Finally, horses are good.

[@TotalThomasMan]

I love the idea of being able to upgrade horse stats without the hours and hours and hours of breeding that are normally required!

[@KCGamingBuddies]

ark players be like

[@mechanical_squid4047]

The problem is the rng, if the new horse only took the best of both parents it would be way better

[@ender0998]

​@@mechanical_squid4047didn't they change it recently where the better stats r preferred a lot more?

[@mechanical_squid4047]

@@ender0998 maybe but its still random, and you still might get a worse horse overall

[@skaareen]

@@KCGamingBuddiesfr bro

[@crawley652]

i cant wait for them to add horses in vanilla

[@layncemc]

That would be so cool, I wish horses were real

[@yeasarmahmud9071]

@@layncemcHorses aren’t real 😰? My life was a lie!

[@freemanc6258]

Guys horses are already in-game😂

[@moobley_269]

@@freemanc6258No way!

[@hvbg]

​Looks like someone didn't get the joke @@freemanc6258

[@AbigailPinehaven]

The horse girls were summoned to this video

[@aurered6387]

Well it worked but i hoped that he will mention and star worm equestrian mod who is best horse mod ever xD also they back to work with mod and probably won't die soon xD

[@Nick-em3kq]

I really appreciate you finding these smaller, useful, vanilla+ style mods! I'd gotten really tired of searching for mods and seeing the same 50 rehashed hundreds of times

[@layncemc]

I have a feeling you’ll like the next video I’m making then! I decided I’d rather fail my challenge right off the bat than force myself to make something lower quality, so it should be out in a day or two, but it’s all about mods I feel blend really well with the base game!

[@ModernSundew]

@@layncemc haha I was wondering about what happened to the challenge, keep doing what you think is best! Your videos are always fun to watch

[@Penny-16]

I’m loving the humour you’re putting in. I can feel the fun you’re having. That’s very attractive to viewers. AND your sub count has grown a heap lately. You so deserve it.

[@layncemc]

Thank you! One of the nice things about having ADHD for me is, ideas will come to me often. Which includes jokes, camera angles, and edits, while recording. It can be really helpful at times!

[@goldendragon_rs2996]

One of my favorite relatively small horse mods is realistic horse genetics. Adds a TON of new skins & even breeds of horses. You can have giant draft horses or small ponies too.

[@kenziem6333]

I highly recommend SWEM as well and they’re continuing to improve and add to the mod

[@avavanpelt926]

Except it's forge only if I remember right and I weep

[@jlewis7221]

1. Unexpectedly good humor. Thank you. 2. Perfect timing for us as we are setting up a new 1.20.1 server. These are all great! thanks

[@lapiswolf2780]

No winnying? That's like removing dog barks.

[@layncemc]

If you still would like to be stopped at random mid ride, every feature can be toggled individually in the config! Although I do think I used the wrong word. The horses still make sound, it’s the giddy-up where the horse stops on its hind legs that it removes

[@jewelofbeauty]

@@layncemc Ah that makes sense now. When they randomly rear up, I find it annoying. But when it first happened a few times, I thought a hostile mob was nearby. Nope. That would be a useful warning feature, though.

[@FlameyClockspeed]

​@@jewelofbeautyIt would be amazing if the jorse would do that if there was a cliff or something

[@5p_nutella]

damn I love how Laynce keeps horsing around (forgive me I saw no horse pun yet and felt a need to change that) still love the video Laynce

[@layncemc]

Saddle up, because I’m gonna stirrup trouble. I’ll shoe you how horse puns are done. Only a few though, so my voice doesn’t get hoarse. Fortunately it shouldn’t take much to reign on your parade. Your puns are the appetizer, but mine are the mane course. You’d be making a mistake sleeping on these puns. Probably because it’s pasture bedtime. I wouldn’t be surprised if I don’t get a reply, because you’re too busy stalling and worrying about getting second place in this competition. I will win this race, completing my foal of destroying you. I’m like a rocket ship, traveling at a million horsepower. You’re just mad you’re not the centaur of attention. *mic drop* 😎

[@5p_nutella]

@@layncemc nooooo he mic dropped me I shall never recover

[@Cherno35]

All of these should be in the game.

