Faking Humanity (NPC Logic)

Rockstar Game's NPC's are usually pretty smart. They should ask them for some advice on how to run GTA Online.
Created By Ocean
Patreon: / darkspaceyt
Shirts: teespring.com/stores/dark-spa...
Discord: / discord

[@jakeclarke1564]

7:38 Read Dead

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

OMG, what a fail

[@emilgeorge3885]

I mean technically it could be pronounced the same way, soooooo 50% fail, maybe

[@jakeclarke1564]

@@emilgeorge3885 yeah i was thinking that

[@SpuddyWesker]

@@emilgeorge3885 read dead don't sound the same as red dead

[@CranSo]

lol

[@racermigs1]

One thing I missed about NPCs in GTA 4 was that you could push them off ledges by walking into them.

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

There was a ledge in Bohan? Is it? The first island. And I would push them off the broken fense area. It was a circle area. Pretty fun.

[@racermigs1]

@@DarkSpaceStudios I usually do it in BOABO near Brucie's apartment since the road around it is pretty high.

[@SpuddyWesker]

@@racermigs1 me too

[@sharp14x]

At the Burger Shot, I would drive into the fat people to push them off.

[@FlapMyJax]

I miss the different car handling.

[@matrtr8542]

In red dead redemption 2 npcs will react to a expensive horse

[@PyroFTB]

In GTA V the npcs take pictures of your car if it's expensive or really customized

[@themodestpineapple9236]

Red dead 2 has some of the best NPCs in all of gaming

[@user-ee5he9oz3k]

thats a mighty fine steed you got there partner!

[@dox1802]

@@oohpaarjan4685 in bully every npc hated you until you bullied them into submission

[@dylancunningham5367]

@@dox1802 well, atleast at the end, they loved you as long as you didn't dress like a bum. Even prefects would give a little respect while in a school uniform. But that damn Constantino, what a douche.

[@MrLukasboys]

Meanwhile in Cyberpunk 2077: "Let's just spawn the police in directly behind the player and call it a day"

[@ladybabe6958]

NCPD : **teleport behind you** nothing personal kid

[@TheDennys21]

Police was added last minute...

[@MrLukasboys]

@@TheDennys21 Should have left it out. Actively makes the game worse.

[@TheDennys21]

@@MrLukasboys yeah sometimes they just insta kill you

[@skylar7720]

@@TheDennys21 i mean not in a car, hop in one and they lose you so fast

[@ThaPugster]

It still amazes me how much time rockstar put into these NPCs, they hired actual gang members to voice the gangsters in the game if this doesnt show dedication from a developer then i dont know what does

[@Captianmex1C0]

Aka anyone in atlanta, Birmingham or chicago

[@ThaPugster]

@@Captianmex1C0 true

[@KoiNyle]

No they didn't Tyler the Creator ain't no gangster and he voice some of the gangsters

[@ThaPugster]

@@KoiNyle So, one out of the hundreds of voices is a celebrity... What's your point?

[@iamacatperson7226]

@@ThaPugster well, OBVIOUSLY since a single person didn’t voice an NPC they must bitch about it to anyone and everyone who will listen because they wish to prove someone else wrong

[@sman14GTA]

Read Dead Redemption 2's NPCs having a daily routine, had me rethinking using NPC as an insult, the ones in the game actually have a life lol.

[@boss_niko]

They are actual people dont kill them for sports.

[@the_criminal_mastermind]

@@boss_niko and they are artificial intelligence trapped in a video game they are alive

[@samanthablack7990]

@@boss_niko RDR2 is one of the few games I wknt slaughter npcs in

[@iamacatperson7226]

@@the_criminal_mastermind no they aren’t, they are Venezuelan children forced to play video games 24/7, and are only released once their character dies, so if you wish to free the children, commit murder against any and all npcs

[@thegamelabgaming7556]

@@iamacatperson7226 a man of culture I see

[@garrettmartin5102]

Red dead 2 has to have one of the best ai systems it makes me feel like they are actual people

[@thejompi]

I love the ai on the wildlife is so dynamic. That’s why hunting is my favorite thing to do in RDR2.

