FROM Season 3 Ending Explained! Theories, Clues & Season 4 Predictions!

[@hydroglyphic]

Sara is the mvp of the episode

[@shawnmcqueen3488]

Facts i love it

[@sigsour5421]

Sarah is so cute

[@tionyt]

Yessss, I do hope Elgin survives though 😭 He couldn’t help his part in the story.

[@Ash.Crow.Goddess]

Word! As soon as I saw her face listening to Accosta's bullshitt, I was like, "Well, girl, you FULLY redeemed!"

[@leahm1883]

@@tionyt couldn't he though? Could have just said it after the first hammer drop

[@mawnkd]

Jade was representing ALL of us in that scene 😂😂

[@Mayindacut]

LITERALLY I WAS THINKING THIS IS ALL OF US RIGHT NOW

[@justinm1721]

Ahaha we all felt that😂

[@yusavelli0448]

tbf the children probably don't have that much power

[@anmarsalhieh]

Jade was all of us all season

[@trueblade3636]

Jade was being selfish by not talking with anyone. The moments he talks with Tabitha, Tabitha give an answer. The moment he talked with Jim about the number, Jim gave the answer.

[@CG3theRealtor]

Isn’t it funny Boyd said my blood is your blood now mf when he killed smiley and now he technically smileys grandpa🤣

[@kaustubh_2703]

Yea damn true 😂 now next season I want the smiley to call boyd Grandpa 😂🤣

[@turbowrath5701]

so maybe that's why Fatima got pregnant? Thru Boyd's blood, then Ellis'

[@altwan862]

The monster from season 1 episode 2 that recognize Julie. Just made my brain go into overdrive with Julie being a story walker

[@MichaelCifaldi-dx6mx]

Wow this makes so much sense now

[@catheseries]

Omg. It makes so much sense now

[@Edge2177]

I think Julie is Victor's sister.

[@tashaenadekle]

Wait was does this mean ?

[@veenasudheer8532]

Yes. She is a story walker means she must have travelled to the past to meet these people. That's why they remember her. It also explains why martin knows her. The future version of julie must have met him in the past through story travelling.

[@holubowichb]

So is Smiley now technically Boyd’s grandson??? I’d love a meeting with the 2 of them in season 4 with Smiley calling him Grandpa! And honestly Sara was definitely my favorite character this season.

[@CG3theRealtor]

That’s hilarious from the fact when Boyd killed him he did say my blood is your blood now mf🤣🤣

[@veenasudheer8532]

​@@CG3theRealtor I can't stop laughing 🤣. This dialogue make so much sense now. That look on his face when he saw smiley emerging out of that slime... He was like " I killed this motherfucker only for him to come back as my grandson "... Lol 🤣

[@itwasntme300]

so basically the town is an incest fest 😂😂

[@jonfreeman9682]

Exactly. So now it comes full circle and all the people and monsters are connected in some way.

[@topcheese2889]

Just a surrogacy

[@RickyRickOnDaBeat]

The monsters ARE the original town inhabitants and the ghost kids are the children they sacrificed to live forever. Them becoming monsters was the flaw of the immortality. I can’t wait to see the first town meeting in season 4. I think with the omniscient entity (man in yellow) revealing himself the urgency to escape will go through the roof.

[@60bangz]

The next town meeting will be in season 7

[@Scrappy_ill_fold_ya_Doo]

Yeah. Jasmine, one of the monsters that guy was simping for, said they didn't choose to be that way. I think they were tricked. I do think the evil entity is controlling them.

[@ItsMe-jz5wb]

who can the Man in yellow be? Their entity god or smt? Cuz he seemed to be walking around during daytime

[@TheFall02]

I think you’re wrong

[@TheFall02]

@ he’s the deity of that place. He’s not human he’s not a monster he’s the one who controls the puppet

[@juans3026]

I feel like the playing of the music notes unlocked and began the "endgame" of the cycle. Them "remembering" solidified their relationship (Tabby and Jade) so Jim had to go, The Town is purging the non essential players maybe as in anyone who isnt connected to somebody from a past cycle Jim was a vessel for Tabby to get to Fromville and now that shes remembered his purpose was served.. Feel like the countdown is on for them to either save the kids or die and the cycle begins again.

[@dangerouskoala6611]

I kind of agree with this because Victoria hid that violin and they make a point of showing us that more than once. Maybe things get worse from here.

