Gentle Giant : Unburied Treasure : Super Deluxe Box Set :Review - Now Spinning Magazine

[@NickIsYouSoFine]

I'm the Nick Yousoufian mentioned at 1:00 in. I'm happy to donate via Ko-fi.

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

Thank you so much for making this possible - Phil :)

[@jimmycampbell78]

This was incredibly generous of you. I would never be able to afford such a rare treasured set as this myself and I can't tell you how delighted I was to watch Phil's fabulous unboxing of this and see the signed photo and book. Thank you so much for making this video happen and enabling Phil to acquire this set.

[@thekivster]

This looks so good. This might be the best box set I've ever seen.

[@jimmycampbell78]

I love Yes, Genesis, King Crimson, ELP, Pink Floyd, Jethro Tull, Rush- all the great 1970s prog rock bands. But, to me at least, Gentle Giant are number one. They're my favourite band from this era at blending all those different genres: rock, jazz, soul, classical, even funk- into a bewitching, multi-layered, whimsical and intricate whole. This boxset is absolutely beautiful to behold and truly a work of art. I could sense your excitement in the video, Phil and no wonder. You can tell this is a band I love as well as I wouldn't normally gush over these sets but this is such an exception. What an incredible set to own. Amazing.

[@damienfoyer]

I have seen Nick on SoT, he is a serious collector. A gesture of true kindness to gift the box set to you Phil. And you are a deserving person to receive it.

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

I am very lucky ! Phil :)

[@NickIsYouSoFine]

@damienflyer6754 Hi there! Yes indeed I am a serious collector. Heck, I got a PO box specifically so there won't be daily deliveries (and keep the post office in business). Since SoT I must've acquired a hundred or so, minimum. As for SoT it was an amicable departure and still remain friends with Pete.

[@damienfoyer]

@@NickIsYouSoFine wondered why I had not seen you on there for a while. Thank you for the update.

[@johnfredmurray]

I saw this box set in a local store and was contemplating buying it. You may have sold me on it after watching the video. Didn't realize how much stuff was inside. Funny story, my family and I grew up in the same town as Gary Green and his wife was our family friend. She'd always say that Gary was going to band practice and I figured he was in a local pub band until I was older.

[@curaeus007]

One of the best and most professionally produced boxsets I've ever seen.

[@colinreynolds8780]

I spent £500 for this set and money well spent signed one too

[@hgghwerff2541]

Oh, wow ! Congratulations Phil... I’m jealous but very happy for you. Enjoy !

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

Thank you 🙏

[@iang1]

GG fan since 1975 when I heard In A Glass House and remains my favourite album, hugely inventive

[@SpiritualSpectrum]

So glad I watched this. I was fortunate enough to get the boxed set and didn't even know about the autographed photo being real autographs and not printed autographs. Also didn't know it was the first printing of 300 units. Thanks Phil!

[@normanmacfarlane6724]

Another great day Phil 😂❤ Two cd boxes arrived today. Caravan : The Decca/Dream Years & Tim Poole Both totally awesome. It's cooler in Western Australia which is so much more civilised. So with this amazing music , and an Indian for tea tonight ( our local curry house is called Scottish Tartan ) this will be a very pleasant evening. PS : I love those cd box sets. Reasonably cheap , great booklets and a great selection of music. Thanks Phil Greetings from Western Australia

[@thomaswery3087]

I have this also Phil absolutely love it.Great box to have

[@chrisdaykin3899]

The great thing about the box set is that it doesn't duplicate many of the live releases that have come out over the years - and the tour history - I love it!

[@waynegoucher4503]

Thank you Phil. Really enjoyed the review and having never explored Gentle Giant i think i'm going to have some fun with this new adventure in music.

[@marvinmoenen4151]

Wow what a very nice big box set from a very underrated great band thank you phil for the detailed review 👍✌️

[@michaelwelton4910]

Unfortunately I'm commenting 20+ hours after this video, but I bought this when it came out. Outstanding band and outstanding boxed set. Listen to a band like Spocks Beard, and they do the a capella stuff clearly influenced by GG. If you've not yet dived in id recommend starting from the beginning and listening to each studio album from 70 to 80. I quite like the later 70s albums, even giant for a day, as it's a good attempt to place themselves in the newer styles of music. As with these madfish boxes, it's the live stuff which is an attraction! Great stuff!

[@tonyyeatropoulos6829]

I may be a tad off on the details, but if memory serves, 1 copy from the original pressing of the box, came with a gold coloured piece in the jigsaw where the "missing" piece is located. Whomever got that copy was given an award of a full-sized (or almost) mirror with the Gentle Giant 'In A Glass House' design (much like the one on your CD jewel case). Somewhere on KZbin I'm sure it's easily locatable, where it shows the winner.

[@brucybabyy7355]

the research and detail are breathtaking.

