#FROMMGM

[@skullscorp]

It's probably a melody. This is the answer. When you connect that Jade can play violin then it makes sense. 1 = C, 2 = D, 3 = E, 4 = F, 5 = G , 6 = A, 7 = B, 8 = C1, 9 = D1 and so on in next octaves... You get chords or notes from this.

[@geekademy]

Love it!

[@fireintheflesh]

That's different

[@berisilin1337]

It's a very nice theory, like in BSG (2004). So maybe Dead Tom is really meant to look like one of BSG Messengers :p . But why would they be groups of four? Is it always 4 notes in a chord?

[@danielleschiazza6172]

That's interesting.

[@davidagiel8130]

Numbers also represent vibrations

[@Lauren-dk6ex]

Now I get why Boyd’s wife thought everyone just needed to wake up because when she was a kid when she woke up from the dreams she had of fromville she was able to escape and get back to the real world.

[@marcellao1716]

I thought about Tabitha falling from the Lighthouse and how a fall like that would likely kill you. When she fell, she woke up in Maine. Maybe Boyd's wife was right??

[@lyly25lila65]

​​@@marcellao1716I'm not saying you're wrong but if that the case victor's mom won't be actually dead , and she would've came home but she didn't so daying doesn't bring you back home

[@JayneTheory]

@@lyly25lila65 maybe because if you die in the dream you stay dead, but if you wake... such as by falling, you survive.

[@lyly25lila65]

@@JayneTheory maybe but I hope it's not the plot I expect something bigger

[@FieryFlamingFajitas]

​@@JayneTheory so Nightmare On Elm Street

[@techwriter248]

Thank you for not basing your hypothesis about From based off of imaginations and nonsense like SOME commentators do. I appreciate the 'evidence based' clues, hints and theories. Count me in as a new subscriber.

[@LoRosa0224]

Fr I love that about his videos a lot of creators just pulling things from the air and swearing up and down it fits and every episode proves them wrong

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

@@LoRosa0224Yup! We are all parts of the entity’s game!

[@LarisaBayaMomo]

​@@LoRosa0224lol truth

[@احمدمنيرجبارطالبهندسةالتكييفوا]

I think that Fatima turns into a monster and there is evidence in the second season, episode 7, when Christie dissected Smiley, there was a wallet and a tooth. I think that when Smiley was human, he was in the same condition as Fatima now, and when he lost the tooth, he put it in his wallet. And let's not forget that Fatima also lost a tooth at the beginning of the third season episodes.

[@a_l_e_k_sandra]

Wow! I don't remember the wallet, but if you say so, good catch! I'm convinced now, after the ultrasound, that Fatima is turning into a monster. This tooth thing seals the theory.

[@berisilin1337]

I like where you are going with this. I thought that the tooth and wallet were some kind of trophee taken from his victims as we see him attracted by human items. But I agree it could very much be his.

[@LilDirtyX]

The Tooth Fairy?

[@lmdevaney]

Another thing I noticed was Victor telling Henry the story about the toy car and the women wanting to see her son smile. If that doesn't sound like the smiley monster. Remember when he went onto the bus and got behind the wheel and pretended to drive like either it was something and did or wanted to do? It could be the writers trying to throw a distraction but it does make one think.

[@Ash.Crow.Goddess]

It does! Good thinking. But Victor did say I guess her son died, too. I assumed because she never made it home to give it to her son. I wonder if Mrs. Davis was the monstor that said something to Victor in the cave.

[@lmdevaney]

@@Ash.Crow.Goddess I think the monsters are made using people memories. They may be people who died there or from the memories of people who have been there. Some act very childish too. Always talking about everything like it is a game of some sort.

[@nunyabusiness3516]

Wow! Great theory! The very first episode one of the monsters asks Julie if she remembers him.

[@p.a.u.v]

Its a good theorie! But It was Mrs. David who arrived to fromville, didnt her? Her son was at home

[@dpzhernandez4941]

Ohhhhhhh great connection 😮 !

[@kevins.2217]

Keep an eye on Marielle. I said it last week too. No reaction at all during the ultrasound. Confessed nothing to Randall about any suffering she's enduring (don't think she is suffering any personally). Wouldn't let Kenny go to the basement. There's something up with her I think.

[@danielleschiazza6172]

Nah. She is just always like that! She is always miserable and has no personality.

[@ananyaprakash8218]

True. She’s an addict. If that experience can make Julie smoke up, I bet she’s stealing supplies. Kristi doesn’t know cuz she is resting currently.

[@49poper]

@@ananyaprakash8218yeah she getting high af to block the noise. Don’t blame her

[@humanbeing3946]

Maybe she is kinda being in a stoned state? Too stoned to show any genuine reaction?

[@49poper]

@@humanbeing3946 she off the perkys

[@Justinian4all]

The backwards 2 and 7 can only be explained through music. When reading music you come across a backwards 2 and 7. It also explains why some numbers (or music notes) repeat. Henry’s mom wrote music notes for her future soul to remember and play the music to free the children and people of Fromville. Tabitha or Jade will have to play the notes on the violin.

