Finding the Locations of Liminal Spaces [Vol. 4 | Ft. Broogli]

[@Broogli]

Goated collab

[@Katzeonfire]

Been a fan since your third vid, you’re a w man

[@katcana1]

both of you are goated

[@timeisntrealtheuniverseisalie]

hell yeah🔥

[@MrVMonke]

I love your chanal broogly

[@Lizard1444]

yeh boi

[@eKzix4]

The weird and also possibly eerie part of liminal photos or media is that they are sometimes taken for different purposes. For example the photos of the bunker, World Trade Center interior, or the abandoned mall that were probably once considered normal photos for show, but are now a staple of the liminal community.

[@Tn-qr1kb]

and Perchance or possibly, it might be so, though I am not certain. in the future, new generations will consider this generation, THEIR liminality

[@eKzix4]

@@Tn-qr1kb that’s DEEP…

[@Tn-qr1kb]

@@eKzix4 yes

[@gb9727]

After a month of delays, it's finally here

[@Lizard1444]

ikr

[@Chitose_]

yo volume 4

[@mftmss7086]

tell him he's a problem He touch kid but he ain't adam johnson

[@WitchKing-Of-Angmar]

And you were such a passionate champ for sticking with it, do you want a medal now?

[@SunnySlays101]

@@WitchKing-Of-Angmaryes

[@LoogiBalloogi]

Just in case anybody is curious, the wind farm seen in "28 Days Later" is the Carland Cross Wind Farm. It is the 2nd oldest Wind Farm in the United Kingdom after the Delabole Wind Farm, and was built in 1992. In 2012/13, all the old smaller Turbines that were seen in "28 Days Later" were replaced with 10 much larger Turbines.

[@sweetparriz]

2:44 BRUH I LITERALLY GASPED WHEN I SAW THIS IMAGE- When I was 5-6 years old I would have these reoccurring dreams where I would go visit a beach at night, AND THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT IT LOOKED LIKE, IM NOT JOKING 😭😭😭!!

[@bignoseman3031]

liminal spaces are just the default maps of dreams

[@ShaneRocker13]

Wow, thats crazy

[@Random_Sam.]

I REMEMBER OF HAVING A DREAM OF BEING IN A PLACE SIMILAR TO THAT AND THERE WAS FIREWORKS

[@AxelZara]

@@bignoseman3031 I can tell some of you don't explore much.

[@Comrade_Blanc]

Suuuureee

[@Arcycesarz]

Yooo my city mentioned! Love from Poznań, Poland

[@gayternatee]

YOO im from poland too

[@paveuu]

Chodzież pozdrawia szefów z Pyrlandii

[@beauregrd]

11:38 fun fact, the eye room has been a poster child for a lost media/ lostwave song called ''try to smile again'' it was used in the thumbnail and video, (btw the song got identified as beatboy-bravely in 1992)

[@VictornHart]

Yeah I was looking for a comment pointing that one out. Glad there’s another lostwaver here

[@beauregrd]

@@VictornHart now we cn try to smile again.

[@girlwantsboy]

​@@VictornHartyay :3

[@A.Ros3]

16:11 As a fellow Nebraskan, I recognized that place immediately as I've passed through Gretna a few times Nebraska as a whole is one big liminal space, ngl.

[@ෆ__ANNA___ෆ]

16:11 is most neighborhoods in Nebraska my mom's aunt lives in a neighborhood like that I think.

[@ෆ__ANNA___ෆ]

Especially the corn fields at night👀

[@A.Ros3]

@@ෆ__ANNA___ෆ My old farm house was in the middle of nowhere and 3 sides were surrounded by cornfields and one side there was the most haunted liminal space-esque wooded area

[@thatadorablefox]

I forgot Nebraska was a state

[@A.Ros3]

@@thatadorablefox LMAO! That's valid, honestly, there's really nothing here. All we truly have is liminal spaces, corn and tornadoes

[@MichiganCube]

Thanks for including some of my finds in this video! It really means a lot to me!

[@JadenSalads]

Of course

[@RobloxGaming_1000]

@@JadenSaladsname of music 2:40?

