PROMETHEUS | How to Fail at ALIEN | EXPLORED

[@iceheart1289]

When this movie came out, I didn't know it was an Alien movie, and I wish I still didn't know...

[@tyskbulle]

Yeah, I was like. That alien ship is total rip off. Then at the end I was like, oh it is a Aliens movie...

[@amaurys93]

As someone who didn’t see Alien or Predator in their hay day, can you explain why something like this movie does the Story canon a disservice?

[@steel749]

@@amaurys93 the movie itself doesn't exactly do a disservice to the series but the sequel it produced is pretty bad and ruins the mythos of the Xenomorph. Theres no mystery to the Xenomorph anymore. Its degraded to a Androids school project. But that's just my opinion. I know some people like the prequel series

[@Ecw_Kevin_Torres]

Same here

[@gobbleswells2883]

Y'all are partially the reason Ridley went this route with the Covenant sequel, as many fans were asking Ridley to go back to the original Alien story about Xenomorphs and the feel of hopelessness coupled w fear of the unknown..

[@pyrrhicvictory5844]

Despite the flaws of this film, I was actually excited about what Shaw was going to find on her journey to the Engineer's homeworld. But then Covenant comes out and....Shaw is just a lifeless husk on a table

[@MrDreadEnd]

yeah that was really disappointing for me as well like wow

[@waywardson911]

The female lead in covenant was so damn bland that I don’t even remember her name. Shaw deserved a better ending and did Hicks and Newt

[@wolf2497]

*the movie was just a lifeless husk

[@demartin975]

Exactly. They caved to the fanboys demanding Xenomorphs. Yes, Prometheus had stupid character decisions but Covenant was the big misstep here.

[@greenkoopa]

@@wolf2497 I loved the whole sequence when david dropped the goo. It was fantastic visually. If the movie had just been about that, that would've been cool. Like...he didnt kill Shaw?...and her goal is to stop mad scientist android

[@iHaveTheDocuments]

Michael Fassbender is often the highlight of movies he's in. Also removing their helmets will forever be made fun of when ppl talk about this movie.

[@DevilGiga]

That and the Prometheus' School of running away from things

[@AuDHDarling]

In one of the terrible X-Men movies (Apocalypse, I think), I vividly remember Fassbender's Magneto being forced to kill again to protect his family after going into hiding and trying to live a human life. On his knees in the forest, he looks up at the sky and screams, "IS THIS WHO I AM?" Then, softly, "This is who I am." I repeat it to myself so often in random everyday contexts.

[@Geronimo_Jehoshaphat]

@@DevilGiga "SERPENTINE CHARLIZE! SERPENTINE!" 😆

[@LifesGuardian]

I prefer the guy who literally maps the entire complex getting lost in the complex he just mapped. Lol

[@gobbleswells2883]

@@LifesGuardian 🤣😭🤣

[@CitizenZero1]

Even though it didn’t make much sense, the emergency c-section was the coolest part of the movie.

[@filmcomicsexplained]

Props to Shaw! She was an interesting protagonist. I cant believe what they did to her in the next film... :(

[@silasclayton7777]

@@filmcomicsexplained I still haven't seen it. Can I just keep it that way and pretend it doesn't exist?

[@Vhlathanosh]

@@silasclayton7777 nope! You have to watch it.

[@codyt821]

@@silasclayton7777 covenant actually has some really good old school xenomorph feels. It's like half Prometheus half Alien. I like it better than Prometheus, despite what they did to Shaws character

[@alt0799]

Why didn't it make sense?

[@OfficialAndies]

"Doctor, are you sure this tumor will go away?" "It's what I choose to believe"

[@logicplague]

Rapidly coming to that.

[@bobcharlie2337]

Good one.

[@shane3478]

While I can agree with what you're making light of, there is no denying that some people with a positive attitude do get better. You can ask just about any doctor about anyone going into some medical situation while being super depressed, are likely going to have complications or negative outcomes as opposed to somebody going in with a cheerful positive attitude. They've done lots of study on that and it does make a big difference

[@EnsoTB]

Many doctors, scientists and physicians believe in religions, so I didn’t find that response in the film particularly jarring 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@tangoyango8995]

@Izzzy Snow or it is ridley way of making fun of scientist.

