FIRST Listen + Analysis of Rubber Soul by the BEATLES - major to minor to major

I tried to up the editing on this one as it's something I need to work on, I hope you enjoyed the video as I enjoyed making it. Rubber Soul is a great album!
TIMESTAMPS BELOW
Rubber Soul
0:00 - Intro
0:38 - Drive My Car
3:17 - Norwegian Wood
6:00 - You Won’t See Me
8:50 - Nowhere Man
11:40 - Think For yourself
14:22 - The Word
16:46 - Michelle
19:44 - What goes on?
21:44 -Girl
25:09 - I’m Looking through you
27:06 - In my life
30:26 - Wait
32:45 - If I needed someone
34:43 - Run for your Life
READ AFTER WATCHING…
You’re not gonna listen to that are you? lol
As my Camera was running low on battery, I didn’t get to share my final thoughts, so here goes!
Rubber Soul had me smiling throughout. Each song (except one :P) instantly caught my ear by using simple yet beautiful melodies, interesting sound design, subject matter, funny lyrics (BEEP BEEP) and musically.
I love that the more and more successful they got they didn’t lose their playful charm as can be seen in Michelle and Drive my car.
I tried to analyse some musical moments as I listened and I hoped you enjoyed it!
Listen to my MUSIC!
• MUSIC by CAZZA
/ sweetcaroline_93
open.spotify.com/artist/4LEn4...
Follow me on:
/ cazzamusicofficial
/ cazzamusicofficial
/ cazza_music

[@cleonmagabeefy8473]

Any other Beatle fan totally addicted to this??

[@luisfabregas3086]

me

[@sharoncappelson9348]

Yeah. I've watched this multiple times! lol

[@keithschofield1158]

This is my second time around watching this she has knowledge and personality I can’t believe she’s only heard yesterday

[@TheSuperWaterweasel]

yes it’s so fun to listen through someone with new ears

[@markstanley565]

Totally

[@mariosandri4010]

"In My Life" is like the finest cognac: the older you get and your past piles up, the more you love it.

[@lejoe48]

exactly

[@fernicusmaximus9282]

Same thing with Eleanor Rigby, the lonelier you get the more it makes more sense.

[@MrKeychange]

Beautiful comment

[@kenttheaker7904]

It was another of John's that was heartfelt. He was thinking of Stuart Sutcliffe, the Beatles' Hamburg bassist, then dead for three years, and of current friends like Pete Shotton. The only contentious note is that Paul later claimed the melody was *his*. The jury has always been out on that.

[@montymontano8618]

John had experienced a lot of loss in his life.

[@bumblingberry]

I don't see any Beatles album as "peak Beatles", but Rubber Soul to me comes pretty close to standing out. I personally think it is the best album they ever made. Everything was in sync, perfect.

[@alibabaschultz352]

Rubber Soul and Abbey Road have always been my favorites.

[@AbsitInvidea]

Almost every Beatle album was superb, but Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band is mine and most people's favorite. It was groundbreaking. I was 14 and my cousin played the whole thing for my sister and I and we sat transfixed the whole time. It was like the first time you heard Bohemian Rhapsody. Most people remember when and where they heard it for the first time. It was like the 1st Star Wars movie.

[@sj49770]

Ringo was the secret weapon on Rubber Soul. I would almost call him the MVP of Rubber Soul. He's always doing something a little outside the box.

[@shayaanrk]

I can't believe Sgt Pepper, White Album and Abbey Road came in 3 years. These 3 albums alone have more versatility than any artists whole career, let alone their other albums

[@shayaanrk]

​@@sj49770Ringo on Revolver is his best version. I have never seen much better drumming. His performance on She Said is just a masterpiece

[@scottmccoppin3]

The pure joy she's experiencing from hearing these songs is so satisfying to watch her express, she's so excited!

[@HaFannyHa]

It's brilliant to see someone so enthusiastic and receptive to this music. There's a spark about this lady!

[@keithmills862]

@John Smith - In the "anthology" series, George Harrison said the same thing. He said that they were like "part one and part two".....

[@keithmills862]

@John Smith - Check it out again. It's (obviously) at the section where they get to "Revolver".....

[@keithmills862]

George also mentions ( in that section ) that he enjoyed doing that album.

[@babylonian.captivity]

It's like hearing them for the first time all over again. In watching her I'm watching myself forty years ago.

[@ead630]

Literally as this was premiering the trailer for "The Beatles: Get Back" dropped. What a day!

[@Danjoker.]

Hype!!!

[@darkjanggo]

a great day for the bottles!

[@IsaacWale2004]

Right after I got back from college I saw that and was like "well this is gonna make my day"

[@dudasomewhere]

fun times for bugs fans

[@debjorgo]

Wow! Yeah. I see it over to the right. Any other video and I'd be dropping this and going to it.

[@mnmade9062]

Caroline, I’m going to let you in on the secret as to why Beatles fans are loving this series, and why there is so much anticipation for each video in your journey. First off, I do want to state that your personality and musical knowledge are what makes the series as enjoyable as it is. It would be a treat to watch any “Beatles virgin” discover their music, but the specific qualities that you bring to the table is what sets you apart. That being said though, when you reach the end of this series and have heard the entire Beatles catalog, consider the following: the Beatles produced all of this music over a 7-8 year period….think back to Love Me Do and consider how radically they’d changed their music over such a short period…consider that at the time they broke up none of them was yet 30 years old, with Ringo being the oldest at 29 and George the youngest at 26…..consider the number of incredible songs that were written by Lennon/McCartney in that short period, and then consider that within the same band was George Harrison, whose song contributions alone would be a HOF career for any other musician….think back to how they looked at the beginning vs the end, and consider the impact they had on fashion….remember that everything they did in the studio was through experimentation and that they were the first to do it….Consider how incredible they were as a live band, yet they quit playing live in 1966….think about how many stars had to align so that these 4 talents and personalities could come together, and that they were fortunate enough to get a producer like George Martin that was smart enough to know when to guide them, and when to get out of the way…. I could go on and on but you get the point, so I’ll make the final point that always blows my mind the most when I think about it: consider the songs, and think about the staggering number of them that go beyond being merely pop songs. It’s overwhelming. Once you reach the end of this musical journey and you consider those facts, you’ll understand what the fuss has always been about with the Beatles, and why the music they created continues to be unparalleled and revered at a level no other band or musician comes close to over 50 years later. After hearing Rubber Soul, you’re now standing on the precipice of the path to understanding it all. Enjoy.

[@tking747]

Great summation!

[@lawrencesmith6536]

Their cultural social political musical impact was a once in a lifetime phenomenon. Our entire generation was waiting for evrything they did

[@wernerthiem7632]

Perfect conclusion

[@patricknelson5151]

In the early 1990’s, I bought an Encyclopedia Britannia, back in those pre-Internet days when you bought such things in hard copy. The Encyclopedia pretty much ignored rock music as if it had never existed, with one exception: a lengthy article on The Beatles. It even had a picture (from the White Album period). The Beatles really are sui generis.

[@dannydine5263]

Love your analogy of George Martin. Knowing when to guide and add plus knowing when to leave them alone. Plus his orchestrations were the best. Brilliant fellow and they all acknowledged that. Even John.

[@hansvandermeulen5515]

"I don't think I ever heard a sitar in a popsong before." Neither had anyone elsexwhen this album came out as that is the first popsong ever with a sitar in there.

[@telover5797]

"In My Life" is a total masterpiece: alone it's worth the whole album.

[@ashsnake0749]

My favorite song ❤

[@dexterop4562]

mine as well @@ashsnake0749

[@eduardocervantesaca]

I agree, the drumming is a masterpiece, then the piano solo, the lyrics... i just love it

[@woodskier]

hahah teenies trying to firgure them out

[@Kaleidoscopia]

Can you imagine that the band that sang 'Love Me Do' is the same one that sang 'In My Life' just two years later? If that isn't growth, IDK what is! What's fascinating about The Beatles is that they never really stopped evolving and getting better. That's what makes them the greatest band of all time

[@jnagarya519]

You point to a song that I overlooked at the time of release -- it didn't "rock". But as I've aged, as will happen to every one of us, and the losses accumulate, I came to cherish that song. Not the least because of the devastating loss of its author.

[@whichgodofthousandsmeansno5306]

Heck you consider from "yeah, yeah, yeah," to "I am the Walrus" was just few short years. The change is astounding yet they were always a step ahead of the game. And having three great writers that could sing and play great in one band adding the perfect drummer and producer. But also explains why they were destined to go solo. Especially once Paul was really taking over I can understand the others started to feel useless

[@transformationgeneration]

It was actually three years and one month (Sept 1962 - Oct 1965) but who's counting :)

[@allenswanson2423]

Funny that she hears the first song and thinks, okay, this sounds pretty much like their other music; but then she doesn't observe that Think for Yourself and The Word sound like nothing that's ever been recorded by anyone, anywhere, ever.

[@Lily_The_Pink972]

@@allenswanson2423 NOTHING that the Beatles recorded ever sounded like anybody else!

