FM23 Youth Intake Analysis 5 - Affiliate Club Newgens

  Рет қаралды 12,385

Evidence Based Football Manager

Evidence Based Football Manager

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 119
@Alex-wh3zw
@Alex-wh3zw Жыл бұрын
Another amazing findings. It can be a very useful feature when managing in a coutnry with low youth rating.
@jordy786
@jordy786 Жыл бұрын
You are such a smart person, much respect for all your work and sharing your knowledge with us!
@Biquetpoyon
@Biquetpoyon Жыл бұрын
You're an absolute hero!!
@d-law868
@d-law868 Жыл бұрын
Hmm again it proves that they have made a great job reg a country's youth rating, completely logical :) Thanks for the investigation
@karlingram8508
@karlingram8508 Жыл бұрын
Really helpful analysis. Been trying add more affiliate clubs to get a better youth intake and this will help when choosing. Thanks
@Gafgarion852
@Gafgarion852 Жыл бұрын
Once again, great work.
@davidboyeswahn4654
@davidboyeswahn4654 Жыл бұрын
Dear Max, please continue to use this music in future videos. it is so Positive!! I really love it as a perfect Intro to your videos
@johnFOOTBALLMAD
@johnFOOTBALLMAD Жыл бұрын
Excellent analysis as always - keep up the good work - I’ve been playing FM since the beginning but I always learn something new from your videos & they make me think in different ways due to the different perspectives & thought processes you put into the game so a big thank you. 👏👏
@voidvector6676
@voidvector6676 Жыл бұрын
This is a topic that has interested me for the longest time. I'm playing as Académica de Coimbra in Portugal and in my first intake after having Omonoia from Cyprus as an affiliate, the best talent is a Cypriot. I've always wondered how much impact things like the YR of the country the affiliate is from, the club's facilities and all those factor affect when a player who clearly comes from an affiliate comes through your intake Another thing I'd like to see tested, maybe more as a novelty? Is seeing how the nationalities of your staff affects the intake. As I mentioned, my team is from Portugal. Currently two of my best youngsters from previous intakes are both English/Portuguese despite not having an English affiliate, while I do have a couple English staff members, the most important was my DoF who was there when those players came through the intake. I wonder if having a staff team with many different nationalities affects the players that come through the intakes
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey bud, I haven't mentioned in my videos but as I added more coaching staff / affiliates, the world scouting knowledge expanded for the club, and made the pool of newgens more diverse in their nationalities.
@zyfon5
@zyfon5 Жыл бұрын
The nationality of newgen is affected by the world scouting knowledge of the club. For example psg can spawn Qatar newgen due to having qatar scouting knowledge from psg chairman. In one of my journeyman save a second division chinese club that i managed (my nationality is Malaysian) spawn Spanish newgens because i was managing spain u18 youth team at the same time and hence gained scouting knowledge on Spain 😂
@sam-rv8tp
@sam-rv8tp 3 ай бұрын
once again, getting into the information and in such depth that no one else bothers to get into. thank you for presenting all of this so nicely. I've managed to get my board to present several possible affiliates to me and this is going to help me make my decision. I have a couple from portugal, one from belgium and Junior FC from Colombia. the teams from Portugal benefit from higher national youth rating than any of the other teams, by about 10-17 points, but they both have awful junior coaching and youth recruitment along with poor reputation. The team from Belgium has a national youth rating that sits in the middle of the proposed affiliates but once again, despite having decent club reputation, has abysmal youth recruitment/junior coaching. Junior FC in Colombia seems like the best pick for me as Real Sociedad in Spain. They are listed as the 3rd biggest club in Colombia, they have a ***20*** rating for youth recruitment, and have the best junior coaching compared to the other affiliates. Not only all this, but they will also send youth prospects who speak Spanish! Which is always a plus when you are managing a team based in Spain.
@randomname9949
@randomname9949 Жыл бұрын
Thank you, a lot of questions answered with this one, I really like playing with the affiliate club feature
@Zntric
@Zntric Жыл бұрын
You have som unique and great content! Good worl
@matiunited97
@matiunited97 Жыл бұрын
I was very curious about the whole affiliate clubs thing and was hoping you'd make a video about it at some point. Great video as always, Max. thank you boss
@LukeGJPotter
@LukeGJPotter Жыл бұрын
Hyped for this episode, as I've been adding new Affiliates ever 3 months to get Newgens.
