"Forever Lost" - MLP Grimdark Song [The Tale of the Lost Narrator]

[@cthulhuian6218]

Every time mag pops up and says "uhuh", i imagine them sitting there while lost tells her gruesome tale and mag is just sitting there nodding like, "Yeah I remember when that one dude got torn in half"

[@thelostnarrator]

This is now my head canon XD

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

@@thelostnarrator i kinda agree

[@cthulhuian6218]

@@thelostnarrator And this is just a parody of your story right? If not what song would you be parodying

[@cthulhuian6218]

@@thelostnarrator As well as, as nice as this song is, i was expecting a much spookier song, you got some really spooky ones planned?

[@thelostnarrator]

@@cthulhuian6218 Each Halloween special I usually like to think of it like a scale. I start off more creepy and less intense, but as the videos come out, they get more intense, scarier, etc. So short answer, yes. lol

[@ScribblerProductions101]

Said it before when y’all showed me this and I’ll say it again: you’re no longer allowed to say you can’t sing, Lost. This was beautiful, especially the harmonies.

[@ScribblerProductions101]

@Tyler Hall Ba dum bum tsch.

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

Hi Scribbler... I agree 100% she can't deny it anymore.... Also hope you're well

[@rene9adekni9ht97]

@Tyler Hall *slowly dies to pun*

[@jakobwendt8999]

@Tyler Hall ok you got your rimshot now leave

[@estepstudios5542]

you both have a sinister harmony

[@Magpiepony]

I'm so proud of you for singing in this one, love! This was a lot of fun, and I'm excited for the rest of the songs this season!!

[@parthxus]

Magpiepony please tell me, from the podcasts and videos I’ve seen- did you edit her singing to fit in with the vocals or did she do this herself with no editing in her voice lol

[@Magpiepony]

@@parthxus Minin and I took a metal bat to her vocals and beat them until they sounded pretty

[@PitchandMagpieProductions]

@@parthxus There was honestly little editing needed, with a little shock therapy anything is possible.

[@parthxus]

Magpiepony Oh man I may need to do that to my vocals

[@parthxus]

Pitch and Magpie Productions Is this the kind of chaos Losty has to go through daily?...

[@PitchandMagpieProductions]

Had a lot of fun editing on this! I know for a fact that Lost can sing now! I heard it!

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

Aww pitch hi... Hope you're well

[@arun2kme11]

Hi pitch

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

@@samelemming690 Pitch is Mags editor but im guessing since Mag and Lost are married Pitch edits Mag and Lost's videos now

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

@@samelemming690 welcome

[@Thedragonlover95]

Indeed

[@MinersLovePonies]

Have you heard the tale of The Lost Narrator? I wouldn't expect you to, not many know of it. One of those stories that has been mostly lost to time and the shadows of the Everfree Forest, same as the Candy Mare, Village Of The Blanks, the Slender Pony. They say she was a pony once, wandered the lonely roads, cursing all who came across her in some stricken hope to find her beloved. Others say she was just another lost soul that lurked the shadows, hunting like any other monster. I don't know how true it is, to be honest. The specifics were lost to time well before I was born. What happened to her? I'm not sure. One day they just seemed to fade away, never spoken of again. The legend went with them, though there is a song that is sometimes sung around the campfires by the colts and fillies of Equestria. You want to hear it? These old bones aren't what they used to be, but I'm told I can still play and sing well...

[@g-destroyer7773]

Yet, there is a tale, a legend forgotten in time. History so sinister, many feared it. A myth many ponies wished that it didn't exist.

[@drswag0076]

the mistress of horror has returned in our deist hour of need.

[@CosmiaNebula]

deist? theist? I prefer... dystheist

[@notepad7871]

Lost: "I can't sing for sh*t..." Me: "Are you sure about that?"

[@TheCommenterDragon]

Alright, first piece of Lost Narrator content of Month of Macabre 2020, this day just keeps getting better and better!!!

