Film Critic Ranks Top 5 Pixar Films • Top 5 Beatdown

[@watcher]

Hey Everybody! Shane, here! Sorry I didn't take this exercise seriously. I thought by adding a joke pick for my number 5 (ha ha, I'm a funny guy!) that it would add plenty of lol's cause it's such a controversial pick (ha ha, I'm a controversial guy!) but I now realize I have disrespected the list and would like to apologize. Anyways, enjoy the rest of the picks, they're gems!

[@isabelle7297]

Ryan we know that’s you

[@ldragon8480]

It's okay Shane. My Dad loves Cars I actually enjoy them as well. They did a really wonderful job building the world of cars in the first movie.

[@itsturt]

Shane is right about Cars and he should say it

[@natasham4803]

Ryan just because you’re isolating from Shane doesn’t mean you can pose as him

[@sabrinasenhaj4796]

cars is a beautiful movie!My brother and I used to re-watch it every day

[@virgomoons]

"She's a wonderful mother, but she didn't take me to see Toy Story"-Shane 2020

[@RachelBastow]

Journey Welborn he totally doesn’t hold any grudges

[@mrs6pack]

TheFemBIZ aw i wish i could experience going to the movies for the first time again! what movie did you see?

[@jorellelouis1551]

Shane has been unfolding his relationship with his mother to us quite a while now. I'm so intrigued.

[@JC-es2qr]

when shane revealed his number five ryan was visibly holding himself back from very real violence

[@junikigai]

Ryan trashed Cars again yesterday on their Discord server meanwhile Shane kept deleting Ryan's messages lmao

[@JC-es2qr]

@@junikigai lmao that sounds like them

[@ctilivi]

@@junikigai do you know their discord server? Can we, fans, join?

[@siiri8902]

@@ctilivi I'm pretty sure the discord is only for Patreon supporters of a certain tier so us regular youtube viewers can't join unfortunately

[@ctilivi]

@@siiri8902 aww, bummer :( thanks for replying!

[@juliannak489]

shane looking sad because ryan doesn’t like cars is the most emotion i’ve ever seen

[@johanvajse8410]

Ryan being a dick and not letting Shane have his own opinion is the most dickhead thing I've ever seen.

[@ohmylorrd]

@@johanvajse8410 Its ok, they do this all the time, they're just joking with each other.

[@isa-belva]

@@johanvajse8410 they even went on a bizarre fake drama over twitter about this so rest assured, it's all just some fun jokes and banters

[@yumikogita]

@@johanvajse8410 how sensitive can you get?

[@johanvajse8410]

@@yumikogita I don't know, I've never really tried or thought about it. I'll get back to you with results.

[@nickz6964]

It’s truly a crime that Monsters Inc. was on none of their lists.

[@astrowolvez]

As someone who hates monsters inc that’s refreshing to hear. 😂

[@ooffordays566]

I'll say this: it's absolutely a classic Pixar film from when they were back in their prime, but I've always felt like it's somewhere in the top ten, not really the top five. It absolutely deserved an honorable mention, though.

[@uglybetty8747]

The bug’s life too !

[@Cole444Train]

A Bug’s Life is one of their weaker films imo

[@yungjoemighty879]

One of if not the best Pixar movie

[@lichsorcrerer]

the face journey ryan went on when shane had cars as his top five. legendary

[@W3lle]

It’s even funnier when Ryan has just said he didn’t like the incredibles

[@johanvajse8410]

sometimes Ryan just needs to take a breath and not speak

[@eshog8954]

I LOVE Cars

[@poggies7639]

Tbh cars isn’t really bad. Cars one is a good movie

[@51Dutchman]

@@poggies7639 I agree. If you pretend Cars 2 doesn’t exist, Cars and Cars 3 is a quite enjoyable double feature, in my opinion.

[@eekeey]

I love how Shane emotionally manipulates the audience and pisses off Ryan at the same time.

[@Whatlander]

Shane did a Pixar.

[@jeremiahg88]

Was thinking the exact same thing. Love how he manipulated him

[@cushab3604]

@@loucathwil86 me and shane share a birthday

[@parasocialyte]

Confirming what we've known along: Shane is a man of taste who recognizes Ratatouille for the masterpiece that it is.

[@roguechevelle]

omg yes!

[@cricket8469]

i've watched ratatouille so many times in quarantine more than i have in my life-

[@kimberlyhaines107]

It’s funny because if you go to Disneyland Paris, there is a whole area devoted to that film. My friend went there and they had hedge mazes for “Alice in Wonderland”, and beautiful stained glass windows...But I think she said it was kept as clean as ours are here in the US. But I’m not sure if there’s a ride AND a restaurant dedicated to the movie, but I know I’ve seen pictures with a HUGE sign for the film.

[@fatinnabihah453]

well he is sexy in a rat kinda way

[@alexisbrown7933]

Ha! I agree, but I tried watching it tonight with my 6 yr old daughter. It was surprisingly on Utube 4 free but she didn't want to watch it 😒we both had to agree on what we wanted to watch

[@jedimaster91]

I was pregnant when I saw Inside Out in theaters. There was ugly sobbing in the theater. Sad Brave wasn't on anyone's list. The mother/daughter journey to repair their relationship is done so well

[@oatmealtruck7811]

Brave is slept on and underrated!! Travesty.

[@varkrow]

I wasn't pregnant when I watched Inside Out, but I am a bit of a crybaby and a huge sucker for coming of age stories, so same. Also, yes. Brave was a nice little thing too, with it being one of the first Disney princess movies to not include any hint of romance in the end and mainly focused on the rare dynamic of a somewhat rigid mother and her rebellious daughter.

[@aff77141]

Cause the bear plot ruined it 😔

[@greysonholtz]

I really do love Brave; I'm a queer with a shitty mother so it really made me empathise with Merida. As the movie went on and explored Merida and her mother's relationship it sort of played out a fantasy in front of me wishing my life was like that, so it's always a comfort for me to rewatch (plus Merida not needing a male love interest always makes me feel like I'm valid in my lesbianism as opposed to so many disney films with the princess falling in love with a man and wed by the end.) Truly an underrated film that appeals to so many people.

