Fun AND Difficult Challenge? (Every item is PER floor)

[@chillrendbeats]

This challenge is super cool! You should totally do more of this.

[@LestFrog]

Yes! but with the passive item thingy so at least there are more chances of stacking stuff

[@LiviRivi]

This was SO much more interesting than the usual "every item is" videos. Having some variety is a lot more fun.

[@erikakerboom2101]

If every item was different it would add a lot of variety maybe that would be a cool challenge

[@YoursTrulyGarbage]

Damn, that comeback. The boney friends sacrifices were not in vain. This challenge format definitely has big potential for the future.

[@lucatdcat8720]

Love these kinds of comments, not just because of the donation. It gives me incentive to keep watching because you mentioned a great moment but didn't spoil it

[@notchillstorm]

Crazy-good comeback.

[@magdziatoja]

@@lucatdcat8720Same here! It's actually the best way to comment imo hahah

[@OryXity]

big potential if it was passives only, active items dont work for "every item is" runs

[@cloak7863]

I would like to see a passive version of this ,this challenge seems super fun!

[@EvilWillow123123]

Idk if someone already explained it but for anyone wondering around 23:00, the reverse fool turned the 99 pennies into quarters instead of a dollar because technically a dollar gives 100 pennies. You can see that when you got deep pockets and get a dollar :)

[@Godseyyy]

This is going to be slightly convoluted, but you should: 1. Do only passive items for this 2. Any time you roll a passive that doesn't stack, you must take that item 3. After taking the non-stacking passive, you reroll for a new item 4. Regardless of if the item stacks or not, you must take the item if it spawns Hopefully this sounds like a fun challenge you want to try out! :)

[@duck13x76]

The only big issue I see with this is that it can be hard to tell which items will or won't stack other than that yea sounds dope

[@depalodor]

this feels like CHaos with extra steps tbh

[@Godseyyy]

@duck13x76 most are pretty self-explanatory (effects can only happen once) and the others are covered in the wiki (surprised he never referenced it in this video)

[@Meister_Wiku]

Wouldn't mind a few episodes more of this.

[@jaguarrampage7306]

15:10 for doing it with passives you could probably do something like this: Changing floor ---> Clear list "A" Changing floor (after 0.01 seconds) ---> spawn random passive item (labeled with B) Things labeled with B (after 0.02 seconds) ---> add to list "A" All Items (labeled with "B") --(replace)--> Smoke puff All items (not labeled with "C") --(replace)--> Things in list "A" (add label "C") Hope this works!

[@randomyoutuber2633]

New challenge: Every item is the first item. The first item you find, no mattter what is, is the only item from then on. Edit: Every floor, the item then changes so it isn't boring. The item also has to be able to stack. He starts with No, and can reject an item and change it once a floor if he thinks it is useless or too op.

[@SoulsTornado]

Throw in Glitched Crown for the first item, choice and fail potential P.S. Add NO! or/and make it so every item is the first item Hutts picks, not finds, so he can lock in something stackable

[@uh-ohspaghetti-os4118]

That sounds unbelievably boring to watch

[@forestpie5396]

That would be interesting for like 20 items and just be really boring for oll of the others

[@hermitcardguy4818]

Most items only stack up to a certain limit most stay related items don’t benefit much more past the 2nd

[@247play3]

Imagine he finds death certificate at first. That would be fun, but boring after a short moment of time

[@ZEDRIkZEDRIk]

Damn Hutts what if... We do like rainbow chest run in Gungeuon, u need to pick 1 item in 8 from all pools every floor, but that it! nothing else!

[@worm-king]

Hutts, are you aware of the Achievement Randomizer mod? It's a really neat mod that locks every item (yes every item), pick-up and character behind different unlock conditions, like no-hitting floors and bosses (+ the normal conditions). Could be a really fun mod for a new series if you ever feel like tackling it.

[@silkenshadow]

A fun variant of this might be testing various items for how well they're able to carry you through a run on their own! If you start with only blue candle, or Death's list, or candy heart, and see how far you can make it

[@cloy4096]

Man that was really fun to watch, specially knowing the struggle of not getting a SINGLE damage or tears up till womb

[@ghastlyembers2062]

would 100% love to see more of this, the random challenges like these are awesome and i could watch em all day

[@thetwistedsavant5821]

Love the per floor change. I'd say every other non-stacking item being rerolled could make it a bit more a bit more 'contenty'. That'd make it so you still have to use some of the trash items that dont stack but at least then every other floor could bring opportunity.