[@Epictious]

8:01 as a Polish person I’m glad to see a liminal space located in my country for the first time Also Cinema City is a cinema company in Poland (that’s not the only location of it)

[@wallflower15875]

Ive found tons of liminal space images really harp upon the frutiger aero aesthetic, rooted in modernistic environmentalism. The ultra green grass, wind turbines, clean well-built eco houses, and sunny landscape are present in so many liminal space images. Its all very frutiger aero.

[@RIP__DRAGONBALL__CREATOR_AKIRA]

Absolutely true

[@Byte_64]

6:39 Hits really hard, knowing that everything there, (and possibly those people in the photos), are now gone forever. I know there are other 'liminal' spaces that have been erased entirely from earth, but this one hurts because, well... -R.I.P

[@thesketchydude1315]

and the music choice as well...slowed down version of the MUZAK cover of "She's always a Woman" by Billy Joel, a song which was blaring away from the WTC Plaza Music speaker system even as people jumped and debris came crashing down in the area footage was recorded by Jack Tailercio, a cameraman who snuck past police into the plaza and caught some horrific sights and sounds

[@HalfAnimation]

21:59 yo it’s the room from i feel fantastic, that video still creeps me out to this day

[@kaiyotee2475]

I knew I had to look it up again the moment I saw it, to make sure I wasn't crazy.

[@bluelandyaandgreenlandya1788]

Where did she go

[@kaiyotee2475]

@@bluelandyaandgreenlandya1788 turn around

[@NoSankyuu]

The image after that is from mom deleted his WoW account, absolutely legendary video.

[@crab-yt2wy]

@@NoSankyuugoated video

[@najibtheawesomeness2438]

To anyone wondering what the song being used during the beginning of each chapters, (example 0:47). Its called popipo00 by Aki

[@ks2650]

Thank you, I was curious about that. Never expected it to be a popipo remix lol

[@egyptianpools]

YES I FREAKIN LOVE THAT SONG

[@denjisprettycool]

popipopipopopipo 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥

[@batteryacid1]

sounds like hatsune miku saying "pussy tight" 😭😭

[@batteryacid1]

it sounds like hatsune miku saying "p*ssy tight" 😭😭

[@slam_it]

These series just gives me a different vibe, thanks Jade for this!

[@maqaroon]

My first reaction to the beach photo was that it looks like Jesolo, but assumed it must have been someplace else considering how many generic beaches there are in the world! Jesolo is incredibly popular for family holidays and most kids from Austria have fuzzy nostalgic memories of the beaches and hotels. I always found the entire place very liminal because it has vibrant, holiday vibes during the day but gets downright creepy as soon as the beach is empty. During our honeymoon we underestimated the time it took to reach a restaurant by foot and decided to turn back because it was getting dark and empty fast. We must have walked right past the Hotel Plaza Esplanade section. The upper areas of the beach weren't fully developed yet and had tonnes of abandoned buildings in between the hotels. Many of them had squatters and sketchy looking people hanging around. Crime and muggings on the beach after dark were not uncommon so we were pretty freaked out and legged it back to the hotel.

[@HeyitsAiko]

OMG I love ur vids! Can’t believe I’m first

[@rockersrobloxandmore]

Jaden, your videos are so calming! I'm glad these series are making a comeback!

[@JadenSalads]

Thank you!!

[@hadookin47]

14:23 massive respect for the Slipknot reference, that album still rocks

[@JadenSalads]

!!!

[@BlackSailPass_GuitarCovers]

PEOPLE EQUAL SHIT

[@JadenSalads]

i just realized i'm seeing them this weekend LOL

[@BlackSailPass_GuitarCovers]

@@JadenSalads Enjoy dude 🤘

[@JadenSalads]

@@BlackSailPass_GuitarCovers Will do!!

[@Weezer1812]

I live near the Toys R Us! Its now replaced by a mall called The Parkway Place Mall! its weird to hear about it Also great vid! keep it up ive been a fan for awhile now!

[@littleryanth]

Thank you for making this video man, ive been going through some panic attacks and anxiety but this video calmed me down a bit plus some other factors, i love this series and ive been watching since the 2nd one. Your videos and voice are soothing dude.

[@JadenSalads]

I’m glad it helps, and just know that everything’s going to be alright. Just let time pass and each day will be easier.

[@littleryanth]

@@JadenSalads Thank you so much you just made my day, after relaxing and taking a warm shower plus reading what you said made me feel better. Your one of my favorite youtubers, keep up the good work man!

