SONG OF DURIN | Bass Singer Cover | Geoff Castellucci

[@DTA-Music]

If Geoff had been in the Fellowship, the Balrog would have forgotten all about attacking and just followed him around begging him to autograph its merch.

[@qcrew2938]

What a kiss ass!

[@HunterTheFerocious]

Don't bother the "Talent", Balrog! 😁

[@pretzel2272]

@DTA-Music 😂😂😂

[@sarahborzelli_Castellineicieli]

maybe that's why Geoff sees himself as boring - because with him the trilogy would have been very boring: all the Orks, Gollum and all other creatures in line for an autograph

[@PatR2243]

@@sarahborzelli_Castellineicieli Would have been a totally different movie LOL

[@glorytoukraine5524]

The fact you started and ended the song with Gimli, alone in Balin's tomb... Just painful. Well done, sir

[@RedNiel100]

Beat me to it! It's really next level to actually show (not tell) a story with the cinematography! Well done!

[@dark_neverland]

Indeed. Beautiful and haunting and heartbreaking! That scene in the fellowship with fili's words being read and gimili's reaction still gets me everytime!

[@HubrisInc]

​@@dark_neverland Ori, not Fili. Fili died during the Battle of Five Armies.

[@dark_neverland]

@@HubrisInc whoops, i i didn't catch my voice-to-text autocorrecting.

[@JulianoGAlvarenga]

Balin was such a nice guy!

[@TrineDaely]

One voice to rule them all, one song to find them, one video to bring them all, and in the algorithm bind them. Beautiful masterpiece. Thank you for all your hard work.

[@BlueblazerPrime]

PRECIOUS!!!!!

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

​@@BlueblazerPrime😂🤣❤️

[@tyrentherisen]

In the land of Geoff, where bass covers lie...

[@marktrombley4084]

In the land of KZbin where the upvotes lie.

[@TetonHillstrom]

more people should know and understand this beautiful poem

[@gandalfolorin-kl3pj]

Geoff: I don't comment on your videos much, but I had to this time. I'm almost 70 and I've been bringing Tolkien to life for various audiences since the 1970s. Your rendition of this song is without equal. Tolkien would be proud. Melon, namarie.

[@sincerelyyours225]

I agree soooo much with you! ❤

[@jeffk1482]

I sooooo agree @gandalfolorin! I’m quite certain “she who is most fair” would ensure there is a place in the Undying Lands for Geoff.

[@austincarter9523]

Geoff needs to see this

[@bossked1563]

You need to check out Clamavi de Profundis, the original songwriters for this. They've done SO many of Tolkien's poems, and every one is gorgeous. I especially recommend their version of The Song of Beren and Luthien - a masterpiece! =D

[@gandalfolorin-kl3pj]

@@bossked1563 Actually, I have heard Clamavi de Profundis. They are great. I saved their versions of Tolkien's poetry so I can listen again.

[@toradrow777]

It's amazing how this song, no matter who sings it, makes you nostalgic for places that you've never been to.

[@cynthiachoate2536]

So true. My daughter and I feel it too. Have you had your DNA done? If not, try it. You may be surprised

[@rani-g6s3z]

True

[@lauriehallcolemandowns7364]

Hmmm...no, for me it really matters who sings it. I have been utterly spoiled by Geoff's superior talent! He brings it alive like no one else.

[@Rekker1]

@@cynthiachoate2536 what's DNA got to do with this? bit hard to convey tone over text only so just know im curious, not trying to be rude

[@doggonemess1]

@@Rekker1 I think she's partially joking, but I have had my DNA tested and it was fascinating. My direct paternal lineage is West Africa, even though I'm white as milk. Turns out my grandmother's claim that her husband's family were descended from Freedmen was true.

[@macfin_inc2709]

These full costume videos are so cool. It’s easy to forget it’s all the same person

[@GeoffCastellucci]

It's all thanks to my incredibly bland face. It's like the perfect blank canvas 😉

[@dainbramage3558]

@@GeoffCastellucci bland! gorgeous more like :P

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

​@@GeoffCastellucci🤣😂❤️

[@perwestermark8920]

​@@GeoffCastellucci You have some suitable company that rents out theater dresses? It would be quite expensive to actually buy all the set dressing and clothes for your videos.

[@beckymurphy4714]

@@perwestermark8920 What makes you think this isn't his own wardrobe?