[@BR78973]

Red dead is just amazing in general

[@garrettmartin5102]

@@BR78973 the story was great, probably one of the best stories I've played personally

[@JudeTheYoutubePoopersubscribe]

@@garrettmartin5102 first 3 chapters were extremely slow for my taste but once things started getting serious it became very good.

[@garrettmartin5102]

@@JudeTheKZbinPoopersubscribe yea chapter 5 has to be my favorite

[@eydok5114]

Cyberpunk comes out. Every one: Thank you Rockstar games for making amazing worlds! We took you for granted! But now we see!

[@x-_arthurmorgan-_x5528]

It really makes you appreciate them more. I think we all take Rockstar for granted.

[@GamingMisthios13]

I only wish the next Rockstar game adds NPC animations like the ones cyberpunk has in conversations.

[@wavyhomeboy]

@@x-_arthurmorgan-_x5528 rockstar is milking gta online

[@AnonVoids]

Rockstar released a game broken af (fixed over time) with a linear story/missons (all same go there shoot this style), all while milking players with a pay to win meta and having them thanking them for it just because a competitor released a game with bugs, what could be more dystopian than that?

[@GamingMisthios13]

@@AnonVoids What game? GTA V? It wasn’t broken sure it had bugs and still do but none of them compromised the experience. The story being linear isn’t even a comparison to cyberpunk , you either like it or not. Cyberpunk has its bugs some game breaking and needs a lot of fixing to do but its still a solid game i rather play cyberpunk than any gta but its comes down to preference i dont think anyone thanks rockstar for gta v rather they expect at least gta iv or rdr storytelling for their next game.

[@zilch.scienta]

Is this a guide for CDPR on how to improve AI in CP 2077?? 😂😂😂😂

[@gamingphantom6305]

but i think we all agree that the gta iv npc is the best of all gtas

[@MidnightClubStillCancelledSoz]

No doubt

[@nickkhalilieh1961]

I think red dead has the best NPC’s

[@x-iei-x4725]

Gta online npc suck

[@OnlyTheFinest125]

Yes

[@wisico640]

Not on mobile for sure tho 😅

[@n0zo.143]

Gta a sandbox action game: creates inmersive enviroments and npcs that are unique Cyberpunk2077 a open world rpg made for inmersion: npcs will stay on the road forever if you put a car infront of them.

[@steveystovey]

And GTA was released in 2013 too, lel

[@gamersgalaxy5885]

Cyberpunk is better

[@marwintalens7066]

@@gamersgalaxy5885 not with the amount of issues it having

[@surfinsilver]

@@gamersgalaxy5885 no cyberpunk is not better then gta I hate to tell you that you are wrong lol, millions of others would agree as well. Gta is what people are comparing to all the shit going wrong in cyberpunk rn. Cyberpunk will never live up to the greatness that GTA did in 2013, & that’s a fact my brother. Grand theft auto in general is a much more realistic and massive immersive game, there’s nothing you can say to make anyone think otherwise too.

[@n0zo.143]

@@gamersgalaxy5885 cops be like: *teleports behind u* Still i have hopes that cdpr will fix everything.

[@22XERO22]

GTA 4 had the best NPC's out of the GTA Series.

[@olliegoria]

Indeed. The GTA V ones felt watered down.

[@superdays7933]

@@olliegoria Well they act like people from Los Angeles and Southern California. So it's just more realism. And the NPC diving I just got out of a car and it was just like GTA V. Almost died in Gta and irl.

[@superdays7933]

But Gta 4 still wins. By a little.

[@metalgearzwei]

GTA IV in general is the best in the series imo. realistic car weight, nice destruction, better ragdolls, best story, humor and serious tones reflected nicely, resuscitation existing, generally the best. deserves a remaster.

[@luzkiemiczkief.solijon8439]

@@olliegoria that's because they sacrifice that for the ocean and uder water parts of the game

[@horix149]

"The NPC is complex" Also the NPC: jumps in front of my car

[@IskenderCaglarM41B441]

Yeah 3, vc and sa npc's are stupid in that part.