[@halo2something]

jim was very vital to overall story - he figured out signal thing in first season, he solved the numbers puzzle, which our genius jade couldn't, he was just not into threesome stuff perhaps

[@halo2something]

btw dont forget we have version of jim on town now - victor's father

[@jayeshpandey92]

I dont like it he was my fav character 😢

[@sayhmm]

maybe the boy in white only drip-fed them information so they could prepare, otherwise they would have to do it all at once. (i bet the whole next season is gonna take place over like 48 hours lol. that would be like them)

[@eshanmohotty3704]

Elgin was literally going to the root celler with supplies for fathima. Boyd and others could have followed him without alerting him and could have avoided so many things. Why isn’t anyone talking about this 🙄

[@sayhmm]

yep. honestly, Elgin being swayed by torture isn't that believable to me? idk

[@kornelijabonert5658]

That's what I was saying.

[@kaustubh_2703]

They're just showing how far a person can go and break. It was all set up to break boyd he's worst enemy now being reborn through his daughter in law !? That's crazy and if you think about it I believe just like Tabitha and jade Boyd has some past connections. I used to think Donna has some connections too but not anymore. But somethings are definitely connected with boyd !

[@lilasflavour]

I prefer the Sara thing 😂

[@abelabebe2529]

Actually the Lady would've warned Eljin if they followed him...since Fatima did not start giving birth the moment they caught Elgin going down the stairs..

[@070spacecowboy]

I think this is the best episode of the entire show so far

[@devinnichols1514]

The only reason for that is because they finally gave some answers. So I guess we'll have to wait for the final episode of next season to get another solid episode.

[@luffymonkey4232]

Sadly Every season it's the last epsiode that is only better .

[@nomsringani8513]

So Martin gave Boyd the worms, Boyd gave Ellis the blood transfusion, Ellis "impregrantes"Fatima, Smiley is reborn! The cycle continues!!! Flip

[@swaybul]

I never noticed this until now. You are a genius.

[@monke4117]

wow thats actually a really cool pick up omg

[@dadillonful]

This made me aroused

[@Unsaid_tales]

You mean monster need people to their future for reborn.

[@shalinalewis2957]

Fatima was already pregnant when Elilis received the transfusion.

[@jonathansmith4737]

Sarah really became quite the Anti-hero this season and im here for it.

[@onyxthecookie5885]

Did she tho? She pretty much sacraficed herself to find Fatima and save Boyd from doing the unthinkable. I don't think it's just her going psycho. Yes she did sth horrible but for the good of others sort of. I more so see it that she tried to help, whilst she knew it's probably over for her since they couldn't let it slide this time (just a theory since who knows if townfolks will learn about what actually happened to Elgin, I have no idea how to spell his name lol).

[@ashmitsahay8696]

i think the julie we saw at the end was Julie from the future cause she said "this is when it happens "

[@ashmitsahay8696]

she might have story walked in the past cause she knew when he was going to die and she also said she have to change the story

[@maximtommmy8483]

Exactly, exactly

[@voizcrack]

I thought the same, her hair is dyed pure black instead of her usual brunette, its also split in the middle and also her outfit is not what she wore before

[@Danhashiel]

Of she was from the future she had a haircut and way different clothing

[@2prettytv636]

Yes and this is probably why she didn’t run when Jim told her too

[@Manjomeli]

"This place took everything from boyd. I wont let it take his soul.........i already gave it mine" *continues to pull out a mans eye with a screwdriver* I always liked sara. Even when i had some second thoughts, i always had a feeling she was gonna come in clutch. Sara will probably be the reason everyone leaves, but she'll end up staying as a price.

[@onyxthecookie5885]

I wonder what the voice meant when it told Sarah that they would find Fatima too late. Fatima seemed completely fine after she gave birth so maybe it was too late to stop the smiley shithead from being reborn?

[@KeepingUpWithRene]

Whew thank god for Sarah but know knowing Jade and Tabitha had a baby together is mind blowing and they keep coming back to save them , Julie going back or in the future now because she had short her she may have tried to save Jim a few times. And poor Jim, but the man in yellow now they have a daytime monster! Can't wait for season 4🎉

[@voizcrack]

The tension in every From season be like Start of Season: Crazy shit happens, impossible to wait for the next episode 😱 Middle of Season: Characters just strolling around town and talking leading to nowhere 🥱 End of Season: Get the answers of the seasons's mystery but introduce new mystery for the next season 🤯

[@voizcrack]

I only watched like 2 seasons of Lost can anyone tell me is Lost like this every season as well?

[@depthsofabjection]

@@voizcrack yes

[@escalatingbarbarism5096]

I was legitimately expected the yellow man to say "It's me, I'm behind it all". Still waiting on that giant spider.