[@Username1237]

what this Ocarina of time ? 😂

[@NessieJapan]

@@Username1237 Ocarina of From

[@playersloucoss]

Wtf are u smoking? Give me some. What a shit theory. Let’s keep simple

[@lukasrucys9198]

Can ONLY be explained. You had a thought and is has to be it

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Or if the person writing it has dyslexia.

[@SBzKillFrenzy]

Imagine if season 3 ended with the camera zooming in on Jasper face just for him to turn to the camera and say "You was expecting Slappy?" 😂

[@spoons250]

Slappy was a rip off of the movie Dead of Night from 1945. Rl Stein has said outright he ripped it off. Why is everyone acting like Goosebumps was a original? In dead of night, a person arrives at a house where they realize theyve have dreamed of every person there, At the end its revealed it was the ventriloquist controlling them like puppets.

[@SBzKillFrenzy]

@@spoons250For one, I was joking...wasn't meant to be taken even half way as serious as you're making it. 2 - I grew up on "Goosebumps" ..not 1945. Not really for the back and forth online. Have yourself a good night.

[@jammylynn4eva]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jammylynn4eva]

@Spoons Lol. Keep trying.

[@Ok.WhatsYourPoint_]

😂😂

[@benjimentv]

When Boyd told jade to stop talking in the bar scene I was so shocked I paused the show to rant the ONE THING they need to do is START TALKING im still wondering when is Boyd going to put together a research team. Also I’m still waiting for Ethan to tell jade that victor told him the trees are moving.

[@mahalia545]

Something odd that struck me about the scene between Donna and Tabitha was Donna’s emphasis on children / kids as opposed to using language like “family”: “Your children thought you were dead. They don’t need answers from you, they needed you back” “Don’t be a hero. Go spend time with your kids because you’re lucky to be here still.” Shortly after this, Tabitha sees the ankoohey children. Made me wonder if there’s some foreshadowing going on with the writing here…

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

I like how Tabby and Jim push they need to be with their kids, but Jim goes to the cabin all night and Tabby leaves Julie to smoke pot and Ethan totally alone to go talk to Donna. What hypocrites!

[@levilama]

The numbers are musical notes. If you play it in the right way you have the "Que Sera" song. It kills the monsters. Game Over.

[@geekademy]

🤣

[@jessn7034]

Tony Teflon has the musical note theory. He posted it and now all of a sudden everyone is posting the same as if y’all figured it out yourself. 😂😂

[@zeemeister1]

I disagree, if any tune is going to kill you it's a Beyonce song

[@medivyanshsingh]

@@zeemeister1 😂

[@Ready4Raw]

@@zeemeister1 not necessary

[@Stephaniefarrah]

Yesss! I've been waiting for you to drop all day!!!!!!💕 thank you. I knew it Fatima isn't pregnant. She's turning!!!!

[@dahl8753]

Me too😍

[@Stephaniefarrah]

@@dahl8753hes the best observer / from channel and I've been watching from since day 1. He catches thing's no one else notices.

[@rich1217]

@@dahl8753I’m sorry to hear you’re turning too 😢

[@dahl8753]

​@@rich1217at least I think I am 🤔🫠😱🤭🤣

[@KH-hs5xv]

Yup and she gave her that stuff to drink right?

[@weaponXwing]

Thomas is trying to get Jade to sober up so he can realize the numbers are music notes he needs to play violin...

[@Calinotch06]

Remember last episode, the voice on the phone told Jim, "they aren't your kids anymore."

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Childhood’s End.

[@phillylady]

The fact that Tabitha described her dreams as nightmares, tells me something in her dreams scared her. I do not believe she would be frightened by her mother in her dreams unless she’s repressing something traumatic about her mother. My guess is that this is some kind of Deja vu, or that she’s actually been there before.

[@Gabriela-zi1wl]

I think they are traumatic memories (she really was in from when she was a kid )that she forget but came back though her dreams

[@joannawinters6592]

There doesn't need to be a trauma to have a nightmare about parents tbh. I didn't have any particular trauma with my mother and had nightmares of her, because just like with the monsters in From who all represent very positive archetypes, one can hold fear of a positive archetype of a mother being evil. That's actually a widespread fear, hence why in folk tales that Grimm brother's tales are based on, it was a MOTHER not step-mother who was attacking snow white. There is an inherent fear in humanity of something innocent and good turning evil. That's why so many children in horrors, being shown as creepy.

[@szajkaninidanda]

I like the theory about two dimentions but I would like to propose other one. Whatever created the town created the pregnancy. There are cables no wires but there is electricity. So that tells us that whatever created houses is a child or not human - only with surface understanding of our world. That is why there is a sigh and a pool but not a motel. So there is a pregnancy, there are cravings and probably later on - bigger belly but no visible embrio on ultrasound - whatever is responsible just do not know about stuff like biology.

[@berisilin1337]

This is why they find patches of cabbages, because this is where little boys are born into! But yes everything screams child's POV in Fromville. If it's the case, it also means that Fromville self actualise everytime someone from outside is dragged in (remember Nathan's fear of cicadas).

[@miaandkylie1961]

This is really really really interesting!!