[@minanathans6005]

Y'know, it's funny- the first time I saw Brave was a year after I lost my mom. I was... I think 13? Either 13 or had just turned 14. And I remember being so _angry_ at Merida. Just furious. I felt like she was such an ungrateful brat to her mother who tried so hard, and I couldn't watch the movie again for years afterwards. And then when I was about 21 and somewhat better adjusted, I rewatched it and found myself realizing- no. No, Merida wasn't a brat. Merida was a young teenager who loved her mother very much, and who's relationship with her was being affected by really daunting circumstances- (who wants to get married at that age?) and the feeling that she wasn't being taken seriously. She loved her mom, but she had a right to be upset. Both things were true. I'd been upset as a kid because it felt like watching a reflection of my own relationship with my mother, and being only able to focus on all the things I'd done wrong. All the ways I'd been a bad, undeserving daughter. All the things I'd never get to say sorry for. And then seeing it again as an adult made me realize that I hadn't been an unredeemable monster, I had been a 13 year old girl. The fact that I fought with my mother didn't mean I loved her any less, and she had _known_ that. Both things were true. Brave helped me move on. It's a special movie to me now.

[@user-qu5js9vw9o]

Unsolved: Ryan and Shane only respectfully disagree about ghosts Watcher: Ryan makes Shane cry over their choice of Pixar movies

[@jessicad5651]

have you watched unsolved? i wouldn’t call that respectfully disagreeing 😂

[@chatman4998]

@@jessicad5651 yea same😭😭

[@camili5072]

Shane saying “kachow” after every number to annoy Ryan is the petty energy I need

[@kayleerogers6043]

Camili Brignoni *i didn’t even notice*

[@kayleerogers6043]

Camili Brignoni wait this isn’t sarcasm I actually didn’t notice Shane you cunning rodent

[@starryeyedgirls_]

kachiga

[@mcwine18]

What is the kachow reference from? I didn’t even notice it at first but i don’t know where kachow is from

[@dannythomas1782]

@@mcwine18 The Kachow reference is from the first Cars movie.

[@dayzed2]

shane and ryan are just showing us that they’re telepathically linked

[@Sanmarachella]

Minus cars

[@dayzed2]

goldie except cars 😂 but Ryan still instinctively knew he was gonna choose something like that

[@HughieKing]

Tow Mater gets so much disrespect for how good of a character he is. Although I'm not a massive fan for Cars, Tow Mater was an icon of my childhood and I'm fully behind Shane for that no 5 pick

[@shannonmarbut3648]

Next time on Buzzfeed unsolved: The Mysterious Disappearance of Shane Madej.

[@christianmayonove6914]

See also: Next time on Buzzfeed unsolved: The Questionable Auto Accident of Ryan Bergara. Theories: Tow Mater ran over Ryan.

[@vict4451]

That's gonna be a baller season.

[@chlo3mak]

shane is definitely still holding a tiny grudge against his mum for not taking him to see toy story..

[@toddgeorge7421]

And for good reason! My mom took me with a bunch of my cousins and it was one of my favourite cinematic experiences of all time

[@shanemadej]

My mom rules. In fact, I think after the egregious error of not taking us to Toy Story she made a point to take us to every Pixar film that followed, so she very much made up for it.

[@faythedemon2372]

I wouldn't call it tiny

[@solidandsoiled]

Could this be why Shane became obsessed with putting up a puppet show? Toys....puppets....kinda close

[@mackenziestade388]

I can’t believe all three of them slept on Monster’s Inc. That movie is so good and expresses emotions about just loving and supporting each other through difficult situations. When Sully wants to help return Boo, Mike is right there with him which just shows this friendship that is pure and amazingly entertaining. Smh it’s definitely my no. 1 pixar movie.

[@aloenuht.1740]

This is what I'm thinking about! Monster's Inc is definitely on my list

[@TheDancerMacabre]

My issue with Monster's Inc is that the 11th hour villain trope is used way too much (Up, Toy Story 2 and 3, Coco to a certain degree (but it was heavily hinted at throughout the movie.) I think its a really good movie that just falls flat on the third act. Personally, I think a Bug's Life would edge it out of my top 5.

[@megangrace6597]

As soon as I started the video I thought, "immediate top 3: Monsters Inc., Up, Toy Story. But I'd have to think about the other two if I were doing a top 5."

[@PtylerBeats]

Yeah, I agree. Toy Story, Up, Finding Nemo, Monsters Inc, and A Bug’s Life. My top 5 easily, but that doesn’t mean that those are the only amazing Pixar films. That’s just because there are way too many great films to only have 5 lol

[@seahunz]

monsters inc was my number 1 too, that movie is one of my favourites of all time let alone my favourite pixar movie

[@cammccutcheon2452]

the amount of respect I have gained for Shane with him putting cars in his top 5, that movie is a goddamn masterpiece

[@ThePositive0ne1]

I completely agree.

[@beckhall6479]

I think people dislike it more for the flack it’s gotten on social media. Watching it without expectation and it’s the best!

[@trentturek6019]

“I felt no emotion watching that movie” was an insane take. I have gotten close to tears as a grown man watching cars

[@ft.jackjimmy7282]

@@trentturek6019 the movie didn't make me cry therefore it's bad take is the worst take to view a movie. Up definitely made people cry at the very beginning but does anyone remember anything afterwards? Cars is a masterpiece, practically the car version of Kuzco: Emperor's New Groove ngl

[@meggnoggs]

Ryan’s reaction to Cars is why the professor rigs puppet history

[@satinsleeves]

You've cracked the code!

[@animetruck833]

I like cars

[@leonkennedymunchrizzler]

*I’m just expecting for an episode where Ryan keeps on triggering the professor causing the professor to commit domestic violence*

[@obp23]

Wtf you talking about? the professor is a stand up guy or puppet and every contestant has won fair and square haha

[@SD-ik3bl]

shane's pick of cars is why ryan killed the professor

[@hannahjoy333.]