[@notakzz]

As a medieval knight I approve

[@snakemaster254]

You actually used to be able to do the crossing water thing with camels on bedrock, I always thought it was intentional so I was devastated when I found out it got removed as that was the only relevant feature Camels had over horses as it allowed you to cross large distances at a slightly slower pace, but without having to either build a bridge or drag your horse across every river. Now camels are just unique less useful horses that only have the fact they protect you from zombies, and can step up 1.5 blocks, although horses can jump 4 blocks and can outrun every aggressive mob to protect you, rather than only protecting from melee.

[@layncemc]

I would absolutely love to see that feature be reintroduced to camels. I would use them all the time if I could hold two players AND swim

[@TrayusStudios]

I'm really, REALLY looking fowards to the week of Mod Reviews! Keep up the great work, you managed to become one of my top three most favourite KZbinrs in just under a month already.

[@layncemc]

That means a lot Trayus, thank you!

[@loraxenclave9426]

Would enjoy seeing the horseshoes (and all of these tbh) in vanilla someday! Especially with new enchants! Like water walking!

[@jewelofbeauty]

Frostwalker for horses!!! For real. XD

[@rebekahredford2]

Another mod you should really check out is Star Worm Equestrian Mod. Horses look more realistic, realistic feeding and drinking, realistic tack, and colorful accessories

[@romannumeralvii4285]

0:20 EXCUSE ME!? DID YOU JUST BLINK!?

[@layncemc]

Maybe…

[@zaferbincan3209]

@@layncemc can u tell me what mod it is? animatica maybe?

[@Shywizz]

@zaferbincan3209 Entity Texture Features Player Skin "Encoding" For the modded version, which i suppose is what @layncemc is using, else you have godlanders v++ player skin coreShader If you need more info ask me or the internet

[@Shywizz]

and yes he just did

[@layncemc]

@@zaferbincan3209 Entity texture features!

[@jesusvargas5963]

Fresh animations make the horse galloping more fluid and nice to see. This combined with better third person makes going on long adventure by horse my preferred way of travel

[@layncemc]

I love fresh animations but sadly could not use it with dyed. The armor change makes them incompatible

[@JelliinaCup]

OMG this couldn't have come at a better time! Thank you! _My Stardew Valley themed pack will be legendary!!_

[@layncemc]

That sounds awesome! I’m glad I could help. Good luck!

[@GoldBean2752]

I would like that pack when you are done with it.

[@MothsWing]

One of the best horse mods out rn is SWEM!! I HIGHLY suggest it, more so for irl equestrians since it adds so much.

[@shatteredvessel265]

Id love to see a mod that adds some kind of charging mechanic that could dismount players/mobs riding lower stat horses or stun them, but also deal more damage based on how fast your going, like a lance. Itd also be cool to see illagers using horses, it doesnt really make sense that a raider type mob wouldnt use horses even if they have ravagers.

[@layncemc]

I like that idea a lot! I think that'd be a much more strategic for horse based combat

[@appletree13]

Ohhh I love the horse whistle mod! Def going to be adding these, though it'll take awhile because I'm stuck on an island lol.

[@PanicBeanWolfie]

these mods are BEAUTIFUL... for vanilla horses! SWEM is a fully blown horse mod for all the horse girls, ect! it truly is beautiful

[@layncemc]

one of my friends actually introduced to the mod after posting this video! I don't think it fits with the vanilla plus vibe I was going for with these mods, but I love what it adds! in a horse themed pack, i could see that being an absolute ton of fun

[@sonya_sonya_]

THAAAAAANK YOU! THANK YOU!

[@chaseaguayo7465]

For anyone looking for better looking horses I think fresh animations adds the best looking animations for both the horse and other mobs. Might have trouble with horse buff because of possible model changes messing with the see through horse thing but I haven’t tried it myself so I’m not certain either way I’d say it’s worth it tho

[@layncemc]

Fresh animations is absolutely fantastic and I use it all the time, but yes, the model does glitch out with Dyed. Perhaps one day there’ll be some compatibility with it!

[@PalmDEV]

Another banger! Thanks for fixing horses, they needed it!

[@LeonSBU]

dude, this video is insanely well done - nice job!!

[@layncemc]

Thanks a ton Leon! ☺️

[@GoldBean2752]

I would love to use horses, just for riding around a little bit and roleplaying.

[@WillFordStudios]

KILLER thumbnail! Your editing style is also very satisfying. Great video, keep it up!

