My brain exploded making this video 🤯 Check out my other FROM videos here: kzbin.info/aero/PLY9KJ1cFVs7gQJ_cXCUJfSWrpd4uksXuZ
@_pedrolagoАй бұрын
Its very interesting having a carachter named Fátima. Look for The Secret of Fátima
@neuroblast1681Ай бұрын
we appreciate you sacrificing your brain
@rubysultraАй бұрын
Awww ...sending mental hug.
@mr.mega_set3017Ай бұрын
My main question is what will be going on with time travel and is it actually possible to change past or nothing can be changed. I hope they save Jim, at the end of the day he is one of the main heroes along with Tabata, Boyd and Jake
@papifaded5335Ай бұрын
🤣🤣🤣
@jisoospinkwig3294Ай бұрын
The creature’s got the big bad man in yellow, kimono lady, cicadas etc while the townsfolk got a boy in white and a bunch of kids who spam angkhooey lmao😭
@BueditАй бұрын
Fr lol and the children look so goofy ahahh.
@77777gracieАй бұрын
Honestly I'm not certain the cicadas are bad. I think they might be similar to Martin's worms, which were certainly terrifying but bc of that they were able to (temporarily) kill Smiley. And it's after the cicadas show up that Julie gets her storywalking power, which I think Randall and Marielle could have too.
@vitaliyred622Ай бұрын
Teams are not balanced at all!
@vitaliyred622Ай бұрын
@@77777graciemaybe that’s why they didn’t kill that dude and only gave him a scar. They saw Boyd kill Smiley and worms and cicadas may be the same thing!
@devind8839Ай бұрын
this comment has me in tears
@DC2992Ай бұрын
And they are gonna give us 25 new questions next season lol
@captain425Ай бұрын
And we’re gonna give you 25 more likes than you alr had lol
@benwarwick4290Ай бұрын
Per answer reveal😂😂
@StyleS_Ай бұрын
Definitely like 4 😂
@greenytaddictАй бұрын
😂😂😂
@roosternm6830Ай бұрын
It never fails.......
@vedatma_kАй бұрын
From script in a nutshell- “Stay calm” , “I’m fine” , “It’s not your fault”
@AbhishekSingh-yh7ceАй бұрын
I don't know I don't remember Etc etc
@dreamingscarlettm5415Ай бұрын
Gotta go
@niacao726129 күн бұрын
whoa whoa whoa whoa, what's going on, breathe
@Wormhide28 күн бұрын
"whats going on here" "FUCK" "its going to be alright"
@abdullahimran697726 күн бұрын
So true
@adnan0968Ай бұрын
All the shenanigans of this season were to get Smiley back (not complaining, great guy)
@brendongriffin4164Ай бұрын
Guys just got a great attitude.
@MrHartshorn79Ай бұрын
Super positive about the whole situation, a real inspiration to the rest of us.
@bigdurksАй бұрын
He pisses me tf off for no reason. (Not the actor, the character)
@Staysick17Ай бұрын
@@bigdurksprobably because his smile 😂
@AaronBowleyАй бұрын
we love smiley
@FatPanda24Ай бұрын
The communication in Fromville boggles my brain, why arent they open an honest? Everyone hallucinates, looks crazy for a few seconds and then when someone asks they say "Its nothing or Im Fine" Like I get that in the real world that is normal behavious but in Fromville where crazy stuff happens all the time surely you let people know
@FlimsyPicklesАй бұрын
Humans are dumb. That’s it. It’s completely believable to me considering how selfish we are and how dumb most of us are.
@BarbieAllNightDanceАй бұрын
The writers don’t know either
Ай бұрын
That is My biggest nitpicking it's so frustrating every time someone asked them something and they just be like nothing🤨🙄
@pioneerjatt93Ай бұрын
biggest point
@chapawattiАй бұрын
Its gonna be okay
@Kb-xq2ryАй бұрын
I only just discovered this series a few days ago and iv binged it all I’m completely obsessed and I can’t believe I didn’t know it existed I’m usually up to date with good shows but the only reason I discovered it was one clip I saw on Facebook. This show needs more recognition
@steph7614Ай бұрын
I tell people about it all the time! Gotta grow it!
@SeddysaidАй бұрын
It's because of the cliffhangers. It's annoying almost seems like a kid wrote this script since they just keep adding new things with no answers
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
@@Seddysaid i felt the same sometimes, theyre not giving any answers and keep adding problems to the point where we get annoyed
@Oops-jg4be25 күн бұрын
I agree..
@RadFad5388 күн бұрын
@@Seddysaid i love cliffhangers 😍
@davidjacobsen308Ай бұрын
Smiley was the most terrifying of the monsters so he had to come back lol.
@bergesaltiyah5986Ай бұрын
😂😂😂
@jonashorn835429 күн бұрын
I‘m honestly kind of annoyed by the fact that they keep using the smiley guy for all the big monster scenes, to me it makes the other monsters less scary and it makes the monsters feel unnatural in general (how comes whenever something important happens, Smiley guy and the same 3-4 other monsters always happen to be nearby, while tons of other monsters only show up in one single scene?) Anyways I was so glad he died and now I‘m annoyed that he’s back.
@sydmatlock23 күн бұрын
Granny is also scary af. Her transformation from sweet old lady to fang toothed monster in the pilot episode still gives me chills.
@davidjacobsen30821 күн бұрын
@@sydmatlock Yea, and they sacrificed their children for immortality, its a dark outcome.
@ricko23013 күн бұрын
@@davidjacobsen308 so they sacrificed their children but ended up better than the people who didn't. That's silly to me.
@km3455Ай бұрын
Smiley is back, Kimono Lady, music box monster & now Man in Yellow. All Boy in White does is speak in riddles. The ppl in Fromsville can’t seem to catch a break. Who else felt like Jim trying to shake some anwers out of Tabitha 😅? Tabitha” NONONONONONO…I just can’t” Jim “ What the actual effing eff are you saying?!”
