My Discord's Favorite Albums of the Decade

The 2019 & 2010s lists: docs.google.com/document/d/1y...
TND Patreon: / theneedledrop
===================================
Follow your melon:
Twitter: / theneedledrop
Instagram: @afantano
FB: / theneedledrop

[@chrisconejo4880]

This discord just told me they have unique taste and tried to show me frank ocean nights and tame impala the less I know the better

[@themysticfedora]

Everyone is an idiot in their own way

[@jakerudd1509]

and sunflower by rex orange county

[@SomeGuyArchivist]

dude, tame impala, lmao

[@drownedcactus5618]

Nights is a pretty ass song

[@IvefoundthetruthonMay]

@@drownedcactus5618 No it's not tf don't cap

[@itsDeej.]

1 more carseat headrest and you'd have a sedan

[@colineasley]

Underrated comment

[@rhino5250]

@@colineasley definitely was stolen from someone else

[@bigboy-qi7sf]

The only funny joke on any fantano video

[@itsDeej.]

@@rhino5250 no I was just drunk af get owned nerd. if I copied someone it was absolutely unintentional even though someone had prob made this joke before however I hate you regardless because you just made this shit not fun and therefore if I see you in real life I will tie your shoelaces together

[@itsDeej.]

@@bigboy-qi7sf the

[@ImClaypool]

I knew Melon in high school, he would sit with me at lunch every day, and rate my lunch from 1-10

[@brXDley]

The sandwich looks good, but I honestly don't think there's enough mayo on it. Also, why turkey instead of ham? I just don't get it, if you would have went with ham I think it would have made the sandwich much better. Great value chips? This is the main problem with your lunch, i expected a more flavorful bag of chips like possibly, Cool Ranch Doritos. Great Value chips just aren't hard hitting enough. Also, really? Grape juice? What if you spilled that on your shirt, wouldn't that ruin your day? I would suggest a more clear drink such as perhaps a bottled water or even something like apple juice. This lunch has a couple good things about it, like the Mott's Apple Sauce and the extra pack of gummies you brought for if you have a sweet tooth, but overall, I'm feeling a light 3 to a strong 4.

[@soggybread3951]

@@brXDley thank you for this godlike copypasta

[@bigbird6978]

this lunch starts off very poorly with a ham and cheese sandwich on sourdough bread which is a good concept but delivered terribly. many of the problems i’ve had with last lunch carry over onto this lunch. it just reeks of its contemporaries and i don’t see what unique qualities it has to set it apart from similar lunches. however the lunch gets slightly better after this point with a bottle of water which is a great item however it carries over the trend of blatantly copying other lunches and being disgustingly bland and tasteless. as time goes on and more items are revealed from the lunchbox, this lunch is almost completely inoffensive consisting of all filler, no killer and many of the criticisms i had of last lunch completely carry over onto this lunch. i’m feeling a light to decent 4.

[@b00psn00t]

Did it have bodacious BEETS

[@akashtiwari1051]

He didn't rate it NOT GOOD? ever?

[@beansntoastyt2616]

I'm so glad Xanarchy is #1. Well deserved

[@mfgrips8133]

Can't believe that nostalgia critics "the wall" wasn't number one, but still a great album.

[@shady8045]

You’re not funny Edit: anyone who still comments on this thread is a confirmed subhuman. Starting now

[@qgp]

@@shady8045 and you're a negative loser, your point?

[@shady8045]

@@qgp im just sick of these retarded meme comments and not seeing shit with actual substance, like only demented seals find them funny anyways it just wastes space

[@qgp]

@@shady8045 i feel you, it is what it is though

[@calvin1559]

4:17 you can see the exact moment he notices Yeezus

[@joaoguilhermeesteves4531]

lmao

[@Dogy0909]

Shout out to the - 😳 - god damn jazz album of the decade

[@lukeanimal]

😂

[@hasanpalabiyik9714]

dude, you made me laugh out loud

[@joelontong7449]

Legit started crying

[@Will-hc4xv]

“My music taste is really unique, you wouldn’t get it.”

[@ijneb1248]

"I like frank ocean and death grips look how sophisticated i am"

[@KoryLunaa]

"I have dyed hair and I heart Neutral Milk Hotel is the best music ever."

[@oddacity5883]

“I have a very mature taste in music compared to people my age”

[@shawnwright336]

@@oddacity5883 AHAHAHAHAHA i don't even know 85% of these albums :(

[@cusionmon6652]

Hey guys this is a collective list, if you're expecting unique albums I don't know what to tell you

[@timtee145]

I feel like I’m watching a bunch of proud kids trying to convince their dad why they should get a dog.

[@TotalAtrocity]

Do you have something against dogs? I'm a part of the problem, I know

[@brrr6342]

Trueee

[@cinzio4615]

@@TotalAtrocity im mr schizoprenia

[@henrylong479]

Damn this top 40 said “women make music?”

[@colbygregory1230]

literally the only two women who made the list I could remember were Lorde and Lana del rey which I love. Melodrama is my favorite album of all time. But like my list would be so different. (My top albums would be NFR by Lana, Blonde by Frank Ocean, Melodrama by Lorde, MAGDALENE by FKA Twigs, Punisher by Phoebe Bridgers) So many good female albums!

[@sammy8749]

Colby Gregory although those albums would probably all be up on my favorite albums of all time, this list was the top albums of the decade, and punisher came out this year lol

[@jamesrodriguez5983]

Pure heroin should be like #4

[@tildeissobieberlike]

I don’t expect anything more from 99% of men listening to music and 85% of women listening to music.

[@jaym8808]

Tbf I don't listen to a lot of women. They completely ruled the 90s and 00s rnb but lately it's harder to find someone I like besides someone like Syd or Noname or Tash Sultana

[@VictorDiaz97]

TND discord be the type of people to call themselves "quirky".