[@mdtrxtrr]

Add "Horse Combat Controls" in their so horses will ride like a boat and you can actually fight with them.

[@voidconcept1269]

Yeah the horses not being able to swim was always really annoying to me. Horses can swim with someone on their back, red dead redemption and irl proves that.

[@Eggmayor]

Lennaaaaaayyyy

[@CodeF53]

As the developer of horsebuff. I'm happy to finally see it getting some attention

[@layncemc]

Horsebuff has been a godsend in my worlds. It makes traveling by horseback actually viable. Thank you for your incredible addition to this game

[@WarDog0123]

would be nice if they made it so if you race on a horse and hit a player, that player will get twice the damage from charge bonus. They also need to add in lances and make combat on horses more fun.

[@Kita-calico_]

Thank you so much! I loved some mods you showed

[@SeanStClair-cr9jl]

These actually look wonderful, great mod.

[@joseluischavez-grimaldo6532]

You know a great idea would be using goat horns as a replacement for the whistle probably and could and should summon pets but other then that I love the ideas and mods shown

[@layncemc]

That is actually a superb idea. I would use that all the time if someone made that mod

[@michaelo4476]

i'm actually working on datapack/mod for that! don't have a lot of free time for it at the moment though :/

[@maerapista6106]

the word subscribe glows when he said it in the video, its so cool

[@BreloomsGarden]

Just found you and I think your personality is so nice! Subbed :D

[@sandwichqueen]

Minecraft should make it to where horses take up all the space in a boat, but you can lead boats together. Making lead pathfinding better is overall a good idea.

[@layncemc]

Linking boats together with chests would be so good. There is a mod called horseboat that I would have included in this video, if it were available for the right version. That one allows horses to sit upright in the back of the boat. Even that change alone fundamentally upgrades steed!

[@stanislavmachulskii7061]

damn this guy really likes horses

[@astermelody]

HORSES AREN’T REAL

[@marcistical]

they are tho

[@TahaMedyaTV]

true they are made by the goverment!

[@DELTARUNEFAN1997]

THATS JUST MORE LIES!!!!!

[@bensonjarvis5025]

I’m not sure if you joking or you’re serious

[@TahaMedyaTV]

The goverment lied to us yet agaiaaaiiin!1!1

[@feelinweakness]

this is literally the most useful video for mods in my recommendations that I have ever found you deserve a like!😮🎉

[@layncemc]

Thank you very much! 😁

[@halfdecent5852]

can’t wait for this week!! don’t pressure yourself into a vid every day tho. we can wait 😊

[@Jinxedghost_exe]

Theres a mod by flashfyre that adds a lot of enchantments and it adds 3 for saddles, Quickness makes the horse faster, leaping makes it jump higher, and buoyancy alloows it to float

[@Beefsag]

I found a mod that lets horses swim, which is a feature mojang should add because horses CAN actually swim, but they just aren't that fast in the mod

[@WatermelonDog512]

Basically Breath Of The Wild horses in Minecraft

[@Sharkbrothers]

It is so crazy how well you edit these videos. You inspire me so often for new video ideas of my own. The fact that you wanna upload a video every single day of the week is just mind blowing for how much effort you put into them. Just wanted to say, I am a really big fan, love ur vids, don’t burn out and have a good day ❤️❤️❤️

[@layncemc]

I really appreciate that thank you! I have no idea if I’ll be able to follow through with my own challenge. I’ve technically already failed since I posted this on Wednesday, not Tuesday, but I’m gonna pretend like that’s what I meant to do and just push it back XD This video specifically didn’t take too long to make. The most time consuming part was re-recording lines after messing them up repeatedly. The recording itself was an hour and a half, for this very short video…

[@Sharkbrothers]

Crazy! That’s pretty good for a video this great. I actually wanted to ask you something: I like your editing style so much, that I want to intigrate some of your’s into mine on my KZbin Channel. Of course I won’t flat out copy you but rather have that whimsical feeling when watching your videos. I am asking you this so you won’t think of me as a copycat. I will still have my own style with a little bit of Layance in it (also sorry, probably misspelled ur name XD). If you don’t want me to do that, it is completely fine. Have a great rest of your day!