[@Fras00]

Even GTA SA got better interaction with NPC that some other modern games,just to show how good Rockstar is in attention to detail

[@dox1802]

In SA if you were in a rival hood for too long gang members would come up to your car and start to shake it/ harass you. Talking about a game that came out in 2004

[@clamchowdah9140]

*cough watch dogs having some of the worst gameplay and npc design cough*

[@erwaldox]

The npcs in Gta 5 is the worst shit ever created, especially the cops are so fucking boring and predictable

[@thelastpersononearth9765]

@@clamchowdah9140 Wach dogs actually have better npcs than other games and especially better than other ubisoft games.

[@IskenderCaglarM41B441]

@@clamchowdah9140 first watch dogs actually tries.

[@MidnightClubStillCancelledSoz]

I always remember the satisfying sound when you run someone over in GTA IV.

[@DeekshanMahanta]

The metal coming in contact with solid stuff hard ❤️

[@theotheranotheryoutuber2101]

😳

[@Chimera144]

Yeah poop

[@KH0LRA]

GTA III splats are comical doe like squishing a bug

[@TigerChamp99]

Good to see you here. I was looking for your comment.

[@Jaiden1028]

Once again the editing is amazing

[@FRMC_SALMON]

Your pfp matches this comment lol

[@jaytwentytenone2068]

flushed

[@ludviktholen4905]

How do they do it. I have no clue but i fully support their work

[@tardwrangler1019]

when the impostor is sus!

[@dauphongii]

4:05 GTA 4 npcs : Umbrellas, newspapers, going under roofs or into buildings, police officers wearing heavier clothing against rain GTA 5 npcs : Guess I'll be dryn't

[@thegamingvillager2392]

LS Npcs aren't used to rain lol

[@animaza5563]

who carries a umbrella in California

[@h.e.scompany446]

gta 5 npc react to rain, her back gets lower when weather get rain.

[@dauphongii]

@@h.e.scompany446 wow.. That's.. Very.. Logical and totally works..

[@h.e.scompany446]

@@dauphongii oiya dong

[@wereedbooks]

GTA IV's physics blew my mind and still do. I played with the Euphoria learning addition program for hours building my own sets and having characters navigate them. Truly an amazing feeling that I believe was lost when they retooled for GTA V.

[@threadschanged4252]

Toned it down way too much luckily all u need is a mod to get it back

[@PyroFTB]

@@threadschanged4252 yeah, mods saved V for me tbh

[@bharatchawla8514]

@@PyroFTB but still mods doesn't feel like we used to feel in gta iv. I hope they will add same physics as RDR 2 to Gta 6 or any new ip.

[@PyroFTB]

@@bharatchawla8514 I liked the ragdolls on modded GTA V tbh, the vanilla IV ragdolls seems too weighty, or that the ragdolls don't really respond to getting shot as much.

[@bharatchawla8514]

@@PyroFTB we are saying (what you are saying) that because we get used to gta v or (you can say) gta v physics mod. But one thing to point is (that I don't if you remember or not) they do properly and timely react to shot in their body. And their reaction was funny. Which makes us fun to play that game.

[@lfla0179]

Cd Projeckt Red needed to watch this video 7 years ago. Cyberpunk is so... JARRING in all videos so far. The npcs do these strange things like walking THROUGH a cabinet, while in GTA they would bump against it, take a step back and walk around.

[@kennethchou4384]

Don’t worry, it’s the future. That’s why they phase through walls.

[@olucaspc]

GTA: * Exists Saints Row, Watch Dogs, Cyberpunk 2077: "Im about to shit my pants"

[@NotMeTF]

Well, if they even get to work on a new GTA game, since right now its only living off on old fame and milking the shit out of GTA Online and even more on RDR Online.

[@bharatchawla8514]

Hell even watch dogs or another Ubisoft games has better Ai (not comparing to Rockstar) than Cyberpunk.