@drprathamprakash1408Ай бұрын
Atleast she did give us some answers man😅😅@@fixyourmind
@user-nk8qf8nz8kАй бұрын
Tbh the boy in white sucks ass bro does below the bare minimum to help😭 victors been there 40 yrs and the boy is supposedly his "friend" to make it even worse in all that time he didn't even lead him to the talismans it took boyds exploration to retrieve them which was probably yr 38 or 39 for victor
@french6013Ай бұрын
@@user-nk8qf8nz8kand justifies not helping with “I tried *once* with Christopher“
@user-nk8qf8nz8kАй бұрын
@@french6013 ong like bro FYM" I TRIED ONCE"😭 if I was victor I'd swing the axe at him next💀
@Relayer526-mi4wtАй бұрын
@@user-nk8qf8nz8kHe's distracted by his alarmingly sudden onset of puberty. 😆
@ashley.taylor174Ай бұрын
The monster guy that knew Julie most likely met her during one of her time traveling adventures. It’s all connected in a circle!
@arcticreviewsАй бұрын
What monster guy?
@nkee_nzeeАй бұрын
@@arcticreviews the one from season 1 episode 2. he asked Julie if she remembered him...
@user-wy1et9dk9wАй бұрын
@@arcticreviewsfrom one of the season 1 early episodes she is on the porch with monsters coming towards her
@bluewater4Ай бұрын
Could be. Or he picked a physical body from her mind. Younger or chemically affected easier to take advantage of. During Colony House raid.
@bluewater4Ай бұрын
Another Jasmine type of monster? Kevin sure got suckered. Jasmine says not help how look...yes, indeed...Kevin's concept of beauty. That is why he is one big Dum Dum sucker. Insider info!
@shiraz2475Ай бұрын
The talismans are the stone tables the kids were sacrificed on. Each rock symbolises each child that died. Perhaps they embodied protection within them like the bottle trees.
@matheuscastelhano3442Ай бұрын
but theres more stones than childs
@LampDoesVideogameАй бұрын
There are only 6 children. There are more than 6 talismans. No.
@keonjАй бұрын
@@matheuscastelhano3442 this is a reach, but maybe they were carved from it? As for the symbols on them, I have no idea
@nithinjoseph9902Ай бұрын
That's a good idea. May be ❤❤
@chaiaftersex1Ай бұрын
@@LampDoesVideogame bro they can carve at least 10 talismans from a single table.
@keonjАй бұрын
My only two complaints about this show is when one question gets answered, we get another 100 other questions to look out for. Also, the whole: "OMG, are you ok? What did you see?" "... It was nothing"
@rj5911Ай бұрын
"If you just told others in the town about your problems, you'd find a resolution quicker."
@WaWa-Zd8Ай бұрын
So true😂
@SimplyPandaАй бұрын
So real lmao 😂
@artisticyeti22Ай бұрын
If they communicated better, they would have solved 50% of the problems
@marinerius4498Ай бұрын
classic "lost" tactics everyone knows somethink but dont tell each other
@kaizen_zs20 күн бұрын
Oh my god , this cant be No no no no no no no no no no (2 drops of tears in left eye) - Tabitha ,at end of every episode
@qweqwadadasdadsf1303Ай бұрын
I think the crops in the forest was a way to break boyd. Boyd tried to save animals night before and due to that kennys mom died. And it was all for nothing for the food Jim and Kenny found
@reminiscinn29 күн бұрын
Yeah thought the same
@YTHeroes2 күн бұрын
Holy shit I never noticed that, it makes Tian Chens fate even sadder, god I miss her.
@tionytАй бұрын
Victor saying he found Eloise in “pieces” is a dead give away (IMO) that she is not dead. He has had a choppy memory and known to be confused at times. At no point in the shows history have a monster ripped anyone to pieces. Not even a small child. The first kill of the series we saw was a little girl, and she was still every recognizable, killed in their signature way of leaving the face and feet alone and destroying the body.
@justkim9827Ай бұрын
And he said that they played hide and seek because Eloise was so good at hiding and he could never find her.
@Hi_TameraАй бұрын
Interesting!!! 👀☕️
@TrudilaАй бұрын
Young Eloise kinda looks like the lady that Jade stole the bike from
@ladyheroine5852Ай бұрын
I think Eloise got away in the far away tree
@Sanskar.TiwariАй бұрын
It's very possible that Eloise can time travel like Julie given they both are Tabitha's daughters
@shedabelle8485Ай бұрын
I think the man crushed by the bolder has the same explanation as Dales trip. He was not ment to go through the tree so he ended up in a bolder.
@NousoftheSupreme17 күн бұрын
yeah but how tf did the boulder end up in the cellar
@veronicamaine3813Ай бұрын
Lighthouses don’t guide ships to land - they warn ships of deadly obstacles.
@Reney30Ай бұрын
Damn fr?
@tinggoybeltran268321 күн бұрын
The lighthouse in the middle of forest, i've seen some comment before that this thing is the main source of all this shit happen (based on Boyd entering Chamber using the torch), that's why the white boy doesn't want Tabitha to stay longer there (afraid of putting the light off)
@adityadayal366217 күн бұрын
Then it makes more sense !! If boats can be used to leave that place , which the characters in the series did not do. Then the lighthouse might actually be warning the ship to not to come here. Maybe through water they can enter and exit this place whenever they want. So the lighthouse is actually acting as a barrier for others not to discover what is there !?? that's what I thought 😅😅
@conwayGAMESАй бұрын
this show was meticulously planned out before season 1. they promised that it wouldn’t be frustrating like lost was. just trust the process. now the director said “we reached the end of the beginning”
@ElSigmundoАй бұрын
Maybe they have some idea for the overarching plot, but the way they tell this story is seriously drawn out to a painful degree. S3 was full of nonsense that went nowhere, and then out of nowhere they crammed a bunch of new stuff into the last 10 minutes of the finale
@oshkoshbegoneАй бұрын
@@ElSigmundo Its very annoying and cliff hangers are just not that important.