[@inmortel9685]

The original location of the main backrooms image, was found. I'll look forward to the next volume where you talk about that.

[@itz_qwill]

DUDE THANKS SO MUCH. You have no idea how long I've been waiting. I actually found your channel bc of my interest of liminal spaces and actually started watching other vids and just made me happy to find like legitimate content I love watching and thanks for filling the empty liminal space gap in my brain . Anyways, Keep it up, Love the content and hope you get far in our youtube career :) (and became one of my fav yt's)

[@JadenSalads]

❤❤❤

[@denbondombe6640]

I saw a liminal space featured in my favourite sitcom: Not Going Out. It was an episode where they all went to a haunted house for Christmas and there was one scene where they got woken up in the night by a song being played on a penny whistle. They were all stood in a line at the bottom of the stairs and it was a very old, dark house. The lights were very dim and you could faintly make out the floor was black and white tiles. It was quite creepy as it very liminal especially with the flooring and Daisy saying to Lee, who was at the back of the line, " Remember, in films, it is always the one at the back that gets it first."

[@fallenangel5829]

Jaden I don’t think you understand how proud I am of how successful your KZbin channel has gotten! I remember seeing one of your liminal space videos pop up on my feed and I actually started getting into liminal spaces again because of you! I always get so excited when you post videos (liminal space or not) and I’ll know it’s gonna be something amazing. You may remember me from your livestreams or other videos you’ve made but either way I’m so happy by how far your channel has gone and I can’t wait for what’s gonna come up for this year and more years to come. I hope someday I could do a collaboration or help with other videos you do and I’m so excited for what’s next to come!

[@JadenSalads]

Thank you so freaking much!!

[@Reyde_]

Another installment of the series, I'm so proud of you Jaden , you videos blowing up for a reason, you are very underrated creator, making content based on what we want to see, nailing both visuals, sound and story telling of topics you talk about, moments of silence have it's horror look, everything is exactly as it should be in Liminal space images explanation. As liminal space photography stays popular genre , so be your series shall.

[@JadenSalads]

Thank you so much, thats a very sweet comment.

[@RadicalTrivia]

Hey, I'm from Pittsburgh, and I remember Century III's glory days. Our podcast had a table at a comic con there before they fully closed. We walked the mall, and it was crazy.

[@extra_bite5]

This is a very fun series to tune into, glad your continuing it

[@greenbolt5391]

These videos have a vibe no others have and I love it. Watching these early in the morning is the best

[@JadenSalads]

❤️❤️❤️

[@Makinri]

19:47 This could be an old picture of a Wallmart, In my area before around 2017 my Wallmart had giant CRT TVs with that would display advertisements and they looked exactly the same as the TVs in this photo.

[@AxelZara]

Those TVs were common in A LOT of stores around America not just Walmart. That view was so common. Did people never go outside back in the day?

[@Blakbox92]

​@@AxelZaraaround America? Around the whole world.

[@Mustlord_Guitar_Ambient]

Thanks for the feature, Jaden 🎶

[@JadenSalads]

Always!! Your music adds so much to the video :)

[@RobloxGaming_1000]

@@JadenSaladsplease name of song 2:40

[@Ace-ps5fu]

Liminal spaces have never scared me. They always invoke feelings of wonder and excitement for the future.

[@sleeparalysisdemon1164]

Ikr, I'd always imagine myself there, they all look amazing

[@Appleonaplinth]

i've always had an interest in liminal spaces, dead malls etc. However, after being made redundant for the first time this year, after my place of work closed down, these images and spaces have unlocked a whole new layer of meaning for me. I know understand that these empty and 'dying' spaces are embued with a lot of human emotion,. As well as nostalgia and memories, for workers and owners these remnants represent job instability, turmoil, benkruptcy, debt, stress, pain, change, but also the hope of moving on to a brighter future.

[@BuzzelsTheGDMasternotreally]

I was watching your other videos in this series, and on the 2nd one I saw that you uploaded this and i literally freaked out worth the wait

[@morticorus]

as someone who currently lives in altoona iowa, i’ve been to that area with those houses many times to take liminal photos, truly amazing place

[@saturing-off]

23:42 i was shocked to see this here tbh :D i´ve literally been at that aqua park and i can confirm it´s still active till this day and it´s the most beautiful water park at Czechia in my opinion.

