Film Theory: Titanic is about Time Travel... No REALLY!

Subscribe to never miss a Film Theory! ► bit.ly/1dI8VBH
Don't miss our Holliday Theory Wear!! ► bit.ly/2UkxCv0
Titanic is a movie that has stood the test of time... and has one of the BIGGEST unanswered questions of any movie. No, I don't mean could they both fit on the door if Rose had just moved over a little. I mean the question is Jack a time traveler sent to make sure the Titanic sinks? Yes, that age old question. Well Theorists, today we are going to answer that once and for all!
Get yourself some Theory Wear! ► bit.ly/2UkxCv0
Don't miss a Film Theory! ► bit.ly/1dI8VBH
#Titanic #TimeTravel #TatanicMovie #TitanicTheory #Jack #Rose #TimeLord #Theory #FilmTheory #Matpat
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get Your 30 Day Free Trial Now ► share.epidemicsound.com/TheFil...
MORE FILM THEORIES
Rick's True CRIME! | Rick and Morty ►► bit.ly/2MVhP2W
Will MORTY KILL RICK?! ►► bit.ly/2qKFFFV
How PICKLE RICK Functions! ►►► bit.ly/2JvU4fT
Blair Witch's SECRET DANGER! ► bit.ly/2qhmv7a
Ariel & Hercules Are RELATED?! ► bit.ly/32WnVWi
Credits:
Writers: Matthew Patrick
Editors: Forrest Lee and Koen Verhagen
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman

[@bibbo3167]

Fun Fact: after Jack froze to death, he becomes Jack Frost, as seen in “rise of the guardians”

[@jaxonellbelurin472]

🤯

[@OrangeLordThe14th]

@@jaxonellbelurin472 what he said

[@moscow9394]

That sounds like some cheap director would do

[@OrangeLordThe14th]

It's over anakin I have the high ground

[@moscow9394]

@@OrangeLordThe14th this is the 2000th anakin comment ive seen in 23 youtube videos today and im not surprised

[@DeamonChocobo]

Fun Fact: my Great Grandfather had a ticket for the Titanic but missed it because of an emergency in his village. Somewhere in our family home in Greece is an unused ticket for the Titanic.

[@octosaurus2179]

@Patrick McCready tons of mons ye

[@mrlemon7436]

Dame really dodged a bullet

[@jjeer6802]

Ask to matpat if he can do a theory bout that

[@dingus3178]

That’s worth... billions of dollars... your future kids and GRAND children wouldn’t have to work a day in their lives. Your great grandkids too if you live frugally

[@taleaccount4682]

Top 10 luckiest coincidences.

[@BlueberryMustard]

Director: makes a few innocent mistakes in his movie Matpat: TIME TRAVEL

[@lutzgrootens3781]

Wasn't the Titanic also a wake up call to people to proper equip boats with enough lifeboats and stuff? So he also safed a lot of sailors lifes in WW1

[@CaityRaindrop]

Yeah maritime law changed that there had to be enough lifeboats to fit all passengers and crew. Wouldn't have helped Titanic tho (they barely got the last 2 boats they did have off before it sunk)

[@JC_Cali]

Exactly! Srprised he didn'y mention it. Imaagine a Titanic-like disaster for a cruise-shipin the 1930s or 1960s without those regulations... massive amounts of deaths

[@thepokemonpowerhouse5562]

"saved" "lives"

[@Third7Plays]

⁠@@CaityRaindropcorrection; Collapsible A did barely make it off the ship thanks to being tied to the ship when the the ship keeled back to an even keel. They had to cut collapsible A off the ship. Collapsible B on the other hand…it flipped over while being pushed off the officers quarters while the bridge was going under (also landed on top of a guy but he survived that and I think was actually saved). It floated off and a bunch of guys, including the guy who had collapsible B land on top of him, and Second Officer Charles Lightoller (the most senior officer on the titanic). Fun history lesson for y’all (lots died on Collapsible A btw, pretty sure everyone on Collapsible B survived, you can look it up and correct me on that. 9:56 The Lusitania was an American ship that belonged to the Cunard line. Not a British one.

[@Hittlerfavjew]

Yes yes it was

[@theblaze5530]

Writers: Make a mistake and reference things that didn't exist back in 1912 MatPat: Time Travel it is!

[@crossyright9493]

Yeah... as much as i like hearing theories, this one is a little too much. Just like Ness

[@LeoStaley]

James Cameron was *obsessed* with accuracy. All of these "mistakes" were about Jack, and all of them were future-centric anachronisms. I personally think it's because rose just made him up.

[@alalalala57]

I still remember when theorists knew how to have fun.

[@elijah6852]

@@alalalala57 Right? People take this stuff way too seriously. Matpat has said before that oftentimes, his theories are made just because they're fun. Not all of his theories are made to be believed. People don't get that.

[@jaydenjewett3796]

Come on man the ness theory was just awesome plain and simple awesome

[@Emily-iy9mr]

This felt like a big English lecture where the author accidentally said something that doesn't match and your English teacher is now like "It's on purpose, what does it mean?"

[@bellamyseals831]

100th like :))

[@MikaylaROL]

It really does feel like this 😂

[@estrellaescobar5723]

Honestly, the Titanic had more than 20 continuity "errors". It could be a coincidence, since the movie had so many details that is almost insane to check all, but also makes you think how is posible that nobody notice before things that are so obvious. I mean, is not like is details that happens in the background for 0.3 seconds.

[@Phantom7251]

jpnewpic88.men xxx

[@deannal.newton9772]

In all fairness, with the exception of Rose, Jack, Rose's fiance, and her mom the rest of the people on the Titanic are actual people who were on the real Titanic. Even down to the baker who was the last person to get off of the Titanic did the exact same thing in real life and lived to tell the tale about it. Heck, they should make a movie out of all the lives of the actual people who survived and died on the Titanic instead of two fictional characters on the ship.

