FROM THEORY: Victor's Sister is ALIVE But Where Is She? | The Best Theories

[@EmansReviews]

What do you think about this theory? What do you think happened to Eloise?

[@marlinbush]

All the answers are hidden in the room of Victor's mom basement in the real world. Even the man in yellows portrait is there. Do a slow mo of all the pictures and you'll get all jr answers

[@JamesTTrott]

I agree with you but I think that she went to another group of people that came by boat rather than the cabin areas

[@ChemicalEngineer275]

Eloise is trapped into a pocket dimension like how Boyd got to the runes. She hasn't been able to scape. Maybe that town that's you mentioned with other people and the noise they hear is the noise from the other dimension like when Sara hears the music box but it was not in that dimension.

[@jessicawoodbridge8457]

@@EmansReviews I agree with Chemical Engineer 275 and that there is a pocket dimension within Fromville and that echoes of the people in that inner dimension, dragged the tent. I'm not sure how this will work though.

[@deer5647]

I think since Season 1 until the last scene with Julie in the forest, we were watching a retelling of the past. I think Julie is from the present day timeline, and she goes back to the past to story-walk her way into finding what really happened to her father who disappeared in the forest awhile ago. I bet in the opening of season 4, the townspeople will be aged or some have passed and some new ones have arrived. That's when I think we will see Eloise pop up as a new resident.

[@etmup80]

It’s not a coincidence that Victor stated 2x that Eloise “was really good at hiding.” That’s why it will pack the biggest punch & makes the most sense, that she’s still in Fromville!

[@jessicawoodbridge8457]

I think it's possible that Eloise is alive. I love the theory that there is another group of people out there.

[@ms.anthropik]

Watching Smiley RUN at Miranda is the only time I ever saw any of the monsters run at a victim. Interesting!

[@daebak_hana]

Good point!

[@deer5647]

In E-mans recent interview with 2 of the 3 writers, E-man asked this question. They replied, referencing what Kenny had told Acosta at the diner. The monsters can both walk and run. We see them walking because they know the humans only have limited places to hide, but they can run too. Smiley ran towards Miranda I believe because she was a direct threat of finding the faraway tree and escaping. But yes, it is confirmed the monsters all can both walk and run.

[@MGmirkin]

He really didn't want her making it into that tree... They never run, they don't need to, since they're the apex predators and their "prey" have nowhere to go/hide, so they can just slow-walk. Unless... There's something they can't control, or some way their prey can actually "get away." So, Smiley "broke character," reverted to his predatory Kujiraat form, and ran to get her quickly before she made it into the tree / safety.

[@pamelamurrell825]

As a person in her 50s, I'm going to have to speak up for Victor. Everyone keeps saying his memory is shaky. Victor is a 50 plus year old man who has been living in a traumatic situation since he was about 12. He isn't forgetful, but due to age and circumstances, he has forgotten a few things, which is normal.

[@EmansReviews]

Not to mention he's also on the spectrum

[@John-pj6iv]

@@EmansReviews Is he? That should have jumped out to me sooner either way. He definitely does give that vibe. I am not aware that is confirmed or implied for him in childhood. So I assumed it was the literal hell he had been through. He looks to be displaying generally proper emotion with his mom in the scene played. Being alone for that long at such a young age while the brain is still forming can screw you up. Coupled with extreme PTSD can explain his mannerisms.

[@grxzzly94]

@@John-pj6ivthat’s exactly what i said, he’s a product of his environment

[@tarabracey1186]

He had to hide by himself all those years ​@@John-pj6iv

[@deer5647]

I think at some point he will actually remember that his father, Henry, was with them all in Fromville at some point. Henry knows some secrets, but is not revealing them. He is not asking questions that someone who is new to this place would ask. He is not asking about Eloise either. So if thats true, he must have cut a deal of some sort to leave and return. But since he didn't return on his own accord, Miranda was sent to the real world to bring him back. again, Victor doesn't address it, like his sister Eloise, at first because the sense of abandonment is too traumatic. Maybe he had to sacrifice Eloise. Again, just a theory.

[@StreetDisciple86]

You're the From King From Now On lol. For real, though, so much respect. I feel like you're an extension of the show. Anything From related, i don't even think twice. It's Eman and then the rest just to hear other theories, easter eggs and such. You have the respect of the actors and show runners, and you're still building your brand. I have a feeling this show will gain more acclaimed due time and reporters, and such will be begging for interviews while you're already uploading them! Keep doing your thing Eman, you're the best!

[@EmansReviews]

Thank you so much 🙏🏿

[@spins321]

I think it's interesting Victor is starting to remember but Ethan is starting to forget.

[@muzikman183]

OoRah

[@ChemicalEngineer275]

Yeah Ethan is going to forget Jim. But I think even if they save the children the entity is going to ask for a sacrifice and that will have to be Ethan.

[@deer5647]

@@ChemicalEngineer275 How are they going to save the children if they are ghosts? They would have to time travel waaaay back to when the village was all humans and some entity convinced several parents immortality to sacrifice and kill their children.

[@spins321]

@@muzikman183 Semper Fi!