[@m3rbs]

yah, the car seat headrest noms discouraged me from ever joining.

[@awesomeshane17]

Yeah this list made me never want to talk to anyone on that discord

[@Aya_02571]

What’s it even like over there?

[@avalon5821]

Dark Requiem pretty nice

[@connerbruce9730]

I think the top 10 was the only decent part of the list

[@vexingvexillologist7554]

Fantano seems like a father reviewing his only child's report card

[@Maxzatlin]

No

[@pogdog6965]

No

[@shady8045]

No

[@dreadedhalo]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 God, I got that joke. Lol masterful, sir.

[@CarlsCozyCorner]

No

[@petefury94]

People in the comments saying "the list is mainstream" nobody said it had to be full of obscure indie bands. He asked for their favorite, he didn't demand them to be unique.

[@DinoCoke]

How tf do the more popular albums get more votes than the obscure ones?? - This comment section

[@tazmoir]

Half of these albums aren’t “mainstream” anyways. 95% of people do not know who JPEGMAFIA is.

[@cianlynch6494]

@@tazmoir Yep, not mainstream, its fantanostream

[@zackzallie8735]

Hipster nerds that only think mainstream instantly means bad

[@noctuh.]

This entire list was just "I'm not like other girls."

[@tuomas.937]

Yeah literally because its a white cishet man list

[@stungun0]

@@tuomas.937 Teenage white cis man list There wasn’t a single woman in the list lmao

[@quetzal7432]

@@stungun0 melodrama?

[@quetzal7432]

@@stungun0 Lana?

[@camilofajardo9199]

@@quetzal7432 *I'm not like other boys

[@1999_reborn]

What a coincidence. I have now discovered my favourite 40 albums of the decade.

[@yd856]

1999 nah if imma be honest even Fantano’s list is wayyy better. Just add MBDTF and GKMC and move Rodeo up a bit. Still not even close to mine but his top 20ish is better than this.

[@Backs3atGaming]

Y D What’s yours? I’m looking for some new music.

[@CHEESEDADDY]

b The only good album was trench... Okay I’m ready to die

[@steez4778]

@@Backs3atGaming probably 1999 by joey badass and AmeriKKKan corruption by STEEZ

[@aim__freakz8499]

47 rest easy steelo

[@astraycat6668]

Anthony: “Scrolling up a little bit...” Also Anthony: * *Moves from 16 to 5* *

[@fhdream]

melon: extremely nuanced opinions about kanye's discography also melon: bound 2 is a good song

[@vedatandak3312]

f.h. dream his opinions are just unpredictable when it comes to kanye.

[@grub1886]

@@fhdream Bound 2 is a good song😤😤

[@matthewevans3718]

What’s this discord link

[@civar8231]

f.h. dream but Bound 2 is actually good

[@GJ-dv8uq]

ok well clearly everyone in this discord wears cuffed skinny jeans, converse and stussy beanies.

[@k-leb4671]

I can't think of anything worse.

[@rte3384]

They also fold their beanies and wear vans

[@tylersquanto8938]

I get it, a lot of the list gives off “I have unique taste for my age” attitudes. But if we’re honest, most of the best records of this decade are on this list. Obviously I wouldn’t include some that I think are on here due to the sad white boy vibes that plague that discord.

[@jlaviation6207]

Where tf is the Mario Galaxy 2 Soundtrack?

[@thomascatty379]

For real the soundtrack for this game is excellent

[@Rishiyisus]

4 real that soundtrack is beautiful

[@avzarathustra6164]

Right? Both 1 and 2 were awesome. Puzzle Plank is a long enduring favorite, along with the Yoshi island one and Gusty Garden.

[@dylaneasterday6638]

Better question. Where tf is the Persona 5 Soundtrack?

[@shady8045]

Weird way to spell undertale

[@DecayToDeath]

Mod from the server here: the reason the albums are almost all kinda fantano-aligned is because it was aggregated from everyone’s individual lists by choosing the albums that appeared most frequently. Most to all of the lists had more outlandish or obscure picks but since they didn’t appear commonly enough they didn’t end up on the final product. For example, I was the only one with The Chariot - Long Live on my list, so it didn’t appear. It do be like that sometimes.

[@mycatisdumb99]

Hi

[@TheHumanCoke]

ok but why isnt shin guard 2020 on the top of the list im contacting my local senator

[@flammmez]

Why isn't Logic Supermarket number 1? Trash list.

[@stereobub]

yep, i was gathering data for this too and most if not all people had personal passions that only got mentioned once or twice across the whole server. the only thing people really agreed on was tpab being #1 of the decade and igor #1 of the year - the rest was pretty uniform and mostly just stuff everyone has heard and is easy to put on a list.

[@ferr9809]

Was Iceage mentioned? It would've been very surprising for Anthony to see them at least at 39

[@penguinraids2723]

Why is there a channel called “slave-market” in your discord sever melon?

[@pratinavtewari452]

Why do u think??

[@ConvincingPeople]

It's called BDSM. Anthony is very sex-positive.

[@salutarypants0792]

BDSM stands for Bnifty Dminimalist Slave-Market

[@oldpotatoman4838]

Bitch Face Big Dad, Small Mom

[@nightwingmix1]

IBoss 2004 That just sounds worse than what it actually stands for

[@7ngel]

Of course his fan base would have Kendrick death grips and frank ocean as top 3 😂😂😂😂😂

[@1vake496]

What do you think about lil peeps come over when you're sober?

[@e.z.3427]

Kendrick is a fucking GOAT in the hip-hop scene though, and definitely the top force in this past decade. Frank Ocean and Death Grips I can do without, prefer Danny Brown and JPEG Mafia's stuff.