[@divine-s]

Liminal spaces are very interesting to me. I love them a lot because of the comfort of nostalgia I get from them. But there’s also an eerie feeling that resides when you look at them. I loved this video because you actually found these photos in real life that bring me so much nostalgia that I miss. Also amazing collab with you and Broogli!

[@WSHARPNESS]

The goat brings back the best series on KZbin

[@junohoney]

ive been hyperfixated on liminal spaces for the longest time, your videos are always my favorite. thank you for existing!

[@AnthonyB_930]

Yessss! I was refreshing and it was HERE!!! thank you Jaden love your stuff 🎉

[@ARIUS_C_vibes]

BROOGLI what a pleasant surprise, the collab I never knew I needed

[@The_voices_are_getting_louder_]

I love the people in the video, they are so nice in the photos

[@rdevers]

Massive respect for anyone who picture these liminal spaces images...

[@f4rrahh]

I LOVE YOU THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR CONTINUING THIS SERIES IM SO HAPPY

[@o_Tubasa_o]

Yo I’m freaking out right now at how there’s a liminal space in a neighborhood I used to work in! I used to drive all over the streets and admired how liminal the place looked. So crazy man. Good video! ❤

[@afkgamer.]

bro probably waited just to upload this vid on 420💀💀

[@MR-SUIT.DABLOONZ]

LMAOOOOO REAL

[@farissoliman7282]

SKULL EMOJI

[@NovisNook]

😂

[@matthewboire6843]

Maybe

[@Peppermintgrl4life]

LOL

[@matthewisguy7336]

I love how after all this time, you use the same music for the intro of this series. I don't know what it is but it's so calming and eerie and bittersweet at the same time

[@gLiTcH3d_sUnFL0w3R]

FINALLY THEY COLLABED

[@Beeguggs]

colabed

[@gLiTcH3d_sUnFL0w3R]

@@Beeguggs ?

[@Beeguggs]

@@gLiTcH3d_sUnFL0w3R you misspelled it lol

[@gLiTcH3d_sUnFL0w3R]

@@Beeguggs Ok ty lol I’ll fix it :)

[@Beeguggs]

@@gLiTcH3d_sUnFL0w3R 👍

[@som_nus]

I have lived around Lafayette Louisiana all my life, and I’m currently 31 years old. My memories of the Northgate Mall have always been liminal. Even when I was like 5, the place was almost always empty and eerie.

[@Cheesy-z7o]

The thing about liminal spaces is that you feel like you are not alone but at the same time it gives that feeling of loneliness Edit: I Hate to be this person but OMG i have never gotten this much likes

[@matthewboire6843]

That is true, it feels like something is intentionally makeing it look weird

[@Cheesy-z7o]

@@matthewboire6843 Yeah but most of the time you get that by images which is wierd

[@matthewboire6843]

@@Cheesy-z7o the weird feeling is that it feels like no one is there it looks like some one is there.

[@AnneGreen15]

0:58 because we arent...

[@Nightroast]

then don't be that person lmao. likes are useless, you just said something people agree with

[@hoopref12281965]

Jaden, I love your videos so much. You put a smile on my face everyday. Liminal spaces are my thing but I never knew where these locations were. Then I saw your channel. I hope to visit these locations someday. Anyways thanks for your amazing work. I hope you reach 1m someday.❤

[@TheSuperCasual2914]

21:36 Oh hael naw… Jaden Salads confused the wee wee and bibbidy babbidy… 🤦 🤣

[@matthewisguy7336]

Spunch bop x Jaden Salads 😂

[@elderxemo92]

Love this series. I love the non lore versions of aesthetics. ❤

[@Slithering-Pyro]

I love how the room from 22:00 is just the room from the 1st episode of the greatest freakout ever lol

[@JadenSalads]

LOL

[@SmallEnginesFan2010]

I remember that video

[@williamfranciswhite450]

21:59 this one is also from a KZbin video the one with animatronic singing

[@makenzie4486]

Hey, this comment might get lost in the waves of comments, but i just wanted to let you know that you're truly a big inspiration to me. I found your channel because of these videos, and i couldn't be more grateful to find such a great youtuber. I know this comment isn't much, but it's one of the only ways i can express how thankful i am for your channel. Keep up the great work, and i can't wait to see more from you! 👍

[@Rededokku]

10:07 By extracting the Metadata from the original image there are actually coordinates which seem to point to the intersection on 82 Section 2, Wuchang St. The data is from an iphone 4S, but this is the approximate location.