@khemrajbudha7955
@khemrajbudha7955 Жыл бұрын
In affiliate youth recruitment, aside from having a diverse range of players from various nations, there are limited tangible advantages. The players' current abilities and potential may not significantly impact outcomes. If you're seeking talent from different nations, opt for countries with high youth ratings, reputable clubs, excellent junior coaching, and lower-quality youth facilities. This detail is clearly shown in VIDEO!
@dekaan
@dekaan Жыл бұрын
Awesome work as usual. Thanks for the info!
@LegateBlake
@LegateBlake Жыл бұрын
Thank you for the analysis, it is great to have some clarity on how affiliates function. My big question that I don't think was touched on as part of the analysis is if affiliates increase the overall CA/PA of your intake. Would a team with 100 junior affiliates have more players to pull from and therefore have higher average CA/PA versus a team with no affiliates? Or is this just a way to pull different nationalities outside of your home region.
@baiisun
@baiisun Жыл бұрын
That's an excellent question. I would say no from my testing but it's not statistically confirmed. An easy test for that would be to have the maximum amount of affiliates with all stats to the max and see if you get only wonderkids. I think not. I'll try it. From my testing the maximum of affiliates newgens is 8 out of 16 anyway and you're not taking some from the affiliates clubs, like it's not they have one less, the best one for example. I think if you pull great players from affiliates, your local newgens will compensate and be weak. The average CA/PA should remain around the same with and without affiliates. But that's just my theory.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey bud, I just went back and did some maths again. Team E Dutch newgens Average CA/PA, no affiliate clubs (from Part 3 video): 39.6/72.3 Team E Dutch newgens Average CA/PA when it had 1 affiliate club: 40.0/71.9 Team E Tajikistani newgens Average CA/PA when it had 1 affiliate club (from this video 10:00): 40.9/68.6 I say the presence of an affiliate club does NOT affect the CA/PA ratings of your club's "regular" newgens. Thanks for bringing it up, I should probably mention this in my next video.
@afasia2341
@afasia2341 Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm So.... having affiliate clubs might be entirely useless?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
@@afasia2341 Well, in this video I've only tested 1 function out of the many functions that an affiliate club can serve. There are other benefits too eg. boosting the finances of the club, giving you extra scouting knowledge.
@slotcarracing5302
@slotcarracing5302 Жыл бұрын
Great work Max. Did you look at if the Tajikistan new gens were 'better' than the average Team E new gens? And were the Tajikistan players picked up by Team E the 'best' Rashvan prospects or average?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey bud, in Part 3 I found: Team E newgens control CA/PA = 39.6/72.3 In this video, Ravshan newgens control CA/PA = 40.9/68.6 So I say Team E / Ravshan newgens are of similar quality. I didn't record the stats for the other newgens of Ravshan 😅
@mariusthechamions8966
@mariusthechamions8966 Жыл бұрын
Determination can be boosted giving warning to players when they have under 6.6 rating
@baiisun
@baiisun Жыл бұрын
Great vid. Thanks!
@Sasquatch10
@Sasquatch10 Жыл бұрын
I can't believe i've never thought of using affiliates to manipulate my intake's nationalities. Time to set up an affiliate in every South American country 😅😅
@rra1139
@rra1139 Жыл бұрын
thank you
@benbenn123
@benbenn123 Жыл бұрын
Wow, great information for me Keep it up
@HCMCDrives
@HCMCDrives Жыл бұрын
Great data! Something I've noticed is that I get a lot of newgens coming through based on my Nationality. I manage Crewe, my nationality is Vietnamese, and I get at least one per year, unfortunately they aren't very good. I wonder if I set it to Brazilian whether I would get Brazil regens, and therefore better possible PA.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey bud, happens to me too, I always get an odd Australian newgen every now and then. It's probably due to the extra scouting knowledge added to your club by the manager's own nationality.
@rompouli
@rompouli Жыл бұрын
Good video🎉
@tomislavprsa9577
@tomislavprsa9577 Жыл бұрын
Awesome video, I know that a lot of people wonder if it would be possible to get a specific regen, for example. a regen with a good Inverted Wingback template. Now that we know what determines the CA/PA could you possibly test the templates and possibly try to analize what kind of HOYD combinations and youth preview Reports are needed for your top talent to be a specific role and good at it.
