Four Teens Fight over One Girl! | Part 2

[@Kaboomboo]

You gotta love when the defendant doesn't need to say anything.

[@unrulysinner635]

I don’t. I wanna hear what he has to say and his story.

[@Kaboomboo]

@@unrulysinner635 I mean it's pretty obvious. He saw three dudes roll up near his house to jump him so he took a bat out and scared them off by hitting the car.

[@oreolover9321]

@@Kaboomboo exactly he has right to defend himself and they on his property

[@joshplayzgamezz]

Just the way he was standing there kinda made me laugh. Almost with the look of "please don't talk to me, please don't talk to me. Just stand politely, I've seen what happens when people interrupt her"

[@Kaboomboo]

@@joshplayzgamezz Kid clearly did the right thing. Judy didn't talk to him at all lol

[@TheJellymonty]

When the defendant is silent, you're doomed. Period.

[@EH23831]

True dat 😂😂

[@jennernolast6858]

Totally agree. When the defense is not defending, the plaintiff is in trouble.

[@amberr1241]

So true 💯😆🤣

[@godmadesam]

Yep! 😂

[@timtrainage]

End of story

[@jjjppp897]

The defendant didn’t even have to defend himself, judge Judy defended the defendant 😂😂😂

[@cntrivergel1992]

Yup, this is why I love Judge Judy 😂

[@marianna1513]

JJ - "Your mom wants me to believe you have halos over your head. That's a lot of baloney. " Kid- "correct" 😭🤣🤣

[@eddie9461]

Bologna lol

[@dandythemandy]

😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@jesuscarrillo3705]

He didn't wamt to lie at those levels

[@marianna1513]

@@eddie9461 Thank you😌

[@marianna1513]

@@jesuscarrillo3705 😭🤣🤣🤣

[@samuelkimble9717]

The mom is a prime example of why kids aren't held accountable for their actions, sad case of parenting.

[@melaniechristinee]

YEEESSS!! And it’s not their fault, a parent is their guide in life. And she’s a doctor?? How embarrassing. But the son was smart he was denying anything. At least the mom didn’t raise a liar. Anyway, hope they all learned something!!

[@litledevel15]

@@melaniechristineeshe’s the typical mom to go, “oh no, not my child”

[@1MrErling]

indeed.

[@1MrErling]

Indeed, I belive the son got it in spite of a stupid mother @@melaniechristinee

[@Sugiyamasama]

Thats usually what spoiled ass rich kids be like. Do something dumb then cry to mommy how their actions aint their faults

[@timothykoconas2377]

I like when Judge Judy says to the mother, "I don't care what you think."

[@nnedwards3260]

YES!

I like when she says I don’t care what you think in any case to anyone. 😂

[@barbarak2836]

Or better yet, "I don't care what you FEEL."

[@JoshuaR1992]

Judge Judy screaming "don't" at the beginning had me shook. I had my headphones in. 😂😂

[@r1r122]

😂😂

[@laurenjwolf]

Sammmeeee. I nearly dropped my phone.... Then went looking for this comment 😂

[@ColinMarcusJackson]

Yuuup, and you can't tell me they didn't edit it that way completely on purpose! 🤣

[@merryhineline7781]

I jumped.

[@pisto30]

Me too! 🤣

[@lynndominic1967]

Plot twist, while these young men are in court, Natalie is probably at home, planning her next relationship with the next guy😅

[@channiejysyiaa]

🤣🤣 The fact that they all know each other speaks volumes about Natalie.

[@alphaomega5909]

You know it,lol. 🤣

[@michaelabailey3622]

😅😅😅

[@HungVu-vs3dv]

She’s probably dated the fifths guy

[@philipposkasotis8658]

@Steve Fox She is the practice girl

[@McTaco]

That blonde kid is the antagonist in every 80’s movie.

[@rupertperiwinkle4477]

He looks like evil Matt Damon LOL!!!

[@LaDominicana2011]

😂😂😂

[@lilhomie8390]

he's giving bully from the rich kid summer camp across the lake

[@Mnt2beeblebee]

He’s like “I have nice cheekbones so I get to dominate the human race”

[@rupertperiwinkle4477]

@@Mnt2beeblebee He looks like a pipsquieak

[@MLife1972]

I love the way the mother turns into a turtle when JJ speaks.

