Game Theory: Hello Neighbor's SATANIC Plot!

[@firedemon43]

I knew he was evil when he drank straight out off the milk bottle

[@Pulstar232]

The 43rd Firedemon the only time you do that is if you can drain it all in one go.

[@dupeycupcakes839]

The 43rd Firedemon XD OMG

[@underscore_535]

You know who drinks straight from the milk carton? SYNTHS

[@johnmathis2378]

The 43rd Firedemon I watched this episode, my lights started to flicker. OHHHHH HELLLLLLL NO

[@jamesonelliott4814]

The 43rd Firedemon o my god noo

[@franklinturtleton6525]

1414 is also police radio code for wounding with intent.

[@guiltytrinity6016]

That's most likely to separate them

[@kwonster8824]

The fact that the neighbor has the role as a killer clown is quite coincidental to the real world

[@kwonster8824]

This man is probably either bad or has a deeper purpose of doing this

[@Georgus_420]

Sometimes its just the fact that he enjoys doing it, remember the simple solutuion is usually the right one

[@picklou123]

Gamzee?

[@Bailey_Dreamfoot]

MatPat: Makes theory about a game Game: changes it's entire underlying plot and structure MatPat: *r a g e*

[@HangboyGamer]

@Jbarbarra Charles uh oh , you're Hiding Something?

[@HangboyGamer]

@@Gingermation idk , I am just asking him what that means cause I am too lazy to find it by myself 😂

[@HangboyGamer]

@phoenix Am I Cursed? 🥺

[@suzannahardjono9951]

Nah, it just the first texted tried to swear but very aware there are kids so he replace it by some nonsense

[@hat7475]

Mood tho. All that work,,,

[@cirkusanette]

the fact that 6 years ago matpat did a joke about fnaf having a shark animatronic is insane

[@wolfyblue5155]

& scary. Might as well do a theory on this.

[@thedorkknight9684]

yeah, he joked about being Omnicient for predicting the mario movie would be a musical, but THIS, this where we say "Calm down Apollo"

[@dakota.000.]

And there is a fnaf book with a robot shark now

[@interstellarkitten6487]

Wikipedia: the neighbor is a sad, crazed father with no remaining family Matpat: *the neighbor is a clown worshipping the devil*

[@TheStealthyOne6]

Eppy yea but I can’t read it all

[@girlysoundtapes]

@@Mrsk1rma Wow that's interesting..

[@bathwaterseller7080]

ok and

[@ducksareurlords3782]

He isn't really that grazy... Wikipedia is lying

[@cherylbohman6518]

Makes sense to me. Sad, lonely man who's family has died, devil worshipping clown, same difference!

[@sneakaboo3486]

When the theory channel makes a more satisfying story than the actual game

[@random_beeya9169]

Pink and Trouble I like this but don’t wanna like because the likes are 212!

[@eazyplayz3510]

Ouch-

[@suicune3776]

If Hello Neighbor took a biblical direction that would be kind of weird but definitely welcome X3

[@fun-epersonnproductions4002]

Devs actually revealed that all the secrets in Pre-lunch Hello Neighbor didn't matter at all.

[@ninomacas4692]

(:😁🤣

[@highfunctioningsociopath3767]

Fun fact about Mr. Rodgers: the reason you see him feed the fish a lot is because a viewer wanted to make sure they're okay :)

[@bengal4047]

That's adorable

[@smkyqrtz]

I'm eating Swedish fish rn...

[@Kuriboh1008]

A blind or deaf one, right?

[@Rookvaleriannocturne]

@@Kuriboh1008 A blind girl, I believe. So he'd announce that he was feeding the fish.

[@Kuriboh1008]

@@Rookvaleriannocturne k

[@AlexPerez-tv1zg]

Matpat: makes a really good snd creepy theory about the game Game: *it was all a dream*

[@iamfluffy4200]

*gets Vietnam flashbacks to FNaF 4*

[@gaminganimators7000]

But it wasn't a dream

[@adrianaslund8605]

I read the canon "story" on Wikipedia and it really wasn't that bad. Just kind of vague.

[@Logan.Massie]

Only Act 3 was a dream, Act 1 and 2 actually happened.

[@Boldorx]

Well the alpha 1 dude did die

[@GameTheory]

I don't normally do "updates" but I found a HUGE piece of evidence to support this theory yesterday that I think you all will really enjoy, so expect a short "Diet Theory" in a few days once I've researched it a bit more!

[@hanifzaman]

The Game Theorists Hiiiii

[@tabyxp2171]

Ily

[@olivermccall3898]

The Game Theorists hi

[@standard_weeb]

The Game Theorists Ok I'll be looking forward to it :D

[@NickFje]

Hello Matpat !

[@coltywolty]

He’s here He’s there He’s everywhere Who ya gonna call *Security shark*

[@marygwynethtenio8158]

Psychic Friend Fredbear LOL

[@wea]

*nOrD VpN*

[@PremiumCheeses]

Who you gonna call? It's your pal neighbor

[@OrangeNoNukegara]

*Top ten psychic friend fredbear bootlegs*

[@alwolf4207]

Paycheckic friend Fredbear yaaaa

[@finleyforevermore]

The fact that this theory is better than the actual "story" of the real game is sad.

[@theblurryviewfinder]

I like to stick to the whole "his whole family died and now he's a lonely dad who probably went insane as he tries to fell the gapes of his dead family members by kidnaping kids" stuff, I mean it Does make sense and fit w the lore, and it's not that complicated

[@momintaj2955]

It has great story and gameplay 10 out of 10

[@hat7475]

Personally I like both lol. Cuz the whole concept of having supernatural entity being in the story is used alot (from gameplay videos I have seen), and this was back in 2016 sooo Whoo! ❤️

[@ItsSupercat94]

@@theblurryviewfinder the thing is that this game acted like it was such a big and convoluted story then the end result is just pretty simple, that's why I like matpats story more.

[@boe_jo9778]

@@ItsSupercat94 Funny, cause he pretty much nailed the OG plot of the game, his theory was a scrapped storyline of the game.