[@AardvarksAreFunny]

My LOTR-obsessed kids debate over which character each Geoff is. Along with Carol of the Bells, this is my favorite song by Geoff. Thank you for blessing my ears!

[@karenponchak5304]

if there's any question, it's Fili, Thorin, Gimli, Kili, and Bofur (l-r) in the video.

[@AardvarksAreFunny]

Thanks ​- they were glad to have their conclusions affirmed.😊

[@kathrynmenzel2615]

A Geoff trifecta: a story song, all the dwarves and all the ranges. Beautiful!

[@GeoffCastellucci]

Thank you!

[@rahelmeyer2750]

❤

[@ТатьянаЛарина-я8д]

Великолепно, четыре диапазона!!!

[@Swan-yo6hn]

I truly love the attention to detail of having Gimli sing this, as he is the one singing the poem in the book. And as it is about forefathers it even makes sense to bring in the dwarfs we already know even though most of them are dead by Gimli's time. What a brilliant version of the piece.

[@timy.9512]

Like his ancestors are singing with him. What I wouldn't give for this.

[@Swan-yo6hn]

@@timy.9512 exactly 😁

[@DarkeAOU]

They're not that far apart in age, though? In the Hobbit, Fili was 82 years old, Kili was 77, and Gimli would've been 62. So he was only 15 years younger than the youngest dwarf there. It's not "Gimli's ancestors;" Fili and Kili were literally his slightly-older cousins who died tragically too soon. Which makes it all the more tragic to me, because Moria wasn't just the home of Gimli's distant ancestors. He also lost friends and family there, too, people he personally knew and loved.

[@timy.9512]

@@DarkeAOU Even more meaningful - it's his friends and family singing with him. Talk about remembering those you knew and loved.

[@nickmarrotte4941]

The vocal range of this man is one of a kind. His voice is so dang smooth and raw.

[@slaveteri]

Well, few of a kind. Tim Foust is also a bass singer with an awesome range. My love of Tim is what lead me to find Geoff some years ago. Now they just have to share my love!

[@Nursense2024]

How many octaves has he?

[@frankhammer9005]

Try to discover Dimash... He will keep you occupied the next month... Worlds best male singer...

[@TaoGamer22]

​@@Nursense2024B0-A#5 al most 5 octaves

[@sztefanek]

It took me 4 minutes to realise this is one person. Mind. Blown.

[@sztefanek]

Also, this is extremely beautiful. Listening to it over and over again.

[@Badger77722]

Don't feel bad. Reactors have gone through the entire videos for Far Over the Misty Mountains Cold and I See Fire without figuring it out!

[@sztefanek]

@@Badger77722 Oh, I don't feel bad :D In fact, I am very fond of this deceivement! **playing it for a 20th or sth time today**

[@amelieroulleau3592]

No one can convince me that Geoff isn't a LotR nerd now. His details are so accurate and he puts so much care into his video creation to not be a fan. Thanks for all the details and respect for the movies Geoff 👏

[@slaveteri]

Haha! Your make up was so good on this one that you confused my 16yr old (aspiring bass singer, if his voice will ever settle) son. He was trying to sing along (captioning on) and when the entire group dropped low, he wasn't anticipating it and was like, "Oh! This isn't the usual group he sings with! These are all bass singers!" I had to explain it was all you. lol He was suitably impressed.

[@DTA-Music]

If I remember right, the other members of the Fellowship didn't understand how glorious Moria had once been or why the Dwarves were still so obsessed with the place long after it was lost, but even Legolas was touched when Gimli sang this song in the book. Hearing Geoff sing it so beautifully here, it's not hard to see why. (Or why Galadriel understood its importance to Gimli when they met her later in Lothlorien--she remembered seeing it all in person.)

[@ImminDragon]

Gandalf knew, having been there before the Doors of Durin were closed. It's why he knew where they were, but he left that way, not entered, so he didn't know how to open them from the outside.

[@Ultraghoul213]

Can we just appreciate the amount of talent and skill it takes to properly sync each "alternate voice" of Geoffs in each of his videos.

[@manasi_kane]

One more comment : I love how much effort was put not just to sound but also look true to original source material by Tolkien ! KUDOS to Kathy, Geoff, Eli, Rick, Layne and Tony and everyone that was involved ! We saw the hard work that went into this video in the BTS. You guys are awesome !

