Gertrude Tredwell and the Merchant's House Hauntings - Fickle Fate Series

[@QuantumPyrite_88.9]

Mr. Oddie is the undisputed master for creepy history , excellent editing and "that voice" . Sleep well my friends if you can . Keep the lights on and the doors locked .

[@lindaireland2751]

🤣🤣🧟‍♀️

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you kindly!

[@charlottewhite1277]

@@ObsoleteOddity , am I just torturing myself? Watching this knowing its gonna scare me, I ol.its 231 am here,thanks Oddie!!! Love this

[@charlottewhite1277]

@@ObsoleteOddity i too would love to visit that house.my mom was born in 34,and I am drawn to that time period because of her growing up in the great depression. That house is a crying shame.seems all the cities were for the rich and the county was for the poor. You can see this in the architecture. NYC is a very rough place now and seems like all the rich have left the city this past year. Thank you for this excellent portrayal of this true story,seems Gertrude lived and died w a broken heart 💔. I would enjoy doing a livestream, joining in . Looking for more of your work. You truly have a artistic ability that's adds so much more than just telling the stories. Enjoy your ☕ coffee,God bless.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

@@charlottewhite1277 I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@cynthialambert9067]

For a year, I spent time at the Tredwell house, giving tours. I was often alone there, and it was definitely creepy. There were certain places I wouldn't even go in the house. One night, I had to shut up the house after a lecture, and I was so creeped out, I had to have friends come and help me close the house for the night, because there were areas so intensely forbidding to me that I could not proceed. I'll never forget it. That building to the left of the house is no longer there, so the house stands by itself, and the brick on the side was not meant to be exposed, so there were water problems on that side. There's a pretty garden in the back. The collection of clothing and personal effects are all archived in the servants' quarters upstairs. I remember Brooke Astor standing on the steps of the house one day, in a lovely suit, with a hat and gloves, talking about old New York. She was over 100 when she died.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for sharing that.

[@VampyreBarbie]

Thank you for sharing your experiences!

[@jennifermcgoldrick6323]

It is a tour with the tenament museum? I'd love to go.

[@celenacasciani8500]

Cynthia: wow that sounds incredible! You working there and seeing Mrs Astor. I love to read about old NY. Still so many things I haven't done yet, though I have lived in NY for almost 50 years.

[@scruffy281]

Wow, what a great memory to share. These old homes have seen alot haven't they? So fascinating to me. I wish I could travel all over and see ALL OF THEM. Thanks Cynthia Lambert!❤️

[@joylumley6858]

I live in a 128 year old house. When we moved in it was in poor shape but my father was a carpenter and together we fixed it up. We found an old photo of the original owner and found out his name was "Uncle Andy Harris" . The lady who was related to him said he died in the "parsonage " (It's a little bedroom on the back of the house for traveling preachers). I told you all of that because while we were fixing up the house we had strange things happening; Bedsheets being tugged on at night, electronics turning on by itself, creaking like someone walking around at night, etc. We got to saying it was Uncle Andy playing with something. We've lived here for 21 years now and we rarely hear from Uncle Andy, but ever so often I will be laying in bed late at night and hear faint music playing. I guess Uncle Andy is enjoying his radio.

[@gigi559]

That's awesome!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Often renovation work will trigger paranormal activity - spirits don't appear to welcome change. Although they settle down if the restoration is sympathetic and not radical.

[@littleredwitch]

@@ObsoleteOddity Very true! A friend of mine experienced that in a small town of the Goldfields, Western Australia.

[@gloriahanes5338]

I lived in a home where on the site contained a sacred Indian burial ground, a massacre, and two deaths by mutilation which occurred over 150 years ago, I never thought much about it as the year was 2010, but one spirit in particular was extremely angry about how she died. I experienced all of the above and much more as one of the spirits put their hand through me to hug the other spirit. Needless to say, we moved and we lost $100,000 cash equity in the home, but it was worth it. Now, living in an older home, a 1895 castle which thank God is not haunted.

[@gigi559]

@@gloriahanes5338 I moved a couple of times but was told I attrack spirits. So far nothing bad has happened but it sometimes scary when there is one around.

[@gailhandschuh1138]

At the very least, Gertrude wasn’t alone all those years, her family stayed close to watch over her. Shows the closeness and dedication of the family unit. God Bless them all RIP FRIENDS. ❤️❤️❤️😆😘😘

[@twocents7495]

I picture her having romantic interludes in the secret chamber 😊

[@mjoverocker6072]

I think she was a beautiful woman, may she RIP

[@joaquimrodriguez8961]

She is resting in peace. That's what dead people do.