“Don’t you high road me” Shane being a master manipulator for 21 minutes straight

[@ives6622]

Monsters Inc is not even here??

[@RubyRedRiots]

i'm genuinely shocked it wasn't on ANYONE'S list. like cars? really?

[@yofuman]

There's just so many good films

[@eringoodwin3079]

Yes!! One of my all time favs for sure✌🏼

[@hanktheclank]

It always seems to get glazed over for some reason which is confusing as heck because I’d say it’s like nearly perfect in every conceivable way and it’s so unique! The visual style, the music, everything about it is special. Sigh.

[@EyeGlassTrainofMind]

THANK YOU! I was just thinking this. The feel and the storyline of this movie combined with the worldbuilding is on par if not superior to Toy Story.

[@PtylerBeats]

My favorite part is everyone’s appreciation for the scores while even discussing the composers by name! Not enough people recognize great scores, and they actually find it weird that I borderline obsess over the score of a movie. I mean... the way that the music sounds underwater in Finding Nemo/Dory is such a creative way to make music. Using regular instruments and music theory techniques, the music very clearly resonates with the audience as being underwater. And it’s not exactly something you can always explain, but even outside of the context of the film, the music feels as big and deep as the ocean. You are almost literally drowning in the vast openness of the arrangements. With watching the film, most people would describe it as feeling like they’re in the ocean. And Pixar does that with all of their films. Not just Finding Nemo. The score for nearly every film is incredible.

[@claireewebber1429]

The disrespect to monsters inc. sickening

[@hannahleigh9460]

monsters inc was actually disney not pixar! i know this bc i was also very angry no one picked monsters inc and i googled it

[@danishstrikes]

Hannahleigh It’s produced by Pixar, and distributed by Disney. So it is a Pixar film

[@sebastiano728]

@@hannahleigh9460 It's as Disney as any of the subsequent Pixar films.

[@soybean3205]

I cried...for real, I'm picky when it comes to movies but monster inc is the only movie I can watch more than once and actually pay attention to the plot. 😭😭💖

[@tessarabbit7160]

Argument: Antoine Ego isnt a villain. Hes someone who has lost the joy of his work, which the movie puts hard emphasis on. Enjoyment of the job is what Remy adores and thats what Ego forgot

[@angrysaltycroutan3262]

Thank you so much for saying this. The part where he tries the ratatouille and it takes him back to his childhood is so beautiful.

[@antoescobedo7177]

i agree, i think he is an antagonist but not a villain

[@vivekagupta]

Yes! And rewatching the movie now, as someone who chose a passion as a career and forgot about the passion along the way, it just made his character so much more relatable to me.

[@ollieofftheboat]

I honestly don't know why they cited him as the villain when the sous-chef of the restaurant was a much more clear villain in my eyes

[@antoescobedo7177]

Ollieontheoffbeat CLEARLY

[@MrAquarius]

Can we get Hoai-Tran back for more lists? She's just well-spoken, intelligent, and has a great speaking voice.

[@TheGuac25]

Hell yeah

[@YoshiMochi13]

Totally agree!

[@JC3_420]

But what do you thinking about her speaking ability?

[@G17x]

💯💯💯💯

[@AlelieHall]

Rate the Fast and Furious movies lol

[@sydneyperry4235]

WHEN RILEY CRIES IN INSIDE OUT I SOBBED. It can be so hard and difficult to admit to your parents that you’re not okay with something that happens (mainly in an out of control situation) in terms of sadness. It’s so important to tell children to tell their parents if something is wrong especially depression or sadness. She even says I know you want me to be happy but I’m not okay and this is really hard. In my family emotion was not something expressed often especially tears. So seeing that movie at 18 I was so moved and wished I would’ve let me parents in a little more on things I was struggling with. You can feel so embarrassed and feel that your emotions aren’t valid when you’re young because adults are always saying life when youre a kid is easy. And for so many out there for different reasons it can be so hard. Inside out was the first Pixar movie that I immediately was like I cannot wait to have kids and have them watch this.

[@everybodyhaveagoodtime6963]

Shane: "My number one pick is... CARS 2" Ryan: *explodes*

[@sebastianmadrigal4014]

Hahaha it would be more than an explode

[@perrytheplatypus2001]

hot take: I didn't hate Cars 2. Is it a good movie? Hell no! but it was a fun movie, not re-watchable tho

[@MyAza21]

ja ja ja

[@CoLoJePa]

I saw your comment while scrolling mid vid and thought it was serious. I was so disappointed. it's definitely something Shane would have done.

[@cylindersarecool984]

cars 2 sucks ass

[@myopinionson4892]

Ryan is not allowed to be mad about Cars in the Top 5 while saying that Incredibles 2 is better than Incredibles. Coldest take

[@roguechevelle]

ikr? I like Incredibles 2 and I think it's very close but I still think the first is the best one. I'm more upset with him calling it boring honestly.

[@CrescentCitySweaters]

I want Incredibles but with the slapping theme songs of the heroes in Incredibles 2

[@casey-capri2914]

Amen 🙏

[@aishah7730]

no he’s right actually

[@ephin3242]

I don’t think you know what a cold take is

[@rowanlastname9878]

Listen, as a fellow Midwesterner, I understand Shane's defense of Mater, every Midwesterner has a relative *EXACTLY* like him. He hits a very familiar spot for us lol.

[@skylarkirby4943]

i hadn't considered that before but it's so true

[@Nightwalker-zk6ce]

Oh my god you’re right

[@llammb]

Don’t got a relative like him but I for everyone I know, 1/10 is like him

[@animetruck833]

Same here, I love the movie

[@cctinsley67]

I'm the mater

[@keuniichiwa]

I can get behind Shane's opinions on Cars. Idk why, i just like watching over and over again. Plus, the music and the atmosphere of the movie reminds me of home, so i guess that adds to why i love it, regardless of the slander. (I do understand why some hate it tho, the reasons are very valid)

[@kittykitties4220]

It's such a fun show! And the relationship between Lightning and Doc was fantastic.

[@岡山大木]

I can't believe Monsters Inc was unanimously snubbed. So disappointing.