[@willwilliams2944]

Probably because they don't really want their stories heard or mainstream. As far as I have researched no one will attest to seeing an iceberg, but they will to hearing an explosion. If you know about who was on board that ship and everything that has transpired after it sinking due to their absence. It would be clear cut motive and opportunity for purposely doing it. Then giving suddle hints in movies and not mainstreaming real testimonies that would make people ask questions. Just my opinion though. Especially since history repeats itself and it's been done before that and even recently.

[@Yetaxa]

@@willwilliams2944 few people saw an iceberg because it was close to midnight, below 0 outside and the iceberg itself was barely visible in the first place. most people barely even noticed the collision The 'explosion' that many people claim they heard was shortly because the Titanic went under, and was likely the deafening sound of the whole thing snapping in half Keep your conspiracy theories out of here

[@Draconic_Incenerator]

Wait, so all the named characters you mentioned are fictional and to this story only? I thought this was supposed to be a recreation of what actually happened?

[@deannal.newton9772]

@@Draconic_Incenerator It is, it's jut that some of the characters (like the ones that I mentioned) are fictional. Everyone else in the movie is based on an actual for real person during the events of The Titanic. Even the baker, who was the last person to jump off the ship, is an actual for real person that survived the Titanic sinking as well as the violinist who stayed behind to keep playing in order to calm the passengers.

[@Draconic_Incenerator]

@@deannal.newton9772 Im surprised this didnt trigger any PTSD or the like as most of the ppl did sadly die on there. So getting those ppl to relive such an event is weird.

[@Arandohistorian202]

I think it’s very very important to mention that the German navy HAD a reason to sink the Lusitania because there was apparently ammunition and weapons aboard the Lusitania and the Germans basically said “oh that’s a cargo ship carrying stuff to supply our enemies” so the U-Boat sank the Lucy other then that the German Navy (to my knowledge) didn’t sink any other ocean liners on their regular routes carrying paying passengers

[@BuckClucks]

They had a reason, but it was in breach of International Law the way the attack was carried out. You had to ask the merchant ship for boarding permission to check for war material, and if you found material the ship had to be scuttled and all civilians onboard rescued, or if close to shore, put into life boats and they can make it to shore. Germany attacking the Lusitania never even said that a attack was coming. And it was also a guess whether or not the ship was carrying war material. And in the future Germany sank many civilian ships that had no war material on board.

[@sarveshbhagwat9045]

Imagine being James Cameron and watching this where he made a few mistakes and a guy makes a theory about time travel.

[@alterego9618]

I’m sure he would like it lol

[@leoaceves2652]

@@alterego9618 True

[@yizao9289]

@@alterego9618 he would probably love it

[@fullliquorbar8829]

@@alterego9618 Yea(❍ᴥ❍ʋ)

[@nateavery2875]

Exactly

[@uncleflagzz]

Everyone: chilling Matpat out of freaking nowhere: *_How MINECRAFT lore connects to the assassination of JFK_*

[@omegalightning5715]

I expect this at this point

[@theoctopus5343]

DONT GIVE HIM IDEAS

[@j.c.ingledue6553]

I don't think... wait.... I kinda wanna see this now

[@baylorwuzhere]

MatPat you know this is true!

[@rjayy1]

THIS ARTIST IS NEXT UP!🚨kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4XTnYt9d9mei5o

[@Puddin205]

“3 hrs and 14 mins is how long it took for the titanic to sink” - MatPat I hate to break the news to ya, but it sank in two hours and forty minutes…

[@thisweeksedition2477]

True

[@Kirasnothome]

Could’ve included the first warnings of the icebergs and the sinking time

[@PhysicalMediaPreventsWea-bx1zm]

Supposedly if you cut out all the "present day" scenes and add all the 1912 scenes together it adds up to 2:40.

[@taylordavis2826]

Love how a huge part of this theory is constructed around continuity errors and mistakes but honestly I'm here for it

[@Skellyender]

so this is why teachers don’t like students asking “what if” questions

[@iamaepicpersonlol557]

Ah yes a fellow intellectual

[@chaz2187]

They’ll immediately change the subject just to avoid ‘what ifs?’

[@BrotherTheory]

Indeed lol. You are BRILLIANT, SkellyEnder :)

[@NinjaCreeper-yx3tl]

Nice

[@itsasecret4451]

I used to do so many “what if’s” that my teachers just answered with “why?”

[@BobBob-zg5lz]

The Titanic Writers after realizing their poor research: “Heheheh... yeah... time travel.... sure...”

[@deadsoldiertr]

@@sekoseko1147 f off

[@Telcrem]

@@sekoseko1147 stop this and get a life.

[@teabsaesae9870]

Plot twist: it wasn't poor research

[@devtianrk]

aint no way after what happen to the submarine this got reccomended to me

[@kcnkck]

Lmao

[@Coffee-Cath]

Insanely popular thing happened ever so slightly related to other insanely popular thing moment. ain’t no way after what happen to the Mat Pat this got recommended to me

[@vcrbetamax]

@@Coffee-CathI take it English isn’t your first language?

[@Coffee-Cath]

@@vcrbetamax Nah I was just on a really short break between doing stuff and I saw that comment and was like, “I feel like I see these everywhere but like that’s not really much of an interesting or unique experience that person is having. I feel as though a lot of that is just how algorithms work as things such as the titanic or Mathew Pat Rick will gain more interest as thing happen surrounding them and that leads to popular videos of them being recommended again.” But instead of writing that I tried to write three separate replies, and tried to salvage the mess within the span of four minutes. (One reply was just going to be “me when water exits” I think I’m tired.)