[@patriciahayes7315]

Her sister Julia was very pretty, too. I'd say she was the family beauty. :)

[@dmecca9283]

Bacon, eggs, toast, and a cup of coffee sitting in my den listening to my absolute favorite storyteller. What a great way to start my day. Thanks Oddie, you're the greatest!👍🏽

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Enjoy!

[@ghostcityshelton9378]

Kool! I just cooked some mash potatoes left over from last night and eggs and you mix them together with really good spices and coffee. Waste not, want not. Then a quick clean up, then it's Oddie time ! !!

[@QuantumPyrite_88.9]

Sitting here with a big mug of hot tea , expensive cognac and a cheap cigar .

[@dmecca9283]

@@QuantumPyrite_88.9 👍🏽

[@dmecca9283]

@@ghostcityshelton9378 👍🏽

[@rachelbartlett1970]

This is just a few blocks away from me! I may have to take a walk there today and see if Gertrude will appear on the doorstep for me

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Have fun!

[@KellyfromMemphis]

Lucky! Would love to visit that place

[@tahira1]

Let's us know if she does.

[@CarTa3]

I live very close too! I bet the museum is closed Sundays by I'm definitely going to try tomorrow

[@lindaireland2751]

@@CarTa3 keep as posted

[@jax2913]

Poor Gertrude, couldn't marry her true love, then watched as one by one her family passed away around her. God bless her and I do hope she's at peace. Thanks Mr Oddity! Lovely video, brought a tear to my eye.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

That's very kind of you, thank you for that.

[@Delaney-and-the-Starlight]

I love this place! It is definitely haunted but not in a scary way. More in a welcoming way? It starts to smell like perfume and good things when you compliment the house! And her mom had AMAZING taste in lace! Sometimes her dresses are out on display and you can see them! And I got a really beautiful vase here 💕

[@brucewayne-cn4vd]

Its funny that it seems the ghosts know their home is a museum and sort of play the part.

[@QuantumPyrite_88.9]

My old stone house is over 200 years old . I got used to the smell of a lady's perfume , her singing , sounds in the kitchen and the smell of food cooking many years ago . She even has a ghost cat named Gem . All the best to you Mr. Wayne .

[@inannatyche3413]

Yes it is.. so cool.. I would love to go there and talk to the entities..

[@lindaireland2751]

Yeah thats great like bugger off we live ere 🤣

[@lindaireland2751]

@@QuantumPyrite_88.9 thats great

[@littleredwitch]

@@inannatyche3413 Me too!

[@marievaleur7877]

What a sad yet beautifully touching story. I admit I shed a tear for dear Gertrude in her solitude. On a lighter note, I live surrounded by my several pieces of my family's Victorian furniture, crystal, porcelain, photos and such mixed in with my own things and I totally understand the 'time capsule' idea 😉😄 My father never got rid of anything from his family!

[@lindaireland2751]

How lovely yeah I can't explain why but that time frame stays with me in my heart don't know why can't explain

[@jennycallaghan3073]

I too have my grandmother's furniture. Maybe not Victorian, but it's mahogany Baker furniture from Manhattan from the early 1900s.

[@marylevin9262]

@@lindaireland2751 same here - i get such a feeling i can't explain seeing the insides of these homes 💜

[@tourbillon13]

@@marylevin9262 Perhaps you and Linda lived in that era in a past life? I'm enraptured by the 1920's, and male Evening Dress. I can still tie a white Bowtie! My house is full of Art Deco pieces, it simply makes me feel happy, even down to my "Spat" cream and tan shoes 🤗 my gf thinks am quite mad of course, but she would look fabulous as a "Flapper!!!" Fascinating to think about really 🤔 you just never know! Thank you so much Oddie really enjoyed this, as always! Hope you are well. Take care all...just off to brush my tails 😂

[@blazefairchild465]

@@tourbillon13 You should dress as you feel best. My son wanted a kilt since he was small when he was 16 he had grown a beard & had beautiful red hair 6 ft 4 inches . He ordered a utility kilt. It was made with snap pockets & a hammer hoop so a tradesman could ware it. He wore it to school & I was afraid the teachers would make him change into his running pants. No , the kilt was a big hit everyone loved it & many boys & girls got the website to order their own. He loved it so much he later ordered a dress up kilt for more formal occasions.