[@coffeecake8835]

😂😂

[@wiesaal827]

Oh no you didn't 🤣🤣🤣 went into a flat screen

[@MsSpider26]

right? And she's a doctor

[@tkn9717]

HAHAHAHHAHA

[@mikephalen3162]

@@MsSpider26 Exactly. I suspect she's a Ph.D., and not a medical doctor. She's probably some academic who doesn't understand the real world.

[@justbusiness01]

I LOVED when she called them a gang. Sweet words to my ears 🤌 lol

[@molly3204]

I was just going to comment this

[@Joyus1]

@@molly3204 same! A bunch of thugs😂

[@krana1605]

Sweet and appropriate! 😄

[@PricelessPrince_]

@@Joyus1not the thugs who they pimpin? 😭😫

[@Joyus1]

@@PricelessPrince_ 🤣🤣🤣💀

[@gshalabama]

People looking to have children should be required to watch 150 episodes of Judge Judy.

[@tori4040]

I forgot the defendant was there for a minute lol

[@cancerianblue85]

😂😂😂 Same!!

[@TylerA52903]

Something I learned about watching Judge Judy is that being quiet in her courtroom is definitely the best thing to do regardless of the case or which side you’re on

[@kakarot4243]

😘😘😘😘😘

[@latentgamer5762]

4 kids went to jump another.. the kid beat their car with a bat and doesn't have to say or pay a thing. Good job on this one, Judy!

[@ReducePlastic]

It was three. I think JJ miscounted. It was the boys in court and their friend.

[@raterus]

He did confirm in the previous part he was currently with the girl.

[@ryanrhea1]

Judge was right. In the first place why these teens went to Max's house.

[@LS-Gaming101]

@@ReducePlastic the 4 boys was: the defendant, the 2 other boys in court, and their friend.

[@elvickRULES]

It was 5. 1:47 Three went to his house. Then nerdy dude and his friend makes two: five total.

[@iguanarana]

The best. Judge Judy is 100 % right. Parenting people.

[@Mehrunissah93]

😂😂😂 I love when Judge Judy has to literally parent other parents. Some of these teens are out of hand because their "role models" don't teach them accountability and wisdom.

[@markbrandon7359]

And most of these bad parents are woke liberals

[@shelberz1]

Yes

[@caramama1731]

And the son had a smirk on the whole time. They knew what they were doing!

[@lnicole2504]

Accountability That's the keyword, here. Kids are not held accountable for their actions.

[@taffiejosh]

She isn't supposed to be a parent, she is supposed to be a judge in the eye of the law. In this case, judy got it wrong.

[@rypoelk997]

Judy isn't just street smart, she's street genius. She could tell what happened instantly. I'm impressed

[@amj4441]

That's one of things I love about her. She analysises the situation very carefully, and she is fair as they come.

[@UncleDuTheWatchman]

Love the terrm "Street Genius"!

[@rypoelk997]

@@amj4441 I love it when she just lays into the pit bull owners

[@amj4441]

@@rypoelk997 😂😂

[@anak6940]

@@rypoelk997go seek psychiatric help. U need it

[@sophielove7896]

The people's reactions in the back when judge judy goes off! 😂😂

[@kakarot4243]

Ur so fine 😘😘😘

[@MariahEbrown]

This is the classic "My son would never" Mom. 🤡💀

[@stevenp25100]

She never said that?

[@korajames9993]

@@stevenp25100 your wife still needs to stop pampering your son man, cmon.

[@stevenp25100]

@@korajames9993 good comeback

[@jazzyj6640]

Sounds about white. I mean right.

[@stevenp25100]

@@jazzyj6640 ah yeah. Cause we know other peoples are known for their classy and upstanding behavior

[@TheJellymonty]

We need to see Natalie. I am beyond interested in what these fools were fighting for.

[@amacuro]

Don't be shallow. Looks are not everything. Maybe she's very smart and/or charming.

[@kyaramckoy1005]

Nah, Natalie is a little to fast.

