GENESIS - Dancing With The Moonlit Knight (intro) / Carpet Crawlers - live in Birmingham, 22/09/2021

[@Eckstein1957]

Wow I love Genesis and Carpet Crawlers is a classic. Sad to see Phil in this condition but give him credit for performing and giving his best !

[@barryhester170]

He fills his Depends with such ease at his age. He makes sitting in a mess of coffee, prunes and a ribeye look second nature.

[@emanuelagranzotto7311]

Hello Andrew, I agree and I like that he passed on his passion to his son.

[@ronniemcnairney334]

Genesis should have kept going with Ray Wilson...and made NEW Albums !!!!!!

[@stevedrums1675]

@@barryhester170: Are you supposed to be funny

[@barryhester170]

@@stevedrums1675 Phil shit himself onstage in Chicago and Philly so far this tour.

[@Andrea-od3zr]

Tears and tears during performance. Remembering younghood and feeling the strength in Phil voice. Thanks for this extremely emotional drops of music.

[@alfamily586]

I never wanted the concert to end! A very touching farewell but what I enjoyed most was watching Phil really enjoying himself and getting to take it all in. Genesis will continue to be with me forever! ❤

[@SuperJohnnyO]

Nobody stays young forever, and I'm glad to see the boys doing their thing, because this is probably it! Thanks Tony, Mike, and Phil!

[@patriciadenis8767]

C'est très difficile de chanter assis, quel courage et force. Respect ! Phil est toujours remarquable et sensible. Phil donne tout à ses fans, c'est un être très généreux. Nous vieillissons tous et on voudrait que Genesis et Phil ne vieillissent jamais. Musique et groupe hors du temps, magique, éternel. Ce sont les meilleurs... 2021 Genesis and Phil still THE BEST in this world. Thanks for this video.

[@padronicusdiroma5936]

Phil , you're a Hero !

[@stevedrums1675]

Phil's voice is definitely stronger here than the first show.

[@frontporchanarchast]

I think Phil knew he needed to get his sh!t together after that first night. Good for him.

[@ThelSuperlKing]

Backing vocalists still covering him on the end of the high sustained notes......have you ever seen Genesis tour with BVs? There's a big reason why they do this time.

[@ThelSuperlKing]

@@jtlampsu2 Oh that's happening as well with the keys also lowered significantly. Look I don't mind people saying they went to see Genesis for sentimental reasons and essentially saying goodbye to Phil. I don't even mind people forgiving the very sub-par vocals by Phil because the concert is more valued for emotional reasons than actual professional singing. But no serious musician is gonna honestly say if that wasn't Phil Collins holding the mic or some other global legend that anyone singing like that will get anywhere near a pass from any pro level musician. It doesn't even pass for a karaoke competition. It's the emotional value that's important not the actual singing.

[@stevedrums1675]

@@ThelSuperlKing: They've never done it but it's minimal and it's also cool that they were able to take harmonies and previously unheard studio vocals like 'Afterglow' and 'Carpet Crawlers' and give the singers something to do while enriching the sound with it.

[@theno1deejay]

Think it sounds really week....

[@leszekwodarczyk2864]

Wspaniały człowiek, wspaniały artysta, wspaniały zespół wspaniały koncert. Muzyka GENESIS przetrwa stulecia. Dziękuję DGF za możliwość obejrzenia i wysłuchania takiego wydarzenia muzycznego.

[@ryszardwalkowiak9156]

Częściwo zgoda... ale ten i inne wczesne kawałki... czuć brak Petera

[@giuseppedeleo688]

From Genesis to revelation until today,for ever in my life ❤

[@wendyhartmann3130]

So glad I got to see their last tour out our home town Boston Mass. Forever in my heart Phil, Andy and Mike 🎸🎹🥁🎤

[@Myrddin1955]

Andy? Tony you mean surely?

[@HughMcQ]

So hard to watch Phil summoning the energy. Bittersweet.

[@LESPossible]

This is probably the best response to any of the live videos I've seen posted about this tour. For some of us, it's not a lack of love and fandom that are keeping us away, its watching our hero struggling to "summon that energy". Wishing them the best of health and safety during this tour.

[@delby66]

You are so right Hugh. I'm a huge genesis fan and to see Phil trying so hard to finish all these great songs, well, it's very emotional. I'm a 65 year old man and I'm in tears.

[@HughMcQ]

@Carl Klinkenborg Harsh. And without any kind of empathy for Phil’s current state. Doubt any true Genesis fan would be throwing words like that at him.

[@marcusbellbass1375]

@Carl Klinkenborg 🤡

[@marcusbellbass1375]

@Carl Klinkenborg I’m just thankful to have seen the band live and experienced it with my dad and my brother as we are all fans, an emotional night and one to remember…

[@intunehypnotherapytaichi2937]

I was at the concert and it was a bittersweet time , but also one of celebration.thanks for this clip and the camera view .

