FROM Season 3 Episode 7: Breakdown, Theories and Review

[@EmansReviews]

What did you think about this episode and the ending?

[@leluseven]

Oh, Tillie isn't the entity...huh. LMAO! ETA: I came to your videos through the FUNNIEST goddamned review of 'Cats' that I have ever seen. And that was stiff competition, my dude! I am so glad I subscribed then, because the algo brought you back when I started search YT for FROM related content.

[@poisonxlee9823]

Something attacked the dude in the cellar the bed was thrown up against the wall before Elgin pulled it down and he was probably cowering in the corner and got his facelift 💅🏾

[@Kmgottman-ol7ef]

I never thought till was a mole or whatever crazy theory’s I liked Tilly a lot 😢

[@hitoshiasakura9109]

This place is where unkown dreams come from,,think of it as another universe or reality where our dreams come from but these dreams are the more sense dreams like youve dreamed a place like youve never seen before,, and the law of physics might violate some of ot but this dream is the one that are more realistic...not the dreams where u can fly or u have super powers those have another place too.... But in fromville it is the more make sense dreams... Like some kind of dejavu like Tabitha experience....to sum it up this is where our dreams are stored why we dream? Because there is this place that subconsciously or somhow conected to us,,,,,like doctor strange parrarel universe....

[@trueblade3636]

6/10 is the correct score to give. 8:52 this is one reason why people wouldn't talk with each other. Fatima is now openly talking about (almost) everything. And because of that, she might have to leave the building because they are scared of her. She talks, and now she faces bad consequences for that. 15:31 all those questions and answers need to be written down, in a book or at a wall like Jim. So that the same questions wouldn't be asked twice or more. And maybe people could see patterns or other people can answers those questions. 36:37 Ellis is gonna trust Fatima and make up a plan. He is not gonna leave her (I think)

[@ButlerOTKing]

Raise your hand if you did not have Fatima shanking Tillie on your Bingo card 🙌🙌🙌

[@EmansReviews]

🙋🏿‍♂️

[@babytoshiro7014]

No one, absolutely no one, saw that coming😮

[@Mrs.buildingblackwealth]

👋

[@andrewashby6090]

@@babytoshiro7014honestly felt stupid af for me. And I started watching From midway through season 1. The show has just lost its suprise and they’ve stretched this Fatima, Randal, Elgin issues for way too long. We haven’t learned a single thing in 7 episodes!!

[@lpa4058]

I knew she was going to hurt Tilly ....Tilly is annoying af and I knew someone was.going to snap on her.

[@ashleycoidlyn]

It’s interesting that Julie “hears”, Randall “sees” and Marielle “feels” the cicada monster stuff. I don’t have a theory but it reminds me of “Hear no evil. See no evil. Speak no evil.”

[@jaygreen19995]

Why is this not being talked about!?

[@annemaried.8055]

Good point 😮

[@GEM.music13403]

Wow, good call. Never even went there in my head. ❤

[@timjones9246]

This was a very good point

[@no.think-again]

Could Julie, Randall, Marielle and Boyd be the key to something? They were all in the tower, 3 of them were chained like the man Boyd helped in the tower and Boyd got bugs under his skin too and there's something with his blood. Seems like the creatures couldn't kill the ones chained in the tower before, cause they were special somehow. Also the creatures didn't kill Randall, could it be cause they actually just can't kill him? Could it be that Julie, Randall and Marielle also have special blood like Boyd?

[@northeastgurl]

After every episode, this is my first stop. Thank you for delivering the best From content out there.

[@EmansReviews]

Wow, thanks!

[@shadyslim4743]

Same!

[@KornelKonkel]

literally what I do every sunday!

[@Dakatalol]

I hate having only 40 minutes per episode every week. But having my man E-Man posting a followup video for each episode counts as 2 episodes of the TV show every week. Keep up the good work!

[@francoherrera601]

He gets me through until next Monday lol

[@mrsw2923]

These reviews are better than the actual show at times. Clears up so much.

[@RennaStarling]

We look forward to watching these almost as much as the episode itself. You're doing a fantastic job man! 👏👏👏

[@EmansReviews]

Thanks a ton!

[@D1026-p8h]

Ngl sometimes I skip the ep and watch these before I sleep

[@essdee9694]

me too, his breakdowns are the best 😄

[@crydcllc2076]

@@D1026-p8hI thought I was the only one lol

[@macmac6318]

E-Man, I can't watch any other movie where someone dies, without the hearing the E-Man soundtrack '"he/she dead." 😉 🤣😂🤣

[@Suko44]

i like how these videos are almost as long as the episodes

[@nicoleb1111]

I’m glad we can finally dismiss this “Tilly is the mole” theory

[@Monikamusic02official]

Sad they probably did that on purpose so they we could stfu. Lol!

[@amandamoore6789]

I feel like we can’t entirely dismiss that theory yet. When she said “you better run” that could be warning Fatima she was a monster and is about to come for her. It could also simply mean you better run before anyone else sees what you did. Regardless, Tilly is still sus imo.