[@FieryFlamingFajitas]

maybe the man in yellow IS the giant spider

[@coryspaldingmusic]

That episode was insane! We found out way more than I could have ever expected to.

[@Kakashi-rx5yc]

Actually Season 3 done a pretty good job, explaining not everything and the last scream of Jade representing not only our frustration but also the character's frustration as well. But I also agree with white Boy, See how difficult it was for Tabitha to admit she was/is Maranda, and if he came and tell them everything, who they are, what they should do, they will end up suspecting him and not beleiving that theory. Jim death was neccessary for entity to win. Just how amazing jim is, He just put small effort to understand the dates and he figure it out, or guessed it. He's the one who comes up with Tower. But entity didnt make his move because he was more concerned/scared about his family and just after he breaks that bubble, Enitity himself came to kill Jim, Because Jim is bigger threat to them as he is a f**king genius and Jade loved him lol. Jim is an outsider, He is nowhere connected with the place so maybe he didnt come in the contract, they form during the sacrifice. Jim was right not to play the song T-T !!

[@Tracy.W]

Finally a great episode! To bad we have to wait a couple years for the next season 😫😩

[@the.average.students]

It’s more like a year and 2 months.

[@QLivin]

​@@the.average.studentsThey are dramatic

[@justinm1721]

This wait is gunna suck 😢

[@jonfreeman9682]

But now you have the answers. So let's see fans will comeback.

[@IronsRM3]

@@Tracy.W yep. I heard it’s not due until winter 2026 😢

[@juicekidfrost9648]

Jim casually just let dude rip his throat thinking he can beat the monster

[@bilalhajoui7636]

he didnt know it was a monster as he has never seen one in the daytime before

[@Inkipinkiponkey-c9o]

I think that man in yellow guy was an entity or god of those monster thats. Why he can walk in daytime

[@juicekidfrost9648]

@ well it’s someone he never seen before and plus the dude in yellow looks like a monster don’t look like a human

[@fletchedfps]

That means no one in the town will know about the man in yellow.

[@juicekidfrost9648]

@@fletchedfps yeah true but Julie went back in the past to try to save him

[@Lavendiii]

Your wife shouldn’t have dug that hole, Jim.

[@fletchedfps]

Im glad they finally tied back to that. One thing answered from 2 seasons ago lol

[@Blackstar-yd3yf]

I didn't get it

[@nemishka93]

​@@Blackstar-yd3yf He was the one on the radio lmao..even the guy in the video says it...sweetie how slow can you be...but love you

[@Blackstar-yd3yf]

@@nemishka93 I m disabled sorry 😐

[@sweetsparkle9465]

​@@nemishka93 How slow can you be?

[@CorruptForces]

Idk I have a feeling the boy in white is the son of the man in yellow and that the boy in white was the first to be sacrificed or killed and the man in yellow was the first to become immortal and maybe that's why they're special since they were the first and they're probably son and father.

[@kevinbum843]

Same with Victor and Henry..

[@FieryFlamingFajitas]

I think the boy in white was meant to be sacrificed as well but he got away. When Tabitha and Jade both remember that Ankhooey means "remember", Jade says "We tried to save them, because one of them.." I think he was about to say "one of them escaped and told us they were going to kill the others"

[@shanlin2249]

I thought he was about to say because one of them was our daughter but what you said is also interesting ​@FieryFlamingFajitas

[@Ash.Crow.Goddess]

The boat. They've got to travel out of From on running salt water BETWEEN WORLDS to break magical charms, avoid magical creatures, and get home. That could mean ocean water, or the galaxy, metaphorically. Probably ocean water because space ain't salty. But the ancients thought it might be. And that's really all that matters.

[@ScottUhlMusic]

Wow what an episode! This is what I loved about the show. The last 5 episodes were tough, but that was amazing!

[@атомноесердце-э4о]

The man in yellow, just like the King in Yellow. For those who don't know, it's a mysterious and malevolent supernatural and gothic entity known as the King in Yellow. Nice, so maybe he's the big dog or the main antagonist-or the entity that controls the whole town. Now, I can't wait for Season 4! But i personally hope Season 4 is about when Miranda first came to this town and how the cycle repeated itself again. The fact that this future Julie that tried to warn jim means that it has happened before, so she saw it coming already and tried to warn him.