[@rahelmeyer2750]

🥰

[@parkerbrown-nesbit1747]

Yes! Without set design, wardrobe, and makeup, that wouldn't happen. (Former theatre kid here)

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

Eli's work on the lighting really added to the mood, too! The more I watch, the more details I appreciate ❤️

[@AnaxErik4ever]

Geoff is a needed bard for any high fantasy journey. No Vicious Mockery attack needed for him. The tremor in his vibrato and his strong bass range would be enough to make a horde fall to their knees…in defeat and in awe.

[@jamescurfman3284]

In the pre-dawn, the General knew something was amiss as he could hear the frightened screams of one of the forward scouts before ever seeing him, who was no longer forward but was returning in a rush. The poor sweating soldier finally slid to a stop and collapsed at death's door directly in front of the General, weakening as his energy left him, all the while repeating over-and-over "He's coming! He brings the Quakes as he sings! Get away fast, before he comes or the ground will swallow all!" The message was so dire that the soldier had purposely sought out the General himself, rather than seeking chain-of-command. The scrawny starved Orc kept mumbling the warning until he in fact passed, as the General looked on. One of the others sneered. "He's led the enemy right to us! Let us eat the little -" but the General cut the big Orc off. "You shall not touch him. He deserves to be honored. This one has saved us all this day, with his very last breath. This was good warning. I know of whom he speaks." The others looked at the General in awe as he decided what to do next. "Break camp, let us move away swiftly. We go North." When nobody moved, the General cursed in Black-speech, then yelled "NOW!" Everybody ran every which way, performed assorted tasks to break camp quickly, pack up and travel at Double-Time march. The General would not forget that poor messenger of death for the remainder of his life, grateful for every day drawing breath that would come to him next.

[@ShadowPerson11]

You said to blame Kathy for this one, so I will! THANK YOU KATHY for all of your hard work with the costumes, and the organization, and the helmet, and the directions, and making this guy not be boring! (And thank you Geoff for a stunning performance and a beautiful arrangement). The two of you are a powerful combination, and I hope nobody makes the mistake of standing in your way!

[@rahelmeyer2750]

Yes!! Thank you Kathy!! Thank s.... The whole Team!! ❤🫂

[@mendydavis3552]

Ty Kathy and team!

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

❤❤❤

[@tessasilberbauer6219]

🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

[@leechowning2712]

I love the ones she is more in charge of... Geoff doubts himself too much, when she does more it is beautiful.

[@JanisMCarney]

As a long-time Tolkien reader, it is thrilling to hear Geoff bring his poems to life. I think he would be pleased.

[@dragonwithamonocle]

When I heard Clamavi De Profundis do this song, I knew I needed a Geoff cover. It's everything I hoped for.

[@jackyfriedman1963]

Likewise. They also do awesome renditions of Last Goodbye, When The Hammer Falls and Diggy Diggy Hole. All their dwarf songs are amazing.

[@Karldin83]

Been waiting a few years. Finally!

[@HamnimationStudios]

That was the first we heard, and the best, but now it has been matched! 😃

[@sebastiannguyen8269]

The fact that this exist made this ten time better, have this guy make some song for the Lord of the ring

[@bar9092]

I love this rendition of "The Song of Durin." It's kinda hooked me. At random times during the day, I suddenly want to listen again! It's a solemn, beautiful tale of a people from their beginning to the wait for Durin to walk the world again.

[@bjspeck4337]

I did that again.

[@Tir220]

I love that he did this cover, and he added a lot to the original, but I still love the original by Clamavi De Profundis

[@kiml.1112]

I think I’ve listened to this 30 times in a row. The harmonies tickle my brain in just the right way, especially with headphones on. What a beautiful and haunting masterpiece - the costumes, the incredibly smooth voice, and the overall production were just perfection! Thank you, Geoff, for sharing your amazing gift with us and for all the hard work that has to happen to produce such a wonderful video.

[@baknata2862]

Роскошно! Как и ожидалось! Подозреваю, скоро Geoff сможет озвучивать всех персонажей целого фильма.

