Fixing The Problem with Most Center Channel Speakers - The Rule Breaker

  Рет қаралды 62,306

Toids DIY Audio

Toids DIY Audio

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 290
@tomconnell7154
@tomconnell7154 7 ай бұрын
I just finished building this after purchasing the plans. I have it paired with klipsch rp-280f towers for L & R channels. This replaced the rp-504c which I was always cranking up the volume and putting closed captions on as my favorite spot in the living room is 40 degrees off axis and I have to admit honestly the rule breaker build sounds so much more audibly clear off axis than the klipsch center channel. I can hear the dialog on movies much more pronounced and LEVEL across the seating from left to right up to around 50 degrees or so. I am not concerned one bit about tamber matching as I was more looking for a better experience with the channel that put out 90 % of movies and television. This thing is a winner!
@Toid
@Toid 7 ай бұрын
Thank you! I am so glad to hear that you are enjoying it! That is high praise. Sounds like it is doing exactly what it was intended. It's always good to hear people experiences and see what they paired it with. Thanks again for sharing!
@Joey22688
@Joey22688 2 ай бұрын
Ignoring all the expensive tools, you spent $100 + alot of time to beat a sub $50 center speaker?, why not compare it to something highend.
@TacticalBuffoonary
@TacticalBuffoonary 19 күн бұрын
KZbinrs only respond to compliments and as kisses.
@Pentenfi
@Pentenfi Жыл бұрын
This bmr is on my bucket list of speaker projects to try and listen to. Great video! By the way, the German DIY loudspeaker magazin "Hobby Hifi" has designed an entire series of speakers based around that tectonic bmr with additional Dayton reference drivers. People seem to be quite impressed. The series is called "daydream" for anyone interested.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Sweet! I’ll check them out. Thank you.
@cabasse_music
@cabasse_music Жыл бұрын
the performance of those BMRs is really amazing. i remember first reading/seeing polar plots of the d'appolito design in one of radio shack's speaker books as a kid and how it controls vertical dispersion (in normal upright mode) - so by flipping it on its side we are getting the worst of both worlds - great vertical dispersion and terrible horizontal.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Yup. Except this design doesn’t have those deficiencies that a typical MTM has.
@danielduesentriebjunior
@danielduesentriebjunior Жыл бұрын
Cute enclosure! That laser is probably not quite cheap.
@shawnbrennan7075
@shawnbrennan7075 Жыл бұрын
Very Nice!
@shawnbrennan7075
@shawnbrennan7075 Жыл бұрын
I wasn't gonna build this speaker, but the music convinced me otherwise 🎶🔊🎼
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
@@shawnbrennan7075 ha ha, nice. Usually I get the opposite reaction. 😁😂😁
@rich1807
@rich1807 Жыл бұрын
Amazing work. Now add a super tweeter :)
@samv6767
@samv6767 7 ай бұрын
Im just thinking about buying 3x floorstanding speakers and putting one as a center
@Toid
@Toid 7 ай бұрын
That’s a great idea, as long as they’re all in the normal standing position.
@GuitarTherapy144
@GuitarTherapy144 6 ай бұрын
Gosh what a snob. Fun to watch though. Thumbs up
@janejia9931
@janejia9931 Жыл бұрын
An amazing video.
@janejia9931
@janejia9931 Жыл бұрын
Please check your email and help me, i would love to invite you to test our projector.
@daveed-c137
@daveed-c137 8 ай бұрын
Is there a 8ohm variant of the BMR speaker? Or recommend another similar speaker? I’m trying to make a 3 way center but 3 way crossovers don’t take 4ohm speakers.
@marcoscarralgadea1928
@marcoscarralgadea1928 11 ай бұрын
Hello, I’m very new to this! I really want to design a Bluetooth speaker similar to this but how would you design this in winisd?
@Toid
@Toid 11 ай бұрын
I have a whole series on WinISD that teaches you it.
@cpg8000
@cpg8000 Жыл бұрын
Awesome. Or, just use phantom center and never have a problem again wherever you sit.
@sebastianjovancic9814
@sebastianjovancic9814 7 ай бұрын
Great for one person, but once you have people sitting outside of the sweet spot which is guaranteed in the standard home theater environment, the phantom center falls apart and you want a center channel to anchor the dialogue to the screen.