[@bitters879]

"Nobody puts Baby in a corner, but sometimes it's appropriate to put Baby in the pod." xD

[@pigmentrich224]

What?

[@PopeyeBjj86]

No body puts baby in a corner but they do leave her in a Portuguese hotel room unsupervised

[@planbrent]

What a beautiful line lmao 😂

[@cfg908]

Said in his serious tone! lol. I died! Ha

[@oldleatherhandsfriends4053]

The humor is a+

[@robby7499]

What pissed me off was that virtually all of the mysteries in Prometheus like why the Engineers wanted to kill humanity (unless you believe the Space Jesus theory) ultimately amounted to nothing because Alien: Covenant pretty much threw that out the window.

[@tonyabrookes9931]

After I saw Prometheus, I couldn't wait for Covenant to come out to get answers. Then, well, like you said, we got almost nothing. I can't believe they put such little consideration into audience anticipation

[@antagonizerr]

Ask any artist why they trash their own painting and paint over it, or why a sculptor would destroy their own sculpture...because sometimes the things we make don't live up to our visions and expectations. As an artist, I completely understand this.

[@NostalgiNorden]

That's why we don't watch Covenant. Covenant was made for all the people who complained about Prometheus not being just another Alien movie.

[@TheSolDrake]

It doesn't though. The Engineer home world never shows up, as they look less like Engineers and more like humans.

[@markphaul3291]

@Izzzy Snow this type of opinion was the reason why alien covenant was so shit. We want a true sequel to prometheus!

[@paulh2468]

Scott lost sight of what is required in a horror film, and ended up making a tragedy, in every sense of the word. A tragedy with more plot holes than plot. He wanted to have Ripley's head ripped off by the xenomorph in the original Alien, but was stopped by the studio. Looks like he did not learn that lesson when he killed off Shaw. He's made some of the best films ever, but it looks like he's lost his touch.

[@Dravianpn02]

Its been lost since he chose to do Robin Hood.

[@grapeshot]

I do like the part when the captain and his crew go out like soldiers. Like when a guy said if you think the bets off you have another thing coming, the other crew member says you can pay me on the other side.

[@dongately2817]

This movie had so much potential, and that potential was squandered. Its still a beautiful looking, well acted film, but it could have truly been great.

[@zacharyberridge7239]

@@dongately2817 I've always considered it to be a beautiful mess. You are absolutely right.

[@rundome8233]

We can say that it was destroyed by the ALIENS fans.

[@Dravianpn02]

@@rundome8233 I hear that over and over and I don't buy it. Companies blame fans now for crappy reception even though it was their own fault. It's been happening like crazy. Has there been any proof that it was fans that did this besides them saying they did?

[@michaelhowell2326]

I think I might be broken. This is another movie that catches so much hell that I just love.

[@logicplague]

Taste is relative, nothing wrong with it.

[@rmcowdery]

People are looking at it wrong. Its an alien movie therefore the protagonist is a Riply analog. Nope, the real protagonist is David. The creation who met his creators as his creators met their own creators. All the other characters look stupid because that's how David sees them.

[@grimmywizard]

Me too. This movie had so much potential tho.

[@tylerbrenard9584]

This is the clearest and well thought through exploration of what went wrong (and what went right) with Prometheus. Thank you for making explicit much of what I was feeling about this film, but couldn’t quite get out in words myself.

[@All-Fur-Coat_No-Trousers]

Oh my sweet movie Jesus, THE HELMETS! And "It's what I choose to believe". I'm betting that coaxed an audible groan in the theater

[@adamnixon2886]

I'm enjoying this evisceration. My favorite part of this moving and one that follows is the character David and how well he's played

[@relighg]

I actually like the film. The production design was impeccable. Yes the characters made some poor choices but it was definitely much better than alien covenant.

[@MrStubbs86]

How can you say that…. They suffer from the same exact problems. It’s the same shit film just one has xeno sprinkles

[@Ecselsiour]

@@MrStubbs86 Some people get off from eating shit.

