests to me that Christ pointed out the hypocrisy of the Pharisees and in fact did not tell them to go and kill anyone Which he would have had to if he meant to uphold that commandment Instead he pointed out the break from tradition and then through example of his teachings showed his new attitude of love and compassion which radically differed from the old traditions

[@jasrelaxing]

Brother Paul should be in the PBD debate, as a moderator 🫡

[@shahjaa4944]

Can you Imagine if Brother Paul was on a massive platform like that? Game Over! Can't wait

[@Thomas20249]

Paul, as is his wont, is objectively enlightening and illuminating.....

[@Mohammedalhaj89]

This channel is very valuable Very authentic 👌

[@whychristianity8388]

I’d like to see you debate Robert Spencer where you can’t twist the truth

[@noorzanayasmin7806]

Thank you so much for this video. I am a new Christian, converted from Islam and trying to learn everything I can about Abrahamic religious. I consider Muslims, Jews as one with Christianity. We may disagree somewhat but we subscrive to the same God or so they say. Subscribed to this channel.

[@milkmonster2310]

Seems as though all the Muslim KZbinrs are ganging up on Robert Spencer lol, and I'm here for it!

[@zehravesile]

Exposing a liar is a must....nobody is ganging up on rs.....muslims are just exposing him n nothing else.....

[@shaami8622]

Not just muslims mind you, christians as well.

[@zehravesile]

@@shaami8622 yes....i agree wd u der....

[@littlefish543]

You are used to consuming irrational doctrines so you have such thoughts🤣🤣

[@michoacan1323]

Alhamdullilah Beautiful knowledge. May Allah reward you brother.

[@publicpm8809]

Ameen

[@tariqaleem1656]

Could we get a clarification on the verse you quoted Ephesians 2:7 I looked it up and couldn’t find what you quoted. May Allah reward you for your work brother.

[@abdullahqazi6261]

Asalaam O aalikum, Really appreciate the insight which “Blogging Theology” always brings to its viewer, the thorough researched content, and keeping an unbiased tone. But I have a question; true that the actual teachings of ‘Christianity’ are not known to most/majority Christians, my question is how many Christians hold the beliefs as reflected in the response and claims made by Mr Spencer? And what do u think is going to happen to Christianity?

[@NotUrDJ]

Jazak Allah. You should definitely do more refutation videos with the more recent remarks some of these guys make.

[@keekl6870]

I thought it wasn't a Christian vs Muslim discussion/debate/argument but rather an anti-Islam/Christian/liberal vs Muslim debate. And as for Paul of Tarsus, he, IMO, was the 1st minor dajjal that came out right after Jesus a.s. ascended to heaven.

[@alifiamd9963]

Agreed

[@TheMuslimApologist]

🎯 *Key Takeaways* for quick navigation: 00:00 📚 This video aims to fact-check statements made by Christian apologist Robert Spencer during a debate on the Religious Roundtable podcast. 02:59 📖 Robert Spencer claimed that no sect of Christianity, school of thought, or tradition upholds the Old Testament law for Christians, saying it never did. This assertion is challenged. 09:14 ✝️ Matthew 5:17-20 suggests that Jesus did not come to abolish the Jewish law but to fulfill it, implying that aspects of the law were still upheld by early Christians. 16:23 🕊️ In Acts 21, James and the elders of the Jerusalem church appear to be Torah-observant Jews who still followed aspects of the Jewish law, despite being followers of Jesus. 23:02 ⚖️ Historical figures like Thomas Aquinas (13th century) and John Calvin (16th century) supported the death penalty for apostates and heretics, demonstrating the Church's past endorsement of such practices. 25:03 📚 Michael Servetus, influenced by Islamic and Jewish arguments against the Trinity, was arrested, tried, and executed for heresy by John Calvin in Geneva. 26:11 ⚖️ Geneva, under Calvin's rule, applied Old Testament laws, including the death penalty for heresy and apostasy. 27:20 💬 Robert Spencer's claim that no sect of Christianity ever upheld the Old Testament law on apostasy is not accurate. Figures like Thomas Aquinas, John Calvin, and early church leaders supported and implemented such laws. 28:00 📜 Evidence from Matthew 15 suggests that Jesus upheld aspects of the Jewish law, challenging the Pharisees for not adhering to it. 29:06 🕊️ In the 21st century, many Christian denominations, like the Catholic Church, no longer uphold the Old Testament laws on apostasy and have shifted their positions on various issues, influenced by secular liberalism.

[@Arabiscuits1]

I would like to offer my tidying up services to organise that shelf behind you. It’s truly messing with my OCD!

[@SI00000]

An important point few make is that death for blasphemy, adultery, or apostasy are not in the Quran but only in certain hadith. These hadith are not accepted by all Muslims since they contradict Allah in the Quran saying you are free to believe or not to believe. Ironically these hadith which are literal word for word translations of the Old Testament Laws are condemned by Christians who believe the Old Testament is Divinely inspired scripture.

[@T-Dog-Mendez]

Liar.

[@solsak836]

Lol

[@SI00000]

​@@T-Dog-Mendez I have probably read the Quran more than Robert Spencer and definitely know more Arabic than him and have not found these verses of death. If you find any, show me. The Quran only mentions 100 lashes for the adulterer and only after four, just, sane witnesses testify to seeing the act. The conditions are intended to be impossible to meet since few meet the criteria for being just and no practicing Muslim would actually look long enough to confirm if there was actual penetration. Merely seeing them naked together is not proof for conviction. Its safe to say that most killings of alleged adulterers in Muslim nations were not according to the Quran since the conditions are impossible to meet. The Quran does however say from beginning to end that we are free to believe or not to believe and that Muhammad's task was only to deliver the Message, not to enforce it. Just read the Quran and see for yourself.

[@OmarAlikaj]

You're referring to "There is no compulsion in religion" quote from the Qur'an, right? Yeah, the Qur'an points to tempting or forcing people to abandon Islam, or even attacking them, as justification to deal with perpetrators. You however lost me over Hadith being translations of the Old Testament.

[@SI00000]

@@OmarAlikaj I didn't mean all hadith sound like the Old Testament, just these hadith about killing adulterers and apostates. From beginning to end, the Quran promotes thinking and offers us the freedom to believe or not to believe but these hadith are the opposite when they warn of death if you change your religion or leave Islam. Its impossible to accept contradictory statements at the same time.

[@Jim-zw7vi]

Thanks so much for making this video, I feel like I have learnt a lot.

[@kalijasin]

Matthew 5:17 (KJV) Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.