@christianwilson3718
@christianwilson3718 Жыл бұрын
I'm sorry but that is not possible
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey mate, I'm not sure if it's possible to 'request' an affiliate newgen with a specific playing position/role.
@zvonimirbrekalo1291
@zvonimirbrekalo1291 Жыл бұрын
Awesome video. Now I'm wondering if one had ten elite affiliates with lower reputation than your own club if one would get intakes that are on average much better than the control ones
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
hey bud, in 10:00 you can see that the Club Reputation of both your own club & your affiliate club are correlated with the CA/PA of affiliate newgens. So if all your affiliates have a lower Club Reputation than your own club, affiliate newgens will on average have lower CA/PA compared to your own newgens.
@natintosh
@natintosh Жыл бұрын
Can you please. make a video on scouting?
@TheMrKrist
@TheMrKrist Жыл бұрын
Great research, but we need go deeper :D
@ParetoEmperor-jp6ke
@ParetoEmperor-jp6ke Жыл бұрын
i took youth intake soon after somewhere regional or nationwide intake schedule by player search, with filter to see PA above 150 and age no more than 17, preparing budgets about 50M only, then i investigate their current CA compare to their PA, i took the biggest CA all of these wonderkids, usually at this age if you see 1 and half or 2 stars CA of 4 stars or 5 stars of PA this showed me this is quality wonderkids, choose good personality at least balance personality and have strong determination above 15, then i went to offer the contracts, if they current contracts are not proffesional or free agents it will be more simple to transfered to my clubs. simply i always made the bet with enough budget not rely only with my youth dept. to capture all potential wonderkids arround the world, i design my targets these wonderkids had to be first team quality (3 stars CA) before age of 23 so its getting excited that my predictions coming true these womderkids will became elite players at their golden age to fullfill their PA as their CA.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
hey bud, your method sounds legit to me. There are always wonderkids that escape your scout knowledge, sometimes you have to do some manual search yourself.
@BrunoSilvaElessar
@BrunoSilvaElessar 8 ай бұрын
Is worth? If u are managing a big club, having affiliate clubes with good general youth teams will up average of your yth intake? Because if the average of PA still the same, is better have no affiliates and have the youngsters with country nationality. This is the best Football manager channel. Congrats. 😉
@BrunoSilvaElessar
@BrunoSilvaElessar 8 ай бұрын
Ignore, find the answer on a comment below. "@ebfm há 6 meses (editado) Hey bud, I just went back and did some maths again. Team E Dutch newgens Average CA/PA, no affiliate clubs (from Part 3 video): 39.6/72.3 Team E Dutch newgens Average CA/PA when it had 1 affiliate club: 40.0/71.9 Team E Tajikistani newgens Average CA/PA when it had 1 affiliate club (from this video 10:00): 40.9/68.6 I say the presence of an affiliate club does NOT affect the CA/PA ratings of your club's "regular" newgens. Thanks for bringing it up, I should probably mention this in my next video."
@ebfm
@ebfm 8 ай бұрын
@@BrunoSilvaElessarhey bud, glad you've found the answer! Yup, the affiliate clubs do not affect your 'regular' newgens.
@J_Vermillion
@J_Vermillion 2 ай бұрын
Nice video. I was also wondering how domestic youth CA/PA correlates to these changes too; in other words, did the quality of the Dutch players decrease?
@mattiaslindholm531
@mattiaslindholm531 Жыл бұрын
Great work :-) I saw a post couple years ago in the SI forum about newgens templates. According to the poster (who worked at SI) the newgens gets assigned different templates when they are created. Templates definied what kind of player the regen would be (poacher, wingback etc). The different templates where influenced by different things like HOYD prefered playstyle. The poster also claimed that nation of the newgen influenced the template. For exemple would brazilian wingback have higher chance to have good flair. I find this template theory really intresting. Is it something you plan to test? CA and PA is important but the most impotant thing is attribute distribution. A 130 PA with good distribution vould be better then a 150PA with wrong attributes.
@baiisun
@baiisun Жыл бұрын
CA is calculated based on weighting of attributes for a specific role. Max has a video about it if you're interested. We can assume PA is similar. Which means that a high PA for a player means he could reach an equivalent CA for the role the PA was calculated. Which also means that a low CA/PA could be low but attributes values high for attributes not connected with the role chosen for the player. Which means if you retrain the player, the CA/PA should increase. (But it is said PA doesn't change no matter what...) Example a central defender with high Technical, First Touch, Shooting attribute values could reach a higher CA/PA if retrain as a Forward/AM. Also, note that Flair is not part of any CA/PA calculations (as Aggression, Natural Fitness, and Determination).