[@ran-ranran598]

This story is actually way more interesting than the actual story of the game.

[@bigmonkeyman45]

"He commits no crimes" Pretty sure trying to injure someone with a bear trap is a crime.

[@anthonymaiolie4890]

It is

[@carsonfoster4775]

Hello there

[@rainbowisticfarts]

The game is set in the United States, where you are given the law to use forces to protect your property, beartraps, shotguns, all legal

[@kitkatty52211]

@@rainbowisticfarts 'MERICA

[@LoudestMan]

Well the thing is he is defending his property because in the newer updates (before the release) he doesn't go fully across the street. He may be kidnapping people, but he is entitled to defend his property.

[@XyzCloud]

We all know he's just hiding an embarrassing picture of SpongeBob from the Christmas party.

[@finno2679]

Amazing

[@azure3655]

wtf how does he know SpongeBob?

[@relaxkid7645]

Nestor Ortiz it was a joke

[@limozy]

KnivesEco lol hahaha

[@Runaway_Skeletons]

KnivesEco the you made my day

[@simigeorge1597]

Matpat: Look closer , look even closer... Me: Looking closely at the cup with the yellow sticker Matpat: The book! Me: Dang it!!!

[@roguebird12]

That's what I was doing to-

[@whynotbeyourselfyt9508]

😂

[@takiyah0526]

I was looking at his mug. Which also had a goat with huge horns. And at times the devil is depicted as a goat.... oof Edit: I just read a comment that said his mug was a bull. Oops

[@Slapnutz76]

I was looking at the hat stand

[@asherzanepaynegibson4042]

I felt that xD

[@GippyHappy]

The idea of a carny that made a deal with the devil is so much better than what they actually did, why didn't they just steal this idea from Mat? He literally gift wrapped it for them.

[@gideongethim-gethim6036]

I keep seeing comments about how this theory was way better than the actual one💀 But I can’t find the canon story anywhere, if you know could you please explain😭

[@Timmering]

@@gideongethim-gethim6036 it’s dumb. Basically it was all a dream. Literally. That’s it.

[@citriosis]

​@@gideongethim-gethim6036Basically, when you were a kid, you tried to save another kid after they got kidnapped, and the neighbor kidnapped you. You escaped, and then years later you moved back to the neighborhood and had a nightmare about his house returning, and had a dream about conquering our fears or something??

[@KattyKitten69]

Here's a proper explanation: Essentially the neighbor was originally a sane person, with a wife and 2 kids, a boy and a girl, one day the neighbor suffered a car accident, which killed his wife, thie led him into depression, and his son also being heavily by it, he started getting violent with his sister whenever he losed a game (they played alot), until one day, they went to play hide and seek, the daughter hid in the roof, and once the son finally found her, he was absolutely enraged, leading to him accidentally pushing his own sister of the roof in a moment of anger. The neighbor, with his mental health basically being non existent at this point, traps his own son in the basement, both due to his anger, but also the fear of losing his only family member. This leads to the events of the game, most especifically act 1, hello neighbor: Search and Rescue, act 2 and hello neighbor 2. in act 1, we play as a close friend of the neighbor's son, nicholas roth, or nicky for short hello neighbor: nicky's diary shows nicky had already noticed the absence of his friend, the way he and his father acted, something suspicious was going on and he knew it, but he only really started exploring the house after the first cutscene, he's just playing with his beach ball but hears a loud scream which appears to be of a child, coming from the neighbor's house, as he goes closer to try and see whats happening, it is possible to see the neighbor kidnapping someone (im assuming aaron escaped and the neighbor captured him) and looking out the window to see if anyone saw him or heard the screams (he probably didnt see us), then the game starts, nicky enters the basement by getting this red key to the lock. And what does he find in the basement? Nothing. Yes, nothing. Nicky is then captured by the neighbor, and is trapped in a room. for some reason, a weird cardboard cutout unlocks the door for him. Idk whats the lore relevancy of this, because nowhere do we see any mention of alive cardboard cutouts in the neighbors basement. And it also isnt the neighbors son. My theory is that this is the squad helping nicky, since in hello neighbor search to rescue, the squad frees nicky with the help of the guest. But im not entirely sur about, Did they just changed the story midway through the final release and hide and seek? (The game where were releaved to the backstory of th neighbor) idk maybe. But even then its really weird, after this nicky escapes the basement only to find out the neighbor built a giant fence so he cant escape. The house is also double the size now. Finally nicky escapes the neighbor's house. Which leads to the events of hello neighbor 2 and whatever happened after that useless cliffhanger, essentially quentin arrives, explores the neighbors house, the bakery, the manor and the taxidermist's house to get acess to the museum where the neighbor is hiding (possibly because nicky called the police or smth), he frees the neighbor's son, crow statue falls in the neighbor, aaron tries to save his father and someone bonks quentin (possibly a forest protector) and boom. Game ends. Now, its act 3 and 4, essentially, after the events of the first and second game, nicky, now as a grown adult is expelled from his appartment, so he returns to his old house in raven brooks, the house where the neighbor lived has been burned to the ground. By going closer to it, a cutscene plays with nicky exploring the remnants of the neighbors burned house, but he sees a weird shadow creature which makes he run to the other side of the street, already going to say this, but the shadowmman isnt a demon, nor the devil, nor the guest, nor the neighbor brother, nor aaron, nor whatever, he's nicky's representation of the trauma he lived as a child, or in other words, its just an hallucination. Lame right? Ik. Nicky gets a phone call and hallucinates more with the shadow man, then he falls asleep and wakes up in a dream, the neighbor's house is back and bigger than ever, he goes through a bunch of really bad and poorly tought out puzzles and enters the basement again, its literally the same thing but now with a small appearence of the shadow creature, the basement is just a check to see if you're with all the habilities from the fear levels (not going to talk about those because they're bad and unecessary). After that, you go to a room with a bed and a cardboard cutout (most likely is supposed to represent aaron) and then a giant neighbor appears and breaks the house entirely, you're now in a white void. And has to parkour your way to the house in the neighbor's back. After entering the house. You go through some weird parts and to the final section. With nicky having to protect his younger self of the shadow man. Which makes you bigger and bigger until the shadow man is defeated (or aka, you finally overcome your trauma). Nicky wakes up from the dream and the end. Well, im not sure if you'll like the lore or not, that's up to you. But for me. The original story that was being alluded to was way better and interesting than what we got.