[@kazzykaioken8873]

Just because someone dies doesnt mean they cant have been a mole or that they didnt have bad intentions. She did a whole voodoo card reading and her last words where suspicious as she never saw anyone put in the box so why would her first thought be run

[@kena322]

@@amandamoore6789just let it go. Jesus Christ 🙄

[@amandamoore6789]

@ hahaha it’s not that serious, let people have fun with their theories

[@awwwsnap4437]

The jukebox seriously is the best guest star on this show, lol. I know for me personally I didn’t know if i should laugh or cry when that song started playing with what we’ve been going through lately. I can’t stand Acosta and Boyd is still the man.

[@MikaHasFaith]

The jukebox didn't look damaged anymore unless I missed it.

[@naefaust581]

@@MikaHasFaithThere is more than one

[@MikaHasFaith]

@@naefaust581 Ohhhh is there one at each booth? I never paid attention.

[@naefaust581]

@@MikaHasFaith I believe I saw one on top of each middle table on either side of the entrance

[@n.barnes3754]

Those jukeboxes are diabolical

[@tutorialslave]

I, too, took Kenny's speech as a 4th wall break. It's a nice touch. If, however, they're going the same route they did right before the Lost series finale released when they told us all "It was never about the mysteries, it was always about the characters", I'm gonna riot and whip up a petition for these guys to never get a writing gig again.

[@augustj3350]

Unfortunately they’ve literally said this in an interview with the cast recently 😩😩

[@tutorialslave]

@@augustj3350 I've read the leaks. They're a bit out there but not awful. The last two seasons are shaping up to be a worthy homestretch.

[@magikarp1666]

​@@augustj3350 what did they say?

[@solefire3517]

​@@magikarp1666 They said the series was about the charcaters and not the mysteries

[@blacprophet1153]

I hope this series does not fall into the trap of the great "Lost" series!

[@july_inkz]

The gun has no benefits unless you’re threatening normal people

[@shanewilliams6772]

Unless she has a back up clip or bullets...I feel she woulda fought more for the bullets if she didn't have back ones.......ya know what i mean probly just as hard as she did for the gun.......

[@puertogreekn8675]

his point is, the gun is useless against monsters and only can harm other people​@shanewilliams6772

[@july_inkz]

I’m betting she does have a backup clip. Especially w the way she said sheriff and swung out the door.

[@trueblade3636]

And it's still a hard instrument to hit someone with it

[@LeaGholson-t6w]

@@july_inkz Exactly.

[@phillylady]

Just as my husband was questioning why the police officer was still in her uniform, Kenny asked her the same thing. 😂

[@highhopeshomestead2678]

@@phillylady I think she wants to wear it to be seen as an authority figure. Maybe her one way to grasp onto something that makes her feel she has a bit of control.

[@phillylady]

I agree! That uniform, along with the badge, but especially the gun, says so much about the power of policing in the United States.

[@yeahrightmyguy481]

​@@highhopeshomestead2678she said why she wore it, she doesn't want to get comfortable there so she's staying in what she came in

[@MissSweetiePie22]

Random but I'm from Philly too go Eagles! Hell of a game yesterday

[@SaraCramer-s3m]

My theory: when Victor was a kid they had talismans, he just doesn't remember. They've hinted that Christopher is the reason everyone died. I think he stole all the talismans and hid them in that tree Boyd later finds them in. I think the town people put Christopher in that cellar to make him give up where he hid them and that's why Victor and his Mom were there. I also think that's why his Mom was so urgent to help those kids and get home, because they weren't protected at night anymore. I also think maybe the new cop will do something stupid with the talismans and it will spark a memory with Victor.

[@bosshuxley4933]

I like your thinking that’s really interesting 😃 however I am not sure it will be like that exactly, I do think we are missing a huge piece of information from that fateful night when they all died which I think is going to shock us once they reveal it (which I think will be soon) 😊

[@farnoushjamshidi]

Yeah and I think now that the cop knows Boyd found talismans and hates Boyd this much for kind of no reason, she is going to do something against Boyd to make people believe the town needs a new sheriff. I have a bad feeling about her.

[@blacprophet1153]

I think that nerve had the Talismans because they were hiding in the homes and underground to avoid he monsters! I think it was intentional for body to find the Talismans because he is like the hero of this show!!

[@balletbabeannie]

I think that dead body Elgin found is Christopher... Everyone was on high tension this episode, Kenny better rethink joining colony house 👀

[@From55555]

I thought so , but how crazy would be that Victors mom Miranda tells her children to hide from Christopher , but leaves them at the same place he is hiding.

[@balletbabeannie]

​@From55555 is it the same place? After we found there are multiple bottle tree idk anymore

[@From55555]

@ oh , that would be good , it would explain how Victor survived, because that one near town was to obvious for Victor to survive a massacre. I do think it’s the same , but your idea would make more sense .