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

The lyrics, the art style, the harmony, the fact that its a parody of song I really love this is perfect.... And lost like scribbler said you can no longer say you cant sing not after this

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

Aww lost thanks for the heart.... Hope you and mag are alright

[@purplepartytigerd1598]

Aww yeeeaaah, here we go. Great start! Edit: For my convenience lol Was she myth, was she mare (A faded filly's story) Found the beast in her lair (In all her rotted glory) Did her words leave you scared? (A frightening allegory) Now you're part of the narrative Not a myth, not a mare I am a monster (Ah-ah) With my words in my wake I leave a massacre (Ah-ah) There's no sign, there's no prayer I'll ever find her (Ah-ah) It keeps on repeating (Oh-oh) Follow the fire light And take a rest if you're weary It's a cold night There's no need to be leery Better sit tight I wanna tell you a story It's bound to give more than a fright (But still she'll be) *Forever lost* Unending days and restless nights, *forever lost* Narrating stories full of fright, *forever lost* My beloved gone from sight, *forever lost* *Forever lost* Rotted flesh behind the mask (But it can't stop the stories) Faded memories of days passed (Her face obscured to me) But I keep searching, though there is no doubt She was just my victim [Second verse] [Pre-chorus] (Because she'll be) *Forever lost* [Chorus] (No release from this hell I'm in Try to escape but it never ends Hide your souls from me Cuz I'm coming for ya) [Pre-chorus] [Chorus] (To me)

[@MythicDay]

Yay someone wrote down the lyrics in the comments! Thanks PurplePartyTiger!

[@purplepartytigerd1598]

@@MythicDay Of course! Makes it easier to sing along 😁

[@BeesMeliss]

Your singing skills have improved a lot over the years, Lost. I love this song! ^^

[@comethazel]

Me: this year kinda sucked, let's hope spooky month doesn't suck Lost and Magpie: *cracks knuckles* hold our drinks

[@FritzRolle732]

Oooooh! A Tale of the Lost Narrator rendition of "Disturbia"! Nice!

[@TheNathand1996]

Dear Losty; I know I said this a few times. Heck, I said it on my twitter. But you inspired me to try new things. And though my next reading may not come for a while, I know that I can always think back to your videos and smile. I've yet to listen to the "Tales of the Lost Narrator" but I can tell that it might be heavy. You helped make this year be a bit more barrable for hundreds, if not thousands. Thank you for doing what you do and keep being an inspiration for us all. ❤

[@CosmiaNebula]

Lyrics (with minimal formatting): Was she myth, was she mare A faded filly's story Found the beast in her lair in all her rotted glory Did her words leave you scared? A frightening allegory Now you're part of the narrative Not a myth, not a mare I am a monster With my words in my wake I leave a massacre There's no sign, there's no prayer I'll ever find her It keeps on repeating Follow the fire light And take a rest if you're weary It's a cold night There's no need to be leary Better sit tight I wanna tell you a story It's bound to give more than a fright But still she'll be... Forever lost Unending days and restless nights Forever lost Narrating stories full of fright Forever lost My beloved gone from sight Forever lost Forever lost Rotted flesh behind the mask But it can't stop the stories Faded memories of days passed Her face obscured to me But I keep searching Though there is no doubt She was just my victim Not a myth, not a mare I am a monster With my words in my wake I leave a massacre There's no sign, there's no prayer I'll ever find her It keeps on repeating Follow the fire light And take a rest if you're weary It's a cold night There's no need to be leary Better sit tight I wanna tell you a story It's bound to give more than a fright Because she'll be... Forever lost Unending days and restless nights Forever lost Narrating stories full of fright Forever lost My beloved gone from sight Forever lost Forever lost No release from this hell I'm in Try to escape but it never ends Hide your souls from me Cuz I'm comin' for ya Follow the fire light And take a rest if you're weary It's a cold night There's no need to be leary Better sit tight I wanna tell you a story It's bound to give more than a fright Because she'll be... Forever lost Unending days and restless nights Forever lost Narrating stories full of fright Forever lost My beloved gone from sight Forever lost Forever lost to me

[@Diamond-Chi]

Omg!! A parody of Disturbia by Rihanna, this is way better than the original. You two really did a good job on this

[@EaglesMan710]

Ok, I definitely wouldn’t say it’s better than the original. After all, Rihanna is a professional singer; I don’t think it’s fair to compare Lost’s and Magpie’s singing with that of Rihanna’s. It’s a fun, cute little parody, don’t get me wrong; I’m not trying to shame anyone for enjoying this, nor Lost and Mag for making it.

[@KirbyVanPelt]

I literally was thinking the same, and it is.

[@walkersweet9403]

I was wondering where I'd heard that beat before!

[@shirlecemcghee]

This is what I enjoy during October. Dark parody and amazing harmony, a real treat. This was a well chosen song for their vocal range. Basically I really liked this. I await for what's next.