@SeddysaidАй бұрын
So basically 10 seasons.. and we probably won't know much until season 7..
@aidancoutts2341Ай бұрын
The way this is written suggests anything but. They use random hallucinations to progress the plot because they clearly dont know how to establish a better mechanism for progressing the story or revealing new information. This would be very easy to do if they had an actual plan. It reeks of "idk, have a ghost tell them" which is a strategy for a writer who doesnt know how their story works.
@abdullahimran697726 күн бұрын
It seems like it's gonna introduce time travel and "dark" its way into making sense.
@HeathenHammer80Ай бұрын
1:37 “The children poured their hopes into the roots and it made the far-away trees”. I think the children control where you wind up.
@joshpl5451Ай бұрын
So even the children hated Dale.
@SexdrgspsychedeliaАй бұрын
@@joshpl5451 eff dale I hated him so much 😂
@WaWa-Zd8Ай бұрын
: ohhhhh..ok so for all this time we didn't understand I totally get it now. Such a great explanation.Why didn't I think of that "Children poured their hopes into the roots" I am not gonna miss these things again...
@yony5769Ай бұрын
May be an unpopular opinion, but I like the idea of getting answers right away. It makes me feel like I'm in the town along for the ride. But unlike Lost, things are starting to connect, which is also a good thing. So looking forward to season 4
@kezo4840Ай бұрын
nothing is connecting homie. How did the monster baby decide to jump inside tabitha’s body. How is Jade and the lady have souls ties but they have no connection in this story. From is a terrible series. but the core is a great idea.
@vedantbansod990021 күн бұрын
@@kezo4840 not every little thing needs to be answered, hope they don't miss out on major questions
@jerseydevils968621 күн бұрын
@@kezo4840 First ones legit. You’re second question is literally answered in the series
@martinsoukup56215 күн бұрын
@@kezo4840why do you think it's terrible?
@kezo484015 күн бұрын
@ the story is all over the place and the plot is not progressing. The authors aren’t really trying to be creative in my opinion. I believe the series is just about retention
@WhyzJАй бұрын
I think the “dream” Tabitha had of the little girl around the rocks, was the child her and jade had in previous lives
@trappedcat3615Ай бұрын
Who is the dog is what I want to know 😅
Ай бұрын
Wait how cuz Christopher and tabitha are white that little kid looks more like tabithas race right now
@amandiniii753Ай бұрын
This makes a lot of sense actually I’m picturing the scene where the little girl went behind the rock and it COULD be revealed later that her screaming was because her mother (original soul in tabitha that keeps reincarnating) and her were playing hide and seek or something and then tabitha remembers the origin? Idk crazy but plausible 🤷🏻♀️
@marythebat2757Ай бұрын
no its her
@krmkaljukmech2558Ай бұрын
i thought Tabitha and Jade was Viktors mom and dad
@blancabatistaАй бұрын
But why hasn’t Acosta changed her uniform?
@tillmonjrvernon240Ай бұрын
😂😂
@saurabhvimal1008Ай бұрын
She loves cos play
@lilsabinАй бұрын
😂😂😂😂
@KermitOfWarАй бұрын
The townsfolk haven't been able to find her clothes that fit her personality. 🤷♂️
@MzRawndiАй бұрын
I bet she don’t want to, she hasn’t settled with the idea that she will be there for a long time yet
@dottieblondelleАй бұрын
I remember Tilly said she was on the bus on her way way to" bet on the ponies." Maybe this is a game to the evil entities? Tilly is still suspicious me. Great video
@johnbrentford5513Ай бұрын
I hope Smiley calls Boyd Grandfather.
@RemoteAdminJayJay2Ай бұрын
They should proactively dialog with the monsters. The best place is the bus they have an excellent view. Also I want Boyd to finally trap & cross examine one of them.
@vladimirredjit1288Ай бұрын
his grandson Smiley?
@artisticyeti22Ай бұрын
Exactly , they could ask them questions in a funny way so that they respond and answer some queries or theories that the towns people have.
@kimjong-z3nАй бұрын
I thought of that too, but again, we were told at the start of the show that those monsters are too good at manipulation so who knows how they might change the conversation.
@sbaiahmed3173Ай бұрын
From what I am seeing season 4 will not be the last season. May God keep me alive until the end of the series
@Staysick17Ай бұрын
Good luck staying alive through the walking dead series I’m not even 40 yet an I know I’ll die waiting on that shit to end
@moonc4lfАй бұрын
@@Staysick17 The show ended 2 years ago, 11 seasons, 177 episodes later though :)
@Staysick17Ай бұрын
@@moonc4lf yea and they keep u waiting to see if there’s ever a Rick and Daryl reunion
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
@@Staysick17 wasn't rick dead in season 6 or something? I stopped it after that
@Mukduck61925 күн бұрын
@@shashankmlrjnah he’s in the spin off which is good apparently
@kylemcleod283928 күн бұрын
The problem with shows like this is they often get cancelled before any real answers can get solved
@estherlepage18782 күн бұрын
this one won’t honestly, it’s popular enough even more now than when they renewed for season 2 so i think we’re good. I’m annoyed though because it’s taking too long to answer questions and i feel like it’s gonna get going for more seasons when i believe it should be done in the next one. The next season is in 2026…
@paulomarcelooz9994Ай бұрын
They're in a story. A horror book or movie that is reedited/readapted/modernized time after time, just like they do in the industry. The man in Yellow is The Author and it isn't happy that they keep changing the story everytime it (book/movie) is remade.
@tutorialslaveАй бұрын
You seriously think they're going for a twist within a twist? If they did, they might as well reveal that Fromville is ALSO a Shadow Realm according to Carl Gustav Jung, a simulation, a video game, an alien experiment, a testing ground for emerging myths, and a twisted take on Valhalla and/or the Garden Eden. It'd never end and we as viewers would get dragged further and further down the rabbit hole.
