First Time Reaction | A Perfect Circle - "Judith"

[@mm9773]

Also affectionately known as “The one where Paz puts her hair up”.

[@Theomite]

Until the day we get "The one where Paz blew Matt/Jimmy in public while in Zwan."

[@gitaaa7740]

I love that part! Always makes me smile and she doesn’t it in time!

[@joshuapendleton5961]

That part is responsible for many people falling in love with her!!!

[@gitaaa7740]

@@joshuapendleton5961 isn’t it awesome! Great comment! That’s when I did! Such insight you have!

[@detrockcity3]

Such a nice touch.

[@michaelcastillo3231]

By far, one of the most underrated, bad ass moments in a rock video is where she puts her hair up during the break.

[@jeffjones2021]

Yes, Paz is such a badass bassist.

[@CheeTooTheeBee]

And she’s in heels. 🤌🏽

[@manray0703]

That scene was sped up because she didnt do it fast enough at normal speed.

[@davemcduringo4377]

Dunno, this is the top comment on any post of this video since the day it came out. Underrated =/= most mentioned detail.

[@lxxlmon8285]

the best bass player in a band

[@FitzieJJ]

Paz tying her hair up is so badass. 16 second belt also does not suck.

[@PorkchopXpress]

One of the greatest moments in film history.

[@tomtomthebear]

I first set my eyes on Paz in this video and immediately fell in love with her for the rest of my life..!! 🤣🤣

[@danigoddess]

F***ing iconic! She dares to remain her feminine self while breaking barriers in a “man’s” world.

[@niles8102]

That has ways been my favorite part

[@chrisrowan702]

Paz is great. Lots of haters upset she is the bassist for Pixies, instead of Kim Deal. Kim left, and didn't want to be there. Paz has earned her place in that band.

[@mpfiveO]

Many have described Maynard’s bands this way: Tool is the Brain, A Perfect Circle is the Heart, and Puscifer is the Genitalia

[@mpfiveO]

@@GZP1023 oh I agree, they just never clicked for me

[@VegasJPH]

100% accurate. 😂

[@soth1sol]

TOOL/square/land/red/father/king/authority/analytic/left-hemisphere/ +1 APC/circle/water/blue/mother/queen/question/intuitive/right-hemisphere/ -1 PUSCIFER/squarethecircle/fire/golden/child/thinkforyourself/creative/46&2/ ZERO! "is this your brain on tool?" - jello biafra, parabola commentary (A: yes, yes it is)

[@VatnikSlayer2799]

@@GZP1023 I wouldn't describe Puscifer as "Not good" but they're not on par with the other two. They're just not your cup of tea. They're not mine either. I'm not into NIN and that's who they remind me of. Them and Depeche Mode.

[@Soljarag5]

Puscifer didn't "click" for me until about 2 years so.. Now I love their songs

[@Spooked.J]

This was when he was still in the anger stage of grieving her issue....Wings for Marie/10,000 Days will show you his coming to terms with her passing. It will pull at your heart. 🤘❤️

[@soth1sol]

judith, 2-3 years before her death wings, 2-3 years after her death

[@Spooked.J]

@@soth1sol I edited it...you're correct.

[@seanikins2972]

@@Spooked.J makes me a little emotional at just the mention of 10,000 days....

[@davidward9737]

No I have to concur. This is a very powerful song. People say I only listen to this once a year

[@iconoclastvii]

I'm pretty much in a Judith frame of mind all the time re: religion.

[@darkphoenix2]

The pure blunt honesty of this song's lyrics always stood out to me. "Fuck your God", "he did this", "the one who left you broken down and paralyzed"...he's questioning her by trying to point out why her faith doesn't make sense, but there's a bitterness to it. These are thoughts he may have never articulated right to her face, but feelings he wrestled with inside and decided to let out in this song. The instrumentals really back up the anger, and the backup vocals from Billy Howerdel are the finishing touch. Just a really good song.