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Is everyone convinced the ultrasound just works in a place where electricity doesn’t have wires and no one knows where the water comes from? A place where the jukebox plays randomly? But the ultrasound would just read fine? What if the entity is messing with them or what is inside Fatima is taking her body over from her womb or maybe it is something supernatural that can’t be seen or an entity doesn’t want the Fromville residents to see?🎉

[@berisilin1337]

@@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396 I don't think anyone is convinced of anything at this point. It could be working or it could not be working. We don't know how it works but electric lamps do work (make believe maybe). But even if the ultrasound is not showing the right image, it would still be an interesting information. And you could ask the same thing about the pregnancy test, how are we sure it worked correctly and not displayed a positive result just to mess with people's mind? After all many things can cause a woman to not have her period among them starvation and stress.

[@xsabrie]

​@@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396what If the baby would be visible during night? Like monsters?

[@lisasafay536]

@18:00 Did you notice how the rock formation Donna made was similar to the anchoohey kids?

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

@@MF-ty2zn1or a cairn?

[@Smt_.x]

You’re the first person who came up with the same theory as my boyfriend and me! We thought the town and monsters had to have come from some type of curse caused by the sacrifice of children. We also noticed the monsters are child like. They take things from people, including their clothes, like they’re playing dress up. When Randal spoke about how they act at night he says one hums songs, one swings on the swing set, another dangles its feet by the pool. Very childish things to do.

[@Ash.Crow.Goddess]

😢It's not a fake out with young Tabitha screaming. It's her. She specifically said it was a recurring nightmare that she had. If she is terrified in the nightmare, then it isn't simply a game with mommy, or whatever. Also, I feel like the writers cheated us out of a guess. They did have her say she was never there, and she didn't remember it. Cheap shot.

[@Calinotch06]

I told Henry to stfu so many times, also, he could've stayed in the tunnel while Victor grabbed Jasper, there was no need for him to enter the room, he could see just fine from there. But no, he had to do a Tabitha and freak out from seeing a familiar item.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

@@MF-ty2zn1Was it Eloise’s voice?

[@Calinotch06]

@@MF-ty2zn1 I'm aware

[@kimhughes-anderson6350]

I'm curious that we have Kenny moving into Colony House and Randall into the clinic in the same episode. I don't think that's random and it will be important to the plot to have them "in place" by the end of the season

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

If anything, it creates a new dynamic.

[@rayadolaimi6300]

Guys why no one mentioned that when the kid in white pushed Tabitha out the light there was an already broken window around the light?? Does that mean Miranda made it out? Or what caused it?

[@danielleschiazza6172]

Victor found Miranda's body so she didn't make it out. He never found his sister's body. Henry told Tabitha that Miranda said that she was chosen to save the children and that many people were chosen before her! Now in the present, Tabitha is the chosen one! So, apparently, this process repeats over and over again over generations. Every time a chosen "savior" fails to save the children, a new one is chosen! So maybe a chosen one prior to Miranda was pushed out of the window of the lighthouse. I did wonder about the broken windows too.

[@rayadolaimi6300]

@@danielleschiazza6172 thank you for your explanation 🤍

[@danielleschiazza6172]

I don't think everyone had hope for a new life. They all seemed to be going through a stressful and even traumatizing time in their life. The Matthews lost a child and were facing divorce. Father Kahtri had beaten a Parrish member who had abused his son. Kenny had just been driving around with his mother looking for his demented father who had wandered off in the middle of the night. The woman whose son was sick and dying, had taken a trip to get him a toy car because she wanted his last days on earth to be happy. Mariel had been on her way to a rehab for drug addiction. Now, not everyone was necessarily going through something traumatic or stressful, but there are also people who had dreams about the pkace like Miranda, Tabitha, and even Elgin! Tilly said her tarot cards told her about that place before she arrived there. Boyd's wife had dreams about that place when she was a kid. Everyone there is there because the pkace or the being controlling the place chose them or was drawing them in.

[@angiemontoya957]

Elgin also dreamt of From before arriving that’s why he was so scared getting there.

[@johnlocke9437]

Miranda had prophetic visions of the place and drew it, Victor does exactly the same thing. As a child, he drew Boyd and the dog decades before he met them. I'd like to see Victors drawings and the stuff in the trunks of the abandoned cars. A lot of the players have little fragments of the puzzle, they really need to start pooling their data!

[@yeahrightmyguy481]

Victor has all the answers, he's just scared to remember

[@fromdowntown2963]

Igor!!!!!! My man! Been waiting on you to drop!

[@Costume_CO]

Hi Igor, this is the best FROM analysis channel. Cheers from Canada!

[@heathhorne8122]

Minor note but @18:54 I don't think Ethan heard the thudding. It seemed like only Tabitha heard it, Ethan didn't show any reaction to sounds from upstairs and seemed confused as to what Tabitha was hearing.

[@CrabtheCore]

Agreed

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

It’s probably Ethan freaking out at his parents being crazy again. Seems like a regular thing.

[@berisilin1337]

I think we should recap Clara's appearances in the scenes. If I remember well it's at least the second time she's there around the time when weird stuff happens. She's in the diner right before the table music box plays "Celebration" to mock Kenny, then now with Elgin. Also she's wearing almost exclusively a primary color.

[@berisilin1337]

​@@MF-ty2zn1 Thanks a lot for this list. Yes Clara comes from the same latin root "clarus" as "clair" and so probably as "clear". She's also the one who warns people that a storm coming from nowhere is coming when they build the tower on CH. It looks like her actions lead people to be where they need to be or do what they need to do. Maybe she an agent of influence to "assist" the story?