[@Dravianpn02]

Bait and switch. Make a shit movie, make a worse movie that makes the shit movie look better and keep doing that because people will keep consuming shit.

[@braxxian]

Agreed. It still remains a favourite of mine. However the absurd actions of many of the characters is hard to overlook.

[@icemav5740]

Prometheus is just as stupid as Covenant

[@thisismybassgun]

This movie really does feel like it was written day by day, with rewrites at lunch.

[@liquidrufus]

Damin Lindelof was the writer of tge script. See Lost for example b of his method of miving a plot along.

[@matxalenc8410]

Is that bad? Writing does take time.

[@thisismybassgun]

@@matxalenc8410 Not bad, but the unfocused nature of the work unfortunately shows what happens when you can't just settle on an idea. Or at least, that's how it feels watching it to me.

[@HonorThyTarkus]

I appreciate your in depth look into so many facets of mistakes but also, SUCCESSES of particular movies and franchises.

[@SkyFree2091]

I love this film! It gave the world the “Prometheus school of running away from things”!

[@tambow13]

You're confused how squid baby grew to such a size although we see the xenomorph grow without any food source as well.

[@Pwnulolumad]

came here to type this same comment..

[@BullScrapPracEff]

It's covered in one of the books. How the xeno is essentially 'dehydrated' at birth and a crystalline structure that can 'unfold.'

[@tambow13]

@@BullScrapPracEff that's fair, they could probably explain this one too in time, won't be the same of course.

[@connorbranscombe6819]

@@BullScrapPracEff That’s called a retcon buddy, and it makes absolutely no scientific sense. But sure whatever fuels your Prometheus hate boner.

[@JoakimKanon]

”Protected by plot armor” Wow. 🔥😂👌🏼

[@BlackHawk2901]

I thought the concept of exploring our creators and the creators of life, as well as the reasoning behind it as well as many historical events such as the creation of the pyramids, etc was extremely cool

[@Skynet_Scans_It]

I'd like to know how the 2 guys got lost in the ship when one of them had just made a map of it

[@LifesGuardian]

It's really a simple reason. The script said so. I'd like to think there was a reason why that happened, maybe the map eas destroyed or because dude was high and couldn't read the map. Sadly, neither was true and it was done to eliminate characters and introduce a zombie.

[@gp2917]

Maybe the data transmitted directly to the ship. I don’t remember seeing any maps in any of the suits, only the display on the ship

[@LifesGuardian]

@@gp2917 the probes launched from a device that projected a holographic map.

[@red0guy]

@@LifesGuardian Sorry but you are misremembering the movie. The probes were take from the guys backpack two by two and after the they cut to the image forming on the deck. They did not have the map on themselves.

[@NatePilgrim]

In the novelization it's stated that Vickers wanted the expedition to fail, so she hired a bunch of bumbling idiots to be part of the crew. The reason why they act like idiots, it's because they genuinely are.

[@Tyler.Burleson]

The absolute serious tone you had when you said "showing that while nobody puts baby in the corner, sometimes it's appropriate to put baby in the pod" is why I keep coming back

[@shainewhite2781]

I know this film has a mixed reception by fans of the Alien Franchise, I consider it to be a guilty pleasure from visionary filmmaker Ridley Scott.

[@theultimateninja]

I love these movies.

[@MaryAnneRosato]

As do I. Prometheus has problems but is far superior to Covenant. 🤢🤮

[@MarcoMariaRossiArte]

I love it

[@AlexJones-ue1ll]

visionary? Well he does good visuals - but his storytelling sucks. Always has.

[@humanbeing2420]

It’s a guilty pleasure because if you derive pleasure from it you’re guilty as an accessory to multiple crimes against the laws of basic screenwriting.

[@MidnightWanderer]

What's really sad is, I really wanted a follow up on these engineers...that part of the film was what really got my attention.

[@albioncia]

finnaly someone explained about prometheus and its school of running away from things

[@JadedOne420]

**aHeM** Graduates of *_The Prometheus School of Running Away From Things_* ...next year is Alumni- *I EXPECT TO SEE YOU ALL THERE* save for those running away from responsibility

[@xwing2417]

"subverting our expectations by making something worse" yup. that sounds about right.