[@willvr4]

Exactly, I have these thoughts all the time. But I'm not going to say it out loud to someone who is religious when they are suffering because there's no point to it. For all I know, I may turn to God on my deathbed just to feel comfortable, even if it's not real.

[@willfromyadkinville]

but she never stopped believing! and never will i! and i truly appreciate this song because we need to have a conversation. that is the most important thing!

[@mikesale6474]

Very well put dark

[@jamesrouse3466]

I think it is also equally relevant to point out that Maynard supposedly (somebody verify whether this is true or not) gave his life to Christ a few years back as well... We have all had those moments of frustration in our lives and questioned our faiths, but in the end we can either depend on our own strength and understanding or we can choose to depend on His. ❤

[@DebNKY]

​@@jamesrouse3466thank you, I'm glad you get it. I hear his pain and disappointment in this beautiful song.

[@LeglessWonder]

Fun anecdote. I was in high school when this came out, and had several friends in bands. One guy was a singer for one and they would do shows at schools sometimes (dances and whatnot) and usually had Judith in their set list. But the schools didn’t allow them to cuss in the songs. So he would always scream “HUG YOUR DOG!” It’s been over 20 years and it still makes me laugh

[@Muzikrazy213]

That is just a fantastic KZbin comment. Whatever you are being legless, thank you for sharing 🤘

[@kylecharles7002]

This video is directed by my favorite living director, David Fincher. He made Zodiac, Se7en, Fight Club, Social Network and Panic Room etc. I love what he did with this as well. He has a huge back catalogue of music videos, could be a cool deep dive later down the path?

[@spiknaaj]

As a Christian I absolutely love and appreciate this song. Maynard’s feelings and truth are as valid as anyone else’s, and deserve no less respect. And honestly, who would feel any different after experiencing what he has. The most important thing to me about God, the universe, or whatever you choose or not choose to believe in, is truth. And you can’t get much more raw, honest truth than this. And Paz! Can’t think of anyone else more suited to replace Kim Deal in The Pixies. What an absolute legend.

[@JonathanVee]

Yes, same here. Maynard's open honesty in all his writing is amazing.. Even as a Christian myself I can totally understand his pain and his point of view in this song. Following the songs through to wings 1&2 is to experience a lifetime of learning and understanding. He doesn't sing to spread hate, he sings to communicate. I so appreciate it, and feel the journey he has walked. Such an amazing artist.

[@spiknaaj]

@@JonathanVee so well said! The whole journey through all those songs is heart wrenching.

[@SunDedGon]

I greatly respect & admire your perspectives as you both stated it perfectly: Truth & communication. I'd like to add empathy as well. I'd also like to say that I'm an Atheist...& my favorite all-time artist is the Christian Metal band 'Demon Hunter' 🤘

[@ericminton6084]

I think even as Christians we still have moments where we question why things happen. It is called being human.

[@jarrodpitts5632]

@@ericminton6084 then you arent really a true christian are you then since it says you should have undying faith in god and never to question god... this is a one of the many major issues with god and christians. you know its bullsh*t but you just dont want to face that reality.

[@DowntownTasty]

It also wasn’t just really his frustration with religion. It was also his frustration with his moms church who said her condition was her fault for not being a good enough Christian. Even though she was incredibly devout already.

[@p0kkitr0kkit34]

I mentioned Wings for Marie and 10000 days in the last Tool video. A Perfect Circle is a great side project where we get to hear the absolutely insane range of Maynards voice talent! I can't wait!!

[@demonicdoc-29]

They have to be together it dont work another way!!!

[@at0micsp0rk]

I came here to suggest Wings for Marie and 10,000 days. I think it is their most emotional and haunting track.