[@short_kingzz]

Jade is the audience trying to piece everything together lol

[@gwendolynbrown-white9230]

Did you notice that for the first time ever the monsters were making noises like they were in pain or something or like they were coming but there's no video of the monsters outside it's like they responded to Tabitha and her husband having an argument and it reminded me of when in previous episodes they said that monsters like it when they are fearful. Maybe this means something? 🤔

[@yubelwish]

They were getting a high off of their fear. This explains a bit why they had stopped screaming when they first found the talisman.

[@Gabriela-zi1wl]

Maybe then need people in fear ,and both are fearless while fighting

[@sudiptomandal7100]

The monsters were complaining...I mean I would too if I had to listen to the bickering of annoying couples whole night

[@crick152]

Hello, I have watched several of your videos and you are quickly becoming one of my favorites. You are very smart and put so much work into your videos. I appreciate all that you do and I can't wait to see your responses to the rest of this season and series. Keep up the amazing work, my friend 😀

[@dariusthomson9521]

What if "the girl who got away" keeps reincarnating and most recently its Tabitha? She was supposed to be sacrificed but she escaped and now her soul keeps reincarnating in an effort to free and save the other children

[@jes88sim]

Ya in a place like this, if I hear mystery thuds and walking upstairs...... Me and my son are GTFO as quickly as I can move 😂

[@ProfessorMystic]

One thing I've been wondering: Ethan already looks a lot older than he was in the beginning. If the series goes on another 2 or 3 seasons, he is going to be around 15. How are they going to handle that? The actual timeline of the show seems to be only about a few months at the most from the 1st episode.

[@cristristam9054]

Assuming the writers have all the META down really well and are not winging it at all, they could just shoot all his future scenes right now and just insert the scenes when their time comes.

[@accountnew7030]

they'll recast the actor like they did it with the boy in white. there's no other way to do it.

[@dougs7367]

@@accountnew7030 There's CGI and deepfake..

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

His voice was so little kid early on. 😊

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

@@accountnew7030You can kill him off. Happened with Yellowjackets! 😊

[@jes88sim]

4:40 in my mind thought. That poor guy had to film IN WINTER, in his lil T shirt and vest. My goodness what a champion. Poor thing had to be freezing.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

He’s a professional!

[@reg8439]

I actually think that’s why he is constantly cleaning the glass, because he’s freezing and if he were just standing there he would literally just be shivering like crazy…so give him something to do with his hands to keep him moving a bit.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

@ yup and glass is a recurring theme so also that!

[@SeanyCaufield]

Igor your deep dives are my favorite! You do such an amazing job with it! Thank you!

[@Mogorman87]

Someone needs to go into the caves with the camera and take a few pictures of the drawings on the wall.

[@miaandkylie1961]

@@mystikmusings5451this. This is my theory

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Someone needs to put that Polaroid to better use. Take photos of the bottle trees! The Farway trees! The cabin! The totems. Take it traveling with you! But no…just take photos of people who don’t want their photo taken!😊

[@berisilin1337]

I wish they'd use a phone in video recording mode and send it through a faraway tree to see what happens, or even plant it in the tunnels to spy on the monsters.

[@Tristarvis]

Somehow, that explanation at 41:38 seems like it can be used for the town if it was a spiritual place (in a dimensional bubble in between place) that people did pilgrimages to and that it got fed up with the people and became bad because people started taking and "moving things about" like bad guests so eventually it set up guardians (evil creature in the town, the other evil creatures might be other spiritual beings from the land, but outside town, and not related to the entity in town) because it was tired of hosting destructive/disrespectful guests. Maybe like a Native American sacred ground and colonists/pilgrims defiling the land kind of theme. It's capable of good like enhanced healing, giving them fresh livestock, etc but the bad actions of people (and maybe their thoughts?) made it so it's actually read their hopes and granting nightmares instead.

[@AnikoVargaMakeup]

Check the painting of the man in yellow suit again and compare the scar on his face to Randall’s 😉

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Or the guy pressed by the rock in the cave Jade sees. Very similar face too. 😊 But turned in a way the scar would be there on that side.

[@jeffreyarndt2066]

If you look closely at the clothes Tabitha is wearing in her childhood flashback they are not clothes from the 60s or 70s, which they should be. They are clothes from 100 years ago or more. She is wearing a cape, a longer dress and an apron, stockings and old button up shoes. This may be a memory from the colonial era. She maybe seeing the colonial era man with a skull.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Little Red Riding Tabby! I thought it was more a child’s interpretation of a fairy tale in her dream.

[@updatedwithnay2788]

I don’t think it’s Tabitha ..

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

@@updatedwithnay2788 70s fashion sometimes looked very pioneer!