[@truecrimereader8346]

me, many years later: yeah... his son is being hidden in the basement..

[@tsmchase6704]

Capri RamFam wait what? Explain pls, I stopped catching up on the lore a long time ago

[@salmoringstar5537]

@@tsmchase6704 same

[@colbedavey5851]

@@tsmchase6704 By the way spoilers! from what I understand from the little research I've done. The mother dies in a car crash, leaving the neighbor (husband) incredibly depressed. They have 2 kids a girl and a boy. The boy is also really upset about his mother's death, and in anger takes it out on his sister. The kids are playing and end up on the roof (I have no idea how) and the boy accidentally shoves his sister to hard, and she falls off the roof and dies. The Neighbor buries his daughter and not wanted to lose his son (his only family left) and locks him in the basement. Unfortunately because the neighbor has lost his mind the son starves to death. That's the background and lore that I found, pretty dark stuff.

[@cherylbohman6518]

@@colbedavey5851 from the "Hide and Seek" game, it's shown that Aaron, the son, lures Maya, the daughter, up to the roof and purely by accident, pushes her off because Mr. Peterson, after his wife's death, became more reclusive instead of comforting his children, who keep in mind, lost their mother as well, and Aaron, felt lost even though Maya tried to cheer him up. *Yikes, this guy's backstory is kinda sad*

[@colbedavey5851]

@@cherylbohman6518 Thanks! I didn't see the "Hide ans Seek", so that clarify's how the kids ended up on the roof.

[@edward3591]

Almost two minutes of explaining the “winky face”. Nice job, MatPat.

[@vyvyanbstard1356]

This face? ;) or this one? ;^)

[@lixyuwu2183]

emma irvine you should know? Did you watch the video or are you just scrolling through the comments like no tomorrow?

[@silverluna8218]

Damn you sassy

[@KakashiHatake-bq9hl]

@@lixyuwu2183lol ur dum

[@PeanutWithWiFiAccess]

😉

[@kxrimuu]

Hello neighbor? More like Hell No neighbor

[@Striker1197]

Kitteny14 ba dun chhh

[@praseodymium4975]

*ba dum tss*

[@pegasipoop6712]

Kitteny14 u just rekt hello neighbour

[@isilva0013]

Kitteny14 if seen u in the comments on another vid but I forgot what the vid was

[@marcirobinson1636]

Kitteny14 omg 😂

[@louschianojr.1169]

Nobody: Matpat: *Comes up with a theory that leads to things with the devil by looking at a mailbox in a game.*

[@trgyfhgnt3]

late reply but lol

[@KD11BURN]

'Developer needs therapy' needs to be a genre.

[@lightningdolt971]

scorn and agony fit that pretty well.

[@Capta1nTD]

Seriously, it would be an awesome genre.

[@KD11BURN]

Degratestdoes Roblox Uh-Huh. OCGN for ya.

[@denopeno7951]

The neighbour is Hillary Clinton

[@hi_its_jerry]

that a wierd genre...

[@452pokemaster]

He knows when something's... Fishy. SECURITY SHARK!

[@Omega1-bq3wv]

I can help him find his favorite song in iTuna

[@Omega1-bq3wv]

Security Shark is doing his job just for the halibut

[@Omega1-bq3wv]

When Security Shark & I were about to leave Starbucks, I almost forgot to “wave” goodbye

[@Omega1-bq3wv]

I hope he doesn’t tip the “scales”

[@Omega1-bq3wv]

Security Shark’s job kinda BITES!!!

[@toplayDA_]

Here’s an interesting consideration - what if the whole “breaking into the house” thing is a metaphor? Let’s say that the house is symbolic of the neighbor’s mind, and then you, as the player, have noticed that something is deeply wrong with it (the neighbor’s general creepiness). So you are trying to get the neighbor to tell you what’s wrong by asking him questions that lead him to talk to you without realising. Every time he catches you in the game emulates each time he realises what you are doing and gets you to go away. That’s why he doesn’t bury you outright straight away, only when you reach the door (what’s bothering him) does he seal you off forever (burying you). Probably not true, but still, thought it was an interesting idea!

[@thomashaeyen6942]

When you strike a deal with lucifer, then there is undoubtedly something wrong with your mind. Edit: with that i don't mean you're not mentally okay when you sign a deal with lucifer, im implying that if you do, it will certainly mess with your mind.

[@yourskulls77]

okay but i love that

[@hat7475]

OooOohh 😳

[@dillandoesthedo1813]

when a comment makes a better story than the actual game

[@adrianaslund8605]

There is some similarity with that and the story of the actual game from what I can tell.

[@Albert_YTC]

The fact that the game devs changed the story of the game because matpat got it all right is crazy

[@crimsonsomething]

That's insane 💀

[@novustalks7525]

Is this proven?

[@Albert_YTC]

@@novustalks7525 matpat told a story about how he got an email form a game company asking if he had a mole on the inside telling him the story. The game proceeded to come out buggy and not what fans wanted. The closest thing to that story would be hello neighbour

[@novustalks7525]

@@Albert_YTC I heard that story but that seemed more like it was security breach

[@fareseno]

​@@novustalks7525I don't think it's fnaf related tbh

[@ARM_DM]

13:14 "Closer... Closer.... The book" "The Book?!?! Did you see the cup tho? There's also an insurmountable amount of one-eyed symbolism, but that's a whole nother...chapter.