[@monke4117]

Uh well I'm confused but I think the cycle hasn't ended yet but where ever Julie came from I believe the cycle has ended their which is why Julie has a scar on her face. I think Julie is just trying to save her dad but since as Ethan said the story is set in stone and can't be changed Julie may try to save her dad countless times but fail again and again. Next season we may see Julie in a deep depression!

[@Unsaid_tales]

Maybe they will mostly focus on Miranda and her trauma , how she ended up her and died here. Next season.

[@nelly2911]

This episode was nice and fast-paced, why didn't they do this for the rest of the season?!?!? Good one.

[@LorettaBillie]

It was a crazy episode! We learned far more than I ever would have thought possible.

[@Tlasdqwe]

Julie coming back in time was the knowledge the man in yellow was saying comes at a cost. so julie coming back is the reason jim dies creating a time loop. If you watch the man in yellow when he says that knowledge comes at a cost hes looking at julie then looks over to jim meaning hes saying it to julie about her coming back in time

[@RickyBStanicky]

Julie came from the future to prevent Jim's death.

[@odd02]

It could be, but it could also be implying the knowledge of the towns people that wanted to be immortal.

[@strawhat_milly2976]

I think the knowledge comes at a cost part was more so tied to Tabitha and jade remembering the past lives and what happened to the kids. The man in yellow wants to prevent them from knowing and breaking the cycle

[@HandsomeKing808]

I think Julie just figured out who that guy was right then and there. She didn’t give off the vibe that she knew what the man in yellow was yet, that must have been her first time seeing him. She only knew her dad dies that day by there old RV. If she knew the man in yellow I believe she would know how dangerous he is and made Jim run off away from him.

[@hanlee3345]

Ethan being able to know things like "storywalkers" ,etc might lead on to him being a host at certain times for the Boy in White to hint/guide the townspeople in the right direction

[@lindsayhughes3775]

OMG ELGIN AND THE PIONEER GUY DRINKING BLOOD FROM THE SKULL ARE MISSING THE SAME EYEBALL

[@sheermoo1247]

Who is the pioneer I’m finding it difficult remembering

[@Cocorobet25p35p]

Elgin is the cultist in the past, the soldier, the guy who drink blood in skeleteon, it was reincarnation to Elgin

[@tvguyultra4448]

If i was Jim i would've taken Julie and ran. This strange guy looks dangerous. kinda seems like be a monster. Especially after he mentioned the song and tabitha digging the hole. He was just walking so towards them like a monster, who Jim should know are very strong. so he shoulda just ran...

[@crystalbspeaks7439]

Right! The price of not believing

[@Rad200G2B]

everything up until that moment said monsters only come out at night and he'd been having hallucinations. By the time he realized dude was real, it was too late. can't fault him for not running immediately.

[@yusavelli0448]

man in yellow was so scary even when I first saw him

[@KodedLive]

theory: smiley returned because he is one of the people who was promised immortality in the sacrificing contract, so he had to be rebirthed by the evil entities as it states in their contract. smiley is one of many people who sacrificed their children for immortality but that immortality came with a cost which is being controlled as pawns by the evil entities. smiley was killed by boyd, so the evil entities did what they could to bring him back, the evil entities cant create the monsters out of the blue even though they seem powerful, as energy cant be created like jade said, so it had to come from fatima?

[@jziahkarimou2169]

I have a theory: since we have seen that Julie is a time traveler. Maybe she’ll have to go back in time and try to save the Ankuey kids from being sacrificed and maybe that’s how that’s how everyone goes home. By saving the children from being sacrificed !!! But I don’t think the monsters are gonna make it easy for them though !! 😂

[@jagnikk]

i think Jim is coming back once julie finds out how she can undo his death

[@jayeshpandey92]

Nope

[@jziahkarimou2169]

No that’s not happening , you heard what Ethan said “The story can’t be changed “

[@upfrfr]

​@@jziahkarimou2169 be fr who believes Ethan 😂😂😂😂

[@jziahkarimou2169]

@@upfrfr Well we clearly see that she tried to save her dad and it didn't work so Ethan’s right

[@jonfreeman9682]

Yeah Julie had y time travel power so can go back and change anything. She hasn't mastered this time travel skill yet so it takes time.

[@luffymonkey4232]

I think even Jim was very important this episode the way he cooperated and brought the idea of the notes

[@Malinowy2024]

It looks like this whole place is not even a purgatory, but the vestibule of hell.

[@MorganVsTheInternet]

I regret asking the FROM people for answers!

[@1Demolish]

I cant process how well this series is made, all the pieces slowly becoming one clear picture.