[@FnegThomin]

I liked the video, cool concept. I hardly ever take sanguine bond but it was cool seeing how it gave you so many black hearts and some halos to help you out in the end. I'd like to see more of this challenge.

[@13McKay13]

Awesome Challenge! Regarding the active Item issue, you could just add +1 to the number rolled if it hits an active item. But i did like the idea of having to use active items to their fullest in the floors where you got them e.g. getting bookworm, or gaining more charges from duplicates. Thanks for all the work you've been putting in. Probably spent the last 10 years with you and didn't regret a single minute I spent on your content! Though i should really really write my bachelor's thesis instead :D

[@andreil7766]

Very awesome challenge! Definitely gonna try this! Another fun idea I had is the Blue baby Alabaster box Forever challenge, where you start with alabaster box as blue baby and whenever you fill one, before taking anything, you give yourself another alabaster box. its a lot like tainted lost - limited health in exchange for nice stuff. active items kinda fuck with this, so either give yourself schoolbag or start with gulping the No trinket (which is what i did).

[@Djeljosue]

If you made a series with this rules on the second channel, i would watch it

[@Homerak]

A dollar is 100 coins and you didn't have 100 coins. I wonder if it would drop a dollar with Deep Pockets.

[@Zyxyro]

sugestion of modification for this challenge, you can rerow at two diferent situations 1 - you can rerow at any time (even in the midle of the floor), but only one time in the run, so, chose carefully 2 - if you already have an active item and the number chosen is an active item, you can chose to rerow or not the number JUST ONE TIME per floor to try to get a passive iten (if another active iten, well, you tried, will be the last one, no mather what iten it is) and a special rule, if you decide to start with the "NO!" trinket, you HAVE to rerow the number any times needed to an passive item be chose at every floor, and you still can change your trinket and leave the NO! behind, but if you do, you are no more in the special rule and will no more have infinite rerows to not get active itens

[@Login-Logan]

I think this is equally as entertaining as the EIS challenges you post. I also think this allows for more fun combos that may have never been seen before, so I'd be happy to see more!

[@GreedyRadish]

Definitely do more of these, this was great. I kinda like that Monster Manual ended up being such a hero in this run, so leaving the actives on might make it more interesting. I suppose you can tweak it however you want. At the end of the day, gotta strike a balance between what’s fun for us to watch and actually fun for you to play.

[@DamianPereyraHs]

This format is really fun TBH. Great comeback!

[@PedroHenrique-vt1nz]

been loving those long isaac videos recently, thanks hutts

[@wiebeklazes4059]

This challenge need to be done more often

[@Chelarino]

this was really fun to watch, definitely would like to see more as annoying as the active items were, i feel like completely taking them out of the equation would also take away a pretty big chunk of what the game has to offer, as there are some pretty banging ones i think maybe limiting yourself to two active-item-floors max, and getting to reroll active items if yu get more then those two floors could be a nice balance, giving you a nice chance to find something cool, but also preventing you potentially not getting any items at all

[@PauloHPBender1988]

This challenge has so much potential I believe it deserves it's own series.

[@PapaWace]

Hutts, i recommend you do this challenge, but use the ID based on the in-game clock. That way, it'll be more rewarding to take your time. (I love your long content)

[@tomkershaw9852]

would love to see more of this challenge. I suggest when the rng gives you an active item, spin again once kinda like t.lost's passive. that way it's still possible to see active items but more likley to get passive

[@hiddenbutdeadly]

Since theres over 700 items, heres an idea Floor 1 (basement) items from 1-100 (each floor you roll a new number) Floor 2 (Caves) items 100-200 Depths 200-300 Womb 300-400 Cathedral/Sheol - 400-500 Darkroom/Chest 500-MAX BONUS Hush/delerium 700-MAX

[@nullnull7509]

As always, great content Hutts. Been watching since your early Rebirth videos and you never fail to entertain; whether it's you're editing on these videos or just chilling in the streams, it's always a good time. Keep up the great work my friend, and God bless.