[@johnrandolph1989]

Honestly I feel like this was the beginning of the end for the ALIEN series, and we'll most likely won't get the third prequel film any time in the distant future.

[@denverbrown1547]

Nah hold faith fam, Disney bought the rights and the marvel produced comics have been promising... movies are in the works

[@DinoDave150]

The beginning of the end was Alien 3.

[@taykitrleevitt4314]

@@DinoDave150 Alien ultimately, is a stalker movie; once we know who the stalker is - the game is up. Aliens was a welcome alternative - but that was essentially IT. I liked Prometheus, because it prolonged the story, and changed the narrative, thus giving the series a fresh impetus...shame they lost their nerve and screwed up.

[@DinoDave150]

@@taykitrleevitt4314 I would have given credit where credit was due if they had just stuck to their guns and made their own thing that just so happens to be set in the Alien universe... But then Covenant came along and completely atom bombed any remaining goodwill people had for this series.

[@ninjasnakeevil9327]

We won’t, Disney is planning on rebooting Alien completely starting with the Hulu show

[@WolfetoneRebel1916]

I actually really like the name Prometheus for the ship and it makes sense to me. Prometheus was known as the greatest friend to mankind and it's likely that in their naivety, this is what they expected to find from 'the invitation'.

[@kikuyuzo2789]

The scene where David finds the navigation room and marvels at the interstellar map only for to unexpectedly turn off leaving him confused and disappointed...that's Prometheus in a nutshell

[@Gelos.]

I was always so intrigued by the lore of this story. Sucks that they couldnt give it a satisfying origin that made sense.

[@iHaveTheDocuments]

With how great Ridley Scott can be, this movie has to make you appreciate the first 2 Alien's. So much can go wrong, yet even more must go right to catch that lightning in the bottle.

[@dingdongs5208]

Ridley used to be great, now hes just a senile old man, Denis Villeneuve kicked him off set of blade runner 2049 due to him endlessly rambling off pointlessly. At least he is still a fantastic cinematographer, prometheus is a beautiful looking film

[@BullScrapPracEff]

I think he has the idea his shit doesn't stink because he used to be something.

[@Nostromo4261]

@@JadedOne420 I named my dog, “Ripley”.

[@daegnaxqelil2733]

Alen 3 wasn't that bad and the fourth was just meh

[@shainewhite2781]

JURASSIC PARK: A Theme Park Gone Wrong.

[@instapowah]

I actually like Prometheus. As a kind of stand alone. I don´t count it to the alien movies though.

[@DeOneandLonely]

I see it as an expanded universe. Xenomorphs exist, and that’s all.

[@camf33]

He still destroyed the mystery of the space jockeys.

[@johnbrooderpt9374]

Damn, as a stand alone piece I really didn't mind this movie.

[@HeatherHolt]

Now the mother of an unwanted child Omg I died 😅😅

[@PhantomHalf]

Ah yes the founding of the prometheus school of running away.

[@rosswebster7877]

When I first saw Prometheus in theaters, my reaction was the same as Krusty the Clown’s when he saw the “Worker and Parasite” cartoon.

[@fahada.979]

This video has one of the most poetic ending ive ever witnessed on youtube, amazing work!

[@xclavex]

That squid baby thing's only purpose was to provide plot protection for Shaw because the only thing it did was kill the Engineer. Without squid baby, the Engineer would have ripped Shaw to pieces as he did with the others.