[@ChemicalEngineer275]

@@deer5647 actually I think they already sacrificed Thomas and if they decide to sacrifice Ethan even if they save the children Ethan will have the same luck as Thomas dies when born and his parents will not know why. They will not remember their past lives @e-man

[@WorldOfEnchantment44]

Don’t forget that Tabitha broke the glass leading to the outside of the lighthouse, but when we first see the inside of the light house, the inside glass surrounding the light itself was shattered. What happened there? Who broke that glass? And with all the food growing by the cabins, that certainly suggests people are still actively living there and taking care of the land. The noises were likely the people returning at dark and being spooked at not knowing what is inside their homes

[@lediarunnels4525]

You are one of my favorite FROM series videos on KZbin.

[@MerryGoWhirl]

I kinda have the same theory, I've been saying she did get to the bottle tree but was sent deeper into the woods and survived there, unable to get back to town I'd love to see another group of people, how they've been surviving, what kind of other creatures/monsters they had to face, etc..

[@Christine-kh2oo]

Another similarity to LOST....The others

[@SandraWarfield-n6i]

​​​I've noticed several things borrowed from LOST. The noise in the forest on From when Boyd and Sarah were in the tent sounded like a lighthouse foghorn to me.​What a lighthouse is doing in the middle of the woods makes me think about Victor's measurements of the trees' movements. Maybe everything has moved over time making other roadblocks in different places to get people into Fromville or another town like it. @@Christine-kh2oo😂 4:15

[@julianakleijn9254]

I was sooo excited when this one ended up being just you talking! I know you like Taran and you are so sweet to work with him but he literally drives me nuts. He is just sooooo self assured in like and “I’m smarter and I have all answers” kind of way. YOU make it FUN!! So I love your solo videos!! ❤❤

[@kheo]

Eloise is the author of the Cromonkle books

[@viciousbeauty]

Cover says Kay Dillon is the author

[@muzikman183]

THATS a great theory man! Personally, I dont think I could handle anymore additions to the Fromville Fromily man! lol Im so exhausted trying to look after and assess everyone we got now! lol

[@grit117]

Hey Emmanuel! I absolutely love your channel. It is definitely going to help me and my wife survive until season 4! I love your theories, interviews with the actors, and just how you deliver your content! Keep it up!!!👍

[@EmansReviews]

Thank you both so much! 🙏🏿

[@Shanannigan1]

One thing that makes me believe that Eloise is a story walker is that I think it explains the dogs. Victor has a drawing of a boy and girl with a German Shepheard, I think that it's a picture of them, and that the dog belongs to Eloise. She hasn't revealed herself, but she has sent the dog to aid at specific times. I can see your idea of another group working. It works well with my current prediction that the next season will start with a massacre, splitting everyone up into separate groups pushing them further into the forest. Part of my prediction for season 4 is that Eloise will reveal herself to save Victor, Ethan, and Julie during a bad situation. Then I think Eloise will help Julie understand and use her story walking abilities. I also think that Julie and Ethan won't be reunited with Tabitha until the very end of season 4, and that season 5 is when Julie learns of Jim's death and that's the moment she story walks to try saving him.

[@alexjung9724]

Damn this is a great theory. The dogs come out of nowhere just like the storywalkers. That could be eloises dog, and she’s living out in that abandoned village

[@Gnb496]

I think this is a good theory. Victor did say that Eloise was good at hiding so this is believable

[@Touffu1]

Another theory is what if eloise DID make it to the tree and DID go inside but because the tree was supposed to be for christopher or miranda it didn’t actually take her to the real world but another part of fromvill.

[@EmansReviews]

Very possible

[@becandteddy9585]

Thanks!

[@EmansReviews]

Thank you! 🙏🏿

[@BusketRVA]

I do love your theory E-Man. Well thought out and beautifully presented. I love the idea of another group out there too, Im just hoping that they will be given enough time and story to weave them together. My theory about Eloise is that yes she may have the StoryWalker ability and maybe she was captured and held captive by the Man in Yellow inorder to use her power. But I think I like your theory better honestly

[@adenijiadebayo870]

“Helped her father clear his throat” 💀

[@katherinemclean1448]

I almost choked on my drink. Lol

[@RickCosta]

I can't with you! LOL

[@weed3728]

He be catching me off guard with the jokes 😭 like whenever he says “ashy kids” 😂😂😂

[@MGmirkin]

I about choked on a burrito... I laughed way harder at that than I should have...

[@Insertuserr]

HI E-MANNNN 🎉🎉🎉!!! Thank you for posting -- I have been looking forward to this video •

[@zbt62]

HE-MANNNNN I been waiting for these type of videos!

[@melissamorris3573]

Hadn't considered it but I like the theory. Also makes me think of when Martin says to Boyd "I always thought the town was the worst part". Who knows, maybe alludes to him being from a different group/faction/what have you? My mind's swimming with new theories now. Love your videos!

[@shaymikes9141]

Eman we need you doing Silo + Severance review/ theories too 😩💯

[@andrewpayne5093]

There could be another group of people who went out so far into to the forest that they are away from any danger, but still stuck there. Remember it took a couple of days for Boyd and Sarah to reach the lighthouse.. they had to camp in the tent overnight plus walk most of the next day just reach it.. But what's further out then the lighthouse ? A group went so far out that they are away from danger and are just living there in hiding. The monsters don't come out during the day so this group would be so far out that the monsters wouldn't be able to reach them before the sun came up and the monsters can't find them and just stick close to the town. Eloise could be there and the 2 groups might end up meeting. I don't think there would be a second town with monsters ect. We found the monsters were cursed from the sacrifice and I doubt 2 different towns would be going through the same thing. I think it's just one town, but 2 groups of people

[@elderemo678]

I think that there is merit to the story walker thing. I don't feel like there needs to be too much thought into whether or not Eloise is Tabitha. One, that you mentioned, was that she said outright that she was Miranda. The only way that she could be Eloise after that would be if Tabitha was just mistaken and I don't think that's the case.