[@p0kkitr0kkit34]

@@at0micsp0rk they really are, it's sad to know that Maynard has reservations about sharing them at all because they are so deeply personal to him. Even though, I am deeply grateful to him for doing so. Haunting is a perfect description. 👍👍

[@p0kkitr0kkit34]

@@demonicdoc-29 absolutely!! Back to back! Otherwise, you don't get the meaning of what Maynard was trying to Lament. They are absolutely heartbreaking and haunting tracks that are the best I've ever had the privilege of experiencing. 👍👍

[@Fenthule]

After hearing this song, and knowing the meaning behind it, absolutely agree these should be her next Tool songs.

[@Duct_Tape.]

The vocal harmonies at the end are pretty soul stirring, tbh.

[@MacAnAirchinnighJM]

You’re gonna dig APC, they’re not Tool but I actually gravitated toward them more in my younger years. Aenima and APC because of the heaviness and shorter songs. Now that I’m 40 I can vibe with the longer stuff and love it equally. But everything Maynard touches turns to gold.

[@neonom1024]

Broad strokes are that Tool is the masculine, APC is the feminine, and Puscifer is the baser animal instincts like lust, etc.

[@sarajade5111]

This entire album is emotionally charged. It's amazing.

[@kevinjohnson4288]

I can listen to the entire album on loop for hours. probably my favorite album of all time. Not a bad track on it

[@davidward9737]

I'm a diehard Tool fan but when APC came out I gave them a chance, glad I did. 3 Libras always makes me tear up. Aileen is on her journey, her sails have been set and the wind(songs) will take her there.

[@TheAnonJohn]

'...eyes of a fallen angel, eyes of a tragedy...' hits me every time

[@eduarDOGames560]

Breña is a beautiful song as well.

[@davidward9737]

@@TheAnonJohn same here, so powerful. Very emotional song from the beginning "I threw you the obvious to see if there is more behind" Also the ending "You dont, you dont see me, you dont see me at all"

[@bootcamp661]

When I first heard APC, I thought, "wow! Listen to these Tool wanabees!!"😂 Little did I know, it was Maynard the whole time😏

[@davidward9737]

@@bootcamp661 that is a great assessment. I can see how people would think that at the time, the voice wasn't recognizable to you? Thanks for sharing your experience of it

[@rubaidaallen2764]

Judith is such a powerful song. A scathing indictment. MJK is known for telling it like it is, which is why we love him so much. I saw APC in 2000 and this song was one of the highlights of the evening. Glad you love the song and love your reaction as always!

[@wammons007]

your emotional appearance is powerful makes me fell like you do understand. thanks

[@claymonster5807]

THERE it is...... outstanding choice!

[@maxdamagusbroski]

not sure how I missed APC reactions, awesome

[@paulpalumbo2734]

If your reacting to Judith then you at some point need to react to TOOL “Wings for Maria Pt1 & Pt2) which is also about Maynard’s mother.

[@duffmanx2000]

THIS THIS THIS

[@chapelperilous9966]

True, these two songs are the following up from a more reflective side of Maynard and coming to terms with what the faith meant to his mother.

[@Hexenkind1]

Wings is the definition of a masterpiece.

[@acxrn]

Yup, and that will bring the tears for sure. Always does for me.

[@soth1sol]

maynard's mother interpretation occults much deeper meaning regarding "ocean (of chaos)" of mind, by which TOOL encourages listeners to "(learn to) swim". "mer de noms" = sea of names. "threw you the obvious and you flew with it on your back, a name in your recollection, down among a million same. difficult not to feel a little bit disappointed, and passed over when i've looked right through, see you naked but oblivious. and you don't see me." marie is a name derived from word for the "sea". a "marinade", for instance, is a salty brine. anyways, try it out. don't just focus on maynard's mother, but "mother of mind", of a collective. recall "merkaba" lyrics: "omniscient, omnipotent, omnipresent, without judgement" (without condition) ...from 10000 days wings 2: "judith marie, unconditional oneeeeeeeee!"

[@cavinbardi2375]

Your reactions are so authentic & true. I would love to see you react to more & obscure bands. You are a true treasure and fan of music. Thanks for being the awesomeness that is you.