[@ashelywebb5612]

The door was locked from the outside meaning someone had to lock the person in. I don't think that's Christopher

[@julianakleijn9254]

Maybe he can help Donna keep order up there

[@Oddy91]

This channel is always the next stop right after every episode

[@rbo2406]

That jukebox is PETTY as hell😂

[@ardentdfender4116]

I think that Jukebox is like a listening device.

[@reecewhite5900]

I felt like Kenny was talking to us too 😂

[@joerod2019]

I thought Fatima was gonna push Tilly under the table for later consumption

[@peterkawa9869]

😂

[@anneefreres3299]

If Ellis hadn't walked in she definitely would've dug in

[@Alicia_1970]

Oh haha good point.

[@ZoyaIslam-l1w]

A little snack for later

[@blacprophet1153]

I actually thought that she was going to start munching on Tilly right there after her heart stopped beating! I think the only reason she didn't is because someone came into the room!

[@juliej7861]

None of my friends watch this show, so this is the only way I can feel some sense of community about this show! Thank you for putting this on so I have an outlet!

[@EmansReviews]

Thank you for watching Julie! Tell your friends to get with the program 😅

[@AprilLeon]

Im sad about Tillie I wasn’t prepared for that. The entire time I was on edge for Elgin I was afraid for him. Poor Randall he’s really going thru it for a guy who came there acting tough those monsters have really broken him

[@highhopeshomestead2678]

I was expecting a monster to jump out and kill Elgin.

[@giraffesareselfish9563]

​@highhopeshomestead2678 where are the monsters? Haven't seen them in 2 episodes

[@camiam582]

I feel like they haven’t even been coming out at nights anymore.

[@giraffesareselfish9563]

@camiam582 we heard them screaming outside when Jim and Tabitha were arguing, but that's about it.

[@tacrewgirl]

Yeah, I was expecting Elgin to die that entire time. It was very suspenseful.

[@amblove3]

Who fixed the radio? Kenny broke it to pieces with it started playing "Celebration," and now he's like "oh it does that sometimes." DJ From 😂😂😂😂

[@chubbs2783]

Pretty sure there’s multiple

[@amblove3]

@chubbs2783 knowing those things, you're probably right

[@blacprophet1153]

I believe that the Monsters repaired the radio and returned it to the diner so the townfolk can have some tunes👺👺

[@nettadavis9384]

Elgin does not appear afraid of the kimono lady anymore. Did you see Tillie take off her jacket like she knows something 😏

[@nunyabusiness3516]

I think Elgin decided his fear wasn't serving him and she wasn't leaving him alone just because he was scared, so why not just see what he has to say.

[@JoJoestar]

Was very convinced if Randal didn't stop Julie from stepping one more step, she would have been back in that weird dream dungeon place back from season 2.

[@Patrickdaawsome]

Not without lighting a torch or something similar .

[@stevenboddy4232]

You're going to s a brick when Julie goes back with her brother. When you see what happens, you're honestly going to be like "alright wtf is this show"

[@manzures14]

Who knows. At this point there's just some random things that happen but get to nowhere.

[@anneefreres3299]

Yeah I definitely feel like he can see what that place is the way he sees the bugs

[@Smt_.x]

I think all 3 need to go back together

[@kelsey.targaryen]

As someone who was groomed by a 22 year old when I was 15 I find it absolutely disgusting how OK everyone seems to be with Randal and Julie flirting. No wonder I didn’t tell anyone for 5 years, people act like it’s normal and it’s not. She’s a child he is a full grown man.

[@shalinalewis2957]

👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@whitneydavis5096]

I have a theory ! I think whenever you go thru the faraway tree you have to bring a bottle with you, an address or even manifest/think of where you want to go ! Remember Tabitha had Victors address in the lunch box& ended up in Maine & then Dale said he was gonna be “poolside” & where did he end up ? In the pools side And on instagram last week I posted that in the ultrasound picture, I see half a face with a nose & creepy smile like smiley ! I think she’s gonna give birth to smiley !!! . I think He’s gonna be reborn & I think he’s gonna be even stronger than before ! Personally I just don’t think you can see it with a regular ultrasound . What if it is in like an egg or something , that she has to push out & maybe it grows more as it’s out of her body . I just don’t think they’d give her this whole pregnancy timeline & she not be pregnant. It’s just not a regular pregnancy , it’s a from pregnancy & it’s definitely a monster being born . Seems like when things/people die , they always get replaced with something or someone new .

[@ItGirl.Merenami]

I love your theory and ive seen some spoilers! Do you want to know what actually happens?

[@whitneydavis5096]

@ thank you 😀 & its like I want to know but at the same time don’t 😭 I really hate waiting for answers but also wanna see it play out . I honestly wish they’d let us pay extra for an early release of the episodes because I would in a heartbeat !

[@thomaswillard6267]

If Fatima starts laying eggs, I'm gonna die

[@whitneydavis5096]

@ right 😂😂 but would It surprise you tho ? this show is wild & at this point I just expect the unexpected lol .

[@kendraraffington4947]

@@ItGirl.Merenami I wanna know!! But don't post the actual spoilers here. Just tell me where to look. Point me in the right direction. LOL! Just because I wanna know, doesn't mean everyone else wants to know.