@inky_partyАй бұрын
One more question is where is that german shepherd, and why didn’t we see the dog in season 3 😅
@AntiWhiteOutАй бұрын
My guess is it was one of the fairies that can shape shift and it could of been the boy. The man in yellow is the king fairy and the boy may be a rival fairy.
@krmkaljukmech2558Ай бұрын
@@AntiWhiteOut since Boyd dont see white child it could be that he sees dog instead right
@shadowwalker4633Ай бұрын
He was emergency food
@joshpl5451Ай бұрын
@@shadowwalker4633 🤣
@PradeeshParameswaran-oe5hqАй бұрын
This video and the show took my brain into a rollercoaster and back! Its numb now!
@cadenoelnetworkАй бұрын
With love, as a Lost fan … I fear we’re going to have 100 new questions next season 😭😂
@greenytaddictАй бұрын
I hope not...Lost was a wild ride 😂
@cadenoelnetworkАй бұрын
@@greenytaddict it was, but I’m embarrassed to say my Mom and I were there from beginning to end 🤣
@v.beggar8544Ай бұрын
@@cadenoelnetwork No shame, Lost was and is good. Rewatch it... It's good
@cadenoelnetworkАй бұрын
@@v.beggar8544 it’s good, especially for the time. It’s just if you watched as it aired, you really had to be dedicated. My Mom and I were there each week hanging on lol. Excellent show but it truly was a slow burn and you had to be into the idea of brainstorming and hearing other opinions. We really had no idea what was going on and were all guessing until it all tied together in the end
@LaketwigАй бұрын
@@v.beggar8544 if you dont like substance or story telling its really good
@thinkersthink-Ай бұрын
1:20 1.Do yall remember in season 1 we all thought from land had some kind of heeling powers because Ethan leg got well so quick 😂😂😂
@WaWa-Zd8Ай бұрын
😂😂
@isaachonican418220 күн бұрын
Jim healed pretty fast after a house fell on him and Randal's face and neck healed pretty quick I think it still could be valid
@natalygonzalez144518 күн бұрын
That's my biggest questions to be honest jajajaj, Ethan was running 2 days after having a table's leg go through his.😂
@YTHeroes2 күн бұрын
@@isaachonican4182 Also Ellis after he got stabbed by Dale, he was fine after like one or two days. Healing seems to just work faster there.
@ConnorJ97Ай бұрын
i see a think story video i click i sit i watch i listen i enjoy
@ndeyendellagueye1250Ай бұрын
I think the man crushed in the cellar is a foreshadowing of what happened to Dale as for the soldier and the man attention the village for Elgin. I think those visions are key moment of things that repeat during all the previous cycles !
@CaptShriverАй бұрын
MAN IN YELLOW I believe that's who Tabitha was looking up at when she was hiding as a child behind that big rock with red on it
@abderissus8324Ай бұрын
good catch i forgot about that
@bluewater4Ай бұрын
Why Jim killed? Julie looks different. Same dimension or a different girl?
@Geezythegreat88Ай бұрын
@@bluewater4Julie from the future
@averagemonkey4067Ай бұрын
lowk not a bad therory, i thought it was the "worse evil" than the monsters mentioned this season
@wazindoАй бұрын
It has to be something visibly scary. He's just an old man to the naked eye.
@samuelblass6994Ай бұрын
One theory is that the talismans and the sun don’t work on the monsters. The only reason they stay away from the talismans and the sun is because the entity gave them orders to do so to give the people hope
@Vejita12Ай бұрын
Remember when Fatima couldn't open the doors? They weren't locked, Nicky went right through them seconds later. Although I think you are still somewhat right, the monsters could for example fall a tree on a house, or use the cars to make a hole in a wall (they went through that box's walls like they weren't even there, so they are very strong), or smoke people out of the buiildings, I mean they got options, but all they do is walk, scream and talk.
@anavmittal9302Ай бұрын
Maybe tailsen was was the yellow entity and not these monsters
@jonashorn835429 күн бұрын
I had the same thought 👍🏻 It’s probably all just a part of their play
@juliabaranowska8770Ай бұрын
#1 5:35 They touch, they break, they steal - I have a theory that apart from Julie, also Randall and Marielle will be able to storywalk. Julie touches which means why she could touch and pass the rope to Boyd in the dungeon, Marielle will be able to steal things and Randall to break things. #2 4:20 I think Martin knows who Julie is because she probably visited him in the past, maybe when he was younger #3 The boat theory. On the photo of Boyd's retirement house the boat was missing and he still has keys to the boat. In the tale of the Cromenockle there is a Lake of Tears and one monster is dressed like a marine captain (you can see him in the scene where Smiley is reborn). In addition there is a lighthouse in the woods and normally the lighthouse should be near the sea, so I think the lake of tears is another name for sea which is missing in the Fromville. #4 I also remember that in season 2 Tillie said he has 7 grandchildren and I noticed that there are also 7 ghost children. She wasnt unhappy when she arrived to the town and when she died she wasnt concerned about her own death and if she didnt die Tabitha wouldnt have to run away from the colony house
@emraldswrdАй бұрын
I saw a post about how Jim had figured out the "answer" in season 1. I forgot the ep number but in it, Jim was trying to find answers to unanswered questions. Tabitha asked him if he figured it out, he said he did, and that "the answer is 12". This connects to the last ep of season 3! I just thought it was cool to share. Feel free to correct me and add more in replies
@saksheformeАй бұрын
Explain pls
@sargmo2Ай бұрын
3:35 the food shortage as far as the vegetables go happened because the town needed to feed Fatima while she was pregnant with smiley hence that was the only thing she could eat!
@standaarddrinkerАй бұрын
But smiley grew beacause she ate blood not fedgetables
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
Yeah they made the food rot so fatima could feed on it
@princejss6383Ай бұрын
I think Tilly has been there before. Also think she gave birth to one or more monsters during her time there that’s why she never had a problem with Fatima eating the spoils crops. Because she did the same thing
@Roadgoing30Ай бұрын
The boy in white asking Victor to collect the items make sense now that we know that good entities are trying to make people remember
@WileCoyoteMoncure-SmithАй бұрын
I watched an interview with the show runners. They said they have mapped the show but they have not mapped all of the mysteries. They don't believe in giving us a "grand mystery" resolution. So, expect new mysteries resolutions as the seasons progress! We won't have to wait for it. I think the trees are the entity. The trees pull people in.