[@tinytinkergacha7747]

XDD

[@vladimirde-vreeze7877]

damn it would have been so much better if you had made the timestamp 14:14, as a reference to the mailbox as well

[@journey9641]

You're seeing the light reflecting off the cup, the actual design on the cup looks like a bull, or some animal with horns

[@randomstranger8554]

@@vladimirde-vreeze7877 But that is AFTER the book part, so it wouldn't make any sense, therefore, it's a TERRIBLE timestamp to put for that comment, and people would reply "THATS NOT THE BOOK PART!!! THE BOOK PART IS 13:14!!!" Plus, it's possible he changed it.

[@nicoleunfrtntly]

it simple, the krabby patty formula is i his basement

[@yffix9735]

Susin Family OBVIOUSLY!! Like what else would be in his basement? Nothing is more precious than the Krabby Patty formula, we are probably playing as Plankton!

[@jibrailnoon2908]

Susin Family 😂😂😂

[@zachnoobnoob7792]

I KNEW it had to be the krabby patty formula

[@mlpfan4565]

Aha Yes finally SOME ONE found out

[@quintilleroni3242]

Creators of the game:You have found out! Great! now we have to make a new game! None was supposed to find out!

[@dontme6996]

Don't you dare associate Mr. Rogers with anything remotely evil.

[@fnaffangirl123]

I agree how dare he pervert Mr Rogers

[@assassinmaster3419]

How dare he try to bring that saint down to this games level

[@smilingcircleicon3427]

what about Mr Robinson, (snl)

[@tim_drinkswater2024]

Ikr

[@Tman5209]

You do know the neighbors and the kids name right?

[@kanna9886]

RIP to the potential of this game

[@007Larry]

Yep

[@cassiebrodie6595]

Wait what

[@butterburger4565]

Can I just say that every theory I see is just so impressive

[@Elai4203]

Butterburger 45 even if their false it's incredible the amount of thinking he puts into these videos

[@stairbanastor2765]

other than sans is ness

[@lamparitaful]

Butterburger 45 same even if it's a game I don't know or aren't interested in like this game for the first reason

[@dogma8538]

ikr

[@zoeengland6823]

+EdgyHoneyBadger_MK and the pyro

[@LIAMODEARME01]

If this was all correct the developers would be in tears right now

[@thatrandompersoni1949]

they would be like: "NOOOOO NOW THE WHOLE PLOT IS RUINED!!! CURSE YOU GAME THEORY!!!" XD

[@tavernburner3066]

jojo coral games like this are built on mystery. Doesn't work if someone figures it out.

[@Jadee95]

LIAMODEARME maybe you are the developer

[@jeremiahwagers3457]

bryce

[@tavernburner3066]

Jeremiah Wagers yes!

[@audiethorn]

*BEWARE HIS JAWS OF JUSTICE* _security shaaark!_

[@FunnybUnnyo]

Audrey Buchthal yeeeees!! XD

[@mrhydro]

xDDDDDDDDDD

[@islandprincess714]

Lol

[@Soul_Slayer]

We need this as a thing like a VPN or something

[@josephtorres521]

Prepare to be fin-ished. SECURITY SHARK!

[@Skippymcskep]

10:30 god damn it matpat you jinxed us, now felix the shark exists

[@jessebaker4245]

I was looking for that comment

[@The_camera_melon]

​@@jessebaker4245Me too

[@Eaawesome59]

The fact that he has a Faust book, and the 666 on the "sole" of his shoe kinda makes the theory confirmed imo.

[@FoolishLoki1294]

DR34DH34D3D_P5YCH0. not to mention the candles around the mattress are in the shape of a pentagram

[@jkeithus]

DR34DH34D3D_P5YCH0 what does imo mean?

[@calomanny]

"In my opinion"

[@icecoldnut5152]

You guys don't have that stuff?

[@kwonster8824]

This theory IS onfirmed

[@amic482]

Plot twist: The neighbor is the purple guy from FNaF

[@themostbritishpersonalive868]

The neighbor behind the slaughter

[@ManiacalMaxPage]

Did you know there is a theory that the kid is Micheal?

[@kiyuthakat4934]

NO GOD PLEASE NO!

[@Muhil_mumu]

:0

[@richardduquette1481]

@@Muhil_mumu oh yes

[@mollymoffat2173]

What if the shoe sticker is a 9.99 price tag..... lol just a thought.

[@shadowspeed5440]

Maybe

[@eligahn.f336]

@@shadowspeed5440 there isn't a dot ;-;

[@schwellenangst1605]

This is a game Everything has a meaning

[@augustusgloop2442]

What if it’s a 6.66 price tag Random but you never know

[@afterthoughts00]

It was 666 go listen again

[@leonardwalletzky1411]

I love how he even explains the winky face emoji to such detail it's almost laughable...

[@Myrus_MBG]

How do we know? *jumps into detailed description of emoji etiquette*

[@theboss3541]

Well well well. We finally meet now ;)

[@TheLakabanzaichrg]

MatPat don't be stupid, the shadowy figure is not satan, it's Ditto he IS in the game.

[@crazinessmation5722]

TheLakabanzaichrg Lmao

[@Silver_Unseelie]

Craziness Mation

[@typoded]

no its not hes shorter than the shadow ditto would be the same height : [ im fun at parties

[@thepoketuberjr1974]

TheLakabanzaichrg

[@EagleZtoTheGrave]

Ditto is satan...?

[@miugh2981]

More like hell no neighbor

[@rennzzz8085]

Mia Thomas Unoriginal, Jackseptceye pinned this comment in his video.

[@kiaranicole9530]

PUNNY😂

[@inspgonzalez]

Mia Thomas PUNS

[@ImMrLucky]

Gaming Sheep Lol

[@henriettehgh8128]

i'm sorry but didn't you get that from Kubz Scouts or is that just me?

[@MR.Sculptor]

I can’t believe Matpat predicted animatronic sharks not ONCE, but TWICE.

[@suchabolognathe2nd831]

That explains why he’s able to hear you tiptoe across the freakin house

[@jadendoyle2287]

Suchabologna The 2nd he has cameras ._.