[@DKajero]

Jim shlda put on the skates as soon as Julie begged him to

[@Jcroffe]

I haven’t watched it yet. It’s 3:26 am. Was binge watching Penguin. Can’t wait to see the season finale of FROM

[@Maikonix]

Smiley breaking out and looking slightly indirect from camera like hes about to deliver the line "Mmmm, beefy!"

[@danielfazio275]

We all knew the king in yellow was coming eventually 🤣. These guys love HP Lovecraft

[@Ash.Crow.Goddess]

And Steven King.

[@sian8648]

Wasn't the king in yellow mentioned in true detective s1 as well?

[@danielfazio275]

@@sian8648 yeah it was, Carcosa and the King in Yellow are characters in the books written by HP Lovecraft. So they’re commonly used in a lot of today’s modern work

[@jonfreeman9682]

No sci-fi horror is complete without the legendary Lovecraft.

[@poopbutt6241]

@@jonfreeman9682chambers*

[@DolphinsAreBetterThanHumans]

Farewell to my fellow FROM viewers. Take care guys. I hope to see you all in after a year again. I was furious before finale but i admit that i am okayish satisfied with the s3 ending.

[@md.md16]

Farewell fella and we shall meet here again for season 4 🤝 😂

[@anjithavelayudhan1418]

See you again on 2026

[@hedwigndokosho2812]

Farewell, until next year 👋🏽👋🏽👋🏽

[@justinm1721]

Cya next year for mad discussions brother man 🫡

[@nomsringani8513]

Guys Please look at Tabithas reflection when she wakes up in Camden and looks outside!!! That's Miranda in the reflection! It was there all along

[@Stephaniefarrah]

YES. IVE BEEN SCREAMING IT!!

[@bcoates87]

I just rewatched that scene and maybe it's just me but I didn't see Miranda’s reflection only Tabitha’s.

[@dadillonful]

Ehhh looks like her actual reflection

[@odd02]

I mean it could be but it's kinda a stretch. I couldn't really see Miranda much in it.

[@DKajero]

Just realised the characters are not gonna find out about the man in yellow until Julie story walks which by then it’ll probably be too late

[@dagod8418]

They will if she tells them. She need to talk to Boyd first though. And tell him about Martin.

[@DKajero]

@ but the point is that the Julie Jim just saw was a storywalker from the future, what I’m saying is I don’t think the ppl in the present will know about the man in yellow until she takes that exact walk we jus saw her take, she’ll obviously end up telling them but I think he’ll do more dmg before Julie goes to try save Jim

[@mritachi3878]

Thankyou! I said the same thing. The town folk will have no idea what happened to Jim.

[@hc8428]

Im glad they confirmed my theories. Now I can finally rest. The only problem with Acosta being Abby is that Acosta is way too old. Boyd has only been there for a couple of years max. By the way, we found out Acosta's name is Dani. People have been saying her first name is important. Do with that information what you will.

[@RennaStarling]

I don't know what to do with that info 😂 I'm literally sitting here in the dark trying to figure out the importance of the name Dani or Danielle?

[@RickyBStanicky]

​@@RennaStarlingDani Daniels?

[@halo2something]

she is not too old, what are you talking about also the town can have same version of characters being alive - jim and victor's father - are same someone from the past

[@nounous01]

Very pleasantly surprised how well the did the birth of Smiley visually. Wasn't easy to do and it worked so well

[@jpedo1486]

Idk kinda don’t like how banana man just randomly went to the rv n killed Jim, kinda reminded me of a walking dead death where it’s like “someone has to die” I like his presence and i just kinda rather the setup of been different

[@kokloj76]

or jim knows too much and god came to fucking stop him yall really think you know more than the damn director and the writers

[@MolokoMinus]

@@kokloj76Lol, the man can have an opinion on the pacing and suddenness of certain events and scenes of a show. While I definitely liked the episode, I totally get what the OP is talking about. Also, why are you putting directors and writers of a tv show on so much of a pedestal? As if we can never question any decision they make because, as viewers, they’re our betters and know better. If that’s the case: You shouldn’t question ME because I wrote a feature length script once.

[@anjalirautela112]

My brother and I used to eagerly wait every Sunday for new episodes of this series. I absolutely love it now! When my brother first made me watch the first episode of the first season, I thought, "What is this nonsense? This doesn’t happen in real life!" It felt so ridiculous at first. But as I continued watching episodes 1, 2, and 3, I found myself getting more and more interested. Before I knew it, I was completely hooked. Now, looking back, it all makes so much sense. The writing is absolutely brilliant-what seemed silly at first has turned into something amazing and incredibly well-crafted.