[@vcrbetamax]

@@Coffee-Cath I meant because it’s hard to understand your sentence structure. You use a lot of run on sentences.

[@RaphBlade7]

Well it wouldn't be the first time that where a time traveling story involving the Titanic prevented a World War, as 1996 video game Titanic Adventure Out of Time also featured a time travel plot!

[@dezs.5202]

James Cameron: *fails history class* MatPat: “Obviously it was time travel”

[@zerlichr426]

It's more complicated then that. Rose just don't remember it correcly. She is over 100 years old, and trust me with how time can affect brain no wonder there is some anachronistic's in this. I know Mat prefers to make it zebras rather then horses, but it's much simpler that she doesn't remember it correcly and make up blanks in her memory. Because human mind doesn't remember anything at all, it just recall HOW we remember that event. That's why mandela effect or deja vu exist. It is how your brain alter your memory because more time passes and more blurry that memory is. It's like old magnetic tapes. The more you play them the less charge they have, and more distroted they get. On that note how does she remember him going with that bag. I mean why we have perspective of ANYONE other that Rose IN HER MEMORY.

[@chao6890]

@@zerlichr426 uhuh....

[@Someone-is4lx]

@@zerlichr426 or maybe the writers wrote a time travel story

[@ICTON123]

@@zerlichr426 He knows that, it's just way too fun to overthink things

[@zerlichr426]

@@ICTON123 I know but as someone said in medical field when watching doctor house "you always think horses before zebras". Aka first simple solution then complicated one. And Mat just like throw first theory the most complicated one there is

[@jackdawson3288]

Dammit Rose, I told you not to tell them!

[@stingraymaster9168]

Why didn't he build 90's?

[@68222]

Dang, it billy

[@notsocuteotaku8662]

they don't believe her anyways, you good 🙄

[@potatoslayer69420]

Well met Weary time traveller. . . . . . I have to ask you something though Is there going to be! *Drumroll* A decent season of game of thrones? Or *Drumroll again* Will tf2 still be alive in 30 years from now?

[@adhiraajsingh517]

@@potatoslayer69420 *blast beat* wtf did i read?

[@sundeath5359]

Jack: It was a canon event Miquel: you see that boy, I raised him

[@Denji350]

😂

[@zephyr8072]

I knew it! Jack was the iceberg all along!

[@hvallois7149]

Counter theory: jack is actually James Cameron, he travels back in time to save rose so she eventually drops her very expensive neckless into the sea, he is waiting under the water in scuba gear to nab the necklace and make big money off it

[@AdoboSoGuud]

But if he stayed in the ocean, wouldn't he be catching hypothermia and die? It'll take him long to dive down to catch the necklace.

[@jonbojsenkvrndrup8180]

He got picked up by his personal submarine and brought back to life just like in the Abyss. HIS NAME IS JAMES CAMERON! dumdumdumdum

[@devinewolfe1906]

The real kicker is he used the money from the necklace to fund the movie. 🤯

[@yourgrandad4882]

I read this as James Cameron? Wtf edit: I MEANT DAVID CAMERON.

[@BrotherTheory]

That's BRILLIANT, Small Man :)

[@saichandra1360]

I am imagining James Cameron smiling in peace because someone finally understood his movie

[@jacobhofius2528]

Isn’t he still alive?

[@kehlercreations]

@@jacobhofius2528 Does the original comment imply that he is not?

[@nathan9901]

@@jacobhofius2528 ok but thats exactly what i thought when i read this comment 🤣

[@Cozmicsaber]

@@kehlercreations yeah it does or at least that's the impression I got. I even googled it to see if dead.

[@speakofthedevil3216]

@@kehlercreations not technically but I had the same thought. I think it has something to do with the use of the words "peace" and "finally", since they are usually associated with death, especially when used in the same sentence.

[@ericschultz4004]

Let's not forget the whole story was told from a 101 year old Rose's perspective. A 101 year old who is about to die at the end of the movie could easily confuse Lake Wissota and Santa Monica Pier as something Jack said. I believe that could be a clue as to where Rose did most of her ice fishing later in life and the pier as something Rose definitely visited in the horseback picture between 1917-1923. Same thing with "Molly" Brown. She confused Brown's name she went by on the Titanic with the name she heard for years and years after the sinking just as she confused actually doing the activities with something Jack actually said.

[@sanjanaakotyada4753]

I love how this went from “Titanic dude is a time traveller” to “World War I History lesson (with mathematical statistics” Like, I just came home from school, let me chill dude!

[@daviddamasceno6063]

They could make an entire new movie about all Jack's failed attempts to keep Rose alive.

[@N0N0111]

Edge of Tomorrow style :D

[@SalemMP4]

It is the choice of steins gate!

[@arealisticbeautystandard8920]

That would be amazing

[@LVrJ100]

Like The Ground Hog day.

[@caseyyy4785]

yeah like groundhog day x happy death day

[@leosong829]

Directors: make a few insignificant timeline mistakes Matpat: And then the world gets taken over by germany!!!

[@challenger8bit572]

Or walking arcade machines

[@Marin_Karin]

It's mildly infuriating that you can make butterfly theories on anything and if you planned it well it can truly make sense.

[@RasmusVJS]

@@challenger8bit572 Phineas and Ferb reference?

[@challenger8bit572]

@@RasmusVJS not really just a random thought

[@RasmusVJS]

@@challenger8bit572 Huh, if I had a dollar for every time someone mentioned the world being taken over by walking machines, I would have 2 dollars. It's not a lot, but it's weird that it's happened twice.

[@jaysonjolin563]

When this movie was out in theaters and "My Heart Will Go On" was on infinite replay on every radio station, my local station released a hilarious version of the song where, instead of being interspersed with audio clips from the movie, it was interspersed with audio clips from Airplane. I absolutely loved that version. I wish I could find a copy.

