First Time Hearing PROCOL HARUM - A Whiter Shade of Pale (Live Denmark 2006) REACTION

[@DianaJG8]

The lead singer, Gary Brooker, just died about 10 days ago, so this is very timely, Devin. I've always loved this song! 50 years old and it's still fresh! - YES, it is a great slow dance song!! God bless! ❤💯

[@Music-Is-Real-Love]

I had no idea the Lead Singer died. Thank you for commenting.

[@DianaJG8]

@@Music-Is-Real-Love - Sorry to deliver the bad news, but thank you for your kind comment! 😊

[@MrDaiseymay]

Gary Brooker was 76. R.I.P.@@Music-Is-Real-Love

[@KajunMoo70]

The original from 1967 was my favorite UNTIL I was blessed to hear Gary Brooker sing along with the Danish Symphonic Orchestra and Chorus. Absolutely glorious version. A sad note to add, Gary passed away at the age of 76 from cancer on February 19, 2022. He left a fabulous legacy of music for us to enjoy❤️

[@mamaasaiz]

Another great performance of the Danish National Symphony is their rendition of The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5_YgHSoesukfdE

[@nancywood7696]

My favorite song from 1967 even better in 2006! RIP Gary Brooker. Thank you for this beautiful masterpiece!

[@bobleek6975]

Song is based on one of the Canterbury Tales. R.I.P. GARY BROOKER, This man had one of the greatest voices. Usually someone starts to lose their vocal range with age, but not Gary.

[@julielevinge266]

Thank goodness, always thought it was “Miller told his tale” referred to Chaucer’s Canterbury tales, Millers tale about all human frailties. But have been told over & over that theirs a white moth called a Miller to do with coke? Never made sense to me,line before is obviously about a coke spoon shaped like very small ladle, but to me that fits perfectly with”Millers tale”✊♥️🌹

[@carolyncappitelli1460]

RIP Gary Brooker

[@dagmar.6954]

Love this song. I actually prefer the studio version from the 60's as it is the one I grew up on. This live version is very good though as it shows how powerful Gary Brooker's voice was even as he got older. "Conquistador" is another great song by Procol Harum. Sad to hear of his passing recently.

[@lisawall3386]

NO! When did he pass?

[@dagmar.6954]

@@lisawall3386 Feb 19/22

[@lisawall3386]

@@dagmar.6954 thanks for info. Such a legend. May sweet Gary rest in eternal, music filled peace.

[@Alberto_1965_BR]

Amazing performance of one of the best songs ever made RIP Gary Brooker

[@reneemallicone6349]

When a song sounds just as good 50 years after it was first released should tell everybody something. One of the greatest songs ever written. It goes straight to your soul! Gary Booker died about a year ago! RIP!

[@uncabuzz118]

Ironically, lead singer Gary Brooker passed away just 9 days ago on February 19.

[@Dreamtime-Walker]

My Step- Dad’s Favorite Song in English. He Heard it Playing in a Dept Store in the 70’s and Loved it so Much he Bought the Album that Same Day.🤍

[@BOOMNERD51]

That's how music gets me! Gotta have it, know who wrote it and buy a copy! ❤

[@simondalzell9673]

You've been schooled young man.I 've loved this song for 40 years.This is my favourite version. RIP Gary. Sorely missed.

[@shirleycollins6241]

I remember this song as a kid but this version is so amazing.

[@susanchadwick7763]

The singer is Gary Brooker and he just passed away Feb 19th. Such an awesome song

[@talltulip]

The first few bars of this original record, with that distinctive organ, comprise one of the most iconic, instantly recognizable songs of the 60s that can instantly transport me back to that time as if in a time machine. Always a favorite.

[@lavantavincent6555]

I was young when I first heard this song. Little did I know I would go through my father's old 45 records that he brought from England when my parents moved to Canada, and that would be one of the records he had. My father gave me all of the old 45's about 15 years ago. I still listen to that song. He just passed away 6 months ago, and this song is a very emotional song for me. I will be forever grateful for that and cherish this record.

[@berndschuster1547]

Thank you for the good music! The man on the piano wars Gary Brooker from Band Procol Harum. He died 19.02.22. The good music is forever. RIP Garry.