[@maryhollenbach4966]

My dad had all the very low notes, we teased him that only elephants could hear him. This is so beautiful

[@Matthewwithers33]

I’m not crying. My eyes are just sweating. This is the kind of art that we get when passionate fans truly care about the material. Thank you Geoff for such amazing work with LOTR music I felt like I was truly in middle earth listening to Gimli. Tell the story of Durin Can I suggest it would be amazing to hear the song that Aragon and Legolas sing for the passing of Boromir

[@judithboulden3456]

Yes

[@gwendolyn2001]

I have often heard judges on AGT, etc., say that a singer made them get "shivers/goosebumps." I don't think I experienced that feeling until listening to this rendition of this song. Kudos and bravo, Geoff. (By the way, I'm almost 72, so I've waited a long time for the goosebumps.)

[@lolotte1475]

This song gives me chills...Extraordinary, well done everyone

[@DoreenBellDotan]

In a generation of such contention, music still unites us. Thank you, Geoff, for being a Peacemaker in a troubled time.

[@ScroogeGD]

Man I can't get enough of these Tolkien LOTR/Hobbit Geoff Covers! Thanks a million!

[@HazMat1012]

I first heard Geoff when he sung "I See Fire" and was amazed at his vocal range. This video and his range still amazes me.

[@travis6359]

Geoff has a way of turning a song you've heard before into a moving piece of music that touches you like it was your first time hearing it all over again.

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

❤!

[@cullentaylor6445]

That ending was POWERFUL

[@hollyryalsgrubb1273]

Over a week later and Geoff is still singing this in my head. I go to bed with it; it's there whenever I wake and there throughout my day. Geoff is now the background soundtrack of my life....

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

Same! ❤

[@maeco7]

What a beautiful cap to the tale that began in Misty Mountains with four warriors about to embark on an epic journey, continued in I See Fire with them grimly preparing to face near-certain doom and hoping they will not be forgotten, and now ended with Gimli singing of his people's glorious history, his ancestors (those same four lost warriors) appearing with him as ghosts or memories - as if their prayer to be remembered has been fulfilled. I had tears in my eyes from the first verse on. Gorgeous. The harmonies and arrangement are just perfect, but I also want to shout out that stunning instrumental track. I keep hearing so many fascinating details (the clever use of forge tools and weapons as instruments sprinkled throughout, for one). The dynamic flow of the arrangement keeps what could be a repetitive song in constant movement and feels like proper storytelling. As an enormously passionate LOTR fan, I deeply appreciate the thoughtfulness you put towards these "dwarfish" covers, Geoff. Although this finishes out the trilogy of Middle Earth covers in a satisfying way, I wouldn't say no to more covers in this world since you do such great justice to it.

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

Well Said! ❤

[@HamnimationStudios]

He still hasn't done The Last Goodbye...

[@DavideBaroni]

@@HamnimationStudios Will he? I so much hope so... ❤️

[@bdmarchant]

"Arranged, Produced, Filmed, Performed and Edited by Geoff Castellucci" Unbelievable talent, and it's obvious he puts a ton of work into getting better and better each time he makes one of these videos!

[@Lynn_M867]

I am a Tolkien loving geek girl and I am so glad for the day youtube recommended Geoff’s version of Misty Mountains Cold. When the teaser came out for I See Fire I became a Patron. This song and video are a chef’s kiss addition to the Dwarves saga. The vocals, the arrangement, setting, costuming and overall storytelling are so on point. There are so many amazing little details. Even more I love the honor this gives to both Tolkiens work and the original arrangement by Clamavi De Profundis. The hard work and heart shine through.

[@JadeDarde]

The announcement of a cover by Geoff on one of the most beautiful songs from Lord of the Rings is the promise of a beautiful day!Happy listening to everyone! Namarië !

[@peteenns67]

I simply cannot fathom the level of talent this man has. The way he arranges these songs that (to my knowledge) are just lyrics in the books, the cinematography and costumes are very impressive. Then his voice: low notes that shake Moria to its core, high notes that would make Minas Tirith quake and everything in between.

[@huldradraco]

The book poem was set to music by Clamavi de Profundis, which Geoff arranged a cover of ❤

[@salemwitch4138]

It's incredible how I found all of Geoff's content literally a few days ago and now I can't get enough of it. Music is such a powerful medium to move so many people in countless ways... A true masterpiece 💛

[@DarleneCheatham]

Try his group Voiceplay. You get hooked on them too

[@salemwitch4138]

@@DarleneCheatham oh I know, I'm already obsessed

[@MarieDesJardin]

That was my Geoff experience also

[@baknata2862]

Ditto

[@Grounded75]

Welcome to the rabbit hole!