@ACW9442
@ACW9442 6 ай бұрын
I hear what you're saying, but most men stay in the workshop just to get some peace away from the family 😓😅
@vmoutsop
@vmoutsop Жыл бұрын
You need to plane the wood with the cup facing down otherwise the wood moves and you don't get a flat surface. JMO
@Nickporter17
@Nickporter17 Жыл бұрын
I've wasted a lot of material before joining and planing weird like this 😅
@chickenpotpie4045
@chickenpotpie4045 7 ай бұрын
Bro you really should cut the audio levels of the power tools, my volume is high enough to hear your voice, but it now sounds like I'm operating a woodshop at 1am.
@q0w1e2r3t4y5
@q0w1e2r3t4y5 13 күн бұрын
Just buy a KEF Q150 ... oh wait, I'm on a DIY channel :D
@Toid
@Toid 13 күн бұрын
@@q0w1e2r3t4y5 I’m all for buying great quality speakers. That is a great option for anyone that doesn’t want to build their own.
@q0w1e2r3t4y5
@q0w1e2r3t4y5 12 күн бұрын
@@Toid thanks for commenting! Looks like I forgot to subscribe the last time. Here, rectified. ;) EDIT: this is such a comprehensive video and I enjoyed watching it til the end.
@leeeagle5994
@leeeagle5994 8 ай бұрын
1.2 KHz to 1.5KHz makes sense ... Not 2,300 KHz = 2,300,000 ? beyond human hearing ..
@Elliott-Designs
@Elliott-Designs Жыл бұрын
What an amazing video Nick! You really got it all in one video, I wasn't expecting that 😂. Looking forward to sharing my version of the project 😁.
@Shorts-n-Stuff-sc9hm
@Shorts-n-Stuff-sc9hm 2 ай бұрын
So 100 bucks for the build and a bank loan for all the gear used 😅
@DIYAudioGuy
@DIYAudioGuy Жыл бұрын
Awesome speaker! Awesome video! Pure fire. 🔥🔥🔥🔥
@themadmurse5212
@themadmurse5212 9 ай бұрын
I solved the center speaker problem by no longer using a center. I just run 3 JBL 530s as L/C/R.
@tshuper
@tshuper Жыл бұрын
Great build. Really appreciate the additional focus on showing the measurements and theory in addition to the practical of the build. Also, with the crossover point so low, it makes me wonder if you could get away with dual 8" drivers to further extend the low end. The box would be pretty big, but if size doesn't matter, or if it's behind a projector screen then it could be a interesting build, even as a tabletop / room speaker. 🤔
@jgsabato
@jgsabato Жыл бұрын
Nice project. It looks like it minimizes typical MTM issues. Size will limit output, but this will work for a lot of setups out there.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
I agree. We really wanted to go with something smaller as there aren’t many good options out there. When you go larger there’s quite a few different options that perform similarly. So the goal with this one was to design something that fits an area that seems overlooked.
@themanwithIBS
@themanwithIBS Жыл бұрын
Nice. If you ever make a box out of pine and it doesn't look good, char it and put lacquer on it, it's gonna look good.
@rakitakhan
@rakitakhan 9 ай бұрын
I notice that you don't use any gasket material. I know some drivers have it but this "tweeter" doesn't nor does the woofers. What's the point of sealing the rest of the box if you leave the drivers unsealed ? Just curious.
@davidt8438
@davidt8438 8 ай бұрын
I found the music a little dramatic for the video. It was more appropriate for a video of someone climbing Mt. Everest and making itt to the summit.
@stevengagnon4777
@stevengagnon4777 7 ай бұрын
I like breaking the rules in speaker design...the rules will keep you inside the box... break some and you're outside the box...isn't that the goal in the first place... having a speaker the doesn't sound like a box.
@feltsjc
@feltsjc Жыл бұрын
What are the downsides to this solution? There must be some reason manufacturers don't offer this option. All audio design choices are a compromise, so what is this design's weaker area? How would increasing the budget alleviate any weaknesses?