[@camilleremiano8463]

@@jadendoyle2287 But does he sit behind the cameras all the time?No.

[@lilblock3564]

@@camilleremiano8463 He might have em connected to a cellphone or sum

[@tavishf.degroot8181]

Hi medic

[@HangboyGamer]

@@lilblock3564 that doesn't make any "Cents"

[@emotionallyunstableandfill2497]

There's a hello neighbor book! It turns out when the developers said "your returning to your childhood home" it's not the neighbour's house, it the one your moving into, when your character was about 12 he lived in that same house. And, the neighbor wasn't a clown, he designed theme parks. Edit: the book is called "hello Neighbor: missing pieces", also, I believe another book just came out, I forgot the name though...

[@nadir4562]

i played the game your character is the son neighbor is your father what hidden in the basement is the shadow man 'your mother indead ghost

[@_bentleyboy3000_]

@@nadir4562 He isn't! I've been reading the books too, (Thank GOSH someone else also commented something about the books as well..) anyway, the Neighbor is Aaron and Mya's dad. Not the player's)

[@spencerhaveman4117]

the book came with the full games release, right?

[@hispanicsalty4473]

Spencer Haveman Nope

[@salthesock1546]

Spencer Haveman wait, I saw you in a FNAF theory I was watching a few minutes ago. Hi!!

[@BEDCORN]

I wonder if Mat ever over analyzes a game and creates like a "fake lore" that developer never actually intended lol

[@chikin6146]

pretty much most theories made by most people..not just matpat

[@alexthedarkelf]

Bedcorn *cough* undertaletheory *cough*

[@waismartialarts1]

That's 99% of most theories. But when creating art after you put it out the interpretation isn't up to you its up to the viewer

[@sigthestargazer7276]

Bedcorn Theory is creating a suitable fake lore to fit into the game current state. So every theory isn't 100% true it's just there to give us satisfaction that the game clues have been solved.

[@pinpanXXI]

Yeah. his "Arrow to the knee" theory created an entire conspiracy around medieval surgery. When in actuality, "taking an arrow to the knee" meant that you are getting married/already got married. But we really can't bag on him too much. He does say "its just a theory", like all the time.

[@pieckfinger3827]

Game: he's a man whom we know nothing about at this point. Just find the basement to answer everything! :) Matpat: So, yeah, he's definitely a runaway circus clown that sold his soul to the devil

[@timothyharris1125]

So William Macy the killer clown possibly?

[@elizajustdrawsnothing7872]

The TRUE theory here is... How was he able to get enough money to build his house? I would like to know because and by the looks of it... some of the rooms look like they were hand built.

[@mercurywise4047]

Eliza Gonzalez and how did he not break zoning laws 😂

[@elizajustdrawsnothing7872]

@@mercurywise4047 EXACTLY!!

[@nixmy]

He works at a theme park and kills children with his rollercoaster

[@cherylbohman6518]

From what I've heard, I'm not completely certain but I believe he may be a carpenter, which kinda makes sense if you think about it

[@nixmy]

He worked in a themepark and i have proof, the people on the newletters are the children he killed, thats what i think it is.

[@mollymoffat2173]

Beware his jaws of justice! He can smell the fishiness all over you! You’ll be facing serious FIN-es Security shaaark!

[@rafaelmihaila7339]

Too much puns

[@jacobbenjamin7778]

Rafael Mihăilă no it isn’t

[@am_goose]

Never too many puns. *coughsanscough*

[@GavinTM]

Glitchgirl555 shutup

[@am_goose]

@@GavinTM y u be hating M80

[@timmylim1844]

Teacher: What’s 600+66 class? Student: 666 Matpat: DEAMON TEACHER! DEMON TEACHER!

[@starbee325]

Timmy Lim baby MatPat

[@sami_irl]

He probably would say that

[@luigidollmcshorts168]

@@starbee325 imagine babypat making theories like this in pre-k

[@mr.silverbones6373]

I think you mean "Demon", not "DEAMON".

[@Pnod666]

It's really only demonic if you pronounce it as "Six six six." If you pronounce it as "Six-hundred and sixty six," it's fine.

[@theokay1]

You can't make Mr. Rodgers scary everything with him is just wholesomeness

[@abhaasghosh]

Plot twist: The neighbour is actually Pennywise

[@Xylophone_man273]

OH MY GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD WOW MY GOD WOOOOOOOOOW

[@technonoob2521]

:0

[@JMB_Knight]

Mom we need to move

[@therealdrimitrose]

This has 69 likes,not changing it

[@crumplezone4286]

Lol

[@fantasticgood5403]

nobody: litteraly nobody: not a soul: not even the mannequins: Matt: ThE nEiGhBoRs A cLoWn

[@majinbuu19831]

your comment doesn't make any sense!

[@kurtislockhart3989]

Hey the new game is in a park

[@krazart]

@Ethan Corpuz you need to learn English again, and you also commented on my video

[@malakkilani6624]

@@krazart your a little rude

[@hyperbolicraider4848]

Hello Neighbor: Has a big mysterious lore that is extreme to solve Scott Cawthon: *Finally.. a worthy opponent. Our battle will be LEGENDARY!!!*

[@fishman4526]

actually Hello Neighbor doesn't have any lore it's the most simple story ever, just some people extremly overthinking it. also there are a lot of game with better lore than FNAF, just try Petscop, Fran Bow, and Little Misfortune.

[@alexplaysminc.-.5922]

@@fishman4526 "Some people extremely overthinking it." I think we all know who these 'some people' are. xD

[@daltonboyd827]

Petscop: who are these people

[@sugarbvnnyluvsyou]

@@fishman4526 I mean there's not a huge amount of Lore in Little Misfortune but i get ur point

[@sakuragihanamichi8527]

@alikh alt and u suck bot

[@jeromevaleska2014]

I love how MatPat just causally shows a piece of promotional artwork that shows the neighbour covered in blood and holding a cleaver and doesn't even mention it. 8:30

[@crab5862]

It's always basements and clowns.