[@clowchan]

Had the privilege to visit this house in 2019. They let you do self-tours there and let you take pictures in a coffin (or did. Not sure what the current situation is now) One of the most underrated museums in Manhattan . I know they were having issues due to construction nearby and the noise was wrecking the house's foundation. Hopefully it's ok now. Thanks for telling this story about Gertrude, Oddie! The entire family is fascinating!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you! 😊 Glad you enjoyed the presentation my friend!

[@TheLadybughug]

I like to think that Gertrude is pleased that her beloved home has been restored. She seems lovely.

[@kellyxx3288]

I hope the building becomes heritage listed. It sounds like such a lonely existence but she seemed quite content.

[@corposant]

Unfortunately, in the US we only have Historical Landmark designations and such a designation doesn't have any teeth to really protect a place. I am envious of how serious the UK takes there architectural heritage.

[@at5389]

Libs probably already leveled it.

[@pegs1659]

@@at5389 It looks like its been turned into Apts.

[@littleredwitch]

@@pegs1659 Oh no! That’s so sad!

[@pegs1659]

@@littleredwitch Update I looked on Google and it says its still there and being maintained with all the historical things in there.

[@MadHatterDJ-]

Sounds like they don’t need to pay guides to take people around the house, just let the ghosts do it for free. I’m so pleased they were able to preserve the home it’s such a treasure, they need to take care of it.

[@myriamkhoury862]

YEEEEYYY finally an Oddie video! I miss your stories man, thanks for being awesome.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for your very kind feedback - much appreciated 😊

[@amc5936]

@@ObsoleteOddity please do a story on my cusin alfred horance wells. killed three and great story with a few twist. aka the hunchback killer he was my cusin

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Here's the link to the Collyer Brothers video for those who haven't seen it: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mKDLhHtrn9ClrNk I am posting on KZbin selected previously locked Patreon videos that are approximately 1.5 (one and a half) years old. This is one of them. Some of the topics discussed on the 'blah blah' towards the end of video, because of the upload date, may no longer be relevant. Many, many thanks to my patrons on Patreon for enabling me to keep going - bless you all!

[@sircharlesborrows7845]

Hi from Lord Charles borrows from UK

[@777blazek]

Oddie, YOU, MY FRIEND ARE TRULY AHHHMAZING! MUCH LOVE AND CONTINUED SUCCESS ❤ SEND LOVE TO THE MRS. YES!!! GET THE THRONE! I KNOW I WOULD LOVE TO CHAT ABOUT VINTAGE CRIME!!

[@ghostcityshelton9378]

I like to think that in the afterlife she met her husband to be that I think daddy may have killed in the house way back and that they're happy together at last. Maybe we go to another demention, maybe they see things as they wete way back. Where we see cars, they see carriages and folks wear the long dresses and such. Do they get to choose the time period they want to be in, or somehow just placed there by some higher being knowing they would be the most comfortable there... I know ...crazy questions huh? One day we'll eighter just wink out or find out.

[@ghostcityshelton9378]

It's probably just shaddows but if you go to the second floor go to the left with a mag glass it looks like a face in the window and next to it figures inside. Prob. just funiture but who knows.😥 AT--14:44 -- 2 windows up to the left you can see the 'face ' again. At--15:48-- the right hand side it states she own alot of land , 6 million in worth, if so who did that go to and maybe she wasn't so poor after all. At--15:50-- that looks like the same kind of couch Mr. Borden was found dead. Doesn't it?

[@friskyopossum7983]

Yep, when I go belly up, I plan to float around out front and tell the local kids to get off my lawn.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

lol

[@free3dmodelsfbx]

And I'm gonna be the exorcist who will send you to place you belong, and sell that story to Hollywood. Thanks man for making me rich!

[@777blazek]

🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂.... #goalsfortheafterlife

[@Lizablue0608]

LOL…🤣👍🏼

[@tahira1]

Lol

[@InsomniOwl_]

I'd absolutely love to buy that entire block and feature the time of Gertrude. New York has a responsibility to care for such properties.

[@markarnold8014]

Oddie, I am a fan of this channel because you always present these stories with dignity and grace. Thank you for giving voice to this legacy and for always showing such respect and proportion to the content. I truly enjoyed this one......may Miss Tredwell and her family rest in peace.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@marylevin9262]

so agree !

