Forza Horizon 5 vs The Crew Motorfest | Cars Engine Sound Direct Comparison | Different Engine Types

Forza Horizon 5 vs The Crew Motorfest | Cars Engine Sounds Direct Comparison | Different Engine Types
Hello everybody! If you enjoy my videos, please press subscribe to my channel, click the like button and leave a comment. This is my motivation for recording new videos.
In order to avoid copyright infringement, please do not upload this video on your channel.
#forzahorizon5 #thecrew #thecrewmotorfest

[@k.r.99]

Forza sounds are recorded mostly in an open field like a runway etc. and thus lack in bass. They just push the metal to the metal and record it that way. The Crew sounds like they do it in a studio or garage with very good mics and filter out the echo.

[@rulingmoss5599]

Nah forza sounds are legit just synthesized

[@Cansislol]

@@rulingmoss5599 Not anymore. That was in Forza Horizon 4. For 5 they recorded at least most of the sounds from real cars. Still a long way to perfection I must admit.

[@Qimchiy]

​@@CansislolIt can still sound synthesized even if it's recorded. Driveclub for example. Regarded as one of the best sounding car games, and it is the best for surround effect. On higher revving engines it sounds synthetic because of the triple engine effect but something like the Regera sounds so good and bassy because it isn't a high revving screaming engine. Forza Horizon 5 is more consistent. Consistently synthetic. Probably because most cars are higher pitched compared to real life, while lacking bass, and the pitch shifting is way more obvious.

[@jonathanseibert761]

@@Cansislol I’m surprised anybody still believes their marketing. The “we recorded sounds” bullshit was disproved as soon as they used carryover sounds from FH4 and glued them all over the place. And the GT350? What the fuck even is it? FM7 was immaculate and then they shit on it with whatever the fuck FH5 did

[@PixelatedWolf2077]

​@Qimchiy See, this is a proper explanation of why I like FH5. Even Motorfest suffers from the synthetic issue, but not as pronounced as FH5 thanks to how they do the shifting sound. Lol

[@saamuellutter]

As a Forza player, I think The Crew has a bit better engine sounds but I hate the "bangs" on the gear shifts, just unrealistic

[@playz_t]

We play games to escape reality

[@bottomtext593]

Some race cars have those bangs.

[@saamuellutter]

@@bottomtext593 Correct me if im wrong, but in The Crew, all cars have those gear shift "bangs"

[@gamingeuphoria7928]

​@@playz_tlmaoo ur slow.. Motorfest has cars that look and sound like real life yet when we critizise the pop and bangs you go "We PlAy GaMeS tO eScApE rEaLiTy" lmaoooooooo

[@playz_t]

​@@gamingeuphoria7928 I forgot this comment even existed since im mostly on TikTok so ignore

[@MRGAMEZ03]

Only problem is in the crew shifting sounds its unrealistic

[@vlpaabnormal2064]

Zzz I can feel this better

[@DeepFried2607]

its an arcade game plus it makes the shifting so much more satisfying

[@aimarowenhuarte]

I combine Forza gear shift and crew sounds and it's golden

[@Josh-ig1ve]

And everything has a turbo

[@Toxic2T]

@@DeepFried2607 lmao 'iTs An aRcAdE' like it justifies it not representing the real car sounds

[@rmderke248]

Motorfest sounds better, but I still enjoy FH5 more as a game.

[@DaRandomChannel-tz4sj]

Facts

[@CorsairWT]

fully agree

[@SakuraGundamR34]

as a game? both ARE video games incase you didnt noticed...

[@rzXavier]

@@SakuraGundamR34 he means car sounds aside. he believes FH5 is a more well rounded game overall.