[@7ngel]

Anthony Salerno Not just peep, quite a few others that he shits on for no reason but to be an a hole

[@7ngel]

@Anthony Salerno I think it goes beyond that where he purposely berates and mocks the artist and puts them down over some fckn music. Thats why i hate this dude.

[@7ngel]

@Anthony Salerno bladee review

[@imranreaza3337]

Saying that the “sad white boys” in your audience deserve to be sad because you effed their mothers was a bit much. Subscribed.

[@nut_in_meme]

I'm not surprised Die Lit was number 1. Good job guys picking Fanta Mans favorite album!

[@parham2653]

I am the first reply to a 197-like comment

[@97EDUB]

Die Lit is the most overrated trash album ever.

[@mateusnobrega9092]

@@97EDUB you say that coz u don't understand cartinese

[@bigpondpond9965]

@@97EDUB Wow, you're the overrated trash after that comment. Carti made music AND you mad.

[@97EDUB]

Mateus Nóbrega Why should I understand Cartisim? I lost brain cells after the first listen.

[@nelson1tom]

I honestly don’t understand where the 8 minute xxxtentacion rant came from.

[@brainer3]

Hilarious bro

[@notevenironicallyfunny204]

Funny

[@jacktm9916]

hahaha

[@jaakko222]

Me nether. And the 5 minute sub rant about xxxtentacion's dagger dick was really uncalled for and frankly disrespectful

[@nelson1tom]

Frankie Holmes Agreed.

[@tj9944]

Cant help but feel like half these albums are only on the list because fantano reviewed them positively

[@theobuniel9643]

True. If Daughters and Swans weren't given 10 scores from the Melon, I highly doubt they'd be here.

[@deiz1083]

Mbdtf and Yeezus say otherwise

[@jvbble]

@@deiz1083 also 2011 Twin Fantasy being on there at all as well as the 2018 version being above ToD

[@ytpremi7809]

@@jvbblewhat is ToD

[@jvbble]

@@ytpremi7809 Teens of Denial

[@woodwardsam]

Very relieved to see that the entire top ten of this list consisted of solely Logic's Supermarket.

[@hey-bf3ds]

what about confessions of a dangerous mind? it made up numbers 3,5,7,9 and 10, get ur facts straight.

[@chuggie]

I’m so glad as a community that The Big Day is No. 1 Chance loves his wife

[@nahuduok]

Flame Beats same

[@lukess.s]

Everyone loves Chance's wife. Every. Last. One of us.

[@sunflwrchyld]

I love the Big Day almost as much as chance love his wife.

[@zachhood7655]

I also choose this guys wife

[@rose_d_mary]

Ooh I love my wiife yes I love my life A let’s go ride a biiiike with my wife A

[@assortedlunatics4381]

Needleman’s shakin up the flannel game

[@97EDUB]

What flannel game?

[@micahpaulsen3940]

He’s even got multiple textures with the flannel and denim, I’m give this a light to decent 8 on this one.

[@getisbhai]

Zane Lowe Needleman interview?

[@evanthehuman2124]

Never heard him referred to as needleman and i like it

[@zzz-tl7kn]

What else would you expect from KZbin’s primary sex symbol.

[@ryanschaeffer3384]

Made me so happy to see c418 on the list lol

[@k-leb4671]

It wasn't his best album though.

[@butterfingersman]

@@k-leb4671 minecraft project is incredibly solid, the music in minecraft for a long time was the only companion to singleplayer. great, ambient, moody, probably generation defining, i love project alpha.

[@lilsebbo6099]

Why did I see a folder on your computer called “KKK scheduale”

[@aaronjohnson8995]

Lol

[@light3181]

Bro where , time stamp it pls 😂😂

[@lettuce7539]

@@light3181 18:41

[@nadirseman96]

@@lettuce7539 I knew it wasn't actually there but I still clicked. Very nice stuff there

[@cherryfocusdotcom]

Alternate title: Dissing My Fans for Liking Car Seat Headrest More than Death Grips

[@coltonc8562]

Johann Paolo got what they deserved 😤

[@braedenhunter6501]

@@urmom8948 opinionssssssssssss

[@GamingOS]

@@urmom8948 your opinion is ass

[@TheDobleQ]

And 22, A Million.

[@tylerasuncion3208]

Called me out like that smh

[@saintonsaturn7070]

Lets be honest, you just wanted to see where MBDTF was.

[@97EDUB]

Not surprising it’s at #1.

[@user-qd6im2hp2e]

Legion Vision so he changed his mind on the “6” rating then

[@VaultRadio]

Yeah it’s supremely overrated

[@VaultRadio]

Kuba Sosnowski it has high highs (power, devil in a new dress, runaway) but the lows are very low (hell of a life, half of monster, blame game having a unnecessary Chris rock skit, so appalled besides ye jay and push) I don’t know how fans can call it a perfect album when the flaws are so clearly there, it’s like they’re ignored on purpose to suit the hivemind that this album is somehow a masterpiece

[@BIadelores]

@@VaultRadio Or those lows are not lows and you're wrong

[@zakkcooke8050]

Alternate title: TND fanboys/girls echo albums Anthony like in an attempt to get validation.

[@antonioio3437]

List was made based on their last.fm charts turns out fantano fans listen to what fantano says is good who would've thought

[@m.arnold9145]

@calypso what difference does that make?

[@huzi37709]

@@antonioio3437 Turns out albums fantano rates highly are actually great albums who would have thought from an experienced music reviewer.

[@k-leb4671]

Fangirls? Ha, get real.

[@rte3384]

*Virgins, not fanboys/girls

[@Benjiroyoface]

man grades his fanbase on how identical their music taste is to his

[@invincible794]

Anthy we call you “melon” when you gonna call ur fans, ur “seeds” Edit: a lot of people in my reply’s want us to be called the “twinks”? Not fucking cool.