[@lpa4058]

Yeah, I think Fatima has only admitted to eating trash and hasn't told anyone that she's a whole cannibal 😂

[@mdcanady1ify]

Bruh!!!!! I said the same thing about the diner!!! That food about to slap.😂😂😂😂😂

[@Mrs.buildingblackwealth]

😂😂

[@LeaGholson-t6w]

@@mdcanady1ify 😂😂😂😂

[@jessbibbo2526]

Watching From with my morning coffee and then right to your channel has been my recent favorite ritual. Can’t wait for the next 3 weeks!

[@LampDoesVideogame]

Elgin also had dreams before he got to town, if we're splitting hairs. It's not unlikely others have.

[@agirlhasnoname3580]

I’m pretty sure Elgin had his first dream as soon as the bus entered from, so right at the tree and not a moment before it, or am i missing something?

[@tarabracey1186]

I believe he mentioned having dreams before he got there. Something about the water screen before he got on the bus or something ​@@agirlhasnoname3580

[@JayeKelz]

Oh girl ain't been a cop that long. Boyd called her out on just getting out of the Academy.

[@brandihebert5617]

LMAO, with the jukebox I was thinking the same thing, "Uh oh, these monsters must be black!"

[@alia0789]

😂😂😅

[@One_Black_Panther]

I feel it for Boyd...he has so much on his shoulders to deal with. As for theories...I DUNNO WHAT TO THINK AT THIS POINT 😂. I'm just gonna watch & find out.

[@lnb2004]

E-man!!! The laugh I just had!! Bakta running the diner! That food about to be BUSSIN’ bussin’. 😆😆😆😆

[@alexacapadona3939]

Kenny is such an amazing character. As you've said before, in previous episodes that this place should have broke him. Honestly, I feel like he's just coming out stronger. He's giving advice to people. He's almost seeming at peace in a way with how crazy this is, and I just I really appreciate that. I think it's amazing. I love it.

[@Gnb496]

Julie is being defiant because she’s mad at her parents and she had an argument experience she hasn’t talked to them about. I’d like to believe Randall is not up to anything. I think he just likes having someone to talk to and you could clearly see he was tripping that Julie was spending the night.

[@thomaswillard6267]

I think Randall is feeling a little awkward going from the loner on the bus to being the only guy with a building full of women, given he has a history if machismo.

[@e-zaylott4310]

For everyone calling tillie evil yall wrong she was just a poor women trying to help and enjoy what life she had left 😢

[@babytoshiro7014]

It will be interesting how many will change their tune now 😅

[@theocjr.43]

The tillie disrespect was outlandish

[@jaketuschak1508]

Ppl calling her a plant is a prime example of people running away with kooky theories

[@kevz2474]

i sure did lol

[@jaketuschak1508]

@ nah right back at ya

[@Ash.Crow.Goddess]

Fun fact: I have a From Playlist. So you could say I'm the From DJ. 😂

[@EmansReviews]

It was YOU!!!! 😮

[@bonitahenderson44]

Fatima’s actions is why Donna didn’t want her in the house anymore. My question is are they going to put Fatima in the box?

[@iluvleasia]

I doubt it I think Ellis might try to help Fatima hide the body

[@nunyabusiness3516]

I think the monsters want Boyd to have the crux of this decision.

[@cdr72916]

I mean, they let Sara live, so if they put Fatima in the box, that won’t really make a lot of sense. Maybe Sara will end up taking the fall for it?

[@blacprophet1153]

I agree 100% with Donna because you cannot trust people when they start to lose their mind because the Monster Town is playing tricks on them!

[@Gnb496]

I find it interesting that Elgin made a mobile for Fatima and then ended up in the underground shelter and then Fatima kills Tillie. I wouldn’t be surprised if Ellis runs with Fatima and end up in that shelter.

[@MikaHasFaith]

I was gonna post the same thing. 😊 I think Elgin is gonna hide Fatima in there....I didn't think about Ellis hiding with her.....OMGosh.

[@thomaswillard6267]

Wait... Ellis... Elgin... El-less... El-gain. Ellis is Elgin confirmed

[@mizdivah]

@@thomaswillard6267silly but I liked it lol

[@Smt_.x]

Maybe when he said “is there where it happens” he meant where Fatima is going to give birth?

[@aakatsis]

​@@Smt_.xoooooh yes good thinking!!

[@JaneHasGame]

If a possessed polaroid directs you to a creepy cellar on the edge of town and then, when you go down into the dark alone, and something starts knocking on a previously blank wall that turns out to be a door, don't open it!!

[@jamesburman9784]

Also, Boyd's wife dreamt of this place before she got here. In season 1 at the flashback, Abbie looks confused and after Ellis asks her if she is okay, she says something along the lines of "Yeah its just a dream I had as a kid..." I think this shows that she also dreamt of the place when she was younger and we saw what she ended up doing....

[@kimalikijames7812]

Maybe the corpse is Martin from the dungeon. Since they are revisiting that topic recently.