[@Bluefoxtail]

I love how the idea of permanence in the lyrics, especially considering how the Lost Narrator series ended. SPOILERS AHEAD In the end, where CurseWord is somehow given a second chance with Mag, but she has to live with those haunting memories of what she had done and what was done unto her. Hence “unending days and restless nights,” and the overall title of the song “Forever Lost.” Sure, Curse was given a second chance, but, from that point on, she has to forever live with the PTSD-inducing memories of Ink Dye’s manipulation and utter torture upon Curse and Mag (psychologically and physically) how Mag used her to get back at Ink, and, of course, the many lives Curse took using her power. But, that’s just my take on it! Overall, it’s a beautiful song that, in my opinion, captures the tone of the Tale of the Lost Narrator series perfectly.

[@Sparrow9642]

Wow! You've certainly grown over the years, Lost. You and Mag both! Great start to the best month of the year! No matter what you choose to do, I will always support your content!

[@TakumoKun]

Alright boys we cant keep up the Lost can't sing joke. This song was absolutely *chef kiss* immaculate

[@Hoodie_Angel]

Buh- Lost giving us music and her and Mag are dueting?? I'd say this was a great listen befitting for the month! Can't wait for what else you two have planned!

[@Tyrannosaurus777]

This proves beyond a shadow of a doubt that you can sing so amazingly well, Lost. You have a wonderful voice and it drew me in with the first line alone. Don't ever tell yourself that you can't sing, because this video and Against the world say otherwise.

[@Holder_TPOP]

You've read my mind

[@mlp_g5_updates785]

Exactly

[@BellaPinkSavage]

Oh my god! Disturbia! This is absolutely beautiful!

[@smokewhisp6665]

Have to say, the song does the story justice. I approve.

[@addypaddysadventures5411]

I love how in the song she's STILL narrating.

[@cameronjsmith7382]

Whoa... That was AWESOME!!!!! Lost seriously you've blown me away with the best content ever!!!! Way to go!

[@sophiapentico6143]

The one dislike is from ink dye

[@DarkTheAuthor]

The dark author approves of this story. Especially considering what my character did

[@deviljinxx5590]

Nice losty, gotta say been missing your stories, hope your doing well

[@blueblaze7312]

A twist on the twisted Month of Macarbe. And it is gorgeous! Well done, Lost. Now I'm hooked.

[@jamsessioninstrumentals6538]

Thank you for using my instrumental and mentionning my channel!! Great video 👍🏻

[@ember6835]

Not gonna lie been listening to the entire playlist on repeat recently, and went back to enjoy the stories oncemore. This was a wave of happy nostalgia, and dang am I glad to go through all of this again! Thank you, Lost and Mag,(and everyone else ofc), for keeping us up with stories of terror and fright. I'm so glad to be a subscriber to all of you wonderful people!

[@Themagicrainbow12345]

This is my new absolute favorite song I absolutely loved the grimdark backstory of curse it is one of my all time favorite grimdarks you and magpiepony did an amazing job with this keep up the amazing work and I hope you have a wonderful day/night!^^

[@catscombs4426]

Wow, this is amazing! I knew Lost could sing! And super well too!! All of these Grimdark songs you’ve been posting are all so amazing! You and Mag did an amazing job!

[@MelodySnowflakeVA]

OMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMGOMG THIS SOUNDS SO GOOOOOD!!!!!!!!

[@freakazonestudios7979]

The Lost Narrator. Thank you for showing me the darker side of this fandom.

[@crystalpayne_entertains9903]

LOST CAN SING!!!!! CANT CHANGE MY MIND!!!!! this was so good!! A Lost and Mag duet is just beautiful

[@DoctorTex]

Lost: *Makes a chilling story that's a bop* Me: This will make a fine addition to my collection.

[@TheNamelessOne]

This song has so much more weight once you have heard the full story of Curse Word and it is absolutely amazing.

[@vantodd2857]

I CANT WAIT FOR THE REST OF THEM!!!!!! IM SO EXCITED! LOVE YOU LOST❤️

[@vantodd2857]

OMG ITS 2 IN THE MORNING AND IM JUST NOW SEEING THIS THE LOST NARRATOR LIKED MY COMMENT........... AND ITS MY BIRTHDAY TOO😳 BEST PRESENT YET!

[@ModelChief]

I swear, your voice just gets better every time you sing, you have no idea

[@CygnusLaboratorys2056]

Awesomeness Increased 20+

[@ShadowFlash-ke1yn]

I still re-watch the story of the lost narrator to this day, it's so good, but now we got a familiar song to sum the story up, nice!