[@ruggs0_037]

​@@SakuraGundamR34 man youre really dumb huh

[@LevyTheGamer]

As a Forza Player, this is an EZ Win for The Crew Motorfest. Forza can’t even find realistic sounds. Let alone have correct pitches

[@notyouraverageyoutuber3172]

Problem is FH5 messed up every aspect of the game lmao, besides graphics but those were always kinda the same since FH4

[@lucky3320]

as a lie detector this is the worse lie i’ve ever seen u probably have less then 100 cars and only 20 of them are modded and all of them have swaps motorfest has literally the worst sounding cars and we nit even finna talking about the graphics😂

[@carterwells2144]

@@notyouraverageyoutuber3172nah frrrr, love the game, but there’s really nothing that makes it feel like a festival IMO, FH1 was…perfect

[@vitr0la062]

​@@lucky3320 fanboy 😅

[@luxyt1255]

@@lucky3320forza simp 🤡🤡🤡🫵

[@DriftFlow116]

Clear win for motorfest

[@Thehumboldtvlogger]

Yes but having played both forza horizon 5 still takes the overall dub as motorfests physics are soooo bad and while some will enjoy the the majority (especially drifters,tuners) will find the game to be almost unplayable as the drifting is practically non existent while forza has some of the best drift physics, and tuning literally doesn’t exist

[@Lysy.2.2T]

Have you ever drifted or drived in assetto corsa?

[@brooklynbeattie9293]

@@Thehumboldtvloggerforza is boring as shit and horrible 😂😂😂

[@brooklynbeattie9293]

@@Thehumboldtvloggerforza does NOT have the best drifting physics 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀 it’s so bad

[@nicog4638]

​@@brooklynbeattie9293 better than nfs and the crew

[@gumball159_shorts]

you have no idea how happy it makes me that you used a lambo v10 rather than the lfa. ive seen so many ppl use the lfa as v10 sounds when its not the ordinary sound.

[@Truccid]

He probably wouldve but the lfa is not in motorfest

[@Thorfinn0607]

plus it's so overrated

[@markusplotz2259]

​@@Thorfinn0607 well just because you see plenty more R8s and Huracans doesn't mean that it is the best sounding V10 out there. It's either the CGT or the LFA. You know that when you already heard them all in reality.

[@Caffeinated-DaVinci]

@@Thorfinn0607 Except reviewers who drove the LFA have stood by their stance that it's one of the best cars ever made. Jeremy Clarkson insists it's the single best car he's ever driven. You can say it's overrated once you drive one. Or once they become popular because the LFA was a total commercial failure, and they took a loss on every single one they did manage to sell.

[@thetounsi6551]

Damn that 812 sound so perfect on motorfest

[@TavsWorld]

No it don’t if you’ve heard one IRL it’s disappointing

[@Majonespagrandis]

Doesnt have to be realistic to sound good​@@TavsWorld

[@g9blin603]

@@Majonespagrandistrue but in a car game where the cars are supposed to be REALISTIC, that is kind of the whole point of having realistic sounding cars so in turn NOT having realistic sounding cars is kind of dumb.

[@BVD_bandits]

That's not wrong

[@dontaviusbingletonthefourt1485]

@@g9blin603motorfest is an arcade game it’s not supposed to be that realistic dude

[@phillipsterling8447]

0:32 damn the vtec, bruh this is king

[@sekyro4388]

not a vtec crossover but ok. The guy just sped up. But yeah damn good engine.

[@marcos1669]

Forza sounds like a 10 years old game, good job on the sounds on The Crew

[@liuziyu8487]

no, even old need for speed sound better than this

[@GustavoOliveira-fo5et]

Nah bro, even 10 year old racing games sounds better lol

[@strider029]

Forza had better sounds in FH4. FH5 was just a downgrade.

[@gibon1431]

Driving in Forza feels much better than your childish The Crew =D

[@diablow1411]

That's because technically, Forza is almost a 10 year old game. It's basically just a reskinned FH3 made worse with live service updates.

[@swabloo1200]

Forza has great models and graphics but the crew sounds are on point (except shifting ones)

[@dakyno]

great models?