[@mysteryminx2619]

This review is great. I swear I did not leave this film as any kind of "Prometheus" fan, but I've seen the thing at least five times. Ridley is hit and miss for me, but when I check out of the story and the characters, EVERY TIME, there is an absolutely beautiful set, design elements and cinematography to look at. I am fascinated with the look and design of the Engineers. Part of the story with David endlessly watching and modeling his look on "Lawrence" was that Ridley had wanted to cast Peter O'Toole as Weyland, but he was too ill to take the role. And this: THANK YOU for your comments regarding Shaw's "Emergency C-Section" (which it can't perform, for your stated reasons, and yet is equipped with obstetrical forceps.) I have HAD this surgery due to tumors and some cancer that decided to also move in. (This year I am a 20 year survivor). And I sent up the "I CALL NO WAY!" flare when we hit this scene, I assure you neither Ridley NOR John Spaihts (whose work I often enjoy) and then came Damon Lindelof (whose heavy-handed fingerprints are all OVER this film, I loathe his writing, and thereby I will hazard a guess that the change was in his rewrite) ... have NEVER met a woman who has just received a Total Abdominal Hysterectomy and is still in the Post Surgical Recovery Phase. I do not care how advanced medical procedures have advanced, or the existence of state of the art ("Don't touch that!") surgical pods are in the latter part of this century. Human anatomy HAS NOT CHANGED and this ENTIRE film is about "Who ARE our makers" and "Who Watches The Watchmen". It is about the DISCOVERY of HUMAN design and the exploration of Intelligent Design. This particular surgery, involves an abdominal incision which is either vertical or horizontal. Muscles, ligaments and blood vessels are all detached from the (trying to not be too graphic or offensive here) as 'organ in question' is completely removed, this ALSO involves an internal procedure that a surgical pod calibrated "only for men" (booo) would not have been possible to perform as it requires a reconstruction procedure, closed with precision and internal sutures. I ASSURE you, no upper grade pain killers could get you LITERALLY up and running, the fact that the incision is closed with staples, etc. proves that abdominal human anatomy and its surgical area has NOT changed by the 2090s. You are not going to just 'hop right up' after that last staple, and with a new gash in your lower abdomen you have severed nerves which take over a year to reconnect, and yes you are convinced that the first time you stand, your guts will spill onto the floor. There is NO running, there is no BENDING, there is no COMPRESSION of this incision and NO a jack tight EVA suit is not going to fix it. Recovery from this surgery is commonly six to eight weeks. It's true. Ten days after, I was able to make short trips, but a walk through a store rapidly involved a 15 minute sit, in order to stand again and leave. Three weeks in, I could not walk a regular city block. You learn to sleep near sources of entertainment and have a small cooler with some 'drinks and snackies'. You are NOT going to be outrunning a rolling spacecraft, fighting off Engineers, or packing up and lowering David to head off to Planet 4. But for some weird reason, largely the beautiful design of the Engineers, Idris Elba (always fun to stare at), Iceland, and the nod to root languages by way of Proto-Indian-European (and yeah, you nailed that too) simply fascinate me. "Derelict" a fan edit of "Prometheus" combined to "Alien", color dropped to black and white and runs at three hours, is superb, the overlap when they wake the Engineers was spectacular. Find it if you can. I remain the Girl Who Loves Horror and Monsters, I love this franchise because since its introduction it has always been a closely written honor of women. What we will do when we fight. When we take command. And when our worst opponent is another female who is just as determined to defend her offspring as Ellen Ripley is to save Newt and redeem her broken promises to her lost daughter. "Alien" and its successors have always been about how deadly the female of the species can be, and I've watched the dawning expression of several "Alien/Xenomorph" fans when presented with this reality. It's the ultimate Chick Flick. Having said that, I really want a version of "Covenent" that includes Mark Watney (who could absolutely tell you why wheat is growing on 'Swing By For Repairs Planet on Way to Origae-6") and Rick Martinez running and screaming like little girls at "WHAT ARE THOSE THINGS?!" Which they consistently kill completely by accident, especially when fleeing full bore in the rover. I would never NOT watch this and stand up and cheer for the first inadvertent Alien comedy utterly comprised by the horrified escape attempts of Watney and Martinez. Honestly, I would love it. Your break down and your story holes are valid and your review is great. I really enjoyed it. Thanks for singling out the absurdity of the Surgical Pod.

[@Incaeduus]

Loved this video. FCE is really intelligent, it's nice to hear him bring out these logical points.