@Elliott-Designs
@Elliott-Designs Жыл бұрын
Sensitivity although good, isn't as good as it could be if the technology wasn't used through adding mass to control how the modes develop within the driver diaphragm. However I think probably the biggest reason you don't see manufacturers/companies using these is because it's proprietary tech to Tectonic Audio Labs. This means manufacturers of speakers might worry about stocking issues and raising the price of the drivers since there's no competition in the field. But for us as DIYers, we don't need to worry about the production of the drivers or where they come from. So for people like us I think they're amazing little drivers!
@alexoncunha2138
@alexoncunha2138 6 ай бұрын
This looks like a perfect speaker to built in an amp, battery and wifi module and make it a "boom box".
@philiptalbert458
@philiptalbert458 Жыл бұрын
Amazing video! This style really solves a lot of problems, great work!!
@danrussell9357
@danrussell9357 Жыл бұрын
This video has so many great details. I like the way you showed the brand of sandpaper. Diablo makes great stuff;I have been using Dura-Gold lately. It is more bodywork than woodwork oriented, but I have been happy with the results. I know it takes extra work to create this way, but I always "like" your production work as well as the project itself.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Thank you Dan. I really appreciate you and your insights. It helps me create better videos. I really thank you for that..
@PhillioDoede
@PhillioDoede Жыл бұрын
Very cool little speaker. I see the appeal for a compact center channel with great off axis response for sure but personally I don't do anything with surround sound. I can see a similar version making a great self powered BT speaker though if the bass is good enough on its own. Also do you think that BMR driver would work in open baffle config instead of its own sealed chamber?
@jimthvac100
@jimthvac100 Жыл бұрын
Why do they make most center channel speakers to only go as low as 100hz? I would think as low 80Hz would be better to accommodate the Male voice that can go as low as 85Hz. Especially if they are singing. I would almost think I may be missing out if the singing voice from a song was sent to the center channel and It may not be going low enough.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
It really depends on what your subwoofers are capable of in your personal taste. Most larger center channel speaker do you get crossed over at 80 or even 60 Hz. Small speakers like this, you start getting distortion creeping in when you try to cross over to low. You could crosses over at 80 hertz depending on your room. of course, with this being sealed you could really crossing over 80 hertz no matter what if you really wanted to.
@zarboaudioprojects1430
@zarboaudioprojects1430 Жыл бұрын
That's a great solution to the MTM center channel problem with video and measurements to back it up. I've messed with those woofers before... they're little beasts! I bet this setup plays pretty loudly before distortion creeps in.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Thanks Tom. I’m really looking forward to our project. I’m glad this one worked out as well as it did.
@spritual_enlightenment
@spritual_enlightenment Жыл бұрын
The concept is very interesting! I didn't know I suppose to lay that centre speaker vertically. Oh, the plans page does not list this plan yet.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
They are there now. 😁
@spritual_enlightenment
@spritual_enlightenment Жыл бұрын
@@Toid, Saw them w SVG, DXF as well. Nice!
@z1berzerker
@z1berzerker Жыл бұрын
Great Design 👍 love the laser 👌 factor again... polyfil behind the bmr 😮hopefully smoothed things out. Great Video 📹
@mattb7895
@mattb7895 Жыл бұрын
Wow, I'm super impressed you got those boards that flat with just a planer. I thought for sure you were going to joint them or at least use a jointing sled in your planer. Your project came out amazing.
@johnbankston3967
@johnbankston3967 Жыл бұрын
This is a great design and video. For some reason I do not see the plans in your website.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
They are there now. Sorry for the delay
@castro619a
@castro619a Жыл бұрын
I cloned the linkwitz Riley speakers to use the 3.5 in BMR for the open baffle tweeter.. it’s incredible. With dispersion and crystal clear
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
That’s awesome! I do really enjoy the BMR dispersion. They should get more love.
@Garage_gg
@Garage_gg Жыл бұрын
Please do a 5.1 DIY and a how-to on setting up old working 5.0 speakers with a diy amp and sub
@csimet
@csimet 9 ай бұрын
Nice build. I would have liked to see the test measurements made at a distance of an average listener (say ~10-15 feet). I went even simpler... I ditched my traditional single center and re-used a pair of older 8 ohm bookshelf speakers I had laying around. I wired them in parallel to get the 4 ohms my AV needs and placed them on their sides (tweeters to the center) under the TV toed out from each other about 15-25 degrees. It actually works great and improved the center radiation pattern, spreading it out plenty to cover my main listening/seating positions. I can adjust them as needed, based on how wide I need it to cover. I can even phase offset them by setting one back a bit from the other to help remove middle low end dead spots. I'm surprised that manufacturer's don't make centers with adjustable patterns.
