Get To US Border Or Die Trying: Chinese Migrants Inch Toward American Dream | Part 2 - Walk The Line

[@rickylow1655]

I like how the entire program gives no judgement, nor delve into politics. It is just an examination of the human side of this current illegal immigration crisis.

[@PM2024-]

Yet they still play creepy background music 🤔

[@annsaunders5768]

It's propaganda.

[@lomoon5214]

它并没有输出太多自己的观点，只是描述现实，剩下的就留给观众思考这个选择是否值得。

[@TrumponSoaksUpRed]

@@annsaunders5768 fifty cents just credited to your BOC account

[@TrumponSoaksUpRed]

@@annsaunders5768 Check your BOC account. You have just received your Wu Mao

[@jc_production]

I say CNA and Wei Du deserves an award. This documentary is unblieveable. Pay me 100k I still won't dare to take up such filming.

[@Mark-mo7rv]

China is large land but ordinary people are unhappy because of greed for power of their leaders that's why this is happening.

[@TrumponSoaksUpRed]

@@Mark-mo7rvwho cares its large ? It is poor AF

[@worksmart196]

​@Mark-mo7rv I often go to Mainland China where most people are happy.

[@candyllj]

@@Mark-mo7rv You are right, I am a chinese and I don't feel happy because of many many reasons. Most of chinese wants to go out of this country.

[@ThePomskysPalace]

Then you need to watch Bald and Bankrupts adventure crossing the Darian gap. As respectable as this documentary is, it’s late to the game. There’s journalists that have done something similar with almost no budget or camera crew.

[@Lkzz279]

"We thought the streets in America were paved with gold" ohh boy, the reality is gonna hit hard on them.

[@crystal2484]

Better than to starve to death with no job prospect and no welfare back home. For those at the bottom of the ranks, there is literally NO opportunity cost to walk the line. TBH, u r not in their shoes to think u know better, your statement shows your ignorant.

[@bluesky-ui7qf]

I laughed out loud at this video while drinking afternoon tea in Guangzhou 哈哈哈--又要到饭了，兄弟们

[@politicalchannel66]

​@@bluesky-ui7qfChinese bot 😂

[@pamelaiken]

@@bluesky-ui7qf what do any of these immigrants are they that desperate to leave China?. I know it's not a pretty picture necessarily a good 70% of the people in China don't have opportunities to get a decent education to move up in their world; what we see through the China lens and what I teach online are those that have the money to move up and get education. it's a rough road. And I'm sure they're watching too many movies that makes America or any European country look like it's better than China. Living as an illegal immigrant is not better than your home country. Stay home fight to make it better. Americans are constantly fighting to make it better here and we've got a lot of issues with democracy. We have a lot of issues with our political system, but I still prefer it to an autocratic regime, let's see what time will tell

[@dualidea]

Hahahahaa 😂😂

[@ladyofhalos]

Wei Du hugging the aunties after meeting them again in Panama was such a human moment in this documentary.

[@JohnDoe-gb8st]

Cannot imagine the danger Wei Du and her team faced for this documentary. The perilous journey that these people are willing to take for the sake for better lives, makes us Singaporeans all the more appreciate what we have that we should not take for granted

[@Sovereign_Citizen_LEO]

There was no danger. I would have like to have seen them cross the Darian Gap on foot, but that was never their goal of course, and they never would have done it. This was a thinly veiled propaganda fluff piece.

[@ladyofhalos]

@@Sovereign_Citizen_LEO well it was unsafe for her. what is the "propaganda fluff piece" angle even??

[@Sovereign_Citizen_LEO]

@@ladyofhalos - I was speaking in general (of CNA). This particular documentary is generally well done with little to no "propaganda", but if there were any "angle", as you put it, it would be to discourage Chinese Citizens from attempting to leave China and immigrate to America. Chinese Citizens in America would generally give America an advantage against the CCP in the same way that Millions of Americans in China would give America a potential advantage or edge against the CCP. The questions you are asking are too difficult to explain in a few sentences on KZbin, as the problems in both countries are infinitely complex and interrelated.

[@tainle]

johndoe is a bot

[@johnnywong1018]

Its not a better life in amerika its all faked

[@dbwkdidwbsof]

I cried when they gave their testimony. They left their home country with such immense faith and gave up everything so that their daughter and they themselves could be with Christ. I pray that the Lord continues to watch over them and keep them safe through all the troubles and social instability they are about to encounter in America. Shalom!

[@funpau7549]

Hope they will be safe settling in US, and that they would not be in refugee camps if China starts war.

[@Sovereign_Citizen_LEO]

This comment lol. Are you Christian or Jewish (or Communist Chinese)? Do you think the social instability in the USA is going to be worse than what they've already experienced in China? I don't think so. That's why they gave up everything to come here. And that is not to say there is not social instability in America (or that it isn't intentionally getting worse through Communist/ Globalist Usury Subversion). Because it is.