[@JayeKelz]

Great theory but if there is another village of folks in Fromville and Eloise has just been chilling safely all these years, we better get 3-4 more seasons. I need at least one season dedicated to Eloise and what she been doing all this time.

[@deer5647]

E-Man: Remember when we were told by the writers that there were a bunch of clues in Season 1? Its only after we get to the end of Season 3, and re-watch the episodes that things start to jump out at us because as new viewers, we were concentrating on watching the content, not looking for patterns or clues. One big clue I found is in EVERY episode of every season. It is in the prelude to every episode with the background music of "Que Cera Cera" is playing and we get flashes of bits and pieces of the town, and drawings. So, let me refer you to the "Skeleton Drawing" that flashes in the prelude. The skeleton is drawn in black crayon with areas of red crayon over a newspaper. So in Season 1, Episode 1, go to Timestamp 8:28. Pause. The image is only up for like 1.5 seconds. I have tried my best to read the words correctly and the ones I can not make out, I label "illegible". In it's totality, every word in that quick flash scene of the newspaper tells the story and it is VERY relevant to how the place was many moons ago. I won't spoil it for you all by deciphering the rest of the words, but in paragraph 2, the newspaper reads: "This prisoner's camp is hunted at night. Everybody drinks in that melody and begins reminiscent (mis-spelled) of the past where daughters, (illegible) mothers, companions and children choose one another through their saddening minds. Even the guard went to order the (illegible) outside to bed, stops and (illegible) it petrified, his (illegible) melted by a similar alm. Many of them (illegible), not care to sleep. Here and there they light candles and play cards. But the cattleman's corner is the deadliest (I am guessing "deadliest) spot....the copies constantly appear on the table and rapidly disappear. The prisoners (illegible) for cash...and under the guarantee...the prisoners...the next day....times the play is for the children..." What are your thoughts? Can you decipher more of the words?

[@aparsharma5335]

I don't understand anything you have just said but still for your efforts i will give you a like

[@deer5647]

@@aparsharma5335 thanks. I deciphered the whole thing - as much as I could with adjusting the color to read the words behind the black and red crayons. Basically, this newspaper is telling the story of the police vs. the prisoners, It makes reference to the ballarina, a sacred place, and how a community tries to deal with being prisoners. It references alot of things that are symbolic to what is now happening. The writers tucked away this gem for some idiot like me to try to enlarge photos of that picture & read the story. There are references to the gendarmies (which are a citizen military group that uses its force to keep others in line) They reference the Russian Ballard - which when googled, shows a pic of the white ballarina. I think you have to check it out for yourself to see what I mean. Clues are tucked in everywhere. I hope someone else gives it a shot in trying to decipher all the words.

[@AshusOddessy]

Good catch

[@rcollins4958]

@@deer5647 I like how you're thinking as I too believe the intro with music holds some major clues . One of course being all those damn crows. I will have to go back and watch closely. Thanks!

[@deer5647]

@@rcollins4958 You are welcome. I just now noticed that a few seconds later in the intro, after the skeleton drawing on newspaper, there is ANOTHER drawing on newspaper. Its a crayon drawing of a house, with the monster leaning over the top of a kids bed on the top floor. But it is drawn over another newspaper!!! It is readable if you take the hours and still pics and color alterations I made to those pics. I am tempted...but if someone else wants to check it out first, please, be my guest & report back. Thanks!

[@danielagh5716]

I think there are more people trapped in the other town, and Victor's sister will be there. They will be reunited again.

[@yvrmx]

Of course there is a group of people living there, they were the ones growing the vegetables and the dog and the farm animals that Boyd found in the woods and they use the statues/totems as the talismans

[@damientom]

My theory: Eloise was etheir killed as a scrifice and made an Angkooey child, or more likely, she was killed to prevent her from becoming an Angkooey child. The evil From villain needs the incarnations of Tabatha and Jade (Miranda and Christopher) to sacrifice their children to complete the orignal rite that created the monsters. The boy in white might have been trying to convince Christopher to kill Eloise and or Victor for ethier reason. This is why Miranda and Tabetha were spirited to Fromville with their children in the two cycles we know of. This is also why Tabetha and Jade arrived in Fromville on the same day. The man behind the curtain needs one or each of the reinarnated parents to sacrifice their children. Killing them saves them from the worser fate of an Angkooey sacrifice. I think the cicada plot hints to the purpose of the Angkooey ritual. Also, I spectulate if Thomas was assassinated by a story-walker, to spare him from being sacrificed too. This could explain why Victor has survived so long, the evil forces need him to be sacrificed and why the smily killed Miranda, because she may have killed Eloise when they wanted her sacrificed at the tower instead. Also, the Boy in white needs people to work it out themselves - he told Christopher directly, and plans went awry. Now the Boy in white needs them to work it out themselves and make their own decisions. Ethier way, Eloise is dead. So a better question is, is Eloise resting in peace, or is she an Angkooey? Edit: This might also be why Sara was tasked by rival forces to kill Ethan, so he couldn't be sacrificed.