@ashley.taylor174Ай бұрын
If all the mysteries are answered then we don’t have a show anymore. 😂
@cyriztzАй бұрын
It's more like giving us something to hold on, yet they give more mysteries
@neilshijilkumar2042Ай бұрын
smellgin too
@Daniel-ll2clАй бұрын
@@cyriztz i've actually lost track of the mysteries. plot didnt even focus on how there was fresh food in that other location at all it just moved on
@aybangz3583Ай бұрын
Not necessarily answer all questions but not to spend the whole season just to answer like 3 questions in the last episode. Then add like ten more questions ffs
@5mk854Ай бұрын
There are a lots of plot in this series. For eg. Monsters vs humans. Migrating to new location. Or maybe even about the outside world where fbi trying to figure out the missing people.
@AmazingslothАй бұрын
Great work! Know that your videos are one of the many things I am truly thankful for this holiday. BTW - Just wonderful that are embracing the 'Daddy loves you very much' coda. It's definitely your best and I just love it as an exclamation mark to another great Think Story video. Thank you so much and have a great holiday.
@neuroblast1681Ай бұрын
2:00 if the cycles started in the 1600's, who built the 1950's / 60's style buildings (like the neon motel sign)? I wonder if the buildings get warped in (replacing older era buildings), because it would make less sense if they were there before the industrial age.
@everythingcollectiblesАй бұрын
That’s what I wanna know too!
@MrHartshorn79Ай бұрын
It seems that whatever happened to cause what our characters are dealing with now, happened in the 50's. The townspeople (not the children's parents specifically, since Tabitha and Jade were parents who tried to save their own and there's too many monsters to have parented 7 kids) sacrificed the children and got their immortality as monsters. The kids were killed by people they trusted - they never said parents specifically, but kids back then probably trusted the milkman, the teacher, the librarian and whatever Smiley was. This ritual sacrifice forced part of their town into this little pocket dimension that everyone now lives in. Other settlements in the area are log cabins (and Martin's dungeon/ruins) and such and could easily have been from the 1600's or whenever. Not familiar enough with lighthouses to try and put a date on that, but it's possible to have come very early on.
@MrKillachristopher2Ай бұрын
@@MrHartshorn79 There are 12 monsters, ending of season 3 showed that, and Jade and Tabitha makes 14.
@MrHartshorn79Ай бұрын
@@MrKillachristopher2 If you google it, there's a reddit post where some guy identified 25 individual, distinct monsters. Has screenshots, episode appearances, all that. Possible the 12 we saw in that episode were actually parents though?
@MrKillachristopher2Ай бұрын
@@MrHartshorn79 Please post the link here, so I can view it. That's too much digging to look for one post out of many.
@natalist8391Ай бұрын
I noticed that in the second season, Mariel gave a stone with an anchor to Christie, and the anchor is connected to the Marines, which is Martin, there is also a similarity between the name Mariel and the word Marine.
@timespacetravelerАй бұрын
The question that boggles my mind is why Julie asks a 6-year-old child for advice 😂
@katinki29 күн бұрын
he's smarter than most of people there ^^
@haribabu490728 күн бұрын
He is better than dale
@Mukduck61925 күн бұрын
Because reality here isn’t normal, and a child has the imagination to understand it
@johnvuu467925 күн бұрын
Probably cause he's a kid so he won't judge
@Zzkieb2219 күн бұрын
Ethan knows something. And of course he’s not gonna tell anyone. Hate that kid
@nabiln85Ай бұрын
My big overall question is why anyone is brought here, and why some have someone they know show up (the nurse, forgot her name), or Vic’s dad.
@kapiljetwani3540Ай бұрын
Marriele
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
People are saying it is like a cycle, in last life tabitha failed to save the children, so came again- jade failed to listen to the boy in white when he was christopher and then he came again now to save the children.
@twolip2Ай бұрын
Possible explanations/ making theories :P 3:02 Possibly another 'story' setting? for the people before the current ones? 3:29 Maybe the town wanted to keep these people alive for the 'story' to be completed? Because they had no other source of survival at that point right? 3:56 I found this point really interesting. These monsters were clearly humans before they became immortal. Did they know that that they would also become monsters in the process? Did they choose to accept this fact with time? When smiley die, did he actually 'die'? because interestingly, around the time he died is when fatima became pregnant. Is this the part of the curse of immortality, that even if they die under certain circumstances, they WILL rebirth through these people? Another thing, as for the the boy in white saying 'this is the only way' while pushing Tabitha from the lighthouse and transporting her back to the real world....what if her only purpose was to find victor's dad and bring him because he's probably an important part of the 'story'? as well as other people like that lady police officer (forgot her name-) Its also pretty interesting with the whole lighthouse and the boat thing, which so far have been the only indication that we can escape from the place Also, so far the only entities which look positive are the boy in white and the dog. interestingly even the anghkooey children didn't mean any harm. Also wth is the deal with the missing buildings....
@afrodan735028 күн бұрын
UNANSWERED QUESTION 1:: In season 1, one of the characters (I can't remember who) said "notice how they never run? They always walk" but then when we see the vision of Mirandas death we can see Smiley running at her before killing her. Was it just inconsistent writing or was it just the only time the creatures felt a sense of urgency. UNANSWERED QUESTION 2:: In season 1 or 2 we see Victor documenting the positions of the trees where he the notices that they are moving. What's up with that? UNANSWERED QUESTION 3:: In season 2 or 3 Victor again notices that the weather is changing and that this place has never changed. Is that something new or is that something that happened before victors time as well ?