[@lordrwbyandnepwatcher1387]

Reference to dead by daylight?

[@islandprincess714]

Always

[@MaxSchmidGame]

Not the full release!

[@nyxeo]

Or in some cases, sewers and clowns.

[@sailormewmewinuluver1238]

Lol

[@avore_2213]

"I will be like the most high" -Isaiah 14:14 I'm going to start using this quote now

[@lightningdolt971]

Avore _ heh, more like isaiah 4:20 amirite.

[@pancakezrblx7077]

Avore _ XD

[@HullsColby]

You high meeeiin?

[@isabellasevillaaguilera9679]

Smoke Bible everyday

[@readyRick]

Roll your Blunts with Bible Pages!

[@omarsukar4342]

Usually I would be to scared to watch these videos but matpat makes it not scary

[@arttukettunen5757]

Expect with the newer GT videos based on horror games

[@jacobbroughton6565]

AAAAAAAAHHHHHHH

[@xPadge112x]

Well let me tell you about a film called Child's Play. Give it a watch it will make you less scared of this I promise.

[@aaronkoh1531]

@@xPadge112x wuts it about?

[@xPadge112x]

@@aaronkoh1531 Watch it

[@Parziphone]

MatPat predicting the shark animatronic ages before it happened gives me life

[@thatperson9478]

My only question is how he got the permits to add THAT many extensions to his house.

[@Philip54622]

Yeah lol, it took my parents half a year just to get an approval to make their fence taller

[@calleum8234]

Right? Like zoning laws do not exist in this universe

[@FlameyClockspeed]

That literally fits out with the so called "hello neighbor song" and at a part there is this part where he says: "you may think I'm the devil and I wish your lives in peril and let me spell out this for you: I'm just your neighbor" (this is me 3 years later: tf?)

[@MCWOriginal]

Now get out

[@spencerhaveman4117]

but that's just a fan made song.

[@anomnisexualpossum8485]

@@MCWOriginal thank you, now I don't have to finish it myself.

[@Hellblazer-ds1bn]

Just leaving comment here so you have massive cringe

[@joshoneill8631]

what if the neighbours prisoners are his wife and child that want to leave him due to his insanity but he's keeping them against their will?

[@sushier]

possible

[@joshuakelleher5879]

.3.

[@The_Archer-he2ft]

or, the man in the picture is the playerr, years before when they were still growing who lost is his child and wife to the neighbor(unknown reason) and he wishes to get them back. Or it could be a Saw type thing where he has to kill either his family, him, or the neighbor. The ways i see it, it is still too early to make assumptions and matpat's jumping on the hype train

[@MIGHTY_LEG3ND]

Josh Iz Kwl thats what i tought it might be his wife and child

[@Steallar]

I'm still hoping there's gonna be a big twist there somewhere. Like him actually trying to save the world from some dark entity he locked up in his home. Or something like that. Or something better (hopefully)!

[@GrabaCuppaPodcast]

Commenter: "I dOnT wAnT tO bE a CrImInAl" Almost every video game ever: "allow me to introduce myself..."

[@slaughtrrd]

*_15:25_* That is the _message_ the _mailbox_ is trying to *_deliver_* *_BaDoOm KsSsSs_*

[@JasM1331]

WaffleCake 08 I should be mad But I’m actually very proud that you realized that dad joke

[@soapgamer1235]

i just realized lol

[@OrangeNoNukegara]

👌

[@limph8019]

Once I saw he drank milk out of the carton I knew he was evil.

[@woah2much139]

TheLostMiner //Soccer/ nope.avi

[@libbywilliams9969]

Once you Jongin You can't Jongout ,read your comment just as I saw that COINCIDENCE I THINK NOT

[@limph8019]

libby Williams ILLUMINATI

[@ericatoogeekedd]

Ok I’m surprised the FBI hasn’t busted into his house just from looking at his search history

[@jaketaller8567]

10:29 I’m pretty sure Matpat just predicted the FNAF Felix The Shark book years before the first Fazbear Frights even came out.

[@katenawolfenstein9468]

This. is. SO FREAKING INTRESTING! I want more immediately! xD so hyped for when there's more information

[@Diamondscarxl]

Katena Wolfenstein Same, and I don't even care about the actual game that much since I'm not going to play it.

[@dogma8538]

same

[@SamBuckland]

Same I reckon best theory to date. I-/

[@gewmmi]

As long as it doesn't turn into a Watch Dog episode, it should come out soon.

[@Sossy64]

me 2

[@TacNaynMC]

And now, Hello Neighbor's plot is going to be completely redone.

[@exodus4550]

I like your name IHadNoIdeaThatGoogleAllowedYouToChangeYourNameIntoSomethingSoRidiculouslyLongAndStupidLikeIDidHere

[@EnderSheeper]

I think I've seen you somewhere before. I recognize that username.

[@ami8643]

IHadNoIdeaThatGoogleAllowedYouToChangeYourNameIntoSomethingSoRidiculouslyLongAndStupidLikeIDidHere lol exactly

[@saratemp9915]

IHadNoIdeaThatGoogleAllowedYouToChangeYourNameIntoSomethingSoRidiculouslyLongAndStupidLikeIDidHere

[@jeffthebeast3816]

IHadNoIdeaThatGoogleAllowedYouToChangeYourNameIntoSomethingSoRidiculouslyLongAndStupidLikeIDidHere

[@fuzzyheartz4673]

"visit the neighbor!" they said. "You'll make new friends!" *THEY SAID*!!!!

[@corahaileyandspeedy4018]

Who's they?

[@LaluzdelaLunaEsp]

traci it's a meme

[@j.epstein7723]

Traci Jones its a meme ب_ب

[@Tinskap]

No one has ever said that

[@j.epstein7723]

Tinskap they said is a meme stupid. look up "they said meme"

[@OOZTIN]

2016: we teased the story of how a man is working with the devil to rule the universe. 2017: *It was all a dream! :D*

[@geno9788]

The neighbour's drinking out of a cup with a goats head and horn, a traditional satanic reference. You got Faust before that really lol.