[@re9246]

Fun fact: the reason it was released December 19th, was because it’s original release date was December 12th. But Scream 2 released December 12th, and it was so anticipated that the studio pushed Titanic’s release a week later

[@lynn-vn8xw]

i wish it was released dec 12 it would’ve been on my birthday

[@mazBANK]

happy very vERY VERYYYYYYYYY VERY late birthday.

[@palivivi]

Showed my mom this video and at the end she just said... DOES THIS GUY BREATHE?

[@elliyoung3050]

No,no he doesn’t

[@Danderfull]

@@elliyoung3050 He's a wizzard Harry! A WIZZARD

[@elliyoung3050]

@@Danderfull yes and Jack has the time turner

[@theuglydumbird]

your mom is asking the real questions

[@jiten9843]

Hmmmmm.......interesting

[@fqidz]

Writers who just made a mistake: Yeah, this theory is true 100%. Totally wrote it like this yep.

[@DayZeroGaming]

Every story i have ever written (even in class) always has a deeper meaning that goes far beyond a normal viewers comprehensive abilities. Now give James Cameron a few hundred millions dollars.. a few of these probably sneak into the films 🎥

[@kaspertheshepherd3010]

@@DayZeroGaming epic

[@farelrajwa1300]

The writter problably just made a small no attention to detail considering that it was the 1990 and information was much much limited but i would still take credit for the fan theory

[@mighty_polar_bear3786]

The research team that was supposed to keep everything time- appropriate : 😰

[@mighty_polar_bear3786]

@Alfred Richmond Ruff I watched it and found it interesting (and I believe there’s a small chance maybe the directer possibly meant this), but I don’t have to agree with him to enjoy his videos.

[@user-rq5eh4gl3p]

Mat Pat can make a theory on anything

[@MCSoutbreak]

Another reason why jack saved rose was that its a destined time event (meaning time is written so well that the thing you would do if you went back in time has already happened so when you go back your just following history)

[@Enraged.]

I love how it went from “Jack made sure the Titanic sank” to “America could have lost the war.”

[@Nostra.Damus14]

Do you love it though?

[@themusther161]

@@Nostra.Damus14 i do

[@The_Irish_Rover]

Spoilers

[@DarthAxolotl]

@@The_Irish_Rover if you don't want spoilers don't read the comments during the video

[@Shimanas527]

@@The_Irish_Rover comments are for people who wached the video if you didnt knew

[@NoSou1L]

The ship sank because Rose is asserting dominance over the ship with the T-Pose. And jack is trying to hold her back.

[@TheRealWoopSlap]

I'm weak also I feel challenged by the thumbnail

[@kikuoisthebestandnoonecant1915]

lmao

[@NoSou1L]

"Don't let go jack" that has new meaning lol

[@MovedToPhilippinesballvolt]

XDDDD

[@NationalSportsEntertainmentNSE]

Now that you mention it, I think the Philadelphia experiment was actually the titanic! That’s why the ship sank so quickly and they were not able to get any correspondence out they went through a time portal. It makes sense the boat was hundreds of years ahead of its time Also Rose knew Picasso would be a great painter. Jack even predicted Roses future life and death 80 ahead of time

[@AnuragKharvi]

Well, it could also be that Cameron got a bit full of himself and didn't research the time period properly.

[@janelleg597]

Cameron wasn't responsible for every frickn detail

[@jasperofthrones1310]

Everyone be gangsta till Jack starts time traveling.

[@bredbear9093]

@@sekoseko893 Ooops.... kzbin.info/www/bejne/mIDQdZt_ZdyAZsU

[@blondejesus252]

Is this durv

[@SheffKane]

Lowkey

[@dragonmaster613]

but is his grace strong enough???... oops, wrong Jack.

[@bredbear9093]

@@blondejesus252 No, this is Sparta.

[@ic236]

movie: has a bunch of continuity timeline errors firm theory: TIME TRAVELLER

[@xxdinobest848]

Don't click it's a bot

[@someloser8640]

I love firm theory

[@domiofthenorth4911]

Firm theory? Nah, I like my theories soft, homie

[@monke4476]

@@xxdinobest848 did u say click?

[@Xzlibur]

Yes FIRM theory

[@DefaultMiserable]

The movie was actually one of my favorite movies as a kid, more because I was fascinated by the story/history of the Titanic itself, not so much for the film's story, although it is a good movie. Now, as an adult, I'm not super interested in movies, and i don't find myself getting so intrigued by history quite as often. So, it was really fun and interesting to revisit a particular childhood interest with a new and very interesting light on it. Thank you for this theory. 😃❤

[@pickle.planet]

It actually took 2 hours and 40 minutes to sink. NOT 3 hours and 14 minutes.

[@rynvail521]

This week on Game Theory: MatPat makes us wonder what horrific disaster the time travelers are preventing by letting 2020 play out.

[@johnmichael8462]

OHohhhhh.. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIS2d5qNoamVgLc

[@rodrigomateodelgadodelacru8154]

@@johnmichael8462 yeah yeah We already know how to turn pdf into Word

[@ricardoflores24]

Another plague? COVID's forcing humanity to advance their research on diseases and stuff. If COVID weren't happening the next pandemic could've been *MUCH* worse.

[@mixedbaggamer]

@@ricardoflores24 preventing the zombies rather than causing them

[@kylerivera3470]

@@ricardoflores24 Maybe there is some big war that would have happened if all the countries were healthy, but didn't happen because all the countries (or most at least) were bust dealing with the pandemic.

[@fanofstuff1607]

I would like to add: this boat sinking led to increased boat safety, saving many many more lives.