[@habyi8423]

As long as you travel to China for a few days, you will find that you have been deceived. 90% of the people they smuggle into China are criminals, those who owe money and refuse to pay it back, and so on

[@boratlion8613]

Isn’t China amazing and rich? We see it daily. Cry? What a joke.

[@Baxter_parxie]

​@@boratlion8613don't you hear the father said he can't have freedom it is not about financial issue

[@decem95]

Wei and production team, this is award-winning frontline journalism . Great job!

[@saraxia6981]

I don’t see humanity here in the documentary. They are ruthless. Watching people risk their lives.

[@chiahsu7386]

@@saraxia6981 They are not supposed to interfere with the so-called ruthless human smuggling, which is the job of law enforcement. They are journalists doing their jobs, and they did their jobs well.

[@saraxia6981]

@@chiahsu7386 I don’t think there’s a thing called ‘not suppose to’ in this case. Basic human nature.

[@chiahsu7386]

@@saraxia6981 So what are reporters supposed to do based on “basic human nature”? Help and risk being seen as human smugglers, or try to detain immigrants without legal authority or armed force? Keep in mind, these immigrants know the risks they’re taking.

[@saraxia6981]

@@chiahsu7386 no actually they dont. They said in the video that if they knew it was that hard and risky, they wont do it. The journalist knew the risk. The lease they can do is to inform them. not watching them to die. The journalist hided what she heard from the local authority from these poor people for the sake of the "success" of this video!

[@amandacalvo1211]

I don’t have words to thank you for this amazing documentary. This is pure gold. Thank you so much for this work. I am Brazilian, I would never imagine in my whole life that Chinese people are immigrating to the US like this, and specially that they are going through Colombia. This is insane. Even myself as a Latina don’t have the courage to go there. Such a dangerous place. I hope someday all people on earth have some dignity.

[@wenerjy]

As a Chinese-American who had the opportunity to be a digital nomad in Latin America, it's crazy to see all of these Chinese migrants as well. Anecdotally, my friends in Colombia told me that this is now a very lucrative business venture for the cartels - they've made peace and share the profits - and that the Colombian side of the Darien Gap is actually super safe as a result. However, the Panama side is still very dangerous, because the Colombian cartels don't share the profits with them.

[@jetd9716]

​@@wenerjyboth the US and Panama have agreed to police and close the Darien Gap for immigrants to cross. They will need to find another option. Also, Biden has ban asylum status to illegals other than in specific circumstances. As a result, illegal numbers have gone down by 60% in the last month.

[@AllenYang-zf9qk]

all people hv dignity.thank you Amandacalvo

[@jessasmrcd]

It’s not about dignity but desperation for improving their lives from poverty, and death threats. When your life is a stake, dignity if the least of your worries. The disparity between social classes it’s horrific and the worst part is that the most vulnerable and innocent suffer the most

[@Elma-b1h]

IGNORANCE IS BLISS THEY DONT KNOW THERE IS DANGER THERE.

[@christopherlaw9184]

Thank you CNA, Wei Du and the team ⭐️ Respect

[@SubwayStreetvendorblocki-hn1wy]

They need to bravely fight for freedom in their own country. Just like the Legend of the Three Kingdoms Heroes Guang Fu, Cao Cao, Super Pig and the Iron Monkey. Be an example of Chinese bravery like the Hong Kong people, don't run away to other people's countries.

[@TrumponSoaksUpRed]

@@SubwayStreetvendorblocki-hn1wyThey won’t. It’s in their cowardly blood to run to other countries

[@ORISONTV]

depot all these scammers

[@Emmy-J]

Someone should tell them there is no American dream. That was gone decades ago.

[@saraxia6981]

The media has the responsibility to tell them the real danger. But she just hide away the info. They should shoulder part of blame for hiding the truth by watching them going through deadly risks.

[@jacobli7858]

America may not be what it used to be, but it's the still the land of the opportunity especially if you compare it to other countries.

[@BadodelsKA]

35:23 America is like the only country on earth at this point lol

[@KayLeeHoward-vc2ph]

Ya idk where there getting there info from media fb and utube arnt always truth states are better than other countries but not all of them we struggling too out here even upper class

[@DeeDeex007o]

It is a dream.... A nightmare!

[@michaelliu7373]

Excellent journalism 👍 As a fellow Chinese with legal status in Canada, I feel very privileged knowing what these people have gone through...

[@hkchan0709]

Hi

[@damien_ashraf]

Any tips for us?