[@SMGJohn]

Probably weights 100 pounds, glasses only your grandma would wear and can be smelled from 16 blocks away, only a true loser in life could love a bike I mean woman like that.

[@Daniellehiu]

Same. Same 🤣

[@acousticshadow4032]

Think "Lulu" from Hee Haw.

[@CaroGee92]

The mom is in complete denial 😂 She doesn’t understand that the one who caused damage to the car was her son. It was under his responsibility and he went to look for trouble. Genius!!! Love you JJ

[@amangotree]

she gets so animated with juvenile cases cause it's her specialty. I freaking love it! she let's teenagers have her wrath 😆

[@jazzya7383]

Love judge Judy! 👏🏾

[@sueparks-ld4ru]

she knows when they are lying

[@katesweeney9101]

And I'm sure having all those kids and grandkids of her own helps, too ;)

[@jessicaarmstrong5035]

I love it when she's like "Usually when a teenager's lips are moving, they're lying."

[@stephencook7337]

She was a family court judge before she was on the JJ show. We’re talking early 1990s or prior….

[@DonGrigorianFishing]

They went over to jump the guy LOLL The guy had no choice but to pull out a bat for self protection

[@MsDulcecandy87fan]

YUP

[@unrulysinner635]

Exactly! They’re lucky it wasn’t a gun

[@mel924]

He could have stayed in the house but they would have gone after him again at another time.

[@ericawilliam7985]

@@mel924 I was just goin to say that but you finished that off nicely…

[@oreolover9321]

Exactly lol I don't get why the mother can understand that

[@state503]

Absolutely right. Don’t cover for your children’s mistakes. Consequences for poor judgement.

[@Waynes-xt9gr]

that is why im NOT married, no gfs, no babies........dont NEED the headaches

[@cha9165]

Legend has it this mother still doesnt get why her son has to pay for the car

[@77barrymac]

Yet, I think the son DOES get it.

[@MenteMaestra91]

Legend has it you still can't come up with an original joke.

[@iguanarana]

Hahaha that’s right she still doesn’t get it.

[@terraespiritus4895]

​@@MenteMaestra91Legend has it you still have a giant cactus up your cornhole.

[@ldr.enjoyer]

@@77barrymacbecause he knows what they were going to do. They were looking to fight and they parked a bit away in case they wanted to jump in the fight too. Gang was the appropriate word for them, jst wish she would’ve also called them jobless thugs

[@larisalynnortiz8979]

JJ got so excited when she found out about the other friend!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@SemeshkoV]

Yes! And at that moment I was waiting for the Judge to sarcastically ask ".. and did Natalie date him also??"

[@pennylane8318]

Judge Judy has the wisdom of Solomon.

[@geerowr.6666]

Irresponsible parenting. She stayed busy trying to justify her kids bad behavior. They coulda been shot descending upon someone's house after 9pm. About a girl who has dated all THREE of them. Let that sink in!!!!

[@alphaomega5909]

I just Googled that mother. She's an Opthamologist still in Nevada. The irony she's an Eye doctor but is Blind to her sons b.s.,lol.

[@NOCALGooN916]

Yea that's crazy they don't think about tings like that

[@EH23831]

Yep! 🙄 no wonder there’s so many irresponsible, entitled people wandering around causing trouble

[@cls3201]

@@EH23831 FAAAAAACTS

[@ishahcanah7351]

And the sad part is she STILL didn’t understand she should hold her son accountable for the damage to the car. After Judge Judy explained it to her more than 5 times, she still didn’t get it. Her son got the message but she didn’t. 😮

[@MaseRhea]

That "DON'T!" blew my hair back 🥴

[@nildabridgeman8104]

🤭😆

[@kmsleyang1980]

BAYBEE my wig flew right off…

[@mashaallah8249]

😅Yes I have whiplash

[@jazzyj6640]

I dropped my ice cream cone 🍦

[@MusedDiaries]

I woke up 😂😂😂

[@vina_colada]

lmao the way she keeps insulting those kids 🤣🤣

[@HighClassWhiteTrashCharlee]

Kid with the smirk…future wolf of Wall Street in the making😂

[@barbarak2836]

And/or a "successful" politician.