[@ThePrimordialJunction]

Does anyone else feel like Randal, Julie, and Mariel all lived an alternate life while in the coma? I think the people in (from) could be trapped in a game. A contest between humanity and eldritch horrors in the style of H.P Lovecraft though with a new twist. The obsession the first two episodes have with Kennies dad playing chess, feels like a big hint. I imagine the victims are in an arena, and it is placed near Camden Maine. The light houses signal light has several broken lenses when Tabatha is there you can clearly see it. Maybe the broken lenses will each represent one loss for humanity. (Meaning all the contestants have been wiped-out, which is the opposition's goal. Giving the Eldrich horrors a victory point towards winning control of our reality. Meanwhile HUMANITY can score points towards a victory by achieving or fulfilling certain conditions. The Civil war soldier could be a clue pointing towards this being a war fought in a more civilized manner, where two side agree on rules and a playing field. Then compete for control of the real world. Also, the American civil war was fought with both side agreeing to line up and shoot each other as gentlemen and the battle tactics were similar to a chess game. I predict that the cicada will be a foreshadowing of famine, which will force the contestants through the bottle tree. Which they all know is a coin toss, but better then starving.

[@TheCromenockleFletch]

Just hope Tabitha doesn't end like the other lady that used to dream about Fromville as a kid.... Boyd's wife, Abby. Oh and by the way, I don't think Tabitha was dreaming, that was a memory of her as a kid.

[@patel271]

What if she’s victor sister? Just guessing 😅

[@BuJabra89]

​@@patel271we already saw his sister in flashbacks, not the same girl.

[@jennhack8043]

Thank you so much!❤ You have beautiful way of organising a lot of information. Have subscribed because you are so great❤

[@NakeshaMoore]

I’ve been looking forward to your upload. Your content is quite thorough.

[@jennhack8043]

Great asessment of Jim this episode...and everything else🎉

[@Calinotch06]

When Randall is carving the skull, the only thing I was thinking is (actually since season 1) "why don't they make more talisman?"

[@berisilin1337]

Because they are not sure why they work. Is it the carvings(they all are unique)? the type of stone? something inside?a ritual you do on them? Boyd found them only recently, and up until season 1 they didn't even know the talismans worked in a RV. So they could try things but who is going to die testing the theories?

[@Calinotch06]

@@berisilin1337 it's just like Walking Dead, Daryl is using his cross bow and nobody is making those metal arrows. I'm always wondering why isn't he making wooden arrows?

[@dahl8753]

Finally 😍🫶 thank you 🥰

[@anthonydelvecchio2588]

THEORY: At some point in the 1970s or 80s, Eloise went through the Faraway Tree and traveled back to around the 1500s. (Which is around the earliest time period etched into the lighthouse wall.) She lived her whole life there, fell pregnant after meeting a man that also ended up there or is organically from there. As an adult she gave birth to Tabitha and 2 other children (Possibly Abby and Christopher). Eloise had 3 large rocks painted red possibly representing each sibling for some type of spiritual symbolism or protection. Tabitha, in her youth, was more than likely hiding from someone when she went into a Faraway tree and was ejected from the dimensional bubble. (Either directly after going through the lighthouse or directly to the “real world”) After her “teleportation” she suffered memory loss (as either a side effect of time/dimensional travel or sustained injury) She was fostered and raised in the “real world”. In her adult life, she met Jim and gave birth to Julie and Ethan. She was then redirected by unknown forces of the dimensional bubble back to the dimensional bubble . (Possibly unfinished business involving the large red entity depicted in the cave drawings) EXTENSION OF THEORY*** Adult Eloise possibly went looking for her disappearing child/children multiple times, being ejected and directed back by the dimensional bubble repeatedly, ending up in random time periods each time. Each time walking through the light house prior to exiting, she would etch the year she had traveled from on the wall as a way to document and attempt to predict a pattern or rule out the time periods she was unable to locate her children. *** This would make Victor Tabitha’s Uncle. Miranda and Henry are Tabitha’s grand parents. If Abby is the other sibling, Elis is related to Tabitha. Possibly every trapped person is linked to 1 common ancestor. If this is all correct, the entity/bubble dimension is luring and trapping 1 family’s lineage as a result of some form of vendetta or unfinished business. THEY ALL COME “FROM” A COMMON ANCESTOR. 🤯 (See what I did there?) I enjoy puzzles and theorising. Don’t condemn me for having some fun with this one. 🙃 Additionally- There is one bracelet involved in a bootstrap paradox where it was left at the hospital by adult Tabitha as well as In the dimensional bubble by Miranda then also moved through time by young Eloise and brought back once again by young Tabitha. Possibly picked up by older Eloise or someone at the hospital on the day Julie was born and evidently re-returned to the diner. I believe Jim will go through time and sometime before everyone gets there leave the bracelet once again. ?? Mind bending. ***Only people connected to the lineage will be transported safely through the faraway trees or if using the faraway bottle tree, to the lighthouse. For example: Faraway bottle tree to lighthouse - Julie, Ethan, Abby, Ellis, Victor, Henry. Faraway bottle into pool concrete or elsewhere 😜- Evidently Dale, Boyd and any else not sharing a blood line with Eloise and was transported as a result of sharing transportation with a blood line relative.

[@MarilynVision13]

Great theory

[@carlie-10]

I was thinking the bottle with the written numbers on paper is a copy of the original. Like Miranda copied the one from the park. The one with the numbers written in bark or whatever it is, is the original in from. If it’s like an upside down world or parallel then maybe Maine is here but not. Like it’s in the same place as from but you can’t see it. Abit like silent hill. When he goes to the house at the end and the woman and kid are not there but are there lol. Great video as always been waiting all day.