[@essdee9694]

man your videos are the first one I watch immediately after I watch each episode! you have kept me going between seasons and I love your takes! your girl-dad moment; SAME! I'm side-eyeing that too haha. I do feel where Acosta is coming from with this town because if I were in her position I'd be like f these assholes I'm taking my gun and I'm gone! obviously watching for 3 seasons, we as viewers know Boyd is the goat, he's gotta be one of my top 5 characters of all time. but I'd be same as Acosta in her shoes lol also I said on your previous from episode recap before you re-upped but your idea on all the townspeople booking in time with jade every week cracked me up - that is the move! with Fatima, I def think she's turning into a monster because as far as I can remember, she's not aware of the dried up guts of mr smiley is she?! I def think what she saw her stomach doing was step 2 of the process! and lastly, thanks for your content Emmanuel, you are awesome and you make me laugh every week, the editing on the Fatima/tilly scene had me crying 😭

[@EmansReviews]

Thank you so much for watching! 🙏🏿

[@RawrxBexJealous]

I’ve been thinking about the connection between Julie, Randall & Marielle. I wasn’t sure if the 3 of them were chosen to be a force for good or evil. I’m thinking good now. After seeing the effigies I believe they represent hear no evil, see no evil & speak no evil. When Jade knocks down the effigy it’s of the one representing see no evil which I think represents Randall. Julie being the hear no evil & Marielle as speak no evil since she refuses to talk about it. Maybe the effigies are protecting the 3 of them as “chosen ones”. Because after the see no evil was knocked over the monsters went after Randall in the next episode. Not sure if they’re able to corrupt them or anything. There’s also the 3 red stone slabs. Not sure if that’s connected or if this is all totally off base but just a thought I wanted to share. Loving the videos, interviews & theories 💚

[@GEM.music13403]

I think you are onto a very good tangible theory here and one I never even entered my mind. ❤

[@RawrxBexJealous]

@@GEM.music13403Thank you! It just came to me & I haven’t heard anyone mention a connection there so I thought I’d share 🙃

[@areinablu]

As for me, I thought before that the three red stone slabs represent the past, present and future children. Like victor is the past child, Ethan as present and Fatima's baby is the future. Victor's father represents the parental figure. So, if parents are all present, bad rituals can be done after the place will finally manipulate them, which is why the children that Tabitha saw always go to her asking for help serving as a warning. I have to include your theory in my list 😂 . Yours is really plausible and mine has a lot of loopholes 😂

[@Smt_.x]

I like your theory! I knew it meant something bad when Jade knocked one of those totems over but I never thought about the connection to Randal

[@RawrxBexJealous]

@@areinablu I don’t care if there’s loopholes, I really like your theory! That would be so messed up but interesting. It would tie into the theories of the town going through cycles & history repeating itself with the children & that guy drinking from the skull trying to warn Tabitha & Jade about the potential sacrificial cycle repeating 🤔 I love that this show allows for so much theory crafting! 🙃

[@Chihuahuamomma78]

Acosta reminds me of that know-it-all phase people go through from their late teens to late 20s, where they clash with older adults and don't realize their own place. That's why Boyd called her a kid after she left. I wouldn't have gone in, guns blazing (literal or metaphorical). I would have respected the current status quo, and not questioned it unless I saw abuse of power. There's a reason things are how they are. Some people just have to FAFO before they learn, if they actually survive the lesson. On a different note: Randall's the bad boy girls fall for when they're young and foolish. Elgin is the type of guy they go for when they're ready to settle down.

[@Okbutwhythoalice]

I said almost the exact same thing when she was grinning in the car....and when he runs off I could practically hear her inner monologue "come back! I can fix you!!!"

[@trueblade3636]

8:52 this is one reason why people wouldn't talk with each other. Fatima is now openly talking about (almost) everything. And because of that, she might have to leave the building because they are scared of her. She talks, and now she faces bad consequences for that.

[@trmartin6821]

But was mad and went off on Tabitha for not telling the outside world what was going on.

[@ahayahshouse5344]

They gonna bury Tillie in the green house and the plants start groeing lije crazy again!!!!😂😂😂😂

[@paularized1]

I think when Elgin asks the kimono lady “Is this really where it happens?” I think this is in reference to part of his dream he had right before he arrived and freaked out. And it’ll probably be something with Fatima because when he first learned of her pregnancy, it triggered his memory of the dream. There’s probably some crazy reveals coming for his still since he’s had such a unique connection to this place. Right from the start of his story when he had a seizure while the house collapsed.

[@amandamoore6789]

I think everyone saying this episode proves Tilly isn’t evil is speaking too soon. The way she said “you better run” felt soooo ominous. Obviously I could be wrong, but I’m not convinced otherwise yet.

[@july_inkz]

I’m sure Jasper will talk to only Jaden. then Jade will start losing his sense of reality and the season will end. Ofc big cliff hanger.