[@idonthaveahairline4227]

Gta shits their pants when they think about rdr1 and rdr2

[@bharatchawla8514]

@@idonthaveahairline4227 keep in mind. If there is no gta then there is no Rdr1 or 2. (With upgraded physics and graphics). And Gta 4 physics are still comparable to Rdr 2.

[@x-_arthurmorgan-_x5528]

But Cyberpunk 2077 has social distancing, NPCs disappear when you attack them. Rockstar take notes.

[@bbuny10]

Pissing someone off/dealing with an enemy by then calling the police, and then they actually come AND deal with them instead of you, was a truly impressive moment for me

[@jcrossan1351]

The most immersive rockstar title for me has got to be GTA IV the npc’s in that game felt the most lifelike to me

[@Rude_Boi]

You must not have played RDR2. The NPC's there have a cycle of daily duties that are dynamic.

[@jcrossan1351]

@@Rude_Boi I have played rdr2 and the npcs are great but the npcs in gta iv are more relatable with how they act and talk

[@deathtrap5556]

The thing is it's difficult to compare the gta series and rdr series because despite both being open world the setting is sooooo different. GTA worlds are made to be filled up with NPCs that are diverse because that's how a neighborhood gets that lively and lived in feeling whereas rdr will have much more detail in a single npc because there are simply lesser npcs per area in rdr

[@Jonas-ej7id]

No. It's RDR2

[@Jonas-ej7id]

@@jcrossan1351 GTA IV npcs are great but you cant exactly interact with them the same way you can in RDR2. And also GTA SA

[@thealifrs4_463]

7:45 somebody shout "nice car" when my Gallardo stopping at red light in Midnight Club LA

[@bipbong2906]

classic game

[@Ebolaface]

somebody print this out and mail it to CDProjekt Red 5 years ago

[@Robocop_1987]

The only racing game I played without rubberbanding was Midnight Club 3 .

[@bitelaserkhalif]

You want insane rubberbanding, try underground 1

[@danielvega4076]

Nah nfsu2 had real bad rubberbanding to point u could look behind and see them smashing into everything obviously getting pulled along, u can almost see an imaginary rope/rubberband from ur vehicle to theirs

[@william_SMMA]

The GOAT of racing games

[@JinteiModding]

@@danielvega4076 and jumping cars in some races like the airport

[@petermanfox2535]

Kenopsia: That feeling you have everytime you play a Garry's Mod map by yourself.

[@branchy1186]

i miss garrys mod, ive got literally thousands of hours in that game, but sadly itll never be the way it used to be again

[@berkoral801]

KZbinrs don't have to remind us to ring the notification bell or to subscribe at each video they make, I saw high quality videos and just subscribed to this channel.

[@ServeraServera0]

And overall, it is annoying

[@shona5512]

It blows my mind how in GTA IV, Rockstar come up with Innovative ways to make humanity feel more real. Even if they knew the lighting, textures, and shades weren't quite there yet on the graphics side, they still knew they could make it more immersive by making the character bodies react in certain ways, the car's had realistic handling characteristics and the NPCs would seek shelter in rain. Then in GTA V the graphical capabilities had improved immensely and they also sought new ways to make the NPCs feel more real, like having them react to you differently, getting scared if you followed them too long, take pictures of nice cars, etc. But for some reason, they completely disregarded the separate techniques they developed in GTA IV to make them more real, rather than combining them to make something almost perfect. If feels like a step forward and a step back at the same time.. Hopefully they can mesh it all together in GTA VI whenever they decide to make it.

[@4four415]

as a programmer myself, I feel embarrassed that I never realized the complexity behind rockstar's NPCs

[@Bacony_Cakes]

2:51 The Ambulance: **drives up** shit he dead **drives away**

[@PigIlFigo32]

Even since gta 3, if you parked an infernus or any other sports car on a sidewalk, people will stare at it while walking

[@nomercy8989]

Shots fired at Cyberpunk. I like it.