[@layncemc]

@@Sharkbrothers I've always been an advocate for personal uniqueness. Just be yourself! You're not copying me by being silly or whimsical. It only becomes a problem to me when someone is flat out stealing from someone. Borrowing an idea and making it something new is totally okay. So yes; be silly. Be you!

[@Sharkbrothers]

Ok thank you!

[@OneCokeAndDrink]

One change to horses I really wish for, is for them to have 'weight' to their charges. Maybe give them a limited sprint option that makes them go quicker (perhaps requires a second or two of normal running before you can charge), but if you run into a mob or player it stops the charge and deals damage to the target, very similar to a ravager's headbutt. I want to have effective cavalry charges in minecraft!

[@The_Primitive]

yes yes yes yes YES YES *YES*

[@llll-lk2mm]

good luck on the video challenge!

[@layncemc]

Thank you! I’ll do my best!

[@JoWackk]

If Mojang added most of these features to Vanilla I would never ask them to add anything again. Maybe enchantments like feather falling on horse armor too. It's been a decade since the horse update and we need some horse buffs to catch up to modern Minecraft!

[@geokou7645]

BRINGING BACK THE GLORIOUS MONGOL EMPIRE WITH THIS ONE (No mod to let you look around?)

[@layncemc]

I couldn’t find one for the version unfortunately. It is totally possible I am just blind, but that one I was specifically looking for and couldn’t not see

[@geokou7645]

@@layncemc ahh that’s a bummer. Horse archers in Minecraft would be fire. I think I have a new idea for mojang…

[@PixelKat5]

0:21 HE BLINKED!!1!!1!

[@SilverSabertooth]

"Is he in survival or creative mode?" "He's in crevival mode."

[@incy000]

⬆️ Best vanilla+ mods channel on the internet

[@sonawhite8813]

All we actualky need is bedrock mechanics for horse breeding. Where breeding a horse with a speed potion effect makes the potion effect permanent, and stackable on the new child. Leading to ridiculous speeds

[@capitanspoiler7393]

may i suggest the mod "niftycarts"? it adds carriages to horses so you can use them to move materials (supply cart), mobs (animal cart, can move villagers) and make paths/strip logs/till soil underneath (plow)

[@layncemc]

Nifty carts is amazing! That one totally slipped my mind when making this

[@capitanspoiler7393]

@@layncemc and if mojang really goes through with their dumb "villager rebalance" that mod will save people SO MUCH TIME when moving villagers to swamps

[@layncemc]

@@capitanspoiler7393 The rebalance does exactly what it's supposed to. Villagers are incredibly overpowered, and this helps them be much more fair. I really like this change, makes progression slower, meaning players will enjoy their world longer. Not to mention book shops would be more valuable. Exploration is now more important, it encourages you to explore more, and build more. It's a slight hassle but you get an excuse to build in more of your world! But if you really hate the change that much, you can move the villagers all in one spot after trading with them once. I should also mention this is still an experiment, and subject to change. Nothing was confirmed to my knowledge

[@capitanspoiler7393]

@@layncemc i'd like it as an option, i don't find villagers OP and i like the way they are and i feel like changing stuff to cater to only one side of the players goes against the idea of a sandbox. also, if they made more meaning of transports available (like actually making carts IN the game) it wouldn't be an issue. let's face it, villagers were handled poorly from the start

[@capitanspoiler7393]

@@layncemc but yeah, if they are smart they'll do the same they did with phantoms, add a rule you can tick when creating your world. also, can you imagine if they DID add the carts in the vanilla game? no more nether ice roads, all bridges and paths in the overwolrd with settlements built all over

[@GojiMC]

0:25 *FINALLY I CAN FEED MY HORSE COKE >:D*

[@e2d877]

Had to sub, 10/10 video

[@ecsko_]

Wow a mod vid every day thats craisy i love these tho keep it up

[@ecsko_]

Ty for the ❤️ :)

[@VerseOW]

YIPPEE!!!

[@anthonypowell4240]

Chainmail horse armor wouldve made the most sense bc thats usally what they wore

[@layncemc]

That’s true now that you mention it! The iron horse armor texture does have a little chainmail in it, I wonder if that’s why they opted not to add it

[@anthonypowell4240]

@@layncemc You cant wear iron armor without a little chainmail

[@rrrrrrrrrRrrrrrRRRhaha]

NiftyCarts is another great mod! You can craft animal carts, storage carts, and even plows.