[@rachelbetteridge9384]

What I love about this Channel, and Emmanuel; is the community it has created. Someone can have a theory or an idea, and someone else will be like "ohhh yes i didnt think about that" or someone will say yes, and then add another bit to it. someone else can disagree and say they don't agree because of XYZ, and everyone is just so respectful of each other. Just sharing thoughts, and theories. No Arguing, just thoughtful conversation. And we get to continue our love of the show, the need for answers, and extend our watching pleasure in these reviews and comments. I love it. Thanks FROMaily.

[@A60PlusBlackLibrarian_Ed.D]

This episode scared the hell out of me!!! Can’t wait for episode 8! #FROM 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

[@aparksmusic]

What in earth in this episode was scary? Maybe Elgin going into the cellar with the knocking... nothing else, just filler, dragging the story along

[@puertogreekn8675]

Was it filler, or did it drag the story along? You statement is contradictory. It was not filler. The writer of the show said himself first and foremost this is a story about people, the rest is actually secondary. The real human expierence, is what makes this show really hit hard. Although, it does require some level of empathy to fully enjoy.

[@cwflet01]

"One of these days, we'll make you stay." - Victor's dad is the chained up old guy that gave Boyd "blood" CONFIRMED! I'm calling it.

[@BillyBong]

But what does that mean? It's just ANOTHER mystery.

[@Hannah-cm8cn]

My halloween costume this year was the boy in white. The fact that no one knew anything about this show at the party, I was pissed. I had to leave early, it's diabolical.

[@gaeouhgaeae]

😊

[@W33ND3X_W1LCOX]

As reasonable as Acosta is why not be like “Yo! First of all I wasnt just bustin’ off shots to bust off shots, 2nd I wasn’t aiming for the window! I was try’na get that one who was standing RIGHT IN FRONT OF THE WINDOW. THIRDLY, y’alls girl thought it’d be a good idea to run RIGHT TO THE WINDOW to peep an active shootout. So whos fault is it really?”

[@millymanning1536]

Love this channel so much! Everytime a “from” episode drops I watch it and come straight here. I love how you combine the seriousness of the show with your humour. Please keep them coming 👏

[@260DiNER0]

A lot of themes are running with reincarnation. Kenny’s convo about seeing both perspectives, Tabitha being Miranda but just at a different time it seems… even the idea of people dying and being replaced in the town with the same role.

[@mazzyt490]

Also to add, cicadas symbolise rebirth

[@SuperKurt1980]

Ok so Kimono corpse was a chosen one also and locked away because the inhabitants she lived with locked her away thinking she was hysterical.

[@FBAMaroon]

The guy who was dead looked like jaspers owner

[@toshebiabrown3927]

Yes I sgree

[@julianakleijn9254]

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO I LIKE THAT

[@bosshuxley4933]

Don’t remember him having a big beard ..

[@raquelmiketapia-mendoza4188]

​@@bosshuxley4933I noticed that as well.

[@bonterezramos2422]

That's why Tilly told her that she has to run because the town will be going after her like the village people going after Frankenstein. She needs to get out and run

[@jermainesmith2297]

The new police girl is gonna learn

[@Mrs.buildingblackwealth]

Exactly. Boyd is the reason the town is viable

[@Okbutwhythoalice]

I'm terrified they lose steam in the plot dept and give blonde her own arc. Hopefully the town will seize on her arrogance and get it over with, I hate when shows feel like they have to bring in a villain to keep things fresh and I'm REALLY hoping this is just a blip and they commit to answering at least something

[@andrewyb830]

I will say I enjoyed some of the conversations in this episode, "free will and fate" "adapt or die" and I can't help think back to the show theme song (Que Sera Sera) and if it also has meaning to the show.

[@yeahrightmyguy481]

That has to be one of the greatest theme songs to a series ever, The ominous creepy vibe it sets every episode is perfect

[@mzscott1985]

“Some day, We'll put it together and we'll get it undone Some day When your head is much lighter” These lyrics from Ooh Child stood out to me

[@whosewoods]

"now I've got beef with you" hahah I love your videos thank you for all the time and effort making this extra fun for the audience while we wait for the next episodes!

[@JajaPage]

Fatima has finally lost it

[@halfmoonstudiozpaint9960]

She gotta go

[@shawnkelleher5562]

Hey EMan, have you ever thought that nothing dragged Boyd and Sarah in the woods, instead it was just the woods moving around and shifting. Victor has always said that the woods move

[@wraith1701]

The last few episodes, I’ve been thinking, “Man; I know Fatima is going through it, but she kinda sucks lately.” This episode, it finally clicked. She’s not just under physical duress; she’s being transformed on a fundamental, spiritual level. I’m afraid she’s not going to make it through this ordeal 🙁

[@Calinotch06]

I'm so glad Julie called Randall out for tying up Donna.