[@agatanakonieczny2213]

Toxic narcissist and potential criminal. Good for Natalie she broke up with him.

[@Struieboy]

Or lawyer

[@scribe712]

That was my exact thought while looking at him.

[@gdenny1748]

He’ll be serving time before you know it

[@relaxwithme3398]

I love how Judge Judy saw how excited he was to have his friend tell the story, but she said “no you’re gonna tell it!”

[@lateblossom]

She's so good, the defendant doesn't even have to speak. That's a good judge.

[@DJ-il2mb]

She put those people in their place but it seems like the lesson flew right over their head

[@crystalsswtor3760]

Of course it did because they think they are entitled

[@EH23831]

Maybe Max got it… but not the mum 🙄

[@earthpart3]

no doubt, she probably won't even make him pay for it or say anything further about it.

[@peacheskong2245]

@@EH23831 you mean Nick

[@butterpecanbrielle]

Yes because she’s a Karen and raising her son to be a Kyle. Lol

[@keanancupido]

I love that the defendant didn't need to do anything. And I loved how the audience applauded too. This was a nice case!

[@wadecarruthers8294]

I hope and pray that you don't have kids. I bet if your child had their heart broken, you'd tell them to just roll over and accept it. The defendant is dating the plaintiffs ex-girlfriend, HELLO IN THERE?!

[@wintercame]

@@wadecarruthers8294 Baloney. This is high school and guess what, you don't own people. Life lessons, toughen up for adulthood, kids.

[@keanancupido]

@@wadecarruthers8294 Uhm you know how ridiculous you sound

[@wadecarruthers8294]

@@wintercame That maybe accurate, but my 15 year old daughter committed suicide after her first boyfriend broke up with her over Facebook, because he was too much of a coward to do it in person. For some people being dumped is devastating.

[@wintercame]

@@wadecarruthers8294 I'm terribly sorry to hear that. There is a report from the CDC today and it doesn't look good for young girls.

[@vgrannyvl2]

I love it...I was taught to NEVER go to someone's house looking for trouble..many ppl wake up dead because of this type of stupidity..

[@elizaleroux9173]

Bad parenting from the mother! Lesson learned, good ruling JJ.

[@PricelessPrince_]

Right I feel like she’s the type of parent that if her son done something wrong she’ll try and justify what he’s done and that’s not great parenting at all kids are supposed to learn from the mistakes and as a parent you’re supposed to give them life learning lessons so they won’t do it again

[@wadecarruthers8294]

Her son had his heart broken.

[@wadecarruthers8294]

@@PricelessPrince_ Do you have children?

[@asanta2023]

@@PricelessPrince_ or maybe the Mom actually thought her son was not at fault. Maybe now, after JJ letting her know, she’ll get it??

[@MLife1972]

I'm not sure any of them learned a lesson. They all went away thinking they were right.

[@Kaboomboo]

Anyone else get a jump scare in the first second?

[@elizaleroux9173]

Me too. 😬

[@leeleefluffy06]

Hell yeah 😂😂

[@Wtftyyy]

Gave me a whole anxiety attack 😭

[@ashmarie_thatsme6517]

Yessssss… 😭 I wasn’t readddyyyyy 😭😭😭

[@oreolover9321]

Lol caught me off guard 🤣

[@Citizenoftheworld20]

As he is telling the story, his friend next to him is being roasted, and judge Judy is having a good time watching him 😂

[@Chidinma.U]

OMG!!! I almost threw my phone when she screamed DON'T!! 😂 AHNNNN

[@lindaharner9245]

Don't forget the pen!!

[@LV2UXO77]

Wholeheartedly agree with Judge Judy's decision. I'm sure what was written on the report for Judy to read made it look like her son and friends were angels. I love how Judge Judy can read between the lines.

[@jerryf3307]

THIS MOTHER SHOULD BE HAPPY THAT THIS GROUP DIDN'T GET INTO A FIGHT AND POSSIBLY HURT THE OTHER YOUNG MAN, IF SO HER SON WOULD HAVE FACED CRIMINAL CHARGES!!!!!

[@annea.4173]

That very brief burst of audience applause in the final few seconds was everything.