[@humanbeing3946]

Wow, your subscribers have increased so quickly in just few hours 🎉 When I started to view this video just few hours earlier, the number of subscribers was at around 4.6k. Now already surpassed 5k 😃

[@geekademy]

It was 4.9 yesterday:)

[@humanbeing3946]

​Oh, my mistake😅 I probably wrongly looked at the actual number. But regardless, congratulations, keep up the great work ​@@geekademy

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

So is the power of “The From”!

[@reruddock]

The numbers represent notes for the Mariah Carey song "All I Want for Christmas is You". It needs to be played repeatedly, over and over, without end... like it is EVERY holiday season. The monsters will become so annoyed their heads will explode, killing them, and the people of Fromville will be set free.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

I thought it was “Who Let The Dogs Out?” 😃

[@brelee2723]

Maybe the numbers in the bottles are the codes for song titles, on the jukeboxes in the diner? It seems clear at this point, the songs that suddenly start playing on the jukebox, are not random- they're played at specific times, in the presence of specific people, seemingly for a reason. Whether that reason is just to f with the residents, or to simply find a way to communicate with them, remains to be seen. Either way, it seems very likely that the bottles/ numbers & the jukebox songs(or song titles?) that are selected /played for certain people, are both being used as some form of communication between groups..

[@ozyris859]

@Geekademy There are synopsis leaked for episodes 6, 7 and 8 of season 3. Episode 6 was exactly like it was described in its synopsis. Everything makes sense now.

[@Kb-gh2rk]

Where can you find them?

[@OkayOkOkay]

What if the bottle tree’s numbers are actually phone numbers that need to be dialed from the phones in the houses. It could make sense since the phones have been making many appearances in recent episodes

[@AnnabelTheGoldsmith]

Ooh wasnt expecting this so soon! Hoozar!

[@highhopeshomestead2678]

This business with the bottle tree numbers is making me think of the zodiac killer and his coded message.

[@ChannieBoo3]

“This is why the monsters are so childish” 😂😂😂😂 your commentary is great

[@MollsMollica]

I think Miranda was experimenting with the faraway tree by going in and marking where the tree took her and giving it a numeric number. When she got back to the tree she put the number in a bottle to program the tree. When she needed to go to a destination all she had to do is think about it and the number was there.

[@televisionhero475]

So a counter point to her phantom pregnancy that falls more in line with her turning into a “Smiley” is that her lack of menstruation, teeth falling out and desire to eaten rotten foods and consume the blood of others is really pointing towards the turning into a smiley. We know they were either once human or very similar anatomy wise to humans. I guarantee this season ends with her transforming into a Smiley and taking out Ellis as the “Town’s” goal to break Boyd.

[@rudeasmith5098]

That torch is going to show that building Henry said was missing in town if they realize they need to light it up.

[@yupitsme9713]

Why don't they get Victor when he's in the tunnels? The dimension theory is completely believable. There are also 2 bottle trees in Maine, whats the link?

[@SandraMartinez-kt1zd]

OMG!! The trees are the symbols on the talismans. It’s the same rune looking symbol. There is a connection to the talismans.

[@danielabianchi851]

In the Viktor's trailer, when we see the map of Fromville, did you notice that what is supposed to be trees (representing the forest) is actually the strange rune symbol that is also encarved on the talismans?

[@downtoearthproductions]

"Hey Fatima. Did the baby even exist" - Tony Soprano😂😂😂

[@gellieenverga1580]

The monster with the purse, she is not there when victor and henry came and then suddenly she's there! 😅

[@yupitsme9713]

9555 could be 9/5/55 = September 5, 1955. Jade called them dates & numbers.

[@yupitsme9713]

I had to come back and mention the use of the word dates vs. years. Jade did not refer to them as years.

[@TipToe71]

That’s what I was thinking

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Or the European way, which would be May 9th, 1955.

[@berisilin1337]

05:38 Dead Tom (Messenger Tom) is using reverse psychology to provoke a reaction. 13:10 It really depends on when you start the year "0". Not all communities have the same calendar system, for the Chinese it's year 4722. 24:15 In this frame she looks genuinely worried or scared, not just faking scared for a laugh. 36:12 Like I was saying on a previous video, there are conditions that could lead to a false positive on a pregnancy test, some very serious. What is bothering me in this video is that two health professionnals don't even think to check with the ultrasound for an ectopic pregnancy, which would potentially be fatal condition and that explains a positive test with an empty uterus. The false positive It could also be explained by Schröedinger 's Fatima theory : she's pregnant and not at the same time but when you observe her uterus she's not. 48:10 To me one of the creepiest moment of this episode. Also it implies that they are well aware of what is happening in the day in the tunnels, they "let" Victor survive. Maybe they did all theses years. But also it means that they physically can't or are not allowed to go out in the day, and not because they are asleep. Or is it maybe because monsters only come out at night in children's books? 49:06 I think it's not the first time that a character was interrupted when they were just about to reveal something.