[@spearmint165]

gross wtf

[@nielsbaumann6485]

Cringe

[@therandomchicken6517]

vagabond - because we’re inside him

[@tomf.oolery6926]

P o l a r o i d z hot

[@anonymouspanda2841]

no we need to go back to "my little needledrops"

[@frankcooper3737]

Why does your jacket say Simp on it

[@DrachenYT]

That was fucking with me the whole video, lmao.

[@willdg8108]

Cause his whole audience are simps Me included

[@willdg8108]

Tyler Morales ‘twas a joke

[@alia4682]

Frank Cooper thats one self aware melon

[@JP-xn3gf]

His audience simps for his opinions

[@dijonnoodles663]

“A lot of very sad white boys in my audience” I feel atacked

[@zaynealmurshidi1572]

They did have a Bon Iver album on the list...

[@Eduardo-zp1os]

At 90% of the times i desagree with Fantano's opinions about music, sometimes it sounds very easy to predict if he's gonna like or dislike an album. But who cares, he's entertaining and fun, and a true enthusiast about music in general. And music is good. Respecto.

[@poudink5791]

If it's easy to predict whether he's going to like or dislike an album, that's a good thing. It means his opinions as a reviewer are consistent.

[@StyxTBuferd]

Twin Fantasy being on the list twice is a top quality meme, well done Discord

[@ashleycatz]

They're both great, how is that a meme

[@DefenestrateYourself]

moupsoup Because it’s excessive obvi

[@recipoldinasty]

moupsoup this list is as memeable as predictible, entry level amazing albums tho

[@StyxTBuferd]

@@ashleycatz I mean both versions are amazing, but it's still mostly the same album getting two spots on the list. You could easily just have one on the list to represent the both of them.

[@ashleycatz]

@@StyxTBuferd they're both unique enough to deserve different spots

[@kane1336]

" I have a very unique music taste" - people who made the list

[@sunfucker2213]

Great taste tho

[@mechaluke]

It's an aggregate list based on lists made by people who are all Fantano fans, of course the list is gonna be somewhat predictable. That doesn't mean that the people who submitted a list don't have a unique taste in music, it's just inevitable that any obscure picks are gonna drown beneath the ones that everyone picked.

[@nielsbaumann6485]

@@mechaluke still I would have expected the list to be more mainstream. It's filled with a lot of very niche albums

[@BIadelores]

@@nielsbaumann6485 Such as? I didn't see any albums that struck me as particularly niche, though I was surprised with the inclusion of some of them like Plastic Beach (no idea people loved this album so much) or the Tribe album, but I wouldn't call either of those niche at all

[@emie1170]

funny thing is they really have unique taste. not by this channels standards of course. everyone likes the same here apparently

[@gloomsdoom649]

Needs more Car Seat Headrest

[@alicestocklistockli8394]

I’m not complaining

[@hendricklamar6558]

This list contained every perfect album on their respective place. One of the best lists I've seen this decade, if not the best. Strong 5/10

[@screamingllamaproductions8570]

The decision to make a list of the best races halfway through was a little distasteful, but good video overall.

[@connemignonne]

#1 Italian

[@LOLquendoTV]

1. Khajit

[@therandomchicken6517]

Screaming Llama Productions #2 the 200m dash

[@torrent8446]

#1 the human race :)

[@prance4058]

@@LOLquendoTV M'aiq is tired now, go bother somebody else

[@godnotavailable2094]

"I'm feeling a strong crossover appeal between me and Will Toledo's audience on this one."

[@97EDUB]

Tran Sition

[@salutarypants0792]

Happy's perfect Perfects tame Tame and cashmere go together Cashmere makes perfect better John and Shelly my people would never Don't it feel good to drive a bus? People need to get picked up

[@koenmetekohy1296]

Anthony’s rating for (almost) each album: 40 (C418 - Minecraft Alpha): No review, as of right now 39 (Lorde - Melodrama): 7/10 38 (Brockhampton - Saturation III): 8/10 37 (Lana Del Ray - Norman F*cking Rockwell): 8/10 36 (Jeff Rosenstock - Worry): 8/10 35 (Kamashi Washington - The Epic): 9/10 34 (Kanye West - Yeezus): 5/10 33 (Car Seat Headrest - Twin Fantasy 2011): No review, as of right now. 32 (A Tribe Called Quest - We Got It from Here... Thank You 4 Your Service): 9/10 31 (JPEGMafia - Veteran): 8/10 30 (Tim Hecker - Virgins): 9/10 29 (Bon Iver - 22, A Million): 5/10 28 (Run The Jewels - Run The Jewels 3): 8/10 27 (Car Seat Headrest - Teens of Denial): 8/10 26 (Flying Lotus - Cosmogramma): 8/10 25 (MGMT - Congratulations): 8/10 24 (Freddie Gibbs & Madlib - Piñata): 9/10 23 (Radiohead - A Moon Shaped Pool): 8/10 22 (Queens of the Stone Age - Like Clockwork): 9/10 21 (Brockhampton - Saturation I): 9/10 20 (Everything Everything - Get To Heaven) 19 (Gorillaz - Plastic Beach): 7/10 18 (Father John Misty - Pure Comedy): 9/10 17 (Car Seat Headrest - Twin Fantasy 2018): 8/10 16 (Daft Punk - Random Access Memories): 8/10 15 (LCD Soundsystem - This Is Happening): 9/10 14 (Mount Eerie - A Crow Looked At Me): 9/10 13 (David Bowie - Blackstar): 9/10 12 (Tyler The Creator - Flower Boy): 8/10 11 (Fleet Foxes - Helplessness Blues): 9/10 10 (Kanye West & Kid Cudi - Kids See Ghosts): 10/10 9 (Swans - To Be Kind): 10/10 8 (Tyler The Creator - Igor): 9/10 7 (Daughters - You Won’t Get What You Want): 10/10 6 (Danny Brown - Atrocity Exhibition): 9/10 5 (Kendrick Lamar - Good Kid, m.A.A.d City): 9/10 4 (Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy): 6/10 3 (Frank Ocean - Blonde): 8/10 2 (Death Grips - The Money Store): 10/10 1 (Kendrick Lamar - To Pimp A Butterfly): 10/10

[@mango-ww3yw]

Plastic beach is 9 now.