[@kathyhansen9546]

Don’t like the applause and other reactions

[@MsVaughnKitty]

She really thinks you can arrive to someones house with MULTIPLE people who all have ill intent and have no repercussions for your actions? She's lucky her little car is the only thing that was hit with a bat and not her "precious innocent" son. I would have liked to hear the details of the scuffle lol.

[@honeyjd780]

“I had nothing else to do” is killing me🤣

[@ilyakogan]

The boy is smarter and more responsible than his mother.

[@kirby2662]

he doesn’t have the karen gene

[@ButWhatIfItIs]

Its true. Least he knew he was in the wrong, and tbh he even seemed a little exasperated with his mother trying to defend something Judge had already made clear to him was indefensible. I'm sure she'd of still been talking about her car damages even if they'd beaten Max up.

[@stevenceja4706]

He shouldn't even have friends like the other guy. He was smug the entire time listening to the Plaintiff get roasted

[@no_one161]

@@stevenceja4706 OH YES YES YES U CAUGHT IT RIGHT

[@vanesslifeygo]

lmao

[@ooostarb3rryooo]

What her son did with his friends was unhinged behavior. Imagine if he wasn’t held accountable and he did this as an adult. Somebody dating your ex shouldn’t have escalated to this point. Mother needs to hold him accountable.

[@ButWhatIfItIs]

Let's be honest, 2nd ex is the leader of their group and 1st ex is kind of passive. So he had no problem with 2nd ex dating Natalie, but 2nd ex couldn't handle her dating Max, the defendant. Its not unhinged, its ridiculous and immature behaviour but its not uncommon in teenagers to behave like this. Its a toss up in who's worse, 1st ex who seems otherwise responsible and as if he wouldn't normally be involved in things like this. Or 2nd ex who comes off as being more of a problem child, and clearly was pushing for the incident that happened.

[@katesweeney9101]

Based on the way the mother was fighting back against JJ, I doubt she learned anything from this, and she'll likely continue encouraging and excusing her son's poor choices.

[@Kaboomboo]

@@ButWhatIfItIs I agree. It's stupid teen behavior. I know it sounds extreme, but I don't think teens should be dating if they don't have anything else to do. As in, if they're not working or have some sort of extra curricular activity, they shouldn't be spending all their time thinking about dating where stupid sh*t like this can happen. They can at least occupy themselves with something else.

[@agatanakonieczny2213]

​@@ButWhatIfItIs Without a cost, first one would never give up the toxic second one.

[@cheriem432]

I understand that teens don't understand the power of nor how to control responses that are directly related to their burgeoning testosterone levels, But *four* of them wanting to beat down another teen is mental. They won't even remember her *name* in another year or two.

[@pwl1950]

I love Judge Judy. I wish all judges were more like her. Society would be better for it.

[@susiesunshine43]

Man!!!!! Judge Judy made me jump so high at the beginning of this one, lmao!!!!

[@themirrorsofmymind]

Hey, the mother in this case is a DOCTOR and JJ made her look like she was at the Principle's office! @2:26

[@tkolove14]

Max and his father got the case dismissed and the appearance fee and didn’t have to say a word. 😂😂😂

[@wadecarruthers8294]

Clearly daddy raised his son to accept leftovers and sloppy seconds.

[@tkolove14]

@@wadecarruthers8294 they are 17 years old. These are playground relationships and won’t matter in 6 months.

[@l.b.9522]

@@wadecarruthers8294 so by your words everyone who has slept with someone should stay forever with that first person no matter what? OR that if someone breaks up with someone else no one is allowed to date anyone ever again? That "Left overs and sloppy seconds" stuff usually comes from someone salty llol

[@wadecarruthers8294]

@@l.b.9522 Nothing else to say?

[@l.b.9522]

@@wadecarruthers8294 well good for you. Some people don't wait like you did. I still think its an old fashioned and IMO wrong. they are CHILDREN who are learning. And Whatever happened with your daughter has nothing to do with these kids. Maybe you failed your kid with this way of thinking. maybe if she thought that she didn't need to be with the first person she was dating with that maybe she wouldn't have taken her life. someone taking their own life has more problems than just the one. oh and I'm sorry that I didn't get back to you in the time YOU thought I should. patience, dude.