@mattiaslindholm531
@mattiaslindholm531 Жыл бұрын
​@@baiisunyes im aware of that, ive seen all his videos. But that is prospect progression. What im talking about is the starting template a newgen is regenerated into. The factor that decides if a player will be created into a poacher, or wingback type of player. I think you can just by eye test judge that there are templates that newgens are created into. The big question is wich factors determine the type of template used. Is it random or can you influence the result to maximise your chance of getting a sweeper goaltender instead of poacher.
@baiisun
@baiisun Жыл бұрын
@@mattiaslindholm531 Right. Well, it has been said yes that the HOYD influences the newgens roles and personality. It would have to be verified.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
hey buddy, I didn't know about this SI forum post. It's interesting that such player templates exist. Unfortunately I don't have plans to dig any deeper on affiliate clubs, as I need to move onto other topics. But I can possibly look into it in the future.
@mattiaslindholm531
@mattiaslindholm531 Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm i fully understand that. I think the most intresting question thou, is how the templates are applied generally on newgens, not only newgens from affiliate clubs. Are they completely randomised at the intake? Can you make ingame choices that gives you a higher probability to get players more suited to a specific role? Does the templates even exist or is it a myth? I think this could be tested since player type is listed for each player. If one did 10 simulations with different HOYD and noted the different player types generated, one should be able to see if there are a pattern worth investigating. If there are templates and these templates could be influenced by for example your HOYD prefered playstyle, then it would give more depth to choosing which HOYD one should hire. Would you trade off a good personality against a higher chance of getting a player that suits you tactic? Should you switch your HOYD regulary to get a more varied intake?
@jlee829
@jlee829 Жыл бұрын
It would be interesting to see if having a youth player affiliate club would hurt your intakes if your team’s national youth rating is higher than the affiliate. Over time, would you have worse youth players collectively due to bringing in players from a nation that is less likely to produce top talent?
@psychotic17
@psychotic17 Жыл бұрын
My thoughts exaxtly.
@mattiaslindholm531
@mattiaslindholm531 Жыл бұрын
I dont think so because the low number of foreign regens. 35 regens in 100 intakes makes it 1 foreign regen every 3 years. If you have 6 affiliate clubs you proberly get 2 each year at avarage. Thats too low for affecting youre whole crop.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey mate, I don't have specific stats to answer this. I believe the quality of affiliate newgens and your 'regular newgens' are independent, and that one does not cause the other to become better or worse.
@trevanbaxter9943
@trevanbaxter9943 Жыл бұрын
In a nation build save would it be useful to take over a team like Brighton and then add affiliates in the target country?
@JohnDoe-ie9iw
@JohnDoe-ie9iw Жыл бұрын
Hi Max, in the football manager editor, managers have different atrributes. For example one attribute is called rotation/substitution, could you do an analysis on these and see how the AI in football manager works?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
hey bud, manager attributes is definitely an interesting topic. I'll write it down on my list of things to research.
@RugnirSvenstarr
@RugnirSvenstarr Жыл бұрын
wow this is a complicated one, I still have a lot of questions. Like its clear here that its important to have better facilities than the affiliate team to attract their best prospects over. But is it more important to have a wide gap (i.e. poor facilities in the other club) or do you want to just nudge them out (I guess to develop their guys as well as possible before they make the switch). Also like some of the other youth prospect ones I'd really love to see some data regarding the best youths not just the average. Something like average of top. I also wonder about things like how league/country reputation and ranking would affect things (would I struggle to attract talent to brazillian talent to iceland even if im champions league winners) I'd also love to see a comparison between the domestic talent and affiliate talent. Like are the tajik youths worse than dutch? what if you were in an area with poor youth rating and had an affiliate in a top league like brazil, would the brazillian players be a marked improvement over domestic?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey mate, all good questions. 1. Regarding Youth Facilities, I don't know whether you just need to 'nudge them out' or 'the higher the better'. 2. I tried making box and whisker graphs (which will show you the 'top' youngsters) instead of averages, but then there was too much information that crowded the screen so I just used averages to keep it simple. 3. Here's the comparison between domestic / affiliate talent: Team E Dutch newgens Average CA/PA, no affiliate clubs (from Part 3 video): 39.6/72.3 Team E Dutch newgens Average CA/PA when it had 1 affiliate club: 40.0/71.9 Team E Tajikistani newgens Average CA/PA when it had 1 affiliate club (from this video 10:00): 40.9/68.6 I say the presence of an affiliate club does NOT affect the CA/PA ratings of your club's "regular" newgens. This is something I forgot to mention in the video, will mention it in the next vid.