[@veryhot2382]

OHohhhhh kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIS2d5qNoamVgLc

[@JC_Cali]

That's where I thought he was going but he took a tur = WAR

[@rodrigomateodelgadodelacru8154]

@@veryhot2382 yeah yeah We already know how to turn pdf into Word

[@Devilspade]

You add nothing he already said that :/

[@fanofstuff1607]

@@Devilspade when?

[@GermanBoy84]

Occean Gate... every 40 Years open a Time Portal. He Tweet that.

[@tankeater]

0:08 Matt, this is a MANDELA EFFECT and you proved it without realizing it!!! I was born a few months after you, making me class of 05. Titanic came out in SUMMER of 1999, between my 6th and 7th grade. YET, the release date, is December 1997??? Mat just turned 11 years old 🤷‍♂️😂🤦‍♂️

[@BKAngmar]

No? There was a Britannic movie in 1999, but not Titanic.

[@tankeater]

@@BKAngmar yes... Because all the girls I was into going into middle school all raved about Leo in the movie he stared in called Dritannic 🤦‍♂️😂

[@GlamGoreChaosQueen]

Nope. I was in fourth grade, born in 88, titanic came out in 97. Plus, you know, documentation.

[@tankeater]

@@GlamGoreChaosQueen you seam to not be understanding my statement... I remember it in middle school too, and I was born in 1987. Mat was the same graduated class as me, 2005. Mat remembers the same thing as me. Yet you don't. THAT'S EXPLAINING THE MANDELA EFFECT PERFECTLY!!!! BUHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA You have no clue what you're talking about, ESPECIALLY because you brought up documentations... You know, something that could be changed in the code. BUT, memories can't be changed. So, you have no clue what you're talking about. 👍

[@apersonyoudontknow1911]

@@tankeater Couldn’t you just be remembering wrong? Also why are you so defensive about it lol

[@artemisamory]

movie: has historical inaccuracies film theory: TIME TRAVEL

[@Mystic_Stirling]

*“Aliens”*

[@samskordi6079]

True lol

[@patricklee7241]

😂 spot on. Plus, this theory isn't new. I heard this theory 20 years ago.

[@SooClassy]

@Patrick Lee youtube wasn’t a thing 20 years ago

[@OMGoobero]

@@patricklee7241 what were you on that saw that?

[@DesiJTemi]

Alternate title: matpat exposes plotholes in a top grossing movie of all time and pretends its intentional writing.

[@aaronking2020]

Film Theory in a nutshell.

[@klop4228]

Or: the entire point of Game and Film Theory. Though there were a few logical leaps and assumptions here :P

[@deepeshvasnani1100]

Almost any theory of films or books centres around plotholes

[@notlikeyouneedmyname.4378]

He is probably just low-key emphasising the plot holes.

[@master0fthearts894]

Does it really matter if it was a historical inaccuracy., or a ‘plot hole’ or not? The point is to take established evidence to create a theory and have fun with it. It wouldn’t be called Film Theory if Mat-Pat just when through the answer of: Oh, it’s probably just the researchers making a couple of mistakes. Sure, Mat-Pat would’ve probably been right... but it would’ve made a bad theory, and made it a lot more boring and dull. It’s kind of a running gag that there’s always a simple answer, but May-Pat ignores it with his... *ability to OVER-ANALYZE.* And to be honest... if people can learn about WW2, the Titanic, and a bunch of knowledge because a dude made a crazy theory about the main love-interest being a time-traveling life-savior, despite there being a clear and logical answer just right in front of him... why should we stop him?

[@KurtIsFat]

Jack: it's a canon event

[@schmoopie2010]

May I just say that if all of our great grandparents went on the titanic we would never be watching this

[@lorimaupas3712]

Everyone: he wanted to save her Matpat: jacks a time traveler

[@BrotherTheory]

Love it! You are actually BRILLIANT, Lori Maupas :)

[@rhoydplaz2853]

Hahahah

[@generichomosapien4666]

Didnt the past already happen? why would he want to change the past and create a new timeline while trying to prevent creating a new timeline??????

[@krievv]

@@generichomosapien4666 Maybe he came from a different timeline where the US had joined the war early. So if he sank the ship that brought the country into the war, why not?

[@Silentgrace11]

@@generichomosapien4666 I mean, when it comes to time travel this just becomes a pile of endless possibilities. Jack could have previously thought, "Well, what if I can save these thousands of people?" and had gone back in time to manipulate the boat's trajectory? What if this led to him taking some actions which led to Rose wanting to jump off the ship? Then, upon returning to his time, he realized he effed up and that he had to find some way to resolve the issue. And then wibbley wobbley timey wimey stuff occurs. Or this, and or that. The problem with time travel theories is that they can basically talk themselves into a circle of obscurity. They're still fun to think about though ;)

[@AyeDaniels]

"It has Leonard Di Caprio chasing after young women, only this time it's age appropriate". Mat really woke up this morning and chose *violence* huh?

[@sekoseko1147]

Oops............... kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIS2d5qNoamVgLc

[@thegoldengamer9315]

Lol

[@tinniesealjiji]

And I oop

[@bredbear9093]

@@sekoseko1147 Ooops ... kzbin.info/www/bejne/mIDQdZt_ZdyAZsU

[@emperorflick]

I choked on my spaghetti when he said that

[@sharagonzales1758]

Here after OceanGate because its got me on a Titanic binge. ✌️

[@colemanmonac2445]

Really thought this was a new video, and I was just waiting for him to make a submarine comment

[@JohnTK]

I have just come to the sudden realization that a large portion of people probably don’t know that the Titanic was a real ship, and I am now worried...