[@rrrrrrrrrRrrrrrRRRhaha]

The plow is by far the most useful out of the three, with three diamond hoes inside the plow you can make path blocks to your hearts content in a way that feels much more natural compared to right clicking dirt all day long.

[@rrrrrrrrrRrrrrrRRRhaha]

Not to mention you can also attach the carts to yourself!

[@layncemc]

I totally forgot about that one dang! That’s a fantastic mod, I’ve played with that one awhile back and it slipped my mind completely

[@ms1-Alex]

very nice i dicovered your channel, even as a mod developer i like to try new mods but not so many channels do mod reviews hat often

[@theretrodragonyope]

You really- reined me in. ^-^.

[@FlamingMoai]

I like your video style.

[@layncemc]

thanks!

[@nartz5361]

you forgot better animation with fresh animation resourcepack, the riding feels much much better

[@layncemc]

I love FA! I talked about that one in my very first mods video. The reason it didn’t even cross my mind to include it though is because Dyed is incompatible with it. I should have though you’re right!

[@doc_annonymous]

"You alright boi"

[@C.J.B.R777]

Horse facts weight: 1000 to 3000 pounds (depending on the breed) speed: 44 to 55 miles per hour (depending on the breed) Hauling Strength: Horses can carry 200 to 400 pounds on their backs, and can pull 2,500 pounds or more. (depending on the breed) Horses have four deadly attacks: Kicking, Striking, Stomping/Trampling, and Biting. Striking: Horses can rear up and strike you with their front hooves, knocking you down, and leaving you vulnerable to be stomped on. Stomping/Trampling: If you get knocked down to the ground, the horse will take advantage and crush you by stomping or trampling you to death. Bite Force: The bite force of horse is 500 psi, which is strong enough to take a humans finger off. What also makes horse bites more dangerous is infections. Horses have a lot of bacteria in their mouths. If you bitten by a horse, head to a hospital immediately to get medical treated or eles you will die from bacteria infection. Kick Strength: 2,000 psi (one good kick to the head will kill a human instantly) Horses are heavier, faster, and stronger than they look.

[@CrazzyJ-iw5rc]

i'd love to see a horse mod that doesnt bind them to my camera, like i can turn and face side saddle if i wanted to while the horse gallops forward. you'd use the A and D keys to get em to turn instead.

[@vice-cent6639]

i would use horses and mounts in general so much more if they could all have chests and mules/donkeys just has a different buff like being able to lead them to each other? maybe have it so camels have a lot of carrying space and horses only have a little, it would make them so much better

[@godzilla_fan_13]

I know one of the Abnormal's mods has Netherite horse armor (i forget which one though) and for their mod "Caverns and Chasms" has Silver and Necromium (scrap+silver) armor for horses.

[@bigboyepic8598]

This reminded me that I accidentally killed my cousin's horse. . . in Minecraft of course. It could jump really high, and I forgot what funny name we came up with for it. Think it was "Ol' Reliable" or something.

[@esmaeilm7676]

You forgot one very important mod, Horse Combat Controls. It makes it possible to look around whilst moving, allowing one to fight astride.

[@layncemc]

I actually looked for that one! These mods are all for fabric though, and to my knowledge there is no port. For forge though, that is a fabulous mod

[@esmaeilm7676]

@@layncemc No port? How sad! It would have made this good list even better.

[@layncemc]

@@esmaeilm7676 It would have yeah! I was trying to find ways to have my character looking at the camera without the horse following, but to no avail... maybe one day!

[@DeiDrei]

Omg laynce your channel is growing so rapidly I WAS HERE😈😈😈

[@hashymashy6853]

One thing I also realize is that horses are more useful in flatter or less hilly terrain.