[@TheSpiritReborn]

Thank you, Oddie! I find it a delight to hear of families that still value and treasure the legacy of their family. This is becoming a very rare thing in our time. It is a shame that this poor lady was forbidden to share this beauty with the man she loved. How awful it would have been to be the only one left out of your large family. How it must have been haunting. At least she knew how to love that deeply.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Glad you enjoyed the presentation Angelica :) I agree, it must have been very sad to have been the last of the family in that big house. I hope she had a few close friends/family to visit her.

[@lestatangel]

I live in a Victorian built in 1902. I've been here 3 years and there's really no way to explain how I feel about this house except to say that when I die I will Haunt It. With the Others here.

[@manilynligaya9048]

Hahahahahahha

[@lindaarrington9397]

Lol hope you enjoy it

[@lestatangel]

@@lindaarrington9397 It's A Love Affair of sorts.

[@christicrenshaw2772]

I hope they don't do that to the Merchant house. They need to fix it up and take care of it. I agree

[@littleredwitch]

According to the comments it has, unfortunately, been bulldozed to make place for appartments. What a sacrilege! 🥲

[@alexah3256]

@@littleredwitch It's actually still there, but developers are trying to build condos next door that would dwarf the building and possibly damage it. Thus far the board has voted against the development, but it's still in danger.

[@littleredwitch]

@@alexah3256 Good to know this. Someone has posted that it was gone. I do hope that it is restored and finds a useful purpose that will assure its survival. (Museum, historic B&B or whatever would be suitable).

[@shawnaellcey6970]

Another excellent episode from obsolete Oddity!!! Very well done- this is the best channel on KZbin! Also, Oddy must visit New Orleans if he gets to America! Such creepy historical sites!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate your positive feedback - thank you very much :)

[@ericanelson1973]

Would love to see some stories from New Orleans!

[@TheKulu42]

I'd want to visit that place, too. If I had a time machine, I'd want to see the home and the neighborhood in its heyday. As usual, your presentation is outstanding, and I think you're absolutely right. NYC surely could buy out the surrounding properties and create a park!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

That would be cool! I really appreciate your positive feedback - thank you very much :)

[@rhondalee2170]

That was great! I love a good ghost story. It's not October now but I found this scrolling through on a quiet Sunday morning. It feels comforting when I hear your voice Oddie. You are truly an amazing story teller of things come to pass! ☕💕💋

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for your kind words Rhonda, that's so nice of you.

[@laina8553]

I love your story telling and all the little details that make this experience. Keep up the amazing work!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you! Will do!

[@christicrenshaw2772]

I love story like this. It's kinda sad. I would love to visit some day.

[@michellep9999]

I absolutely love she came out to say “get off my lawn.” Lol. I love her!

[@heatherlawson3437]

What an amazing, but hauntingly sad story. It's like the house tat Gertrude lived in long after her family passed was a tomb, not a home. It's very sad to think how lonely she must have been, and she lived to be quite a good age. Fantastic narration, so nice to listen to, and, as always another great true story that I haven't heard of before.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for your very kind feedback Heather - much appreciated 😊

[@amandasusanne4657]

A great Sunday at home.. with Oddie Beau ❤

[@DeeNailsX]

Your stories are by far my favorite videos to watch on KZbin. Thank you so much for these wonderful uploads

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate your positive feedback - thank you very much :)

[@patsmith9284]

Wonderful, Wonderful story; I love the ancient folks and the way they lived. Thank you Oddie, you are amazing 👏

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Many thanks!

[@DerekNing]

Another brilliant presentation Odds! Your videos are like a mini time travel and didn't realize how much I've missed them until now. Thank you, my friend!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Many thanks!

[@miracleboi7336]

its night time here and im about to go to sleep bc im really so tired but i saw this and your voice and stories is what it feels like to come home with no work tomorrow. i thank you so much for posting at this moment.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for your kind words, that's so nice of you.

[@lindaireland2751]

Yeah he has a great voice

[@sheilagraham4144]

Thank you so much for sharing this! How fascinating! I've always been drawn to old houses and the stories of those who resided there. I could spend days inside this house, simply soaking up its memories and aura. Oddie, you're simply the best!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you :)

[@shazzali5156]

Same here

[@jayleigh4642]

This was fascinating to me and it came with so many deep emotions Sadness for Gertrude’s loss for a love she was forbidden to have, then here family slowly dying and her money starting to run out was heartbreaking in itself. I agree with you about the city of New York stepping up to the plate and looking after the merchant house better, but, I found when I lived on that side of the pond for over 10 years they were all about “getting rid of the old and in with the new” Unlike us here in the UK we do love to hold onto our history. Anyway, a truly fascinating story very well delivered and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Thank you so much. I'm such a happy new subscriber 🤣🤣🙏🏻

[@ObsoleteOddity]

That is very kind of you and it really makes my day, that my efforts are so appreciated - I thank you sincerely.