[@imgonnatellmom3245]

I like how all the top 10 albums have great reviews And then there's mbdtf

[@holylucane9019]

He gave plastic beach a 90

[@TheGuyBL0ND3]

Already calling TPAB is number 1 and MBDTF is gonna be top 5 at least. Edit: yes

[@anuel3780]

FANTANO MY MAN PLEASE CLARIFY THAT IT'S YOUR PATROEN DISCORD OUR FANMADE DISCORD IS GETTING FLOODED

[@eduardo_moya]

He did

[@tyronium6950]

He did

[@SunnyOddny]

He very much did, pretty early on in the video too.

[@A.S.28]

He did. A lot of spergs in the discord, like clockwork

[@shitocodone8940]

Anuel he did

[@redcalxz6846]

Your discord server is a hellscape I'm never returning to

[@santisinferno]

TRUUUUE

[@j.rlouis3756]

I just assume all discord servers are full of weirdos.

[@jonl7893]

its legit a bunch of retards. I dont understand why anyone would go there

[@stereobub]

this is about the patreon discord server, which is much less of a hellscape! get in there instead

[@lukamagicc]

LMAO. I was gonna ask how do I get in, nevermind..

[@scylla019]

Needle Drop fans are the kind of people who value albums according to how much they can flex they know of its existence to other needle drop fans.

[@roddor7254]

Listens to Tame Impala: You’re so quirky Listens to Drake: you’re such a normie

[@dpd420]

wha

[@_PuppetMaster86]

Cuz it’s true! 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@astronova6150]

i mean you deserve to be bullied to listen to drake

[@prith7900]

Also cuz tame impala is better than drake in every way

[@Dan-pi6dx]

serious comment alert : can you do a vid on like 10 albums / discography ( of an artist) that you would choose if you would be stuck on a desert island forever - i know its kinda cliche but meh i really want to know if you would choose like quantity over quality cause of the massive time period etc etc

[@Greenhourglass]

u should ask it for a Let's Argue on his ig/twitter or send it as fanmail, i'm curious to hear it too

[@LightPink]

Thank you based God

[@r005ta8]

It's so refreshing to actually see a sane comment in this comment section. I totally agree

[@LemonyTerror]

That question came up before on a let's agree or something and all he said was Prince and wasn't sure past that @greenhourglass

[@mostlyimportant4212]

I was surprised to see you so accepting of Speeding bullet to heaven on number 1

[@97EDUB]

Are you that blind? Clearly, Revival is #1.

[@nicholasallingham9504]

@@97EDUB nah you guys are dumb The big day is the best.

[@isaacorsomethin9910]

Nah man, its total xanarchy

[@nicholasallingham9504]

@@isaacorsomethin9910 no its not idiot kamikaze is king

[@Darknight4434]

Clearly its Nostalgia Critics - The Wall, smh my head

[@joeboonmusic4004]

Sad to see Carrie and Lowell being left off yet another list of top albums of the decade. I truly think it's some of the most perfect songwriting I've heard for years.

[@heckingbamboozled8097]

I've never seen an audience as hostile towards itself as Melon's. These comments are weirdly hostile towards an album list.

[@poudink5791]

There's the SMT/Persona community where everyone in the community hates everyone else in the community.

[@brettd7923]

Whoa it's like an echo chamber of stuff you like. That's crazy....

[@joshcuneo2782]

Especially #4

[@kys3264]

Wow people who watch fantano like similar type of music as him. What a shocker

[@hipster_tacos]

Tbh, I tend to disagree with just about every opinion Melon puts out, but I keep continuing to watch.

[@Pontificate]

I would wager that most of the people on the discord haven’t heard half of the list.

[@aixide]

@@Pontificate I've heard (or at least know the name of) only 6 albums on there, 4 because of Melon.

[@Trogdor390]

TND discord clearly full of doomers

[@cartoonchaos2594]

I like your TF2 profile pic

[@driftingthroughthisplace5898]

more like clearly full of people who base their music opinions off of fantano’s high ratings

[@fisheatsyourhead]

@@driftingthroughthisplace5898 which is why yeezus is there

[@bipbong2906]

@@fisheatsyourhead whoa an outlier crazy bro

[@nalimlattarai2873]

bip bong that’s not

[@zackhologram6563]

This is the whitest list I have ever seen

[@RaylaEclipse]

The list looks like that of the most stereotypical discord white boy. I feel like if every TND fan contributed as opposed to the discord it might be more varied.

[@yd856]

et Han of Astora yeah cause only the dudes with no social life join a needledrop discord. The list very much reflects that.

[@jo_nm9484]

Oh that's because the whole background is white

[@gustavoramirez4569]

It looks like only white ppl patronizes him :( but it's ok, he stays objective on his reviews despite the fact his being funded (partially bc of the youtube revenue) by white ppl lmao

[@Pontificate]

et Han of Astora it’s because it wasn’t based on discussion and voting it was just based on all of their individual lists and how much everything appeared.