@tomconnell7154
@tomconnell7154 7 ай бұрын
Can you give more details - I have the klipsch rp-450c and I am sick of how poorly it performs off center and am searching for a wide sound stage patter for my center. Why I'm watching this video.... But how did you do wore them together? ... How would I keep the same 8 ohm? I have two klipsch rp-400m that I could use if I knew how to do it.... Any advice I would appreciate it
@csimet
@csimet 7 ай бұрын
@@tomconnell7154 Your speakers are rated to 50W RMS at 8 ohms, so you could hook them in parallel (4 ohm load net) and use a single 4 ohm 100W resistor in series to both to balance the draw from your amp so it does not sound louder than the other channels. If you don't add the resistor, you take the chance of overloading the amp's center channel (too much power draw).
@tomconnell7154
@tomconnell7154 7 ай бұрын
@@csimetplease forgive me as I am very GREEN on this....couldn't I use a speaker selector box with impedance protection built in to do this as well ? what are you thoughts...any help is appreciated.
@csimet
@csimet 7 ай бұрын
@@tomconnell7154 If the box does impedance matching, then you should be fine. Curious... what unit are you going to use?
@tomconnell7154
@tomconnell7154 7 ай бұрын
@@csimet well I was looking at either the OSD ISS4 or the PYLE PSS4 ....also I am wondering if my Klipsch RP-500M would work better. The amplifier to connect to is the OSD Nero XA5180 - provides 150W per channel (8 Ohms), 250W per channel (4 ohms) do you think either switch would work fine with the speakers hooked up through the switch and that amp? Don't want to hurt the speakers or the amp.
@mullinperformanceaudio5902
@mullinperformanceaudio5902 Жыл бұрын
Think I'm gonna build one of these when I get the audio shed set up.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
You know you are going to have to show it to me when you are finished!
@Nacturnal702
@Nacturnal702 Жыл бұрын
LMAO! , i bought 2 polk audio center channel speakers, but i built bigger speaker cabinets, they were going to become bluetooth speakers ,added a 6" subwoofer and cross over, one i am using for center channel, applied a 6 1/2" lazy susan mount around sub/ firing downward to position any way i want,,,5.1 stereo with the extra sub on center channel sounds amazing, 2 tannoy platinum white towers , JBL sub and Onkyo receiver.Made in 2020
@DonnieMulligan
@DonnieMulligan Жыл бұрын
Great Stuff Nick!!! Very helpful as usual. Love the measurement comparisons. Jealous of the laser cutter. Keep up the great work!!!
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Don’t be jealous, just get one 😂😁
@wattspeakers
@wattspeakers 11 ай бұрын
That was a nice project, very creative and looks like it turned out quite well. I really liked the way the real wood sandwiched cabinet was cut, assembled and finished. The logic behind the driver choice seems to make sense and the frequency responses were good too. Nice video shooting and editing!
@Kingkobbe
@Kingkobbe 3 ай бұрын
Very cool project and good idea!! Thx! Facinating how a so important speaker (center) is typically designed to allow placement instead of desiged to reproduce sound correctly on and off axis.
@brianraulerson5037
@brianraulerson5037 Жыл бұрын
I am consumed with laser envy. Also, that is a fancy looking fire place!
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Thank you. Still working on it. I can’t wait for it to be finished.
@falvegas511
@falvegas511 3 ай бұрын
Got a Center Chanel by Klipsch, 2 x Mids with center Titanium Horn. Yaa the Highs roll off a tiny bit off axis, HOWEVER i hear no difference 90 DEGREES EAST & WEST OF NORTH.
@Peter-p7e
@Peter-p7e 2 күн бұрын
Na stredový reproduktor stačí jeden reproduktor fullrange . Pretože nie je nič horšie ako ľudský hlas rozdelený na 2 cesty reproduktorov.
@getsum8931
@getsum8931 Жыл бұрын
Nick, this is an outstanding video! Keep em coming 👍
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Thank you.