@AllanFCL
@AllanFCL Жыл бұрын
Could you make a video about the "Overall" training and show whether or not it's as effective as the others. I have a view that it's important, but I've been told it's the least effective of all the trainings, so I don't know what to believe. 😅
@fccadoni7304
@fccadoni7304 Жыл бұрын
He has already tested that Allan! Looks his previous videos.
@AllanFCL
@AllanFCL Жыл бұрын
@@fccadoni7304 Yeah, bro. Just found the video I needed right after this comment. Thank you. This guy is a gem.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
hey bud, I have done a video series on training before, check out the previous videos on my channel. In short, Defending/Attacking/Match Practice sessions are more effective than Overall.
@AllanFCL
@AllanFCL Жыл бұрын
@@ebfmI already found the correct video, Max. Thank you
@AllanFCL
@AllanFCL Жыл бұрын
​@@ebfmHey, Max, it's me again. Do you know if there's any difference in the evolution of the player if he trains or not in the specific position of your main tactic? For example: A poacher training like Poacher. And if I train my "Poacher" as a "Complete Forward" that trains more technical and mental attributes, is there a difference? Thx in advance ❤
@bramusa
@bramusa 10 ай бұрын
Wonderful research, but I have one more question: does the average CA and PA value go up the more affiliate clubs you have? Or does an affiliate club not improve the average rating of your youth players?
@CharlesOffdensen
@CharlesOffdensen Жыл бұрын
We need experiments for player traits.
@d63sx5
@d63sx5 7 ай бұрын
Love the content, keep it up! Do you think your findings apply for older versions of FM? I'm on FM18 due to my laptop capabilities and was wondering if anything would be different.
@ebfm
@ebfm 7 ай бұрын
Hey bud, can't say for sure whether these findings apply in other versions of FM 😅 but given that FM changes very little over time.. I would say 95% of the findings are applicable in other versions.
@menno7349
@menno7349 Жыл бұрын
One thing you didn't cover, but I'm curious about: does having these affiliates raise the average CA and PA of the youth intakes compared to a situation without affiliates? Way i imagine it working is the youth recruitment would get a wider pool of players to chose from, so can potentially pick better talents. Just not sure whether this actually works like this, or whether average CA and PA remains the same in which case it's basically just swapping a home nationality for another.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey bud, here's the comparison between Team E's 'own newgens' and the 'affiliate newgens': Team E Dutch newgens Average CA/PA, no affiliate clubs (from Part 3 video): 39.6/72.3 Team E Dutch newgens Average CA/PA when it had 1 affiliate club: 40.0/71.9 Team E Tajikistani newgens Average CA/PA when it had 1 affiliate club (from this video 10:00): 40.9/68.6 I say the presence of an affiliate club does NOT affect the CA/PA ratings of your club's "regular" newgens. This is something I forgot to mention in the video, will mention it in the next vid.
@menno7349
@menno7349 Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm Thank you!
@arifadnan3224
@arifadnan3224 6 ай бұрын
Brilliant work as always. I had a question. How does this stand with the draft theory. Like if the youth intake is limited to 16 players only, do the players from affiliates replace the last slots or random slots? If you still have the data, it would be interesting to see if the lowest CA/PA of each intake is effected by having affiliate clubs.
@ebfm
@ebfm 6 ай бұрын
Hey bud, Gosh it's been a while so I can't recall exactly, but yes, the annual intake is limited to 16 per year. So if the club gets 2 newgens from the affiliates, that means the original club will produce 14 newgens. Refer to 19:15 to find out which factors affect the CA/PA of affiliate newgens.