[@yeahrightmyguy481]

Julie calls out everybody for everything lol

[@rubygr.4168]

Hands down the best commentary channel on this show, gonna have to watch some more of the content youve reviewed just so i can hear your commentary :)

[@alphablack5520]

The only way to prove Fatima is a monster or not is by putting her in the box. Also regarding the jukebox, is there a weird chance that maybe this thing is connected to the people who have died before? A weird relay of communication? A source of hope misinterpreted as a result of grief? When Tian died, the jukebox played the song Celebration, Kenny interpreted it as a jab at him, but is it not perhaps his mother communicating with him as someone who is celebrating being freed from the place? The same thing goes for the song in the beginning of the show, we gotta get out of this place, could have been another message relayed from the other side. Reminds me a lot of Frequency and how Bumblebee expressed himself on Transformers with music, a certain communication.

[@JermzGXIII]

I love your videos fr. They help my theorist brain and they also help me sleep. I swear you’re on repeat while I go to bed lol

[@7spidersofhh]

idk how this season ends but i know i would love to see another busload of people arrive with a completely different vibe. ive been wondering for a while: wouldnt some people prefer life in fromville to whatever they got going on in the real world? i mean say a prison transport bus ends up stuck in fromville. theres not gonna be too many prisoners on board that worried about making contact with the outside, and they would be already used to 'night out lights out' type of regimen. it would definitely spice things up in fromville

[@DreamerX08]

FATIMA is a gangster shanking an old woman dying of cancer. RANDALL being kind and giving Julie driving lessons.. Henry hitting the bottle again, just your typical day in Fromville.

[@Helennnnnnn____]

Your comment on bakta dinners were insane!!!! Yes baby, we be throwing down 😜😜

[@sabrinawalker1421]

OKAY so In season 1 ep 2 of from Ethan had a fever dream from the pain of the table and in the delirioum he said “I Saw the lake of tears, it was a drawing on the wall , there were so Many drawings in the wall . We were in the drawings. Somebody screamed because the spider came down from the ceiling” ITS SPIDERS!!!!! They told us in episode 1!

[@sabrinawalker1421]

Soooo based on the beard and the hair I think it’s the marine that was trapped in the cellar that Boyd found!

[@joerod2019]

Bro.....Spanish Harlem rolling with the Fromily...💪💯I enjoy your videos. Id like to repay you for the info with my theory. The man In all yellow who is in the show's opening credits will be Randall in the future. You can tell my the scar on the right side of his face + his big ass ears.

[@zeeshanshazi2567]

Here is what I think, The corpse which Elgin saw was of Victor. Victor is one of the monsters and he had forgotten that and I think he is the one who killed everyone on 1978 massacre...

[@tacrewgirl]

Ohhh. Good theory.

[@smootbeatz3060]

Lol the town got some good taste in music 🤣

[@lisasafay536]

Thank you for always adding the Fun to this show! I’m always smiling and laughing when watching your videos! Yes I agree with your 6 rating. I felt like some moments were slow and unnecessary! Why the long shot of Victor’s door while Henry was closing it?

[@tyronemiles4176]

Hats off to you sir!! You really broke this show down and I really appreciate it

[@tutorialslave]

So the overall theme of this episode would probably come out to being/feeling trapped: - Fatima's transformation - Elgin's journey to the cellar - Acosta's guilt - Ellis standing by his woman come hell or high water - Tabitha's past and potential fate - Randall (and Julie) being tethered to that torture dimension/the cicadas

[@SavageThrifter]

What if Victor isn't ACTUALLY victor? What if Victor died and someone else assumed his identity for whatever reason? I have no reason to suspect Victor but I've said this a million times. His name is VICTOR for a reason

[@Mrs.buildingblackwealth]

Jim is always like " f those kids'

[@zavielyoung8060]

The body that Elgin found was dressed the same way Jade was dressed when he first saw the symbol in the cellar. Blue and white vertical striped shirt, blue jeans, and a beard (albeit longer than Jade's in season 1). Connection???

[@Loret826]

I absolutely love your merchandise people always comment on it and ask what it is and that’s great word-of-mouth advertisement for the show and your channel.

[@charleswebsterjr.6350]

Eligin is more like "screw it, let me see what this lady wants, so she can leave me alone".

[@JoshRaymer-u3s]

I'm not surprised Acosta is going bad with the way everyone has treated her. No sane person would have believed what Tabitha was saying. And how would she know there's any difference between the monsters outside and the real people inside? When she saw Nicky in the windrow, Acosta thought she was a monster the same as the ones outside. She had no reason, at all, to believe otherwise. But she did make one idiotic, pretty unforgivable mistake. That was handcuffing Tabitha inside the ambulance. She already saw these monsters murder the EMTs. How could she possibly think that handcuffing a real person, making her vulnerable to these monsters, was a good idea?? That was her unforgivable error, and it led way more directly to Randall's situation than anything Boyd did.

[@thomaswillard6267]

Was Nicky shot intentionally? I thought she caught a stray.

[@Youraputa]

Exactly

[@JoshRaymer-u3s]

@@thomaswillard6267 looked intentional to me. When Nicky pulled the curtain back, Acosta looked up and shot her.

[@nunyabusiness3516]

I feel like it's Acosta's job to bring people back to Fromville. This is NOT the first ambulance to come into Fromville. It's the second Kenny and Kristi took parts from an older ambulance in season 1. Why did she handcuff Tabitha?