[@l1nus0nl1neproductions9]

Scribbler starts of with ”Awoken” and Lost with a great song....this is gonna be a excitivly- terrifying month of macabre 😏

[@darkblade8205]

You know what just came up in my head lost OC singing in front of a fire singing the song with her beloved in phantom form appearing behind her singing a few lines of with her the Lost narrator can hear someone singing from behind her but every time she turns her head around to see who it is she can't find anyone. Well my weird imagination aside great song lost really great and like everyone else is saying you have a great singing voice lost don't let anyone say you don't and don't even doubt yourself anymore.

[@y.9645]

thats a cool idea id imagine the first few times Curse would cry when she sees no one is there since the voice resembles mags but as time goes on all feelings are voided

[@DiamondDrizzle]

I haven't been here for so long... I listened to both songs so far and like them both, can't wait for more coming soon!

[@MidnightTheGothArtist]

Loved this so much!! I’m excited to see what else you have in store for this month!

[@NyxMoonTV]

Stunning. Breathtaking. Everything about this is... amazing. Yep, this is going in my True Music playlist.

[@Psychologicallogix]

Oh my ive been keeping up with these since forever i’m so happy there’s more Akekkeke

[@courtneytheangelhog5603]

Hello lost narrator I'm just a fan passing by just want to say I remember back a long time ago in one of your old videos you said you couldn't sing worth a shit. Well in the worth of your character in The Tale of the Lost narrator would say bulshit you sing just as beautiful as magpiepony does and don't you forget that lost narrator you have a lovely voice you have a talent worth gold and you are awesome you and your wife Magpie both

[@cookiegacha2701]

A parody song. That's better than the original version. Okay I'm to see what story you have to tell.

[@EaglesMan710]

“That’s better than the original?” I don’t know about that, Rihanna’s a freakin legend!!

[@awkardweirdperson2840]

What's the orginal song?

[@EaglesMan710]

Diana Gonzalez-Marroquin Disturbia by Rihanna.

[@JasmineSwantek]

Haunting and beautiful at the same time. Love how you the "Rihanna's 'Disturbia'" song for your recap of "The Tale of the Lost Narrator" saga. I love that story. I think it what got me into grimdark tales to begin with. So, thank you Losty. My you and your beloved Magpie be bless and healthy for many years. And tell Mag I'm sorry for what she went trough. I know what it's like to not feel loved from someone else. And it was my own mother. She's dead now. Don't know what she die of and yet I really don't care. I'm just glad that I'm still moving forward.

[@lunasnight5603]

This song along with the story is beautiful and will for ever be one of my favorite i have listen to them all so much i can tell whole story word for word as it plays thank you for doing this and putting so much hard work into something so beautiful

[@Lunaisity]

Listen to this song for about 15mins. I love the lyrics, the harmony between Lost and Mag is soo good. I think it's time to rewatch Tales of the Lost Narrator. Keep it up 😁🎉

[@zaybug]

definitely a throwback to my one favorite gridmarks ive ever heard off your channel.

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

That’s an amazing parody of this song. It’s amazing. Can’t wait for the rest. Edit: disturbia by Rihanna, that’s what I was talking about by the way.

[@jazzykingjack2846]

The queen of grim darks, horror and terror has come out once again to tell a story to us all during this trying time.

[@gamingwithjosie]

This song is so catchy lost. You did an amazing job on it.

[@darkblastoise9199]

OMG this is a Spooktaculer way to start October 🎃 this is such a beautiful and scary song XD Wonderful job Lost and Mag you two are just amazing 😆

[@nicolaaudyova9362]

Wau, this song is so beautiful. I love it since her first note. Just keep going with this amazing content. I love you both.

[@SingalekSMW]

I think a got A LIIIITTLE addicted:D

[@simonbelmont207]

Losty! You can no longer say you can’t sing! You know you’re very good! We need more covers from you!

[@jadgamester1975]

i wish you all are replaying the song as many times as i have its to good the lyrics the music in the background ooooo it hits my sweet spot for music audio can only do soo much lyrics is what gets me =}

[@journijones3253]

Love this SO much!

[@ChildOfTheFence]

Wow. Not at all what I was expecting, but that was absolutely beautiful! I think that's the best singing we've gotten from lost yet!