[@masonresnick5105]

I believe Rubber Soul has healing properties. In 1966 I was 9 years old, and sick with the flu. I'm lying on the couch with a fever. The couch was located between the two console stereo speakers with 14-inch woofers. I put on Rubber Soul, closed my eyes, and let the music flow through me. When I woke up, I felt better. It also has one of John's best songs, "In My Life." When he died, this song was a comfort to so many of us.

[@senseichess8688]

@Simon Archbold I remember when the vocals and instruments were separated on this one with the vinyl pressings from way back

[@jeffreykaufmann2867]

@Simon Archbold Why wasn't "In My Life" released as a Single? It surely would have been a huge #1 hit.

[@jnagarya519]

I was inspired to become a writer by John (and Mark Twain). When he was killed I was devastated (as were millions of others). I couldn't listen to "Beatles" music for at least 10 years thereafter because it was too upsetting: that murder was so contrary to their spirit.

[@jnagarya519]

@@senseichess8688 They were on all the LPs up to "Sgt. Pepper's". The first 4 were not stereo; they were pre-mix mono. George Martin explains that in his book, "All You Need is Ears".

[@senseichess8688]

@@jnagarya519 i had all the original lps and i only heard the difference on rubber soul and I bet I hear better than you

[@garmit61]

IMHO this was the finest release by the Beatles. So many wonderful songs on such a small piece of plastic. In My Life and Norwegian Wood are songwriting masterpieces.

[@diltberg9627]

I totally agree it's their masterpiece

[@Dadof3kidz]

Absolutely agree. In My Life is my all time Beatles favorite. Paul McCarthney being my favorite with songs like Hey Juse, Let It Be, Yesterday, that says a lot.

[@jnagarya519]

Don't neglect "Girl" -- which John said was his favorite of all his songs..

[@isaiahneilguitaristofficia549]

“Rubber Soul” is for me the PERFECT transition album, transitioning from incredible “pop” Song’s that get on the radio, and even those lyrically are just incredible, to more introspective songs( In My Life) that still have incredible melodies, and the harmonies it’s just a fantastic album.

[@gclip9883]

It is also a nice prelude to the more psychedelic and experimental sound of Revolver and Sgt. Peppers. It is the first time they used the Sitar and songs like Nowhere Man and Think for Yourself were later featured on Yellow Submarine, which is overtly psychedelic. Also, Rubber Soul and Revolver to me feel like they belong together - it really is their peak as a band in my opinion, even though their later work is still brilliant.

[@thatoneguyagain2252]

Rubber Soul is the first album I ever bought, when I was 8 years old. I'm 62 now, and the only real difference is that "In My Life" still makes me cry uncontrollably, but now it takes longer to stop.

[@alisonanthony1228]

In My Life was the song I walked down the aisle to on my wedding day. A couple of years ago it was played at my husband's funeral. It used to be my favourite Beatles song but I really can't listen to it any more - there's just too much tied up in that song for me.

[@feedigli]

@@mgtowchampion7961 And the award for first negative comment goes to... one of the strengths of hevy meddle moosic and its adherents, it always seemed to me.

[@Chiroman527]

TOGA, I think you should get a Grip... Unfortunately there is so MUCH MORE going on on this planet, and particularly in the USA that Makes Me CRY !! (well almost). Back to the point, I'm 70 YO, retired now (Thank God), my first LP purchase was Meet The Beatles (don't remember the price ... est $3 or $4 ). I purchased 45s first , played on the Phonograph with an Automatic stacker and changer (very cool at the time). The first 45 was probably a Beatles record, but don't actually remember (She Loves You ??) at age 14 (1965 +/- ).

[@jnagarya519]

I got the LP on release. I didn't like "In My Life" because it didn't rock. But as I've got older, and in particular with the loss of John, it gets to me. (As it is, I wasn't able to listen to "Beatles" for some 10 years after John was murdered without breaking down. Which means I couldn't listen at all. I'm hoping the Super Deluxe sets will help me reconnect -- and perhaps the way it was before then.)

[@Mr.Ekshin]

@@mgtowchampion7961 - Face it... you were an Iron Maiden fan because you had a thing for long haired men wearing tight leather pants, chains, spikes, and other BDSM gear. You were probably into Judas Priest too. And the "music" you were listening to ranked a distant second to the actual needs you were satisfying.

[@DonnaLang42rockglobally]

The melody for "Michelle" is the oldest one on the album; back when John was in art college, he'd invite Paul to a lot of the parties... Paul would show up in a black turtleneck toting his acoustic guitar along, and he'd sort of sit in the corner playing the melody of what would become "Michelle" and mumble French sounding lyrics in hopes of meeting girls. Around the time they were working on Rubber Soul, John basically asked, " What happened to that French thing? How 'bout finishing it?" So Paul thought there should be some French in the lyrics and decided to ask a friend who spoke the language to help get that sorted out. And there we have it - a sweet, beautiful, sad story of love and the language barrier. The story teller spoke almost no French, and the girl (probably) didn't have much English... a tragic love story, but is it doomed before it began? That's for you to decide.

[@kathleenhudson8429]

Paul said in McCartney 321 that she was a friend of a friend.

[@jp3813]

How is it sad? He's clearly just serenading a French girl. Nothing in it suggests that she's rejecting him.

[@craigsmith8669]

Paul has famously said that Michelle was his dog.

[@thesilvershining]

@@craigsmith8669 No, that was Martha.

[@craigsmith8669]

Yeah I know, I got mixed up, heard Martha my dear a few days after and remembered…. My bad

[@michaelkimsal788]

2600 comments already - this was probably mentioned, but one of the things that really *gets* me about Rubber Soul so much is that this whole thing was (more or less) written and recorded in a month. This is just a crazy amount of work to have been done so quickly. That it has held up so well for 50 years is yet another testament to their creative energy. For me, Rubber Soul and Revolver are "peak Beatles", and ... Revolver had more time (and a different engineer) in the studio, which, in many ways, makes Rubber Soul so much more impressive by comparison.

[@bigmike159]

And their first double A sided single which was not included in this masterpiece!

[@klayng1]

And they were in their early 20s to boot. Simply amazing!

[@unclefuggly7149]

Here's the story I heard. They had intended to make a double album. But no rock and roll artists had yet done that so they weren't sure how that would go over. Then The Who released "Tommy" and it was huge so they were confident to release their White Album.

[@josesarango710]

Agreed. Rubber Soul and Revolver are peak Beatles

[@jacobyoung729]

As a younger, new Beatles fan, I’ve got to agree. I think they were in their “prime” for their entire run but Rubber Soul and Revolver are just something else. A great in between of their rockin early stuff and their psychedelic later stuff.

[@kingdancekiller]

The harmonies on “If I Needed Someone” always get me. Imo this is my second favorite album with Revolver and Abbey Road tied for first.

[@grantmalone]

So third favourite :)

[@averyadrian1534]

Imho Sgt. Pepper is the best white album is amazing as well

[@handzar6402]

That's a good top three, very similar to mine. I have a hard time picking between Rubber Soul and A Hard Day's Night for third place.

[@timstrobel7828]

@@handzar6402 Great pick... gotta toss in the White album. But it always seems to be, the last one you listened too... inches out the topper most poppermost. 👊

[@handzar6402]

@@timstrobel7828 I'm a bit ambivalent about the White Album.

[@tdgallagher218]

In My Life is the song I associate most with the death of John Lennon. My sister called that night to tell me that Lennon was shot to death. After the call, I thought she must've got it all wrong or at the very worst, maybe he was only injured. I stopped as I reached for the radio and thought, if the first thing I hear is a song by the Beatles or Lennon, then maybe it was true. As fate would have it, the song they were playing was In My Life. From that night forward, that song turned into something special to me. Well before that tragic day, I've always loved the song simply because of the performance, the soothing vocals and easy going tempo. But now I cherish it because the lyrics take on a whole new meaning and speaks to my heart. You can bet I'm not the only person who feels this way about it.

[@CallMeCaroline]

That's a beautiful story, thank you for sharing it with us.

[@Riff156]

This is the album Paul really started innovating with his bass. He's a very influential bass player to this day.

[@270yis7]

Started using a new bass guitar too. Before RUBBER SOUL, he only used his Hofner violin basses. Beginning with RUBBER SOUL, he'd start using a Rickenbacker 4001 bass, which he would continue using as his main bass guitar during his Wings years in the 1970s and into the 1980s before reclaiming the Hofner bass at the end of the 80s.

[@archraskal]

@@270yis7 You and @Riff156 probably have more interesting things to say about the Beatles' music than Caroline could ever imagine

[@SpaceCattttt]

@@270yis7 He did the right thing. Hofners are awful.

[@bluepeng8895]

@@270yis7 He went back to the Hofner for the let It Be sessions

[@gotham61]

@@SpaceCattttt He still plays a Hofner pretty much exclusively today, so it's clearly not awful for him.