@alexw890
@alexw890 Жыл бұрын
Great build and great lesson Nick. Thanks!
@wiredforstereo
@wiredforstereo 6 ай бұрын
I have THX Onkyo speakers, very similar to the one you're trying to fix by replacing the center. My mains are the same, just the center is sideways. I would be stoked if I could build all three mains just like this one. I have the skills, just don't have all the tools. If I were to replace the mains though, my goal would be to do all three fronts behind the screen. Subs could be below if I can't make them fit. I wouldn't have any idea what to buy, but for the fun of it, I'd rather build. My total experience building speakers was building my sub about 12 years ago. It's still running, though I did have to replace the amp once. I want to do more. I want to build two new subs.
@abuzafi
@abuzafi 2 ай бұрын
Center channels are typically dipole/mtm,, stand them up and it change its output to a wider dispersion for better off-axis listening, rather than on-axis/beaming.
@wiredforstereo
@wiredforstereo 6 ай бұрын
Couldn't one just replace the tweeter and crossover in the existing box? I mean, I love your laser cut cherry, but if I were trying to cheap out on it and and couldn't afford a $1300 laser.
@fubartotale3389
@fubartotale3389 Жыл бұрын
LOL!, The oil for the finish cost more than the speaker! 😂👍 Good stuff though, Odies.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Haha, nice
@Windycitysmokers
@Windycitysmokers Жыл бұрын
Great video as always! I have the 10 watt xtool d1 and love it! Inspires me to make more substantial builds with it like this!
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
I can’t wait to see what you build with it. You always come up with some great ideas! These losers are pretty awesome though, aren’t they?
@Windycitysmokers
@Windycitysmokers Жыл бұрын
@@Toid yeah absolutely lasers can do some things that a cnc cannot especially tight corners on cut throughs
@BrZi38501
@BrZi38501 Жыл бұрын
I was just searching all of your videos for a center solution for my space and just as I was starting to think there is no solution, you upload this video 🥳🥳🥳 thank you so much 🥹
@Nickporter17
@Nickporter17 10 ай бұрын
How did your build go?
@dijpdepijp2154
@dijpdepijp2154 Жыл бұрын
Thanks toid. Inspiring
@mackenziebullied4900
@mackenziebullied4900 Жыл бұрын
Thanks toid! Finally a build plan id pay for lol
@williamtomkiel8215
@williamtomkiel8215 2 ай бұрын
some old school flok will fondly remember Jeff Bagby and his awesome 88 Special. I have 5 in my base layer . .
@theungoliant9410
@theungoliant9410 Ай бұрын
You seem to leave A LOT OF IMPORTANT INFO out of your descriptions....
@davidkoslek9372
@davidkoslek9372 Жыл бұрын
Awesome video 💪🏽
@nicolasnicolas3889
@nicolasnicolas3889 Жыл бұрын
I was just looking at these drivers today! I want to make a small MTM set up for a practice! Amazing! 🥰
@IrfanKhan-ze4yx
@IrfanKhan-ze4yx 8 ай бұрын
Liked the video. Thanks. But I’d recommend cutting out the extraneous transition effects, it gets very distracting
@jondonnelly3
@jondonnelly3 6 ай бұрын
Could you mod the daytun with that full range middle speaker and your crossover, would be a lot easier for us non carpentry.
@rxpsycho7326
@rxpsycho7326 8 ай бұрын
Pretty nice. Would have liked more focus on the x-over construction. Those cnc wood tables are bassass.
@LordDarthNihilus
@LordDarthNihilus 7 ай бұрын
Damn I have exactly this dayton center. Maybe I will modify it with just the crossover and the mtm then
@russgaefe1554
@russgaefe1554 7 ай бұрын
I was wondering if you could recommend a pre-built crossover for this speaker?
@Will2DoesStuff
@Will2DoesStuff 8 ай бұрын
Did you know Cambridge Audio made a commercial version of this design? The aero 5 center, it was part of a surround sound system but they seem to have discontinued it sadly.
@Toid
@Toid 8 ай бұрын
I did not know that. That’s really awesome. And you’re right, it’s very similar
@VEC7ORlt
@VEC7ORlt 6 ай бұрын
Why not use tebm65 in the center role? It would eat a bit more power and the low end can be provided by woofers to the sides.