[@kimhughes-anderson6350]

The positive pregnancy test had me thinking Fatima might have a gynaecological cancer, meanwhile Tilly is hanging around her and looking pretty spry

[@berisilin1337]

@@kimhughes-anderson6350 I'm not sure how they could test for it in Fromville. Would it explain the pica though?

[@kimhughes-anderson6350]

@@berisilin1337 I'm a nurse, not a midwife but as far as I know pica is usually triggered by a mineral deficiency. So eating things like chalk, charcoal, egg shells and even paper makes sense in that context. I don't think craving rotting veg is pica. Like you, I can't help but think of the reasons Fatima's test might be positive. I also doubt that Kristie as a third year med student has enough experience to do an accurate ultrasound in early pregnancy. I like your thinking about the ectopic pregnancy, but usual symptom is early and severe pain. Apart from the "obvious" Fatima-is-turning possibility, I wouldn't be surprised if the town/entity is messing with her. Once the story gets out the colony house crew will turn on her and want to cast her out or kill her. Imagine if they did then found out they were wrong.

[@berisilin1337]

@@kimhughes-anderson6350 thanks for the medical precisions. If it's the entity messing with Fatima (the kid topic is sensitive for her because she said she couldn't have kids) then there is another entity who tries to protect her (by supplying rotten food and medical staff and tools).

[@washedgioggy3999]

Support from italy❤❤

[@dougs7367]

29:40 The seven stones are probably the ones in a circle that the angkooey children are laying on, facing up to the tree roots in the opening of the cave ceiling

[@joannawinters6592]

The fact that they have dreams about it and saw it after LSD makes me think that my theory that this is collective unconscious may be valid.

[@etmup80]

Did Fatima actually take a pregnancy test? Because I’m pretty sure she just asked for one, but we never saw if Kristy even had any.

[@madamesherice]

What I think is interesting about Randall whittling one of those talisman looking heads at the village is -when did he see them? While taken over by the cicadas? I miss things sometimes so I am genuinely curious. I’ve rewatched so many times since season 1 came out, but still. There’s so much to see!!

[@camryncarriere4543]

i have never loved an artist more

[@FromilyTheory]

Great breakdown Igor 🔥🔥

[@ameninaquequerialer]

I keep thinking about what victor said, “I didn’t know if it was a dream or if it was real” something along these lines. Tabatha said she kept having the same nightmare over and over, but it could be a memory.

[@kbhs0008]

i think tillie knows something about fromland she said she had 4 children and 7 grandchildren there are 7 anghkoey kids and in the drawing from the cave 7 sacrificial stones she was also happy and dancing when she arrived in fromland

[@marioenrique1743]

yeah that biih knows someyhing fr.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Tillie the Shaman!

[@shaunanahodil8686]

A few episodes ago what's a bracelet is when I came to the conclusion that Tabitha is Victor's sister and just with this last episode and her saying about having nightmares of the rocks in those voodoo figurines when she was a little girl I believe Tabitha is Victor's sister❤

[@patel271]

I was screaming she’s a victor sister..when she said she’s saw this place in dream , but it’s her memories

[@LoRosa0224]

Unless reincarnated there is no other evidence or proof of them being the same person. All the connections between Tabitha and victors mom are because they are chosen ones to save the children. There is nothing other than that connecting Tabitha with Miranda and nothing connecting her to Eloise.

[@davidagiel8130]

The numbers are not music. They are vibrations. Look up frequency sounds and ancient numbers. Ancient cultures either figured it out or theorised about some crazy stuff. Crazy stuff directly related to the nature of From with there being two worlds and the idea of harnessing energies by attaching Ancient numbers to structures or within the dimensions of the structure.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Astral (Star) Magic.

[@davidagiel8130]

@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396 yes, and there is something significant about two bottle trees with the same numbers, like two tuning forks at the same frequency.

[@tikochibara]

Nobody(characters) thinks about " if you go forward on fallen tree what will happen "

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Or if they just run into the woods.

[@berisilin1337]

Afaik the only one who could have done that was Tabitha because she is the only one who had the knowledge of what happens when you see the fallen tree AND the opportunity to do so, because people don't see the tree again once they turn back on the road and lose sight of the tree.

[@ananyaprakash8218]

Been waiting for your video

[@lavarstubbs3537]

I just realized victor drew a picture of the spider!!! Why doesnt Tabitha, Donna n Boyd make victor tell them everything!!!

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Main problem with the show!

[@yeahrightmyguy481]

Cause he always runs off, he never wants to talk about shit, he's the most valuable and useless character at the same time lol

[@TipToe71]

Idk if the kids were walking around the village bc everyone heard the noise but in the house only Tabitha heard it. Ethan didn’t hear anything

[@TheZoraPlan]

My thing with the married couple is that people say Jim this Jim that. Yes he’s not an amazing father, but let’s not forget the same goes for Tabitha. Even when she’s there, she’s not having a heart to heart with Julie or Ethan she’s too busy on her adventure, and in my opinion that kinda proves Jim right when he says she’s a coward that runs away. She’s so focused on freeing the dusty kids that she hasn’t realized the kids that need to be freed is her own kids that were help prisoners to adults that were too selfish and abandoned their kids in their own way

[@yeahrightmyguy481]

She's a dick, Jim literally defended her against everyone in the town at the meeting in the diner, tried to comfort her while she was beating herself up for not doing more while she was free and what does she do in return? Calls him weak for not being honest about the fact that SHES A PIECE OF SHIT PERSON. typical relationships really, women exaggerating our red flags while we try our hardest to ignore theirs.