[@kingru839]

Hopefully in season 4 we don’t get new townies and have to do the whole new member introduction again. Spend episodes saving/explaining the ton to the new people

[@blengblong01712]

Julie's ability would be a great help and main focus of season 4. Even though future Julie didn't saved her dad, they still got the information about the Man in yello

[@fletchedfps]

@@blengblong01712 im not sure if they would end up with info tho. Jim was the only person who witnessed the man in yellow besides presumably future julie. And im not sure different Julie can or will stick around to explain things to the town (she already refuses to tell anyone but ethan anything useful)

[@blengblong01712]

@@fletchedfps well we still have more than a year to figure that out

[@fletchedfps]

@@blengblong01712 I meant the people in the show won't know about him

[@comebackqing8452]

I hope not too many and especially not ones that are important to the plot. Everytime I see Acosta on screen it feels like a fan just jumped onto the stage, she has no reason to be there, i have no connection to her and her actress sucks

[@eluv7284]

U are right about Mabuse, keep digging into that. Watch the films and you'll have more answers. 😉🤫

[@jayeshpandey92]

How do you know

[@ashley.taylor174]

Just realized! What if the ghosts of Abby, Father Guthrie, and maybe even the Kinono lady are story walkers like Julie? Maybe they’re not ghosts?

[@sayhmm]

boy in white seems like a story walker

[@InIn-g6e]

In the cave painting, there were 2 people on top of the symbol, maybe jade and tabitha

[@OzTheGuy8224]

Randal is obviously not the man in yellow. I think we can all see that the "scar" on the painting of the man in yellow was just an unintentional mistake on the painting as the actual guy had no such scar. The man in yellow is probably kimono lady's husband. I can't believe the monsters are basically just vampire now.

[@sumeetsingh3663]

So Boyd saying "My blood is your blood" have different meaning now. Boyd's got a grand-kid. And Julie in hopes of preventing his Jim's death ended up causing it, which we will see in later season.

[@ЮлиянНайденов-ю2я]

Daym. This is the best series ever. What a blast of an episode! Dr. Mabuse theory is a big one! Congrats on looking so indepth!

[@silviutarpazac]

1. Tabitha and Jade are reincarnations of Victor's mom and Christopher 2. Monsters are former town inhabitants who sacrificed their children 3. Creepy kids are the children who were sacrificed 4. The voice Jim heard on the radio at the end of S1 was the guy in yellow 5. Julie can time travel to revisit certain parts of the story 6. Elgin was manipulated by the kimono chick and Fatima was never really pregnant, she just helped Smiley get reincarnated There's a few more minor revelations and theories too, but those above are HUGE for the story! WHO...is..the..man..in...yellow?!?

[@KA-4000A]

Julie will be main character in next season, She will now learn how to time travel and see whole story from start.

[@halo2something]

she neesd to learn how to explain people how to move fast from danger, to change the story - she could just say to jim - it's very dangerous here, this man is dangerous, we need to run and hide, i'll explain you everything on the go

[@sayhmm]

​@@halo2somethingmaybe that was the writers that Jim still hadn't learned to listen to his kids, and that's why he needed to die 😆

[@halo2something]

@@sayhmm yeah that jim was a bit of a slow learner, wasn't he? anyways, we still have other jim in town - victor's dad, but he is a bit too old and maybe less intuitive, smart

[@kornelijabonert5658]

Honestly, I don't know why they had to hurt Elgin. If they had gone about it the smart way and said nothing to him, they could have followed him to the root cellar and found Fatima. No bloodshed.

[@halo2something]

there is always a third factor in such plans - the town, something could happen on the way, freaking crows or a dog, or what else boyd was seeing, and elgin is gone

[@fazalurehaman1269]

Idk why ppl are hating on Jim he was one of the best characters out there what a character arc

[@DrCristina1997]

Episode 10 done got me all messed up. I’m gonna have to start back at Season 1 episode 1 wtf who the yellow man and did jade and Tabitha sacrifice their kid too?

[@scolyo]

Man Sara DID NOT NEED to do Elgin like that lmfaooooo esp bc they got there and the lady literally left her alone. She more than likely woulda lived regardless, elgin did not need to lose his god damn eye for that ish

[@tashaenadekle]

Better safe than sorry. We do not know that Fatima would have been spared. Elgin could’ve just said where she was his life wasn’t in immediate danger when it came to the walking ghost lady.

[@tmarbut]

The last person stuck in that room died in there. Also, they saw the rebirth of Smiley, which is a pretty useful piece of intel.