@bwatcsb9990
@bwatcsb9990 4 күн бұрын
For ordinary people like me, I can't read those graphics noodles, so a sound test comparison will be much easier to understand because I can listen it, will appreciate if you add audio compare between those speaker.
@Toid
@Toid 4 күн бұрын
@@bwatcsb9990 I’d encourage you to learn the graph. Is not hard and will tell considerably more than a flawed sound test over a highly compressed internet video ever will. Once you understand the graph, it’ll be much easier for you to know whether you’re getting a good or bad speaker before you even listen to it.
@goodgoat3096
@goodgoat3096 Жыл бұрын
Wouldn't your cnc router have made quicker work at cutting out all of those layers? I would never leave any cnc tool running unattended, especially a laser. Moving the xover frequency down is the only way to attack the comb filtering issue and the speaker looks great. Nice project.
@Windycitysmokers
@Windycitysmokers Жыл бұрын
He had a camera set up for monitoring and it has a flame sensor
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Yeah, the one really nice thing about the Xtool is it has a flame sensor. If it ever senses that it might be burning, it will actually shut off the machine. You can also set the sensitivity level. But it is definitely good practice to stay with your machine. Especially when you’re starting to get used to them.
@lokilowkey1
@lokilowkey1 9 ай бұрын
Nice build! I think it would have been good to include a subjective listening portion to the review. Although the frequency response graph is night and day better, it would be good to hear your overall thoughts comparing the quality of the sound in the on vs off axis for both speakers.
@Toid
@Toid 9 ай бұрын
That would have been good idea. Maybe it will be a good follow up video. Currently working on 3D printing an enclosure for this to test the differences vs the solid wood enclosure I already built.
@muhlui
@muhlui Жыл бұрын
Great diy :). How it sounds a longer distance eg. 16ft (5meters).? I have problem withn my tannoy center speaker to get nice clear voice at longer distance.
@lawrencebroski5840
@lawrencebroski5840 8 ай бұрын
The Tweeter is 4 ohms, while the woofers are 8 ohms, so do you parallel the woofers and put the tweeter in series for a total of 8 ohms?
@fynn1202
@fynn1202 Жыл бұрын
now throw some vents in it and you have a decent design for a bluetooth speaker. bet it sounds better than most of the ones avaliable
@KarthikSktk
@KarthikSktk Жыл бұрын
Can this be upscaled to something big in order to become the perfect center channel complement to the Phil BMR monitors?
@SilenceintheNight
@SilenceintheNight Жыл бұрын
This is my question as well, if space isn't a concern why not go bigger
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
You can, but the main issue with going bigger would be the lack of sensitivity in the BMR. This might become problematic with larger woofers.
@54tristin
@54tristin 7 ай бұрын
This would be better without the music from journey to another universe!
@joshcatstream
@joshcatstream 5 ай бұрын
You didn't use enough transitions near the end there, just a few more please.
@rodolfocaicedo07
@rodolfocaicedo07 9 ай бұрын
I can't believe this video only have 680 likes, you made an outstanding job with this center channel speaker. Beautiful.
@Toid
@Toid 9 ай бұрын
Thank you
@TCBITW
@TCBITW Жыл бұрын
I bought a xtool last week just can't wait until it arrives!
@davidewhite69
@davidewhite69 7 ай бұрын
why dont you ever give the details of the crossover in your speakers?
@Schjoenz
@Schjoenz Жыл бұрын
I've always liked your videos but, we don't want just the graph. We also want to hear an actual sound comparison like playing music or even just some videos while you are moving the mic across the room so that we have an idea how it really sounds. Graph might be accurate and detailed but hearing it is another thing. So can I suggest for your next video if we can also hear it (in case you built something like that again)? Thanks and 💖
@Elliott-Designs
@Elliott-Designs Жыл бұрын
Hi mate, I get wanting to hear sound demos, but that's the problem. A sound recording will tell you practically nothing about how it sounds, since for 1. The way speakers behave differently in different rooms can change (for example good directivity properties like this translate equally well across different rooms, other speakers with worse directivity and off axis response can change how they sound quite drastically across different rooms). 2. You're hearing it through your own speakers/headphones and so if it were ideal speakers in an ideal room all you'd hear is your own speakers. Graphs, although a bit boring for some, actually can tell the whole picture if you look at the response both on and off axis. A good benefit about builds like this is it doesn't hurt much to just build one and try it out.