[@terrydaktyllus1320]

I am both envious of you but glad that you got a copy of it also - this is one of the box sets that I hope Madfish to a reprint of.

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

Thank you 🙏 it is amazing 🤩

[@lesblatnyak5947]

Like the good witch said to Dorothy a good place to start is at the being. Got to see GG 4 times. 🙏🎶

[@garymey4314]

We should start crowdfunding to get the next 1000 reprinted. And then include all the new Steven Wilson Atmos and 5.1 blu rays as well!!

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

Good point !

[@terrydaktyllus1320]

Count me in if that happens. The other one I'd love to see reprinted that I missed out on is the Steve Hillage one.

[@ilabelle1]

It’s a little overkill but man, I would love to have this monster. Unfortunately it seems to be next to impossible to get. So frustrating. You’re a lucky guy Phil…. 🤘😳🤘

[@stanferraro4130]

Hi Phil, and thanks for the look at the box. I have been a big G.G. fan for the last 50 yrs, saw them several times when they played in So.Cal. USA, always amazing. You are in for a surprise when you give "Giant For a Day" a spin. They made some incredible music in the 10 yrs that they existed. They were a unique band, being that they did not duplicate their studio sound in live situations, most of the time, but they did change the arrangements which was good (as you'll hear when playing the live discs). Enjoy !!!

[@jean-lucpernel2202]

Bonjour Phil, hier j'ai regardé cette réédition complètement étonné par la quantité incroyable d'enregistrements du groupe! Aujourd'hui je regarde a nouveau ton excellente présentation de ce " pavé de Rock progressif" !! Le Book est génial,la représentation des pochettes dans leur intégralité perfect, je n'ai que les premiers albums jusqu'à " brokin' Glass". Pour la petite histoire,si j'ai appris à maîtriser les saxophones ( alto, soprano et ténor plus les harmonicas blues et le chant ) c'est a cause d'eux, ma première écoute du groupe fut ACQUIRING THE TASTE j'ai usé le vinyl à l'époque je l'écoutais en boucle, la polyphonie incroyable,un grand groupe avec de magnifiques musiciens !!! Et dieu sait que ce n'est pas ce qui manquait à l'époque ! Merci pour cette " grande gentille" présentation !❤❤❤❤❤😊

[@dannyhartley5]

I’m a huge GG fan. Have been since the early 70s. Hard to say which album I like the most. But I would recommend doing a hard listen of Three Friends. It’s a concept album that imo is unlike the others. A couple of years ago, the fan GG website published a guy’s dissertation on GG specifically Three Friends. It was a very interesting read.

[@ciciusss]

Phil, First album I ever bought from Gentle Giant was Three Friends. It is still my favorite album from them, an all-time top 20 album. But, Acquiring the Taste, Octopus, Power and the Glory, Free Hand and Glass House are brilliant too. A great run by the band. I came to the band when I was reading an interview of Triumph's great guitarist Rik Emmitt. He was talking about his big influences, Steve Howe from Yes, Steve Morse from the Dixie Dregs, etc and mentioned Gary Green from Gentle Giant. Now, being a guitarist, I was already down the rabbit hole with Howe and Morse. Obviously, I was an admirer of Emmitt and it was him talking about Green and Gentle Giant that started me down that rabbit hole. They are one of my favorite bands, no matter the genre. In the Prog world they rank just behind Yes, Rush and Genesis, but ahead of King Crimson, ELP and Kansas. Not bad company in my opinion. This is a stellar box set and as you said there is no skimping. If possible, there would have been a back stage pass to a GG concert attached to this box set. Definitely put together from a fans perspective. Quite possible that whoever was in charge of putting this set together is a fan.

[@normanmacfarlane6724]

A terrific review I have a couple of cd size box sets but nothing compared to this work of art 😂

[@JohnFiocchi]

This is insane!! 😅 I've never seen anything like it!! All the history...alone is a treasure within itself. Heard Gentle Giant in 73'. Collected their entire discography...first on LP in the 70s analog age then on cd in the digital age.. The first four Gentle Giant albums differ from other periods of their career. Even though In A Glass House reflects some of the early material it is an actual transition into something else. It falls between Octopus and Power And The Glory and its a combination of the earlier style and the development of what revealed on Power And The Glory. The first 4 albums were more magical less confined to a personal agenda of the record company to either sound more like Yes or perhaps just generally more commercial. The first 4 albums could have sounded more magical and affected your listening experience differently because of the presence of Phil Shulman. That's always a possibility and it is a fact that they sounded differently after his departure. With the exception of "Inmate's Lullaby " , ( which is reminiscent of their quirky writing style on the early albums), the rest of Glass House is stylistically based on a harder edge of Rock riffing ....which Gary Green always did...but this time it was different somehow. It has a lot to do with why the first 4 albums are in a class of their own. Phil Shulman had reasons for leaving and no doubt in my mind that your kids take priority over your music career. It's very hurtful to your kids when you're in the music business. The cool thing about Phil Shulman is that he left this music for people to enjoy. It's a short time period but a really interesting one.