[@Mrbones1102]

huge potential with this one. The struggle at the beginning made the win so much sweeter

[@theonlydeadguy]

Definitely do more of this challenge. One of the most interesting ones.

[@unknownsoul5333]

If you did more of this challenge, I think a good way to change it is by having a quality limit if that were possible with the mod, so none of your items are above quality 3, or maybe even 2 if you want more of a challenge.

[@Jaalco]

Don't think I've laughed this much before to a video before - Great challenge!

[@franksjazz]

Great challenge! You should make a series out of it

[@magdziatoja]

Such a fun challenge! I would love to see it done with only passive items or different characters. The editing is also so cool! Wishing everyone a nice day

[@Fidooop]

Absolutely do this again but passives only and give yourself 1 or 3 rerolls too? I am loving this! Or maybe, your limited rerolls you have for the challenge, you could ONLY use if it's an active item. So you still run the risk of an active item floor which helps makes the challenge interesting!

[@k-sherry]

Wrong Tim is a little unnerving, I wonder what he did to the real Tim 😧

[@eclairush]

Insanely great video! Would love to see more of this challenge

[@amethysttvgl1601]

I would really love to see this challenge again with only passive items! This was super fun as is!

[@That1_Toaster]

2:32 Protogen's would be dissapointed in that statement

[@MerxTheWizard]

This challenge is really interesting in concept and I’d love to see more videos with the challenge!

[@randyjunkyard4391]

Really liked this one! Would love to see more Hutts

[@KerranJast1337]

I'd love to see more videos of this challenge in the future! Keep up the great work!

[@hushedwoodsman2582]

They really had us in the first half, not gonna lie. Such a cool challenge, glad to see it had a happy ending.

[@Guackamolo]

I'd love to see more of this! Super fun challenge idea.

[@Luminarigon]

One thing you could add to the challenge is the ability to reroll the item 1 - 5 times (depending on how difficult you want it to be) across the entire so that way you can avoid getting just a bunch of active items

[@smollmoth6376]

I think what could improve this challenge is making it so the random items are chosen from a pool of items that are actually interesting (like stats, healthy ups, and other items that work with multiple copies of itself.)

[@smollmoth6376]

@@test99947 aw

[@benmike3576]

Great episode, would love to see more from this challenge

[@benjo2648]

Love the idea of this challenge I think you should do it again but only include items that CAN stack or remove all active items or both.

[@PleakeCrions]

Looked like a lot of fun. And a lot of fun to watch! Can’t wait to see more challenges

[@CorporalEditor]

I very much love this challenge! Keep up the good work Hutts

[@samuelinca64]

Love this style of video! Would love to see more in the future.

[@smashingtheadam]

I enjoyed this format; would totally watch more.

[@worm-king]

If you do this again, you should play Bethany instead of Isaac for the actives to become a little more interesting and giving you different wisps.

[@derwolpertinger4381]

Really liked this challenge, yeah but maybe with only passives or even only items from a specific pool:) would love to see more

[@Meatslapontable]

The challenge was really fun but the true hero here is the editor

[@ondrejrichtr6835]

I love these challenges. Maybe next time you could get an item per floor and reroll all current items to that.

[@SynisterJeff]

Really fun idea, would love to see more of these

[@19Flagg19]

I loved watching this challenge, even though you didn't get many passives I thought it made the video more interesting. I firmly thought you were going to lose, it was exciting to watch

[@hideout7398]

Even with this kind of challenge, the game still gives you multiple actives lol Definitely wanna see more though!

[@dampesthydra7422]

challenge was great, very entertaining as always hutts. love ya content

[@the_furf_of_july4652]

To get a list of only passives, get a list of the passive item ids or names in text form, there's ways to randomly select a line from a list.

[@Vanilla4Gorilla]

Would watch more of this, keep up the good work!

[@nathanpotter236]

Absolutely love this editing such a good job lately

[@impostercatfish255]

I’d love to see this again! Rerolling until a passive also makes sense and would be cool

[@davidkjerulf3502]

What about a challenge run: having normal item spawns on each floor, but the first item you pick will be duplicated for all other spawned items on that floor. -IE- You see an item you don't want, you can leave it and continue fishing for other items on the same floor that potentially have more value when duped. It would arguably be less challenging than what was done in this run, but still be an interesting dynamic of sacrificing variety for duped items.