[@SirToaster9330]

Jurassic World: How to succeed in Rise of Skywalker

[@AuDHDarling]

How To Make Jurassic Worlds and Influence Skywalkers

[@SirToaster9330]

@@AuDHDarling yes

[@imalloutagum6083]

You do a great job discussing the issues with Prometheus, putting a concise voice to it instead of the endless conjecture out there. As a long time fan of your channel, it's clear that you have a great appreciation for the Alien films. Its release promised a revival that included the original master, Ridley Scott himself. But it ultimately did little to update and add to the franchise except for spawning questions and its more disappointing sequel. It did however give us a fantastic performance by Michael Fassbender, which makes it worth watching if you are a fan of his. Thank you for making such an in depth exploration.

[@filmcomicsexplained]

Thanks for watching Brett!

[@guydavies1342]

So when Ridley Scott said Prometheus had the DNA of Alien I guess what he really meant is that they just decided to reuse Giger's designs. Then they brought out that trailer edited to be like the original Alien trailer with the same sound effects. This film was just a complete blue balls experience.

[@blakedabner9338]

"The vessel he uses is riddled with hiles and operated by idiots " Absof*ckinlutely brilliant line!!!!!

[@Fiorwestcoast]

A++++ Ridley single handedly betrayed ALIEN. And it is such an incredible let down.

[@The_Slow_Z]

Well now I’m waiting for Covenant explored video! ASAP

[@HEYMANFOODREVIEWS]

This is the most savage I have ever seen Neyat and I love it. This is the classiest roast I have ever seen 😂

[@Ghostmite98]

A Great opening for how prometheus retconned a lot of shit in the franchise, keep up the great work man.

[@Edward-6909]

Ikr found it humorous😄👍still love all the films.

[@gryphonlaw2138]

They didnt retcon shit. They simply showed it. Man was created by the beings, shit got funky and spread to others. Aliens

[@Ghostmite98]

@@gryphonlaw2138 I won't lie and say I've seen every movie so I won't argue small details like how the Beings created man because your right about that and how shit got funky and boom aliens happened but let's be honest it took the director of the movie to confirm that the movie took place in the aliens universe and was a prequel at that. I mean come on, if the movie couldn't do a well enough job to convey that it was an aliens movie then you done messed up when you have to have an outside source tell you otherwise.

[@gryphonlaw2138]

@@Ghostmite98 yeah I agree, unfortunately it goes over most people's heads. I blatantly got it the first time I started watching it, with what scott was doing. Yet I agree wish it wasn't too broad for some people to understand. Still I enjoyed it. Take care guys and wish the best, till the the next....

[@icemav5740]

@@gryphonlaw2138 the problem is that the idea that David created the xenomorphs completely ruins the entire franchise. They fucking aliens, why do they have to be made by androids

[@theultimateninja]

People were so mad when they didn't understand the intro haha.

[@Geronimo_Jehoshaphat]

Oh I got it. It was just fucking stupid.

[@wunderwurst9031]

I liked the scene where they woke up from kyrosleep after what, years? Of travel to be informed what their mission is. I mean, who tf would go on a mission like that without knowing where they are heading/what they're about to do? Who would volunteer for that?

[@red0guy]

Greedy idiots?

[@wunderwurst9031]

@@red0guy at least that would explain their behaviour throughout the movie

[@humanbeing2420]

I liked the way the crew is briefed on the basic facts of their mission halfway into it rather than in advance. This prevents them from deciding beforehand whether they are well-suited for the mission or if they agree with its basic goals and premises. It also means they can’t prepare for it mentally or otherwise. This may partially explain why so many of the characters behave like brain-dead zombies with less emotional control than most severely autistic pre-teens. It’s such brilliant screenwriting.

[@alexischavez3238]

Not really, what was the reason for them being briefed half way into the job in story, none other than the writers needed the characters to be caught off guard

[@humanbeing2420]

@@alexischavez3238 I was being sarcastic.

[@alexischavez3238]

@@humanbeing2420 so you typed out a whole page to be sarcastic, ok

[@humanbeing2420]

@@alexischavez3238 Why would I lie about this? Look - trust me, I hate Prometheus, because its so poorly written. I previously posted at least one other separate comment denigrating it. If I truly liked the film, then I'd just defend it, not lie about my opinion. The sarcasm in my post seems pretty obvious to me - look at my description of the characters as brain-dead zombies with no emotional control - that describes a bad movie, not a good one.