[@notdynomonkey]

My thoughts are your exact words on this subject, and I grew up in religion. This song hit hard when it came out......and still does. Awesome reactions and LOVE your channel. Now listen to the other 2 of the trilogy as people have suggested.

[@Army_Rob]

I'm thinking if you haven't hit by the time this drops, then this reaction will surely put you over, sooooi happy 30k Aileen 🎉🥳🎉

[@AileenSenpai]

You’re so sweet 😭❤️❤️❤️

[@tonyyul703]

@@AileenSenpai you better react to *The Doomed* by A Perfect Circle ⭕

[@jakecameron2976]

I discovered Tool, APC, Puscifer when I was 36. I’m now 45 and their music has changed my life for the better.

[@eggstu]

3 Libras, Sleeping Beauty, Orestes, Gravity, Weak and Powerless, The Package, The Outsider, Passive. just a few good early APC songs to suggest 😊 Oh and Josh Freese on drums is a badass that gets overlooked.

[@jams_world81]

Add By and down the river

[@patrickgiles6376]

Yeah she’s about to go down another amazing rabbit hole!

[@Fireknight7]

If Judith moves you like this than Wings for Marie 1 & 2 will touch your soul! I love watching the emotion manifest in people listening to these songs for the first time! It’s my new addiction! Do Wings for Marie when your ready! Love your content!

[@Spudz76]

Worth getting through the most intense Judith feelings songs all in a row than spreading it out.

[@alfonsoagren414]

I live in the very secularized Sweden. My view is also to just be the kindest and most helpful person hou can. Who knows which religion, if any, is the right one? We all choose our belief. Even none believers. Lets just respect eachother and make the best we can. In the end we all will know. Just treat all respectfully. Helpp the needing when you can. Then all will be good. Cheers!

[@stromghouls]

the entire album is incredible. a gem. josh freeze is a very good drummer.

[@Vitericus1]

This song is nearly the same story with my mom. I was raised Catholic, but at about age 18, I started asking questions and doing research, looking at history, and now I'm a full-fledged and open atheist and it wasn't due to same personal event in my life or my mom's situation; it was more naturally acquired. I think religion (well, certain religions) really stops people from thinking rationally and dims intellect. It has done far more negative things for humanity than good. That said, i don't go out of my way to get in people's face about; I'll debate and discuss in a friendly manner if they ask. Nice reaction 👍 BTW dig the ink and your style. look forward to more of your reactions!

[@Wolf359Actual]

Judith's ashes were spread out on the east slope at Merkin Vineyards. Maynard honored his mother in such a way that we can all experiance a part of her. Caduceus Cellars, and Merkin Vineyards produce some of the finest wines that I enjoy, and Maynard is an incredible vintner.

[@IocaIhost]

Maynard writes and sings for 3 bands-Tool, APC and Puscifer-with Puscifer being what he describes as his “collective creative consciousness.” You can keep yourself from the feeling of monotony by switching between the 3 - all while still being able to appreciate his unbelievable ability to write lyrics.

[@VegasJPH]

AND, he operates 2 vineyards in AZ. Dude's got his life by the horns!

[@soth1sol]

everything he does tells the same story.

[@VeggyZ]

Tool and APC are two of my favorite bands. Puscifer was the odd one out, where I just can't seem to like many songs. Maybe next year I'll try again, again, and maybe then I'll like it. That is what had to happen with Tool at first too - for whatever reason I didn't like it when I was really young. I listened to it later and was blown away. Not sure what was "different" besides my mind.