[@vampirequeen953]

Absolutely fantastic!! Definitely have to say your stories keep getting better and better!! I'm so looking forward to your next video.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much!

[@vampirequeen953]

@@ObsoleteOddity You are without a doubt so welcome 😊😊😊

[@MM-nn4vz]

@@ObsoleteOddity my you a great voice tell these story 😻

[@Fairybongmother]

My spooky goal for the afterlife is to be known as the sarcastic ghost of wherever the place is where I am haunting. Thank you for this one. It was interesting. I want to know more about what happened to Louis after the relationship. The condition of the outside is sad to see. I hope that something is done to preserve such an amazing property.

[@empressoftheknownuniverse]

Well researched, scripted and narrated. The music is spine-tingling and the visuals haunting. Thank you so much for your work. 😊

[@ObsoleteOddity]

That's very kind of you, thank you for that!

[@robinmartz9052]

I found it on google, and they’re at least keeping the house up. It’s beautiful. It’s just horrible the surroundings. Where has peoples respect for others gone?! It would be so fun to go see it. I have a bucket list. One can dream

[@mareebrown2163]

I googled it too. Says a lot about modern humans. Not in a good way either.

[@rocksteady4me]

I can't keep saying "Well Oddie, you've done it again". I do LOVE your way of telling a story. I sure hope you keep it up because I've learned about a lot of people watching you. I watch other story tellers. I think you're the best. Hugs to you and to Oddette!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for your kind words my friend, that's so nice of you.

[@cherylcallahan5402]

Absolute Oddity Gertrude Treadwell appreciate your videos Listening from Mass USA TYVM ♥️ 93 years Gertrude

[@gvivo2120]

Splendid! I was expecting true stories like this to take place in a British rather than an American setting. Mr. Oddie Beau, I was entranced by the beauty of this presentation. THIS is the kind of ghost story I believe suitable for the more discriminating audiences: it is elegantly serene and as you say, gentle (nothing vulgar about it) and marked by a sweet melancholy that leaves you aching with nostalgia. It is a rare beauty. I am still 53 but i consider myself an antiquarian when it comes to literature... however, true-to-life stories like this accommodate my taste for the vintage. There is something about the past that makes it worth holding on to and letting go of it is tantamount to a dying. A tear rolls down while listening to the demise of each Treadwell family member all the way until the last daughter is left alone to EMBRACE and keep alive the ravishing beauty of a dying past about to be devoured by an encroaching civilization devoid of heart and soul. Their spectral visitations were rather... friendly, to say the least. They were not at all intimidating; one may as well consider such visits most welcoming.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much for reaching out with your kind feedback 😊 So glad you enjoyed the presentation - very much appreciated 😊

[@debbiejones3911]

That was very good. I always found the Collyer Brothers to be very interesting too.

[@mita729able]

Wow! I spent every summer in Brooklyn growing up and didn't know about this museum. I definitely have to go see it this summer. Thank you so much for sharing! You really are an amazing storyteller.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@yodagaming2559]

If you are into creepy things in the Brooklyn area, the docent at the MHM suggested the Museum of Morbid Anatomy and the Green-Wood Cemetery, both of which are in Brooklyn. I think the D or A train will take you down there from midtown.

[@originaloldfashionedtarot]

That was excellent! Thank you again, Oddie. Another creepy treat. Surely she wanted to keep appearances and could hide away if embarrassed. It may have been better to be thought a recluse to her. That last picture of what it's like on that street made me catch my breath. You're positively correct about preserving the area around the house, as well. It's so decrepit and sad. NY has lost its glamour, for sure.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you! 😊 Glad you enjoyed the presentation my friend!

[@chanel58style70]

I really really enjoyed this. The music you attached was beautiful. I thought it was weird that Gertrude never married (you explained why she didn’t). But why none of her other sisters married. The picture you showed of the area surrounding the home is really sad. It looks like a rough section of NY. It certainly takes away from the charm of the home. Thanks for this video. You never disappoint

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much!