[@luissantiago5129]

I feel like so much yet so little has happened in these last 2 episodes. I’m impatient and want more answers we only have 4 episodes left this season. And who knows if we’re getting a season 4 because it’s on such an obscure streaming platform.

[@digsbious]

I am right there with ya bro. I really hope this series does not get cancelled.

[@dariusthomson9521]

It turns your fears into reality. The townspeople manifest their own nightmares via group consciousness.

[@lovelyki1091]

That’s a good idea

[@yeahrightmyguy481]

I bet the aghnkooey kids were sacrificed there and their biggest fears were then adults acting nice but doing evil, thus creating the from monsters

[@JR-bm8dl]

My mind has been working overtime with this show. I dreamed the original settlers wanted to be immortal so they did a ritual sacrifice with the children. This created a pocket universe and turned all the people in the town into trees which almost live forever. They draw people to them, hoping to be released. There was no real explanation of the monsters other than they were previous residents. I am only sharing this because I thought it was interesting, not that I think it is the answer. Wait, I am dreaming about Fromville like Tabitha! Have I been chosen?! 😵‍💫

[@berisilin1337]

I know what you mean, lately I had a wtf moment when I was speaking to a lady and then noticed she was wearing a infinity symbol trinket on her necklace.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Yes. Find the nearest tree with a hole in it.

[@brianramm2020]

Could Tom cleaning the glass be symbolsm for jade to clean his mind from alcohal?

[@johndillon92]

Go back to when Tabitha woke up in the Hospital when she looked out of the window this little girls reflection was there a lot of people missed that.

[@empreor61601]

Went back and watched S2e10 and S3e01, I see no little girl just Tabitha's exact reflection as an adult, am I missing something?

[@KH-hs5xv]

There was a little girl's reflection....it was probably her in the past....

[@LoRosa0224]

​@@empreor61601i watched it a few times and even looked at videos of people claiming that but I never saw anything different it was always Tabithas adult reflection

[@empreor61601]

@@LoRosa0224 Yea I think it’s just people looking TOO hard and tricking themselves into seeing what they want to see, can’t blame them though this show is great and anything that gets you to actively think is better than most media nowadays

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

The reflection looks like a blonde haired female though. But a fuller face, like a child.

[@E5PY]

You are the first theorist I have heard. Mention the einstein podolsky, Rosen paradox. THANK YOU!

[@E5PY]

It is not entirely science fiction. If you look up those 3 names you will find a book that thry published suggesting reality is more than we currently understand based off of quantum mechanics.

[@lmdevaney]

I can't help but think Victor is one of them in some way. The way the women said to him that if he keeps coming down there he would have to stay. Sound like they allow him to stay in the town.

[@danielleschiazza6172]

No. I think they just let him slide sometimes because for so long, he just accepted his life there. Remember he told Jade that "this is my home!" When Jade was trying to get answers out of him about the symbol. Jade said, "Don't u want to go home?" Victor said no! That's his home! He understands how everything works there and what will make the place "angry" and he avoided getting it angry. He basically played by the rules for 40 years! So I think they kind of let him be until now. Now he is trying to find answers and they don't like that.

[@Marmalady-s6f]

Какой труд вы продлеваете,спасибо большое вам ❤

[@berisilin1337]

Maybe the numbers are a distance from the faraway tree, but you need the number from the other bottle tree to have an intersection point and this is where you land. Which number/distance is used could depend on the time(maybe that's why the times on the clocks are messed up) you enter the faraway tree. This could explain why Victor think it's bad that the trees are moving, it means that the travel through faraway trees is less reliable since the distances change. I wonder if the drawing of the tree is correct, I mean are the bottles all aligned like that? Jade might doing the same mistake he was doing with the root symbol, he was looking at it vertically and not horizontally.

[@thenewwatchersonthewall]

Nice content.

[@s.devries4349]

"They like to take things sometimes" , ( same as Jim take stuff from Kenny house)

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

Fairies?

[@s.devries4349]

@@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396 Maybe Gnome O_o

[@crimetimeAU]

I'm thinking that the woman who's haunting Eljin might be Victor's mother. I could picture her looking like that and wearing a kimono because she's artistic.

[@wildmarjoramdieselpunk6396]

She could really be anyone at this point…even Fatima. 🤷‍♀️

[@ramirorodriguez9953]

He giving him a perspective to look at why the bottles were put there

[@DeepRootedwithTulani]

I think that was just Tom being Tom. He was already skeptical about the tower going onto colony house. I think he was just a pessimist but generally wanted them to succeed.

[@kaylen6302]

I can’t say what I think the thudding is outside the shack but I believe it is the same thing that was walking around Boyd’s tent and it was moved to the lighthouse. But now it’s walking around as it can’t move the shack.

[@vinacar]

the numbers are to move in to the 5th dimension time is the 4th how we understand but cant use it yet but with all the points in time and location from there you can move back into the 3rd dimension. The path the kids lead Tabitha on an exact path to get her out and then lead her to Vic's dad which put her on another path to go back.