[@IocaIhost]

@@soth1sol A

[@davejefferson2695]

You're literally reacting to ALL my favourite bands at this point 😭 ❤️

[@VegasJPH]

1st, man you're gorgeous. 😍 2nd, you're going to love APC. The band plays well & Maynard's lyrical genius shines not just in his singing abilities but writing also. Like Tool, there are so many great APC songs

[@michaeltveten8458]

I really feel like Billy and Paz let it all out on this track. I think they truly knew what it meant to Maynard. Props, to Paz for understanding that she was on this track, cuz she deserved to be. She added that extra “something” with her Bass-play. Fincher did a good job of switching camera angles at just the right time, to capture the emotion each instrument, and backing-vocal provided. The song is awesome, and the video-editing was on point.

[@od.haroldbchaveza4243]

I don't know you (now i do), first time for me watching you, BUT, a massive THAAAANNKKK YOUUUU!!, Seeing you feeling this song in your soul made me remember the first time i listened the song and it hitted as hard as it could. Wish you the best

[@jameshendricks4846]

I'm moved by your reaction to this and the other music that I have grown up loving. It reminds me of when this music was there for me as a teenager and was the eye opening, soul searching content that was a little more rare just a short time ago. Gorgeous, genuine and willing to do something new!! Thanks!

[@jaypeterson2311]

Thank you for being brave enough to speak about how a lot of us feel about religion. Good work.

[@gaborberkes468]

I love it!One of my all time favorite song 🙂 Just a small detail.The bass player La Paz she just incredible.And Misa /Band-Maid/said in a interview her all time favorite bass player La Paz 🙂 Another thing you should check Perfect Circle: Week and powerless, Outsiders 😉

[@NorthGaReptile]

You and I are on the same page when it comes to faith/religion. It doesn't matter what religion, faith, creed, etc a person comes from, being kind is universal.

[@MacV552]

ah, here it is! glad I found this reaction. I love the part the bassist puts up her hair!

[@shadowplayjack]

Even though this video is over a year old, I’m glad I discovered it. I wasn’t sure at first, but I thought I’d give it a try, and I’m glad I did. Your eloquence and emotional expression are so accurate. Back in 2000, seeing the video the first time, I recall feeling this great amount of exhilaration. I was surprised, captivated and instantly wanted more, so, the excitement for the album was real, and I recall this anticipation to hear the album in its entirety. ‘Lateralus’ was released almost exactly a year later, so there was this period in between where I explored A Perfect Circle, ‘Mer De Noms’ in particular, and it was a remarkable journey, as I learned so much about Billy, and Maynard’s connection to him. Till this very day, listening to Judith and certain songs on the album, it resonates in such an undeniably powerful manner. I can only appreciate seeing a review where someone can show and describe how the music makes them feel, and what they can take from it and make it part of their lives. The impact it has on us is immense, that’s when we realize the power music has. Thank you for your video. I enjoyed it thoroughly.

[@BegToDiffah]

The "Judith" cycle begins with Jimmy where we hear Maynard's shock and pain, proceeds to Judith where we hear his anger, and reaches its climax at Wings for Marie parts 1 & 2... it's quite a journey, quite a work of musical and emotional expression, so bring your tissues when you're ready for WFM.

[@player2860]

You are missing a big part of the picture, namely APC's "passive", which is from a point of denial, where he can't even accept yet what happened to her - instead of the anger expressed in this, the acceptance in "Wings for Marie" and his depression in "Jimmy" - and the stage of bargaining probably in "sleeping beauty"...?

[@Wungolioth]

Just adding that Jimmy is personally my favorite song of the Judith cycle, I love the sonic landscape it paints, and the whole concept of him saving his 11 year old self from the trauma of what happened to Judith, how he was frozen there in that place. It's moving, and oddly uplifting, it's truly one of my favorite songs by Tool.

[@Shake69ification]

Yes, by the time you get to _Wings_ he's seemingly over his initial anger and while he may still have his own views, he seems more accepting and understanding of her beliefs.

[@PorkchopXpress]

The thing I love about Maynard, is he never willingly puts himself in the spotlight. He surrounds himself brilliant musicians in every project he's part of, and doesn't take attention away from their own genius. The man is a master at building REAL supergroups for every mood you're in. ❤

[@folkblues4u]

Paz playing bass in heels is still one of the hottest things I've ever seen in a music video! Don't think women (as a whole) really appreciate how crazy that drives us - women who can function in heels.