[@blackhorse11thACR]

I grew up with The Beatles and bought Rubber Soul when it came out in America. "In my life" is my favorite all time. I wasn't able to afford all the albums and had to settle for 45s. I eventually started delivering newspapers and had money to buy all the albums and Beatles cards. I still have all my albums, every one they made and in mint condition. I couldn't get enough of The Beatles. Today I have a massive collection. We needed the Beatles because we were devastated when JFK was assassinated and the Fab 4 brought us some joy again. I'm so thankful for the Sunday night when we watched the Beatles performance on the Ed Sullivan show in 1964 as they changed our lives forever and for the betterment of mankind. Never thought I would have reached when I'm 64!

[@jnagarya519]

The link between the JFK assassination and "The Beatles" is pure speculation.

[@monkmchorning]

@@jnagarya519 This is Blackhorse's personal observation. Maybe it doesn't work for you, but it works for Blackhorse and see his point. A lot of US journalists were saying the same thing around then, too.

[@jnagarya519]

@@monkmchorning ONE journalist -- Walter Cronkite -- made that SPECULATIVE "link". It has ever since been treated as a quasi-fact: unquestioned. There is actually no evidence for it. I had music in my life since earliest memories. I first heard "The Beatles" in October, 1963 -- before the assassination -- on a Chicago radio station. VeeJay Records was located in Chicago, and were the first to release "Beatles" in LP form. It went nowhere commercially until after the turn of the year, but I distinctly remember it was of particular interest to me.

[@monkmchorning]

@@jnagarya519 Well, I guess we should have asked you before expressing our impressions of hearing our first Beatles records. Sorry for disrespecting your authority.

[@jnagarya519]

@@monkmchorning I agree: your experience matters but mine doesn't. But facts matter: The issue was the statement connecting the assassination with "The Beatles" success. I was 15 at the time, I saw Walter Cronkite make that connection -- which was OPINION. He was the only one who did, but nearly everyone treated it as Gospel, even though, as said, it was speculation with no evidence for it. I'll also note that I next heard "The Beatles" -- beginning in November, 1963 -- on an all night radio program. The DJ had 8 hours to fill so had several running "skits," and occasionally played "oddball" non-playlist recordings -- one night he played a "Goon" comedy skit (research it: "The Beatles" grew up with them, and it is reflected in their humor). During that November he began playing "I Want to Hold your Hand"; and as he began getting requests for it he played it more often. And the requests grew so he began playing "I Saw Her Standing There," which he said was the "B"-side (it actually began with the "1-2-3-FAH!" so was actually from the VeeJay LP release). He also began talking about "The Beatles," saying they were the latest "big thing" in England. And I clearly remember his prediction that they would "Never go anywhere". During that year I was listening to radio stations outside my local area, as indicated -- such as Chicago and New York. One New York radio station listed "I Want to Hold Your Hand" as "Bubbling Under" the Top 20 on December 31, 1963. The next day, January 1st, 1964, it was #1 on that station.

[@sergei_mikhailovich]

As a diehard Beatles fan, I've known this album for ages, but watching you listening for the first time and analyzing it makes me appreciate it even more. This one and Revolver are both on my top 5 Albums of all time.

[@rikkousa]

@Sergei Mikhailovich you captured my sentiments perfectly. Caroline’s intense listening and detailed analysis caused me to listen more intently and with much more analysis as well… soooo glad she did

[@sergei_mikhailovich]

@@rikkousa As I said, I've known the Rubber Soul album since I was a kid (I'm 30 now), and Caroline's analysis made me discover new and amazing things about those songs, things I didn't notice before.

[@FeelingShred]

@@sergei_mikhailovich As a "Revolver kind of person" (I guess?) there's something that intrigues me about the Beatles. Maybe you will be able to explain it to me? (below) copied from comments from another video, broken in segments otherwise it gets deleted FeelingShred 1 second ago I don't really "understand" the Beatles, but I have been finding most of the bands I love have been influenced by them. So it affects me indirectly I guess XD FeelingShred FeelingShred 1 second ago The thing that really makes me have some kind of "beef" with the Beatles is that (to me) it doesn't seem like they were capable of playing their own material live? I might be wrong on this for my lack of knowledge on the band, being by how little I listened to them. (continues...) FeelingShred FeelingShred 1 second ago For example, everyone and their grandma seems to idolize that album Sgt Peppers, right? It came out in 1967. Did the band ever tour that album? Or played the songs from it live on a stage performance? FeelingShred FeelingShred 1 second ago Because my impression from Sgt Peppers (and Beatles' more well-known "hits" in general) is that these songs were mostly heavily-doctored inside a studio, heavily altered material by technological interference. I don't hear much of "a band playing" on these recordings. So that's why I assume the band wasn't really capable of reproducing these songs live, or they butchered it live. Am I wrong? FeelingShred FeelingShred 0 seconds ago To put it into perspective, I very much prefer the album (also released in 1967) from Pink Floyd, Piper At The Gates of Dawn, their debut album... Not only the album was a technological and artistic GROUND-BREAKING EFFORT in terms of composition, creativity and specially SOUND QUALITY for the time (it's really impressive!!) Not only that but also the band could PLAY THE SONGS LIVE! There is footage!!

[@monkmchorning]

While I have a personal fondness for Beatles for Sale (which wasn't available in the States), I praise Rubber Soul and Revolver as the best.

[@monkmchorning]

@@FeelingShred In 1966 the Beatles announced they would do no more live concerts. The reason was, the quality of the performances wasn't meeting their standards. This was due to the crowd noise and misbehavior and lousy sound systems of the time. There were no stage monitors. The art of micing guitar amplifiers for PA was still primitive. And PA speakers were still primitive. If you go back to the Beatles' early years, though, you learn that they honed their talent and skill through live performance. They really were two cuts above any of their contemporaries.

[@Fool3SufferingFools]

Paul tells a great story about the origins of "Michelle"... apologies if someone else has shared this already. In the early days of the Beatles, John was in art college and used to invite Paul with him to school parties, where Paul used to feel very uncomfortable around all the art students. He didn't know what to say to anyone, so he would sit in a corner and pretend to be French. Part of that act was playing this song on the guitar and singing in French. Years later, when they were looking for material for Rubber Soul, John said to Paul: "Remember that daft French thing you used to do? Let's use that."

[@Imw101]

He called himself "Paul Ramone"

[@Fool3SufferingFools]

@@Imw101 Yeah, those were the days when they were using stage names like "Long John Silver" and "Carl Harrison."

[@drusilla3882]

‘Michelle’ was one of McCartney’s oldest songs, dating as far back as 1959. It was inspired by Austin Mitchell, one of John Lennon’s tutors at the Liverpool College of Art.

[@scottandrewbrass1931]

Drusila. It was actually Austin Davies who was an artist and lecturer at The Liverpool Art College (Where John and Stu attended). He was married to the author Beryl Bainbridge and would have parties that would last for days in end. Paul misremembered him as Austin Mitchell in the Many Years From Now book.

[@SM-jg8fr]

@@Fool3SufferingFools Which carried through to the Traveling Wilburys

[@infiniteflow1]

Post rubber soul beatles is a different beast. I feel most of us agree.

[@jnagarya519]

We don't "all agree" despite your effort to dragoon everyone else, without the courtesy of asking whether "we" are willing to be involuntarily drafted into your insecure demand that your view is the only one that is correct. The REVOLUTION BEGAN WITH "Rubber Soul". You've obviously ignored everything before "Revolver". "Rubber Soul" has more emotional substance than "Revolver".

[@alejonunez5788]

@@jnagarya519 man, relax

[@billpaul6675]

@@jnagarya519 I agree! For me, Rubber Soul changed everything. The Fab Four even looked OLD on the cover, especially to this 13-year old. Revolver was a logical follow-up, and even more mature. But for me, there was a vast difference between Rubber Soul and every LP that preceded it.

[@phillydisco]

If Help! had come out before Beatles For Sale, then I would have said Beatles For Sale. I think that album was a huge leap forward, but then they took a step back with Help! just to get the 'product' out for the upcoming movie. Then Rubber Soul continued that leap forward, and they never looked back.

[@marceloliberatodesou]

@@jnagarya519 hahaha whoa, that was a bitter comment

[@frederickfisher9323]

John said he was sorry he wrote "Run For Your Life". John definitely added a lot of edge to the song writing duo.

[@BareBandSubscription]

I love that song, I don’t even care. The lyrics being as genuinely frightening as they are further it’s appeal to me.

[@Tom-xh8yj]

​@@BareBandSubscription right it's just a song people are way to sensitive anymore.

[@bruce-e-bonus]

@@BareBandSubscription Yeah - I've really liked it since a kid. For me it's more to do with the music and attitude than a literal reading of the lyrics. Exactly why I love I am the Walrus

[@siroswaldfortitude5346]

@@BareBandSubscription same here

[@diltberg9627]

Why should of he apologized for writing a great song he only told truth in the song

[@sarahtonin4649]

Drive My Car is amazing. The verses are one guitar, a bass, drums (including cowbell), and two voices. No one's even playing chords til the piano does in the chorus. Recorded on four tracks, no quantization, and no fucking autotune. Talent was required in 1965.

[@BeachLifeinDeath]

BEEP BEEP MM BEEP BEEP YEAH!

[@gettingkilt]

Also I think the first pop use of deliberately dissonant harmonies.