[@anonymousgirl4605]

I love Samantha's reasoning about Acosta's actions in episode 7. This wasn't my favorite episode, but I didn't see Tilly being killed off by Fatima! That was pretty shocking.

[@laned03]

I am going to reach just a bit. I had to scroll back to make sure before I open my mouth but the dead man dresses, and has long hair and beard, reminds me of Jade.

[@samantharenee9488]

Thank you for having integrity unlike some of the other From theory video KZbinrs and NOT passing off the spoiler leaks as your own theories! 🙏

[@LilWitch-7]

I'm so excited about the next episodes, I can't wait 👍

[@heathhunter24]

People need to realize two people can share scenes without being romantically involved. First Elgin, now Randall, can’t Julie just explore with people.. there are no other young ladies, and plenty or dudes.

[@medaherf9462]

That whole community needs to learn the buddy system

[@bosshuxley4933]

Btw Elgin said “is this where it happens” not - is this what happens, also Ellis said to Fatima “you’ve been acting wierd ever since that bus pulled up in town” this is around the time smiler was killed , I think the town needs to replace the monster with someone new and Fatima is the chosen one , and maybe that place Elgin found is where they will imprison Fatima perhaps .. or is Fatima gonna be put in the box & then not be killed by the monsters but actually joins them ….

[@SarcasmIsMySecondName]

Oh man you're so funny, so fun to watch! This show is so awesome and so complex at the same time that it makes spaghetti out of my brain 😂

[@ayeshaabid5152]

Since its turning into night (as we can recall Randall warning Julie about heading back since its gonna turn dark soon), i think Elis and Fatima might just leave Tillie out there and hope the monsters mutilate her before other people from colony house catch on to what happened

[@patricia2007]

“I can’t with this place, and these damn jukebox” 😂

[@trueblade3636]

15:11 all those questions and answers need to be written down, in a book or at a wall like Jim. So that the same questions wouldn't be asked twice or more. And maybe people could see patterns or other people can answers those questions.

[@christinet638]

There isn’t any paper.

[@trueblade3636]

@@christinet638 "at a wall" Doesn't need to be paper, if there is no paper

[@leluseven]

Tabitha and Jade are entering folie a deux. If you recall, before Abby went on her killing spree, she began to tell Ellis about a "dream she had as a little girl". This was a season ago and a small detail, but it's another hint that dreaming of the place beforehand is maybe not unusual or a sign of being "chosen" to free the ashy kids. I read the leaks from the rest of the season. Eh. I think this is a bluff with a mimetic twist, that will get thrown in our face again he end of next season, should the show get renewed. Throughout this series, the audience has been in the dark along with the town residents and leaders about what is going on there. I thought this was just a coincidence of art-imitating life, vice versa (mimesis), but I think there's also a piece of it happening with red herrings and manipulation, that the showrunners are trying to school us on. There are countless examples of the town's non-human entities manipulating human perception and using it to torture people. Randall and the cicadas. Sarah and the "Kill The Boy" worms. Boyd being able to enter the chamber only with the torch. The three that fell into the cicada coma. Perhaps Elgin and this Kimono Lady, too. Also it can be more subtle/emotional. The anger Boyd feels at Acosta feels totally out of character and out of proportion to what is happening. The anger in Fatima as whatever is growing grows. The emotional ups and downs with Kenny (Marielle coming back, the loss of his parents). The things the monsters now say, which clearly seem meant to rattle the town residents. Even that jukebox and it's pernicious song selections. It's emotional torture. It stands to reason that if something has the technology to keep people from seeing an exit and to hallucinate, manipulating human neuro-chemistry to make them angrier, sadder, more fearful is probably very easy for it. The dialogue from our "reason avatars" (Dead Tom and Jim in this instance) increasingly drops hints that symbols and signs found in visions should be viewed very critically. Dead Tom did everything short of laugh in Jade's face when he mentioned the bottle tree. Jim also mentioned the desire to find meaning will make people find it where there isn't any. Why put that in the dialogue if not to be like "oh btw, we will misdirect you. Just a heads up." Unfortunately, we do this as the audience, too. We take these writers at their word and find patterns which, while they almost always will uphold theories, never seem to give answers. Just a small example, saying the dream was "little Tabitha" when we don't have evidence of that. We saw a small, dark-haired child in colonial dress. I agree Tabitha was dreaming in first person, but I don't think we should take dreams and visions as a sign of "this is how you get out" or "this is why you are here". Also don't get me started on those ashy kids. I think Julie has their number more than Tabitha does. I think FROM's bad actors want Tabitha and Jade to release the children, because, just like the kimono lady, it wants to get out of the prison constructed for it. I know I am a broken record but I cannot understand the credulousness surrounding those kids. They only show up by the tunnels. Nothing good has ever come from those tunnels!

[@selexie]

You should make theory videos! I like your analysis and perspective.

[@nettadavis9384]

You are so funny! Would you please send Elgin one of your shirts? He never takes off that crow shirt😄

[@EmansReviews]

💀💀💀