[@guillermoalvaradoflores8698]

La mejor banda de todos los tiempos con los beatles .cada quien en su estilo....the best band ever with the beatles.

[@pilsnrimgaard2507]

Can you imagine the immense sense of self worth Nick feels playing behind the greatest progressive rock front man in history that is his dad.

[@2leighthurlow]

The greatest front man this band ever had was Peter Gabriel. From the album then there was three the band become a commercially juggernaut. Chart success yes.progressive...no. I liked Collins s as a drummer and he filled Pete's role very well from 76 to 80.But to say he was one of the best frontman of rock is a little extreme. I found some of the footage on the tour quite sad

[@filmneye]

@@2leighthurlow I agree wholeheartedly with what you said here.

[@sionyevans]

What a beautiful circle it makes !! Was watching them last nightknebworth 1994ish I think..brilliant...

[@sionyevans]

@@2leighthurlow we all deserve our opinions bud....if its felt that it matters...respect

[@sionyevans]

@Carl Klinkenborg bit more respect due really...it is Phil Collins...that's his son playing drums

[@fernandomonodnunez5945]

Realmente me pone triste verlo así al gran maestro. Se nota que el esfuerzo es muy grande , creo que luego de tantos homenajes brindados por la banda llegó el momento en donde el homenaje lo hace el público

[@jesusmacarronleal2337]

Grandes!!El mejor grupo de la historia!! Fuerza Phil!! Tu hijo es muy bueno también!!Viva Genesis!!

[@MarceloAngio]

Gracias, gracias, gracias x compartir Volker!! Siento una ola inmensa de recuerdos. Y gracias Phil, Mike, Tony por regalarnos estos escenarios!! El tiempo los convirtió en Leyenda...

[@gloriamillanir6283]

Sigues siendo el mejor baterista y músico de mis años de adolescente....y la mejor música...

[@mikeshaffer4912]

Thank you for the upload and for sharing this with those of us who couldn't see them live.

[@jcc2709]

Es muy triste ver apagarse poco a poco a uno de tus grandes ídolos. Gracias Genesis , por toda la gran música que nos habéis brindado.

[@marysefonta8371]

Awsome performance, Thanks to go on again , Phil. Still amazed by your voice, Thanks to your friends musicians, Thanks to Nicholas !

[@carlossaba5259]

Maravilhoso Genesis e lenda viva do rock progressivo. Espetacular!

[@1Ljubica]

Thank you. I was at the Birmingham shows and this is a lovely reminder.

[@sajeevpanakalv.6257]

Love this, brings tears to my eyes, watching the aged Maestro Phil Collins. The others are doin great. We're all gonna get there. I usually watch the carpet crawlers here on my large screen. (6) Genesis - the Carpet Crawlers live - KZbin

[@richardmiller8201]

Beautiful !!!

[@SuperDaz34]

I was there sat not far behind you !! Awesome concert , really loved this performance. Thank you for the upload

[@btmolnar1089]

Thank you, Volker, in the name of "absent friends". Greetings from Budapest.

[@simonsparks2602]

Just as brilliant in manchester Friday... I loved it, thanks for this video.

[@ikhnaton]

That’s an amazing audience video ! Thanks !

[@davidbrignon2894]

Un moment magnifique, Phil Collins me fait vibrer sur ce morceau ❤❤💖💖

[@krishar1460]

So many memories in this songs. Thankyou Genesis for chances going back to those sweet times

[@jeffbauer3425]

Yeah. That's life . We can't be royal roaring lions for all of our life. We are but a spark that turns into a flame , yet diminishes with time and all the roads traveled. Thanks for giving it your all Phil.

[@stephenmathes1]

wow...very emotional...thank you Genesis!

[@SuperQdaddy]

Thanks for posting..lets give phil a hand !

[@lcn1222]

Love the way you brought Nic into the show! Excellent work. Thanks for posting.

[@jussaraleme8264]

e obrigada eternamente ! nao precisava desse esforco em meio a tanta dor.! foi um.presente para nic!

[@SteveFletcherGuitar]

Genesis play Dancing With The Moonlit Knight and about three people in the audience acknowledge it. Steve Hackett plays it and 4000 people go nuts. Tells you a lot about the current audience at Genesis shows and who has the most 'ownership' of the classic Genesis material.

[@keithf_]

You make a good point. Steve does carry the torch for 'classic prog' Genesis in a way that the Genesis threesome somewhat discarded.

[@1998rks]

Very true

[@greatpcfan]

Other side of the argument could also be how much other material Steve has that will draw audience to his shows if he stops playing old genesis songs?

[@JimmyGris]

Sublime, merci Phil.

[@rebelrobot]

I love this version, so beautiful and sad.