[@you_tubeslonelyheartsclubband]

And an awesome bass/guitar riff based on Otis Redding's version of Respect (Made even more popular than it already was by Aretha Franklin).

[@cristhianbecerra5458]

So sweet of Caroline to take into account the suggestion of listening on Spotify with headphones 🥰

[@prabhakarsharma7910]

Any old classic album is a headphone album

[@gribwitch]

Sweeeeeeeeeeeeeet Caro-linnnnnne, good times never felt so good....

[@axelowell4084]

The Greatness of the Beatles is not that one song beeing an all time hit, it's the high quality of the songs throuhout all of their work.

[@doriskray1430]

This is when we went from buying a big hit single to an album playing nation. FM radio, etc.

[@hondomckee.8232]

And all the inventive, little constructs hidden throughout the songs.

[@Zongadude]

I've said it before but I'd like to say it again: thank you for making us all remember why we all loved discovering the Beatles in the first place. :) The emotions, surprises and enjoyements you are going through while listening are very communicative, even to us folks that have been knowing those songs by heart for years. It's like we're discovering those songs again. Thank you for that ;)

[@Pwecko]

When I was a youngster, a long time ago, my friends and I tried to play some songs from a book of Beatles songs. In the lyric for Girl, the sucking in of breath was notated as "yooths", which we found very amusing. Every time we played it instead of drawing in air, we sang "Girl, yooths". That amused us even more.

[@mauricesummer1011]

YES!!! You are getting closer to Revolver. After you do the Day Tripper/We Can Work It Out single, listen to the Paperback Writer/ Rain single before listening to Revolver. That single came out months before Revolver did. It's a teaser for the new sound of that album. Prepare for everything to change from this point forward.

[@patricknelson5151]

Totally agree. And then Strawberry Fields Forever/Penny Lane after Revolver and before Pepper. That order gives a real sense of their growth. The only thing that can be hard to get your head around is that the next song they recorded after Rubber Soul was the early version of Tomorrow Never Knows. Nothing on Rubber Soul anticipates that.

[@alwylie4252]

Please listen to the version of "Paperback Writer" on the currently available version of the 1 compilation, which has a great Giles Martin remix more like the original mono version released in 1966. The stereo mix on "Past Masters" was created a few years later (1969/70 ?) and is very poor. It's like all the life has been sucked out of it - and the harsh l/r separation sounds even more woeful through headphones, with a ton of dead air in the middle where the vocals and guitar need to be. "Rain" is only available on "Past Masters" and its stereo mix isn't as bad...but, really, in the absence of the original mono - the "1" version of Paperback Writer is absolutely essential, especially if you are using 'phones. The fuzz guitar riff really hits home. If anyone else can back me up on this, that would be great. 😀 ✌

[@jnagarya519]

"Rubber Soul" was the REVOLUTION -- and has greater emotional substance than "Revolver".

[@ricmac2067]

In addition to Al Wylie's comments, I might suggest similar choices when you eventually come to Sgt Peppers. In those days the mono mix was the definitive version and there is a vast difference between that and the stereo. Caroline, if a mono version is unavailable, please choose the Giles Martin stereo mix which closer to what was intended. Fingers crossed. ;)

[@bluepeng8895]

@@patricknelson5151 Nah, Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane are on Magical Mystery Tour already. Might as well save it until she reacts to that album

[@demonhoopa]

“I’m not a drummer, I can’t technically tell you why I like the drumming on this song” You just unintentionally summed up Ringo’s entire stint with The Beatles. Cheers

[@BronyDanProductions]

And yet there are still people who think he’s the shittest drummer ever and the weak link in the Beatles.

[@StraightBananaAction]

@@BronyDanProductions anyone who thinks perfectionists like Lennon and McCartney would allow themselves to have a less than incredible drummer AND continue to use him on their solo projects is fooling themselves

[@AlBarzUK]

It’s good to note that Ringo always moulded his beats to whatever music was coming at him. Just as much as the songwriting developed, so did Ringo’s innovation, and there was very often a new way of matching the mood of the piece that no one had done before. He didn’t “show off” with big drum solos so a few ignorant blokes didn’t get him. IMHO 😁🤗

[@demonhoopa]

I’m glad I’m not alone in loving his drumming. He was so unorthodox and musical.

[@phillydisco]

@@BronyDanProductions Only snobs thing Ringo is a shitty drummer.

[@myfavoritedream2149]

My dearest friend passed away 4 years ago. We both loved music, and when she could no longer get out of bed we lay together listening to Sweet Baby James by James Taylor. She whisper-sang every word. The day after she died I was in my garage, walking to my car when "In My Life" came on out of nowhere. And I mean nowhere. Just the ending chorus. Transcendent to hear it now.

[@JRoss80]

To clarify for people who say John abused his wives: I read the book “John” by Cynthia a long time ago. It is a personal account of her relationship with John. She says in the book that he slapped her ONCE in 1957 when they were 17, and they broke up because of it. According to her, he never did it again. There is also no evidence he ever hit Yoko. People need to stop making up history. Listen to the women who were actually married to him. John may have been a violent person when he was younger but with all his faults, it did appear he grew out of that behavior.

[@TAJMofficial]

He also strangled May Pang

[@wallclock4648]

@@TAJMofficial lol

[@cactaceous]

@@TAJMofficial Ringo beat up and chocked out his wife Barbara as well. Nothing good comes from excessive drinking with a nagging woman around.

[@cantsay8894]

I envy young people hearing great music for the first time.

[@davidrowley8577]

Cheers to THAT!

[@goldtown6747]

I know what you mean. I remember vividly being a teenager in the early 1980s and becoming a die hard Beatles fan. Each new album was quite an adventure, full of surprises and pleasure.

[@TheReubenKincaid]

@@goldtown6747 me too. In 1980 I bought them in sequence...well My dad had me buy Pepper first. I bought cassettes and they were the US Capitol Releases...Started with Meet The Beatles and worked up. I hear a lot of younger people call The Beatles overrated lately, and I guess to a degree I can understand. It was almost 60 years ago and the very early stuff does not sound fresh. But put in the context of the time, and do what this young lady is doing..and you can hear the innovation....not re-invention as some will say, but invention. I remember asking my father..”What was it like Togo from Denise by Randy and the Rainbows in 63 to White Rabbit in 67.....4 years...like going from 2017 to 2021..He said it was weird...

[@zetmoon]

“The word” is one of the first songs were the word love doesn’t just refer to love between boy & girl/man & woman but to love in the “hippy” sense. Love for everyone and everything!

[@feedigli]

Listening to it here, I hear John examining christianity and the bible, drawing meaning out for himself.

[@lawrencesmith6536]

I think Beatles in general, and , John in particular, have recorded more songs about love than any other artists

[@Koshek137]

"The Word" was the song that attracted the counter culture to the Beatles. Many hippies and folkies (people who listened only to folk music) were not that into the Beatles (being suspicious of pop music in general, and that they wore suits and ties and sang about wanting to just hold your hand) but with Rubber Soul and songs like The Word and Norwegian Wood, the Beatles gained a whole new audience.

[@gavinreid5387]

A few months after this album was released lennon said that The Beatles were more popular than jesus . An extremely controversial statement.

[@davidlivermore7481]

@@gavinreid5387 Controversial maybe in the touchy religion staid, states in the USA but not so in the fast becoming, social enlightening Britian and large chunks of the rest of the western world that quickly embraced the 'freedom' of a more 'open' free thinking society. And at the same time all this was being driven by the likes of the Beatles and their piers.

[@ypt100]

Caroline.. Rubber Soul is my favorite album. I'm a Beatles fan. The later albums were great, but this to me was their absolute peak. I'm sure many Beatles fans will disagree with me!!

[@johndavids4780]

In My Life is the best Beatles song ever written as described my many musicians. Art Garfunkle thinks it is the best song ever written.

[@nathan43082]

Some consider this their best album. I honestly cannot pick a favorite, although I do prefer this and all the albums that follow it. When they started pushing the boundaries of studio time: 1. Paul starting to incorporate more sophisticated bass lines as well as his use of the nasal/throaty and "thunky" Rickenbacker 4001 bass 2. Their nearly-endless experimentation and perfectionism 3. The close microphone placement by engineer Geoff Emerick on Ringo's drums 4. The deadening of the ringing on those drums for more punch 5. Their ability to distill complicated things down to the most listenable and accessible material for all ages 6. Their switch to the more bluesy Epiphone Casino for richer guitar tones 7. The invention of Automatic Double Tracking by one of their engineers in response to a request by John (now called the flange effect) 8. Their use of headphones in the studio to reduce sound leaking 9. John modulating his voice in response to the echo in his headphones 10. Their willingness to try anything and everything for a new and different sound, including John lying on the floor with the microphone above him All the guys in the studio, including The Beatles, are legends.

[@murff625]

@Simon Archbold I thought the tea towels started with Revolver when Geoff Emerick became engineer.