[@Xira32]

I think Elgin is the civil soldier that Jade used to saw

[@Biggiecheeseness]

Yes he did. Elgin sucks

[@Ch50304]

Yes poor ELgin, I felt so bad for him.

[@Star24456]

On the painting the man in yellow doesnt have a scar,its just a white line on that red background

[@sayhmm]

I'm annoyed at Tabitha for shutting down. that's how Christopher got everyone killed. how is she not scared of dead children, but she's scared of reincarnation? put on a brave face and keep going. i feel like this started a count down

[@mattgilbert7347]

It ain't time travel. It's story travel. I've been calling it a "hyperlink" in the story. Julie and, I would guess, MIY, Randall (same person??) and Marielle all have this ability. Jade is the Voice of the People!

[@comebackqing8452]

It's called a "closed" time loop as opposed to an "open" time loop. In an "open" time loop you can go back in time and change your present. In a "closed" time loop you can go back to the past but it will create the future you are already living in.

[@mattgilbert7347]

@@comebackqing8452 I believe I called it a closed-loop, like in that show "dark", or the original "Terminator" film. I think those are the rules they are using here.

[@mattgilbert7347]

@@comebackqing8452 oh sorry my bad, different comment. In a different comment on a different video I called it a closed-loop. I agree with you.

[@hungrynebs]

I think Tabby and Jade were apart of the group who chose to sacrifice their children for eternal life, but they tried to back out when it was too late, so instead they told them the story that they poured into the roots. But because their daughter was still sacrificed, they get eternal life, they are reincarnated again and again

[@Baaper-j4h]

Kimono lady is the red entity. The kimono is red. She made them immortal.

[@cheese-p2v]

I thought there was no way they'd answer enough questions in one episode but I was so, so wrong. S4 will definitely be worth the wait! We found out so many things. 1. Tabitha and Jim are reincarnations of Victor's mom and Christopher 2. Monsters are former town inhabitants who sacrificed their children 3. Creepy kids are the children who were sacrificed 4. The voice Jim heard on the radio at the end of S1 was the guy in yellow 5. Julie can time travel to revisit certain parts of the story 6. Elgin was manipulated by the kimono chick and Fatima was never really pregnant, she just helped Smiley get reincarnated There's a few more minor revelations and theories too, but those above are HUGE for the story!

[@sayhmm]

i think the man in yellow has been all of the phone and radio voices

[@kornelijabonert5658]

Jade was Christopher not Jim.

[@lycaon1243]

Sara is Goated this Season she’s the Town’s Ripper

[@vingram100]

So this town is like the Storm of the Century town after they gave in to the demon's demand for a child. It cursed the town.

[@Smichiwerbenjaggermanjensen]

I'm calling it out. Martin is Randall.

[@IronsRM3]

The man in yellow has to be the final boss. Surely the one controlling everything that’s going on. Wow what an ending.

[@theinvertedworld.]

the man in yellow told jim that "knowledge always comes with a cost" . that tingled my cranium a bit. that led me to H.P lovecraft's redition of the king in yellow. he literally holds the secrets of the universe there and has the ability of manipulation and reincarnation with so much more. he is also connected to "the king in yellow" play. it's like the town is going through a play of sorts. same characters played by different people.

[@LuisMorenoBlanco]

I think the boy in white is a tree. ..

[@ashley.taylor174]

Abby was probably right all along. They just need to go to sleep (die). When they die they are reincarnated. I’m not sure if they will return to the town but their souls never die.

[@biddi7972]

As for the kids not telling them. The boy in white said it earlier. He said to victor that they need to figure it out on their own, it is clear that every time they straight up tell them, they end up failing.

[@Crow0fEarth]

The man in yellow being the main antagonist saved this series thank goodness. I’ve stuck with it but I see so much discourse about people thinking it drags, I’m pretty comfortable with their pace myself but you know how hate trains are nowadays on the internet people will get a show cancelled just bc word of mouth. But everyone I’ve seen seems really happy we finally have a big bad reveal.

[@llgla]

"The past is already written. The ink is dry." - Three-Eye Raven

[@kaustubh_2703]

I understood that reference.

[@namumakwembo]

i was so hooked to watching this show , and i missed most the points explained here, it makes sense now or at least i think it does . can't wait for season 4 !