@MrHartshorn7923 күн бұрын
1. My guess is that they walk whenever they're in view of people until they're ready to pounce, then they run in for the kill. 2. Been curious about this myself. 3. Another good question.
@Cocorobet25p35pАй бұрын
the key for the town is 1. Lighthouse 2. Boat 3. not digging hole 4. don't let them near water maybe the town would flooding someday and creatures are drowning
@VeruasАй бұрын
jade saw Christopher , later we found out that he once was Christopher himself, so maybe every person jade saw was his previous life self
@Vejita12Ай бұрын
Most likely the one eye guy/pinned to the tree and the guy crushed with the boulder, maybe except the civil war soldier, who stabs Jade in his vision, maybe that's how that version died and Jade remembers it from his previous self's perspective.
@UrbanBeauty166Ай бұрын
The monsters know everyone's name as well as Julie's. In S1, Jasmine referred to Trudy by name and explained to her that they know all of their names but without explaining how they know.
@jeffpcfreak8 күн бұрын
for me a comment on reddit makes sence: The Threes dont move , the city does move thats why the portal threes send people into buildings/walls
@noturmum7967Ай бұрын
Video idea: a full video on wether Marielle is secretly working for the entity, or just saw some of what the people fromsville will have to deal with and made her lose hope Why did she tell Randal he was going to be ok then admit to Kristi nobody would be. Sure she could've been trying to calm him down. But rewatch that scene again... She seemed a little to aware of the situation and what he was going through.
@noturmum7967Ай бұрын
Elaboration: if you look into her appearance in s1 to s2 she makes a noticable shift in personality the MINUTE she wakes up from the sacadia nightmare.
@diptanshuk5Ай бұрын
Julie Marielle and Randall, were all tied together. At first we can assume that Julie being the one can allow her to enter the ruins and jump into stories (past/future). But Boyd managed to enter the ruins too and maybe, Boyd was Martin in his past life. cz martin was never killed but forced to suffer just like Boyd. They had multiple chance to finish boyd but instead they thought of making him suffer. We haven’t seen Randall or marielle entering ruins maybe the characters that are linked with the places can. If tabby is Miranda, Jade is Christopher maybe Jullie is Victor’s sister. Jullie might be the one who tells the story to angkhooey kids giving them hope just like she tells stories to her brother Ethan.
@pauloshman6188Ай бұрын
I might a theory. The Magic tree. The only that can used it is people who has souls. That been there before.
@wonderegg757820 күн бұрын
what
@pauloshman618820 күн бұрын
Okay do you remember the bottle tree. How some people can used it and stay alive. And remember the old guy used it and he was sent to pool and died.
@wonderegg757819 күн бұрын
@@pauloshman6188 i think it can only be used by the ones that are reborn and stuff
@Jas_per_Ай бұрын
9:43 Tilly was just a sweet old lady. Get over it people 😂 Let her rest in peace.
@amarok9749Ай бұрын
My theory is that Jade and Tabitha are special because their past selves were the only couple to refuse to sacrifice their child (The boy in white) and so they are basically in a constant cycle of trying to rescue the other kids whilst the entity try's to stop or corrupt them.
@lukasrucys9198Ай бұрын
How is this a theory? That's the most basic info you could off the episode.
@amarok9749Ай бұрын
@@lukasrucys9198 Its a theory because it isn't confirmed. I have full confidence in the writers ability to not connect the most obvious dots and instead create a convoluted mess instead, So yeah a theory.
@BileDuctBalderdashАй бұрын
your theory is shit because you failed to listen to Tabitha speaking in the woods when Jade was playing the violin 🎻
@amarok9749Ай бұрын
@@BileDuctBalderdash Guess we'll see in season 4 🤷♂🤷♂
@BileDuctBalderdashАй бұрын
In 3 years you can tell me about S4 if you're still watching @@amarok9749 had more patience in my forties but now in my fifties not so much.
@gulzila9 күн бұрын
Great analysis. Maybe I could add something to your thought process regarding lighthouses - They are in fact design to guide ships into safety ... Things that people do forget is that you are not supposed to go TO the lighthouse for safety. It is usually placed around rough areas near the shore that ship should AVOID. So if you are a ship's captain, you would never go towards lighthouse. Something to chew on.
@christophermccutcheon2143Ай бұрын
Question 58: Why is the gal bladder of these undead things significant? When they cut open the Ken doll, his gal bladder was the only thing significant. Figured they'd try shooting the others in the gal bladder, like maybe that's their heart
@johnnyvenhaus2904Ай бұрын
lol idk if they gonna be trying to kill these things anymore now that they know what happens when they die
@hsblw_6Ай бұрын
Awesome! I've made a comment in someone's review of the season with 10 questions. This is a nice evolution 😂 let's see how many of these questions get answered in the next 4-5 years it's gonna take for us to see 2 more seasons.
@AcguarnicaАй бұрын
god...
@greenytaddictАй бұрын
I will definitely be visiting this video again 😅
@optimus6858Ай бұрын
This show itself is an entity 😂 It only makes more questions
@likeluptidАй бұрын
Victor was in the tunnels for 3 nights and 3 days beginning the night that the Nightmare Creatures attacked Colony House. The creatures had no idea he was there until they saw him walking out with Tabitha. The first thing they did was move deeper into the tunnels, and leave the thing that frightened Victor the most, Jasper, there near the entrance, evidently as a scarecrow for Victor. We see this when Jade came into the tunnels a few days later. He immediately sees Jasper, then when he makes it to the chamber where the nightmare creatures had been sleeping, they and their stuff were gone. Then Victor comes back to the tunnels with his father. Jasper is not at the entrance, and when they go deeper into the tunnels past the chamber, they find Jasper, the nightmare creatures sleeping, and their stuff. Karen from Management creature says to Victor, "If you keep coming down here . . ." Her language indicates that she thinks Victor has been coming repeatedly. Victor has only been there 1 time. Evidently, she thought Victor had come back a 2nd time when it was actually Jade who made that brief visit there. That's why the dummy wasn't at the entrance anymore by the time that Victor came back. Karen Creature from Management thought that Jasper scared Victor away, and he would never come back; she doesn't know that Jade was the visitor.