[@ethanterry7021]

exactly...gtfo with Wall-E over one of the most imaginative movies ever

[@porby2032]

@@ethanterry7021 I love monsters inc, but lets not insult Wall-E

[@swtxveee]

Monsters Inc is the best.

[@bellybutton3806]

@@ethanterry7021 Yeah, I always appreciated Wall-E, but nothing in it really resonated with me the way Monsters did. Its take on the future is done times a dozen, and most of its charm comes from the scenes of Wall-e and his dame interacting, that's it. Monsters has a broader spectrum. The scene where Sulley unintentionally terrifies Boo still gets me as an adult.

[@abidsyed6160]

Monsters Inc is a top 3 Pixar film

[@raybarnes5690]

I genuinely don’t see how people don’t like cars. It gives us an unsympathetic main character. Something very bold and nearly unheard of. It gives us him actually getting punished for his actions. It gives us characters who give their all to a town that’s going under. The soundtrack is phenomenal and like in all Pixar movies it gives us a ending that isn’t what the main character thought they wanted but see it’s what they need. Lighting doesn’t win the big race. He doesn’t get the big sponsor ship. Instead he helps the other guy finish. So he wouldn’t end up like a new friend of his. And he goes back to radiator springs and brings it back to life. He gets friends and fulfillment. Honestly I’ve never encountered someone who doesn’t like cars.

[@goro123451]

It is a pretty good film, but just FYI Shane was trolling Ryan about Cars being his number 5

[@momogi618]

well i like it too and when im read online that so many hate cars like its the norm im just shock. but maybe they just didnt like the design or it throw people off. for me i love it. i rewatch it too many times like adam sandler movie when im a kid xD

[@oxxenchillero]

Cars 2 was shit, cars 3 was a little better, cars was the best

[@jorellelouis1551]

You haven't encountered me.

[@socaltypes7670]

Your not alone. I loved the cars series but that was mainly because racing was a mainstaple. And omg... The sound track for that film really hit me. To this day I have all of them but I come back to watch cars again and again and again. It was my first pixar movie that really hit me in the feels. Then all the other ones came later but now I need to rewatch all of them again

[@livelife9680]

Listen, Coco’s bad guy reveal legitimately got me, this man straight up murdered

[@r0tt1on-s0cks8]

He got murked

[@AllTheArtsy]

I felt like it was a needless gotcha

[@kittykitties4220]

I saw it coming from a mile away, which is why I really didn't care for the movie. Found it to be pretty predictable.

[@oogabooga5510]

@@kittykitties4220 it was predictable, but for me it didn’t sway away from my enjoyment of the movie. also because i relate to the movie a lot, i think it holds a special place in my heart :) i would honestly prefer a predictable scene rather than a sudden one that doesn’t quite make sense, but that’s just me :p

[@Skrimbi]

STOP ITS NOT PREDICTABLE AND I AM SMART

[@whimsandworries]

Here's my little take on Inside Out. The part that made me cry was watching the islands break down inside of Riley as she progressed through the film. I suffer from a lot of anxiety and depression and have had periods of time where I was a shell of the lively, firey, creative person I am with just a shell left behind. Seeing those core parts of her get torn down hurt me a lot and watching them spring back up at the end made me so warm 😃

[@Emily.-.]

I couldn’t agree more

[@britt8099]

Oh my gosh yes I remember crying hard watching that bc it represents that so well and now knowing I had anxiety and depression growing up and still do

[@jillstephenson]

The fact that Monsters Inc isn't on ANY of their lists is LUDICROUS

[@ang3lica2k]

Jill Stephenson true

[@juliasofie4911]

Agree

[@socalgoth]

my exact thoughts

[@miadavies6795]

YES

[@kimberlywilson7929]

I thought about that. It should have replaced Cars.

[@maevetaylorreilly]

Okay - the villain In UP - I think the message of it was that your childhood heroes can let you down and aren’t all they appear to be.

[@greatvalue_ethelcain]

Maeve Reilly That was also in Coco, and was delivered better

[@kklondikke9019]

I think that was a really good message and is especially relevant today, maybe just wasn’t as appreciated at the time? Especially w all the other themes in the movie

[@valvelocity6525]

I agree but I feel like it wasn't really relevant to the main theme of UP and was more of a "remember this guy? L-look he's back? Isn't that cool?" Where as in Coco it was actively a part of the main storyline

[@alalalala57]

@@valvelocity6525 Lol the old guy and his wife literally built their life of adventure around the secret villain.

[@Whatlander]

Yeah, it was a valid message, but I think Up's downfall was trying to do too many things at once. Grief, regret, aging, being hurt by your heroes, whatever was happening with Russel's dad, some weird bird stuff - it sort of spiraled out of focus the longer it went on.

[@patricia.sews.sometimes]

I think Ratatouille doesn't get enough credit. I love how fleshed out the characters are, like how Remy is supposed to be the good guy, the protagonist, but is also very pretentious while also dealing with leaving his family to pursue his dream. I like how he needs Linguini to achieve his dream, and in turn Linguini achieves success and skill, bit only because of Remy. Also, I really love the visuals and the aesthetic of it. It's very classy and French. Ego is also an interesting character because he isn't pure evil like some other Pixar villains. Ratatouille is definitely my #1 Pixar film.

[@razb8888]

that's funny since i think it's a pretty overrated movie for those reasons lol

[@destinyelle7120]

@@razb8888 it’s overrated? Nobody ever talks about it

[@celeste257]

I also love it because it’s one of the most accurate films about food because of the extent of research the team did on real professional kitchens. They even depict the tiniest details about a chef and the kitchens, it’s amazing. A bunch of celebs and chefs like Anthony Bourdain and Gordon Ramsey love it because of that.

[@rezhaadriantanuharja3389]

If there is one movie I can rewatch as happily as the first time I saw it, it gotta be Ratatouille

[@elenalatsis5131]

same

[@JessiPotter]

The fact that Ryan was making fun of Shane for his number five pick and then their list matches 3/5 is so funny

[@ashleyelliott-rowe1260]

Shane saying “I want to be small” when talking about Ratatouille made me audibly awwww

[@hope5801]

See, my immediate response was, out loud, to my self. “Hehe, little rat boy.”