[@ahmedriahi4662]

i think in season 4 the main mission will be saving the kids but the man in yellow will be a pain in the ass for everyone and i think the ending of the story will be sad cause julie said "i need to change the story " and we will get some answers about the spiders thing from season 1 because boyd's trip to the woods got a huge load of unanswered questions

[@DawggBone]

"Samsara" and the wheel of Karma, they all will keep coming back

[@benjamintriplett3]

Like " The Wheel of Ka" from Stephen King.

[@ImJustKyle_]

The thing i hate about the reincarnation shit is, are they gonna be able to explain everyone? Or is it just Tabitha and Jade that was reincarnated? And everyone else is just there as a punishment, why was Boyd and everyone else there before Tabitha and Jade? Waiting 2 years for this shit is so disappointing and also advertising this episode as 74 minutes when the last 15 are a preview for another show is so fucking grimey towards the From audience, i didn't like that at all

[@afnanmakhdoom6119]

It was 74 mins and this was a great episode

[@felix3033]

I agree it was just getting good then the show ended lol

[@soloe8447]

@@afnanmakhdoom6119the episode was mid nothing extravagant happened

[@BileDuctBalderdash]

​@@afnanmakhdoom6119you are a re re if you think you watched 74 minutes of From

[@ImJustKyle_]

@@afnanmakhdoom6119 it ran 74 mins but the last 15 of that was a preview for another show

[@M24071]

I knew the explanation would be Dark level twisted and sure enough here we are and with that Julie reveal her pulling the same move as Thomas did in Dark is a big possibility for the show's ending

[@Askar2810]

Damn, It was a nice episode. I complained about previous ones but for a reason. I am still convinced that the construction of this season was done incorrectly and at a slow pace. It's a pity that the creators could not do at least half of the season as interesting as this episode (Yes I know that it was the final). I got the impression from this episode that every dialogue is not a filler, it's there for a reason. I don't understand one thing: How the hell Jade himself didn't think it was music-related. You can see that he knows music notes, plays the violin, but he did not find connection to these numbers. It was a strange plot for me. Perhaps the creators of the series wanted to emphasize the usefulness of Jim, who had a problem with it this season before he finished his ride 😅 After the previous episodes, I felt so much frustration that I was thinking about abandoning this series. I hope last season will be better because this season has been the worst for me so far (but with interesting ending).

[@halo2something]

i think, overall it was a strong season with long term setting of clues, it never going to be like 1st season - when everything was new, monsters, characters, environment, all exciting

[@emilgetsov4176]

The whole story we got until now could’ve been made in two seasons cutting out so much unnecessary chitchat

[@AmberAntics]

So who’s making these monsters immortal? Man in yellow or kimono lady? Or could it be entirely something else

[@IMANWARRIOR103]

I know it sounds crazy but i think boyd is the guy in yellow bc boyd hade a same shirt as that yellow man

[@yusavelli0448]

'tip of spear' means most dangerous

[@gaycat599]

So thats how theyre immortal. They are born even after they die. The numberof monsters remain same.

[@interestings7866]

Ok good episode! Things are really getting good, slow start but very cool stuff for next season

[@jakubpersjanow1938]

Imagine getting into hellish town and you are just a supporting character XD and you must rely on stupid stupid people who do not communicate, do not think that much and are overall pretty bad in solving mysteries, just because they were "chosen" and "reincarnated". Fromville truly is hell.

[@futurecpa5312]

Mark this. Boyd will be caught by those monsters but they can't KILL him. Boyd was Martin's descendant. There will be no time travel BS. The answers will be found in the beginning. Julie, Marielle and Randall are the keys to unlocking the whole fromvilles timeline. Tabitha and Jade will focus on finding answers through the help of Ankhooey kids. The most critical part and I think the person that should be protected are Victor and Ethan because they were direct descendants of the boy in White. S4 will be an all out showdown now that the man in yellow was introduced.

[@freelanxe]

Definitely gonna be 3 more seasons 😂 😭😭😭……… I just want answers

[@digitalsage5636]

Smiley is back... Let's go!!!😁

[@georgegonzalez2253]

Can’t wait for season 4 and seeing the steamy Jade and Tabitha scenes

[@nareanmano]

My heart is still racing from the endin I think Man in yellow is the creatures the man chained up to the wall mentioned to boyd In s1, a creature remembers Julie's name. Is tat because he met her in the past when she storywalked Where's dr. Mabuse from

[@divineglitch9550]

the king in yellow, Carcosa an urban legend about twisted roots that steal childrens souls.

[@JustGreatBanter]

Father Khantri watching Boyd about to torture Elgin was a great touch I thought, made you wonder if he was gonna do it, also since it was Sarah that did the worse does it mean the place didn’t break Boyd?