[@ANUBIS209]

As a fellow Chinese American. I hope Trump gets re-elected so he could send every illegals packing

[@Tomor81]

So your good feeling is builded upon other people's difficulties?? 永远的三等公民！

[@downtomars6268]

They took the long hard route. Indians go to Canada as international students but get jobs, use food banks for the homeless. The Canadian government caves in to their protests to stay, work and claim permanent residence when they were suppose to leave after studies. Tens of thousands of Indians have done this in the past couple years. If they choose to go to the US, it's easier with a base in Canada. Some Canadians have noticed the substantial increase in the Indian population out of every other group and are miffed at their demands.

[@Onana888]

Can't imagine & comprehend the risks of crossing the Darien Gap despite the dangers and threats from drug cartels.. i'm glad the Chinese family made it out in one piece, the trek may look easy on camera but the mental and physical stress/tiredness is not one can easily relate to... Well done to the CNA team & Wei who undertook the risks and danger to shoot with a cam & bring us this excellent documentary to us!!! A REALLY BIG RISK!!!

[@crystal2484]

in other documentaries, 4 in 10 did not make it.

[@hartonolee]

As singaporean, we are exposed to so many news outlets from western mainstream to independent to russian etc. I maybe biased but cna is really the best. No bs no propoganda just great journalism.

[@wsmithe2209]

As Singaporean, this is totally an BS. There are flights from China to other countries in South America including Mexico. From there, they can take bus or other transportation to Mexican side of El Paso city. From there, they can walk right inside US. There are direct flights from China to Mexico. All these people fell for the scam.

[@hartonolee]

@@wsmithe2209 you are absolutely right. Unless they cannot even get a mexican visa which is truly suspect. Its really unclear what the background of these people.

[@calvinchow160]

@wsmithe2209 Chinese citizens require a visa to go to Mexico. The people who are being smuggled are usually heavily in debt or unemployed and would struggle to get a Mexican visa. Ecuador is normally chosen as the starting point because it's visa free for Chinese citizens

[@wsmithe2209]

@@calvinchow160 - Visa fee is nothing comapre to airfare, food and staying. Getting a visa to Mexico should not be a problem from China.

[@wsmithe2209]

@@hartonolee - There are many Chinese setup shops selling goods in central America. Some are making it and some aren't. The ones that are not making it don't have enough money to fly back home. This is the way to go back home free.

[@minlim8744]

One of the best documentaries in recent years. Thank you Wei Du for journeying with these people along the line!

[@joycelok1767]

God protect them all the

[@enganntan6969]

I have watched all the 3 parts in one shot. Wei Du and the team did a great job.. Very professional and in-depth ..Salute and respect👍👍👍

[@2KSnSLifestyle]

Typical biased Western propaganda and unprofessional reporting. CNA didn't even bother to investigate the background of these people. The US government issues millions of visa to Chinese Nationals every year. There are hundreds of direct flights from China to America every week.

[@peijuns9698]

This is absolutely riveting! So proud of CNA for doing this documentary and thank you to the production team for risking their lives to document this.

[@DHDH_DH]

Wei Du, you are brave and great! Thank you so much for your work!

[@diorll8147]

It ends at a cliff hanger, is what differentiates other documentary than this, truly heart stopping

[@user-uj4xl5ct5y]

Kudos to CNA team!Kudos to Du Wei! A remarkable documentary to watch these Chinese migrants who risk their life to reach to the US.

[@petertiang71]

Grass always seems greener on the other side, until you get there

[@llamaliammm]

sometimes it actually is greener pastures for these ppl

[@aat399]

It seems greener until they encounter blatant racism. That's why a lot of Chinese went back to China after a few years in US - it is far far worse ...

[@xiphoid2011]

I'm a Shanghainese immigrant to US. Yes, the grass REALLY is greener in the US. But the big disclaimer is IF you come here legally and you are a good student. I came here as a top student. My wife is from GuangXi, and we were classmates in graduate school. We, like MOST chinese Americans are now living the American Dream. Keep in mind, most Chinese Americans are wealthier than even white americans. Most of us have university degrees, and 25% of us have masters/doctorates. This is the reason why we Chinese (Asian) Americans are so prosperous in the US, NOT by coming here illegally.

[@MickyLimon]

​@@xiphoid2011 , Is it worth it to leave China behind? I'm asking this because I've seen so many videos of China thriving, and it's good for foreigners living there. I'm curious.

[@nikedoesthings]

It's literally the difference between a dictatorial regime without freedom and a democracy with freedom. Depending on what you value, it might be worth taking the risk.

[@ICTicon]

Who ever behind this production, my DEEPEST RESPECT to all of you ❤❤❤❤ You present the dreams of humanity to the world 🌎 Those Chinese faces and their language are so familiar to some of my neighbours here in beautiful rural Malaysia ❤

[@sumc4897]

Can't you see it's propaganda to glorify the Murican dream adik? These are folks escaping the law...save your respect for our Tanah Air joining BRICS...😍😍

[@huangjian7749]

Wei Du is excellent journalism

[@muliyanto5097]

Every country is struggling so it’s citizens, so don’t ever think it would be better when you choose to run or leave your country

[@TommyLeUSA]

they are not running to leave their country but intentionally invading others

[@wenerjy]

I think unless your life is already in danger (like in certain Latin American countries), it is simply not worth the risk.

