Gas vs Inertia Driven Shotguns

[@AnthonySmith-sc4zs]

It’s nice to see an intelligent explanation about the two types of cycling actions. Excellent video.

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks!

[@donhuynh5186]

Hat off to you from US. Best informative comparison of both systems.

[@EnglishShooting]

Thank you!

[@cabbage0dusk]

Glad to see English Shooting back on form with great unbias info!

[@JPJamster]

Inertia for me, used my Dad's Benelli years back, it was absolutely fantastic. Never had a cycling issue. Used to double tap at targets, so easy. The kick was not even an issue. Thank you for the video, great explanation!!!

[@uriahallen7212]

I dont mean to be off topic but does someone know of a method to log back into an instagram account?? I stupidly lost my account password. I appreciate any tricks you can offer me.

[@donaldjett8037]

@Uriah Allen instablaster :)

[@uriahallen7212]

@Donald Jett I really appreciate your reply. I found the site through google and Im in the hacking process atm. Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later when my account password hopefully is recovered.

[@uriahallen7212]

@Donald Jett It worked and I actually got access to my account again. I'm so happy:D Thanks so much, you saved my ass!

[@donaldjett8037]

@Uriah Allen Glad I could help :)

[@avocado9763]

Excellent. My beretta semi auto would act up after 125 rounds. My gun was highly maintained and was still very tempermental. Used high quality ammo. Didn't matter. Nice job.

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks for watching!

[@robertsalyers1351]

I'm getting my first ever simi auto shotgun and I am excited. I've only owned 12 gauge and I am moving on to a 20 ga simi auto. I am hoping the Stoeger M3020 has less recoil for me. I am a small game hunter who loves light recoil weapons

[@Thatguy96103]

@@thatskrazy8145 youre opinion is 🗑

[@littytitty4670]

@@thatskrazy8145 just ask the hundreds of ducks I’ve killed with a 20 gauge at 20 to 40 yards how they feel about your point blank statement lol.

[@cesarpareja2002]

@@thatskrazy8145 c’mon bro ! Trust me you will be a better person and feel better if you respect other people opinions

[@jakemonster001]

Good stuff English Shooter! Very happy to see gun culture thriving in the UK!

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks, as am I but still loads more people to get shooting still here!

[@jakemonster001]

@@EnglishShooting I have some friends over there who want to go shooting for the first time - I'd love to send your way. :)

[@hawgleyferguson9832]

Great presentation. I was entertaining the thought of getting a semi auto shotgun. Now I know the nuances of both systems. Thank you!

[@20cameron1]

Real solid and honest details. Too many cover up and gloss over the brutal facts. Would add gas gun performance depends on the quality. Some new models are not as well made as older models-Remington 1100 being a prime example.

[@jessesmith2906]

1100 being an example of good or bad quality

[@Marshall006]

Jesse Smith am example that they aren’t made as great as they were a long time ago. Meaning they are not “bad quality”, but not as good as they used to be

[@bgdesignandsolutions]

1100 is tough to beat. I have both the 2 3/4 and 3" versions. Never had any hiccups in either. Most of the time they just sit in my safe, but I used my 2 3/4 for dove earlier this year. Reminds me of the old days. Felt good.

[@sdriza]

​@@bgdesignandsolutionsLOVE MY 1100.....

[@TaistoTakkumaki]

Our World Champion Jarkko Laukia says that Beretta needs cleaning after 5000 rounds and I tend to agree. I have cleaned my Beretta 1301 Comp only twice so far. ;)

[@merelynx701]

This is an awesome video. I was looking for my first shotgun and came across a compact Weatherby 20 gauge but had never heard of a gas shotgun before. Now I know that that's NOT what I want! Thank you!!

[@brentdiehl4023]

I own a weatherby sa08 in that same configuration and haven't had a problem with it. If reliability is an issue, a good pump shotgun will serve you well.

[@sprayandprayhunting5711]

I have a akkar altay and it cycle every thing i put in it, it is a beast cleaning wise i clean it every 2/3 weeks lightly and then maybe after a season i clean it internaly and always cycled from the low low loads to the heavy loads

[@fren111]

summing up inertia is a little harder to use, but needs less maintenance and is more reliable

[@EnglishShooting]

Pretty much!