[@Therealgirlinthedesert]

Yes, just thrilled I found you. My absolute favorite storyteller ever. Thank you for this one. Wonderful way to spend my Sunday afternoon.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Welcome aboard! Thank you so much for reaching out with your kind feedback 😊

[@SueGirling68]

Hi Oddie, wow what a stunning place and with an amazing history attached to it. How awful that such a beautiful property is surrounded by such an awful area. Thank you for sharing, much love. xx 💖

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@bagpuss211]

Brilliant video, best one yet, tastefully narrated & beautifully choreographed! You always excel yourself😘

[@ObsoleteOddity]

So glad you enjoyed the presentation - very much appreciated 😊

[@charlesclager6808]

WONDERFUL WONDERFUL WONDERFUL story. Now this is my favorite type of presentation that you do. The visuals, the tale itself and your masterful voice combine to make it a delightful experience. I want you to know that the considerable work you must invest in this and other like presentations is totally appreciated. Oddie, you made my day. Thank you so much. Charlie C.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Glad you enjoyed it! That's very kind of you, thank you for that.

[@toolsteel8482]

I really enjoyed this. So glad in 1936 , a man saw the historical significance of this house., and ultimately, subsequent caretakers saw its preservation. The 1960’s saw wholesale destruction of so many historic buildings. I was thinking of the collyer brothers before you mentioned them. The building still stands but definitely needs help; I agree NYC should step up to really secure this property. Thank you Oddiy, loved this.

[@christineevans4408]

I’m laying here in Hospital after a rather large operation and come on to your Chanel I really enjoyed this story well done and thank you

[@ObsoleteOddity]

So glad you enjoyed the presentation - very much appreciated 😊 Get well soon!

[@pipiwilson7854]

💐

[@mizera_mykle]

Thank you so much Oddie, your soothing voice and choice of story is just what I need to feel less alone. Sad how people take all the kindness offered over decades then turn away when the source of kindness, me, becomes old and disabled. Heaven forbid I ask for help, which I tried, only to be rebuffed. It hurts but thankfully Oddie *always* pops up with the most perfect pick-me-up. Happy loving hugs dear Oddie🤗 EDIT: I'm sorry to say dear Oddie but America overall has no sense of preservation. Too many citizens are only interested in turning as much of this nation in to a ghetto, sad but true.😞

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much for reaching out with your kind feedback 😊

[@patricialenaburg6553]

I was absolutely enthralled with this story, so sad, and haunting {no pun intended}. Every step leaves you spell bounded, and wanting more. I agree, this old home deserves better than what it is getting. If it's a historical site, you would think the city would buy the property on both sides to keep the damages limited to this old home. A shame, Gertrude with meager means kept it up as best she could, and the city doesn't seem to care. It's all about money, and gain. Thank you Oddie, your stories are the best.

[@ghostcityshelton9378]

Please read the bottom part of the newspaper clipping. It seems she may have owned alot of land worth 6 million if I read it right. Maybe she didn't know her family owned it?

[@patricialenaburg6553]

@@ghostcityshelton9378 I will have to go back, and read it, what a shame if she didn't know. Thank you.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@pompokkko]

I hope to visit it someday. Gonna include in my museum bucket list.

[@gigisong81]

OMG WHEN U DO COME PLEASE HOST A MEET AND GREET! IM SURE THERE ARE MANY WHO AGREE WOULD LOVE TO PURCHASE TICKETS TO MAKE IT HAPPEN!! PLEASE VISIT!! 🥰🥰🥰

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Glad you enjoyed the presentation Gigi, yes one day I will get over to the US! :)

[@christicrenshaw2772]

Yes would love that

[@alexiswaller3065]

This would have been in the glided age .Has me thinking of Edith Wharton and The Age Of Innocence .She is one my favorite authors .She was part of old New York society wonder if they crossed paths .

[@beverlykrebs4372]

Hello Oddy! Thanks for remembering us poor folk on YT! LOL! 😉 I have missed your wonderful videos & hearing your pleasant voice reading such scrumptuously creepy stories! I loved this story. I remember your video on the Collyer brothers. That was more sad than anything. But thank you very, very much forvthis story about poor Gertrude. I'm 61 and kind of reclusive myself (although nowhere near this extent!) so I feel very sorry for her. Lots of love dear Oddy!! XO

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you kindly!