@sungerbok
@sungerbok Жыл бұрын
Hi Max great vid! A little heads up though: the correct term is Tajik, there's no such thing as Tajikistani.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
oops, didn't know it's Tajik 🤭
@mememanfresh
@mememanfresh Жыл бұрын
can you analyze what affects club reputation the most
@fccadoni7304
@fccadoni7304 Жыл бұрын
Winning cups and leagues. In Pre-Game Editor you can see winning the EPL will give to club X points of reputation.
@camerondavisslag
@camerondavisslag Жыл бұрын
when're you going to release the intro song on spotify? so annoying to have to keep rewinding the video over and over again when i want a boogie after a long day's work
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
haha the music is called "We Come Alive" by Waykap. It's on KZbin you can look it up.
@Createk
@Createk Жыл бұрын
if im premier league club and i have affliate say from china (low youth rating country) does it lower my average ca/pa of newgens
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
The variables of the Chinese affiliate club will determine the quality of your Chinese newgens. The variables of your affiliate clubs will not affect the quality of your other, non-Chinese newgens.
@EnsoHenzo
@EnsoHenzo Жыл бұрын
Summary at 18:18 for people who cannot devote 20 mins of their day because of late stage capitalism
@ukaszfurmaniak1555
@ukaszfurmaniak1555 Жыл бұрын
that is interesting way to say "are lazy".
@mememanfresh
@mememanfresh Жыл бұрын
Also could you analyze if playing a player in a role theyre not training in for a whole season makes them gain attributes in the training role or the playing role? And if it makes them gain attributes in the training roles are the attribute gains reduced?
@cenciskhan3731
@cenciskhan3731 Жыл бұрын
Great job as always :) Did newgens always get 2nd nationality as Dutch?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
They had some progress towards the Dutch nationality (263/1095 days) but not full. It's strange that they already have 263 days progress in the Netherlands. Even if you assume that they 'moved over' from their home country to Team E on Youth Preview day (6 Dec 22), it should be around 120+ days, not 263. It is as if the game assume that those newgens were at your club since the start of the season. 1/7/22 (season start) ~ 20/3/23 (Team E youth announcement) is around 263 days.
@cenciskhan3731
@cenciskhan3731 Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm wow so accurate! thanks again so much! :)
@jakesimpson5233
@jakesimpson5233 Жыл бұрын
Hey EBFM! I recently did a little experiment where I tried to give Real Salt Lake in the MLS perfect youth facilities, youth recruitment, head of youth development, perfect everything. But I was still only getting youth intakes with potentials around the CA of my current best players. Is it possible that the youth intake takes into account the CA or PA of the current team, so as to not give you a player WAY better than you already have? I’d be curious to see an experiment on this! Thanks for the great content!
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey mate, not sure if youth intake takes into account the quality of the current squad. In my tests, there are 0 players in the Youth Intake League (so the squad is filled with 'ghost' players), but the teams still got good newgens (PA160-180) every now and then. So I don't think quality of the current squad is a factor.
@jakesimpson5233
@jakesimpson5233 Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm in my save I’m playing as Real Salt Lake in the MLS, and my best PA’s have been consistently 130-140 with the best CA’s being 90-100 for the last 3 years. I could have just gotten unlucky so far, but I have been surprised my intake is so low as the highest reputation team in the highest reputation league in the highest reputation country with the best coaching and facilities possible(all done in the editors of course).
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
​@@jakesimpson5233 Strange mate. When did you try resetting the youth intake? If the reset is done just before the Youth Announcement, the range of possible CA/PA would be restricted by the dice throw done at the Youth Preview event. Remember the dice is thrown twice - first at Youth Preview and second at Youth Announcement. If you had a bad dice roll at Youth Preview, a 'cap' will be placed on how good the Youth Intake can be, even if you maximise all the variables. Also, maybe the youth intake mechanics is different in the MLS because they use the draft system.
@jakesimpson5233
@jakesimpson5233 Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm i set everything right at the beginning, before the youth announcement:) yeah that’s true about the draft stuff, I wonder if the “academy” youth intakes are different than other U18 leagues. There are differences in how they play and how you sign them. The academy is more like an affiliate club than a U18 team in some ways. I’ll have to try it in a European league for sure:)
@Draddar
@Draddar Жыл бұрын
Does having a few good affiliates for intake actually improve overall quality of the intake or is it more or less cosmetic so you can have some more diverse nationalities?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
I don't think so. I did an experiment (not shown in the video) with 6 different affiliate clubs, and the affiliate newgens all had similar CA/PA compared to having just 1 affiliate club. But with more affiliate clubs, the nationalities of your youth candidates will become more diverse.