[@geno9788]

Also Faustus makes a deal with Mephistopheles a demon not lucifer. Kinda nitpicking but I just saw the play, really good.

[@mattiegr6423]

Good point. The Neighbor's partner is more likely Mephistopheles than Satan himself.

[@Deoster]

yeah I thought it was what he was going to say in the look closer part

[@aazhie]

Cup looked like a bull head rather than a goat to me ;D but it's pretty abstract

[@aazhie]

ouch XD it burns

[@Natalie-ze7ql]

"That was the message the mailbox was trying to *deliver*"

[@slashisotonic5191]

Chocolate Cat OwO -opens door- leave now 😂❤️

[@ooeygooeygoodra3068]

Chocolate Cat OwO best joke I've heard today!

[@Natalie-ze7ql]

+OoeyGooeyGoodra thank you

[@다나.진부한]

On point I say so myself XD

[@fayewars]

FFS

[@poodlepunch9154]

Matpat: See anything that's say, um, a bit off? Me: Yes, there's a shirt that has 69 written on it Matpat: There's a female skinsuit Me: oh

[@SageAhlanHuskySAORDER]

RECENT

[@F-cel3ss]

Thought that was a sports Jersey, you can see the neighbor working out so, mabey he plays sports :/? *shrug*

[@cherylbohman6518]

@@F-cel3ss maybe the neighbor just got the drip

[@mikethewhizz5085]

I think the piano hit is also three tri-tone note pairs. Tri-tones are often used to create harsh stinger noises, but they're considered the devil's interval because of its sound

[@JasM1331]

Nobody: Still nobody: Not even the FBI: Matpat: OH FART NUGGETS

[@JasM1331]

Madelyn Hennings aw thank youuuuuu!!

[@royalqueer7795]

@Madelyn Hennings I find it really funny when someone uses an anime characters name and comment on videos that present them 😂

[@JAKqkak]

Lel, read this as he said it XD

[@widgetfilms]

So, would you say that his "sole" was sealed by the devil?

[@diamondhatchett4722]

Wyvernblue i now have cancer

[@widgetfilms]

You're welcome.

[@Sergeant_Bastion]

Wyvernblue Let's get this more likes people

[@AhoyDanDan]

Wyvernblue he needs to see this

[@XPmaybe]

kill me

[@Vyn_REALITY]

Between jaws of justice SECURITY SHARK

[@Vyn_REALITY]

Prepare to be FINished SECURITY SHARK

[@drnerf193]

KittyQuake18 Gaming I loved the security Shark part

[@metrofugitive2928]

LOL loved that part

[@generalgrievous2745]

In part 4:17 its funny

[@generalgrievous2745]

i mean 5:00

[@serpentymeisdead]

"Its the holiday season!" As I sit here sweating at 5: 07 o clock, July 11...

[@jindo5]

"It's like the biggest leap of logic that I could ever make" Wario is 10 ft. tall Ness is Sans Is the Neighbor being a clown REALLY the biggest leap of logic you could make?

[@Oscar97o]

Where does the "Wario is 10 ft. tall" theory come from?

[@moisesblandon9136]

Oscar97o fart rocket physics video

[@georgemosidze1794]

Alexander Ar. yes and i am a pink fluffy unicorn jumping on rainbows

[@jindo5]

Alexander Ar. And where did you get that information from? Because his theory is complete bullshit.

[@-ZH]

PandaPickle! it's been confirmed by the creator of undertale that sans is not ness

[@ronincruickshank4175]

I found a way to prove the Devil is in the game. You just have to throw some toast in the air and if it lands jelly side down the Devil is near.

[@rabnadskubla8594]

Did you get that from Nostalgia Critic?

[@ronincruickshank4175]

RABNAD SKUBLA Yeah

[@TheGoldenNeil]

Ronin Cruickshank JELLY SIDE DOWN, JELLY SIDE DOWN!

[@sonicroachdoggjrraven3263]

Ronin Cruickshank XD LOL THAT'S SO FREAKIN GREAT

[@crazycoolben13]

GENIUS!!!!!

[@emmaaadoddd]

*looks at Winkie face* "semi colon, open parenthese" I'm dead😂

[@ralphanthonyespos9417]

Glad to know I'm not the only one to notice!

[@imogenroberts1658]

Short_Stuff _620 Thing is tho... isn't it a closed parentheses?? ;)

[@emmaaadoddd]

Imogen Roberts Omg lol it is... I'm dumb! ^o^

[@imogenroberts1658]

Short_Stuff _620 No MatPat says it too!😂😂 I reslistened like 5 times just to make sure😂

[@kylewoodard5347]

I rushed to the comments to see if anyone else noticed lmao

[@Justtiredyay]

2016 Matpat: Freddy, Foxy, Bonnie, Chica and… Sharky! 2022 Matpat: *screams in Fazbear Frights*

[@AvocadoDiaboli]

So you think the devil is after his soles?

[@DiskCord]

Leto Atreides II "soles"

[@hayabusafs8476]

Leto Atreides II why would the devil want the bottom of your shoe?

[@silvertotodile6958]

Leto Atreides II yes, shoe bottoms are what the development wants

[@leob0v0b93]

Leto Atreides II i applause

[@prestonzingg1399]

Nice joke

[@billythedog6485]

When he said the neighbor had a "partner", I thought this theory would go a COMPLETELY different direction. I literally thought this game would be about a kid napping, gay, clown couple. Whoops

[@danielroy2822]

Kookie and Joons Expensive Girl lololol

[@masakoseptianingrumo2370]

Kookie and Joons Expensive Girl i love your name hahaha

[@PennyLovesKitties]

same

[@Crancebarry1432]

Kookie and Joons Expensive Girl 😂

[@lostmaknae667]

Kookie and Joons Expensive Girl I knew I would find an ARMY hea😂

[@maddikemp7789]

*hE KnOwS wHEn sOmEThiNgS FisHY!!!!* *SECURITY SHARK!!!!!!*

[@SmplyBoi]

7:14 “A child coughing, a baby whining, a female crying…” DAMN BRO THOSE PEOPLE ARE BEING TAKEN HOSTAGE AND YOU’RE SPITTING BARS

[@madelyn8174]

Maybe the woman and children were his wife and she wanted to leave him be he didn't want her to leave so he trapped them The tables have turned

[@JayGotGameBruhXL]

thats a good theory

[@reflectra4194]

JayGotGameBruh A good game theory!