[@刘大华-r2n]

是的

[@seollllllla]

shout out to director Wei Du for always making meaningful documentaries!

[@PM2024-]

Why is every other comment praising “Wei Du?” 🤷🏻 seems suspicious 🤨

[@crosbyong]

I’ve watched all 3 parts. Thank you, CNA & Wei Du, for this enlightening and extremely sad documentary. What an excellent report! I’m looking forward to your follow-up report.

[@ronisugianto4416]

Terima kasih mbak Wei Du dan tim CNA untuk film dokumenternya yg sangat bagus ini. Dulu tahun 2005 (umur 18 thn) saya ikut undian green card dan lolos tapi saya waktu itu galau banget, di satu sisi pengin banget jadi warga U.S karena saya dari keluarga miskin tapi di sisi lain saya belum siap secara mental. Modal saya waktu itu cuma satu: bisa bahasa inggris. Akhirnya saya pun gagal ke Amerika. 3 tahun berselang saya nyaris merantau ke Canada, tapi akhirnya gagal juga. Andaikan dulu saya ambil kesempatan jadi U.S citizen mungkin nasib saya jauh lbh baik dan bisa membantu saudara dan keluarga. Sekarang hidup di Indo hanya cukup buat survive, hanya sedikit sisa utk ditabung, mau bangun rumah sederhana saja penuh perjuangan.

[@omilo888]

green card lottery itu scam biasanya

[@minchutong9296]

that man at 37:20, there's nothing we can do to help him, solely bearing the sorrow and pain of losing the love ones, without knowing what lies ahead of the future

[@Melange2]

My heart melted when I saw that man, you could really feel his pain talking about the recent deaths of his entire family

[@Happyllama220]

THIS is an asylum case. Whereas the Chinese people shown on the documentary, I don’t fully get why they are making the whole worldwide trek. What is so terrible that they have to run away? I see some comments here that they are bad actors running from debt or crimes. Hmm… that doesn’t sound like asylum cases. That sounds like fugitives.

[@tuongchu2867]

I wish the best for him

[@sherneeliakohmin4736]

Thanks Wei Du and CNA team for risking your lives for producing such real and unbiased documentary. Really eye opening, but yet sad at the same time listening to why they need to leave China. Given a choice, no one would risk their lives to leave their home country.

[@Lishanmao]

实际上是有的，从目前越来越多走线者选择回去就可以知道。但是他们深受洗脑，不负责任的意识形态宣传和移民利益网蒙蔽了他们

[@AllenYang-zf9qk]

agree

[@magendkalis9148]

I just love the way this documentary were produced.. Kudos to the reporter and filming crew...

[@christinavance1128]

Really she didn’t even travel like everyone else I’ve watched other independent reporters show dead bodies and talking about the rapes and killings she didn’t show truly what happens to people

[@Mary-sh2bp]

I had a classmate from Iraq back in college. His family fled to Armenia first then the US. Their family converted to Christianity secretly and they chose God instead of their homeland. We got talking because I brought pancit, which is a Filipino noodle dish with meat. I made it with cricket and crispy pork, so I was so sorry because I thought he couldn’t eat it. He said he was ok because he’s Christian mow. He took out the rosary he was wearing under his shirt and gladly ate. We’re lucky here in America that we have freedom of religion. Although flawed, because we’re not as tolerant to other religions such as Islam, we still respect their right to worship. I hope they can live peacefully now and pray in public as much as they want now. 😊

[@hopkin2006]

Thank you for your efforts and bravery for making this documentary Wei Du. Props to the film crew as well!

[@PM2024-]

Why is every other comment praising and CNA “Wei Du?” 🤷🏻 seems manufactured and suspicious 🤨

[@hhspore]

A very compelling, gripping documentary. Excellent story telling with a huge dose of nail biting and emotional moments. Well done !!

[@AlejandroPikoulasPlata]

CNA is the best channel of news on KZbin!!!! Congrats for this reportage!!!!

[@oldgun1676]

This is truly an award-winning piece!

[@polyyoung3745]

难得一见的好纪录片，CNA用心之作，记者也辛苦了

[@juncliffhanger2731]

Wow CNA, thank you for showing us an award winning documentary this is beyond extraordinary film, and kudos to the documentaries Wei Du and for the rest of team for such a brave act for making this film possible, imagine how dangerous the central american countries but still they made it.

[@tomxiacomedy]

Give Wei Du and her entire team the Oscar now. This is an incredible documentary.