[@NiceHyper01]

very good video mr laynce

[@nonreligionist]

Someone tell BDubs about these... I'm sure he could get at least a few onto Hermitcraft

[@VitorEmanuelOliver]

Cool. I'mma change my profile to include these mods

[@slippyio]

One mod that should have been on this list is the zombie horses spawning in zombie villages

[@wortwortwort117]

Horse breeding is such a unique feature if horses though. Breeding should still determine the cap of its stats

[@layncemc]

If I'm remembering it correctly, I do believe that's how it works. A horse is born with a maximum cap, and then riding it levels it up. I'm not sure if I'm wrong right now, or in the video, but If i'm correct, this is a really cool way to implement interaction with the horse to its stats

[@wortwortwort117]

@@layncemc that's what I'm saying Breeding should determine the max cap a horse can be leveled up to. Even after leveling up some horses should still be better then others

[@mikedan]

I genuinely verbally said it when he blinks. I’ll get used to it though I’m only 0:23 in

[@KodaConstellation]

I got this on my recomended and got excited when i saw Superbsteeds *points* MY FRIENDS MADE THAT!!! :DD

[@FeritWolf95]

OMG! MY FRIENDS MADE THAT TOO! OUR FRIENDS MADE THAT MOD! YIPPEE! :D

[@layncemc]

@@FeritWolf95 Both your friends are incredibly talented. Superb Steeds is a brilliant mod!

[@MoriyaShiine]

@@layncemc Thank you!

[@FeritWolf95]

@@layncemc AGREED! Preach it brother! :D

[@lorekeeper685]

Mounted combat would be neat Megamorph them

[@joodgement3388]

Another good horse mod, if you want nicer models and colors is Realistic horse genetics. (Also does mules and donkeys)

[@Jintenzo]

Missed horse combat controls. It's only for forge but it revamps how you control horses and it's a lot better.

[@LuciaSelvlysende]

Ooooooo, I play part of the first piece on piano.

[@NotMalachi]

i forget the name of it, but theres a mod that allows 2 players to mount the same horse too. RIDE TOGETHER THROUGH THE SUNSET

[@layncemc]

That one just about made the list! The only reason I decided not to was because camels would have no functionality. That is a great mod though, maybe I should have included it

[@DearValentina]

4:49 my sibling in Christ, you edited the video

[@Echolotl3]

FINALLY

[@nyafu_uwu]

he spinnin

[@alicered4941]

We need a mod that allows you to turn around while riding a horse, like on a boat

[@CikodelGames]

you forgot horse stonks mod, however, great choices!

[@bruex2277]

This is nice But the best buff to horses would be a nerf to elytras

[@layncemc]

I’ve actually thought about this. I’ve got a series that I removed the elytra for, and it got me pondering. What if the ability to put mending on it was the nerf? That way you can’t use it all the time since you have to be more conservative with the durability, AND phantoms are now much more useful. That or removing the ability to use fireworks with them, so it’s just a glider like the good ol’ days

[@bruex2277]

@@layncemc Removing the ability to fly and maybe compensating it with some other function is how I'd do it But I do think that might be a bit too drastic for some people, so I think that mending nerf would be really nice

[@ilhanilhanDev]

First idea with stars taked from Zelda

[@lambdaluka]

Can you make a modpack with all of the vanilla+ mods you've gone through on the channel? Preferably Fabric!

[@layncemc]

If/when I do that, I pretty much only play on fabric, so you'll most definitely get your wish!

[@lambdaluka]

@@layncemc I'm actually working on a modpack right now with most of the mods shown in your vanilla+ videos for 1.20.4! Though, I may take a few creative liberties and add more. Sadly I'll have to wait for Exposure to update to 1.20.4, I LOVE how that mod looks.

[@KonokiSeri]

Ima start again Day 1 Rooting For Laynce

[@Aveisinpain]

Nice video!

[@comfybox]

subbing for the end credits. actually tho, I’m loving the personality and effort in this video, nice work! You really weren’t horsing around :D

[@J0SAX]

Finically!

[@llll-lk2mm]

this is great!?!

[@Lezm]

Great video, I was wondering if you knew a mod that plays placing sounds when crafting, I swear it exists, but I could be wrong Also how’d you do that animation with the skin? Thanks a bunch! I’m sure you’ll be one of the greats with videos like these!

[@layncemc]

Crafting as in picking up and setting down items in your inventory? Or when completing a craft it plays a saw sound effect? The first one is "Sounds". The second one is "Dynamic Surroundings", but it doesn't seem to make the sound for me. Might need to be turned on in the config, or is not available in 1.20.1. My skins have an extra segment with it that "Entity Texture Features" uses to make me blink! In the empty space that skin files usually have, I've added two extra frames that the mod switches between to make that possible!

[@Lezm]

@@layncemc Thanks a bunch! I’m sorry for not responding sooner, I didn’t see this until I rewatched this video