[@okay9340]

two kinds of people, and both are very valid

[@jennacided6502]

honestly who doesnt want to be a rodent for a day

[@momogi618]

maybe because he tall, i sometimes can relate to with wanna be small and have small problem.

[@lilleilei169]

like him talking about eating a big popcorn? ADORABLE!!

[@ginganinja1548]

Monster's INC #1 for me. The end where they put the last piece of the door back together and Sully walks through and all you hear is "kitty!" In my mind, it took them years to put that door back together and that Boo is not a little girl no more but a teen and that was the time she first saw her big furry friend in a long time and probably teared up and gave him the biggest hug. That's what I imagined that happened. 😭

[@finaathehuman]

thank you!

[@aleeshahsohail8012]

bro every single time i watch that movie this scene makes me cry 💀😭🤚🏻

[@lovepotion39]

jesus christ i started crying just from reading this comment

[@dre5540]

I remember vividly that this was the first movie that made me cry, I was 4 and didn’t even understand what was going on with me because I felt happy but I was crying 😭

[@Countrydiva524]

Cars is underrated, Lightning has a humbling experience and has to learn what it's like to live without and go back to basics. It's about learning how the world is much bigger then yourself and your dreams, follow up with commitments, respect your elders ect.

[@rosamoon8182]

Agreed Justice for cars!😤

[@mcat2315]

100% agreed

[@juliesong3149]

Totally agree

[@sofia-dx5of]

nope. no no no

[@juliesong3149]

It is underated, agree. But it belongs in top 10, rather than top 5

[@tehreeem]

this show is literally just shane and ryan bickering over their disagreements and the third person being awkward

[@supernoodle704]

and it’s great, it’s like an awkward family reunion

[@eastonborso4377]

Total snub of monster inc. That’s a crying movie.

[@ariaaani]

PLEASEEEE i was waiting for monsters inc for so long 😭

[@TurquoiseTurtle22]

Easton Borso absolutely i cant believe they didn’t talk about it

[@dominiqueroseeee]

YES

[@Reggie_la]

I would like to point out two things about ratatouille: 1. The journey of Remy was finding acceptance in his family, but even more than that. He had a place in his family that he didn't like, he got separated from his family, they thought he was dead, and he was living his best life. But his family had his back and he had to accept that he was still part of the colony and he had to go back to them. The journey was about Remy balancing two important aspects of his life. He didn't get a girlfriend nor a love interest. He didn't go back to the colony because he had a romantic love. He didn't go back because his passion failed. He didn't go back because his father was dying and needed him. But he still HAD to go back. Loved that. Very personal motivations, and not external ones. 2. Anton Ego did a great explanation at the end. "Not anyone can be a great chef, but a great chef can come from any place". They had to say this in the movie so we could erase the original meaning. Not everyone can be good at everything, but the place where you start does not determine what you want to do. I want to bring that over to Linguinni: he didn't want to be a chef. After Gustau's closed and La Ratatouille was opened, he was a server. We can assume he had some legal ownership if the new restaurant, but he sticked to what he was good at and what he was comfortable doing. At the peak of the movie, at Gustau's, we saw him getting into the role of server instantly. He got on skates and served the fuck out of the tables. Linguinni's serving was Remy's cooking. That's a powerful message right there.

[@_GunpowdertheGabite]

Then there's me: I'm a rat mom, I love rats so Ratatouille is a great movie. I watch it religiously twice a year.

[@HufflepuffsPanda]

This comment deserves a BIG OLE chef’s kiss 👏👏👏👏👏

[@hannahmason5041]

Cannot believe that Monsters Inc. isn’t on anyone’s list

[@saracarr3382]

Hoai-Tran’s list is sooo good!! 👌🏼👌🏼 I probably would’ve put The Incredibles higher but it’s hard to take nostalgia out of it for me because I watched it a lot when I was a kid.

[@rajatchhajta7397]

Exactly, incredibles is rewatchable funny, in the feels and with a great villain too. Could be rated higher.

[@oliviagrutzius9624]

Monsters Inc wasn't on any of their lists and that is a crime.

[@sierramcpherson3841]

Olivia Grutzius I came to the comments to say this.

[@KandiiLoverr]

RIGHT!

[@han-ht3dd]

THANK YOU i was searching for this comment

[@smileywatts8691]

That would have been my number one pick!

[@zvrrr7]

I don't know about y'all, but Meet the robinsons is one of the most underrated animated movie of all time, plus that ending with "Little Wonders" playing in the back tho

[@aimena1931]

True but it's Disney not Pixar so it arguably could never have made this list.

[@chloecola71102]

i 100% agree with this comment. It’s one of the most underrated movies ever

[@mac4951]

For real!

[@wasabisushi404]

Hell yes!!!! Best disney cg film imo. Always gets me at the end

[@DeaDoubleU]

Yeah...I don't think it's Pixar. Great movie though.

[@ZanraiKid]

Shane: My number 5 is Cars. **several people are typing**

[@firmanchristiansianturi4794]

Cars is in my personal favourite so he's not alone

[@carsfan1995]

Firman Christian Sianturi I love all the Cars movies!

[@casualviewer9792]

I dont get it coz cars was great!

[@eleanorgouldie9355]

Yeah as a kid I enjoyed cars but now it’s just a background film when I’m doing something else

[@lizhowell5993]

I liked Shane’s list the best!

[@RanndiMarie01]

I actually started tearing up when you guys just mentioned how Finding Nemo starts. 😂😭 I just want to add, The Toy Story movies work so well with our generation, because they are released during moments in our lives than match Andy. They purposefully released them because they knew so many of us would be able to relate to Andy’s point in his life. That last scene of Toy Story 3 really was the perfect sadness as most of us had also stopped playing with toys, or were going off to college.

[@mal992]

YALL SHOULD DO STUDIO GHIBLI

[@eekeey]

If Spirited Away isn't #1 on any of their lists, I will riot.