@vladimirredjit1288Ай бұрын
in Victor's memory there is still a sign on the hotel - Star Magic
@IgorAntunes13Ай бұрын
I have some of my teories to those questions -Elgin is a reencarnation of the soldier that jade saw - The skeleton guy who is dressed like jade was og jade who got captured by the soldier -The og town people knew the soldier had og jade and tried to torture him to say the location ( thats why the burn marks and the no eye) but he didnt have up the location -Eloise got capture and is the girl thing tabitha saw in the cave -The totems are like talismans but for the outside -Randal julie and mariele will have special tasks , like julie watching the past, randal being the one who breaks will protect the town with the totems, and mariele maybe will be able to do something when she touches what victor gathered as a child from the og people -Boyd wife was the reencarnation between miranda and tabitha (hint being she had dreams) , and she killed the reencarnation of christopher in the mass shooting, and since they died in the same day , they also arrived in the same day as tabitha and jade -The night monsters we see are not the parents who sacrificed their children (hint being there is a teen and a old lady monsters) but are in fact the people who died in previous cycles, but since victors didnt die they didnt change - Kimono lady is in fact one of the parents (since she is one who tells the story to Fatima and she looks in her 30´s) -The people who come to the town are simple random people just to feed the big bad but the boy in white can also bring people
@Noble_NexusАй бұрын
I'm thinking about the bugs that came out of Smiley when he died and also the bugs that Randall is bothered by that no one else sees. Could there be a connection between Randall and Smiley?
@robertl1135Ай бұрын
I think tillie is one of the townspeople (Julie possibly?) from the future since the story line seems to be going into the time travel loop stuff. Maybe the events of the town have always happened and will continue to happen (even if the good guys win) out of our plane of space time but changes based on the time period of the cycle. In that case all of the souls are doomed to repeat the cycle forever
@AzeKanoАй бұрын
For me it’s Julie’s wig.
@jessicawagner770823 күн бұрын
It looks like different actress completely
@christophermccutcheon2143Ай бұрын
I did want to mention what happened to Boyd's plan to capture one of these things, but you brought it up right at the end. Really wanted him to do that
@agent-33Ай бұрын
Miranda said the kids in the tower need salvation. But when Tabitha got in it, there are no kids and she got pushed off the tower by the kid who said "this is the only way". The questions: 1. What does he mean by only way? Only way out of that place? Or only way to the children? Or both? 2. But why would the Angkooey kids wanted her to get out of that place? 3. If storywalker cannot change the story, then how did Julie threw the rope to Boyd in the chamber which result in her affecting the story? 4. How the hell did Ethan know all of these quest, spiders, storywalker stuff? Did the boy in white told him all these stuff?
@x0x0xLАй бұрын
i think the BIW said that because he’s trying to get tabitha and jade to remember who they are. when him & victor are talking while he’s trying to chop down the tree, victor asks why he won’t help them and the BIW says “i tried with christopher. i think you need to learn for yourselves. it’s the only way you’ll understand”
@amitjaikaran4915Ай бұрын
To answer ur third point. Think of it as that was always suppose to happen. Julie was always suppose to drop the rope for boyd. It’s part of the story
@twolip2Ай бұрын
for your first question... the boy in white saying 'this is the only way' while pushing Tabitha from the lighthouse and transporting her back to the real world....what if her only purpose was to find victor's dad and bring him because he's probably an important part of the 'story'?
@Carbonate-6Ай бұрын
for the fourth one, ethan knew all that because he reads a lot of stories
@abiba1006Ай бұрын
@@Carbonate-6what could Ethan in this version of the story be ? The boy in white ? (Cuz When in season1 l those creatures wanted Sarah to kill Ethan that could probably be the child in white (good side) that leads the people to the way home in newer versions of the story -l hope u understood lol-) Or Victor? (Because only him and Victor are able to see the boy in white )
@C.a.imageryАй бұрын
I love how you answer people’s questions
@aeraeraeraerАй бұрын
honestly one of the most annoying shows I’ve ever watched with all that „I’m fine”, „I don’t want to talk about it” 💀
@jackwilliam4436Ай бұрын
About Tabitha ending up in the same town as Victor's dad : Maybe that's because she was 'anchored' to that place and to her previous family. She is a reincarnation of Victor's mother. She was carrying Victor's lunchbox. She raised Victor in that house. She was married to Victor's dad. She made those paintings and a Faraway Tree. When she came back to Fromland in the ambulance, it was revealed she was always destined to come back to Fromland. Maybe, she was also always destined to end up in the town where she raised Victor, each and every time she left Fromland. Sure, it was not her 'actual Tabitha' life, but it was one of her previous incarnations. She is always being pulled back to the two places where she belongs : Fromland and the town where she raised Victor.
@greenytaddictАй бұрын
Laughed so hard at the title 😆
@matnels2776 күн бұрын
Victor and Jade are by far the best characters. All the arguing and hypocrisy in that town does my head in. I love jades comment to the boy saying as you get older you realise any meeting with more than 3 people is pointless.
@liz651Ай бұрын
I dont really remember, but Boyed wife did mention a dream she had when she was a kid.
@adityadayal366217 күн бұрын
I think the Directors should now think of answering the questions they have introduced during the 3 seasons. This series have good potential. The directors should take their time and come up with answers because if they fail to connect the questions with the right answers then there is not use of putting efforts for the 3 f* seasons. I hope things get well in Season 4 !! (they are great till now) ONE OF THE BIGGEST ISSUE WITH THIS SHOW IS - The lack of conversations b/w the characters, if Jade and Jim had talked to each other they might have solved the 12 music keys problem a season earlier. And same goes for everyone else !!
@ChemicalEngineer275Ай бұрын
I'm missing if Jasper has some sort of connection to the town. Why Victor said only in the basement he can tell secrets. Why Ethan started to lose memory. And what are the intentions of the boy in white.