[@Africanhotdogchild93]

I honestly believe this movie should have been a show. I think it would have done better having more time to find out what direction it would go.

[@harrisondejoux8520]

As you pointed out, the crew of the Nostromo were a little stupid but human when they wanted to break quarantine with Kane, but Ellen overrode them and maintained it until Ash overrides her and let's them onboard. Not for a stupid reason either, but because that was his mission.

[@glenakatsr]

I just realised, do you think David wanted Elizabeth to go back to Earth all along near the end, I can't help but think he wanted to drop the payload on Earth himself instead but was forced to do it on the other planet in Covenant?

[@Simplechioces]

Aliens is such a awesome movie. I still watch it annually. They should just forget about these movies and remake the old ones beat for beat.

[@SubjectDeath00]

This became one of my top ten favorite movies of all time.

[@post-apocalypticchocolate8416]

That "alien snake penis" comment made me spit up my raisin bran all over🤣thanks man I needed that in my life.

[@fgstech4857]

What always struck me as odd was Peter Wayland was seeking knowledge from the creators, but he created David a near life-like human. He was chasing the wrong vision. To me the story would have been more interesting with Peter the Creator and David the Android. Because the mini promotional clips for the film was better than the film, lol. Nice video Sir.

[@dionisossolon2335]

The beggining was so accurate. I actually replayed it a few times and veryfied it's so true!!!

[@fayis4everlove]

I haven't seen any Aliens film before but Prometheus was fun even with its unbelievable scifi takes.

[@Nugatron50000]

My main gripe with the movie is that none of the characters are likeable.

[@whybro3516]

i swear Noomi Rapace is one of the most gorgeous of all creations... she is so uniquely beautiful

[@davidannett3322]

wicked hot in Dragon Tattoo

[@bullseye6969]

Nahh, u just like her all the time smirking face.

[@raytan956]

naming the ship prometheus is the equivalent of sunshine's icarus

[@milantak8113]

It’s embarrassing how much potential Prometheus sequels had and what happened to it. I hope Disney realizes this and not redcon it to “legend” status 🙏🏻

[@GodlikeIridium]

7:30 "An alien snake penis" i died 😂👌

[@Jeanine.mp4]

I actually really enjoyed Shaw and was excited to see her character in the next installment but when they killed her off, re-started with other characters and barely gave them any depth, i was so disappointed.

[@xxvaltielxx1789]

Thank you for that intro man, my ribs hurt xD If only they could at least give us the Earth War as an Aliens sequel, to hell with Alien 3, thaat could be 3 full movies at least

[@yungloge7703]

I love this movie so much and I don’t think I’ve ever been more disappointed by a sequel than I was with Alien: Covenant. 😢

[@gryphonlaw2138]

You know, I actually liked this film to wrap up some questions. But some hate it. I understood it but loved hearing your take. Thank you for the great video 👍

[@lewis18051]

I really liked Prometheus and I think reacting to the criticism made them changed Covenant, which is a shame I really want more of the Engineers

[@gerythionargarys7848]

Prometheus, languishing on the rock, "I should have seen that coming."

[@CanineLupus0114]

"they went on voyage to try to meet their maker" Haha Good one

[@RedVelvetUnderground333]

Failed as alien, succeeded as Prometheus, alien covenant failed at both

[@guy1nguy2]

Hold up, hold up, hold up. See, what we're not gonna do is shit on the third best Alien film.

[@charliedango2664]

I never noticed it before, but why do their space helmets breaking sound like glass shattering? They can't possibly expect anyone to believe those helmets are glass.

[@LeolaGlamour]

On a side note I'd be very pissed if I spent years loving a series of films about an alien only to be disappointed to know its not truly an alien but some man made thing by a man made thing.

[@KingCuba]

The ending of this video blew my mind. Awesome video again man

[@twstf8905]

🎵 If you can't be with the one you love, honey, love the one you're with 🎶

[@logicplague]

Kind of like wanting another Alien movie but getting this instead.