[@darcyska]

What a beautiful set!

[@tonyyeatropoulos6829]

If you're interested in the 'boots', the Brussels/Dusseldorf concerts are the best sounding. For me, those alone made my purchase well worth the money, not to mention that the remastered catalog sound fantastic!! All of the remasters I've purchased in the past, these sound the best by far... with the exception of the newer, individual deluxe sets with remixes by Steven Wilson, which are jaw-dropping!! My copy of this box does not have the autographs, but I love it!!! GG have long been in my Top 5 favorite bands of all-time, and this is a must box for all GG fans. I'm so happy that, after all this time since its release, that you were able to acquire a copy for yourself. Kudos to those folks that helped make that happen! Enjoy!!!

[@Mikesmallfanclub]

Hi Phil, that’s an incredible box set so much to look at and listen to not sure I’ll get my hands on a copy but will pursue, great review as always Phil 👍

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

Thank you 🙏

[@douglasweston126]

Hi Phil - WOW that is amazing. These box sets are amazing aren't they - I collect some when I can afford them, but not at this level. I have a few of their CD's, I think they were on the outer circle maybe because the songs were too complex, or quirky for general consumption, and the melodies were hidden deeper into the songs. Maybe, as a general comment - the songs weren't strong enough? I dont know - and maybe they were just plain unlucky? Lets face it the competition wasnt bad was it lol. Yes, ELP, King Crimson, Genesis, Pink Floyd, Tull, etc etc etc and our pockets can only stretch so far. My fav song of theirs is Freehand. There's some great BBC live footage from 1978 that just smokes - absolutely brilliant. Amazing box set. Cheers Doug

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

Thank you 🙏

[@rasardo1]

I've got mine (first pressing). Until "Interview", everything is a must have.

[@jean-lucpernel2202]

REALLY GIANT❤

[@yesmanasia123]

Thanks for this video. It's an amazing boxset! Wish that it was still in print. Missed my chance when it came out. Would be great if they made a second pressing with updated Steven Wilson mixes.

[@brucybabyy7355]

i would dive straight into the live stuff!

[@747jono]

That's a work of art amazing

[@seanwills4946]

A lot of people say to me why do you buy a boxset when you already have the individual albums?. Well my answer to that is just look at this boxset and the Wishbone Ash one and great extra stuff you get, lots of live performances that you are not likely get anyehere else and a wonderful book full of great information. Fantastic stuff, Phil.

[@gavaxemanspins]

Oooo that’s well cool! 😮

[@CloseToTheEdge-Prog]

Amazing band.

[@yolandakalt5053]

I have a box 🙂

[@mickgrundy4615]

Great video thanks for sharing phil .thats a gem of a box set, i still play octupus , any chance of a box set by edgar broughton band? Keep them coming .

[@majedalamine4404]

When the box came out Steven wilson had done several albums remix of GG, and he had done Three Piece Suite which is a remix of the tracks from the first 3 albums that they managed to find the multi tracks of. thus making us all assume that the other tracks from the first album are not possible for re-mixing and 5.1 ing . Thus the bluray in this box was and still is a big surprise and sought after disc, and I dont believe it was ever put out as a separate disc

[@747jono]

Talking of jigsaws I have a Blind Guardian one and a Amon Amarth one both from limited edition box sets, both still in accompanied plastic bags lol wouldn't dare attempt to do them lol both 1,000 pces I think lol 😂

[@progmonster2010]

You have the same taste as me lol. Tull, Giant, Yes, Express, Purple, Sabbath etc. Have you checked out Camel, Le Orme or Caravan?

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

Yes - love them

[@progmonster2010]

@@NowSpinningMagazine le Orme fantastico

[@progmonster2010]

@@NowSpinningMagazine Don’t forget the thick as a brick of Italy 😎 kzbin.info/www/bejne/oavXf42Vgqx6i5Isi=2QpSA6Zf7OsD2dkI

[@2010ditta]

How long did it take to put all that back Phil? lol. Seriously though that was jaw-dropping, so much in the box. Amazing.

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

It took ages! I actually filmed this three times! The first time the microphone was switched off. The second time I did not take all the CDs out thinking who is going to sit through all of this. The third time I thought, this is a one off, show them everything! Phil :)

[@jean-lucpernel2202]

Hi Phil shame on me , j'ai fait une erreur sur mon commentaire précédent j'ai écrit " brokin' Glass" pour IN A GLASS HOUSE, SORRY i'm tide😢

[@H0LT-85]

There’s a used one on eBay for £599.99 😳😳😬😬

[@NowSpinningMagazine]

I got a very good deal on one. It is very rare now.