[@christopheratkins6640]

Paz putting her hair up then just might be my favorite thing in music ever. You’ve got to react to Jimmy next, and then Wings for Marie/10000 Days (both Tool sings)- the beginning and end of the story.

[@davazz9586]

thanks Aileen - and listeners remember, she did it all for you!

[@vikhaedan]

That reaction earned my sub... your mind is in the right spot, respect..

[@jamesm5883]

I remember when this song came out my had a similar situation happen to her, she was religious but not to the extreme, but without going into detail, I became frustrated with how it could happen, so this song hit home with me, also I agree with you on everything you said about being a good person and everything else you commented on, I've been living with that rule for a very long time, you took the words right out of my mouth lol, on another note this song has a killer groove and an awesome video, keep em coming Aileen! Great stuff!

[@jamalsampson9389]

This actually is my favorite song from A Perfect Circle. I remember this song from back in 2000, when I was 11. Great upload!

[@rcguitarcovers8614]

One of the best songs ever written imo. the lyrics are just so raw and honest, but it was obviously written out of love for a mother who is very sick. And then if you mix it with the instrumentals, you have a song that is actually saying the same thing. As a guitar player i wished i wrote those guitar riffs they are beautiful, especially that riff with the slider, they are so mournful. its very rare nowadays that we get songs where the lyrics, melodies and instrumentals are saying the same thing.

[@BuzzaB77]

I love that how he turns "did it all for you" into major making the sarcasm more obvious.

[@heyskipj]

Stir “The Pot?” Ha! Listened to this song for years before the lyrics finally hit. One of the best opening lines ever. Such a setup. Next would be “Sober” live I guess.

[@chriswesley8497]

Every time I hear this tune, goose bumps! Every time...after all these years still hits me like a 'punch in the f'in mouth!'...Pucifer reference, if I may. Great reaction!

[@danielleva5519]

So glad tool really hits you deep, I love watching your reactions bc it takes me back to the first time hearing tool myself and how those songs affected me and influenced me in my life as well

[@TWOnly666]

One of my favorite songs of all time

[@chadkhouchin]

Aileen, I can feel your passion. not only in your words, expressions but your voice is very soothing.

[@morganash2171]

Love your reactions! Wings for Marie and 10,000 days is the next and final stage of particular struggle/journey in Maynard's life. Definitely worth a listen and to see where his perspective ultimately ends up. It's definitely emotionally powerful and the most beautiful love letter/eulogy to a mother I've ever heard.

[@jaybird4346]

My favorite part of your reaction videos is always your actual reaction to the lyrics. I love it. Keep it going

[@michaelfurman7912]

Love your channel Love your reactions and love that you said "Oh my GOD" at the end ❤

[@nickdanger108]

A Perfect Circle knows how to get into your feelings. A lot of emotionally charged songs! Can’t wait to continue on the Maynard journey with you

[@jainelson8840]

Love your take on this. I’ve been watching your reactions for a bit, was happy to hear you’re on the same page philosophically as me on this. “The Noose” and “The Package” I highly recommend from A Perfect Circle’s Thirteenth Step album.

[@NightBL00D_]

Stumbled upon your channel today, can't stop watching. Your personality aligns closely with mine and I love it. Keep it up! 😃

[@AileenSenpai]

Yay! Thank you!

[@briannieubuurt332]

Can't wait till you get to "wings for Marie 1&2"...still brings me to tears after a million listens. Judith, Jambi, Jimmy, The Patient...so many of the trifecta's material come for Maynard and his mother. A Perfect Circle is where you get to appreciate Maynard's vocal talent. I would like to see you review "3 Libra's" next... you'll understand when that moment comes in the song...when the music actually touches your soul, no cliche, ACTUALLY TOUCHES YOUR SOUL.