[@zealeliteassaultlegionfoun2789]

Rockstar - Shots fired Cyberpunk - I'm hit officer down

[@maxinefinnfoxen]

Kenopsina is why we all think we've been in that one "the back rooms" picture because most are familiar with that office room look and the feeling of being alone in a place that should have people. It's a familiar, yet mysterious occurance.

[@KoolKeithProductions]

The irony here that most ppl will miss is that while most marvel at the time, effort and detail Rockstar puts into it's open world games, they will still complain that they need to hurry up and push out GTA6 already 🤔

[@beavisjon1038]

This is the common sense I’ve been waiting to see, thank you.

[@KoolKeithProductions]

@@beavisjon1038 I'm just glad I'm not the only one who sees that unlike CD Projekt Red, Rockstar isn't going to bow down to public pressure and push out a game just because the fans demand it.

[@taistelulaama9159]

It's quite ironic that this dude keeps praising R*'s detail in their games, yet he's complaining that gta 6 is taking so long. Rdr2 is so detailed for a reason.

[@KoolKeithProductions]

@@taistelulaama9159 I noticed that too. He recently put out yet another anti R* vid, and I bet a month later he'll make a vid about how detailed the footprints in RDR2 are 🤔

[@hamiltonmcgregor5534]

Man so many people want gta 6 just so they can find more stuff to complain about a few months after it releases

[@nelsontorres6820]

I can’t wait for the future when games like GTA are have homes that you can break into and see NPC families do random things in a home

[@emoji7397]

Creepy

[@DariusDareDevil]

You could break into homes in GTA San Andreas

[@Rude_Boi]

Nelson Torres kinda like in GTA V when Franklin broke into Michael's house and you seen Jimmy playing video games, Tracie in her room, and Amanda and the tennis instructor getting touchy?

[@gamesandguitars3901]

i literally feel bad for killing in GTA sometimes because they have phone calls talking to their families and shit, like damn im sorry i feel bad now

[@ari-dynamicarchive]

Let's not forget the fact that Mendoza exists, and everywhere he goes he's been hit. He's been f'ng hit.

[@Tjmoza986]

7:37 aww yes I love playing read dead redemption 2

[@danwordgod2017]

Can't wait for Read Dead Reademption 3!

[@Hano..]

Back on the grind again I see

[@nico_m_t]

Cyberpunk 2077 NPCs: Play the guitar in a realistic way, have routines, talk trough the phone, have conversations in other languages etc. Also Cyberpunk 2077 NPCs: *Stand up from the wheelchair when hit*

[@YoungFroo]

This 8 min video felt like a whole documentary lmao

[@LuddyPuppy]

GTA 5: decent NPCs Cyberpunk: "Write that down! Write that down!" then they just lost the note.

[@yippies3726]

Rdr2 definitely has the best NPCs

[@rono7964]

Every latest rockstar game will do

[@ADB-_]

Can watch these quality videos everyday on repeat, Defo one of the highest qual out there on yt

[@sengiko]

It is clear that you really love cinematography and it pays off, I love your videos man! The pacing, the editing, the script is tops and you deserve more people watching these

[@imfvortex5413]

The production of these videos are great. keep up.

[@PainCrashDaGPuff3000]

It’s funny seeing the abundance of GTA appreciation videos since Cyberpunk’s release. Over 7 years after release and people are really starting to appreciate how great of a game it was, not just for its time, but in general.

[@dutchvanderlinde4965]

This video was extremely well made. Easy to understand and simplistic. Definitely subbed!

[@slothsong080]

Saints Row 2's NPCs were really good too. They worked on a system of nodes they could approach and interact with. The player can too if they stand still too long and go into idle mode near one.

[@inphiknight3141]

I just subbed because of the quality of your work.

[@sapphirenick4171]

Dude... The quality of your videos is just phenomenal! Please keep on making such awesome, almost movie like videos.

[@yeehawnina]

ah so nice to see fresh content 👍 I've been rewatching old videos while waiting, Thank you

[@Amber57499]

Still can't get over the fact that just standing next to NPCs in GTA 5 will make them call the cops on you :p

[@Jonas-ej7id]

NPCs in GTA V have anger issues

[@x-_arthurmorgan-_x5528]

When decade old titles have more stable AI than a modern game.