[@AerynSB]

I just dont think anyone could fill Judge Judys shoes man... Shes like a force of nature when it comes to truth. People can come in with all their lies rooted firmly and prepared, doesnt matter. Judge Judy shakes them loose with a couple questions and her empathic capabilities.

[@ClaudeS39]

JJ 😂so savage! She gave that mother a lesson in parenting she’ll never forget!

[@patriciadebnam879]

We hope she learned

[@asanta2023]

Honestly, I learn from every case with JJ about life.

[@trinity72gp]

She should rewatch this and see how they both stood either side of her, grinning about the whole thing 🤡

[@patriciadebnam879]

@@trinity72gp exactly!

[@MsSpider26]

i don't think that mother learned anything

[@ericmatthews9076]

The Plantiffs were smirking at the end. They know damn well they are wrong

[@Prometheus_43]

Judy kicks @ss, I love how she cuts through the BS and gets straight to the point!

[@lucky1u]

Good for her. Gotta teach these kids and parents a lesson. I love how that boy owned up to his mistake the entire time even as his mom tried to defend him. He is the only one I believe will learn from this event.

[@jlr108]

Except his mum will fill his head with how much of a victim he is instead of insisting the boy work and pay for the damage his choices caused.

[@cheriem432]

Sadly, I don't think the mother will ever learn. Her behavior is much too ingrained by now.

[@DonGrigorianFishing]

JJ jumped out of the screen for a sec! 😱

[@alieyesonme247]

It is absolutely mind-blowing how smart judge Judy really is she is such a genius, I wish you would be our first woman president

[@janetpartyka5968]

She had kids and she's not an idiot like the mother.

[@kenbob1071]

Hopefully she will replace that unethical disaster named Clarence Thomas on the SC.

[@joecrawford172]

That smug mom came to that courtroom thinking all she had to do was hand Byrd an estimate for the car repairs and Judge Judy would order that Max kid to cut them a check. Hahahahaha. Wrong.

[@fatimaboebina]

These boys look so old yet young at the same time 😂

[@BouncyBrown]

The defendant looks like a toddler, the two plaintiffs look like middle aged accountants.

[@wispothewindchimemeadow8973]

😂😭

[@sandlotkrew8778]

LMAO !! FACTS !!... Homeboy's hairline is already heading into retirement... While his short friend looks like a grown adult in the face. In fact, he looks like a short version of the dad from Seventh Heaven. Benjamin Button genetics !! LOL !!

[@CanadianMonarchist]

I was impressed they all dressed appropriately for court.

[@Eastsid3]

I thought I was the only one who noticed this

[@etv2045]

The way that judge Judy pieced all of this together is amazing

[@blackbutterflytarot8071]

AND THIS IS WHY I ADORE JUDGE JUDY....SOMETIMES lol

[@tiffbeevachou108]

Too many parents delude themselves to think their children are perfect, so these kids act like absolute tools. This Mom is a primary example

[@joannlove3414]

this is why judge Judy has the job. well done

[@missbradicah]

She called the boys out to be a gang, lol! GO Judge Judy!

[@Stephen_A.]

Unbelievable. The mother agrees that her son should not have gone to that house, but still wants the defendant to pay for the damages. And the defendant agreed that he should pay for the damages, so why are they suing him in court ? Their stupidity really worked against them.

[@jacksafereffort516]

If I was 16 years old and a woman identifying herself as a Doctor (who would also eventually sue me) was coming at me about damage to her car after her kid rolled up on my spot looking for payback, yeah I'd be scared enough to cave to her unreasonable demands via text. I also would hope a judge like JJ would later see through that.

[@vmcougarintn5035]

Maybe this will help... Just think of males over the age of ooh..., say 13 as aliens. They only think about 2 things, food, and sex! Like the Judge, I happen to understand her wisdom. These are teens let loose! They have no purpose, if they were required to work on the farm or in a family business most of this nonsense would go away.