[@lone20wolf]

What an amazing documentary. Hats off to Wei Du and CNA, had heard a lot about Donkey routes but to see what the people really go through was an eye opening experience.

[@JasonLim-cc6iy]

Kudos to the CNA team for this documentary. Outstanding!

[@a_gohan3146]

Thank you CNA, Reporter team and the immigration family.

[@damnhard1863]

They seem too naive to the reality of life in the U.S as an illegal migrant

[@alhkcblack9617]

​@@mingzmings88 as an American I'll agree. Chinese out of all groups have the ability to live in any circumstance because Chinese eat bitter. That's why there's a Chinatown in every city of the world no matter how poor. Unfortunately when these Chinese reach the US they'll find it's no easier than back in China. The pay is high but the living expenses are higher. Many Americans have to live on credit debt just to get by. The Chinese couple in Monterey Park in this clip complained that the cost of groceries were so high but if the set foot outside the Chinese communities they'll find the regular supermarket prices are even higher. Like that one guy said maybe half go back to China. The rest will live lives of toil. In past generations the Chinese parents accept this in exchange for their children being well educated in the US and live an elevated life but in this new age that's no longer a guarantee as many American college graduates struggle to find good paying jobs upon graduation.

[@alhkcblack9617]

@@mingzmings88 for you the US costs of living are not bad because it's similar to Singapore. San Francisco is a bit higher than SG but in Las Vegas Arizona Dallas it should be cheaper than SG. For mainland Chinese it's a different story like you said especially these migrant worker types who live in maybe 3rd tier Chinese cities US cities will be a price shock. Not sure what you mean target. target them for what? Not sure what you mean. I think lot of these illegal immigrants to the US left China mainly because they were sold a false hope by gangster human trafficking groups doing certain promotions to people in China who are in bad situations whatever those may be. As you can see from the show some of these people thought the streets were paved with gold still same as the Chinese who sold other Chinese the same stories hundreds of years ago to look for the gold mountain. In this episode where the one guy went to the immigration lawyer she said if he stays there's a chance that if he wants to stay he won't get a green card or permanent residency status and he can only have working rights and will report to the Chinese embassy. But there's a good chance the Chinese embassy wouldn't even give these people the papers to be able to return to China by plane. This means for many of these people the CCP views them as better for Chinese society to be rid of them for whatever reasons. China wouldn't even waste time to have them back to punish if that's what you mean.

[@mantapdjiwa9768]

of course they are naive, remember they are christian

[@thiesemuel]

@@mingzmings88 CCP target them? why are you so sure of that? Maybe CCP is fine that they leave China. Thousands freely leave China daily to make Singapore , Malaysia, Indonesia , Australia and all parts of the world their new homes. Just like thousands leave USA and Canada to live in other countries. You heard of anyone being prosecuted for doing that in their home countries? Please lah , don't be biased in your opinion. This phenomena of hordes of people entering a country illegally is only happening in USA , why? maybe it's because the current government really support it. They want illegal immigrants. They rather house them and feed them while they struggle with their own homeless citizen . Maybe if Singapore open its border like American do, thousands of illegal immigrants will flock to Singapore too.

[@wynterwei9628]

@@mingzmings88 针对？……你难道不知道今年美国想遣返这些走线润人，中国不收，甚至管都不想管么，自己选择撕了护照有什么好说的

[@OngSamuel]

Amazing work! Kudos to the CNA team! Wishing the immigrants well ❤

[@angiemf9033]

Very brave of the team to put themselves in this dangerous situations to bring this info to us

[@premjitc]

Very detailed and riveting documentary. Wei Du and her team truly deserve an ovation for this work.

[@starry91]

Thank you for producing this CNA, amazing

[@amberoliverelowsky49]

WOW. The perseverance of humanity to make it through the unknown. The Darien Gap is a beast!

[@AlfordLau]

Thank you for telling the story in close up. I moved from Hong Kong to Canada 30 years ago but I am lucky that I got educated and was permitted to immigrate legally without the hardship and life threatening situations. ❤

[@luk2k3]

Even the current wave of HK immigrants are so much more luckier than them.

[@sunha2133]

Chinese from Hong Kong are much more affluent and highly educated than mainland China that they can immigrate easily.

[@Qiushishuo]

自我催眠罢了

[@Jafail4079]

Thank you for producing this authentic documentary. Those who still attempt to walk the line should really think twice. It is not worth their lives. No matter how hard they are in China, they still have second/third chances to improve their life quality.