[@justkim9827]

I think you're definitely on to something here. Remember Victor said that his mother told him and Eloise to hide "where Christopher couldn't find them"? I wonder why the kids would have to hide from Christopher, unless what you're speculating is actually the case, which would make sense. Christopher is the reincarnation of the original townsperson, who, with Miranda's original incarnation, went against the sacrifice and tried to save the children. If Christopher knew about his past life, which we presume the BIW told him, why would he want to now hurt children? Unless it boils down to becoming a sacrificed angkooey kid, or dying before that happens. OR, maybe Abby was right, and the only way out is to die and then wake up.

[@damientom]

@justkim9827 yeah. Also, Christopher got angry after that conversation with Jasper/the boy-in-white, and that could be why. Mirada and Tabetha want to free the Angkooey children, but they don't know what that will cost, and nor do we right now, too. I don't believe that Jade is being given the same incentives to free them. I am speculating that the dead men in his visions are his former incarnations, who may have taken their own lives, rather than allow themselves to harm the children with them in those earlier time periods, maybe - it's not a strong part of my theory right now.

[@damientom]

@@justkim9827 thank you.

[@1ndigo5oul83]

I agree with the theory. My daughter and I actually came up with the same theory when they first heard the footsteps outside of those cabins. I think Eloise may end up being like the Rousseau/Claire situation in Lost.

[@eddieterrell5457]

It's funny I've been yelling about Eloise all season but people were more concerned about who threw Boyd the rope😂and Tabitha WAS Miranda but it's funny because Miranda could play violin where Tabitha couldn't and had to have Jade play and ima go back a few videos my guy I jokingly said Eloise was the person walking around outside of those cabins... but you cool u can have it😂

[@megs4193]

She could have made it out and either ended up in a mental hospital being told it wasn't real. Or just wanting to forget not remembering her father, and to traumatised to let herself think about it. You'd have to think like a child. ❤❤❤.

[@The_Barefoot_Wrestler8824]

the boy in white is the one who has to let you out, even if you make it to the tree, so by canon she wouldn't have been able to just, jump into the tree and then, make it home. so any theory that she made it out is easy to deflate

[@edalove]

On the "you can't change a story once it's been told" thing and Julie throwing the rope, she was able to throw the rope because she threw it when Boyd was down there it already happened that way so that's the way it happens but something else that already happened, i.e. her father's death, if he wasn't already saved by her then she wasn't going to be able to change the story by saving him. At least that's how I understand time travel to typically work it's a paradoxical thing.

[@puertogreekn8675]

Thats incorrect, Julie already changed the past by throwing the rope.

[@edalove]

@@puertogreekn8675 but that wasn't changing the past that already happened. You are only able to do what you've already done since her father wasn't saved she can't save him since the rope was already thrown she could throw it. The story can only be changed as it's being told while it was being told is when she threw the rope but in the future her father is already dead so she couldn't go back and change the story by saving him.

[@Alchemic09]

Ngl La Brea straight up disregarded eyecolor 😂

[@megs4193]

5:05 she could be, she may have been helping manoeuvre things all this time. Or protecting victor ❤.

[@ronoakforest]

If Eloise is still alive, she didn't leave. the only exit we know about is at the top of the lighthouse and all the windows were intact until the boy in white pushed Tabitha out at the end of season 2. Bringing up the show Lost, Eloise could be like the French woman Rousseau. She lived by herself in the Jungle after everyone she knew was killed... bringing up Julie throwing the rope down to Boyd, she didn't change anything. the boy in white anticipated her arrival there. by having Sarah get Boyd into the farway tree, the boy in white placed Boyd at the bottom of the well where he was safe from worm infested Martin. Boyd can only get out if Julie throws down the rope. However, Julie can only show up if Boyd gets the worms from Martin and successfully destroys the music box. Martin can only tell Julie to throw down the rope if he puts 2 and 2 together for why she is there. He knew her but seemed confused when he squinted his eyes saying her name. what probably confused Martin was her appearance. he knows what "future Julie" looks like but not season 3 Julie. Basically the boy in white helped Julie become a story walker. Everything goes back to the boy in white's failure with Christopher in 1978. His current plan isn't to spoon feed people information like he did in the past. he told Victor you people need to learn for yourself this time. Anyway, like Nathan said a story walking can't change what has already happened in the story. That was the point at the end of the season 3 finale when Julie couldn’t stop her father’s death. Only after she comes to terms with the fact that she can’t change anything will she get on the correct course figuring out how she can work with Tabitha and Jade rescuing the souls of the children in the present. Although Tabitha and Jade now remember who they were, they probably don’t know everything, one of the reasons their past lives kept failing. Story walking Julie can fill in the gaps… Julie, Randall and Mari probably all have to work together. All 3 are spiritually connected to the ruins.

[@bonnieedens7869]

Nice theory!! I recently watched the very first episode for the third time, and saw the train tracks I forgot about. When the Matthews fam tries to find the highway, they drive across a train track 2 or 3 times and as far as I know, those are NEVER mentioned, shown, or talked about again. Where do the train tracks go?? 😐They could be like the road (the same few miles over and over again), or it could lead somewhere, like an entirely different community... 🤔 I mean; the road will lead you to the same town centre time and time again, but the tracks go in a very different direction.

[@McLovin-kg1if]

Plot twist Eloise did escape into the real world but did not want to reunite with her dad because her dad was part of a cult that was trying to sacrifice the children which is why Miranda ran away with Victor and Eloise in the first place but everybody ended up in the town anyways

[@veronicamaine3813]

I actually am pretty sure that Eloise is alive. Something I’ve notice about the bodies the monsters leave behind is that face as are always intact. I guess they need them to scream as long as possible. I was surprised when victor was unsure - because victim id has always been easy in the show.