[@DiamondAxolotl]

This entire comment section is full of people making fun of condescending music fans, while simultaneously being incredibly condescending. Wow, it's almost like a collective list of top music from a group that follows a music reviewer will tend to have similar tastes to that reviewer, and that popular stuff will get the most votes. Who is fucking surprised? All of these albums are good albums, I don't think most people would generally dispute that, so I don't see what the problem is. You can't complain about music snobbery while being incredibly snobby at the fact that the music that was on the list wasn't "obscure" enough for you. Good music is good music, regardless of how popular it is. How about you people just let people like what they like.

[@georgeporter1836]

This comment is full of you making fun of condescending music fans, while simultaneously being incredibly condescending. Wow, it's almost like a collective comment section that follows a music reviewer will be critical of music tastes, and that popular comments will get the most likes. Who is fucking surprised? All of these comments are good comments, I don't think most people would generally dispute that, so I don't see what the problem is. You can't complain about comment snobbery while being incredibly snobby at the fact that comments in the comment section weren't "conformist" to your opinion. Good comments are good comments, regardless of your opinion on them. How about you just let people like what they like.

[@krlllx]

George Porter can you be more of a hypocrite? You say he should let people enjoy what they want when the comments he is criticising make fun of the music that they enjoy.

[@DiamondAxolotl]

George Porter big L

[@fluf9941]

RANDOM ACESS MEMORIES SHOULD BE THE BEST OF THE DECADE WE ALL FORGOT ABOUT HOW GOOD IT WAS BUT ITS HERE NOW

[@bart6929]

QSFluff Agree

[@Aya_02571]

Great album.

[@LOLquendoTV]

If only Daft Punk release another album this decade :(

[@callumwakeling8443]

I agree 100%

[@fckSashka]

I agree

[@baronvonbeandip]

He called it here, folks. Frank Ocean's 10/10 is coming out in 2025.

[@lonk2902]

My favourite album of the decade wasn't on the list. That is because your discord mods tried to silence me, but I will not be silenced! THE (OBJECTIVELY CORRECT) TOP FIVE ALBUMS OF THE DECADE IS: 5: Death Grips - No love deep web 4: P.O.S. - Never better (Ten year anniversary edition) 3: Death Grips - No love deep web 2: Clipping. - Literally all of their albums becasue they are very good 1: Now that's what I call music! - Now That's What I Call Christmas 2

[@ok6866]

Damn sorry to hear that bro

[@lonk2902]

@@ok6866 Are you the higher mid level competitive super smash bros. ultimate Ganondorf main SeaBass? ARE YOU? BIG FAN I LIKE HOW YOU USE FLAME CHOKE A LOT IT'S VERY CREATIVE!

[@ok6866]

seabass

[@ugonwigwe5136]

@@lonk2902 how long did it take u to get into midcity? im trying to get into clipping and im going through their discog in order. the songs on that tape are really.. loud. like really really loud and almost earpiercing. i know thats their thing, hence the name, but im not sure what to think of it.

[@lonk2902]

@@ugonwigwe5136 I was already listening to noise artists like dreamcrusher before I discovered clipping. so their music was far from the most earpiercing thing I listened to.

[@monstersponge9096]

flattered to see tyler the creator's Goblin is number 1! stay strong tnd discord

[@conorcarmichael]

Melon loves experimental, as long as it isn’t Bon Iver or Yeezus

[@butterfingersman]

bon iver: hoOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOo OoOOOOOoo oooOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO every white listener: hOYL I... I FEEL LIKE THIS.................

[@no1u521]

@@butterfingersman lmaoooo

[@freddysamjacob363]

I mean, he still has pretty valid criticism for both the records.

[@quinnd3726]

Yeezus isn’t experimental

[@olivias2437]

Watching this at the risk that I may finally learn what a discord is

[@aleph4425]

Olivia S child grooming app

[@MelMelodyWerner]

Discord is a wallet salesperson killing simulator. yw.

[@GamingOS]

Boomer time

[@AbsoluteAbsurd]

Kekitsu Thank you.

[@KamFails]

There are literally only 2 women on this list lmao yeet

[@KamFails]

The 2019 list I can forgive however

[@jonathancarranza6046]

They should make better music

[@braxtonslife7779]

Jonathan Carranza As if half of the people on the list make good music.

[@KamFails]

@@jonathancarranza6046 Perhaps their music is just as good it's just that men don't take it as seriously because of a ton of sociocultural factors I mean TRY and tell me Kate Bush's music isn't just as good if not BETTER than her contemporaries at the time. See also Bjork, Fiona Apple, Joni Mitchell, Rico Nasty, Phoebe Bridgers, just to name a few

[@jonathancarranza6046]

@@KamFails I don't think we have to blame society just because those women you mention don't have enough appeal. People like what they like.

[@Mr_DPZ]

Yeezus is legitimately my favorite Kanye album. Though as far as the entire decade goes, it can't surpass To Pimp a Butterfly or AT.LONG.LAST.A$AP, but probably ties with Blank Face LP for third place.

[@falo4043]

Finally some respect in ATLLA,amazing album, yeezus it's one of the best kanye albums, not my favorite i think mbdtf and late registration are better but it's awesome

[@maximequinternet7913]

I find it sad how little recognition Denzel curry’s taboo gets.

[@Pedro-tc5kd]

Its a good album for sure, but i wouldnt be sad if it isnt on a top 40 of the decade

[@barry.mccockiner]

Maxime Quinternet it’s fairly good, sure, but is it really a top 40 album? It’s probably somewhere in the low 100 to high 200 range for me

[@cartikitty8948]

it's not "good" tf it's fucking amazing

[@jasoncortes2658]

Zuu is way better

[@Chrono-hn5nv]

Why would you listen to any rap music when you have Taboo

[@luxmar1]

We get it, you have a discord

[@shwift8789]

Car seat headrest legitimately could have been number one if it weren't for the amount of versions sharing the votes.