[@arianewinter4266]

Or they think the movie portrays what actualy happened . . . It is losely based on reality, but the whole plot itself did not happen

[@kike77772014]

Wait that boat is real? Lmao 🤣

[@marceluttembergue3217]

Bro you got me thinking that as well what if

[@kakahass8845]

Yeah i saw on reddit someone said "Canadians think the Titanic was a real event and not just a movie how dumb can you be? laughing emoji laughing emoji laughing emoji" humanity doesn't deserve the world.

[@Historyguy-xu5ht]

Fun fact, a jack Dawson was on the Titanic... as a part of the crew, specifically the guys in the engines. He was 17 and died

[@xxliquidnsolidxx648]

Are we all gonna ignore the fact that the sinking of the Titanic saved millions of lives because it lead to some new safety requirements on passanger ships like enough lifeboats or better communication and warning between ships?

[@veryhot2382]

OHohhhhh kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIS2d5qNoamVgLc

[@deadpossm2488]

Gotta break a break a few eggs to make an omelet as they say

[@Jack-sf9zo]

While you arent wrong even if titanic diddnt sink there would likely be an incident that would happen to cause these changes anyway, an example even possibly being lusitania, considering the death tole she had even when there were enough lifeboats

[@MrMissingnin44]

Imagine having enough lifeboats. ....

[@rumstun1121]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aIXOhJ6dh7OojJo

[@kokirimido3924]

A Personal Theory: James Cameron is from another dimension, where all The films like Avatar Titanic and Terminator have been made, and he hopped in to this verse, to make them. This level of Perfection from Cameron is Simply Unreal.

[@YamaLlamasss]

Titanic 2 the ice berge strikes back: an Epic sequel

[@mr.depthleviathan5425]

MatPat's child in 2069: "Technoblade ACTUALLY can't die!"

[@marcinshitpost1482]

Masaka

[@calvinhelm2572]

Yup

[@pandadogunited1504]

Is...is this news?

[@aden4431]

@@pandadogunited1504 no, it’s truth

[@Tears_Eurydice]

BH AHAHAHA

[@marten2857]

*Plot twist:* MatPat used a time machine himself to make the director put this secret lore into the movie, just so he could make a Film Theory video on the most iconic movie ever

[@johnmichael8462]

OHohhhhh.. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIS2d5qNoamVgLc

[@thesong6984]

69 likes milestone.

[@marten2857]

@Crotchwhistle Purple keyword “children” 🤨

[@LTRevan-lg6mw]

Jack: Its a cannon event

[@Creepzter]

I find it funny how saving a fictional character would change history when it's already happened

[@rosesareredvioletsblue5438]

Movie creator: **makes historical inaccuracies in his movie** MatPat: _t i m e t r a v e l_

[@nerotoxin0661]

@@alanwalkers9646 bruh

[@BrotherTheory]

I love him so much! You are BRILLIANT, Eleonora :)

[@colmlooney5843]

Maybe not inaccuracies but rather inconsistencies in storytelling. This is rose telling the story after all

[@emeraldkoala2543]

Yeah, but would you watch a fifteen minute video on tiny historical inaccuracies in Titanic?

[@itachiuchiha6912]

@gmail.com

[@parthbansal2775]

Internet : Jack is actually an imagination of Rose because she wanted a coping mechanism Matpat : That's outrageous Internet : Okay Matpat : He was actually a Time Traveller

[@NathanM72641]

That's are mattpat

[@Your_Native_Mothman]

I actually like this theory a lot more

[@Michael-bt6ht]

That piece of information that he was nonexistent helps solidify the explanation he's a time traveler people don't seem to realize this movie costed 200m made by James Cameron a science fiction film maker you really think he would make all these historical inaccuracies? He made tje terminator which is about time travel. He isn't making mistakes about history unless it's on purpose film makers of Cameron's caliber include every piece of detail, every scene, every line and every piece of furniture or wallpaper etc in the movie for a specific reason he made the movie to the exact time it took the titanic to sink, obviously he's very serious about details.

[@Your_Native_Mothman]

@@Michael-bt6ht yeah I agree

[@vincevandensteen2490]

I want to like but it’s at 666 likes so......

[@twisted258]

Many problems with the WW1 aspect, as the Titanic would've been converted for British use during the war (like its sisters the Olympic and the Britannic) instead of carrying passengers across a transatlantic voyage like the Lusitania.

[@hawkssimp5862]

youtube recommended me this video at the right time

[@bluevoxyt3453]

The titanic: literally a horrible tragedy MatPat: ITS TIME TRAVEL!!!!!!!

[@bryan3754]

Well he’s talking about the movie not the actual sinking.

[@bluevoxyt3453]

@@bryan3754 r/woooosh

[@fear_is_nearcz]

Sub u

[@goldenwitherphoenix1389]

Oh great. Can't wait to see idiots, not you, try cancelling him over this.

[@gagiibaaji2774]

@@sekoseko893 STOP

[@raphaelcestari272]

MatPat: JACK IS A TIME TRAVELER LOOK AT ALL THESE HISTORICALLY INACCURATE THINGS IN THE MOVIE! The people who worked on the movie: Yeah..... Definetly on purpose.....

[@ashply4306]

Yeahh I was thinking of the same thing😂

[@VietnamKermit]

Kola Bright what does that have to do with this though?

[@Vortex-fz7br]

More fun though

[@Phantom7251]

jpnewpic88.men xx

[@jimuelyutrago2577]

I swear Matpat is so convincing he can probably make like all of people who watch his videos think that homosapians are closer to BIRDS rather than like Apes and that side

[@Nooo_Way]

He might have time travelled in the future, changed his name, married rose, and lived on with her as a new person with a new identity

[@user-hy2oj7rh7h]

this is literally history channel in the middle of the night

[@ShadowLynx777]

Hmm he did say the word alien when talking about Alien the movie *history channel seal of approval*

[@i_need_more_sleep9050]

I have never have thought of that

[@monkeylordofdoom14]

There is an island in the north Atlantic!....