[@stephaniehunter-morris3252]

I think your theory makes perfect since. I mean who could be growing that garden of veggies? The creatures? probably not! I have a few questions though, why did Sarah tell Boyd and Kenny, that she didn't think the boy in white was a little boy? Why is he dressed in white like an Angkooey child, when clearly he is not one of them? Also, why does he only speak to Victor and Christopher? He never spoke to Ethen, It's not clear if he ever actually spoke to Miranda, and he only used telepathy with communicating with Sarah. Last question why did he stop talking to Victor for all those years? I'm sorry but I have a really, really hard time buying that a young child was able to survive in such a hostile place for so long all alone. Which is another reason why I agree with your theory. There must be other people, and much more to this tale, and just like he forgot his little sister, maybe he has conveniently forgotten this other group as well.

[@busmonkey22]

❤ I love your videos!!!!! I like how you mentioned lost and how the others were the passengers from the back of the plane. Which made me think we know all the people in the town arrived by vehicles. but people have been coming into the from land for a long time like way before cars. Is it possible that Maybe there is a place or settlement that is full of people that arrive on foot arrive. (Missing hikers and what not , Tabatha was found on a hiking trail) And like you said if victors sister is alive and she did run deeper into the woods maybe that’s who she’s with. Also if the road always loops maybe there are only places you can get to by walking.

[@valardeeedeyosuri9851]

Love that theory so much, I had to subscribe!

[@dionsherman3824]

I also think Eloise is still alive but I think she is who was heard around the cottages.

[@EmansReviews]

You think she's climbing on roofs and walls? 👀

[@jarradclarke4895]

Another group makes sense… it would explain why there was a crop at the old shack village… they’re gonna be pissed when they go back to harvest.

[@swilliams23]

So many theorist saying there are other parts of the town but I don’t think I’ve heard that Eloise could be among them. Interesting and logical conclusion

[@debbieebbiebobebbie]

I have found over 30 same/similar names on LOST & FROM and another over 30 same items or situations… not a coincidence 🎉 Victor tells us Eloisebis the best at hide & seek and also that Sara’s house is her favorite. She definitely found an escape route from Sara’s basement to the settlement (or at least to the caves.) Eloise is our Danielle Rousseau. She grew those vegetables. She is the one who knocked (hehe.) There’s definitely another settlement though, imho, they will be indigenous Americans.

[@Christine-kh2oo]

Yeah there are many similarities between the two shows. It's interesting that both shows share the same producers and Harold perrineau who was highly under utilized in LOST.

[@KenLieck]

@@Christine-kh2oo And one of the LOST producers (Damon, IIRC) stated flat out that he was completely fine with the possibility that someone other than himself might produce a sequel/reboot of that show in ten years time or so.

[@raychell1979]

Love this theory E-man👏🏽. But I’m also concerned with WHY Miranda was afraid of Christopher? If they are the “2 ppl there from the beginning “ who tried to save the children, and Tabitha and Jade are “ them” in this cycle/life; does that mean Jade is going to change and be a threat like Christopher was? Also WHAT IS THE DOG?! 😂🧐

[@jasonrosa5268]

…definitely loving on ur theriies mutha!

[@Teeville1]

Nice theory!Can’t wait to find out.

[@Moon-pb3sp]

I think Eloise is the Komono woman, may be the reason why the night monsters never attacked Victor. She’s talk like Vic, w a little gray hair - yeah I’m 99% sure she’s the Komono Angel.

[@PizzyONLY]

Hell nah

[@ericbmnt39]

I feel dumb about my Tabitha theory. I must have looked away from the screen when they showed the picture of Eloise on Henry's wall. And I couldn't remember Henry ever mentioning her, so I theorized Victor never actually had a sister and Tabitha was found by Victor and his mom when they arrived in Fromville and Victor's mind altered his memory of her to look like his mom. Well that theory was obviously thrown in the trash after the season finale lol. Anyway, I definitely think Eloise is somewhere in the woods, possibly in another town in From World. New wild theory, she discovered the totems in the old settlement and saw they repelled the monsters and then created the talismans with markings representing the totems.

[@MGmirkin]

Henry did say "This is where my children slept. My son ... and my daughter." When he showed Tabitha their room.

[@Nothannahbruhk]

Random theory: Eloise escaped to the real world, but to an alternate timeline. When she came out of the tree, she was so traumatized she barely remembered getting adopted or being found after being escaped Fromville. Weird but maybe?? Haha

[@ronniecee2532]

Or she remembered everything told the authorities and they thought she was some crazy person and locked her up just like tabitha thought would happened to her.

[@800gaming-y2k]

I think she was the one who made the talismans and that’s how she survived and she left them there because she couldn’t find her way home hoping victor would find them but Boyd did

[@JonLeary]

Totally forgot that they didn’t explain the old village Ah!! Or the bear trap!

[@MGmirkin]

Settler's/Trapper's camp. Possibly Viking, or something else...? Dunno. Presumably some of the folks shown on the cave painting coming down the river with the tree across it. Thought they'd have to make camp briefly 'til they could find their way back home, but never made it back... So, just basic rustic settler / trapper cabins, not really meant for a long-term stay. But, presumably they had to "make do."