[@TheVOIDKingHimself]

The shifting sounds on the I4 are pretty realistic, not sure what you mean. The shifting sounds sound like your right near the car in the crew but in Forza it sounds like your far from it

[@aidenespinoza5861]

One thing I really don’t like about motor fest is the shaky up shifts on many cars that would never do that

[@tcgsamedia]

Gosh motorfest did so damn good with the 812 sound, why cant forza sound more realistic like in the older horizons😭

[@DarkDemonXR]

I dont know why I like a lot more the crew sounds, but could be because we are really burned of the low quality forza has been in the last years? I have to say tho, the Skyline sounds better on FH... motorfest misses something

[@brooklynbeattie9293]

The crew is so much more better, the first game were I actually feel like I’m going that speed

[@Jaymodtm]

U trippin that’s literally the one thing i miss from forza other then the upgradability,car availability,and car selection

[@mattia3253]

sense of speed on the crew is quite bad bro

[@Deadsphere]

You need to play NFS Prostreet and Shift 2 then.

[@EL_CHPP0]

Lying through your teeth

[@Twiggo_The_Foxxo]

I want you to get in a fast car in Forza and drive it on a road that isn't the main highway

[@Caffeinated-DaVinci]

Gotta give Ubisoft some credit, their sound design is better. But at least I'll still be able to play Forza Horizon 5 when Microsoft shuts the servers down. Meanwhile Ubisoft just shut down The Crew 1's servers and the game is completely unplayable, even singleplayer. Eventually Motorfest will go the same route because Ubisoft insists we don't own what we buy from them. Genuinely cannot believe how bad the sense of speed is in both games though. Going 120mph shouldn't feel like you're getting passed by NPC traffic

[@TheVOIDKingHimself]

Yeah Ubisoft is garbage.

[@alexm.180]

Holy.. the electric car sound from the Taycan sound wild in Mottorfest

[@smr8750]

For real , I’m obsessed with the sound😭

[@broskiidakid7129]

I miss when Audi sounded like the Lamborghini Huracán and Gallardo that V🔟 sound🔥 you can’t beat that

[@TheVOIDKingHimself]

In forza? Probably sounded like that because they reuse car sounds

[@Ponchoblatz]

The crew motorfest engine sound are more accurate to real life car sounds. Forza horizon car sounds are so weird sounds like a 10-year-old game

[@jacobramos8326]

Shifting sounds better in forza tbh and the graphics are miles ahead of the crew

[@gamingeuphoria7928]

​@@jacobramos8326where talking about sounds you fanboy jeez so cringe

[@Just_A_Border_Hopper]

@@jacobramos8326just because he is stating a fact doesn’t make him a fanboy

[@Toxic2T]

@@gamingeuphoria7928 lmao the crew fanboy got triggered.

[@Ponchoblatz]

@@Just_A_Border_Hopper that’s true

[@samowen7080]

i prefer the crew's engine sounds but i don't like the clunk between shifts and the rpm shaking after a shift

[@m1sst4k37]

clunk is really questionable, but rpm shake is pretty realistic (engines in real life are not welded to the body, they are mounted on soft rubber mounts)

[@samskinner213]

Man, I need to start playing the Crew! It sounds so much better!

[@emsii7207]

it only sounds better, the physics there are horrible... its imposibble to drift, or play on a racing wheel, the wheel just has its own life XD

[@Adrianinhd]

@@emsii7207the physics aren’t horrible they just aren’t based as much on realism, which isn’t a bad thing imo. It’s refreshing to play something that feels a little more fun than real.

[@rotoocold3444]

@@emsii7207most of y’all clearly haven’t played since early crew 2 days motorfest is way better for drifting now

[@josemigueljimenezgarcia8033]

En Horizon los sonidos son como una auténtica lavadora a punto de estallar

[@sergeortiz6183]

Jugué motor fest no me gustó por más buenos sonidos de autos que tenga no me lleno cómo forza horizon pero si hay que aclarar que en sonido de motor es mejor de crew pero nada más eso a mi parecer

[@aligutierrez3440]

Jajajjaa que exagerado

[@Toxic2T]

mi compa el menos exagerado:

[@alexisg4576]

​@@Toxic2T es la verdad XD

[@marcoantoniocebadacardiel8541]

Cállate fanboy

[@user-zw7pu3hz7i]

İn the motorfest, the drivers while shifting opens the window and uses gun

[@ReFr4ct1oN]

The only reason I still don't have Motorfest in my library is that it's a Ubisoft game and I don't want to support Ubisoft in any way...