[@Monotheizt]

But the recoil 👀

[@johnherbert5919]

I moved to gas guns a few years back, faster shot to shot times because of the reduced felt recoil. If you want a gas gun that shoots anything get one that uses the Benelli M4 gas system. This twin piston system is very reliable, needs far less cleaning than a traditional gas system. Used in Benelli M4, Remington Versamax and Turkish Sulans.

[@onuronur451]

Sorry.. What mean Turkish sulans? Don’t know that gun.😞

[@johnherbert5919]

@@onuronur451 Sulan is a copy of the Benelli M4 made in Turkey. I believe in the US they sell under another name.

[@sdriza]

Dad and I been using Remington gas models (58 and 1100) since 1959 and had pretty darn good luck with them....

[@mikehobbs7421]

I own a beretta a350 with the blink has system and a Benelli M2 with THE inertia system. I do not shoot any competitions with either of them but I do waterfowl hunt and shoot sporting clays and can honestly say that the blink has system can go 100’s if not into the 1000’s of round without cleaning and no cycling issue and I’m a ride it hard put away wet kind of guy with me gear. The M2 same thing. Biggest difference between the 2 is felt recoil. Gas gun shoots softer inertia fires every round under the sun but has a little more pop in the stock. The beretta needs 1200fps or more to cycle perfectly which is fine by me. Great video! Cheers from Canada eh 🍻🇨🇦🤘

[@apsaffles531]

Great review, as a hunter, reliability is gonna be number one for me, so I guess I'm going with inertia driven.

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks for watching!

[@browningmaxus5360]

Iv gas 4 years not one jam or missfeed

[@yummyKFCstuff]

i personally hate gas operated shotguns because of its extremely annoying cleaning process and bad weight balance. That's the reason i sold one. Now I'm a Stoeger m3k owner and i stand for inertia driven shotguns for IPSC. Nice video! Greetings from Russia!

[@Saviour3]

1976 I bought a Remington 1100 Trap semi for $179; over many, many years I never had a problem, ever ...

[@Bill_Liggon]

I have a stoeger m2000 self defense and I love it. I have heard people complain about it not cycling but I have never had problems even with birdshot. I just wish it held 6 or 7 shells and not only 5. Either way it’s a great gun.

[@jimhamilton3544]

Excellent presentation, I have a couple auto-5’s Silver Hunter ( which is about the worst shotgun I have owned), a Bennelli auto ie (all 12Ga’s and I have always found the Browning Auto Lt 5 has less recoil than my gas shotguns !ie( just the opposite of your conclusion). My thinking is the inertia recoil brake on the tube accounts for some of the recoil taken out ie ( with the recoil brake brass action-ring ). If the rings are set properly for the right load. 🤔😃 It has been my experience the gas guns have a faster and consistently harsher kick than the inertial guns ie (Auto-5 Lt 12Ga) 🥴

[@avocado9763]

Great job. I thought benelli could produce a much higher quality semiauto shotgun but I was WRONG! My semi auto beretta was that good either. Recommend your favorite recoil operated shot gun.

[@josephstalin6913]

Inertia shotguns only have feeding issues when u feed them light loads. I’ve shot plenty of slugs and turkey loads with out shouldering properly and no issues with heavy loads

[@eddyflo2978]

You said it, with HEAVY loads. Light loads wont have enough energy and will give you miss feeds as you mention. Both have good and bad

[@aqhasassy]

My first gun was a 1972 Remington 1100 12 ga. My husband was a VietNam vet & picked it out for me. He did very good. An inertia kicks like a mule. I’ve shot skeet with this, can shoot slugs. I still have it & as a woman it’s the only shotgun for me. Never ever a problem with this gun & it doesn’t require any special attention. I’ve had a gunsmith check it only bc of age, it’s in top shape. Remington doesn’t let you down.

[@DoubleM55]

I have a Benelli M1 super 90 (Inertia system), and I found it had issues only with some types of ammo (Low powered trap/skeet shells), but strangely only when I really held it hard against my shoulder. It acted better even with bad ammo when it had some slack, and then when it bumped on my shoulder it actually caused it to cycle correctly. I guess it's not possible to generalize, and every rifle is unique (Even the same brand/model acts differently depending on lots of factors).