[@kathleenlandolt5936]

I get a lot of pleasure from watching the younger generations listening to this song for the first time. I just loved your reaction. You may know this by now, but I read somewhere that Gary Brooker not only composed and sang the original version, he also composed the orchestral and choir accompaniment in this version. Amazingly talented person. May he rest in peace, listening to choirs from on high.

[@JamesDolen-dn6wz]

He co-composed the original version along with Matthew Fisher, the group’s original organist.

[@zachmoore4550]

He regrettably died last week

[@jeffreybooth5129]

Truly great performance by all concerned. I have seen procol harum 8 times and they are my all time favourites. Hard to believe I won't see him again there no doubt God has just booked the top of the bill for his concert in heaven

[@geraldbrown640]

The perfect performance of a perfect song.

[@Brandi6666]

Dude, you have the best reactions. You seem like you feel every song as i did when i first heard these classics 40 years ago. And still feel them now🤘❤️

[@jamesdrynan]

I'm sure you realize now it is NOT winter's. The combination of the orchestral arrangement with the iconic song creates something quite profound and moving.

[@mikedickerson521]

The song is about a one night stand or sexual escapade that ended bad. Gary Brooker reminds me of Ray Charles! I surpassed the half century mark last year. I can clearly remember that song playing on a 45. My mother loved this piece.She passed about almost a year ago. At her Memorial Service I pulled together an insane amount of pics. While the pics were showing Whiter shade of pale (this version) was playing. I turned around to see the reaction. It was a challenge to find a dry eye in the Sanctuary! Great videos my friend! Enjoy your holiday!

[@Brandi6666]

One of the most finest concerts you’d ever hear gary recently passed last week😥🤘❤️lead singer of procol harum 70’s rock band

[@franabreu7594]

Gary Brooker died at the age of 76. (R.I.P.) 02.19.2022 Cancer. A remarkable and unforgettable voice. I Love You, Gary. I Love Procol Harum. Forever. 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@wpollock1]

RIP Gary Brooker --the Lord blessed us with his talents for 76 years. Please consider the song Conquistador from the same concert....beautiful!

[@miamidolphinsfan]

This is one of the best from the Summer of Love crowd of hippies

[@debigiroux1811]

Love this reaction and version. Gary Brooker is the singer an just passed away recently. RIP

[@reneewauchula]

The fact that his voice is still perfect after 50 years just puts me in awe

[@michaeldey1894]

While Winter is White, the title is a Whiter Shade of Pale. Love your reactions!

[@knutsto]

There is so many memories to this song. You should also listen to Grand Hotel and Salty dag from the same consert. Absolutly stunning.

[@davidhoneycutt220]

God bless Gary!

[@cindybrooks4800]

You picked a wonderful song brought memories back to me. This is a beautiful song. Remembering that I would play this song over and over. Powerful song 👏❤️🎵🎶🥰

[@thomasbeauchemin1298]

The lead singer is Gary Brooker and sadly he died about a week ago! RIP

[@vickieray]

WHITER not Winter. Gary Brooker on piano & vocals just passed away on Saturday February 19th of cancer 😢 RIP to a most amazing musician ♥️

[@julielevinge266]

Danish symphony orchestra joined Gary on this,amazing, best version ever,remember original, so I’m ancient, but can still appreciate music thank god😂✊♥️

[@marcieharreld286]

Now you need to react to "Nights In White Satin" released in 1967 also!!!🎵🎼🎶🤘🤘🤘

[@BOOMNERD51]

Great reaction, quickly bringing yourself up to speed. 1964 he was in a band the Paramount's, and when he sings Ray Charles or Perry Sledge's "When a Man Loves a Woman" that powerful voice was embarking on a great musical journey he just got better, RIP, Gary Brooker, your music stays with us, a blessing! ❤️

[@philipshort7491]

RIP the late great Gary brooker, best wishes from the north east of England.

[@jimpaquette8007]

RIP Gary Brooker thanks for this great masterpiece!

[@mikes62soupcan]

It brings a tear to my eye every time I hear it.

[@JUSTMAR1E]

This song has been on my playlist for a long long time and I listen to it at night and it helps me sleep. I got a lot of songs that help me sleep and this is one of my favorites

[@simondalzell9673]

You got CLASS Marie.