[@MikaHasFaith]

Ok...I've had wine. I love all things Emann and From. I'm such a fan...particularly all the recaps. However....I'm sorry to say that quite a few ppl were throwing around Eloise living in those house thingies. So unless I misunderstood the assignment (because of the wine...Prosecco btw)....I think that theory was tossed around. I can't quite remember what channel, but perhaps Screen Invaders,...not sure. But still...LOVE ALL THINGS EMANN/FROM. 🥂

[@EmansReviews]

Hey it's definitely possible. I can't say this is the most outlandish theory. 😅

[@simonrudd]

i think its possible the Eloise is still alive - the village has to be there for a reason - the "others" in lost were not the tail section, there were a few servivors who joined up with the rest but most of them ended up dying. The others were people bought in from Dharma and from the main land, with a smattering of people who were native. (if i remember correctly)

[@Hopeeey03_]

why is Henry still alive if the parallels between the Mathews family and victors family are true?

[@KaylasBestie]

Eman? This is why I 'ucks' with you and Anthony (The Movie Blog)! Theories that are based in somewhat reality. While also taking into effect it's a television show that wants to appeal to as big of a base as possible. This is a theory i can see/work it/accept. As a matter of fact, the more I let it marinate, the more I like it and hope this is the truth. And yes, you're the first person I've heard talk about this theory. Take care!!

[@CAlibanMan]

Second theory doesn’t make sense. We saw Tabitha as a child when she was in fromville. Doesn’t look anything like Eloise

[@mrmonar5]

Love the others theory! Just a note to take into account, the Others aren't the Tail end, they are the current island inhabitants made up of the followers of Jacob. But if it all parallels there could definitely be a lot more people and monsters or entities in FROMville.

[@likeluptid]

I have absolutely no doubt in my mind where Eloise is. I 1,000% know for a fact. She's dead. He expressed doubt of the body he buried only to illustrate how little of her was left. It is extremely difficult to confuse the very tiny body and bones of an 8-year old with the cadavers of adults strewn across town. Just a tiny patch of the clothing, or a tiny shoe that you immediately recognize on the tiny foot and leg is enough for you to distinguish your sister from everybody else in Town. He needed only a cigarette holder with jewelry in it to remember "Delores." He knows who his sister is. When Eloise went running for her mother, THAT is what she was interested in. No bottle trees, no hiding places (she LEFT her hiding place), no other places to live. She was looking for mommy. Even if a nightmare creature was standing next to the bottle tree, offering Eloise a genuine chance to escape, even insisting that she escape, and Eloise saw her mother's corpse nearby, Eloise was interested in her mom, not escape. She did not leave the safety for anything else except Mommy. And even if she did go through the Bottle Tree, it does not send a person home. Apparently, you have to be chosen just to get to the Tower so that you can save the spirits if the dead children there. Miranda would have gone to the Tower if she had gone through and found the children. Tabitha went to the Tower, but the Boy in White was there specifically to send her to no other place but Camden, Maine because he figured that it was "the only way" Miranda would awaken within her so that when he brings her back, and she was definitely coming back, she can complete her personal quest to save the children and end the cycle that keeps repeating. Eloise would not have gone to the tower. Even one of Jade's previous lives was killed after walking into a Faraway tree, evidently before he was ready to remember or save children; he was crushed by a boulder. Even if Eloise had made it to the real world, it is not possible to pick up such a thick Colombian accent. She already spoke English! Even every kid born to immigrants in the US can't pick up an foreign accent as thick as Tabitha's. Her accent is so thick that you KNOW FOR A FACT that she herself wasn't born in the US. She lived in Colombia at least the 1st 10 years of her life to have that accent. Eloise CAN'T BE Tabitha by any stretch of the imagination. Tabitha saw only a picture of the totems and IMMEDIATELY remembered a dream she used to have as a little girl of herself in a 19th Century lifetime. But the sight of Henry brought back nothing, neither did any of the pictures Eloise drew, Victor, or the rest of the Town. Tabitha gave no indication that she ever suffered amnesia. She is not Eloise. The nightmare creatures came within an inch, so to speak, of complete extinction. Literally, they were some 5 seconds away from Miranda ending them. That's when Smiley made a different move. In fact, all the nightmare creature made a different move that night. In a mad rage, they swept the town, finding every person exposed and hiding, and literally tore them apart in ways that we've not seen them do with anyone since. You can see little Victor taking an item from "Delores" and her body was ripped in half, the torso completely separated from her lower half. The nightmare creatures did not tear through every person hiding and running, but miss an 8-year-old who was unconcerned with hiding. That's 100% impossible. The ONLY reason they didn't get Victor is because Victor wasn't there. He was away from Town, hiding in the root cellar. And this is only a small part of how I definitely know that Eloise is 1,000% dead.

[@rorschach723]

Anyone also notice smiley running? Not once until that scene have we seen any of the monsters running… weird

[@count_anthony_de_orleans]

I think you on to something with Eloise theory. And that old interview with Scott gave easter egg, no one gets out of Fromville

[@MK-pt3iy]

Another group of people, probably a few generations old could also explain the food around the old houses and lake (also the animals Boyd found). Maybe they're descendants of the group that didn't become monsters and are under some kind of protection but still stuck in Fromville. Maybe as time goes by round and round they move further and further away from the town which might be the epicentre of evil. Maybe because this cycle is different, they recently moved hurriedly running away from something like the monsters suddenly having access to their protected area.