[@ragamerzzone597]

Why

[@rTrickz]

@@ragamerzzone597r u serious bro

[@UsuarioDeSubstancias]

​@@ragamerzzone597they are not trustable anymore

[@user-gc2be2xf5i]

They need a chance

[@ivladykt9270]

It's actually quite a decent game. Give it a chance. I love both Forza Horizon 5 and The Crew Motorfest.

[@josenunez6411]

As a forza Enthusiast i think the crew is on point with the sounds except the shifting part

[@B14.Shawno]

Only thing i hate abiut the motorfest sounds is almost every car has a loud turbo or superchager. Like this one Mercedes is stock with a loud turbo

[@arenek3737]

Forza has better and more realistic sounds, but on the other hand, those from The Crew (at least to me) are more fun and are simply cool

[@camiones_aviones]

For me Forza has the most unrealistic sounds

[@ksarito3965]

Forza has terrible engine sound

[@pos1571]

The crew still got good sounds

[@konkeydong6907]

I love the sounds in Motorfest and I actually really like the driving mechanics this time compared to Crew 2. Arcadey but it feels organic and natural. However I got really bored of Motorfest after a few playlists and I think thats the problem with Motorfest now. Too little cars, too little things to do. Forza you could almost infinitely grind for the next car, and in Motorfest there just isn't enough incentives to grind. Forza needs to do something about their outdated driving physics and sounds to make the next Horizon actually worth buying, and not just giving us a new map.

[@yongling9825]

TCM's physics feel more realistic this time, now you really can't brake late like you would in other arcade racing games. Even RWDs without TC enabled require controlled throttle inputs to prevent spinning out in corners. All to prompt players to drive better, which I'm all for it. I even caught myself not using my nitrous as often as I usually do in any other game.

[@nightwolf9375]

I love the fact that they remade most of the engine sounds from the crew 2! Still think some of the newer cars should be louder imo.

[@aftabzaman7022]

The Crew Motorfest ❤

[@ClaytonamoBay]

It also depends on what exhaust you go with on Forza. Stock, Street, and Race exhaust all sound different.

[@OliverMattison]

We need a Forza with the crew sounds

[@potatodonkey1856]

Whoever did the sound for Motorsport definitely knows their stuff

[@santiagogalvezpulgarin1514]

The Crew Motorfest engine sounds are better than Forza's (Almost all), but i think the V8 Engine sounds better in Forza tho (i have heard that Shelby GT500 in real life, and sounds legit like the one in Forza).

[@abuabdullah8024]

4:30 lowkey sounds like the pagani from the transformer movie

[@ragamerzzone597]

Let’s be real both games are good But motorfest is better. I love forza horizon too Both are incredible. No FIGTHING

[@Adrianinhd]

Imo: The Crew is the perfect example of what Forza Horizon used to be and how its much better than what Forza Horizon js now.

[@MziModesto]

In Motorfest, all sounds sound like a remade V10 or V12 In Forza, the difference between engine sounds of different variations is much brighter

[@buckshotcannon6038]

There’s good and bad about both games in general beyond just the sound, a lot of forza sounds suck but I think it’s fair to say that forza features a better handling model.

[@VitalkaGamer]

Забавно, как все хвалят Motorfest за звук, который звучит будто его записывали в студии, но забывают , что Forza имеет raytracing и звуки в пространстве распространяются так как должны, а не так, будто машина стоит в комнате

[@MimikU7812]

Its funny that everysingle sound is better in The Crew's side hahaha

[@n1co2017]

i'd say the crew is a lot worse for electric

[@lucky3320]

dang i didn’t know mustangs sounded like a temu corvette and shifting was supposed to sound like your trans is having a meltdown 😂

[@bencezavarko7312]

​@@n1co2017it's not realistic but way more fun. I really hate electric cars but The Crew was the first game where it was kinda good to drive them

[@ksarito3965]

@@n1co2017no the Porsche actually sounds like that in real life it has speakers

[@tcgsamedia]

Nah the R34 i6 and the Mustang V8 sounds better in forza imo

[@Whatintarnationisthat]

Give me a game with Forza graphics, crew sounds (minus some personal dislikes), mixture of maps and customization and I’d play all day

[@kaiogomes9519]

the lighting at the crew motorfest is incredible

[@ceverett68]

I've played all the horizon and the crew games. physics are better in horizon. sounds are better in the crew. let's not talk about the shifting in the crew though

[@DeathgripSTEZE]

If i played arcade games id be on motorfest… and im a fm7 player

[@NoHateBro66]

I love the gtr sound in the crew, sounds amazing

[@josemigueljimenezgarcia8033]

En sonidos de coche motorfest le da mil patadas a Horizon 😂😂😂

[@Nuno-x9d]

2021 vs 2023

[@mEmEzMaN...]