[@judithboulden3456]

At this time 684 comments. Whew. I was here for the premiere, but was at work. I really couldn't listen well, but I did take the time to introduce my regular customer and his son to Geoff and VP. I share with all that I can. I can't help it. Everyone should know this talent and joy!

[@AnnaPianalto]

And Bilbo and Frodo's Birthday is tomorrow, so this was the perfect time for a song like this!

[@se7engold]

After the song was finished, your audience sat in silence. After 5 seconds of total silence, a man stood up and clapped slowly. Another stood and started clapping after the first. Soon after, dozens and dozens of audiences stood and join the gesture. Before long the theatre was filled with thunderous clapping sound and audiences cheering. That first man would've been me. Marvelous performance Geoff, well done.

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

❤❤❤

[@monicam.8006]

Mr. Castellucci, to do this you either have to really LOVE dressing up and being on stage or you have to really understand that your fans are super nerds (that's a compliment) who want to be able to live that life through you. Either way, I have to respect you.

[@slaveteri]

I'm 100% certain that it's both.

[@jefftaylor6072]

If it means anything sir please keep these performances going. You and your team have helped give this old veteran a taste of life again. Your music has made this heart beat and soul soar. Thank you.

[@kmwwrench]

I wonder how many "strangers" to Geoff's work will watch this and wonder which one is him. Ha! Fabulous costumes for all the Geoffs. Never a dull moment with him. Not really my music because I'm not familiar with the Ring at all.

[@Badger77722]

There were a number of first-time reactors who watched Far Over the Misty Mountains Cold and I See Fire and never figured out that it was all the same person; a few even asked about "who are all the other guys?"

[@morph1024]

I have listened to this song at least 50 times since discovering it yesterday. I cannot stop listening to it. It is truly incredible. Superbly done... I bet Tolkien would have loved it.

[@PhilKelley]

This just blew me away. The authenticity of the lyrics and sound were perfect. Someone could, and should, build a whole film around you singing the entire Lord of the Rings Trilogy's lyrics. Thank you.

[@karenponchak5304]

Or we could just get him to narrate the whole of it (a couple chapters at a time).

[@wyattstevens8574]

​@@karenponchak5304That would be absolutely 👌!

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

​@@karenponchak5304 Good idea!❤

[@rosegallo5305]

I have never felt so much excitement about a song being released

[@SweetCuttlefish-AshleyE]

Once again, you have done what you do best with this song, and I am not only referring to singing it very, very low. I have always enjoyed Clamavi De Profundis’ version of this song, and I am in love with the ways that you have taken inspiration from their delivery and performance. But the thing you really do best is tell the story. I see and hear and feel all the emotion, all the loss and the hope, the wistfulness and the joy, in every aspect of what you have done with this. You bring Tolkien’s exquisite lyrics to life for me in a way I’ve never experienced before, I understand and feel them so much more deeply. I can’t help thinking, this is what Tolkien meant for us to feel when we hear these words. And then of course, I break down and cry for a minute, cause how else am I supposed to react to that thought? Thank you, once again, for breaking and filling my heart in ever evolving ways.

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

❤❤

[@WALDSMIND]

Its crazy thinking that he plays all the roles, it's edited so seamlessly and it all sounds incredibly good. Props to you Geoff :)

[@paularodery8074]

Wow😮!!!❤ What a voice!

[@the-reading-lemon]

Pros of listening to Geoff with headphones: free deep tissue massage delivered through my ear canal. Cons of listening to Geoff sing any Hobbit songs: desperate need to re-read my favourite fanfic. Again. So basically only pros, delivered by another pro.

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

❤😂

[@jasminnemcdonald94A]

What are the cons?

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

​@@jasminnemcdonald94A There are No cons that I can see!❤️

[@ThePhantomTomo]

What is your favorite fanfic?

[@Dogsparkster]

I have been listening to this nonstop for the past few days. The vocal range here is insane, and just very chill to listen to. It honestly calms me down when I get stressed.

[@tiger_cat_marksman]

Me too

[@agnieszkaoberc2635]

The first time I heard Clamavi De Profudis sing this song, I fell in love. I've never thought I would find the version I like even more. But this is phenomenal. Instead of a song about a distant, legendary past, this feels more relevant and immediate, with much clearer emotions. While, as always, I'm truly impressed by Geoff's voice and range, and I absolutely love costumes, I think the interpretation of the lyrics and the melody makes it great. It is beautiful, and I know I will be listening to it many times in the future.