[@arnoldmws6330]

I hope this doesn't creep the both of you out, but I love you both so much. You both make my heart feel so happy. Keep rocking Lost and Magpie

[@bladeraptor1]

No matter how many times I listen to this song I get the same chill down my spine. Thank you lost and mag for making such an awesome video

[@ryeregular]

Just watched the tale of the lost narrator playlist and omg. I loved it. And. I cried at one point cause I'm a whimp lol and just I loved it soooo much 👻 best story ever

[@Thedragonlover95]

Back when Lost said she couldn't sing, well this is proof she's come along way. And you Lost have a very fitting voice for these

[@coyotealienss]

I just realized that its Disturbia!! I LOVE IT EVEN MORE--

[@1989JROG]

This was very well done, Losty. And Mag also did a great job as well. You both should be proud of yourselves. You both got me hooked on this song.

[@undeadban8692]

The song is actually really catchy I found myself singing this song in my head the entire time I was at work

[@parthxus]

I have been waiting all week for this. I got something right. I’m excited for the next one. Amazing as always Losty!

[@FlutterRoze]

Lost signing!? Holy sh*t!!! What!? You sound so good! Why you kept this locked hidden away from the world girl!! Keep up the awesome work! Can’t wait to see more of this singing side of you Lost!! 💙 ALSO! HOW DID I MOSS SEEING THIS VIDEO!!! LMAO!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@HSOP-OFFICIAL]

You completely forgot this is a parody because of the true emotion and amazing tail in the flawless lyrics.

[@aetherlight_melody]

Lost u have a great singing voice, awesome job both of u on this piece ^^

[@fluffyasmr7633]

Ok how did I miss this? Bad youtube

[@tenshineko0159]

You both did beautifully. I want more of LostNarrator singing.

[@pokemonfan6132]

Well what a great way to start off this month, Wonderful job Lost and Mag!

[@almondhhooves2000]

Mag and Lost together sounds good as ever...

[@quintonjones2699]

Mag Losty that was an absolutely spectacular duet kudos to you two

[@katiemefford6483]

That was really great, you should put this on Spotify or something I would gladly listen to this on repeat

[@taylorbassinger6846]

Okay but this is a bop

[@Gresekjr122]

Dear Lost and Mag wow just Wow you both have beautiful singing voices. I really enjoyed this spooky song. Keep up the good work you too. Love you both. Have a wonderful day.

[@nephylias3507]

This is really beautiful! Good job Lost! 😃

[@Animanster]

Good song. This song almost perfectly matches the aspects of 1 of my OC's, who lost everything she cared about but no one wants to believe or help her take down the ones responsible. So she feels so alone and is the only one who know the evil deeds done.

[@jessicapedley4082]

Spooktacular reading Lost ^^

[@thegothicmermaid5382]

This is beautiful,Lost,Your Music and Fanfics are addicting to listen to

[@rae5456]

Is anyone else disturbed by the face of Mag? It just looks so oddly human It's really uncanny valley

[@SuperSpike47]

This is so awesome 😸

[@shadestone9024]

this so well done Lost you and Mag have very beautiful voices also I love the lyrics for the song as they help tell Lost's story as well as fill the listener with dread and fear

[@shadestone9024]

Also this is Lost's theme in my mind XD but seriously good job Lost and Mag for your awesome and beautiful singing

[@Nevelation7]

I really enjoyed this one, such a fitting song for the series. The music, the singing, just fantastic :)

[@mlpfan3449]

I love this song and awesome video editing Beautiful voice

[@agentriptide7002]

I love it amazing work

[@ViolightMLP]

This is really interesting, very nice story and singing is amazing :D

[@CT-BONITA]

Thus song reminds of the original I just can't remember. But overall YOU KILLED IT with this vid! Edit: Disturbia by Rihanna.

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

Some um 3 weeks later and I ALMOST perfectly in key with both of you... There are some parts I'm still perfecting but I'm almost there same with Nook Inc. Void and of course A Flight That Never Comes... If thats bad then... Sorry not Sorry they are all catchy... So is Fluttershy's Music Box... But that one's taking a bit longer to sing with probably cause its higher then what I can do as an Alto... But I'll get there eventually.

[@darumakunto6299]

Ooooh this is so spooky I love it!! Great work guys ! 💖💕🎃

[@spicybicy6667]

I missed you so much! Welcome back!

[@CavatinaProductions]

Lost being like "I can't sing" and then pulls out this shit lol. For real, this was great!