[@kitsune_UwU]

I think You should do the same but Only allow yourself to get the first ever active you hit with numbers, and then every other active should be rerolled. You could also make a set of number that don't include actives, for after you've gotten an active items, but that's probably too much work.

[@edelledezma9872]

Please do more! Hope you are doing well hutts, we all love you

[@starryfae]

I feel like maybe an alteration where you keep active items in the pool for items, but only up until you get an active or something. Once you've got it, then reroll again if you get an active item. Your rules, of course, but just an idea. Fun idea though! Rough at some points lol

[@ToxicUnknown24]

Hilarious video, definitely please do this challenge again.

[@gravitysword2002]

A dollar gives you 100 coins so it didnt drop a dollar

[@liamross1591]

Really enjoyed it. Would love to see it again

[@bongosmcdongos4190]

Dude those sanguine bond plays in the womb were sick.

[@FranXiT]

By the way, the dollar is 100 coins, not 99, which worked out perfectly for the reverse fool since you "only" had 99 coins

[@krad6298]

Would love to see a video on the new Isaac Champions mod that came out yesterday. Love the content, Hutts!

[@tylercopeland7920]

Awesome challenge and GG! Keep up the awesome content Hutts

[@modzflare8683]

Awesome run! Too bad it didn't go amazingly (nice clutch). Do you think this could work well in Risk of Rain 2 with the artifact of Command item? Obviously it wouldn't be perfect with all the different tiers of items, but a lot more items in that game stack.

[@ianrobson7459]

I think maybe looking to see if there is a way to have a mod that does allow for item stacking may be helpful. And maybe do a subset for the challenge, where you go through all the eras of Isaac and only use items/cards/pills from that era (only items from repentance for one run, only rebirth items for another, etc.)

[@Kalightortaio]

I love this challenge! And yes, there is a way to program this into Da Rules. I would also love to see a passives only run!

[@DRIFTERX673]

Great video!! You should spawn yourself a key for the mega satan fight at the end of your runs to keep them going, especially on challenge runs

[@yarvzix]

We need a series on this!

[@AnarchyFrequency]

Strange and unusual challenges are good and cool, but you raise a good point with 'forcing for passive items'. On two accounts, one: if the run is difficult or uninteresting because of the relatively unhelpful items you are getting than it's rough for both the audience and you, bringing us to account two: if you're not having fun. YOU, HUTTS, are not having fun. Than what's the point? as much as we want to see you encounter a 'Challenge', it's not really a great challenge if you feel like you're just grinding your way through it. You catch my drift homeslice? Now get out there and kick some ass

[@themysterypotato1156]

I’m pretty sure you could’ve gone lost mode to get a free dead bird from the shop in downpour 2 It wouldn’t have been useful, but it’s fun, right? Also you could’ve taken all the pickups for free with the holy mantle (I forget if flight lets you go over the spikes from pound of flesh)

[@zackmar4449]

Was very fun to watch! I hope you do more ^^

[@nicodotzeta]

Excellent idea for a challenge, more of this pls!

[@scaleb2]

Really deep social commentary when the book turned into a video game xD

[@kertiboi844]

In the words of TMBG, "This could lead to excellence, or serious injury, only one way to know, go, go, go."

[@creative3419]

Hi Hutts, i don't except an answer but i just wanna thank you and the content you do, not only tboi but any game you play. You've became one of those youtuber i watch for the youtuber more than for the game, thank you for always cheering up my evenings And sorry for the bad english, I'm actually Chilean so english it's not my first language

[@tarrindalzell9536]

Would love to watch long form videos of this challenge.

[@duck730]

Best isaac challenge I've ever seen Would love to see p2

[@izgoose]

There is so much potential for “every item is” in terms of rng and I’d love to see more

[@beewaare]

I’d love to see more of this for sure

[@Pikakeung]

This is pretty entertaining. Frankly, any of your Isaac content is ❤❤.

[@museofsalzburg2373]

Would def like to see more like this. Maybe do it in greed mode and with item pools instead of specific items?

[@neptune_main4049]

*skeleton dies* Hutts: "The human form of refried beans"

[@tijldeschermer2716]

This is a genius idea

[@PinkiePieParties]

Please do this challenge again. I'd love to see what else would happen with it.