[@monovision566]

Great list. To clarify, flange is its own thing. The ADT was invented at Abbey Road, however, and studios use it to this day. :)

[@aureliande2659]

You're right about what the most inventive steps were, but you get the timeline wrong in a couple of cases. Rubber Soul was engineered by Norman Smith. Points 3, 4, 6, 7, 8 apply to Revolver, also the Rickenbacker bass. Acquired by Paul in '65 but used in recordings in '66. Hope you don't mind.

[@doriskray1430]

Nathan, I just screenshot your 10 points! We’re you in the recording studio when the Beatles recorded this? ☺️PS this is my favorite album too.

[@beatlemaniacwaltdisneyfan4753]

Geoff Emerick wasn't Even on rubber soul neither did headphones. Other than that it started on Help

[@cameronbrownell6782]

Caroline: It's official, you're a star! Your Beatles series is so much fun for those of us who watched that Ed Sullivan show in early February 1964. Keep having fun with it and we'll keep watching you. Cheers!

[@doubtingthomasreviews7702]

I don’t go back that far, born in ‘68, but as a lifer I totally agree with you! This is the perfect addition to the new Get Back series and Let It Be remix coming out…⭐️

[@stlmopoet]

Agreed.

[@thomastimlin1724]

She does this with the joy of discovering but yet the intelligent approach of analysis, with a musical background to back it up. She actually listens to it with her ears, not her eyes, analyses chord progressions, instruments, lyrics...rather than watches the music with their eyes....on the videos, [promotional films, [live performances]b saying "oh look at that"paying no attention to the music and lyrics. Does not cry "Old school"or "eeeooo, it's in black and white..." She's on the music, spot on...

[@doriskray1430]

And Caroline sings well too.

[@carolwood53]

@@thomastimlin1724 At some time, though, I hope she does add the visuals to her experience - they were SO fun to watch!!

[@sejrec56]

In so many songs I hear Paul’s such strong vocals in harmony or lead, so powerful and yet perfect pitch notes! Amazing still to me how great their vocals were!

[@FBAV]

Well and playing his bass, which Caroline mentions so often. He could a counter melodic bass tune and sing in harmony at the same time. Some folks praised me for being able to play drums and sing at the same time.... But playing bass and singing? I'm sorry, if it's just 4 notes to hit on a bass guitar I might be able to but that's it.

[@virginiapicker]

I really wish someone would do a remix of the Beatles catalogue and bring McCartney’s bass lines higher up in the mix. It must be possible with modern digital technology. It would make the overall sound seem more modern, and make it easier for even casual listeners to enjoy how great his bass lines were.

[@saytr4]

It's fun to follow a typical band through their songs over the years but the Beatles are even more fun because you can follow John's songs, Paul's songs and George's songs separately and see how they express themselves individually too. They each have quite different styles and personalities.

[@dudasomewhere]

Oh the pure joy on your face listening to these songs is priceless, and makes my heart all warm and fuzzy. I'm so glad you are doing this, this is very magical. And from now on it's only gonna get better!

[@lcarpetrondookmariot7620]

Someday I hope we get a video on The Beach Boys' attempt to top Rubber Soul (Pet Sounds). The sequence of Rubber Soul to Pet Sounds to Revolver advanced pop music so far in so little time.

[@masonresnick5105]

@@lcarpetrondookmariot7620 Actually, I hope Caroline you'll do a similar series breaking down all The Beach Boys albums through the early-mid 70s when they became VERY experimental. The evolution from The Beach Boys Today to Pet Sounds, Sunflower, Smiley Smile, Holland, and Surf's Up is pretty amazing. And also Smile, even though it wasn't released until more than 30 years after it had been recorded.

[@demonhoopa]

How beautifully put Eduarda. Cheers

[@TrekBeatTK]

This is my favorite album. The “harpischord” solo in “In My Life” is George Martin playing piano recorded at half speed so that when played back “normally” it gets that faster higher pitch sound. He was a genius.

[@transformationgeneration]

I've always wished George (Martin) would have taken more care with the end of the harpsichord solo. The way it rushes out just seems almost lazy (no insult meant). I just wish he would have taken the time to complete that beautiful piece the same way he began it. Prosody would demand a more melodic classy resolve. That said, if anything else in the song had to change to make that happen, I would vote to leave it as is :) Possible the best Beatles song ever written.

[@MrDiddyDee]

@@transformationgeneration I think it works fine melodically, but the end rundown would have been better simplified, for me it's the bit that really gives the game away that it's been played at a different speed and just sounds unnaturally fast. I pity all the poor tribute bands that have had to try to replicate it live.

[@transformationgeneration]

@@MrDiddyDee I agree.

[@BogusOp]

Fun fact : it is not a harpsichord! It is a piano played and recorded slowly and then speeded up on tape which George Martin played but didn't have the ability to play it at speed so he used a recording trick

[@sagnhill]

As they say, George Martin was the 5th Beatle.

[@christophertomsa7071]

Your combination of musical analysis and appreciation are so fresh and welcome from all the other reaction videos that are out there. Thanks for your obvious knowledge and joy of music!

[@marystercula9165]

I was a long time employee of a large supermarket and worked with many young people over my forty years of service. The best part of working with all these young people was educating them about the Beatles. Whenever a Beatles song came on the loadspeaker I would say who is singing this song they eventually caught on and knew I would only ask if it was the Beatles they were amazed. And yes I know ever word of this album.

[@craigerb2630]

I do the same with my kids.

[@brachiator1]

Rubber Soul helped spur the invention of rock criticism as a separate branch of arts criticism. Before this, the general music critics of newspapers or magazines would write about pop and rock. Before this album, Newsweek, for example, didn't think the Beatles would do more as a group. They had to rethink their position about the Beatles and other groups, and also hire writers who had a better feel for this pop music revolution. This also led to younger writers joining media outlets.

[@71hammyman]

The ripples the beatles made still continue to amaze me, never knew this, imagine they never existed.

[@Blackmallowtube]

@@71hammyman There's a movie about that. Yesterday.

[@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820]

The Beatles have always vexed the music critics honestly. I believe it was around the time of “With the Beatles” that a critic mentioned the “Aeolian cadences” in one of their songs.

[@comanchio1976]

😅 Imagine writing that The Beatles we're a spent force just before they released Rubber Soul!? Talk about embarrassing! It's almost as bad as the person at Decca Records turning them down, because "guitar bands are on the way out" nice going, lads! 😂👍

[@keith1222]

@@comanchio1976 That man learnt his lesson. Later he asked George Harrison if he knew of any other decent guitar bands. George mentioned The Rolling Stones. He signed them!

[@daddyguerrero]

It’s really interesting to know that years later in an interview with John Lennon about his favorite and least favorite Beatles songs he listed Run for Your Life as one of his least favorite, mainly due to the negativity of the lyrics. He was the harshest critic of his own music. But Rubber Soul is one of my top three Beatles albums. Now we’re coming to the pinnacle of the Beatles creativity not just as musicians but as composers. From here on out all their songs are their own, no covers. And with them having ended their concert tours to focus on the music, their creativity just soars beyond anyone’s imagining. This was no longer a rock band or pop stars, they were artists on the level of a Mozart or Beethoven. Classical performers and composers began to listen and take the Beatles more seriously. The next album, Revolver, in the opinions of many, is probably their best. You’re in for a treat from here on out. Whatever you thought you knew about the Beatles to this point, goes all out the window.

[@Pilcha.]

Except for “Maggie Mae” 🥸

[@daddyguerrero]

@@Pilcha. That was just them fooling around in the studio and the producers just happened to throw that onto the album as a filler. They did not seriously record it or intend for it to be put onto Let It Be.

[@jeffreykaufmann2867]

My first Beatles Album that I got was Meet the Beatles. Seargent Pepper was the 2nd. A Xmas gift . I regret not hearing all their Albums in Chronological Order.

[@steveeliscu1254]

@@jeffreykaufmann2867 Yeah. I feel sorry for people who weren't born during the baby boom - if for no reason other than we got to hear each new Beatles album AS they came out. And it was always a mind blower. They kept changing and innovating.

[@daddyguerrero]

@@steveeliscu1254 Those were the best times growing up.

[@kathymiller9916]

KZbin threw your channel at me because I'd fallen into a Beatles interviews hole for awhile. I was a major Beatles fan as a kid... bought almost all of their albums and used to have every lyric and nuance of their songs memorized (I'm almost 70)... picked out things on guitar and piano. Definitely obsessed! I just wanted you to know how much I've enjoyed listening to you listening. You have a wonderful musical ear and talent to bring to the table and you seem like such a delightful person.

[@brandtheisner4313]

I'm sure someone else has made this comment, but part of the magic of the Beatles' songwriting is that they didn't know theory and didn't know modes or "accepted" chord progressions. They just wrote what was in their heads without knowledge of "the rules" and came up with some truly innovative stuff as a result.

[@abandonedchannel1159]

From this album to the next ones It will be the beatles that changed music history.

[@thomastimlin1724]

True, although they already changed music history to a point but if they had continued the same routine of touring and then do a quick album, they would have become stagnant. So well put.

[@samuelmregister]

Yes and no- had they stopped at help, they'd still be in the R & R hall of fame.