[@brendon4558]

😱🤘This is such a good song!! Honestly your videos are the best 😊🖖

[@AileenSenpai]

Thank you! ❤️

[@HorusHeresy1982]

This is one of my fasvourite tracks of all time. Not just the lyrics resonating with me but the sheer composition is always breathtaking.

[@manna6618]

Some of Maynard's best work, both vocally and lyrically, right there. And the Paz hairbun thing, absolutely iconic!

[@Daniel-E-W1979]

LoL I can't believe its taken so long to see a reaction like this, seriously. I first got into tool at the end of highschool, and only a select few of the friends ive met could relate as well. It's great to see the understanding you have for music/lyrics. ❤👍

[@JynxedKoma]

Love Paz always. Especially for how she ties up her hair just in time to continue her epic riff... And just her posture whilst playing, aaaaaauuuhhh... To die for!

[@brucejensen5697]

He has also shown me other ways to look at life that I never seen before I love all of his music

[@TheViceCitySaint]

You are clearly a deep thinker. That is appreciated and respected. 🙂💓👍🏻 And great authentic reaction. Keep smiling. 🙂✌🏻

[@UndergroundRap4eva]

One of the best waltz you'll ever hear. One of the best rock videos to exist. I love the fact that you never really get a good look at his face for the entire video. I think it was the guy who directed Se7en who made this video. He basically did the same with John Doe for the majority of the film. Epic!!!

[@jeffwesthof9711]

Wings for Marie 1 and 2 would be the perfect follow up to this!

[@Loddaphat]

I love your views!!! So true!!! Without sounding like a creep, I love you, I love you, I love you!!!!! You stand for everything music is meant to be!!!!!

[@shadymodnation5781]

A beautiful and honest reaction! Best of luck with your channel! Subscribed!

[@cosmetica5999]

Loving the passion in your reactions, thank you!

[@johnwalters583]

APC is actually Billy Howerdel’s band (guitarist). He is a roadie and is friends with Maynard and wanted to create a band. He made the band Ashes Divide because he felt APC was kind of turning into Maynard’s band. His Ashes Divide album (he only has done one so far) is absolutely amazing.

[@terrynunez7957]

3 Libras Pet The outsider Sleeping beauty The hollow The noose Weak and powerless All of them songs are deep and awesome 👌

[@iczero1224]

This is one of my favourite songs of all time, thank you🤘❤️🤘

[@TheMadMedek]

This song to this day still gives me goosebumps. Next APC song has to be 3 Libras. One of my favorite songs

[@akirameru675]

Tool is the Brain. A Perfect Circle is the Heart.

[@stephenandrew6087]

Best review I’ve seen in a while. New fan, new subscriber as of tonight. Thanks and keep up the good work, cheers from ATX!

[@AileenSenpai]

Thank you so much! 🤘🏼

[@HorridClyde]

I'm tearing up as well listening to this while you react in this video. I relate as my mom was the same with Maynard's. She had autoimmune liver cirrhosis and she suffered painfully 'til her last breath and her faith went even stronger as she was deteriorating very badly.

[@Padregazelle]

So amazing to see you discover the music I’ve lived my life to for decades.

[@crowsheadband5020]

When Paz puts her hair up, and drops that pic on the strings kicking that bass in right after that little solo...well that's the definition of hot 🔥

[@arwiviv]

Nice reaction. Im 52 now and I first heard Perfect Circle when I was in my mid-late 30"s maybe? Of course I had known Tool before then. I get it.

[@ryanolsen8431]

Aileen…you got that right. I believe in being kind and courteous and because some is going to “judge” me when my time is up. Treat people the way you want to be treated.

[@tithannisk7470]

Idk why but something as simple as Paz Lechantin putting her hair up in a bun in this video is one of the sexiest things I've ever seen

[@michaelkyzar504]

A little more about Maynard , he is a very successful wine maker and his Signature wine is named Judith has won several prestigious awards . His Caduceus Cellar and Ostiaries are in Jerome, Az . I’ve been there several times and it was amazing to have his wine while enjoying his art and passion . Highly recommend a visit , and also “Blood into Wine” documentary .