[@marley3076]

internallogic that movie is so superior like I’d be lying if that didn’t shape my childhood

[@SaschaCz]

Spirited Away is defs top 5 but for me, Howl’s Moving Castle is #1. I feel if they do a Studio Ghibli list they would have to make it Miyazaki specific, because there’s also amazing films like Grave of the Fireflies that are Ghibli, but not Miyazaki, and still deserve credit.

[@Emmanuella1383]

I second that, they definitely should do Ghibli/Miyazaki movies, i hope they see your comment ~

[@amandarakestraw2915]

I love HT's take on Inside Out, it is the same take I have on it, I have a degree in psychology and plan to become a counselor, I think it is important how Inside Out represents emotions and their complexities for children. It is my number 1 pixar movie.

[@rememberozma]

Seriously! I am a counselor, and when that movie came out my job got way easier for like one year. It did not take long before they had all forgotten about it, though.

[@elizabethjane0327]

The visualization of emotions and 'core memories' really helps with parts work and trauma therapy. My therapist brings it up frequently and we would watch clips in our DBT group sometimes. It's a great film

[@M0IVD0]

Happiness ruining everything practically on purpose was frustrating. Good not top 5 tho

[@amandarakestraw2915]

@@M0IVD0 maybe obvious but it was to show that just being happy all the time is destructive and isnt healthy, we have to feel and acknowledge our other emotions to be healthy

[@M0IVD0]

Amanda Rakestraw it could mean that, the execution tho not that great in that aspect of happiness character was not really represented good enough imo

[@kimberlywilson7929]

This is the best show on Watcher hands down. The experts always prove why they belong in that chair (I've actually started steaming my buns), Shane is consistently sacrilegious in the best way, Ryan is so earnest, and (I cannot overstate this point) Ryan and Shane's chemistry is one of the best on KZbin. This episode was great.

[@violetskies14]

For me: 5. Wall-E just a lovely sweet film. It came out when I was 8 and I loved it. 4. Finding Nemo this mostly here because of Dory being one of the first films I ever saw with a character that was disabled in some way 3. Monsters Inc I watched it so many times growing up it's tied to wonderful memories of my uncle looking after me 2. Inside out I have chronic pain and it came out when I was 15 and struggling a lot with depression and coping and this idea of happiness and sadness not being mutually exclusive really helped me. 1. Brave I know that one won't be on most people's list but that idea of your families expectations vs your wants really resonated with me when I was figuring out I was a lesbian. I felt my illness and disability was already letting my family down and didn't want to add another disappointed to my list (no one in my family would ever really think or say that it was my own issues) but the way they learned to see and love eachother for who they are made me think about how loved I really was too.

[@WhatsInTheCookieJar]

Brave is in my top 5 too! I just love that movie. It's beautiful to look at, I love the story. It also has an amazing soundtrack that I listen to often.

[@k80_]

I wouldn’t put brave in my top 5 b/c as a whole i didn’t think it was very good. but like you I do love its themes which personally resonate for the reasons you said! For me though the real kicker is the complicated mother-daughter relationship. And I like that the protagonist is also the closest thing the movie has to a villain and her arc sort of revolves around realizing that her mom is not the villain but just the person she’s closest to

[@jujulachlan11]

also technically Nemo himself is disabled ahaha

[@andjela3527]

Brave is my top 1 too. It's the movie I watched the most and cried the most

[@giacintacarissa7681]

Shane: reveals his top 5 as Cars Ryan and Hoai: *sighs collectively*

[@thewillofabeast9079]

Tbh, when HT said “If you take Pixar out of the equation, it’s a fine film.” Does she think that Pixar only does serious and/or emotional movies? Cars is just a movie for fun and they seem to ignore that.

[@xenophiliuslovegood6914]

Ryan: The Incredibles isn't that good. Shane: 😮 Ryan: It's a hot take! Shane: 🚘 Ryan: 😐 Shane: 🚘🚘🥳 Ryan: 😡 Shane: 🚘😍🤠😍 Ryan: 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

[@sophiemcgrill304]

I love HT's analysis on Inside Out and her comparison to children experiencing trauma or people going through depression. The irony of that is that the first time I saw Inside Out in theaters I saw it with my two biggest abusers

[@ellamaymcc5173]

I hope you are safe now.

[@theprofessor4759]

shane putting cars in his top 5 list might be the reason why he is how he is.

[@BMiren-bc6ye]

This is why we dont deserve nice things, it's Shane liking Cars

[@kyndramb7050]

I agree with Ryan... it was a troll.

[@kyndramb7050]

And thats why I love Shane. I value the hilarious asshole.

[@xenophiliuslovegood6914]

Kachow!

[@johannahagstrom2588]

fuck it cars is a great fucking movie i love it to death

[@daniyahumayera07]

What if they do one about the top haunted locations 😳😳

[@abbyvachirawit2508]

YESSSS GET THIS TO TOP COMMENT

[@gretamari312]

YES YES YES YES

[@tayet2360]

Yes please!!!

[@raine5548]

shane’s list will be empty lmao

[@alyssamarzorati4053]

Father Gary Thomas guest stars

[@amandalee1639]

I swear Top 5 Beatdown has the most chaotic energy from the jokes to the filming location

[@bayleecorona7625]

I LOVE Hoai Tran’s list. It’s near perfect. I can’t disagree with any of the entries on her list!

[@razkable]

coco?..she underrated that film

[@tellthealien5801]

wow wasn’t expecting to get all fired up in the first five minutes over how Ryan thinks incredibles 2 is better than the incredibles

[@chatman4998]

I mean i see y he would say that

[@aikaterineillt9876]

I nearly choked on my own throat.

[@fruitbythefoote]

Incredibles 2’s villain was straight up embarrassing. First of all, if you’re going to give your villain a pun name, don’t have them be a twist villain. Second, blaming superheroes for her parents’ death was so freaking lame. She doesn’t hold a candle to Syndrome.

[@pawsieee_]

SHANE HAS THE TASTE FOR INCLUDING CARS IN THE LIST. DON'T TELL ME OTHERWISE. CARS IS MY CHILDHOOD AND MATER IS MY BEST FRIEND.