[@rinotuccini1245]

Por siempre phil música de culto muchas gracias que Dios te bendiga amigo del alma

[@JoseAngelEspinosaLopez]

Wie schön!!

[@ksjoyjespeace]

Chills don't lie...🥰🎶

[@jeffurey6399]

Can’t wait to see them in Pittsburgh, Pa. in December!

[@jussaraleme8264]

obrigada Phil!

[@maartengoossens5252]

From Genesis to Revelation.... What a tremendous band and musicians. Love. All love. We are all getting older but what a way to get old. Revelation.

[@dennydarrington7792]

thank you

[@nelsonfragoso5713]

Carpet Crawlers é uma das minhas músicas preferidas da vida.......Um clássico absoluto!!!!!!!

[@voice_of_reason5604]

Kind words from the army of Genesis fans and even the press from what I've seen. Nostalgia overtook reality for me. But if everyone else is happy then who am I to make waves.

[@pallina70able]

Fabulous!!!!!

[@jussaraleme8264]

phil ! obrigada, maravilhoso.

[@jessyl_bln5109]

Danke Volker, wir wissen es zu schätzen wenn Jemand uns 'Daheimgebliebene' mit Material versorgt 😊👍 hoffentlich konntest Du vor lauter Filmen auch das Konzert genießen 😉

[@gutgolf74]

LOL, die Leute, die dahinter saßen und die ganze Zeit den Bildschirm vor der Nase hatte, wussten es ganz sicher auch zu schätzen!

[@audiomez]

Nik is the only drummer to actually finesse the variations in timing and offsets live when they performed Carpet Crawlers live. His dad didn't even attempt it. One can see the subtle minute hat/snare timing off sets and variations by watching the reflection of the hat actions reflected on the underside of the right tide

[@MrJomakie]

this tears me up. Phil nails this beginning of Selling

[@coombster1]

Saw this live in Birmingham England and I don’t think there was a dry eye after these two songs

[@zacka.]

Legends

[@Joselle1810]

I love you Phil!

[@carlosmuller5655]

❤'ll until the end...and forever

[@BladeRock1996]

Hubiera sido hermoso ver a Phil junto con Peter Gabriel cantando juntos estos dos temasos, como en los viejos tiempos.

[@georgepyle6887]

Selling England By The Pound. 1973 classic.

[@pumpkinking5174]

@Carl Klinkenborg Agreed. Go see Steve Hackett. No comparison.

[@sergiofrancescoamorico1086]

ottima posizione

[@jamesdinning9107]

To quote a great song: Angels never know it's time To close the book and gracefully decline, The song has found a tale. My, what a jealous pool is she. The face in the water looks up She shakes her head as if to say That the bluegirls have all gone away.

[@danielpaez4210]

Ripples.

[@coffeetrailsthailand1035]

The least sad of them. A shadow of his former self

[@tinabenda3866]

💗💗💗

[@chrisjenkins3067]

I'm the most ardent Genesis fan . But it's so sad to see one of the greatest bands that has ever been fading away . Should never have done the tour . I shall remember them as they were

[@darrellclingman1120]

Finally someone said it. Its heartbreaking. Love the guys….. but

[@alfamily586]

You are rude, ungrateful and selfish. Don't watch or listen. He won't miss you either!

[@УДИЛЬЩИК-я1л]

Сын Фила на барабанах как трогательно и здорово! Просто династия барабанщиков. Genesis останется жить.

[@danburnes722]

Last tour… please bring Steve and Peter into a show somewhere if you can. Do it for the fans.

[@Rodrigotosomandouvcsefoder]

@gary burrows Tony was such that bad? Didn't know that

[@Prog-t9d]

Go see Steve Hackett he still has the energy and creative fire.

[@peterharrington8709]

Remarkable intimacy that you'd not expect from an arena show. The band doing it one last time for their fans and those true fans being there for their band. Not really the Genesis way over the years, but definitely Phil's way when you consider all those songs where he laid his heart out. Hopefully he can take strength from doing this and maybe look at doing a bit of acting and mentoring in *semi* retirement. Maybe some small unannounced gigs to if he feels like he could?

[@pedromartinez-xv9is]

El viejo Phill pero lo escucho como si los años no hubiesen pasado, tenía yo 14 cdo me enamoré de Genesis, dentro de 4 meses cumplo 60.

[@AECJ1]

Swan Song of a great band

[@Lucy0809]

Nic is amazing 😉❤️❤️

[@viva6244]

感動

[@brianw6626]

Phil Collins is the greatest of all time.

[@attiliobertelli8093]

💓

[@Marion-hz8vr]

💖💖💖💖💖💖

[@isabelledelisere1635]

On a besoin de tes talents et de toi.

[@celioazevedoofficial]

Still a nice voice.