[@jas8581]

You should try the Danish National Symphony Orchestra doing The Good The Bad and The Ugly.

[@SQUATCHY614]

Singing orchestra backup singers all were great. What a treat to hear that live. As mentioned by another viewer I also grew up with this in the 60’s. When in came over the new FM radio I blasted it. I love both versions. Thanks for showing it.

[@SQUATCHY614]

A classic for sure.

[@carolynsaint6263]

Whiter Shade of Pale, not Winter. 😇

[@brendamatthews9866]

Beautiful... This song tugs at your heart strings like no other. RIP Gary Brooker . you will long be remembered

[@dropzone9639]

Hey Devin. It is Whiter Shade of Pale...not Winter Shade. It is a classic. Just wait for it.....💕💕💕

[@ruththomas6361]

I'm one of those old people who listened to this stuff when we were young, so now maybe you can understand why we view new music as crap. You need to listen to Knights in White Satin, too. There was just SO much great music being written and sung; I sure miss those days. At least I have all the greats on CD so I can listen all day to real music.

[@julielevinge266]

Funnily enough I love old & new music! Shocked to hear you describe new music as 💩? You sound just like my mum when all this stuff came out😂😂😂 I’ve taught my children about old music & they in turn have introduced me to so many amazingly talented young performers & so it goes on thanks to god✊😍🌹

[@mikes62soupcan]

There is no comparison in my humble opinion, the old stuff shames modern music.

[@thunderstruck5484]

Beautiful! A choir of Angels! Thanks again

[@cricketpitts3744]

R.I. P Gary Booker!! This is a beautiful song. It's whiter shade of pale !! No winter

[@kayjohnson8377]

Rest In Peace, Garry Brooker. Lead singer for Provo Harum, passed away last week. One of the most beautiful Melodie’s in rock.

[@byronmitchell3784]

Lead singer Gary Brooker of PROCOL HAREM, "WHITER SHADE OF PALE"...This was a nice tribute to him, especially since he just passed away a few days ago. The song was released in 1967. You should give this a listen to. More... "CONQUISTADOR"..

[@susieq9801]

Please listen to the original of this song as well as their song "Conquistador".

[@jackrobinson6277]

One of the best reactions to this song I have seen. Thank you. RIP Gary Brooker, Thank you for giving us over 55 years of amazing music. You will never be forgotten Sir.

[@gailsimmons5270]

We just lost Gary (the singer) just the other day😔🙏🏼

[@757optim]

While it's not supposed to be a reference to Chaucer, the "Miller's Tale" would be apt to shock a "lady". Sad to learn that Gary Brooker has passed. RIP.

[@garylorentzen228]

First released in May 1967, this song became part of the sound track of my first term at university that summer. It's one of the most iconic songs of the era. The lyrics are considered 'psychedelic rock' in their dream-like poeticism, but, according to Gary Brooker (the lead singer) in an interview, he said it's about a break up where she's leaving him with no real stated reason. She's pale with nerves when she tells him she's leaving, and when he doesn't accept there's no reason, she turns a whiter shade of pale. RIP Gary Brooker. For those of us who were listening to you from the beginning, you will forever be missed.

[@kathleenlandolt5936]

Elsewhere I've read that some of the lyrics refer to "The Miller's Tale" from the "Canterbury Tales". Both explanations are probably correct.

[@marcieharreld286]

This was "born" in 1967 when I was 15!!!! Spectacular year for music!!!💜💜💜💜🎵🎼🎶🥁🎸🎧🎹🎤🎙 Gary Brooker....the voice of many angels!!!🤘🤘🤘🤘 Bless you for this reaction!!! 🤘🤘

[@michelleydenisey4697]

I've always loved this song, but this version with the symphony is fabulous!