[@bluuecone]

Is it “DHS Service Point”?

[@random2024-6dy]

The neighborhood liminal space has a sort of emptiness, lonliness, and unsettling feeling in this image. Like whos maintaining the grass here? Why is everything so clean and bright? Is this something I saw in my dreams? Irl its a true masterpiece! I dont think the builders know that their creation was seen by millions and millions of people worldwide! Its Insane!

[@microwave-wo3to]

9:44 broogliy jumpscare scared me

[@Kgkdr158]

Fr

[@a_ad95]

I’ve been watching this series since the day part one got uploaded. I hope there’s a part 5 (and many more after that)

[@Pilps]

You didn’t actually say the location of the wind turbines from 28 days later though?

[@Heartbreak_Swift]

Hey, this is one of jerni’s friends coming to support! Really cool channel overall. Props to you!

[@xotoothbat]

trust me there are SO MANY hidden gem liminal spaces in iowa 💗

[@JadenSalads]

❤️❤️❤️

[@AdrianGhastly]

Gotta drop everything when a new Jaden Salads video drops

[@MichiganCube]

agreed

[@JadenSalads]

☝🏼☝🏼☝🏼☝🏼

[@casablanca6754]

What is the song you play between lovations

[@StaticGnA]

“Popipo00” by aki Hope this helps :3

[@LOOPIE-12]

Idk why, but the different pictures at the start of the WTC Sky Lobby segment made me feel very nostalgic and at peace.

[@The_SonicFan2010]

24:03 my dad used to live in Bristol and took me to this exact McDonald's inside of WalMart

[@s1lly_lighting]

I live 15minutes from here😂 i ate here a year ago and thought it looked suspiciously similar to somewhere i have seen online

[@monterrang1]

the second one hit me hard honestly. As someone who went multiple times around Jesolo for holidays, this place is pretty cool & yea the parasols lines you see go on for miles, would recommend

[@FazbearEntertainment414]

the backrooms photo was found

[@Withered_Bonniex87]

FAZBEAR ENTERTAINMENT !!??

[@FazbearEntertainment414]

@@Withered_Bonniex87 yes

[@Withered_Bonniex87]

@@FazbearEntertainment414 I didnt I would you guys find in the video of the voicelines of withered springbonnie

[@Nik-kv7dc]

I grew up in Westmoreland County, PA, and instantly recognized these places! Another famous liminal space was taken at the Kiski area high school, near Saltsburg, Pennsylvania. PA is full of liminal and abandoned spaces, it's the one thing I miss about home now that I live in the coastal south where everything abandoned is ripped apart and built up instantly.

[@StarberryCreetH]

Whats the song that plays in between every chapter? Like this one 5:13

[@exhausted6547]

lmk if you find out

[@polposekhmet]

It's popipo00

[@remor9637]

Man.... I really love the mood of this videos

[@TeeHeeTwinkleToes]

8:43 dang, its not even in Michigan 💀

[@Game_Hero]

That whole citation reading in french was just the best part of your videos, ever! You have to be a native speaker like myself to enjoy this wonderful pronounciation to the maximum

[@VeryMadVeryHappy]

Hey man, what music did you use at 0:46 ? (timestamps??)

[@famillemurciarodriguezcauc38]

Its popipo 00 :) sry im late

[@VeryMadVeryHappy]

@@famillemurciarodriguezcauc38 It's fine! really

[@Yuri.skz_lover143]

Btw there’s also one called warm nights:)

[@Nekoneex]

How do yall know the names

[@dogisgame211]

​@@Nekoneexvocaloid fans.

[@kazoot8265]

This is my favourite series fr

[@porfiriotomas70]

ok what's that music Jayden uses in the transition?

[@polposekhmet]

It's popipo00

[@porfiriotomas70]

@@polposekhmet what?