[@doritodarling]

these videos are incredibly well made. Good job Dark Space

[@ALtheBoi]

The way you handle perspective is incredible, *Very* well done!

[@johnnydavis2484]

I like how he doesn’t even once show footage of watch dogs legion

[@Jonas-ej7id]

He also skips over alot of things that makes WD2 npcs great

[@darkeye8669]

dude you're underrated, you need more fans man

[@SvenNero]

You deserve more views man, the effort you put into this video is overwhelming

[@FordRanger-ie5mu]

Great video as always. Editing, narration, and points made went above and beyond. Keep up the good work!

[@haripk1]

Each and every sentence seems to be aimed at cdpr 🤣

[@Razorjaw86]

I think you totally ignored the NPC’s significance in watchdogs 2, you can interact with them in different ways and have a choice over it, you can use hacking to find out about them, call the cops on them, see how they react and their models are way more random than the GTA 5 ones where you can come across the same NPC multiple times, you can find them around the map doing different things, different animations and they react in different ways, you’ve just skimmed over how they actually are programmed

[@mikeh4818]

True, but to be fair, GTA V is 5 years older. RDR2 is now the new gold standard for NPC's. I can only imagine what GTA 6 will be

[@Razorjaw86]

@@mikeh4818 I’m not saying they’re better than GTA 5’s but they’re as bad as he’s making them out to be

[@mattmattmatt131313]

@@Razorjaw86 I think the clip with the npc jumping out of the way randomly/artificially at 2:21 was more to show the contrast with the GTA physics engine with it's much deeper variety of responses (npcs will brace on your hood, stumble, get knocked back...if the player rams them with a car) and npc actions that tie in nicely with the games basic gameplay (running people over in GTA IV and seeing this unique simulated response each time is simply fun). Whereas in a Watchdogs game (and any other ubisoft game for that matter) you quickly become painfully aware you are just triggering a certain set of "dodge animations" over and over again (like the clip with the lady jumping out of the way of the scooter). Same is true for the rest of the game with npcs overreacting to your actions, doing something weird like stuck in a animation loop, ... I am playing Watchdogs right now and when you are just simply walking on the street, with its slow walk animation, taking in the city vibe, the sounds, the atmosphere, the npc activities and animations, hacking their information on your phone... it's frankly amazing how well that is done (I would almost dare to say it's BETTER than in GTA). But as soon as you the player with your actions disturb any this carefully crafted illusion of a living world it all falls apart quickly. Combine that with ubisofts very bland and limited gameplay and the game is far from a good game.

[@maxel313]

@@Razorjaw86 true, i actually think watch dogs 2's open world feels really lively and real too

[@jvg7498]

while I would agree that watchdogs 2 has far worse AI, he definitely should've shared a bit more on how their AI can also be really interactive too. A while back I was just fooling around at one of the populated beaches with the RC gadget, I had a dog following my RC as I moved it across the beach, and with the taunt ability, I was able to get a guy angry enough to try and destroy my RC, only to fail repeatedly as the crowd around us laughed in amusement.

[@redd_revvz3929]

Dude please don’t stop making videos, your voice and soothing and I absolutely love watching ypu

[@racermigs1]

Something I noticed about NPCs in GTA 4 and 5: In GTA 4, if you stop at a red light, they will still drive into you like you were blocking the street. But in GTA 5, they won't try to drive around or push you if the light is red. But once it turns green they start getting angry at you.

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

I vaguely remember that. Really weird. They definitely have their dumb moments.