[@JROCK100ification]

Limp shoulder =limp wrist

[@JRH6271]

Nice 1911 and Chiappa Rhino on the shelf behind you.

[@trxcummins7388]

Shot my Beretta a400 Xtreme plus this weekend ran hundreds of rounds through it of all different kinds from high brass to low brass to targets to duck rounds never had one issue

[@antonioadinolfi4052]

Great video. I’ve watched it again, very informative and based on your real experience. Well done.

[@EnglishShooting]

Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it 😀

[@cloudkicker-gx7gb]

Excellent informative video, was just thinking about this today

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks for watching 😀

[@freeandcriticalthinker4431]

When you state that you need to clean it often, how many "average" rounds are you talking between cleanings? Not competition clean, but just clean enough for fully expected operational proficiency? Thanks do much, cheers

[@codyrivenburgh2926]

Depends really....ive ran Remington 1187s for years and one would run 3 to 50

[@codyrivenburgh2926]

I mean 3000 to 5000 rnds a season with no cleanings ...amd then had other ones that may only run 250 to 300 rnds before starting to have issues....so really it depends.... Best advice I can give would be to clean regularly....if ur not clear regularly just shot it till it gets sluggish amd u start haveing issues then clean it

[@glocktown21]

LOVE THIS VIDEO!!! For a home defense shotgun... would you recommend the Stoeger Tactical M3000 semi auto OR The Beretta A300 Ultima?????

[@bgdesignandsolutions]

My Stoeger M3500 will cycle rounds my Browning Maxus won't. Both will shoot light loads through heavy. However, the Maxus messes up more with the 3 1/2 inch shells. Very disappointing when you get one shot and have to clear the jam. The Stoeger doesn't do that. Use a stock weight on the Stoeger, and cycling issues go to the wayside.

[@dancortes3062]

I personally prefer gas guns. I hunt waterfowl in a cold climate and want my gun to cycle reliably if I wear thick clothing. I also like having faster follow up shots. Yes they might have more trouble cycling the light target loads but it's not hard or expensive to find shells with heavier loads.

[@Sardarhussain248]

Is there any velocity difference between gas and inertia guns??

[@hilalbaburhan4231]

Great video. You explained very well👏👏

[@patrickkelly8095]

great comparison video, Ive been looking at Stoeger for an inexpensive Benelli option. I'm surprised about how finicky the beretta gas driven was though. My early 90's Remington 1100 will run anything through it and I havent cleaned it in two season. Remington is garbage now unfortunately but wanted to hear better from the Beretta.

[@adamw770]

Remington is not garbage. You only read that on some hunting page.

[@TheCenturion8404]

My beretta 1301 comp shown here has run ammo as low as 950fps and round counts into 500 without cleaning with “zero” issues. I like the comp so much I sold my benelli M4 after I bought the 1301 tactical which is also a beast

[@marks6290]

Great info. Thanks for sharing and teaching.

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks for watching!

[@leonard.l2671]

Clear explanation and balanced review!

[@AussieStandsWithRussia]

Gday mate Love the video. Could you help if you can tell me how the stoeger M3000 inertia driven operates compared to the Stoeger m3000 straight pull. I know well how gas operated shotguns work but the difference between inertia and straightpull eludes me. Regards

[@barry-cq4xg]

Great video. Are you planning on reviewing bulpupp shotguns any time in the future?

[@eddyflo2978]

I second this montion

[@Daywalkerbmz1188]

Love my 15 year old berreta 391 urika field. Runs flawlessly with 3in haha

[@shanecroftpodcast]

This was super helpful.

[@EnglishShooting]

Glad you think so!

[@AkrahMonafik]

Which semi-automatic hunting rifle is better in terms of sturdiness and fewer malfunctions of the gas system or the inertia system? I would like a reply

[@FreedomsLife1776]

This does not represent all shotguns. ARGO gas systems are substantially more reliable than what is represented here.

[@The10thManRules]

I doubt he said those two examples represented all semiautomatic shotguns. How do you qualify or quantify that the Argo is [more] reliable than the Stoeger. No all semiautomatic shotguns are designed for the type of gun games that the M3k and 1301 were designed for.