[@queenbee3647]

Cant take the law into your own hands. JJ called them a gang. Why didnt she say the defendant should have left? Stayed in his house? Called 911? She loves to lecture about taking the law into your own hands but this time she didnt. Because it would have ruined her big close up and a chance to yell at the mom. JJ is a joke. But Im not laughing.

[@Kaboomboo]

@@queenbee3647 There's a difference between getting into an altercation at a store, and someone rolling up to your own house unexpectedly. In this case, it doesn't matter if the defendant called the police or not. The boys came to him with the explicit intent to beat him up, 3 to 1. At that point it was self defense. The kid had every right to defend his home and body. If he had caused bodily injury, that would be a different story. But in this case, the car was damaged because the three boys precipitated the altercation believing they could wallop on one guy for no reason. For that, Judy wasn't going to award one cent to the plaintiffs. They shouldn't have gone looking for trouble.

[@agatanakonieczny2213]

​@@queenbee3647 JJ was probably happy the third one occurred to be braver, more intelligent and efficient than the coward second one. (He was attacked, he showed his justified aggression, lightly damaged the car and not injured a person). They played a stupid game and won a stupid prize. The second one is toxic. The first one needed a wake-up call. I guess that is why JJ wanted him to pay. Having a friend who probably "stole" your date and later being easily involved in the criminal act shows how weak and stupid he is. The mother is also not the sharpest knife in the drawer.

[@TheDigitalDecade]

Oh man that was awesome. People think they can go intimidate someone with no consequences. Judy is the shit.

[@Tiviab]

The entitlement these parents have is insane. They are teaching their kids the same. Although you instigated the situation you shouldn’t have to pay…. I’m glad judge Judy ruled the way she did.

[@janetpartyka5968]

Exactly.

[@Derek.Joseph]

I know I sound like a broken record talking about the defendant being silent, but it’s part of the reason he won in my opinion. He doesn’t come across as a hothead, and proved a point without anyone getting hurt despite a group rolling up to his address. Been watching JJ for 20 years and don’t remember any litigant speaking less.

[@Kaboomboo]

True. I think Judy picked up on that. He wasn't being aggressive. Not the type to just swing bats at people for fun.

[@wesleyorange8133]

He was very smart to damage their car, and not attack a person.

[@MSG4L]

So true he’s smart and I think being silent is 50% of why he won the case

[@Maeve_Puffs]

That “DONT” surprised the hell out of me. Especially take a break right after part 1! 😂

[@nildabridgeman8104]

You know your case is DONE when JJ says "OH.. just a second.. just a second..."

[@debongarrigues9177]

SOoooooooooo Truuuuuuue. It's always in that moment, when she knows "Exactly WHO she's dealing with"

[@trinity72gp]

2:56 The defendants mother WASN'T READY FOR JJ 👩🏻‍⚖️😂

[@healthyinchrist7156]

I believe you meant the "plantif's mother"

[@trinity72gp]

@@healthyinchrist7156 👍🏾the Plaintiff yes 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@eltondelcid3672]

Actually she thought she was, she had many papers there and it seemed had read them many times. But never thought JJ was this smart

[@margiesweet6362]

Excellent ruling. The guy had every right to defend himself BEFORE something bad happened.

[@djanime317]

0:00 Headphone users might want to turn it down, that scared the crap out of me 😂😂😂😂😂💀

[@deontek]

💀🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@cls3201]

I knew as soon as that kid said he went with Mr. Smarty pants because he had nothing better to do, it was a WRAP!!!

[@darwingarcia4574]

A good parents should listen and follow judge Judy advice 😂😂😂😅😅😅

[@kylewhittle6565]

This made me smile. One of the best cases I’ve seen. I don’t always agree with JJ but here the law is clear. Named ‘criminal enterprise’ if a gang goes to cause trouble and inadvertently one of them gets hurt or their property is damaged, they are liable!

[@RyHTX]

Man if I were the mom I’d be super embarrassed 😂😂😂

[@cheriem432]

Nah, she's too entitled to be embarrassed. I agree with you, because you have a sense of morality.

[@robertfuentes9677]

Judge Judy: "Don't move your head!" Matthew: Moves head nodding in approval*

[@theangrycowb0y]

And that right there is exactly why I keep coming back! Bless your gifted heart, Judge Judy.