@BrZi38501
@BrZi38501 Жыл бұрын
Hmmm could this BMR driver be a quick fix for Polk s35… puting it instead of original twitter and redoing the crossover 🤔
@fedism
@fedism 4 ай бұрын
Hi I couldnt find a link of where to buy one of these...
@welderfixer
@welderfixer Жыл бұрын
Nick, That center you built is a fantastic design - as always. I have to ask, Is that Dayton center and it's siblings worth buying? Thanks.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Good question. For the price they aren’t bad. But they aren’t good either. Basically they are worth what you are paying, nothing more. I’d rather build something like this or similar for around the same price. You’ll get better performance. But if subversive said they didn’t want to build and only had $60 for a speaker, then I’d offer it as an option.
@welderfixer
@welderfixer Жыл бұрын
@@Toid Thanks Nick! Sounds like the best bet is to stay in the higher priced and better reviewed speaker lines or go DIY with your designs or some of similar quality. May I ask what your current/favorite HT speakers are? Thanks again and all the very best to you and yours.
@BostonMike68
@BostonMike68 Жыл бұрын
I love the TCP 115
@RobertCookcx
@RobertCookcx 8 ай бұрын
I'm building pods to test these same BMR drivers in my Jetta so this video is a shot of confidence. I was planning to use a SEAS 1" soft-dome tweeter though because I have heard that they can get a bit "papery" sounding on the high end. Have you seen those Philharmonic speakers using these things. dadgum they get good reviews. And I was planning to cross them over at about 500Hz which seems like a nice compromise to their range and the midbass in the doors.
@GaryFord-Audio
@GaryFord-Audio Ай бұрын
More about the x-over please
@inex1smsat
@inex1smsat Жыл бұрын
I built this kind of speaker some years ago, because I could not find this anywhere. I used 2 FRSX 5 as a "mini Line" in the middle. Perfect sound.
@zoroluva
@zoroluva Жыл бұрын
I've been kicking this idea around in my head for almost a year now! Got down to 3 choices for the mid/tweeter: BMR, Dayton CX120 coaxial and a SB acoustics coaxial. Good to see the idea works! Love it. Great job explaining the physics behind it. For those wanting a more detailed explanation Erin's Audio Corner did a very detailed video on this: kzbin.info/www/bejne/fYvVlaaup8ijeNk
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Honestly any of those would work. I would definitely choose one of the others if you are planning a bigger center channel. You are right, that is a great video Erin did.
@zoroluva
@zoroluva Жыл бұрын
@@Toid yes it would be slightly larger at about 24" wide with 2 ports. Hoping to hit at least 60Hz.
@alont93
@alont93 Жыл бұрын
Just discovered your channel by recommendation from Erin - wow really awesome video! The end result came out looking sweet and probably performs more than enough for the typical household's living room setup. I'd be very interested in seeing distortion & compression figures - I assume the BMR will be a bottleneck in this regard.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
Thanks for coming by. I really appreciate it. And love everything Erin does. He’s such a great asset to the Audio community. The main issues with the BMR arise under 250hz, which is why we crossed it over higher than that. But you are correct. The BMR is low sensitivity and can only handle so much power. This type of design is good for small bedrooms and living rooms. Which is where I felt there really weren’t many good alternatives. When you go larger, there’s a lot of great designs that don’t have the off axis issues I’m describing in the video. Although, admittedly there are still a lot of bad designs as well.
@alont93
@alont93 Жыл бұрын
Yep I agree. Again, really cool design and looking forward to following your future endeavors
@davehood1514
@davehood1514 8 ай бұрын
Looks nice but given the cabinet size it can't have any base
@blaze2051
@blaze2051 7 ай бұрын
can you design a 4x 6.5woofer design
@mwahlert
@mwahlert Жыл бұрын
What sort out output levels can this design reach without noteworthy compression?