[@waflelplays6478]

This is my favorite comment

[@dont6927]

Don't read my profile picture 😊 .

[@therearenoshortcuts9868]

the Time Traveler wasn't Jack Dawson... it was actually Leonardo Dicaprio... he travelled back in time to sink the ship so they can hire him to make a movie about it thus making him famous

[@maggotsinyourshoes]

Hmmmmm

[@seanpurdom6380]

But... He was a famous child actor? He was already famous.

[@theghostlyterror3578]

NOW THAAAAATS A THEORY

[@AAAAAA-eg6pe]

@@seanpurdom6380 Yeah, but he wouldn't have been a famous child actor if Hollywood wasn't created... Nor would he have had his big break in Titanic if the Titanic hadn't sunk.

[@scarlex8721]

Thats what matpat at the end of the video...

[@carolinem32218]

Okay, another question that I just thought of watching this halfway through. Let's say, hypothetically, if Jack never won the ticket on the Titanic, then the Titanic would never have sunk if Jack was the reason it would sink anyways.

[@beargreen1]

The stuff back then was more simple back then, and so awesome and can become very trendy with memes of it.

[@jasongilman8025]

You didn’t convince me that the movie titanic is about a time traveler. You convinced me the ACTUAL titanic was sunk by a time traveler.

[@weedcaat]

Underrated

[@SobrietyandSolace]

Of course, to make sure the Federal Reserve was created. (haven't finished the video yet but that's my theory)

[@BrotherTheory]

I love your comment. You are BRILLIANT, Jason :)

[@PhantomGato-v-]

Brain 100

[@Wizard4k]

Well the actual titanic didn’t have Rose since Rose is a fictional character

[@H-MAN-yn3ok]

Does anyone else think right after jack went under water he was like “mission accomplished” and just zapped away into the future

[@derekstein6193]

Que Quantum Leap theme.

[@TRTheIronFist]

yep

[@generalkenobianimations]

But Leo, what about your acting career? "Acting? Where we're going, I don't have an acting career!"

[@LaneCorbett]

Much hugging, High fives, Drinking, and Ravelry were had at mission Control

[@CasualAviationEnthusiast]

🤔🤔🤔

[@the_glitter_is]

The search for Rose delay would have also resulted in them most likely being in the iceberg area at day instead of night, making it easier to avoid.

[@crimz482]

True fact: The movie titanic cost more than the actual titanic

[@Maxx__________]

Well, obviously. They had to rebuild the ship again so they could crash it.

[@yusha1059]

@@Maxx__________ and the time travel costs alot aswell

[@field5758]

Oh... Bad ship i guess, seems like it could just break

[@madtony1608]

@Osama been Laggin you forgot paying for people to time travel

[@YuRaNXue]

These are matpat thinking levels

[@mythicmud837]

I love how matpat takes his theorist pills and is like “Okay Jack is a time traveler and the Lorax is a type of bear”

[@ICTON123]

And in Food Theory "So you can eat your entire Christmas Tree"

[@idontknowimebored77]

And we love him for it

[@alaiaomanu6318]

wolverine grunting kzbin.info/www/bejne/on-ZiqV7q7Fjbrs

[@dont6927]

Don't read my profile picture 😊 .

[@idontknowimebored77]

@@dont6927 okay I wont

[@aaabn8]

I remember those old days when people would explain things like this with a simple "Well, the production/screenwriters messed it up there"

[@alexanderlopez8195]

Had to come back to this, instead of time travel. Since it was told from a 100 year old rose point of view. Maybe she had mistaken some details as she was telling the story not being able to remember every little detail some get mistaken because of her age and memory. she remembers it differently and gets some of it confused. If that makes sense what do y’all think?

[@itsrelevantgaming]

Everyone living 2020 debating about the door, but Film Theory is living in 3020 with this doozy.

[@pizzaonearth6511]

Nah they live in like 5050 with this doozy

[@ecec6852]

The Door? Explanation? Plotline summary?

[@martinmatti9655]

Ya. Thay are good

[@chaihill1837]

Yeah, could you explain?

[@luke873]

Subscribe to airrack

[@paulpieri9904]

“They’re just mistakes”, film theory ”nothing is a mistake”

[@Brid1]

There are no mistakes! -Master Oogway

[@bredbear9093]

@@Brid1 There are some good catchy songs... -Me kzbin.info/www/bejne/mIDQdZt_ZdyAZsU

[@pemtl5917]

"there are no accidents" - Master Oogway

[@legoboyfan123456789]

Only happy accidents -bob ross

[@greasy979]

Just happy accidents.

[@BugJuiceFlavor]

I don't think the Titanic getting torpedoed would have done much. It hitting the iceberg caused numerous immediate changes to ships, such as dual hulls, bulk head design, water tight doors, and 24/7 radio operators. These likely saved hundreds of thousands of lives at sea from ww1 through ww2. The wars could have been very different if sea transit was hit more severely.

[@aysealtn1669]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@aaronemerson8049]

Bonus Theory: Jack actually told Rose that he was a time traveler and instead of dying, he moved on to a different timeline. Rose made up his death to protect his secret.

[@bandotaku]

I like this theory! Also, maybe she actually did end up with him, but he was under a different name.

[@crizmixakaghostyboi2965]

Very clever

[@stealthbeatle4945]

And then jack met the doctor in WWII when an alien healing microbe was transforming everyone into gas mask wearing zombies

[@helenaluk5752]

that makes a hole lot of sence

[@jesslouise1556]

this deserves more clout

[@AdrianChazz]

Alright, MatPat, enough internet for you. Go play outside.