[@speedtriials]

no one can convince me that twin fantasy isn’t the best album ever made

[@alejandroacevedo4005]

17:44 nice Eminem’s Rap God flow

[@jimbo6519]

Angelic 2 The Core just edging it into the top 10? A real curveball I must say.

[@sicsmoo1]

No E•MO•TION , list is invalid

[@KonkeyDongkey]

No crazy frog either

[@jelletimmermans3916]

EXACTLY!

[@Jamie2OO4]

I agree

[@eduardodias8302]

@@KonkeyDongkey fuck you bitch

[@KonkeyDongkey]

@@eduardodias8302 Bruh

[@BassLiberators]

I like how he automatically assumed that all three Saturations would be higher up the list, but 2 just straight up wasn't there.

[@OptifiedPixels]

Now I can listen to unique music that suppliments my unique taste

[@jacklujan-peru2453]

💀

[@vinsarasin8658]

Shout out to Carseat Head Rest!! They clearly didn't get enough love in the list.

[@jaybaby5896]

I discovered Carseat Head Rest like two days ago, loved them, and then randomly happened upon this video. I am being watched.

[@pietarikuikka795]

When you're so early there's no funny comments

[@hesus9978]

very original haha

[@pietarikuikka795]

@@hesus9978 thank you❤️

[@chrissan2044]

There's never funny comments

[@ugo5200]

There are no funny comments on Fantano’s videos

[@MelMelodyWerner]

the same is true when you're late, so don't worry 'bout it

[@edenton2002]

oh my god. hive minded. i'm establishing a new genre known as needle drop discord

[@emily-404]

the lack of charli on this list shows how male this audience is lol

[@trevstation]

she’s not top 40 material

[@lucasrienstra4163]

@@trevstation Charli is though

[@goghballs8938]

And Carly, Weyes, FKA, Phoebe, Lingua Ignota, or any woman at all lol

[@lucasrienstra4163]

​@@goghballs8938 Kacey musgraves, kkb (ik it's a band but the main singer is a girl so whatever it counts i guess), Lingua Ignota, Rina Sawayama, Björk or even rosalia should be on here tbh

[@goghballs8938]

@@lucasrienstra4163 Yes! Time 'n' Place, SAWAYAMA, Golden Hour, Vulnicura, Caligula, so many great albums left out.

[@michaelflynn7688]

Like Clockwork is at least top 5 for me. The drums on that album kick so much ass, especially on If I Had a Tail. And the guitar work on it is so all over the place but in a way that feels so right; which I thought applied to tracks like Smooth Sailing and Fairweather Friends as well. Plus you got Vampyre of Time and Memory, where the Piano and Guitar work so well together to make one of the most Melancholic songs ive ever listened to. Every song is at least very good. But the meat of the album, starting at Sat By the Ocean and ending with I Appear Missing, make it a Masterpiece imo. Especially the last minute of I Appear Missing. All in all, the album sounds like what coming back to life might feel like.

[@Lynskey263]

I had it #2 on my list behind MBDTF. My God is the sun and I Appear Missing both in my top 10 favourite songs from the last decade too with the latter having one of the best finishes to a rock song ever.

[@jeff5685]

I Sat By The Ocean has me crying every time, such a beautiful fucking song. and I'd definitely put it in my top 10

[@grigno97]

I appear missing best rock song of the decade

[@adreto2978]

Michael Flynn like clockwork is so fucking good

[@beammeupjosi]

Let's not undersell keep your eyes peeled and the title track. That fucking instrumental break on ...like clockwork is heavenly

[@Novaze59]

Does your jacket say simp? We need to know Anty.

[@kurexx3424]

Christian Lorenzen it says “Wimp”

[@imnotactuallydead8890]

He wore it again in the new review

[@dombawamba7519]

I'm so glad Everything Everything got such a high placement

[@jakeadams7697]

Same dood it's in my top 10. Totally didn't expect to see it tho.

[@aleccangemi111]

Wow, I agree so much with your discord! Total Xanarchy was my #1 too!

[@hc3314]

My album of the decade is IGOR. While there may be technically better albums out there, IGOR hit me like no other album did, and was something I'd never heard before in music. It genuinely captivated me and now whenever I hear one song from it I have to go and listen through all of it. On a more objective standpoint it takes influences from some of the other bests of the last decade, meaning its an amalgamation of the best. I love the album dude.

[@JorgeGomez-hx5uu]

Great statement.

[@Daplin1]

Atrocity exhibition wins because it gave me the most music. From listening time to samples found. It won my decade

[@7___k554]

Jake paul litmas album because it added tradition to all of my christmas spriit

[@untitledunmastered5427]

@@7___k554 the streets need a jake paul x michael bublé album

[@Daplin1]

I'm gonna edit this with a nod to strays with rabies

[@alextheo9766]

Bruh, it's like this list was created by the curly haired white boys and alt-girls with elaborate eye-liners from my school wtf. The only thing missing is tame impala and maybe rex orange county if you're "quirky" enough to handle that.

[@ricardohernandez8683]

Literally the most accurate description I’ve heard lmao

[@Pontificate]

Make sure they are wearing dark side of the moon shirts even if they don’t like the album or the band. Just so you know they like music.

[@atotallyrandomperson3889]

This whole comment section keeps talking about these kinds of people, yet I’ve never met anyone who has even heard of either of those artists and half of the artists on this list

[@roddor7254]

I’ve yet to meet someone like this

[@Caaaaspeeer]

Lonerism deserved to be here tbh

[@Finkster5]

Did nobody else like Crack Up by Fleet Foxes? I liked Helplessness Blues well enough, but I could never think of it as one of my all-time favorites (made my top 100 but not my top 50). Crack Up is just such a well made, subtle piece of work that grows on you over time. Also the two dudes from Wolf Parade killed it this decade, with the debut from Operators and the last Moonface album absolutely knocking it out of the park (both in my top 10).