@markbntt4360
@markbntt4360 Жыл бұрын
anyone had any success getting a Brazilian club afiliate? I can't get any, not even serie C clubs to agree. I can get any other countries fine, but Brazilian clubs seem impossible
@afsoc4life
@afsoc4life Жыл бұрын
What are your thoughts on foreign newgens e.g., Caley Braves and their newgens who are French? Is the quality based on France or Scotland?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey mate the answer is both. The quality of those French newgens will be determined by the variables of both your own club / your French affiliate club.
@afsoc4life
@afsoc4life Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm Thanks for the answer. Caley Braves is a Scottish team that produces French newgens. They don't have a French affiliate. Would the quality of the newgens be affected by France's or Scotland's youth rating?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
@@afsoc4life Not too sure mate, I know it will definitely be affected by Scotland's YR. Not sure whether the player will also be affected by France's YR.
@afsoc4life
@afsoc4life Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm i am hoping that the French rating affects it. I will see how it plays out during this save.
@miguelquinto
@miguelquinto Жыл бұрын
And if you have multiple affiliates? Will it give you more newgens from such country?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Hey bud, discussed this in 6:00. Yes you will get more affiliate newgens if you have multiple affiliate clubs.
@miguelquinto
@miguelquinto Жыл бұрын
@@ebfm yes that part I saw and great work by the way! But for example, if you have multiple teams from Tajikistan, does it generate more Tajikistan players?
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
@@miguelquinto ooh not too sure about that. I didn't test the effects of having multiple affiliate clubs from the same country. 😅
@KexanR
@KexanR Жыл бұрын
So if you're playing a small club in a minor league what would be the benefit of getting a senior affiliate from one of the big leagues?
@ukaszfurmaniak1555
@ukaszfurmaniak1555 Жыл бұрын
you can get money paid yearly, free friendly match, you can get some good players send to you as loanies.
@ebfm
@ebfm Жыл бұрын
Well, you won't get any newgens from them, but the senior club may give you other perks, like 'boosting merchandising sales' or allowing your players to go on loan.
@nikolai1714
@nikolai1714 10 ай бұрын
Great work. This is what i want. Zealands videos in not watchable - a guy with no humor trying to be funny every 5 seconds in every video.
@mememanfresh
@mememanfresh Жыл бұрын
Could you analyze the effect of scout judging potential on youth intake? According to the guy who made this video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nIOTdp5pgpVnndksi=rANP9DvkHtgUTi95, it has a big impact.
FM23 Youth Intake Analysis 6 (FINAL) - Club Geography + Full Summary
17:09
Evidence Based Football Manager
Рет қаралды 11 М.
FM23 Youth Intake Analysis 1 + statement
21:01
Evidence Based Football Manager
Рет қаралды 80 М.
Motorbike Smashes Into Porsche! 😱
00:15
Caters Clips
Рет қаралды 23 МЛН
ЛУЧШИЙ ФОКУС + секрет! #shorts
00:12
Роман Magic
Рет қаралды 30 МЛН
Ice Cream or Surprise Trip Around the World?
00:31
Hungry FAM
Рет қаралды 9 МЛН
😜 #aminkavitaminka #aminokka #аминкавитаминка
00:14
Аминка Витаминка
Рет қаралды 3,1 МЛН
FM23 Training Analysis 3 - 10 factors tested
22:34
Evidence Based Football Manager
Рет қаралды 17 М.
FM23 Youth Intake Analysis 4 - The Draft Hypothesis
19:56
Evidence Based Football Manager
Рет қаралды 10 М.
Turn Your Wonderkid Into a Mentality Monster
10:00
Zealand
Рет қаралды 144 М.
FM23 Youth Intake Analysis 3 - Youth Preview
25:13
Evidence Based Football Manager
Рет қаралды 16 М.
10 MUST KNOW Clubs for AMAZING WONDERKIDS in FM23
7:47
Coach Roan
Рет қаралды 10 М.
How Affiliate Clubs Help You Win
18:51
Zealand
Рет қаралды 98 М.
I Locked A Perfect Player On The Worst Team In Football
25:26
Get Out of Debt in FM
15:43
Zealand
Рет қаралды 126 М.
Motorbike Smashes Into Porsche! 😱
00:15
Caters Clips
Рет қаралды 23 МЛН