[@Farsider3955]

Great reaction video! First time viewer here (🤔 just might have to subscribe if you do more of this quality) 👍 I have some comments, interpreting the lyrics of this song which gives it even a deeper dimension - I will share that at the end of this - (and sorry for this detailed commentary, but I think you will find it helpful if you listen to the song again and/or share it with others). The name of the song is actually “A Whiter Shade Of Pale” (not “Winter”) Gary Brooker’s incredible singing in this live performance matched - or perhaps even exceeded - the quality of the original 1967 recording that took place 40 years earlier. The band’s name comes from a couple of possible sources. One of the band members in ‘67 had a cat named Procol Harum. This is Latin for “Far beyond these things”…. Personally, I think they named the band after the cat. 😁 This song and about 3 or 4 others defined the sound and the scene that was the “Summer of Love”. Unfortunately, that beautiful era only lasted about three years…. Innocence lost - marked by another outdoor concert in December ‘69 at Altamont - The Rolling Stones - they hired the Hells Angels motorcycle gang to be their “security” force - 4 people died that night. However, great music continued to come out from the late 60s all through to the mid 90s. But 1967 through Woodstock 1969 was magic. There has been much debate/misunderstanding regarding the lyrics. I believe I can unlock the mystery for you. The lyrics are mostly metaphorical. The song is about a young couple who are attending a party perhaps at a ballroom - maybe even on a ship. They were either entertainers for the crowd, or they were just part of the crowd dancing….”We skipped the Light Fandango” but instead did cartwheels across the floor, implying that they were having a great time, perhaps even on their way to getting drunk. The room seem to be shaking apart as they “ordered another drink”, but the waiter brought a tray of many drinks. As the night wore on, the young man was fast becoming interested in having a more private intimate time with this young girl…. But yet even through her near drunkenness, she sensed it, and became frightened. As the young man shuffled through his “playing cards” - a metaphor for looking for that winning hand to convince her to go with him - she again was unable or unwilling to give into him. Even as he told her stories, and lies about himself to impress and take advantage of her she knew she was potentially headed for trouble as “The truth was plain to see”. The vestal virgin metaphor clearly implied that she was young, inexperienced, and not ready for what she feared was his ultimate intent. But he kept on with his tales and lies, and he “would not let her be”…..ramping up the pressure on her to give in. This frightened her tremendously. I have heard, but I cannot confirm, that Gary Brooker and his cowriter actually wrote two more verses, that were never recorded. We will probably never hear the end of that story. Again, I want to say your reaction video was wonderful and genuine. Well done.

[@romanazzitube]

AMAZING ! Step 1 - Orchestra prelude Step 2 - Gary Brooker and orchestra Step 3 - Gary Brooker + orchestra + band (Procol Harum) + choir “A WHITER SHADE OF PALE” was released by Procol Harum in 1967 and it was their first single ❤ RIP Gary Brooker 1945 - 2022 *PROCOL HARUM is a latin expression that means "beyond these things"

[@adam.4487]

This song is so weird but I love it. Old version and his new. Here are the lyrics, still don't make sense, but nice to know. Procol Harum 1967 We skipped the light fandango Turned cartwheels 'cross the floor I was feeling kinda seasick But the crowd called out for more The room was humming harder As the ceiling flew away When we called out for another drink The waiter brought a tray And so it was that later As the miller told his tale That her face, at first just ghostly Turned a whiter shade of pale She said, 'There is no reason' And the truth is plain to see But I wandered through my playing cards And would not let her be One of sixteen vestal virgins Who were leaving for the coast And although my eyes were open They might have just as well've been closed And so it was that later As the miller told his tale That her face, at first just ghostly Turned a whiter shade of pale And so it was that later Source: LyricFind Songwriters: Gary Brooker / Keith Reid / Matthew Fisher A Whiter Shade of Pale lyrics © Onward Music Limited, T.R.O. Inc

[@julielevinge266]

Where’s chorus? Goes with Miller told his tale??

[@dennispaskel4487]

my first junior high school dance with a girl in 1968 never yes was very slow been playing this song for 50 years, written in Middle English by Geoffrey Chaucer between 1387 and 1400, The Miller's Tale is one of 24 stories, RIP Mr. Garry Brookert,

[@leezion5457]

Gotta say it. The song is "A WHITER Shade of Pale," although I imagine "winter" could work just as well. And to one of the commenters down below, the women are VESTAL virgins, which is to say., priestesses of Vesta, the Roman goddess of the hearth. I'm not out to spoil people's fun, but if you love the song, you should want to understand it more. And by the way, for your next Procol Harum song, try "Conquistador."