[@abandonedchannel1159]

I agree, they would still be famous and a great rock band, but I don't know if they would've been considered by many as the greatest band of all time

[@scottamichie]

They were revolutionary from the very start. Their debut album shook up a moribund recording industry and changed music radio …and yes, Rubber Soul launched changes in music AND so much more.

[@rubygreta1]

Today, Revolver seems to be much more well regarded than Sgt. Pepper. But it was Sgt. Pepper that really exploded The Beatles into another universe, and probably remained the critics and fans #1 album into the 80's and 90's. Not sure of the numbers, but it blew away Revolver in terms of sales.

[@norryonbass6574]

This is where things kick up a notch. Pre-Rubber Soul Beatle albums are awesome but after this they reach new heights.

[@KikomochiMendoza]

Very true. Many bands and musicians could do what the Beatles did which was to constantly reinvent oneself. Rubber Soul was a step up to their reinvention.

[@patricknelson5151]

I mentioned elsewhere but it’s worth repeating that the interesting thing about “Run for Your Life” is that it was the first song recorded for Rubber Soul and so sounds the most like an earlier Beatles cut (with the possible exception of “What Goes On”). The song has a weird mix of catchy tune with deplorable lyrics. I have always thought that “Getting Better” was a bit of a response to this song, though it’s often debated whether the lines about “I used to be cruel to my woman…” in “Getting Better” were written by Paul or John. “Man, I was mean but I’m changing my scene and I’m doing the best that I can…”

[@arttoegemann]

Brilliant channel. So nice to have the efforts of smart musician. And the approach of a first listen of a beloved subject. Thanks! And I promise I will listen to your songs soon.

[@leekovalskyj9218]

Love it, Caroline! Your reactions are priceless - delightful and insightful.

[@rifyrafi]

It's becoming evident to most us here , that waiting for your Beatles album analysis is a welcome addiction, Caroline. That Beatles Complete Scores book you got there is musicians gold. I love your musicality. You hear chord progressions and subtle changes that make songs magical. As you listen to each song, it's like waiting for a friend opening presents on Christmas Eve with anticipation. Rubber Soul was the catapult album for the lads to musical immortality. It's hard to imagine that even more innovative and inventive albums are in the horizon.

[@doriskray1430]

Good take about the Christmas presents.

[@norryonbass6574]

I refer to that book as the Musicians Bible

[@RayRay-zt7bj]

Damet! I am getting an addiction to liking all the great comments on this video, such as yours! Listening to each song really is like waiting for a friend opening Christmas presents on Christmas Eve. Only difference in my case is that it would be a relative, because I almost always had a big family gathering on Christmas Eve.

[@alrivers8458]

You got it. That's just all right. Great comment.

[@aintwurfnufnifitaintfree2853]

Welcome addiction?? Dude, you're a pillar of strength. It's been 3 days and already the wait has me curled up in the fetal position under the kitchen table, shivering and grinding my teeth like crazy. I had to steal the dog's chew toy for something to bite down on. I'm jonesin' hard over here rifyrafi... jonesin' real hard! :P

[@wayne_twentyfive]

These Beatles breakdowns are just so good !!.. They're the thing I enjoy most on YT at the moment, and the next 3 weeks is going to seem like forever .. Love being on this musical journey with you, Caroline ! .. Thanks heaps, Wayne

[@CallMeCaroline]

I'm so glad you are enjoying the videos Wayne!

[@wayne_twentyfive]

@@CallMeCaroline That's the understatement of 2021 ! 😉 .. You must feel so good, knowing how much pleasure you are giving to thousands of people .. Personality, education and pure joy .. Can't ask any more from a video .. Cheers, and keep up the great work, both with these Beatles vids and your other content .. Wayne 👍👍👍

[@mikek5958]

@@CallMeCaroline From Songfacts: As far as "Run For Your Life," John was inspired by an Elvis Presley song, "Baby, Let's Play House," when he wrote this. The title and entire first line came from Elvis' song: "I'd rather see you dead little girl, than to be with another man." He made no bones about this being his "least favorite Beatles song." Many agree. Do keep in mind that this was 1965; there was more slack attitudes towards gender equality than there are now.

[@dondamon4669]

@@wayne_twentyfive Man your weird! Leave her alone as your bordering on stalker talk!

[@wayne_twentyfive]

@@dondamon4669 Whatever you say, dude 🥱. You sound way too intelligent for me to argue with you .. Thanks for the helpful and considered advice 😂

[@jeffa6841]

Hi Caroline. This is the first video of yours I've ever watched. I must say I really enjoyed it. Most reaction videos I've seen consist of someone grooving along to the song, and saying they like it. But your analysis, and commentary add so much more substance. Your wonderful personality kept me engaged as well. Great job!

[@MsAppassionata]

She has been doing their albums in chronological order, which is the way I prefer them to be done. People who review their music out of context or don’t listen to their earlier material don’t really understand why they became such a musical phenomenon and how they influenced an entire generation of fans and other musicians.

[@robmarjenberg677]

Thanks again. I've am loving the journey, the music and your amazingly insightful in the moment reactions. Agree about the song Run for your life, the lyrics are shocking. Can't wait for Revolver!

[@MrKeychange]

Can you guys picture how good this record could have been if they swapped "Run For Your Life" & "What Goes On" with "We Can Work it Out" & "Day Tripper"?? 🤯 It's wild that they still kept the "Hold the two catchiest songs back for a single" attitude when they had the chance to make this beautiful record into a Revolver-level masterpiece.

[@blythjc]

Yes I can. I have a playlist on Apple Music that does just that. Makes for a sublime listening experience.

[@andyallan2909]

Did the same with 'Pepper'. It was supposed to include, "Penny Lane" and "Strawberry Fields Forever" but the record company wanted a single.

[@MrKeychange]

@@andyallan2909At least Pepper was a wall to wall a beautiful record. I can't imagine removing any of the songs. Rubber Soul (my opinion), would have really been elevated by swapping out those two.

[@MrKeychange]

@@andyallan2909 George Martin wanted that too. It's admirable conceptually, since they did it so people wouldn't have to buy a song twice. Just in this case... ehhhh. I wonder if they were tempted to switch them before releasing this.

[@MrKeychange]

@@blythjc I can imagine. I think the early albums could probably be condensed as well to make it easier for younger ears to digest them. There were SO many covers done just to create product, that water down the gems (in my opinion obviously). Given that the early albums were always being distributed in various forms, it's not sacrilegious as if they were reorganizing Pepper I'd do a record with the iconic shaded cover and cover all the essential pre- Hard Days Night Lennon/ McCartney stuff. They could pair it with a "Cavern Club" sort of record, lead by "Twist & Shout" and get all the essential covers out of the way (including Dizzy from Help, Bad Boy, Leave My Kitten Alone etc.). Then I'd streamline both Hard Days Night & Help!. Leave them as two album of course, but include the singles from the era & remove any cover songs. After that, switch the two songs up on Rubber Soul and everything stays the same after that. 👍 Ah, revisionist history. 😜

[@Me-fr7yj]

In case you didn’t notice, Nowhere Man is the first Beatles song to not be about love or a romantic relationship in some form or fashion.

[@SpindlyScoudrel]

Anyone else excited for Caroline because we know which album comes next....?

[@Hennessysupremacy]

Revolvahhhhhh

[@deslawson3444]

I know all these songs so well - I can barely imagine hearing them for the first time - Your musical knowledge combined with the sheer joy you experience listening to them is completely enchanting. It brings a whole new angle to these songs - as I think some one else on this thread said, it's hearing them for the first time through some one else's ears - and you manage to point things out that even the most intense and musically knowledgeable Beatles fan might have missed. Love it. You're rather fab!

[@MrKeychange]

These reactions of yours are really starting to become events. Nicely done!

[@ConglomerationCat]

Truly! So anxious for Revolver, Strawberry and beyond....

[@rifyrafi]

She’s really refreshing to listen to.

[@CallMeCaroline]

Thanks MusicalPancakes...great name!

[@MrKeychange]

@@CallMeCaroline Thank you 🤍 I've been trying to come up with a clever pancake pun, but alas...

[@jamesvogrin5652]

The Beatles producer was George Martin who played a major roll in different sounds and instruments. The boys were always asking what else they could do adding new sounds that they could use. He became more and more involved now and upcoming albums. Caroline you are a joy to watch,keep up the good work.

[@dennysmall9155]

Caroline, I love your reaction videos! Thanks for the front row seat to your discovery of the magic of The Beatles! I look forward to the next leg of your adventure! Peace & Love

[@0675rs]

I should tidy up my apartment but here I am sitting and watching Caroline react to one of my favorite albums ever. Enchanting.

[@stefanosg1432]

In My Life is the most beautiful poem ever written.

[@docsavage8640]

Well, no. Aside from not being a poem.

[@stefanosg1432]

@@docsavage8640 a piece of writing in which the expression of feelings and ideas is given intensity by particular attention to diction (sometimes involving rhyme), rhythm, and imagery.