[@hawkes1859]

Idk about mater but the nostalgia that Cars induces (specifically the music!) is quite something. I really appreciate that movie and I'm glad it was included

[@tillyseymour8722]

I am 17 yrs old and currently have a cars duvet on my bed which I got when I was abt 3, tis an iconic movie and I am not ashamed to like it

[@fruitbythefoote]

I feel like the movie is kind of manipulative at parts though. The whole thing about the town becoming forgotten because of the interstate and the “drove to have a great time” line kind of comes off as boomers blaming everything on millennials unfairly. It was just a natural evolution of road travel; just because I don’t really care about the small places with gas along the way doesn’t mean I don’t travel “correctly”.

[@brigade7678]

​@@fruitbythefoote bruh if you've seen the 3rd film it is SO incredibly boomer yelling at millennials its PAINFUL. People always talk about how terrible cars 2 is (which is fair its fucking buck wild) but having seen all 3 many times with my lil nieces & nephews......... 3 is by far the LEAST tolerable to me, the vibes are disgusting start to finish. There's a message about like accepting that time moves on and we all have our day in the spotlight, too, But overall... too much "our generation did it RIGHT without all your dumb tech!" so I guess that message really was with the series start to finish lol.

[@judeconnor-macintyre9874]

Cars 2 is better. I'm not making a joke.

[@theprofessor4759]

shane madej: loves the idea of emotion i think that sums him up pretty well actually

[@mikaylaval]

UP really told the worlds purest love story in a perfect silent and short sequence. If that doesn’t say something, idk what will

[@charlottealexander6822]

EXCUSE ME- how could they forget about monsters inc 🥺

[@camili5072]

Charlotte Alexander THANK YOU OMG MONSTERS INC WAS MY THINNGGGGG

[@rosamoon8182]

Yes exactly!!!

[@jillstephenson]

MONSTERS INC IS MY #1

[@AgentMulder120]

SAME THOUGHT. THAT MOVIE IS IMMACULATE.

[@steinaf]

Monsters Inc has a special place in our Disney kid hearts but I think they choose the movies based on how great the films are and mix it with their own favourites.

[@nicktokar2459]

The fact that nobody even mentioned Monsters Inc is absolutely mind boggling to me. I demand an explanation for this.

[@safamushtaq1887]

Exactly!

[@noshpah575]

ok but can we appreciate HT's reasoning and their critique of the films they choose? they were so well spoken and their analysis was rlly good 💖💖💖

[@thewillofabeast9079]

In all honesty, I wasn’t a fan when she said “if you take Pixar out of the equation, it’s a fine film.” Does she think that Pixar can only make serious movies (The Incredibles) and emotional movies? (Finding Nemo) Cars is a film that has meaning and a good message in that being popular and financially successful isn’t always the key to happiness. McQueen was a rookie and soaked up the attention he was getting but his cocky personality is what kept him from not making friends. Him winding up in Radiator Springs and getting to know the towns folk is what changed him. Ryan is just over here bashing the film thinking that it has no purpose.

[@valness3017]

I'm so glad Ryan included UP. That film hits me in the feels without fail.

[@madisonowens2728]

Absolutely insane Monsters Inc. isn’t on anyone’s list. Like you’re actually wrong, sry.

[@marafuentes3904]

Scary feet, scary feet, scary feet 😔

[@mrkaye4266]

Plot twist: Shane was 100% serious that cars was #5 because he did like it and didnt need it to be a tear jerker, but Ryan so earnestly thought Shane was trolling that Shane just went with it.

[@elfish4767]

dang ryan gets ELOQUENT when he's mad. feel like i could see Ricky Goldberg trying to escape for a hot minute there when Shane revealed CARS tho

[@lolawhiterabbit]

For me Coco is number one bc I feel like I related to that one the most, I watched it w/ my dad who is in his mid 60’s and we both cried. My grandma (my dad’s mom) had died a few years back and she didn’t remember a lot but she recognized him for a brief moment few days before she passed, so he especially was in tears. This film means so much, not just bc of my Grandma but other topics as well that I would have to write an essay 😂 but I won’t

[@mal992]

SHANE AND RYAN BOTH HAVING WALL-E AT 3 MAKES ME SO HAPPY.

[@LopsidedFrogs]

EXACTLY WALL-E IS SO UNDERRATED

[@royalfizzbin2131]

The fact that Monster's Inc. didn't make anyone's list is a crying shame

[@HopeElizabeth]

i would have genuinely rioted if coco wasn’t on anyone’s lists, i feel like it’s such an underrated movie. definitely one of my favorite movies of all time.

[@nickiskandar4856]

Too similar to "the book of life"

[@klaudiagiezecka6861]

The number one on my list, definitely. Such visually pleasing movie and the music... Well, let's be real, everything is great about Coco

[@bellecwy]

Nick Iskandar they are just about the same festival lol

[@poggies7639]

I love it but it isn’t really underrated, it’s universally loved and acclaimed by the vast majority of people who have seen it

[@thewillofabeast9079]

I will say it’s a great film but I wasn’t a fan of Elena and the rest of the family.

[@shanaperzynski286]

Can we just take a second to appreciate how great of a job Patton Oswalt did as Remy in Ratatouille? He really made that animated rat even more memorable.

[@spookymia8135]

My husband spent most of his time in the movie expecting Bing Bong to betray Joy and Sadness, and so when the big tear-jerker moment happened, it was extra upsetting because he felt like he'd not been fair to him.

[@rituallobotomy3294]

Shane: "This is my frown" :C Me: *wheeze* And speaking of Pixar movies, Inside Out and WALL-E are definitely up there for me but how no one remembered Monster Inc. That was definitely the one that did it for me.

[@Ausjuuhbal]

Shane’s so tall look at how he has to cross his legs to sit on that chair 😂

[@UnknxwnExe]

TRUEEE😂😂😂

[@brendanfoehr5086]

His foot is bigger than Ryan's head

[@T_1.5]

Brendan Foehr well for most people your foot size correlates with your head size

[@froggygal_]

@@T_1.5 yeah, sure. "Head" size.