[@rigobertohidalgo2487]

What if the spring tension on the bolt spring of an inertia operated shotgun was lowered, so that it could cycle properly less powerful rounds and/or shoot it looselly held to the shoulder allowing the entire mass of the gun to move backwards (hence not providing the bolt enough strength to travel the distance it is supposed inside the gun in order to extract the spent case and/or feed a new one into the chamber). Is there a risk for some of the burning gunpowder from the exploding cartridge to escape through the ejection port and land on top of my face, clothes,flammable paperwork, or clean floor; If so how damaging could it be for the shotgun. Thank you I appreciate any clarity you could shine on that matter and great video by the way.

[@mchenryjeremy]

Then you'd start running into feeding issues where shells hang up going into the chamber. These manufacturers have the spring tension set to the optimal tension so that they can reliabily cycle as many different loads as possible.

[@fenheadfarm3262]

Open division magazine fed.... Job done 🙌

[@EnglishShooting]

I like my guns to work… 🤣

[@fenheadfarm3262]

@@EnglishShooting 😂 never had a problem..... Although I must admit I do prefer my benelli M2 (personal choice).

[@The10thManRules]

@@fenheadfarm3262 If you've never had a problem with a box fed, that tells me you don't shoot it enough, or at a competitive pace. OR, your box fed was gun smith'd to run right out of the box. My M3k runs. Eats everything shes fed and and never complains.

[@thegoru0106]

Great explanation

[@EnglishShooting]

Glad you think so!

[@jeffw.5462]

Very helpful video with practical insights.

[@EnglishShooting]

Glad to hear that!

[@mobeefus9707]

Very helpful. Thank you. I’ve decided to buy a pump action.

[@robertsalyers1351]

My pump Remington 870 in 12 gauge kicks like a Horse on Meth And That's why it's getting traded in on a 20 gauge Simi Auto right Now

[@mobeefus9707]

@@robertsalyers1351 funny story. I went with a Winchester pump and you are correct...it kicks like a mule. Live and learn.

[@ATINKERER]

That's just what I wanted to know!

[@ashy1423]

Thanks for this informative video👍

[@samrowe2889]

Sending out this message to see if what your opinion is on the benilli m4.

[@fneric]

Very insightful and helpful.

[@EnglishShooting]

Glad to here!

[@KKKKKKK-sr1fz]

Can you use also those semi auto shotgun filled with heavy buckshot for hog hunt ?

[@EnglishShooting]

Absolutely, slug as well if you need

[@KKKKKKK-sr1fz]

@@EnglishShooting wooow ok 👌🏼

[@In_con_ceivable]

So aside from cleaning, would a gas gun be better than an inertia gun for smaller stature guys…? or does it really just come to form and practise..?

[@mohamadkurdi1820]

Who needs to clean more the pomp action or the inertia?

[@neuvocastezero1838]

In another video, a reviewer described the Benelli MP40's gas system as being "self cleaning". Is this accurate?

[@meangreen320]

That just means it runs naturally cleaner and requires less cleaning and standard maintenance. So you can get of significant more shots off with the gun before it fouls beyond functioning reliably. Same goes for gas piston guns

[@neuvocastezero1838]

@@meangreen320 Thanks for the reply!

[@Mike41919]

Great video sir

[@stevenbodum3405]

i have an old 48al 12ga and it cycles with 24g trap shot, even if shooted one handed.

[@EnglishShooting]

Can’t beat the old ones!

[@stevenbodum3405]

@@EnglishShooting for the ultraweak loads, the trick is to remove the friction ring. i made a brass adapter ring without friction on the lathe. this old guns are not made to shoot todays weak sporting loads, but with this mod, auto 5s, bredas and al48 cycle the ceapest low brass ammo you can buy. so this old shotguns in 12-2/3/4 can shoot every ammo from 24-40 grams. only drawback, you cant switch between hot and weak loads without adjusting your shotgun.

[@JK-ic1ot]

Great video and explanation!

[@EnglishShooting]

Glad you liked it!

[@BillHimmel]

Great! Really helpful vid!

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks!

[@The10thManRules]

There are zero drawbacks regarding the Stoeger. Firing the shotgun while not properly shouldered, aka bad marksmanship, will get you DQd (disqualified) from the match. Be marksman at all times. Agreed, the M3K doesn't get dirty. Swab the barrel every few hundred rounds and carry on.