[@Jafail4079]

sorry, typo. it is not worth risking their lives

[@龚术]

他们认为在美国可以毫不费力成为富人。

[@Jafail4079]

@@龚术 怎么看出来我是中国人的😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@龚术]

@@Jafail4079 有几个西方人知道中国的实际情况的？还以为真的过去的都是被迫害中国经济衰落导致的，其实我最大的问题就是这些人以为美国钱很好赚，然后一堆欠债的想过去捞一笔翻身再加上现在有这么多走线的攻略和中介想割这些煞笔的韭菜把漂亮说的像天堂一样去了就能发财，去了才知道踏马比国内还难混！连踏马几句英文都说不利索就撸空一切跑过去，等着他的就是最多洗盘子洗到他们怀疑人生，而这个行业都卷到不行，现在就只有2000多美金一月了，我也是疫情亏了100多个房子都卖了现在不也重头开始，至少你在你熟悉的这片土地上，不至于要拿命跑去漂亮国洗盘子真是一群傻屌

[@pushslice]

and yet....thousands are doing just that. Actions > mere words. clearly, you have not come close to walking in their shoes, have you?

[@write2YK]

Kudos to CNA and team for giving us an extraordinary insight.

[@sueelliott4793]

The Best video I have seen about migrants so far, every time the Chinese dad cried it brought tears to my eyes. It shows how families are trying to get a better life and with the world being a mess in its entirety, there is nowhere else to go unless we could find another hospitable planet with welcoming inhabitants. May God bless his people and let them find what they are searching for, a life for their children.

[@crosbyong]

Watching part 1&2/3. Thank you, CNA & Wei Du, for this enlightening and extremely sad documentary. What a cover!

[@charlieyoung1492]

“就算船翻了，也是上帝与我们同在，我们进入他的怀抱。“ “我很渴望那种自由，远离恐惧，你说什么，做什么，只要你不侵犯他人，你就是自由的，我就很想这样的感觉，但是我从来没有过。“看到这两句忍不住抹眼泪

[@ArroganceCorrectorneeded]

看起来真的很可怜。我可能不太理解为什么一定要让孩子上教会学校，这么虔诚的话，上帝不是应该处处与他们同在吗？上普通学校，上帝不允许？

[@charlieyoung1492]

@@ArroganceCorrectorneeded 这种感觉，也许你可以看看当初新教徒为什么要考虑放弃欧洲，去新大陆，他们有类似的情况，也许能找到答案

[@ArroganceCorrectorneeded]

@@charlieyoung1492 我很理解他为什么带着一家人做出这样的选择，5月花的故事在大陆也一直是教科书里记录美洲大陆和歌颂自由的文字。 他可能是这个纪录片里唯一一个因为要让孩子上我没理解的什么“教会学校” 而去走线的人群。因为你看看其他人都是为了什么：90%的人都觉得在USA基本的底层体力劳动就可以薪资丰厚才冒险去的，不想在大陆卷了，还有很多就是逃犯才去的。 所以我对这个教会学校十分不理解，因为大陆天主教基督教伊斯兰教你随便信，教堂也随处都是，很多农村乡镇都有。这个非要上教会学校这个事儿，我确实闻所未闻，所以我的问题是天主教教义规定了信徒儿女必须上天主教教会学校吗？ 我又重看了他们家的这一段，我觉得其实男主人最想要的是认为他在美国可以找到非常多的天主教同修，非常多天主教教会学校，不会和周围的人看起来很不一样而已。 特别希望纪录片可以持续跟踪下去，1 年后 2 两年后 5 年后，他到底达成所愿了没有。

[@charlieyoung1492]

@@ArroganceCorrectorneeded 那这个真的需要问问当事人了，看看他们自己的说法

[@melissamengxuanlu2216]

@@ArroganceCorrectorneeded 上普通学校要接收无神论和共产主义教育， 与基督圣经是背道而驰的， 他们接受不了。但是完全可以homeschool啊，最后参加高考就行了，或者以正规途径去别的国家， 新加坡马来西亚等等，不需要这样冒死来美国吧。可能还是把美国太理想化了。

[@soonglinhao]

Respect to Wei Du and the CNA team! Arguably best documentary!

[@habyi8423]

The scammer is just interviewing the scammer

[@Slaythehippies]

It seems to me like the Chinese migrants doing this trek are not in the same precarious situation that the Haitian/South American migrants are in. It seems to be that they're being intentionally mislead into thinking there is something for them in the U.S that they can't find in China, and as they arrive they are finding out they made a mistake.

[@Devilishlybenevolent]

Like that one family, they think the US is paved with gold. Meanwhile my Chinese family is thinking of leaving the US to go to China just because we feel unsafe here with the ramping up of sinophobia. Seems like most the people coming here are either naive or are debt ridden and want to escape for a "new" life like the people we saw in the first segment.

[@jackrlong]

The family is literally escaping religious persecution for being Christian so it's definitely not the case for everyone, they have a legitimate reason to want to go to the US.