[@luvuforeverjames]

Well worth waiting for and excellent narration as usual by yourself dear oddie. Quite sad for poor Gertrude though. I look forward to hearing more about haunted houses in these time capsules.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@shazzali5156]

I absolutely love this Oddie! The story, the music, the pictures, everything is brilliantly presented ❤️ Hopefully there are more stories like this in the future Oddie 😍 It amazes me how a place like that was well kept just like in it's glory days. Thank you so much Oddie & looking forward for your next video. Keep it up 👏🏻❤️

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much!

[@cherylsurplice1417]

It makes sense that it’s so haunted bc the house has its original belongings and it must b a comforting place to b for these spirits.

[@jessidade2039]

I love the history of that beautiful house is amazing. It's terrible the surrounding area has become. It's absolutely fantastic that it's still there. I love the stories like this. I thought you'd been here to the states. You really should come soon before more of our history is lost. Miss Jessi

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I totally agree!

[@bubzilla6137]

I'm always impressed with the amount of research you do for these videos! All the editing and stuff is impressive too, of course, but all the photos and such that you put in here require searching. Another fascinating story! I love these so much! 🤗🤗🤗

[@lindaireland2751]

Yeah great eh

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much for reaching out with your kind feedback 😊

[@lindaireland2751]

@@ObsoleteOddity your welcome I love the old stories&things like this 😊

[@tinkerbell1479]

Nothing compares to a lovely relaxing Sunday afternoon watching one of your amazing videos Oddie 😌🥰

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for your very kind feedback - much appreciated 😊

[@lovescoffee9780]

I would love to visit this home. Old homes intrigue me. Thank you for this fine story. As always, enjoyed.

[@notit340]

what a beautiful home! and amazing the interior is so original everything still there, so glad they saved it.

[@Liz-cmc313]

Nice story. Amazing the home still stands.

[@cherylfoster1223]

Just a great rendention of the past lives of folks. Thanks for sharing. Stay safe and healthy.

[@sarahm9615]

Finally got the time for your video. On a grey afternoon with a big cup of tea, under a blanket on the couch. I love it❤ thank you Oddie

[@ObsoleteOddity]

That is most definitely a wise decision on a grey afternoon...sofa, blanket...bliss :)

[@emilyromany6181]

Listened to this every night since it was posted to lull me to sleep...truly, that voice of yours. 💓💓

[@ObsoleteOddity]

That's very kind of you, thank you for that.

[@msc8663]

What a lovely story thank you for sharing. I miss hearing your stories. Love to you oddie and Mrs oddie. Be safe with this virus my friend.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks so much!

[@marieelena]

The Biltmore hotel in Coral Gables, Florida , built in the 1920s,may be of interest to you. There is a suppose haunted suite of rooms where in the 1920s had illegal gambling and alcohol by the Chicago mob. In the 1940s,the Biltmore was converted into a VA hospital and it's also haunted by American soilders that died there from their injuries after WWII. It's now a luxury again with list of many famous guests that have staid there.

[@JudithElizabeth67]

You are my favorite channel on KZbin! This was a wonderful experience! I really like how you create! You are fantastic in what you do! Thank you for yet another wonderful experience! It saddens me that these beautiful old houses are often forgotten. These houses deserves so much more respect. And should be much more preserved! I fully agree with you there! Fantastic creation and upload!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

That's very kind of you, thank you for that!

[@loislloyd4476]

I love your commentaries on different events that have occurred in the past about people or events, which includes the weird, creepy & wonderful disclosures you present. You have a unique narrating method. From Perth, Western Australia. ❤👍

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you for reaching out with your positive feedback Lois, Much appreciated 🙏

[@cathythecup5782]

Watching your video absolutely made my day and made my work day much better. Love your videos ❤️❤️

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Wow, thank you!

[@georginalim5409]

Mr. Oddie's voice is impeccable. Your narrative adds to the already chilling cases and great photos of all times! Thanks for all the videos!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@georginalim5409]

@@ObsoleteOddity Thank you for bringing us all the great stories 🙏

[@darkskinneddamsel8203]

Patreon Member for life yet I still get a kick whenever there's a YT posting. Great video, Oddie! 😍

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for the loyalty and great feedback my friend! 😊

[@arbel7655]

Same; It's strange but I couldn't find this on one Patreon. I'd prefer to watch and listen without commercials but I'll watch Oddie anywhere.