@6-Iron
@6-Iron 6 ай бұрын
An affordable speaker that requires a million dollar laser CNC machine to make the parts. Got it. 👍
@Toid
@Toid 6 ай бұрын
Any excuse can make the simplest task seem impossible
@zeldatearsofthekingdom3577
@zeldatearsofthekingdom3577 Жыл бұрын
What is the final impedance on the speaker? 4? 6? 8? I’m about to build 3 sets of them and just curious. Thanks 🙏
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
It’s considered a nominal 4ohm load. Having said that, I was concerned that my surround sound receiver might have issues with that. But I tried it on three different ones I had in the house, and none of them had an issue playing them.
@zeldatearsofthekingdom3577
@zeldatearsofthekingdom3577 Жыл бұрын
@@Toid sounds good. I’m guessing as long as I don’t turn it up crazy loud and put a big strain on the receiver it will be just fine… looking forward to building them and testing them out. Thanks 🙏
@Nickporter17
@Nickporter17 10 ай бұрын
​@@zeldatearsofthekingdom3577how'd your build go? I built one and I like it. I bought the parts to build two more.
@jimthvac100
@jimthvac100 Жыл бұрын
I understand why you designed this for wide dispersion. It seems most manufactures put those woofers side by side to fit under the large flat screen. But I think I would rather build a custom stand under the TV to accommodate a Center channel similar to the Cinema 10's you build a while back but use an 8" like the Aurum Cantus AC-200MKII for wider dispersion; and use the Selenium D250-X GW 1" Phenolic Horn Driver with the Selenium HC23-25 1" Exponential Horn 100x40. then use the DS18 PRO-DKN25 Neodymium Driver with Aluminum Horn 1-3/8"-18 TPI for a tweeter using the Crossover frequencies of 1.2kHz and 3.5Khz. This would provide a very wide dispersion of anything coming out of that center channel. I would rather have the Best sounding center channel speaker than to compromise to fit in a narrow slot. Love you build though makes me want to save for a Laser cutter.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
I don't disagree. There is a reason my Theater has an Acoustically Transparent Screen. 😁 But for the living room or a small home theater system, this is perfect.
@jimthvac100
@jimthvac100 Жыл бұрын
@@Toid How do you like your projection system? I am trying to decide on a nice OLED or something like you are using. Seems like it would be hard to beat an OLED. Of course you can have your speakers behind your screen.
@Toid
@Toid Жыл бұрын
@@jimthvac100 an OLED will definitely have the best video quality period. But I really like the much larger screen and the fact that project are supposedly better for your eyes. If I had the chance I’d have both. OLED for the living room and projector for the theater.
@Silverado_UK
@Silverado_UK 4 ай бұрын
Came here to learn something about centre speaker, and then I just sit back and enjoyed the craftsmanship of this beautiful solid cherry wood box. Masterclass! So satisfying to watch!
Discover the Surprising Flaw in Center Channel Speakers
35:44
Erin's Audio Corner
Рет қаралды 349 М.
BUILD speakers, don't BUY them...
47:40
Zac Builds
Рет қаралды 202 М.
ПРИКОЛЫ НАД БРАТОМ #shorts
00:23
Паша Осадчий
Рет қаралды 6 МЛН
How To Get Married:   #short
00:22
Jin and Hattie
Рет қаралды 22 МЛН
Design Crossovers for HiFi speakers using Xsim - Tips and Tricks
18:48
Toids DIY Audio
Рет қаралды 102 М.
Do Home Theaters NEED a CENTER SPEAKER?
33:48
Andrew Robinson
Рет қаралды 42 М.
Why Do Audiophiles HATE the Center Channel?
15:35
Audioholics
Рет қаралды 98 М.
How to Make an $80 Speaker Beat $1,000 Speakers
18:49
cheapaudioman
Рет қаралды 427 М.
Center Channel Sound: Two Hacks to Improve TV Sound
10:38
Axiom Audio
Рет қаралды 134 М.
WHAT THE KLIPSCH!?! Elac, Dynaudio and more!
18:30
GR-Research
Рет қаралды 46 М.
5 Tools Every Speaker Builder Needs
9:59
Toids DIY Audio
Рет қаралды 97 М.
7 Tips for THE BEST Center Channel Setup
8:04
Youthman
Рет қаралды 152 М.
ПРИКОЛЫ НАД БРАТОМ #shorts
00:23
Паша Осадчий
Рет қаралды 6 МЛН