[@zeldron3812]

5:15 Actually, I found out that cops in WD2 actually will go off the road, but it will only happen in difficulties set higher than normal Also, in defence for the game I would say that Watch Dogs 2 NPC'S are flawed also very believable. They can react to your emotes (insults, flirts, dances, etc.) in a different way. The same applies about when you jack a car, NPC's fighting each other, when an NPC hits something with his car and even when you call the police on them (some abides, some tries to run away, but gets caught by the cops) And, of course your hacker ability to check their name, hobby, salary, their real time mood that can change, to listen to their phone calls and messages, and they will react to the missions that you did or didn't complete (for instance, when you get a side mission about a zombie virus (the computer virus that makes all messages change to the word "ZOMBIE"), you will sometimes see this virus in random NPC'n phones So yeah, I think that Watch Dogs 2 NPC's are not that bad

[@jaytin1284]

I've never thought about it like this before lol npcs are really important when u think about it

[@moro346]

Man you're way of talking and editing makes me feel like i am watching a documentary about gta online and gta story mode keep the good work

[@kiranaifu]

I'm so glad I found this channel. The contect is addictive and the editing is GOLD. Even if you don't see this, keep up the great content.

[@levkranchevko1432]

GTA V is like a "Ready to play" giant sandbox for me, I could put much mods to suits my taste to the game

[@barnarnars8503]

Ironic how he’s talking about artificial intelligence and sound like a robot too

[@plunger8343]

This just makes me think about Mafia 3 where pedestrians go out of their way to jump off the sidewalk infront of you

[@mynameis8211]

This is actually really freaking cool. Great video dude.

[@williambanack8785]

3:33 His eyes, He's looking right at us! He's looking at us, the viewers! What does he know that we don't? Is it possible that this NPC has sentience?

[@Momoka7]

I hope you didn't talk about GTA5's great NPC ... I just love when I have a cop behind me, drive full speed on a rural road ... and no matter where I turn I know one thing for sure: there WILL be a cop appear right in front of me, out in the desert where no one is. Suddenly being swarmed by cops ... rubber-banding ram me from behind with a ferocity ... without first giving me a chance to surrender and give up. In fact in GTA5 cops usually shoot first ... in the 10 or so hours I played it I never got BUSTED ... they always WASTED me ...

[@slyaspie4934]

Love these video essays they're top class stuff, from the info to editing 👍👍 Please keep them coming

[@gautamr9809]

This is what you call pure gold content ❤️...we need more vids like this

[@Leomatoad]

“Rockstar’s Npcs are pretty good and realistic” *bumps into a cop, cop immediately shoots to kill*

[@PartiallyLoyal]

@Guy Panzerboss If your bla... (This is just a joke)

[@weirdsock3032]

Lol, the title could literally be: "Why Cyberscan 2077 sucks" and the video would still make sense

[@pjotrsc280]

the amount of effort that has gone in to all of these videos...Is astonishing!!!

[@slushman4632]

I love all the details u put into your videos

[@nickharper3137]

As much as i love the story and quest in cyberpunk ,too bad npc in cyberpunk is so stupid

[@TechPrezz]

that is how its meant to be I think..in Cyberpunk most of the npcs are copy paste.... CDPR's main focus was on main quests and the storyline and I think they did it pretty well, despite the bugs. Cyberpunk and GTA 5 quests and story are completely different ones, I think there is no point in comparing GTA 5 with Cyberpunk 2077 just by dragging behavior of NPCs, one talks about our apparent distant future obsessed with technology, body modification and power.. a "bad world" and the other is trying to depict what the world looks and acts like now. And Yea there are some bugs that CDPR must fix...

[@RokashyLowlights]

After the cyberpunk release, CD Projekt Red needs to watch this video for a refresher course

[@GigaJamoke]

I really wish you were able to upload more this channels editing the commentary everything is so fucking cool and so fucking amazing. I’m genuinely thinking about the patreon cause these videos are amazing

[@Comeonhomie]

This channel is too good. Just watched the one about gta shark cards. Keep it up!

[@kostasp6195]

The production quality is soo good, definately worth the one month wait for a new vid

[@newginslab6993]

Even in 2020 with games like Cyberpunk or Watchdogs legion, Rockstar is still unmatched in NPC immersion

[@henning8737]

I see how much love you put in your videos. You are doing a really good job, I wish I would be so good in video editing.