[@chris...9497]

The lyrics are enigmatic and meant to be enigmatic. If anyone tells you they 'know' what the song is exactly about, they are speaking from ignorance. The meaning has been debated for decades, since the first time it was released in 1967. The lyricist was a big fan of surrealism and wrote this more as a mood piece painted in words. There's even a couple interviews where he (Keith Reid) denies his mention of the 'miller told his tale' has anything to do with Chaucer. All interpretations are speculative. Some enigmas are meant to stay mysterious. But wasn't this performance beautiful? Gary Brooker was the only original member to perform at this music festival. What is incredible is how little his voice had changed in 40 years. If you listen to the 1967 original with a 22-year-old Brooker singing, and compare it to the voice in this 2006 recording, you'll find they are almost identical. RIP, Mr Brooker.

[@twwtjohns]

I can't believe we just recently lost lead Singer Gary Brooker on February 19, 2022.

[@debbienewton909]

It's a WHITE-R shade of pale, not "winter". Idk what the lyrics mean either, lol, but I was only 7 when this song came out. As a teenager, I thought it was probably about drugs. Love the music and the voice though! Enjoyed the live version, but I think this one is better: kzbin.info/www/bejne/g5OWmoOGYtl7mqM

[@thomasjorge4734]

You got it, "Being Blest"!

[@markhorton8578]

The song lyrics are cryptic becuase it is the rock equivalent of a surrealist painting. Many images and scenarious with pale faces. Going all the way back to the Millers Tale (1485?). Whose face would have been ghostly with flour dust, and who would have turned pale when he realised he had been betrayed, yet correctly, blamed himself. Gary Brooker sang it and composed the original music.

[@sheririos7534]

Gary Brooks was the lead singer, recently passed away. Please listen to the studio version of this song. It is beautiful. The Word whiter is pronounced white-r shade of pale. Lyrics don't really make sense. God bless!!

[@lorrietrabing2425]

See all the grey hair in the crowd. Our music from decades before you were born. And the time when we listened to songs like this on LSD and alcohol.

[@AliasMark69]

You really want to react to "TIME HAS COME TODAY" - The Chamber Brothers - Album long version. It is an experience you will never forget. 4 black brothers with a white drummer created this ICONIC Masterpiece.

[@pamelajohnson6199]

Of course, the original did not have an orchestra and choir lol, it straight up rocked! But his vocals here are better than '67 original. RIP Gary

[@marcieharreld286]

Rest in Paradise dear man and thank you for the many memories!!!🎶🎼🎵💜💜💜

[@stephenhuber1219]

The melody is from BACH Sleepers Wake and Air on a G-String

[@stephenhuber1219]

A Salty Dog and Conquistador same concert

[@debbiegoodman4233]

Gary Brooker and B.J. Wilson are deceased. RIP.

[@carollittle1059]

This is a huge production of the song, the radio version didn't have this part.

[@timparr8794]

his name is Gary Booker and he died this year on Feb. 19, 2022

[@israelgonzales6923]

A very small peice of heaven indeed roams this earth. What an amazing group of God given talent was put together here for this iconic performance. Thank you Devin for the reaction video.

[@davidtullis2810]

RIP Gary

[@timparr8794]

it is not a winter shade of pale !! it is a whiter shade of pale

[@donnysmith946]

WHITE-R Shade of Pale Please!!!!

[@shirleybuffington6420]

The lead singer passed away one day last week

[@bullmoon1718]

"WHITER" not winter! 🙂

[@Stephen-nd1sx]

Grateful Dead 🌹 Ripple

[@brendahipsher273]

GARY BOOKER, JUST PASSED DAYS AGO.

[@brendahipsher273]

Rip Mr Booker. Thank you.

[@stephenhuber1219]

There are two extra verses on KZbin

[@carlajimenez5483]

I love this song however I prefer the original from 1967. RIP Gary Brooker.

[@ekim0513]

WHIT - ER not Winter

[@claimguy]

RIP Gary - L.E.G.E.N.D.

[@ricardoperez-nd2es]

GOD BLESS YOU BRO 🙏☝️

[@cpbricef]

Gary, RIP, Neil

[@donnagreen3626]

Garry Brooker

[@AD4MRick]

RIP Gary

[@carollittle1059]

RIP GARY

[@russellkaplan1818]

Witer

[@russellkaplan1818]

Writer