[@MsSwitchblade13]

The intro of this video made me think I was watching a Filmento video. I'm subscribed to you both.

[@driznardelunyar5199]

always enjoy your perspective. maybe one day we'll get a worthy Alien film, one that is focused on the fan's experience, rather than ego or film executive ignorance.

[@ExarAnubis]

I love how people get pissed and say this is a horrible Alien movie, It's funny cause this isn't an Alien movie, Scott told everybody before the movie came out he wasn't making an Alien movie, he said it took place in the Alien universe but it wasn't about the Xenomorphs, it's like saying Man Of Steel was a horrible Wonder Woman movie

[@dvxAznxvb]

This is why CoVid was allowed to spread as such since some individuals completely refuse to keep their helmets on

[@logicplague]

Except that the helmets were actually protecting them from airborne pathogens. Note they weren't wearing scarves.

[@SwayzieMayne]

Me: Covid is real Covidiot: no it’s not Me: show me your proof Covidiot: it’s what I choose to believe

[@logicplague]

@@SwayzieMayne yes, it's real, and it is being used as an excuse for a power grab. That's cute btw, "show me your proof", since you know well and good that every time someone tries they are immediately censored and labeled a conspiracy theorist. Silencing critics and telling people to only trust "approved sources of information" is not how science works, it's how a cult works.

[@jeff-hd9og]

@@logicplague he’s was making a joke, use your brain

[@Hydrogenblonde]

This is a excellent analysis of this movie, probably the best.

[@pandemicapocalypse3051]

Basic takeaway: pretty pictures, minimally thought provoking plot, silly characters, only 1 decent actor (Michael Fassbender), supernaturally disappointing mythos integration.

[@woollywoolwoolz]

I swear Ridley Scott was drunk when making Prometheus and Covenant.

[@nickolasbarnes4430]

I was actually very excited to see covenant to see where the story went. Then they killed off the main character before the movie starts

[@nigelcarren]

In all fairness, I love this film for all of the reasons you describe, I don't care if you hate me for doing so! Total madness trapped in a bottle, which is all I look for in a film. Also, it's music and soundscapes are number one on my list. I listen to this film in the workshop like many listen to an album. I don't look for logic in Sci-Fi, because only I come to Sci-Fi to escape it. I have much more to say on the matter, though I will wait until you have all Stopped throwing tomatoes at me before saying. 🍅🍅🤖 Great thought-provoking video mon ami. Best wishes 😉🇬🇧

[@jaredcolon4535]

I consider Prometheus and covenant as an alternate universe to the alien verse

[@TheVictorLoyiso]

I loved the film but I always have an ear for your analysis Niyat! Thanks 👍🏿

[@UATU.]

Loved the intro 😂

[@jordyjords1928]

I wasn’t even looking at the screen when you said “characters do really dumb things” and I immediately thought of the scene you showed 😂😂😂😂😂

[@jameslabbe4119]

Years later and I still obsess over how beautiful Prometheus is. Beautiful, and terrible to behold. That into Niyat is perfect. I feel like Nolan is going the way of Carpenter

[@THE_WAAAAGH]

That beginning Intro had me laughing so HARD

[@h.plovecat4307]

The pilots are the only smart people, ironically they're the only regular Joe's in the whole film.

[@the_once-and-future_king.]

Ah yes, the Prometheus School of Running Away From Things!

[@shane3478]

I enjoyed both movies. I'm a very Avid aliens fan, and just because it had plotholes didn't mean that it wasn't entertaining. I like to use this lyric from one of my favorite TV shows for when I go and see movies. "If you're wondering how he eats and breathes And other science facts Then repeat to yourself "It's just a show I should really just relax"

[@THEchiQ]

This could have been such a fabulous film. Great break-down, Niyat!

[@WolfetoneRebel1916]

Such a beautiful mess. I have to admit that I do really enjoy watching it. It's such a missed opportunity because with a few small changes to to fix plot holes and and dumb character decisions, it could have been a masterpiece and the perfect launching point for another Alien Trilogy.

[@sarajohnson6855]

That opening sequence gave me life 😂🧬🤣🧬😅🧬😂 Thanks Niyat