[@Sungblox]

This is my 4th video of yours in a row, your editing is fricking beautiful, keep it up!

[@sharul1709]

Ok soo.... It took 7 years to speak about Gta v details , and still not over yet , (what a game🔥🔥)

[@idekbruh753]

Not GTA V just GTA in general

[@zatcheryalern3454]

Watch Dogs 2 npcs are way better than GTA npcs. The npcs in GTA ignore car accidents, they only all out fight or run/walk away, and they don't call the cops on other npcs. In Watch Dogs 2 you can watch two npcs get into a car accident, get out of their cars, and start throwing insults at each other. Most of the time one of them will come to their senses and return to their car, but sometimes they start shoving or punching. Other npcs will gather around and start recording on their phones or just watch. Eventually a spectating npc will call the police and the cops will come and arrest one or both of the fighting npcs. I love the npcs in GTA and Watch Dogs 2. In both games the npcs have weak points and sometimes act strangely, but Watch Dogs 2 npcs seem to act more like real people. Except from the weird dodging vehicles animations.

[@zatcheryalern3454]

the ragdolls in WD2 are shit as well

[@automation7295]

While GTA has some amazing details for the NPCs, but in my opinion, NPCs in Watch_Dogs 2 are way better than GTA NPCs, especially V. I'm not shitting on GTA or anything. Let's start with Watch_Dogs 2 NPCs: They behave more realistic to car accidents, they get out of their cars, and throwing insults at each other. NPCs do have common sense to return to their vehicles, sometimes they don't. Police do actually respond to car accidents and will arrest the fighting NPCs. NPCs can be found sitting on benches, just like GTA. But unlike GTA, NPCs can also be found cuddling on the bench, holding hands, making out with each other, streaming videos, etc. Gay and lesbian NPCs are also seen, you even find two male or two female kissing, holding hands, cuddle on benches. Including homosexual couples makes sense for San Francisco. Marcus can even pet dogs anytime, except K9 and other enemy dogs. GTA Online recently ability to pet Chop, but only in Franklin's office. GTA: All NPCs in GTA just ignore car accident, when they get out, they simply just want to fight them to death or simply abandon their cars in the middle of the road and never return. Police simply just shoot NPCs on reason, except people do arrest NPCs in GTA IV. NPCs can be found sitting on benches just doing nothing. They're never seen cuddling on benches, holding hands (except GTA SA), making out, etc.. They do carry grocery bags in GTA IV. Gays and lesbians do not exist in Los Santos or Liberty City or anywhere in GTA universe, only references and jokes. Again, I'm NOT shitting on GTA, but in my opinion, Watch_Dogs 2 has better NPCs behavior than GTA.

[@MahmWithThePlan]

Been watching your videos for a while. Man, you pump out quality, keep it up!

[@Infinite_Vacation]

Hey, I like how much effort you put into this video! Is original and well made. Good job 👌

[@DurangoCzechoslovakia]

It’s time for you to become the king of GTA editing after the disappearance of AstroSoup.

[@xBABYLIF3]

Cyberpunk has none of these except graphics like if it is true

[@sebastiaomendonca1477]

Cyberpunk devs spent the 7 years making a gorgeous map and then didnt have time to fill it with actually good AI

[@MartinKusimo]

More incredible work from you.

[@svenvolwater5473]

The editing is too good to be true, keep going like this

[@weonvirtual]

You know this is one of the best videos you will see today when *_the dislike count is -1_*

[@lockdownMxx]

I feel like watchdogs npc’s are much more realistic than gta’s, at least they don’t drive into you because they feel like it

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

They're not too bad in a lot of aspects if I'm honest

[@BumAssNigga408]

GTA is more of a satire on American culture so maybe is just road rage but exaggerated.

[@afeeling8300]

i need more videos, i'm addicted to this

[@sh4yj]

I love the quality and style of your videos. They’re beautiful. The style of the presentation reminds me of ColdFusionTV and the editing reminds me of a cross between ColdFusionTV and TheProperPeople. Keep up the great videos!