[@jahanshadi1934]

I’m listening to this masterpiece since 3 weeks almost in loops. I can’t stop, I can’t have enough, it’s like a lullaby i don’t know why. It conforts me in a way. I play it as background music while I’m drawing or writing too. Thank you so much !

[@nathanaelfriday7596]

“The Dwarves [sung] too greedily and too deep, and disturbed that from which they fled, [Geoff].”

[@alainhofman3894]

I think this is the best out of the three dwarven songs. And the way he lingers on "Kazah-dûm" brings so much emotion although I haven't yet figured out why exactly. Stunning!❤

[@Badger77722]

This is story-telling at it's best! For me, telling a story through song always makes it more memorable, with the melody and rhyming making it easier to remember the story itself. Geoff is just so good at this, it's not even fair. Not only do we get the beautiful arrangement and instruments, but Geoff brought back not only the dwarves from Misty Mountains and I See Fire, but added Gimli into the mix (although Gimli appears to have been working out quite a bit!). The dwarves haven't lost their touch with a song! While I See Fire is still my favorite video on Geoff's channel, this one is not far behind, and from a story-telling perspective, is a little better IMO. But all of the dwarven songs have been wonderful, and this video just adds to their splendor. Kudos to everyone involved in the making of this video - Geoff, Kathy, Layne, Tony, Eli, Rick, and everyone else who helped out in creating this amazing video - and let's not forget Tommy, who supervised Geoff as he worked in the garage!

[@ashleyswim1997]

As someone with auditory processing issues, I just want to thank you for always having subtitles on your videos!

[@Lila-ie1eo]

I'm going to listen to this on repeat for the rest of the day. Sound therapy. Edit 3 hours later: It's actually working. Edit 21 hours later: Still here :p

[@jackyfriedman1963]

It's the first video to my new playlist category "Jacky's Lullabies". Which I need to go through the rest of my playlist and add my other lullabies to it. These are songs I listen to with my sleep headphones on repeat when I'm laying down relaxing or going to sleep. Which one depends on what my brain wants to listen to. They are songs that clear my mind and settle my body so I have a more restful sleep. So far besides this one..... Voiceplay.... In The Hall of The Mountain King, Classical Chaos, Hide and Seek, Dragonborn Comes, Halo. Be Prepared (when it's released next week). Geoff.... Ain't No Sunshine, Rains of Castemere, Unshaken, I See Fire. Pattycake.... Villains Haunted Mansion, You're The One With The Problem (Genshin Impact). Other... Redemption, Immersion (both Syts Piano), Light of Seven (Game of Thrones-Silva Screen Records). Yeah. Not your typical lullabies but those bore me. Gotta listen to what I love and want to listen to over and over and over and etc.

[@missl1775]

The costumes! Everything else too, but between the different tones and intonations in the vocals and how dramatic the costumes are, I had to check to really believe that this was a solo act. And yes, it is heartbreaking that Gimli starts alone, and then is accompanied by Fili and Kili and other fallen dwarves, and then... alone.

[@loripiontek]

Geoff's costumes are spot on, and harmonizing is incredible, as always.

[@angiewoollard704]

THESE GUYS ARE SO TALENTED! Gimli is sooooooo handsome 😍 Seriously, though, with a void as deep as the abyss below the Bridge of Khazad-Dûm, these dwarf tunes are right in your wheelhouse, Geoff. But not only because of your deep voice, also because of your supremely incredible ability to take fairly repetitive songs and to breathe new life into them, changing them subtly here and there, taking our ears and brains and hearts on a journey through Middle Earth itself through song. ⛰ ♥

[@drake0421]

One guy.

[@patriciagyorfi7758]

It's the Castelucci Quads😂

[@jacquelinemanges5509]

If my best friend was still with us I would share all of these videos with him. Being a bass himself he would have loved to see them. These help me keep his voice alive in my heart so I thank you.