​@@Nuno-x9d 2 years to fix their shit

[@josemigueljimenezgarcia8033]

@@mEmEzMaN... Exact!!!!!! Jajajajaja

[@Cxsh_Wing]

I feel like for a better but crew more fun cuz of the city and how it feels and look when the wheel turns in first person

[@Ronaldo_-s3m]

The bang in the shifting is because the turbine

[@bencezavarko7312]

Motorfest sounds are incredible

[@LastSimmer]

I think FH5 performs better on everything else, maybe the sound, not that much.. but graphics, game engine, game modes, immersion, even something as simple as mirrors (yes, motorfest has dummy mirrors), control mappings, everything is way better.. at least in console.. don't know about PC but well, motorfest ain't cheap.. I was dying to get the crew 2 on PS4 and now that I have it, I barely played it.. I decided to spend my money rather on getting an Xbox and play FH5

[@IIAzamukaII]

From a personal opinion, Forza will always be a bit better in the graphics, but to me The Crew always has better sounds for vehicles, I just wish they'd change the speed thing, I'd rather be able to play and actually feel as if I'm going 230MPH rather than 90.

[@Thomas160r]

I Can hear italian v10-v12 in Porsche and Shelby from motorfest

[@bagelbomb1887]

Motorfest is all about the cars and immersing you in the driving experience and the sounds are next level ! I deleted Forza after trying to enjoy it again but after the crew it just feels generic and lifeless. It's hard to put your finger on exactly what makes it so underwhelming compared to Motorfest but in the heat of race it never feels exciting and just great fun in a way the crew absolutely nails and once you've heard those engine sounds for yourself it's very difficult to go back to Forza 😂

[@loganross984]

If the crew had forzas handling physics it'd be damn near perfect

[@losresubidosdeluves1918]

The 2 games sound very good to me, probably motorfest is a little more accurate but saying that Horizon cars sound bad is literally not having ears

[@OnkelRobinjo]

The V8 sounds in The Crew Motorfest are actually insane

[@TheGamblerman123]

A lot of cars sound very good in both games, still Motorfest might be better. In Forza the sound even changes with different intaktes or exhaust systems, so you should not compare the stock sounds to a Motorfest Sound. But: I am annoyed by Ubisoft, the strange handling of the cars, the playlist system and the ridiculous shifting sound, which fits just a few cars well. Went back to Forza last week and the game ist much better as I remembered after start playing Motorfest.

[@F22Raptor_]

At this point comparing crew motorfest with forza is like comparing a Rocket with a child

[@gtr35feet]

Every engine on forza Horizon 5 has buzzing sound

[@autisticroomba1165]

Love the crew engine sounds I just thing the stuttering during shifting is a bit cheese. Main difference is that you can actually hear the engine note changing over the rev range and also actually feels like it has some life to it. Forza has no excuse for having terrible engine sounds, they have the biggest budget, biggest player base as well as shown good potential back in FH2 and FH3. Plus games like NFS MW 2012 actually nailed the majority of car sounds (scarily close) of which this game is more than 10 years old. Get a grip Forza you pos

[@stankbagel1265]

I like the crew in every way better than forza, ill admit handling can be improved still but at least the car gets tossed around when you hit something unlike forza, and plus, im sure tge crew will go back to massive maps after having good success with the smaller but more detailed map making it even more of a pick for me

[@Rubenonclaps_YT]

Bro shifting in a electric car😂😂 Forza take some notes from the crew about electric cars