[@paulopinheirosc]

John Lennon wrote "Nowhere Man" about himself. Sitting in his mansion far away from the wonderful Swinging London (in the suburb... a nowhere land), the world at his command (yes, that's a metaphor... fans all around the world loving him) and still feeling empty, like he knows not where he is going to. He was just living till somebody else would lend him a hand. He was unhappy.

[@albertschepis]

I LOVE Carolines' feeling and analysis of these Beatles songs, especially "Girl". I love that song too. "In My Life" is one to make you cry though, and each song does something quite different musically.

[@tonymorielli7158]

You do the best , most insightful , enthusiastic Beatles reviews ...and you're having fun . Equally as fun listening to the review

[@ree_boksock]

You have to respect just how different and distinct the sound of this album is as compared to “A Hard Days Night” and even “Help!”They’ve already come so far and they are just shoveling out smash hits!!! With more to come! Catchy and timeless songs 🙏 Love your reactions and analysis btw

[@davidcarter5038]

"shoveling" is a great word. By this time, L&M have already given away songs that became top ten hits for other bands in Brian Epstein's stable plus a US/UK number one hit for Peter and Gordon, "World Without Love".

[@ree_boksock]

@@davidcarter5038 also a great song! 👍🏼

[@jeffreykaufmann2867]

I've just seen a face was on Rubber Soul when released in the U.S.

[@dj71162]

Help is an underrated album. Its not such a big leap from that to RS. It had songs like Yesterday and You've Got to Hide Your Love Away, so the signs were there. Plus the song Help is RS standard as well if you slow it down and listen it its lyrics. Lennon said it was him expressing how he felt at the time, like he was calling for help. BIt for commercial purposes the song was a faster tempo. It was originally a slow song.

[@270yis7]

...and they would keep topping their previous album on the next album. Every new record became another quantum leap forward.

[@richardbeaton7324]

The medieval solo on " In My Life " Was played on piano by their producer , And they slowed down the backing track played the solo then sped it up to normal speed getting that Harpsicord sound.

[@finosuilleabhain7781]

More faux Bach than Faux medieval though.

[@patricknelson5151]

There is an excellent podcast about this from a few years ago called “Producing The Beatles”, mostly about George Martin’s work. The first episode is dedicated to the piano solo in “In My Life” (“Wind Up Piano”).

[@puglia5375]

The production of Beatles without precedent. Every song is produced, sung, delivered whatever, flawlessly.

[@babylonian.captivity]

Caroline, I just love how joyfully attentive you are. You hang on and respond to every morsel of music. I count you a kindred spirit.

[@paultivy1456]

The "reverse guitar" sound you're hearing on "Wait" is actually George's volume pedal, as previously featured on "I Need You" and "Yes It Is". Apart from one more outing on the "Day Tripper" single, where it's used on the ascending chords supporting the solo, I think I'm right in saying it was never touched again. They first used genuine reversed guitar on the next album. Can't wait to see what you make of that one :)

[@hubabava]

Wait was a leftover from help, so recorded in the same sessions as I need you and Yes it is. I remember they added some florishes to it but that's why that volume pedal is in there. And you're totally right: they'd use something like that in 2 or 3 songs and then never use it again

[@1monki]

Yup, those are still volume swells. We haven't quite reached the reverse guitar yet 😉 I don't think George had a volume pedal. I think he was just working the volume on the guitar

[@bjornerikroth]

@@hubabava And it's quite a bit better than several songs on Help! Can't understand why they left it off, but it does fit better on Rubber Soul. The Beatles, master editors, strike again.

[@phillydisco]

@@hubabava Funny that the song was called 'Wait' and it had to wait to appear on an LP. Strange they left it off Help! considering that LP was short one song on the B side. But it fits in fine in Rubber Soul.

[@sjm1]

Yes. Watch Mike Pachelli's breakdown of the song.

[@stephenpolly2793]

The songs on the brillant double A-side single "Daytripper" and " We Can We Work It Out" were recorded during the Rubber Soul Sessions and this single was released the same day as the album: December 3, 1965. These two songs MUST be included in any playlist of Rubber Soul - I put them at the beginning of the playlist. This addition makes a brilliant album the perfect album and puts the album into the category of one of the greatest rock/popular album ever.

[@timothybolshaw]

I feel the same way. Similarly, at the time Sergeant Pepper's is encountered, you really must include Strawberry Fields Forever/Penny Lane. These superb singles belong to their respective Beatles eras, and are important to understand the group's evolution.

[@Octavian7771]

My playlist of Rubber Soul includes Day Tripper and We Can Work It Out, and I also have the mix start out with these songs in the same order. I just realized that both songs are lead vocal Paul. This must have troubled John, the beginnings of John's resentment that Paul was so prolific?

[@paulsaret]

@@Octavian7771 Day Tripper is a John song, though, Paul was harmonizing with him , so John's voice was not as prominent.

[@clintatk]

I place Rubber Soul above all other albums except Abbey Road. RS is as solid as a brick outhouse! Probably the peak of the band as a band! You can feel they are all on the same wavelength.

[@Octavian7771]

@@paulsaret When I think of Day Tripper, I think of the line 'She's a big teaser, which is sung by Paul, my bad :P Both songs are very closely Lennon/McCartney collab.

[@rareosts5752]

I'm loving this series, Caroline, can't wait for the next one!

[@captgeech]

Just found your channel today, right at the perfect spot! This is the real beginning point of the fascinating evolution of the Beatles

[@stellarpod]

Rubber Soul was *the* turning point for the Beatles. From that point forward the music will be more studio derived and largely more complex. Revolver, Sgt. Peppers, Magical Mystery Tour, The White Album, Let It Be, and what I believe to be the pinnacle of the Beatles' repertoire, Abbey Road. I cannot wait to hear your thoughts on these albums - especially Abbey Road. I'm 65 years old and have been a Beatles fan my entire life. I much appreciate your perspective. It reminds me of the magic when I'd buy the latest LP release and then immerse myself it for the first time. You have earned my subscription. Well done, Caroline. As always, thanks much for sharing. Steve

[@FeelingShred]

​ @Sergei Mikhailovich As a "Revolver kind of person" (I guess?) there's something that intrigues me about the Beatles. Maybe you will be able to explain it to me? (below) copied from comments from another video, broken in segments otherwise it gets deleted I have questions exactly about that post-Revolver transformation (did the Beatles fans even liked that period?) FeelingShred 1 second ago I don't really "understand" the Beatles, but I have been finding most of the bands I love have been influenced by them. So it affects me indirectly I guess XD FeelingShred FeelingShred 1 second ago The thing that really makes me have some kind of "beef" with the Beatles is that (to me) it doesn't seem like they were capable of playing their own material live? I might be wrong on this for my lack of knowledge on the band, being by how little I listened to them. (continues...) FeelingShred FeelingShred 1 second ago For example, everyone and their grandma seems to idolize that album Sgt Peppers, right? It came out in 1967. Did the band ever tour that album? Or played the songs from it live on a stage performance? FeelingShred FeelingShred 1 second ago Because my impression from Sgt Peppers (and Beatles' more well-known "hits" in general) is that these songs were mostly heavily-doctored inside a studio, heavily altered material by technological interference. I don't hear much of "a band playing" on these recordings. So that's why I assume the band wasn't really capable of reproducing these songs live, or they butchered it live. Am I wrong? FeelingShred FeelingShred 0 seconds ago To put it into perspective, I very much prefer the album (also released in 1967) from Pink Floyd, Piper At The Gates of Dawn, their debut album... Not only the album was a technological and artistic GROUND-BREAKING EFFORT in terms of composition, creativity and specially SOUND QUALITY for the time (it's really impressive!!) Not only that but also the band could PLAY THE SONGS LIVE! There is footage!!

[@LanceRED58]

Steve I totally agree with you , have been a Beatle fan all my life , 70 now !

[@spharion1941]

It's such a joy to see an adorable young woman discovering and appreciating the Beatles' songs.👍👍

[@davidreider9373]

I just discovered your videos. I'm in my late 60's and grew up with the Beatles. I know all these albums by heart. Thank you for such refreshing looks at these classics !!!

[@cnewtn0232]

I’m enjoying your analysis of the Beatles albums. Your emotions tell a story as you listen. I can’t wait for your future analysis of the albums. I’m sure you’re emotions will tell wonderful stories as you get to later albums.

[@syduk]

Have loved your previous entries. Totally agree with most other commenters that this is where the true Beatles creativity properly begins. Looking forward to vicariously hearing this for the first time again. 🙂

[@feedigli]

I disagree about their creativity beginning here. Seeing them on the Ed Sullivan show changed my 8th grade world from black-and-white to color in an instant: everything was going to be different now. Yes, they started coming on strong as maturing artists, here, and we all started growing by leaps and bounds with them at this time, but they were amazing and had already changed the world way before this. Beatlemania! ring a bell?

[@syduk]

@@feedigli I appreciate that the Beatles were pretty special from the outset. But while there were occasional gems in their earlier work (mixed with some barely passable covers), in my personal opinion it was Rubber Soul which really kick-started their forays into more experimental studio techniques and lyrical themes. I was sadly not around when the Beatles were together, so all of my views are retrospective. I'm sure that it was different for those who saw their rise firsthand.