@fulanoide718Ай бұрын
Jasper was just a doll, Victor misremembered, he didn't hear Jasper talk, just Christopher, as he was a ventriloquist Victor probably associated his voice with the "doll's voice". Ethan didn't lost any memory, it's just a normal fear that grieving people have, forgetting the dead, it's normal for him to not remember how his baby brother looked like, it was just a baby and it happened a while ago
@LsArivuАй бұрын
end of 9th episode i thought victor & tabitha are siblings (eloise is tabiatha ).. but now all the theories and explanations blows my brain out 😵😵💫😵💫.. but that the reason i love these series much more 😍😜❤
@riteshpandey814Ай бұрын
Why Miranda was running in night??. She can go in day time to thetree
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
Aankhui
@FunctionalJunkie_Ай бұрын
The light house is a giant spy eye big brother style. Theres even a drawing of it in the opening sequence...
@markkuykendall5475Ай бұрын
What episode was it that someone mentioned the wrecked truck in the pool was driven by someone named Danny?
@Sutareta27 күн бұрын
I think the vegetables found are connected to Tian-Chen Liu, before she died she was going to plant seeds
@luthert657Ай бұрын
After season 4. Writers will double the questions and give it to their audiences
@daryldixon6920Ай бұрын
Absolutely amazing answers
@Gundam_JAYАй бұрын
So idk if this is already explained. But I have a theory that every person that jade sees is him from a past life. And the closer he gets to solving the mystery and "remebering" what happened the more visions appear. However the bartender is perhaps a spirt trying to mis guid him
@loribarr3787Ай бұрын
Perhaps an homage to the bartender in The Shining who's trying to misguide Jack Torrance?
@Gundam_JAYАй бұрын
@loribarr3787 ooo I like that idea! Definitely possible. Although there's also the priest for boyd and I have a feeling it's the same spirit trying to tempt both of them to go over the edge or to quit fining answers
@djc836Ай бұрын
Where do they get toilet papper from? I couldn't be bothered going through the list, but that's one question I've been asking myself.
@NotSamuelAtAllАй бұрын
I'm not sure if this one got answered, but when the couple from the bus, 'Brian' and 'Kelly' related to someone Boyd knew as 'Brian Kelly' in the past. This one is weird and I have no idea how they will answer it.
@johnnyvenhaus2904Ай бұрын
Think it was just another way to try to break Boyd. Could be wrong tho and could have more meaning
@GeoGoatGB19 күн бұрын
Just ended watching season 3, really excited for season 4! Something tell me that this will become new "lost" with lots of seasons
@TheusphilipАй бұрын
Why did people start dying in their sleep? This is the question that seems to have been forgotten.
@themasterchefnzАй бұрын
Pretty sure that was the music box monster. Which Boyd defeated by destroying the music box.
@TheusphilipАй бұрын
@@themasterchefnz but whats the point???
@fulanoide718Ай бұрын
@@Theusphilipthe point of what? Of the music box? We don't know, Boyd found it on the dungeon, we don't know ANYTHING about the dungeon, how or why Boyd ended up there, why there was an old dude chained to a wall with the worms disease, why Julie, the idiot guy and Marielle got chained up there while their brains got fucked. Nothing
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
@@Theusphilip should drag the season to 10 mandatory episodes 😅
@haidaisrandomАй бұрын
bro, i just finish the series yesterday... i felt like it was a destiny for you to upload the video just for me to watch it.
@NeatoManeatoАй бұрын
Just a theory but what if only those who were reincarnated can pass through the far away trees.
@jalalexeАй бұрын
I'm not a person who like series or movies, but this movie personally for me so fun to watch, every mystery kept me thinking about what's gonna happen next. I personally don't feel bothered by the very slow pace. My prediction for season 4, there will be some daytime monsters that can still appear, like the yellow robed man who was teased a little at the end of the season, or maybe some monsters that victor drawn, or couple draw of a monster that appears on opening scene. And I'm really looking forward to what kind of monster pulls Boyd's tent while camping in the middle of the forest. Julie who tries time traveling, tries to solve the mystery, and maybe goes back and forth in time to save her father. It is likely that with the rebirth of Smiley, he will have a fairly important role in the next season. I hope the monsters increase the intensity of their terror, so that next season will be more interesting and exciting to watch.
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
What do u like if not movies and series?
@jalalexe27 күн бұрын
@@shashankmlrj Video Games ofc 😁
@FlimsyPicklesАй бұрын
Still to me the weirdest thing is why everyone in town came from one of the 48 contiguous USA states… how does that make any sense? That’s why I thought it was some sort of experiment at first, but I think it’s just a plot hole…
@destiny6080Ай бұрын
People in discord said it was magic, magic to sacrifice your children for eternal life. I'm not sure why they turned into monsters tho. To your question, if it's magic then since it happened in America it might only exist in America, can't affect past america.
@GaganSingh-fe3piАй бұрын
Boy in white tasked victor to collect those items to make the reincarnated townspeople remember their past, same reason why monsters are keeping them hidden in their cave because they dont want them to remember
@eddiemagАй бұрын
I saw a theory that says: Marielle is will become the woman wearing the kimono, because she stole the baby, randall will become the man in yellow because he’s meant to break humans and Julie can only touch stories and not change them
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
Why is marielle the kimono lady?
@user-ff1mm2sk5b27 күн бұрын
@@shashankmlrj "because she stole the baby" referring to when she stole the drugs
@shashankmlrj27 күн бұрын
@@user-ff1mm2sk5b thats too much i guess but in this town maybe
@atienootieno1384Ай бұрын
I think the guy crushed by the giant Boulder in season 1 is related to the one eye guy near the 3 red boulders. Also related to Elgin who now has one eye.
@wolfinwool3Ай бұрын
Tabitha went to Camden because that where Miranda was from.
@704NikeАй бұрын
How did you hear what the creatures were saying outside the camper? I’ve very interested in how you grasped that. Thank you.