[@MarkHanna23]

I like that Eloise is a nod to lost

[@Midwest_Idiot]

When it killed Victor's mom it's the first time we saw one running too

[@JanetSnakehole28]

Maybe Eloise set up the bear traps. She's roaming around the woods, all battle scarred, necklace made of teeth, missing an eye, like a semi feral warrior princess. That'd be dope.

[@cosdnb7998]

yeah shes living at the village for sure, explains the footsteps outside the cabin at night and the food they found and the bear trap

[@LoveLeigh313]

I’ve heard that theory a few times since the episode where they found the food

[@SandraWarfield-n6i]

On LOST, the Hostiles were the first people on the island long before 815 ever crashed there.

[@owenbunny]

I love where you’re going and the parallel with Lost. But I watch Lost at least 2x a year start to finish. I have to correct you. The Others/Hostiles were not the Tailies. The Others were on the island all along. Even before Dharma. But Yes, I love your idea!

[@EmansReviews]

Thank you. I only watched some of season 1. Lol

[@SHIRLEI777]

I would hate if she’s been in that settlement all these decades away from Victor! And so close…

[@qlg8574]

Keep the videos coming, I just recommend your channel to person who just newly discovered From. Bless her heart, she is calling the monsters ghosts. 😂 As for Eloise, I believe she is still very much a live. Even though From is not logical , your theory is. I am over the Tabitha is Miranda/Eloise.

[@kellypack1995]

I truly am still hoping for an enter into the season twist w Tabitha either having a new vision or dream showing her tht she had only witnessed Miranda's death and the reason she felt super emotionally connected is because it's her mother as well because she's actually Eloise and had witnessed her mother's death by smiley by the tree or tht Eloise is in the tunnels w the monsters still they kept her jus like they had threatened Victor when he kept going down there and she's who had jasper and the other worldly possessions trying to make it reassemble her world. But I'm hoping most for the first. And it really still could b Clara because we NVR see her stay anywhere and she's always around for big events but then nowhere to b found and she's close to his age but def a lil younger and we don't know anything about her story so the monsters could've let her live as long as she promised to not say anything and report to them. So we'll see. It's prolly the last one. I hope for the first. But u NVR know

[@EmansReviews]

Please stay tuned for my next video. I think you'll really need to hear what's said

[@97Ant]

I think more people came to the town that never made it to the colony house but found a way to survive elsewhere. The townspeople were clueless of the settlement out in the woods, I don't doubt it's vice versa. Eloise more than likely tried to search for her brother but saw all the bodies and assumed everyone met their demise.

[@97Ant]

I think the people will notice that their food was taken, and Eloise will be amongst them. Could lead to a reunion.

[@evak8837]

I know Lost is an old tv show but i'd love some content on that and maybe in connection with from? with your style it would be great imo

[@tyrondacoleman2694]

Anything is possible. But if there are other ppl where have they been, or where do they live because Jim and Kenny were in the cabin overnight.

[@andrewpayne5093]

I think they would be so far in the forest that it would take a couple days to get there. Remember it took over a day for Boyd and Sarah to reach the lighthouse.. but what's further out then that ? Maybe a another town. The lighthouse could be the center point between the 2 towns.

[@EmansReviews]

Don't forget, the forest does move. So what used to be far away may not be anymore

[@tyrondacoleman2694]

Okay. I can see that

[@rcollins4958]

Definitely possible. Eloise is still there I believe as well.

[@LampDoesVideogame]

Now that we know Tabitha isn't Eloise, I don't think Eloise made it to the real world, either. But I also... Don't think she's alive? She's just alive hanging out in the forest for 40 years? I did read up that their physical ages didn't match up, she's like 10 years younger than him. You mentioned Tabitha is to Miranda as Jim is to Victor's dad and Ethan is to Victor, but that doesn't 100% track because... Thomas? Julie makes sense, Miranda had 2 kids prior, and that's kinda fine... But does this also mean that Jim is to Victor's dad is to the Man In Yellow what Ethan is to Victor is to the Boy In White?

[@JayneTheory]

I can buy her being Victor's sister. She looks close enough to Victor in age that if she returned to the real world without memories of her identity her adopted family could guess her being younger and she could continue her life thinking that she was.

[@EmansReviews]

But that wouldn't explain how she wouldn't recognize herself as a child in Henry's family pictures. Lost memory or not, you're gonna know what you looked like as a kid at least. 😅

[@julia8386]

Maybe Miranda put Eloise in the tree and possibly was heading back to get Victor when Smiley got to the tree first. Eloise could be in another part of Fromville, ie: she could be what Kenny, Jim, Kristi & Jade heard walking around in the old village where the totems are - it is possible Eloise made the totems? I think she would be a lady in her fifties and has made a life elsewhere because she doesn't know how to get back to the town - maybe the dogs are with her? I've always had the sense there is someone else or other people in the forest or in the outskirts of the town. The boy in white seems to know where the trees take you & I think he uses them to commute around Fromville.