[@EnglishShooting]

It depends on the match and rule set but in IPSC people regularly shoot out of the shoulder, hip fire is specifically included within safety courses.

[@angeo11]

Great! What do you think of fabarm sat 8 tactical?

[@dave_724]

Is the Steoger available with a 28 inch barrel in the M3K blue is the only one selling it in the south and I'm just about to put on for my FAC shot one in NZ and there a great gun

[@ChrisHolman]

I'm in the market for a Binelli M3, best of Semi Auto and Pump.

[@henrynorth6558]

I have a gas gun: mossberg 930 but the range I go to only allows 28g loads so far I have found it not be to picky but it does have loading issues, do you have any advice to sort this please?

[@crushjacko6135]

Thanks much. I am now more informed to make a decision.

[@EnglishShooting]

Glad you found it helpful!

[@MIKEC2000]

Quite the opposite, gasshoot light loads better and inertia heavy loads

[@avisilvermann2838]

I use ELY 28G cartridges on my 1301 Comp Pro never failed to recycle

[@Monotheizt]

I'm from a 3rd world country. Looking to buy a baikaal MP 153 (gas gun) or maybe baikaal MP 156 (inertia). I'll be hunting birds. But like maximum 20-50 shots/year . Which would you recommend.

[@chadcowman6293]

I think inertia will suit me best. I'm 6'3 240 pounds. Recoil doesn't bother me as much.

[@toomuch9762]

Gorgeous guns

[@J_LOVES_ME]

Very informative, thank you!

[@DinoNucci]

TY for info!

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks for watching!

[@scottieeasley4907]

How do yo get your hands on guns in your country.

[@reddawng43x91]

I call bs on the inertia being less fussy on the super light loads

[@earldelsanto]

Im at 600 rounds with my a300 ultima patrol. Never a hicup. Light med heavy loads.

[@balkrishnaprabhu4766]

Sir Supurb video, all clear information, thank you ❤️

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks!

[@guerom1367]

Have u ever tried a tristar viper g2?

[@stephenm9944]

Very helpful thank you

[@jeffreyelliott622]

I'll stick with my tested tried and true early 80's Remington 1100 and my early 90's Remington 870 Magnum pump !!!

[@EnglishShooting]

Can’t go wrong with those!

[@RenuDevi-oo9uo]

Ka price hai iss gun kei

[@bradleyreams1026]

Gas does save recoil. My 12 gauge 940 gas has less recoil than a Franchi 20

[@spiros_s6100]

Beretta a 400 Its always normal to have an issue with cartidgies with this gun 😂 Try an older beretta 300,301,302,303,304,390 And then you will not have any issue

[@leifnilsen6107]

👏👏👏👏👏 Good video.

[@jjjo7352]

Great video but I dont think that shouldering it correctly is a flaw of an inertia gun rather human error.

[@epicfirsts888]

So inertia are easier to maintained and are better?

[@EnglishShooting]

Better is subjective, but I would say they are easier to maintain.

[@giggergigger1]

Definitely easier to maintain, definitely less fussy with ammo

[@8wealthyone8]

@@giggergigger1 So i will get interia shotguns...now... thanks that helped...

[@Urbanspacefox]

I mean it sounds like gas is easier to use while inertia is more reliable in the long run...

[@tiortedrootsky]

How strange... I thought more movement from recoil would make inertia gun more reliable...

[@toomuch9762]

Inertia is more reliable

[@markwebster9455]

I think that explanation was incorrect, the term inertia means to stay at rest which in an inertia gun, the bolt body try’s to stay at rest due to its mass, the gun needs to move rearwards from the recoil which pushes back the rotating bolt face, as the bolt face moves rearwards towards the bolt body which is trying to stay at rest due to its inertia, it compresses a spring inside the bolt body, the geometry of the bolt face causes it to rotate and unlock itself from the breach as it moves rearwards, once it’s unlocked from the breach and the spring is compressed, the energy in the spring is released and pushes the bolt rearwards, this is the secondary recoil Callum mentioned, moving rearwards it re-cocks the trigger, the spring under the fore grip then pushes the bolt back to the battery position. A bit long winded, but as far as I can see, the inertia shotgun needs to recoil freely to work.