[@darkskinneddamsel8203]

@@arbel7655 my sentiments exactly, Friend! 😊

[@hauntedhighway2166]

THANK YOU, Sir, for the trip back in time. I empathize greatly with Gertrude Tredwell. It sounds like she had / has a gentle soul. I hope she has found peace.

[@grandmimm]

Your editing is awesome, I absolutely love how much work you put into your work, so much passion & love, I greatly appreciate your hard work, love this story, I would so love to be able touch history

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much!!

[@calliopec544]

Just had to give this one a re-listen. Definitely one of my favorite stories. Thanks again, Oddie!

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I’m happy to hear that, thank you! 😊🙏

[@anniej1834]

Smashed the like button now time 2 kick back and get stuck into the video thanks Oddi really enjoyed the video see u next time u post 😊 x

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Much appreciated!

[@Sandra-ww6oz]

Mr Oddie your delivered this engaging story with such style and charisma and, as usual I feel as if I have been in a dream state wishing it would go on longer. Thank you ❤️🐨🇦🇺.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

That’s a great compliment Sandra, thank you very much 🙏😊

[@KellyfromMemphis]

We even have a few old Victorian mansions that are museums in my town, don’t know if they are haunted though. I think I’ll go an visit now that our governor has lifted the state of emergency (and mandatory mask order) yesterday...

[@jrsalazar1465]

I had never heard this story... Everything in this documentary was brilliantly done! Excellent

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@SeekingSerpent6]

This was a very good story. I really enjoy it. I am sadden and not surprise about the place in New York..Thank U and I hope u are doing well.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for listening!

[@gerardexupery2532]

I was a volunteer docent in the old merchants house in the '80s. I spent a lbit of time in the place by myself and I can tell you that it was never lonely. It was a privilege to work there.

[@mariekitty]

I love the paranormal stories. Thanks, Oddie. R.I.P.. Gertrude and family.

[@AndreonLong]

Thank you, Oddie. I grew up reading about the ghost stories. Very fascinating narrative you provide.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much for reaching out with your kind feedback 😊

[@annaszdidi1355]

Thank you for make my day..Oddie..you dont know how much it meant to me...

[@ObsoleteOddity]

You are so welcome my friend

[@michellejeaneden2083]

Oh ive missed your voice. Its like having family come for a visit. Im snuggled in my comfy over stuffed chair, my 2 old dogs at my feet and gonna listen to all your stories I've missed. With no shortage of my favorite cup of tea, real cream and Organic Honey. Life is good. Thank you.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for your kind words Michelle, that's so nice of you.

[@jacquelinequigley6035]

Who cares what your talking about you have the most magnetic voice. I could listen to you for hours oh I do!! I always love the content. Good job keep it up

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@BrandyD1777]

I can't believe I have never noticed or visited this house when I go to NY. I love Washington Square for many reasons. Great convo with up & coming artists, musicians, scholars of all kind. I must have seen this house and knew nothing about it....I can't wait to get back and visit. Thanks Oddie. Best channel on YT that should be monetized....Oddie does his own research, gives us facts, time period authentic photos or ones that actually are authentic to the story. Happy Sunday Oddie. Thank you for all you do, your passion, and always sharing ❤️

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thanks for your kind words Brandy, that's so nice of you.

[@in_vino_veritas7938]

This is a lovely story about an interesting family and their activities. I would very much like to visit the museum, spirits and ghosts don't frighten me. Sounds silly but it would be nice to visit and have conversations with them. :) I grew up in a haunted house, it wasn't particularly pleasant but well, I guess I'm more intrigued. This is great, Oddie, thanks for all your hard work in sharing these videos with us

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@cinbritton5626]

This was one of the most beautifully divine stories...I can totally relate to those, of any age, including ours, that choose to not change their way of living, while all the while the world outside seems to constantly change around us all. Thank you so very much for this.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate that. Thank you :)

[@susaaz]

Oldie what awonderful story. Now to do more research and see the museum brochures

[@rubysanchez-powell9184]

As always my son and I enjoyed another episode from you. We loved it. Thank you, so much for all your hard work. We really appreciate it 🤗

[@ObsoleteOddity]

Thank you so much for reaching out with your kind feedback 😊

[@glendaeden2501]

I loved this story! So sad for Gertrude and Louis.

[@deana1938]

Oddy, the way you tell these stories makes me feel almost as if I knew these people personally. I love how you bring these characters to life using your beautiful voice. Thank you so very much kind sir.

[@ObsoleteOddity]

I really appreciate your positive feedback - thank you very much :)