[@Devilishlybenevolent]

@@jackrlong That's the same excuse my grandfather used. Lmao please, chinese are smart people, they will see the anti China stuff and latch on to it. My grandfather was a Buddhist who feigned Christian and told us immigration the ccp persecuted him for being Christian (lie in an attempt to see if it'll help with his green card) and it worked lmao. We've been doing this for decades

[@alextyy]

​@user-by5kf6ed8o真的虔诚的基督徒接受不了政府教会

[@smsmart1111]

@user-by5kf6ed8o他们可能搞了什么教会学校 这个不知道在国内是不是合法了 如果只是单纯信教没问题的

[@Justin_Da]

it's a quiet signification mark as CNA produce this knid of documentary, it's a mix feeling to watch this as a Chinese and more than that as a human. Duwei 杜唯and her team more than a journalist in this journey, pouring so much emotional and humanity into it. 人各有其志，志未必一定在西方，希望“润人”也能得偿所愿，找到自己的归宿。

[@loongsiu4766]

目前为止，片中绝大多数润人明显对美国一无所知。 这不叫勇敢，这叫鲁莽，明明出发前可以了解更多，偏要到地方了才叫“完犊子”

[@loongsiu4766]

目前为止，片中绝大多数润人明显对美国一无所知。 这不叫勇敢，这叫鲁莽，明明出发前可以了解更多，偏要到地方了才叫“完犊子”

[@meiliz2452]

这些人根本不值得同情。

[@Areflection4]

Facinating documentry. I had no idea that Chinese ppl were making this perilous journey that they have no preparation for.

[@janmascarina]

This is an amazingly produced documentary. CNA you've outdone yourselves.

[@tenasmith6911]

I applaud Wei Du and the CNA team ....very true humans. 🙏🙌😢 Sad cry heart breaking , deeply touching. God bless you & all that caringly without strings attach help good decent people without judgment. No one should have to go through any of that. The high risk to freedom for some people, especially fyi. China ...and I know there's many Other places folks fleeing from

[@wardumb]

I had no idea this was CNA until I tried to find the next ep. This is high quality work!

[@meaningfulnwonderful]

Really applaud Duwei and her team for making this very insightful documentary...bravo to CNA for making this type of documentary!!

[@leoleo2100]

剛剛接著看完第二集，才發現主持人就是Du Wei，最早是在tw看到Du Wei帖子推介這個三集的視頻。沒想到發帖人就是支持人。了不起的記者👍

[@Allentangcl]

Best documentary of CNA I’ve watched so far, well done !

[@lukawong8921]

After seeing the hardships of other groups , it feels the Chinese are jumping the line paying their way illegally entering the USA. They’re not running for hardships but believed in personally financial gain believed an unfortunate future of uncertainty!

[@lindabederio4603]

They think they are better than other migrants from other eastern states like I absolutely believe that to be true!!

[@why_are_you_gae6729]

They didn’t film the Chinese who suffered on the journey. Many Chinese got kidnapped and killed by cartels.

[@honeywest990405]

Trump will figure out the gig and stop it. 🇺🇸

[@lukawong8921]

@honeywest990405 - that's one of the reason he win by majority, Trudeau is the next to go.

[@amerisum]

Thank you for this documentary. You and your team were brave and those families. I wish I can help in some way monetarily.

[@KopiOkaya]

The best CNA documentary to date. Excellent production. Breathtaking storytelling. Remarkable video journalism. My highest praise to Dui Wei and her team.

[@LisaTang-t2h]

Rooting for the safe arrival of the family. This is modern day migration and in the end we all just chase for the same dream. Freedom and a better life. Thank you Wei Du and the production team for documenting this first hand. What a journey!

[@honeywest990405]

At the end, they will be turned away or deported.

[@lindabederio4603]

It’s what they all say every migrant says “I want my family to have a better life/future. What they don’t say is that every migrant thinks that all Americans are millionaires, they think that every American lives in a mansion and that we all shop on Rodeo Drive and drive Lamborghini’s. They also believe that within three days of coming to the United States they will be rich, a millionaire, whose government gives them everything for free. House, car, money.

[@popcorn6931]

you really think these chinese are that naive? everyone knew about homeless problem i the US

[@kcleez]

These people didn't tell the truth - they are running away from huge personal debts. Not China.

[@Chelsea12118]

I’m Taiwanese , the wife did say that she and husband think American road were paved with gold , so they can just pick it up after arriving America 😂😂🤣🤣

[@weigangfu8826]

​@@popcorn6931Some people is that naive,otherwise they won't walk this line.

[@lindaqiu9944]

My mother thought money grew on trees in America before she immigrated in 1988.

[@engtecktan496]

wondering why they were robbed of everything but still have their phones with them ? Amazing documentary... I havent been hooked on a documentary for a very long time.... THIS IS REALLY REALLY GOOD

[@ann-marie3516]

They only carry limited cash for their journey expenses. Most of assets are in WeChat Pay or Alipay phone app

[@karlkenyong6718]

I have the same question. If they are able to borrow some money from back home, doesn't it make sense to keep the money back in the account than carrying all in cash?