[@eekeey]

@@T_1.5 what's his shoe size? I need it for reasons. 😂😂

[@galileogalilli3123]

i actually really love the cars movie, it’s extremely nostalgic for me

[@poolsidejoe]

THIS IS WHY I'M A SHANIAC, RATATOUILLE IS THE GREATEST ANIMATED FILM EVER, AND I TOO WOULD LOVE TO BE SMALL AND SLEEP IN THAT WINDOWSILL WITH GRAPES AND CHEESE.

[@numbo655]

THANK YOU

[@thewillofabeast9079]

And he put Cars on his list. A movie that is my personal favorite

[@truthisobjective7628]

I just now realized Shane would make a perfect live-action Woody! Long limbs, big head, and the perfect voice for "There's a snake in my boot!"

[@subhamgoswami269]

Ryan: I find the first incredibles quite boring *you have initiated gang war*

[@gota7738]

I will fight for Ryan.

[@goodsoop420]

That to me is more controversial than Shane putting Cars in his top 5.

[@kimberlyhaines107]

I agree. I hate the movie. And “Finding Nemo”. And I’ve never seen any of the “Toy Story” films after the 2nd one. I realize I just don’t like Pixar films all that much for some reason, and I don’t know why.

[@niyaak28]

Brad Bird is a legend.

[@tehreeem]

if y’all do another movie-based top 5 beat down PLEASE have her back on it !!! love listening to her speak !!!

[@kimvargas841]

Not even 6 minutes in and Shane's sad face just hurt me. Fake or not he looks so broken. Also I get the hate on Cars but that was my brother favorite film, we watched it so much. I had to SING that song to him so much so he'd calm down. So it has found memories for me.

[@haleywagner2827]

Bethany Leon I agree! It’s wouldn’t be in my top picks but I have sentiment for it because my dad is a huge NASCAR fan and it’s one of the few kid movies that he genuinely loves.😊

[@FioreCiliegia]

All I can say is Jessie’s abandonment scene makes me cry even without the context of the film

[@stevejenks9940]

Plus the song?! Wooooo

[@oneshortlady]

jessie and mittens from bolt were the only disney/pixar characters that made me cry

[@brigade7678]

@@oneshortlady oh god mittens ;-; Those both hit me so damn hard

[@backupnameplease]

I really liked Hoai-Tran's comments, you can tell she's a really great movie critic. She's made me want to re-watch all the movies on her list 👍

[@razkable]

if she just did not put inside out on her list and put on coco i could respect her 100%...if coco did not make you cry then you are a heartless sob ..period....her other 4 films are great choices..and it would be unfair to put sequels to toy story on the list cause they are just building off the first one and not new films on their own but they are up there as well...i genuinely loved her other 4 choices...

[@fm3227]

My favorite part about Shane making Ryan mad and emotionally manipulating him is when Shane starts being nice to him and making him feel guilty and it's like even though Ryan knows it's a bit it works 😂😂😂😂😂 they act like an old married couple 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@honeypot6719]

Look. Don't get me wrong. Great lists... BUT WHY TF ARE YOU GUYS NOT GIVING MOSTER INC THE CREDIT IT DISSEVERS

[@mattsaracen7]

Exactly!!! That's probably my number 1

[@mykarmapolice]

Alexia J I agree

[@chaiantoinnette1667]

YES!!!!

[@cararankin8729]

THATS WHAT I SAID

[@molly-cw9tj]

put that list back where it came from or so help me

[@NonaNona_39]

My top 5 Pixar films: 5: Monster’s Inc 4: Toy Story 2 3: Finding Nemo 2: Wall-E 1: Up Yes I know, some believe that Up is overrated and only the first 10 min are worth it. But I love how ambitious it is in having a human senior citizen as a main character in a kids film (as supposed to an anthropomorphized object or animal). I love the story and Carl’s progression in accepting Ellie’s death (and celebrating her life life by the end) which is mimicked in the audience’s emotion throughout the film. We cry at Ellie’s death at the beginning but by the end are happy when Carl sees Ellie wrote in the adventure book. Love the film. Truly.

[@alinatedwards]

this is such a valid list and great analysis! i feel like ratatouille deserves at least one spot though haha

[@orla6795]

I completely agree, up is my favourite childhood film and has a special place in my heart

[@TheWeeklyFangirl]

Shane's lived his entire life as Linguine and he just wants to be Remy so bad 🐀🐀🐀 #mood

[@hannah-nj3pq]

i unironically enjoy cars... maybe ive been brainwashed because of how much my little brother has watched it but i think doc's backstory and character arc were touching, and the subplot of radiator springs and towns like it with rich history being forgotten because of the interstate is underrated!

[@karimecubillas]

i feel personally offended that monsters inc wasn't in any of their lists

[@theprofessor4759]

shane’s legs are so long he has to cross his legs

[@Scorpia161]

I understand why he wants to be small

[@jadazfoster]

Monsters Inc didn't get the respect it deserves. I cry every time

[@claireg2286]

SO GOOD

[@russsss3098]

“ Nemo’s egg when they murk his mom” Ryan Bergara 2020

[@christianv2921]

I'm kinda shocked that none of them put Monsters Inc on their lists anywhere. That movie always get me in the feels

[@genesiscarrillo4641]

I ugly cried watching Inside out, as someone who has suffered from depression since the age of 9 i felt like that movie understood how important it is to validate a childs emotions and feelings.

[@elijahkanakis8183]

no one: shane: i wANna bE A _r A t_

[@breahnadougherty7357]

this made me ugly laugh

[@isabellejunio4232]

He truly is a rat man

[@jessdewhurst4996]

As far as I’m concerned he already is one

[@jessdewhurst4996]

I say this w love

[@elijahkanakis8183]

Jess Dewhurst yes ofc

[@tandyegg]

Instead of going to Prom, I went with my mom to see Finding Nemo. One of my favorite moments of my life. We missed the first ten minutes though, and had no idea about the beginning until we saw it again. And we both turned to each other and were like “Ohhhh.”