[@bruhmomentonumerotresgamin2188]

ayo the crew motorfest has insane sounds fr

[@G0LFman_1989yr]

Forza is evolving backwards with sounds

[@veranza5461]

i like the sound detail of crew

[@Igorxr7_]

The crew's gear changes are so bad, other than that the sounds are good

[@OllieDM910]

Motorfest drive by sounds are awesome

[@jan2606]

Motorfest sound designers cooked for real

[@m4te625]

ok but the crew motorfest has 2 year gap

[@nicolasfrullini1787]

@@m4te625 there are older games with better sounds

[@randymarsh4748]

@@m4te625 how much do u wanna bet fh6 is going to sound worse than motorfest? btw i odnt even like the r=crew but FH sounds so bad its getting worse with every game. fh2 had the best sound of the series

[@Bielzilla_o_pequeno]

O VR38 do R35 no The Crew Motorfest, faltou só um pouquinho para ficar idêntico com o da vida real

[@kennygo5053]

physics and handling, motorfest is way better. it just makes sense

[@DenimBullets]

why does every car in the crew sound like its turbo charged

[@ChrisJones-pi5mh]

Forza has never had great engine sounds. The Crew definitely wins for this, but Forza wins literally everywhere else.

[@nazaregomes1087]

Ok im going to buy motorfest NOW

[@bennm-ct5qm]

i heard a rx7 or something like that and they sound really cool i think it had a turbo or supercharger i dunno

[@yongling9825]

Did you hear a whine when it revs or a blowoff when the throttle is let off?

[@Grimreaper-g2i]

motorfest takes the win

[@TheCristopher7777]

You need testing the cars in manually to in motorfest.

[@LightThingies]

The only car that Forza sounded more realistic was the porsche

[@TritonLunar]

Any nfs from 10+ years ago destroys these

[@Stolen_GT]

lexus lfa from NFS MW 2012 ☠

[@Carsforlife_]

Motorfest is easily the better game. More colour. More vehicle types. Bikes. Way better customisation and clearly way better engine sounds too. It’s a better game. Prove me wrong

[@aymanabdalla7677]

كوضوح ومتعه فورزا تتفوق ولكن ك أصوات ذا كرو الأفضل

[@lockettlv]

Can Forza for ONCE hire a fucking decent audio designer?

[@wr_bx]

In the crew motorfest the cars have turbos (some, not all) and in forza Horizon 5 they don't

[@Rahulrawatgaming.]

Always Daddy Forza horizon 5 bro😅

[@samuelblack7314]

The Crew sounds a lot better, except for the shifting sounds.

[@mellogurke5866]

The flat six in fh5 is sooo much better if he would use the 991.2 not the 991.1

[@joseandresgonzalez7258]

Engine sounds are clearly better in the crew but god that shifting and turbo sound is awful.

[@lychee2ndsworkshop959]

Motorfest sounds better in general, but FH5 has a lot more road noise which is kinda neat.

[@Thiago787B]

Motorfest perfect sounds🤌🏽🔥

[@Yomamaowner2137]

Only engine sounds are better in motorfest 😢

[@tcgsamedia]

Id say the only ones forza wins is the i6 and the v8. Everything else goes to motorfest but the shifting sounds unrealistic.

[@MeccanSamarraie]

So many cars in forza kinda unfair you can’t hear the car half the time, but Crew sounds way better

[@nughair1133]

The crew too vibrant

[@tallsuffer]

i think we need better cars to start with I5 Quattro F6 911 gt3 V6 NSX V8 458 Italia/ Jesko V10 LFA V12 Valkyrie

[@Jayden-Gaminggg]

Forza Horizon 3 best game in history, still better than Forza Horizon 4 and 5

[@johnnytacosauce]

Forza horizon 5 has the best handling, the crew has the best audio and need for speed has the best action i will listen to no other opinions mine is set 😈😂

[@joeschipper6465]

horizon 5 has mostly accurate sounds but they feel like they lack bass or something idk what it is

[@danialrodrigues7603]

Motorfest has the best sounds of all cars

[@mixaz7869]

Forza would have won with a better map

[@Exoticsfree]

Beamng sounds arent accurate but if u get the right mods they sounds noice