[@AileenSenpai]

Funny enough I was about to order some wine from Caduceus online! Very excited to try I’m a huge fan of wineries and Maynard! 🍷

[@michaelkyzar504]

Fun fact , his wife operates the Puscifer store next door to Caduceus which has a Barber shop downstairs , and I didn’t know at the time but his wife washed my hair before I got the haircut . When I walked upstairs to pay , someone told me that was Maynard’s wife . I’m glad I didn’t know because I’m such a nerd I would of said something to embarrass myself . Also , Judith is a little pricey, but if you like white wine , I recommend The Diddler , and I’m not a huge white wine drinker . Enjoy , and I’ll stop boring your channel with my dumb comments.

[@DrMcnugget1]

Loved the reaction, this song brings me to tears after I knew what it was about. People start to lose their faith and question WHY, then like you said "people say its gods plan" well his plan really sucks. I lost my dad last year cause someone pulled out in front of him while he was on his motorcycle and I started to ask WHY, why does a child molester or murderer get to live but my dad was taken from us. This song always hits home.

[@Tcanderson2]

I know this an older video but when you said the thing about “yeah but what about what the surgeon did”. I literally think those same thoughts all the time. It’s refreshing to hear someone else think that way!

[@kylerichmond4806]

Subbed a while back and have been following your channel for a bit. I have been a Tool fan since mid 90's after running away from a strict/abusive "christian" home at the age of 15. Tool got me through a lot. Tool/ APC/Puscifer are equally tied for my favorite bands of all time, and anything MJK is a part of. His duet with Tori Amos "Mohammad my Friend", his collab with David Bowie "The Disco King" and the Deftones "Passenger" are some of my favorite songs, and I think you would enjoy them as well. Keep up the amazing content.

[@trevortomei2793]

In case you were wondering Billy Howerdel is the leading founder of A Perfect Circle, he's the Guitarist writer and back up vocalist for the Band. He's the lead singer for Ashes Divide. Met him after a show once. Very humble man.I recommend listening to The Stone from Ashes Divide. A Perfect Circle sound with a different Vocal feeling

[@rnrweb1968]

I am the same! I believe in what religion trys to achieve, thou shall not kill, do onto others... but not necessarily the vehicle behind that belief. But I too respect others and want love to prevale!! 😇 We evolve by questioning life!! The music is powerful!!! Much love sweetheart ❤️ More APC please 🙏

[@munchkincatsnz]

There is a short documentary some where online just about the making of the Judith video clip, When she ties her hair up in the video she couldn’t do it (tie it up) in the short time she had between base lines but they still put it in the clip regardless!

[@mornelinell5955]

Suggestions : APC - 3 Libra's, Puscifer - Momma Said, Tool - Wings for Mary pt1 & 2.....Heart wrenching

[@tskeates]

literally only watched this to see the reaction to paz putting her hair up. don't really even know why but defs one of the best rock moments i can think of. so simple but so epic.

[@Hexenkind1]

After that you should listen to "Jimmy" which is also a part of the evolving thought process about his mother and then the final conclusion from the 10.000 Days album (named after the time his mom suffered from her aneurysm and died, which was 27 years in total) "Wings for Marie" 1 and 2. Then you have his evolution on his thoughts on the whole subject.

[@shaneC69]

Glad you got around to Judith, the story continues with wings of Marie and 10,000 Days

[@fergarising1972]

“Sometimes people don't want to hear the truth because they don't want their illusions destroyed.” ― Friedrich Nietzsche (the divine is not to blame, it is man's dogmatic illusions that are to blame)

[@voxstelarum]

one of my favorites bands growing up. Even after all these years they sound unique and interesting, what any band should aspire to