[@polposekhmet]

@@porfiriotomas70 music is popipo00 by akiba

[@porfiriotomas70]

@@polposekhmet ahhh ok thanx

[@AnarchistOnPaws]

Po pi po or ぱぴぱ sped up by like 100x

[@stylintylin77]

Dude ur videos a such a breath of fresh air. Huge props for using ur time and looking for all of these crazy pics.

[@VeryCoolMinecraftGamer00]

3:14 hey, not to be rude or anything, but in italian, most I's are pronounced as you pronounce e, so instead of [læido] it would be [lido]

[@nataliepolivkova8389]

You just reminded me of a memory I totally forgot about :) I was actually at the water park in Czechia as a kid, and yes I remember it had a weird feeling to it, the dimmed lights and bizarre sculptures and colours made it dreamlike and eerie

[@Jordanninja09]

What’s the cover of Alberto Balsam called that appears at 23:53

[@beabuzzkill]

i second this, i need some kind of payment for the sudden and unexpected aphex twin jumpscare

[@cybersans0]

well the most similar one i could find is the cover by riftworks

[@beabuzzkill]

@@cybersans0YOU ARE CORRECT (i think) THANK YOU

[@Jordanninja09]

@@cybersans0 Thanks!

[@Beaches_Peaches]

How did I miss this? I'm glad it's finally out, I missed this series, this is the best episode!

[@ZapperRS]

21:30 dat French accent

[@oreo903the2one]

8:27 it honestly makes me so happy that he referenced this movie because it's so good. It's unsettling, but it's hella cool.

[@ariete_3281]

21:40 you just paired a french man with a french accent with an Italian song.... bruh

[@GoldenRevenge]

I don't care about all the delays, I'm just glad you're back

[@franz03paso36]

transition song?

[@Gamer_on_roblox124]

jaden salads you dont know me but i want you to never give up i love the liminal space locations hope you make a lot of videos

[@s1lly_lighting]

24:07 oh my fucking god i live like 10 minutes from here 😂 i had eaten here before like a year ago and thought i had seen it before

[@TheMemeBorrower.]

SAME!!! I drive through there often just to clear my head. It’s so peaceful and perfectly tucked away between the main roads

[@matthewisguy7336]

That's funny 😂 I wonder what would happen if I saw somewhere 10 minutes from where I live

[@rmwlobster6707]

liminal spaces are my fav kind of spaces thank you for telling us the locations, it would be my dream to go to one someday.

[@takomasmith8246]

Bro where are you the original has been found

[@konner4908]

Never stop doing these videos, I would’ve never knew where these came from.

[@animox6303]

Bro still didn‘t say where the wind turbine pic of 28 days later was taken

[@tiandi5585]

Mandela County.

[@koralate7119]

This is so nicely edited, the lil "not Broogli's hands.." made me giggle sm

[@EpicSpud]

If this gets top comment I will eat 100 forks

[@elysiumPC-ov9pk]

No comments and 50 LIKES!? Lemme change that

[@rhythm_kitchenn]

get eating bucko

[@IAmSmg6-w7h]

Wow um I’ll get the forks!

[@Least_Patriotic_Texan]

Welp are you a man of your word?

[@bunnyfamily8]

guys I have bad news he’s at the hospital

[@Volti21]

Hi, I have been to Babylon in Liberec, Czechia. I'd like to say, it's still very liminal (been there last summer holidays), there is also child fun park and many "amusement park-like" attractions. But it is soo crowded. Even that, once i stepped inside, it felt like i was in my dream from when I was 9 year old Thanks for including that! keep up these videos, Jaden!

[@jennis6399]

Toys were us

[@northplayz5899]

You know it's gonna be a great day when Jaden uploads

[@Kade-c0gh4]

Fr

[@KitCatzii]

Is yoour pfp jumbo josh

[@weirdstashcat4437]

The moment he mentioned Ankeny, Iowa I squealed a little bit. As an Iowan, I like the recognition. While I'm nowhere near Ankeny, it's still pretty neat!! Also side nkte my ex boyfriend was from Huntsville, so also ironic to see Toys R Us image be from his hometine. We sti get along as friends so I immediately sent the video to him!

[@anabz0]

The level 94 one surprised me, I wouldn't expect a liminal place to be 30 mins away.

[@thetheoryofphantomsdelta2779]

holy shit, one of these is in my city! I'm going to go check it out, this is crazy!