[@JoshuaJackson-n2u]

Im so sorry for your loss❤ He never truly left. He will always be there

[@DSJ-gg2ns]

❤❤❤❤

[@lanaart912]

Geoff enchanted me again and transported me to a magical location of a bygone era. This journey began in the shadows of the Misty Mountains and continued with the melodies of I See Fire and now I am here in the depths of Moira. Tolkien's tales and poems come to life and become reality, and memories live forever. Five beautiful voices ( Yes, I know it's only one! ) Slowly melt into each other and build a harmony that even the tiniest speck of dust in Khazad-Dûm can shake. The background music is amazing! Starting with the sound of soft drops of water, which nevertheless fall so sharply into the lake of silence of memories and the metallic sounds that evoke the sound of swords daggers bards, the mystical sound of strings and drums...As it all slowly unfolds and melts into one. There is a lot of feeling in this beautifully constructed song and memories... memories of warriors... I'd love to hear more... And the view is really impressive! The background, the lighting, the costumes, the make-up and the great direction deserve special thanks! Now I don't want to list names, but everyone did a fantastic job! Thanks for this masterpiece!

[@hwyla4416]

It’s a surprisingly short list. Mostly Geoff and Kathy (his wife), but with Rick Underwood for make-up and ‘beard-wrangling’ and Eli from VoicePlay for lighting, plus Layne and Tony from PattyCake Productions (and VoicePlay). These guys are just Uber-talented! Not just in their voices.

[@lanaart912]

@@hwyla4416 Yes, thank you. I know all this and I have already written on other platforms. Now I didn't want to list everyone again, but usually in most posts I mention everyone who contributed to the making of a music video. They are fantastically talented and their work is amazing! They always do their best or even more, and without them such masterpieces would not be possible!

[@iansmom398]

Shame you can only like it once. This is the third time I heard it, it gets better every time.

[@AuntLoopy123]

Only three times? AMATEUR!

[@banker4ever]

I swear this man's voice is going to be the death of me. HOW, HOW CAN THIS ONE MAN BE SO TALENTED!!!!!!! I am now convinced that these acapella singers are not human, definitely not this guy. This is taking me places I did not know about. Thank you Mr. Castellucci for your voice and your talent, I need more.❤‍🔥❤

[@Rekker1]

"When Durin woke and walked alone... He named the nameless hills and dells..." There's something about this part of the song, this specific bit melodically that I really love. It goes from the really deep voice of (I think) Thorin, to the other Dwarf with a higher voice, it is really really soothing to the ears. The beat also starts here so I believe that's part of it too. I've been a bit obsessed with you recently Mr. Castellucci, you have a magnificent voice, thank God for giving you this natural talent and thank you for practicing so much and gracing our ears with your hard work built upon said talent.

[@chih-chaoyang5290]

The dwarves are back!! The set, the singing!! Everything is just amazing!! Those facial hairs definitely took a lot of works!! And Gimli's nose!! Thank you for taking so much effort to create this one!! ❤❤

[@elkeprei2682]

Unglaublich.So wunderschön. Geoff übertrifft sich wieder einmal. Da stimmt aber auch alles.Danke, ❤❤❤

[@Blue24Osprey]

This gets more beautiful every time I hear it.

[@melaniehobbs3323]

I LOVE THESE GUYS!! How did you ever convince such a handsome dwarf like Gimli to come and join in for the fun on this one?? More dwarfs please!! This song gets better every time I listen to it, and it will be going into my playlist as soon as I can manage it! Thanks, Geoff -- this was a masterpiece to round out the "trilogy"!

[@food4thought1925]

the dripping sound from the cave was the cherry on top of the cream

[@luciamartini8217]

Geoff's vocal range makes him a one-man choir. Amazing!

[@Internetguy_L337_90D]

geoff really nailed this song felt the tolkien in his voice

[@Anwa71]

Ich liebe seinen Gesang, solo und mit Voice Play

[@GeoffCastellucci]

Thank you!

[@Panou]

Holy fuck, you're so good... that's by far the best version of this song we've ever had. This gives me the chills.

[@oblivian9505]

I watched 3 of these videos before realizing you were harmonizing with yourself... lol Damn, you're good! If I hadn't listened to you thanking patreons after "I See Fire" I wonder how long it would have taken me...

[@RissaFirecat]

This is the most amazing version I’ve heard. I am back in Moria with the Fellowship. Tolkien reigns supreme. Geoff has an awesome voice.

[@Stan_S_Stanman]

The vibrato on the low notes gets me. Not many basses can relax on a D or D# enough to produce such a strong and healthy vibrato. That's one extra bit of evidence of Geoff's development as a bass singer through practice but also as his voice matures and he ages closer to what is considered "prime" age for many bass singers.

[@SouthPawBowler24]

Geoff is a very smooth Bass singer

[@karenponchak5304]

Do note, the lowest notes are Bb1 and Ab1.