[@sansthespidergod3995]

why was the little girl saying RUN!!

[@sansthespidergod3995]

why was the little girl saying RUN!!

[@monsjoseph573]

Maddie B :3 Hmm....that's also a possibility....oh I know something else! What if the wife loved someone else and tried running away from the neighbour but he caught her and is trapping her as hostage with her kids? That's just a theory...a game theory!

[@sillymooncartoons3375]

So here’s a theory: When playing “Hello, Neighbor” and you get into the basement, you’ll notice that you only hear a woman and children screaming. Nobody else. If the children are really the kidnapped woman’s biological mom, than maybe they are the neighbors family. The neighbor and the kidnaped woman had a two (maybe one I’m pretty sure you hear two different child sounding screams but whatever) children, but they abandoned him. Left him alone in there old winding house. Any normal person would try to move on, if needed get a therapist, ex. Okay good. But the neighbor isn’t the most stable guy, now is he? Instead of moving on, he kidnaps them. Makes sure they can never leave again. Maybe the neighbor does more.......... sexual things to the children’s mom. I didn’t look into the logistics of this theory, but if I where you I would look deeper into it.

[@your_dad_on_vacation]

That sounds like a really good and logical/normal theory 👍

[@vene.__x]

Player: *Goes in house and attempts to go upstairs* SECURITY SHARK: So YoU hAve ChoSen Death.

[@morganeskyetattoo]

I never thought about this before, but the hiding room could be in the basement to protect the family from would be ‘rescuers’. He may have brainwashed them that if anyone comes down they need to hide, or maybe they don’t want to be found. She may have screamed when they got checked on, worried that the player was the one who opened the door.

[@patrickikose5803]

Security Shark is going to be the new Psychic Fred Bear.

[@xxsuperjackgamerxx1622]

ah the security shark so funny and the shark is a robot shark

[@lemonshark2038]

+XxsuperJackgamer xX I'm a shark :D

[@danielisgamer]

Patrick Ikose That's what I said

[@patrickikose5803]

masterofthediamondsword Oh, I'm sorry.

[@danaskunca2679]

He's here, he's there, he's everywhere! Who ya gonna call? Physic friend Fred bear!

[@abreebee]

*watches into* ... Yep, imma hide in the comments.

[@Charlie-cl5ny]

If ya need any company I'm right in those comments with ya

[@bisexualichigo4227]

I just found out this game exists, and I was like “I bet Matpat has a theory on it” And surely enough, yes.

[@Alizarin2565]

I find it hilarious that Matt Pat thought it would be so out of the question that Fnaf would make a robotic shark, but here we are

[@0DarkTime0]

15:24 You sure he isn't just talking about getting hella high? I mean, "I will be like the most High."

[@svetlanachapskaya5313]

lol I'm actually laughing rn

[@barvem851]

Hey, could work as a sub theory. A man making a contract with the devil to get the best weed the world's ever known!

[@chubledoobles4257]

Temisk i will be, like, the most high dude

[@ramontorres2720]

L

[@100dead]

"Like, I would be the most high, dude." LMAO

[@theobserver4214]

Even more evidence, the Alpha 1 download is 666 MB for the download

[@theobserver4214]

Zvonimir Emanuel Matijašević same.

[@AshesandFlames]

Me too!

[@theplaguedog69]

Blank Blank TRIGGERED

[@croissant2137]

Blank Blank I bet you it doesn't even take up that much space and they just added extra stuff to get that number

[@phil5172]

Jordan Tavares I'll bet you nothing

[@jmc7262]

Can't you just call the police?

[@squiiishee9505]

You'd still need evidence, but then again, JUST RECORD THE SCREAMS AND RUNNNNNN!

[@couchsmell6969]

Without ny proof, the police would arrest you instead.

[@jennifercavenee7572]

Bye innocent victims, bye yourself.

[@TNTMans]

I don't think that's how police work...

[@alexmoscatelli149]

lol police never does it work anyway so, its kinda useless! just watch some Marvel or action movies!

[@trash-boiii]

It is sad to see how when the game finally came out, everything that was promised wasn't fulfilled and they also ruined their own game making it more complicated than it should have and trying to stick more to the theme that fnaf games have

[@layer3086]

2:57 security shark best part ever

[@spinosaurus4728]

Yay, psychic friend fredbear has a new friend, SECURITY SHARK

[@fishyfishy3140]

Spinosaurus47 he deserves it.

[@spinosaurus4728]

Yeah lol

[@shootingstar2550]

Spinosaurus47- I was going to comment that 😂 😝 lololololol

[@briidoesgaming]

Spinosaurus47 he s here he's there he's everywhere! who do do you call? secrity shark

[@Whitewolffire10]

i must ask how on earth did you miss that the neighour's mug has a ram's head on it?

[@Whitewolffire10]

upon further inspection, i think it's a bull

[@Thadj1]

The first thing that comes to minds is Moloch, the biblical name for a god associated with child sacrifices often depicted as a bull. Leviticus (Where he is mentioned) 14:14 says: "The priest is to take some of the blood of the guilt offering and put it on the lobe of the right ear of the one to be cleansed, on the thumb of their right hand and on the big toe of their right foot." Here's the interesting thing, a "guilt offering" or a "trespass offering" is a sacrifice made to compensate for trespassing one way or another.

[@marianna3443]

Lucian Balthazar Atleast he got the theory correct

[@Mylesdesu]

Maybes that's what his update is gonna be about

[@musicmore9167]

that's was the first thing i noticed.