[@martinbosch8022]

I love Steve Hackett and his band keeping alive the spirit of Genesis music, more than Genesis does..... 🤔🙄😣😜

[@LirycNonStop]

"funny" to hear that Phil now sings the "carpet crawlers" melody at the same range as Peter Gabriel originally did :)

[@TheChristOfRockNRoll]

On the album version Gabriel hits much much higher notes during some parts of the chorus.....even Phil and Peter ducked them in their prime during live concerts.

[@LirycNonStop]

@@TheChristOfRockNRoll true :) but I can hear in the "ancient era"'s bootlegs that Phil WAS definitely reaching the higher cotes when Gab was too busy acting... and crawling ;) THIS here is something absolutely different though... I noticed most of the songs were pitched (transposed) way way down for the occasion

[@alinayaroshenko1848]

Спасибо Фил

[@johndominici1761]

A great song originally written and sung by. Peter Gabriel

[@I_am_Jordan_K]

I would have lost it if I were at this show and I heard "can you tell me where my country lies?"

[@phenixreturns]

now Phil is like the old man in the musical box but it's life

[@peterasaro1914]

Sono un grande fan dei Genesis,ma pongo questa domanda: questa riunione era veramente necessario? P.Collins mi sembra l'ombra di se stesso. Sorry.

[@aliciacahuirivera6586]

🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@nga319]

Es stimmt mich traurig zu sehen, wie Phil sich quält. Sein Zustand lässt so eine Belastung eigentlich gar nicht zu.

[@artemis4186]

Es ist seine Art sich von seinen Fans und auch in gewisser Weise von der Band zu verabschieden.. Ich glaube mit dieser Tour erfüllt er sich und seinen Fans einen Herzenswunsch.. Nur ein Wunsch wird sich leider nicht mehr erfüllen.. Das er mit seinem Sohn gemeinsam spielt.. Ich hätte es ihm so sehr gewünscht

[@expectaculos1]

why they are not singing the first part?

[@casasjaume]

I'll always love genesis and phil collins, they are part of my life, but is this necessary?

[@Prog-t9d]

All about one more big payday.So sad .Move one guys ,hang it up.

[@aftabkhan1961]

Does anyone know what the intro music is before the guys come on stage?

[@shokthemonkey]

Since this is Most likely the Last Tour i would love to suggest to form a band with the son of Phil Collins to Carry on the Style of Music That Genesis made Genesis. Just gimme a call ☎️ 🥳🥳🥳Nils

[@josejavierreymiralles7085]

HARD. DURO.

[@IanMcGrath70]

sounded like he sang "Old Father TIME" instead of "Old Father Thames"

[@1Ljubica]

He did. Sadly he loses the words sometimes now :(

[@IanMcGrath70]

@@1Ljubica from what I've heard, he's doing pretty well. He sings Peter's Carpet Crawling tongue twisters fine. This one sounds like a conscious change...or perhaps a Freudian slip.

[@JH-uk2cy]

He did but it was a conscious decision - no mistake there.

[@ksjoyjespeace]

Who cares ? I think this is just beautiful...chills don't lie...

[@Chuckles..]

"...old man dies, the note he left was signed old father time" - obviously a clever play on an iconic Genesis lyric. Not a mistake, a bit of Phil-osophy, and understandably so.

[@ianfrost9758]

Glad I wasn't there seeing this. If you want classic era Genesis go and watch Steve Hackett perform it properly.

[@OurFamilyInMotion]

Beautiful. Will you be posting all the other songs from that night?

[@73superglide62]

Phil gave of himself a drummer too front man .and stress shows whats left of him

[@filmneye]

Phil's vocal of Dancing w/Moonlit Knight doesn't come close to comparing w/Peter's very poignant vocal of the same on his last tour w/Sting in 2016: kzbin.info/www/bejne/i5WXkn2YpbJ-p8k

[@gabriellevesque-lessard5052]

phil and Peter should have played THE SONG IN FULLLL. wtf only the intro...

[@garysargent5529]

Do you have the whole concert for this night?

[@annuvynarawn392]

mixed feelings - 🙃

[@danmaurer3834]

Sorry, but in my opinion, they should have left it. I know they don't need the money so why go out on a low. They were a great band that I first saw in April, 1974. Should have taken the ABBA route and said "Remember us as we were". Pity...

[@2leighthurlow]

Totally agree...worth seeing Hackett doing seconds out though in my opinion

[@turnerthemanc]

totally agree too. A lot of these other comments remind me of The Kings New Clothes. I had been a genesis fan for 5 years when I finally saw them in 1980, Duke tour. Being honest here, I think they should have been honest too. I dont know how the "Phil" problem got past planning, let alone rehearsals (even with the best will in the world)

[@hartmuthermannwill]

Phil gut so

[@jeffreyindri]

Imagine if Peter Gabriel joined the Tour to replace Phill🤔🤔🤔❤️