[@foureyes264]

I gotta say Caroline, this old Aussie gets so much pleasure out of watching you get all excited and giggle with joy when you hear a sound or a lyric or a musical surprise that takes your fancy. It really reminds me of how we all felt the first time we heard these songs ourselves. Can't wait for the next few albums to drop so we can see your mind blown!

[@fromtheblonx]

I've just discovered your videos and I absolutely adore your enthusiasm! I also love The Beatles so to see you enjoying them like this is so joyful 🙏❤️

[@msheboigen]

What a treat to go through the album with you! I clicked out of mild curiosity, expecting to only stay a few minutes, but watching you delight in the songs was too good to leave. It's a nice feeling to see someone responding as I first did many years ago. Lovely.

[@mariomf1644]

From now on all The Beatles albums are masterpieces, every single one with an unique essence and they change the rules about how to do music in general with them.

[@cancerandaids3822]

Every Beatles album is a masterpiece

[@phillydisco]

Even You Know My Name, Look Up The Number is fun to listen to, and musically well done.

[@mariomf1644]

@@cancerandaids3822 Well said! But at this point it's a fact that no one can say that they were a bad group 😆

[@mariomf1644]

@@phillydisco totally agree!!!

[@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820]

Mm...Personally I like the early albums more than any of the ones after Rubber Soul. They are all masterpieces, but the early albums are masterpieces of rock and roll / pop, while the later ones are like pieces in an art gallery. They are both enjoyable for their own reasons.

[@nickchurch4102]

This is my favorite Beatles album, so glad you got to this one. Basically from this album forward everybody has a different favorite album, if that tells you anything about how good the rest is. Won’t spoil anything but from Rubber Soul onwards, the beatles basically rewrite music history

[@salernolake]

Rubber Soul was the first album where the Beatles had full creative control, with producer George Martin acting more as a facilitator and collaborator - rather than a director. The Beatles started working on the album in late September 1965, immediately after they returned from a 32 concerts in 32 day North American tour. The record label gave them a hard deadline to have recording complete by mid-November, so the LP would be ready for Christmas sales. The Beatles had already decided to record only original material for the LP - so including their next single, they had six weeks to record 16 new song!!! John and Paul reached deep into their musical bag of tricks to come up with the required quota: 1) "What Goes On" was recorded for the "With The Beatles" LP in 1963, but was left off because they were unhappy with the result. With Ringo's help they reworked it into a Ringo song, and Ringo received a writing credit. 2) "Michelle" features a tune that Paul conceived back when he and John were students at the Liverpool Institute of Art in the late 1950's. Apparently the two were taking an art class given by a snooty French professor. Paul apparently made up a parody song of the professor, using the Michelle tune to entertain John and their fellow students in the school cafeteria. Apparently when time was running short in the Rubber Soul sessions, John reminded Paul of this - telling him that the tune was far too good to waste. So Paul quickly cooked up the song, with John contributing the middle eight based on a Nina Simone song he liked. 3) "Run for your Life" was a quick composition by John based on an Elvis Presley song. John later regretted having written it, and disavowed it because of the misogyny of its lyrics.

[@angelonintendo]

Great stuff, I never believe those "first listen videos", but I just go with the flow, the difference of your channel is that you are the only one so far with great musical knowledge and teach us stuff too.

[@jnagarya519]

Ah -- finally! The LP with which "The Beatles" REVOLUTION took off -- the feet on the ground launching pad for which was "Beatles for Sale". I love your enthusiasm!

[@thomastimlin1724]

The Beatles revolution started long before Rubber Soul, just by them being the Beatles in any capacity...it came in increments, in steps with each album. No one wore long hair until 1964 in the USA. At the time that was considered revolutionary along with the "Yeh Yeh Yeh" noisy guitars and drums mentality parents didn't understand. Many adults thought the Beatles were a Russian communist plot to disrupt the youth, lol. Made no sense since the boys came from England. Must have been the Queen's idea lol. Yes they started to spend more time in the studio, and touring the next year stopped and freed them up to do so.

[@joe6096]

@@thomastimlin1724 Rubber Soul was their first album of all completely original music. This isn't the mop-tops singing She Loves You to 14 year old little girls any more. This is "you better run for your life if you can little girl, catch you with another man, that's the end little girl". Things are...... different. THAT'S the Revolution here.

[@jnagarya519]

@@thomastimlin1724 Did you miss the fact that Elvis and his contemporaries wore long hair and were criticized for it. When Elvis went into the army and his hair was cut, the media celebrated about his, well, being brought down to size. And the "parents" were complaining about "too loud" during the 1950s.

[@jnagarya519]

@@joe6096 Uh, no: 1964'a "A Hard Day's Night" was all original songs. "Rubber Soul" was 1965.

[@jnagarya519]

And the REVOLUTION was in not only the maturing songwriting -- John and Paul were songwriters; that was their focus -- but also the production.

[@jimirayo]

Yes. The thing that stands out and makes this album 'advanced' is the lyrical content. They moved from writing love songs to writing about life experiences. That's the real change.

[@CallMeCaroline]

I personally really enjoy songs which lyrics explore topics other than love, so I'm looking forward to see if this cotinues!

[@Kaleidoscopia]

@@CallMeCaroline The Beatles pioneered this shift in pop music from writing banal lovey dovey lyrics to exploring more personal themes and topics, and also some really funny ones. So YES, it continues!

[@buddyneher9359]

@@CallMeCaroline you will not be disappointed!

[@ronalddobis6782]

@@CallMeCaroline well George writes about his taxes on the next album.

[@darrinstinson2890]

Dylan and pot heavily influenced the lyrical changes. John said Rubber Soul was the pot album, Revolver was the acid album

[@roadwerthy]

Great opportunity to revisit these gorgeous creations with fresh ears, vicariously, through your discovery. Thank you for the tour and for your interest in, understanding of, and respect for the music.

[@aBeatleFan4ever]

OMG... I am really enjoying watching the joy on your face - as you listen to these songs. You are giving me the great pleasure of getting to re-live listening to these great songs for the first time - all over again. Thanks so much for doing that.

[@willhorowitz8806]

This is a transition album for the Beatles in my opinion.

[@TTM9691]

Totally agree. 1965 in general is a transitional year for them, and also in the context of the 60s in general. It's a real cusp year.

[@hondomckee.8232]

It's the album where more things crept in, including cynicism. It's not always happy and light, but more worldly.

[@unknown_username314]

“in my life” is one of the most beautiful songs of all time, but besides that “you won’t see me” has always been my favorite track on this

[@tdsims1963]

My #1 favourite Beatles album and definitely in my Top Three Albums To Take To A Desert Island.

[@vickjr98]

Is either Revolver or Abbey Road part of that top 3?

[@eddiekraemer]

Hey Caroline, I love your enthusiasm and your musical knowledge. You are pointing out things that I "knew", but never realized that I knew it ("Oh yeah, they did do that in that song, didn't they!!"). I have done this very same program with 3 generations of kids, all between 10 and 15.... It took about a year with each kid. I gave them each album (in order) and let them listen to it for a month. Then we would get together and they would share likes and dislikes. it started by me wondering how the millennial generation would like The Beatles if they were to come out today. According to my "students" they would be a hit. I took them to see Paul live here in Texas as their "Graduation" ceremony. We are out here trying to guess what your reaction will be for certain songs coming up in the next month... HOW FUN! Thank you!!

[@dolnick7]

Really enjoy your reactions and insights. You remind me once again of the incredible musical strides the Beatles were making, and it's still only 1965! Any group would be lucky to have a bass playing Paul, a drumming Ringo, or a rhythm guitar playing John, or a songwriter like Paul, John, or George. The Beatles had all of them. What are the odds? Still blown away 50 years later.

[@scottamichie]

And George on lead guitar, the anti-lead guitarist…it’s his greatness. Like Miles Davis-the genius of the note not played. Less is more.

[@bennyfactor1]

Bought this on the day it was released along with Day Tripper/We Can Work It Out. We had been listening on and off all day at school to the double A side over our transistor radios so couldn't wait to get my grubby hands on the single and album. I even took a short cut through a prohibited area in school at the end of the day just to get hold of them a few minutes earlier.

[@doriskray1430]

Yep. Nothing else mattered. Glued to transistor all day to hear latest Beatles’ single. NEVER disappointed.

[@feedigli]

And always released just before summer vacation, and just before Christmas...

[@ClearTheRubble7]

I discovered the Beatles later as a kid, starting in '69 and buying their albums in the early '70's. They had only one Magical Mystery Tour album, but I experienced every one of their albums as a magical mystery tour, a musical adventure. My dad, a professional jazz musician, was given the Abbey Road album by one of his students, which he then played for our whole family. He had never liked rock music before, but the Beatles changed his mind--and all of our minds...

[@jlrthebassplayer]

This was so much fun! thank you Caroline you were clearly having a blast and I love your music insights too! You reminded me that I overtime changed the key of Norwegian Wood to better suit my acoustic guitar part that I adapted. I'm going to subscribe and watch all your content, thank you this was fun!

[@pedrovalente207]

rubber soul is just... PERFECT.