[@tiortedrootsky]

I didnt understand why on 3:28 the gun fails when it can move farther. The answer is because to cycle properly the carrier has to have enough speed relative to the gun, and if the gun is free to move back, it catches up to the carrier. So the gun has to be able to recoil back for 4mm (0.16 inches) to compress the carrier spring. Then the spring will push the carrier back to press the cam track in the carrier against the cam lug on the bolt to unlock it, then extraction happens. After the gun traveled this 4mm it has to stop, so the carrier has enough speed relative to the gun. Theres good animation, search for "benelli inertia shotgun".

[@TheChopperwhopper]

Have you got your licences back?

[@EnglishShooting]

Not yet!

[@TheChopperwhopper]

@@EnglishShooting shame. I don't live in UK so i live under different rules but your channel really helped educate me on gun ownership. Shame the authorises have gone after the teacher. I hope you get them back need to let police know that you want to work with them and not against them. So maybe a heads up warning. Instead of a revoke of guns might be adequate as your promoting legal shooting to allot of people. Your not iust 1 person applying for a licence. Need the firearms officers to monitor your posts and have them tell you to take something down that might effect your ownership or if it is that inappropriate they should ask you to take down anyway. Rather see a post removed for legal reasons than have your licenses takeb away. The truth is that you don't have to make these videos and if you didnt you would still have your licences. The objective is the get people into the sport and educate which no one else is doing. Looks like you have been thrown under a bus Shame i hope the police can work with you rarther than against the person who has same objectiveals as them No one in the legal shooting community wants to see guns purchased for illagl activity. Defears the objective in purchasing a legal firearm Thanks

[@Nics574]

TheChopperwhopper licenses?

[@fenheadfarm3262]

Seen guys fire benelli M2, one handed and never missfired.... Not a fan of gas....

[@avocado9763]

Great job.

[@EnglishShooting]

Thanks!

[@АртемК-о5ю]

As the owner of a Benelli m2 shooting without stop and no problems with the suspension fractions 24г.stoeger it is not correct to compare with.

[@EnglishShooting]

I'm not comparing a the 1301 to the M3K, I'm comparing gas driven to inertia driven with the 1301 and M3K as examples....

[@АртемК-о5ю]

@@EnglishShooting for combat uniquely gas takes first place, and for sports and hunting is quite suitable inertial system with its ease of maintenance and a much greater resource, still cleaning the gas outlet a little ,but harder...what do you say to resource breakdowns updated Beretta 1301?In Russia, the first breakage was seen on Nasrallah 3000-4000 thousand rounds.

[@reidweathersby6450]

My stoeger won’t eject cheap shells

[@The10thManRules]

Don't feed it cheap/low velocity loads. Also, if your shotgun was used or worn-out, upgrade the ejector and spring. Check out MOA Precision.

[@calebsmith95]

You know that’s a light rifle when he held it with his right hand with an 80/20 balance point.

[@mattconklin4026]

👌🏼

[@J.O.A.T.s]

We're the Man.. Govenor 🇺🇸🇬🇧🇺🇸..

[@TheBlankmediams]

How can you compare an m3k against a 1301 Pro? There's like a grand between them

[@EnglishShooting]

Did I compare an M3K to a 1301 Pro Comp, or a gas driven gun to an inertia driven gun?

[@Andrey_ZH]

Я не понимаю в чем разница между ружьями, которые продают в вашей стране и которые продают в России. У меня ружье МР-155. Оно газоотводное. Никаких проблем. Работает на любых патронах. От 24 грамма, до 48 граммов. Я не спортсмен. Я просто охотник. Охота бывает в очень тяжелых условиях. Ружье справляется с любыми проблемами. Ружье стоеджер м3000 моего товарища работает на много хуже. Капризное. Нужно подбирать патроны. Легкие патроны не перезаряжает. Не работает. То же самое происходит и с другими инерционными ружьями. Газоотводные ружья для охоты на много надежнее. Проверенно много раз. Ваше видео не правда.

[@MOCKACHINO]

Nice chest hair #manlyMan #furryMic

[@EnglishShooting]

Just jealous 😘

[@earldelsanto]

Small difference. Recoil is no small issue. I dont care how big and bad you think you are.