[@veryhot2279]

WTF.... kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIS2d5qNoamVgLc

[@dottiet6688]

go touch some grass 😌🍊

[@bredbear9093]

@@veryhot2279 JP2GMD... kzbin.info/www/bejne/mIDQdZt_ZdyAZsU

[@scrablse2613]

Matpat: NO! *MUST. TAKE. NOTES.*

[@minidreschi2]

he would came back with a theory about the local park :D

[@redips123gaming3]

Fun fact: my great great uncle was a crew member of the titanic he was born in England ( I was born in Southampton England he might’ve been born there as well) he did survive he’s name is William weller

[@Ravuun]

I was fortunate enough to see this one in the theater and it was amazing.

[@Wolfiyeethegranddukecerberus17]

James Cameron: Titanic MatPat: *_Jack to the Future_*

[@wham1984]

🤣🤣🤣

[@Meowtomee]

Laughing a lot😂😂😂

[@justinslaughter8933]

Best comment

[@MiloMurphysLaw]

Imagine if Titanic 2 is actually about an alternate timeline where the ship didn’t sink

[@fortymcmeme3846]

👏👏

[@chip5892]

First thought: “Of course it is, why wouldn’t it be? This is Film Theory.” Edit: Obligatory ‘lots of likes’ edit.

[@yaloairosa2679]

I like your profile picture

[@meme_pegan5226]

@@yaloairosa2679 yes

[@yaloairosa2679]

@@meme_pegan5226 ya

[@ChunkL123]

@@yaloairosa2679 yes yes yes

[@arianewinter4266]

It is not a new one and it makes sense of well, filmerrors

[@Urban_Tech369]

I think this the BEST theory you ever made and I haven't even seen the actual film :)

[@funnygmemes]

James Cameron is a movie making genius

[@TheImmortalLEGO]

James Cameron be like: Finally! Someone understood my masterpiece!

[@myoddeffect2520]

🤣

[@LukeIdontKnow]

Yeah

[@carterround4600]

Or completely misunderstood

[@yeahyeahdevs8203]

This theory isn’t new just saying

[@thegoldengamer9315]

Lmao

[@shaminresandu8771]

This time travelling Jack concept would have been a brilliant plot for a Titanic part 2 movie

[@lauramillan6298]

Bruh! I still want it even though Leo is fairly old for the role😩.

[@jamestomato1744]

Just because we could, doesn't always mean we should (especially with something like the Titanic, I feel it should just be left alone).

[@shaminresandu8771]

@@jamestomato1744 yeah ur right too

[@entity_unknown5289]

finally i got a 666th like

[@PokeTheMysticJelly]

690 likes? Ima ruin this man's whole career...

[@Huhgundai399]

Fun video. Entertaining. But this sort of thing really goes to show that if the human brain is looking for something, however ridiculous, it will find it.

[@JeremyScobby]

my grandparents went to see this with my dad and my aunt. after watching it they went and bought more tickets to watch it again.

[@cb6733]

Me, as reading the title: Yep, the FNAF theories have finally done it. He's gone insane.

[@Nugcon]

yep

[@adamthefirsthuman]

69th like

[@nguyen5762]

@@iamaepicpersonlol557 what?

[@lilyrose-mo7iy]

So did the tree tea

[@MyTran-dn9ti]

jpnewpic88.men

[@todd5purlock497]

Plot twist: Leonardo DeCaprio is a time traveler who went back to make sure the ship sunk so he could play in a movie about time traveling to make sure the ship sunk

[@cicingel3473]

LMAOOOOO

[@kle5449]

🥲

[@caitlin1397]

It's not a twist is a fact I'm just saying because of my personal experience of being a time traveler also I know you're great great great grand daughter she is very funny XD

[@marzipanmerci1068]

I once had a dream where I was forced to time travel in order to save this particular existent from his untimely death and anonymity, *which still got erased from the history* because he in turn also time travelled to the future in order to make sure that I got sent back in time to save him. This person got inspired by me, went and created a time travelling machine so that he could go to the future to personally send me back to his past where my appearance had inspired him to create the machine in the first place. If that's not a perfect loop, I don't know what is. My mind was blown when I woke up from that awesome slumber.

[@kle5449]

@@marzipanmerci1068 have you seen Dark on netflix? 😂

[@anthonymarshall6868]

There already were time travelers on the Titanic. If you don't know, Brian and Stewie Griffin decided to help Chris Griffin get smarter and they eventually got onto the Titanic. Soon, since an officer named Nigel Harpington wouldn't let them on a lifeboat, Chris pushed him off and killed him. And it was disguised as a dream the whole time and Chris thinks the Titanic was called the Gigantic.

[@janimayares8086]

The tragedy of all those people dying because there weren't enough life boats is also the reason why nowadays everything is super prepared and organized in case of emergency.

[@discordsmorgan2023]

*The people who made those mistakes in the script/costuming:* Write that down, write that down!

[@fikrijuanda6321]

Would be great adaptation for Titanic 2

[@name.255]

the Williamson turn was discoverd in 1943, soooooo...... shut up mat

[@bxdanny]

@@name.255 The Williamson turn was NAMED for someone who used it in 1943. But it was used before that, just wasn't called that. Wikipedia says it was used in the Russo-Japanese war of 1904-05.

[@will-oftheconvictionsforge]

@@bxdanny Thank ya man! ^_^

[@Cesus11]

scriptwriter: didn't study carefully the timeline of stuffs said in the movie Film Theory: *time travel*

[@veryhot2382]

OHohhhhh kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIS2d5qNoamVgLc

[@bradek2792]

Yeah I thought of that right away

[@GayAnnabeth]

what I see this as an absolute win