[@Violet_Beauregard]

I think in season 2 the writers wanted us to believe Eloise had left Fromville the way Tabitha did and they would meet in the real world, only to show us Tabby actually met with Victor's father and there was no sign of Eloise. Now in season 3 they have purposely left the door open: is Eloise alive or dead then? And if she's survived where is she? My theories are: She is ALIVE and was taken by the evil forces (the creatures? The man in yellow? Another entity?) For some reason, maybe because they knew that Miranda would come back sooner or later and they're gonna need Eloise. That could explain why Victor was able to survive for all these years and without the talismans, somehow they were keeping them alive for when Miranda would come back. Also Eloise may have turned to the dark side, that could build up the tension with Victor and Tabby in the next seasons. She actually DEAD and just like Tabby and Jade she's come back as someone else. In this case I think Sara could be the reincarnation of Eloise (Ethan is my second option). That would explain why Sara has a strong connection with this place and she's one of the few people who can see or hear things. My idea is that people who have this ability is because they have already been there before and the more they come back, the more they remember or are connected to the power of that place. Also Sara is one of the few people who can see the boy in white, the others who have been able to see him so far are: Tabitha, Ethan, Victor and Christopher. I think there is a connection among the people who can see the boy in white, just like I thought there was a reason because only Tabitha and Jade could see the Anghkooey children. So if Sara is the reincarnation of Eloise, all the people who can see the boy in white would be connected thru Tabitha/Miranda. Also when Victor needed helped he turned to Sara and she was able to understand and help him, they way a sister would. This makes perfect sense to me, the idea of her being with another groupmof people could be interesting, but are they really going to intruduce a whole bunch of new characters with only (probably) 20 episodes to the end? Mmm, don't think so. I really hope they won't. We still have to figure out what's going on with Randall, Julie and Marielle, the kimono woman , the man in yellow... there's already too much going on!

[@VR-sd1hf]

I don't think she's found other people exactly. But she's definitely out there in another place we haven't seen yet. Maybe she's imprisoned. Maybe she's hiding. Maybe she's doing her own thing. But there's definitely something up with that whole family. We don't know how exactly Victor has survived forever. Heck, we don't even know whether him remebering her running after their mother is what happened in reality.

[@Trumpwins-i2g]

I think the same song that woke up everyone, woke up the yellow man also. I believe he is dead like the children. For some reason he needs Jim out of the way to accomplish his agenda with Jade and Tabitha. Remember he said they are not your children anymore. The yellow man needs his sacrifice completed, thus his ultimate goal of completely controlling Fromville and its residents. His life completely restored to his evil self, by completing the sacrifice. The kimono lady is a dark Faye, with which he has nade a very dark deal with. The boy in white is a good Faye and an opposing force to kimono lady. When the first settlers arrived she caused their crops to fail and they were starving, which made them vulnerable. The yellow man referred to the somg Jade played. He never held up his end of the deal with kimono because all the parents did not agree to sacrifice their children. Those that did got 1/2 of the promise. They live forever, but as monster's, till the deal is completed.

[@DylanNewman22]

THATS WHY HES THE GOAT! I LOVE this theory. A second group would be awesome but maybe hard to relate to the children / reincarnation stuff.

[@KenLieck]

The fact that we know where "her" grave is makes me wonder if at some point in the next season there might be an exhuming! Maybe they'll find... I don't know... Puppet parts or something...

[@CatherineBrown-n1r]

Maybe saving Elowise is key to the plot, think definitely more groups or old places they lived to stay

[@jasonrosa5268]

U kinda my favorite’fromilist!’

[@DaD88354]

Eloise is secretly the monster.

[@EmansReviews]

😦

[@OnwardToMail]

I know this video isn't about Lost, but you got some information wrong about it. The Others, and the Tailies (talk section survivors) in Lost aren't the same. The Others were a group of people that were followers of Mark Pellegrinos character (not saying the character name as I'm sure that would count as spoilers).

[@EmansReviews]

Thank you for the correction. I didn't make it that far into Lost. 😅

[@OnwardToMail]

@@EmansReviews Ah, it's understandable how that mistake happened. The tail section survivors were introduced in season 2 and The Others in season 3.

[@Mi_Pi]

I ❤ your theory!!!

[@viciousbeauty]

I think Eloise is a story walker using it to her advantage to hide. Maybe in season 4 Julie is going to meet her, and Eloise is going to teach her to hide in the stories. While doing so, I think Eloise will tell Julie all the parts of the story and how to hide in them. They will use that to show us flashbacks of the backstory. Eloise is too defeated to try to change the story since hiding in them has been her survival mechanism, but Julie is going to charge ahead and try to change the story leaving Eloise behind and I am going to guess in one of these instances getting Eloise killed by changing a story Eloise previously knew how to hide in but gets killed since Julie changed it. I also think that in season 4 we are going to find out there are a group of other people that control the monsters and their job is to make sure the story remains the same. These will likely be people that tricked the townsfolk to perform the ritual claiming immortality but not in the way they expected and the ritual was truly meant to somehow enhance the people controlling the monster townspeople. "This place doesnt give, it only takes." Which is why I think its not gonna be a new group of survivors but a new type of evil being. I think the Man in yellow may be what the spider represents in the kids stuff, trapping people in the wicked web he weaves. BUT after seeing the webs in the woods and stuff, I dont think so. I Doubt they would have a transforming man monster person. Doubt thats in their budget SFX wise lol.

[@medivyanshsingh]

5:30 😂😂no no i die laughing literally

[@cnb3552]

I think Tabitha was a writer in her past life and wrote the books that Ethan loves

[@ChemicalEngineer275]

Thanks ❤

[@kelvindoss513]

How would Eloise know about the massacre, if she never came back?

[@EmansReviews]

Maybe the massacre is just assumed given whatever was going on with Christopher... 🤷🏿‍♂️

[@Nisa2312]

I love your theory great minds think alike this would be dope to do. I thought the same thing.