[@jeanettestefanik5854]

so the true story in your songs is not that you are a bass cover singer but that you have an incredible range. Maybe deeper than any others we know but your high range is so far above what i would expect.

[@silv-eee]

He counts his octaves in Monster Mash 😉

[@susannethies2538]

Gott hat dich wahrlich mit einer einzigartigen Stimmbreite gesegnet! Danke für diesen Song, mach bitte weiter so!!!!!❤

[@КсенияИванова-к7э]

Это невероятно... Огромное спасибо ща доставленное удовольствие от просмотра. Вы сделали невероятную работу. Видео потрясающее.

[@Agnes_EvaR]

I LOVE THESE GUYS! It was the 4 "ghost" dwarves that brought me to this channel. (Misty Mountain). I have been grateful to them ever since. This song with Gimli is also amazing! Oh, and those perks on the Patreon are really incredible!

[@comterostov62]

WE will never have enough of Geoff singing lotr related songs. I literally dream about singing this way.

[@danielmingone3190]

Geoff slayed it! I think my beard grew an additional 6 inches while watching this. He has the best voice I've heard in years!!!

[@Encaris]

Can we give a round of applause to the costume department 👏👏

[@Chebawitch]

👏 👏 👏

[@lauriehallcolemandowns7364]

Hear hear!

[@CindyPayne-by3bi]

This song immediately catapulted itself to top of my favorites list. And Gimli is the best dwarf ever!!!!!!! MORE DWARVES PLEASE!!!!

[@donnaj9964]

Haunting, beautiful, and as always perfectly staged, costumed, and lighted. Just...wow.

[@z3n_z]

MY VOTE WON ON PATREON!! Definitely worth subscribing to Geoff Castellucci himself and Voiceplay 👌🔥

[@Runar_Tvalfager]

we need more Clamavi de profundis votes!

[@BWGPEI]

Both my Wife and I have participated in coral music and my Wife's Father was involved in an award-winning barbershop quartet. Thus our congratulations on your music are backed by knowledge of what is truly good. Bless you and yours!

[@Filiz_E]

Geoff calling to us from the halls of Moria🔥🔥🔥

[@HeartoftheDragonColo]

Well done! We played this for a friend and told her up front there was just one singer, and at the end she said, "Those guys are great!" And we reminded her that it was you x5.

[@ForFrogFog]

When i first saw the short for this video, I thought it was a movie trailer but this is so much better than a movie.

[@sandraf.108]

Oh mein Gott! Die Harmonien in diesem Lied sind einfach nur perfekt. Die Gänsehaut will einfach nicht mehr verschwinden, egal wie oft man es hört. Vielen Dank Geoff für diesen Hochgenuss. 🥰👏🔥❤

[@PaulCornish-ys4cn]

I love the other two Hobbit covers but this is my favourite. The 5 part harmony is sublime. I especially love the beautiful, almost angelic tone near the end when you sing 'Mirrormere'. So atmospheric. A wonderful arrangement. Thank you and your wonderful voice so very much.

[@vtaviscratch2428]

This is by far my favorite song you’ve done yet, Geoff. It is absolutely beautiful and flows so perfectly, I can’t help but close my eyes and sway to the music. And just an added note - the harmonies on ‘fishes mail’ make me shiver every time. Masterfully done. Thank you so much for sharing this with us.

[@EmmaYadkin]

Such an amazing arrangement of this great song. I think this will break more than one reactor. Huge shout out to Kathy for making this such a treat.

[@Michael-bw7tz]

Can we also just appreciate the lyrics we have to work with thanks to Tolkien.. "the world was young, the mountains green / no stain yet on the moon was seen"

[@bjspeck4337]

Such a touching, beautiful, and sad Song of Durin. The water drops made me feel that Moria was weeping. Geoff - just wanted you to know how much I love your music.

[@MrsRdTripp14]

I've heard other renditions of this song numerous times, but this one moved me to tears. You captured the melancholy perfectly.

[@alyssadaniels7841]

Such a wonderful arrangement of this beautiful song! The harmonies are like wrapping yourself in a cozy blanket. Storytelling is once again a 10/10, Geoff!

[@allan12712]

Have loved this song since Clamavi de Profundis covered it. Love how it sounds with Geoff's low voice echoing through Moria, a worthy tribute to Tolkien's work.