[@Scoob3rs]

This list was so predictable lmao.

[@ijneb1248]

Suburban white boy music

[@poosniff44]

@@ijneb1248 Yall try and be so different

[@xiscaw]

@@poosniff44 fr people hate shit because its popular

[@ijneb1248]

@Cinda Oppenheimer you know i gotta say it

[@MongerOfStrings8222]

Doesn't make it bad ffs

[@Zelgaro]

So no Janelle Monae and no St Vincent Discord is sexist confirmed.

[@ConvincingPeople]

Zelgaro Regarding St. Vincent, while I personally love Strange Mercy and especially the self-titled, they are slightly messier, more divisive records than Actor, which I would say remains her best. Still disappointing, however. And really, while I wouldn't call it outright sexist, the list is exceedingly dudely-mainly, I think, as a function of the people who seek out and stan female artists being less likely to come to a consensus on what record was best from whom-although the effusive love for Will Toledo, Tyler and the Brockhampton boys at least keeps it from being painfully straight.

[@jasonwren1124]

Also think fiona apple, charli, björk, little simz, tierra whack should have been in contention to be on this list too

[@Lennli]

theres more car seat headrest than women on this list lol

[@Pedro-jf4hw]

@Vatro Skok yikes

[@Betta66]

Masseduction and Dirty Computer will always be bops tho

[@keensley91]

Some great recommendations for me to check out. I'd have put Slowdive's self titled and Firepower by Judas Priest in my list!

[@conjonboi4506]

I have a problem where I haven't touched an artists whole discography or even more than 2 of so records and I had no idea about Tim heckers record virgins being so high. As I discovered him a few months ago with anoyo and loved it. Hope isolation can help change that

[@stephenanthonysmith]

8:02 You act like the Congratulations placement is generous, yet it’s my favorite album of all time

[@leocalostros7442]

what a great album

[@brendanspaulding7930]

Stephen A. Smith i wonder what he’d think of me replacing congratulations with the self titled and putting it even higher. MGMT are hardcore overlooked and I wish he cared about their other work more. (He did place congratulation on his top 200 along with LDA to be fair)

[@zeilian]

Not my favourite album of all time (that's TOTBL), but I sure as hell love Congratulations to death.

[@Revealingstorm.]

I don't get the love for congratulations. LDA is much better in my opinion.

[@stephenanthonysmith]

Revealing Storm LDA has my favorite MGMT song, but I think Congratulations has no skips and is just overall fun

[@ROL4NDpkmnguide]

In other words... People in Melon’s discord have his same opinion on music, how weird

[@keeronrahman4210]

except for MBDTF

[@ivoxvxi7482]

Not really but k

[@odysseus9176]

ROL4NDpkmnguide I mean he disagrees with every other album on here

[@Will-bn9km]

@@odysseus9176 Eh, he says he likes them but would change the order of them. But that could just be fantano trying to be as nice as possible.

[@mattymario1004]

People tend to like the music that there favourite reviewer likes. Why would you watch someone you who disagree with more than agree with (for music journalism at least)

[@jare___]

Maybe I'm missing something but are y'all really telling me that Lana Del Rey is the only woman of the 2010's to release a record that is deserving of Top 40 of the whole decade status? Open up your taste, y'all.

[@decoy033x]

Lorde? Edit. I do however agree with your point tho. I would personally add one of Chelsea Wolf records in the list. She is underrated even between needledrops.

[@ericcartman7188]

Aurora

[@user-js8ud3ub9p]

“Open up your taste, y’all” lol

[@therealpotpol4027]

Imagine using y'all unironically

[@OsirusHandle]

"like more things"

[@user_dudeman3]

im suprised they didnt include thundercat after adding flying lotus and kamasi washington to the list

[@lean.2366]

I bet the ones on TND patreon discord are the ones who buy the metallic wallets

[@_Maxten]

i can't tell if this is popular opinion or technically just core mleon fans' opinion

[@golden-sun]

MELON fans

[@eee9266]

Melon fans are afraid of women. This list only has two female artists. It’s definitely mleon seed opinion.

[@norkenz2756]

surface level melon taste

[@KonkeyDongkey]

This is absolutely melon taste

[@roscosinclair8114]

Shocked that given the Mount Eerie/ Car seat Headrest/ Radiohead love that Sun Kil Moon didn't make the cut. Benji is fantastic and I wouldn't have even been upset to see Among the Leaves on here

[@MrSkaterfan21]

To Pimp a Butterfly is my favorite album too, I thought of that in the shower the other day but no surprise to see it’s yours too.

[@yandhi5016]

Shout out to Random Access Memories

[@callumrymer3046]

Lol these people on the discord basically just regurgitating what Fantano likes without anything surprising. Also... Wow, only two female artists on the entire list...no Joanna Newsom, Julia Holter, Angel Olsen, Alvvays, Bjork, Courtney Barnett, Fiona Apple, Fever Ray, FKA Twigs, Grimes, Janelle Monae, Jenny Hval, Mitski, Robyn or Solange in sight...and oddly Sufjan Stevens who I thought would be here twice.

[@kunjoaquin4syth]

Not having Sufjan is surprising - perhaps he is a little too old for Fantano's audience.

[@ambereensadiq368]

melodrama by Lorde was amazing :)

[@stvivianne8820]

Alvvays fuuucckkkinggg rocksss

[@worrywirt]

Car Seat Headrest Cult RISE UP!!!!!

[@hakongjerde1611]

Would love to see a video on "the best SONGS of the decade". Makes these different albums and various genres more accessible for the people who haven't discovered them properly yet, such as myself;))