[@VisualizeHealing]

This was the best JJ EVER! She called "Mr. Smarty Pants" out and his little follower got held accountable. Ms./Dr., needed a lesson in parenting and got it front and center. I just hope she heeds it.

[@louisemckinney2598]

I’m not sure she did. Her comment afterwards and her face said “I can’t believe she talked to me like that”

[@janetpartyka5968]

Oh she won't. She hasn't learned her lesson. She doesn't spend enough time with her kid to know where he is.

[@saulgood2548]

Judge Judy’s verdict and explanation is beyond accurate.

[@Alice-ui9oy]

I love JJ dealing with kids and teens and teaching parents how to parent 😅

[@cheriem432]

If only the parents would *learn* what they are being taught!

[@evea1735]

Very good lesson! Don't go around looking for trouble!! The ones who come looking for trouble will pay for the consequences. Lesson taught at kindergarten level.

[@doxcb4717]

Judge Judy is one of the wisest person around . She is so right on the ruling of this case . They went there as a gang looking to cause harm and this young man came out with a bat to defend himself

[@BuckinNightmare]

Teaching that mom how to mom 👏👏👏👏👏 I love Judge Judy!!! Those kids just sitting there with those smirks, they could use a lot more then just losing in court

[@LoverGworl777]

She ripped her a 🗣NEW ONE!! Yaaassss Judge Judy!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣💅🏾🥰

[@davidunger1526]

JJ knew what happened and already had her verdict before they ever even entered the courtroom. Love it!

[@garrethenderson9695]

Max is probably the smartest person to ever come on Judge Judy. Never said a word. He knew he was winning and kept his mouth shut.

[@9k49]

He’s definitely a good example for defendants who (think they are) in the right

[@keoraanderson459]

His mom really did not see that her son was at fault 🤔

[@3yearsago287]

She's part of their gang

[@jazzyj6640]

Sounds about right 😂

[@chikenfrye5071]

3:45 "I'm speaking, I'm speaking." Classic judy line

[@parisaloveee1612]

JJ: “And I know that that’s alot of baloney!” Plaintiff: “Correct” 😭🤣😅

[@trinity72gp]

Commendation for the editing on this case. JJ frightened everyone (including me) with one word "DON'T" 👩🏻‍⚖️😂👏🏾

[@Telemergion]

"I didn't really want to go to the house but I had nothing else to do." If that isn't the most peak teenager sentence.

[@brocktoon8]

That was nothing short of awesome. JJ doesn't stand for bullying. Whoop whoop!

[@stellac.e2086]

SELF DEFENSE!! the teeny bopper nerds were gonna try to do a BEAT DOWN. they lost. 😂

[@byronbuchanan3066]

JJ is a genius. The most important lesson is to avoid trouble.... Id come out with a bat too if 4 guys showed up to jump me.

[@adrianachong9029]

What kind of mother is THAT stupid! That’s how criminals are raised. She refused to see that the responsibility rested on her son’s shoulders and now she’s been embarrassed on national television. This is why I freakin LOVE Judge Judy!!! ❤

[@ttww1590]

More mothers than you think.

[@wadecarruthers8294]

Her son had his heart broken!

[@ButWhatIfItIs]

@@wadecarruthers8294 And you can tell she'd really go with that in a court :D

[@joymosley8997]

And his mother is Dr. Irish btw 🙄

[@gingerisevil02]

Mothers never think their "precious baby boys" should be held accountable for anything.

[@cteda]

Momma’s shocked her baby is being held accountable 😂

[@confidentialp6292]

Judge was absolutely right. My mom always told me “son you play stupid games, you win stupid prizes”. Let that sink to all

[@KaneshaAndrews]

As I was watching this....I was laughing and shaking my head at the nonsense that could have been avoided if Nick would have just told Matthew, "I'm not getting involved, I'm going home".

[@scottythegreat1]

Its called peer pressure. The witness to this case is easily the leader of this gang. A lot of gang leaders have their followers so wrapped around their fingers that their followers would be willing to follow them off a cliff. Edit: In many cases, one of the followers ends up paying the price for the misdeeds, not the leader.