[@honeywest990405]

There ya go! I see that without fail. These downtrodden people trying to get to the US and all carrying cellphones. We’re mass deporting in a couple of months. We don’t need any more foreign people to deal with for a while!

[@AlgernonWang]

43:41 The imagery with the words "La Libertad" (Freedom) is almost poetic. Yes I know its a town in Mexico but still.

[@thatsyouandme]

What an irony. They are dying to leave China and yet shouting "China, China, China go go go". If the country is so great. Why do you want to leave?

[@Mylovelydaddy8778]

Ikr, since they keep saying their country is getting strong and first in the world, why still need to move?

[@claretheworm]

They want to escape the CCP government and their policies.

[@ac8760]

In the context, he was not cheering for the government that he was running from, but the camaraderie between the people sharing the same ethnicity.

[@Lishanmao]

​@@Mylovelydaddy8778伊甸园是完美的，为什么亚当夏娃要离开呢？

[@warrenpeterson5709]

@@Lishanmao because they disobeyed god. sinned and were kicked out. they regretted their shame.

[@momijigrayson7738]

Come to this country legally, pay the immigration fee, set up an interview, and medical fee, and wait a long year to be granted a visa and no help from the government. But these people just cross the borders and get free healthcare, food, and a place to stay. This is so unfair and very disrespectful to those who come here and follow the proper way.

[@BiaheroSolutions]

Dude, their life was on the table taking the walk. The process you're talking has a cost they can't afford.

[@stevenroshni1228]

there's a very long waiting list for Chinese

[@Emmy-J]

@@BiaheroSolutions So the US taxpayer is supposed to foot the bill when they are struggling? Working 2 jobs to survive having taxes taken out of their checks to support these people when they themselves desperately need it?

[@IMSiegfried]

​@@Emmy-JImmigrants keep our economy going and they pay into Medicare and Social security and can not access it themselves until they become US citizens...Facts matter

[@Chelsea12118]

Ok… you can vote for Trump in the next election😂

[@avivxtodah]

Great work! Thank you, CNA for putting this together. Can we hear about the families really soon if they are okay?

[@huiyingtanyayap]

World class documentary . Is heart broken to see what they have been through , and is sad that on the flip side, who are Americans are taking drugs become homeless etc and completely ruin their life.

[@helenphan6496]

It's so heart breaking, I hope each and every soul safe travels. Every human should have a chance to live freely, work hard and be given the opportunity to prosper

[@gfd9535]

这个大哥我看他说话就觉得他是一个好人，希望他一切顺利平安

[@laraegonzalesingoditrust]

I really love this family, I pray for the best for them🙏 God bless you😇

[@shan5075]

In China everyone's dream is to be a millionaire, its not about freedom its about money. Most of them never ever paid any tax to the country, but all they want is free medical service free wife free big house and free benefit 😓 Thank you really good documentary

[@swaggerpinto9777]

then why you run a restaurant? not for money? who say everyone wants to be a millionaire? you are a joke.

[@Eddy-p6r]

being Chinese yourself, have a bit of compassion to your fellow country man. being human with apathy wouldn't cost money.

[@shashibhushansingh_]

It is somewhat the same in India. Very few people pay taxes and all they want is free electricity water and a government job.

[@mygoalismylife7990]

​@@shashibhushansingh_ True ✅

[@ivantan5690]

This is really a wake-up call for all of us to treasure and appreciate what we have...

[@vamnec]

US $5000 per month is better than RMB ¥30,000 in China????😂😂😂 That Chinese car dealer will say anything to do business.

[@SallieuKoroma-sl4ck]

It's because they have weaponize the dollar to make it reserve currency and Petro dollar that why you see the dollar have value than Chinese Yuan

[@后宫后]

主要是这些受众自己愿意相信🤣

[@后宫后]

这种人太多了，即使与这件事无关的所有事

[@johnnynomoney]

As a Mexican American who his family migrated and did everything legally I have one thing to say I'm for migration just no illegal immigration. Can you Imagine buying entire Disneyland package with hotel and 5 days, but you see there is others who jump the gate and got their rooms for free and are able to cut in front of every line in the rides but you have to wait. Thats a small comparison of how it feels.

[@SzeChan-oj6nn]

很心疼 很心酸 真实的漂洋过海 I really hope the best for them

[@BoikanoGM]

I have seen a few of this, but this video made me cry throughout...may good God change the world....

[@karwyai]

Thank you for this eye opening documentary.

[@chopper5245]

Even though I am against illegal immigration, I really admire the father in this documentary who is only wanting to give a better life to his daughter and for his family. I have to admire that.

[@ryanlake9722]

Have you ever thought this father just add his own thought on his daughter and let his daughter in big danger, how selfish!

[@chopper5245]

@@ryanlake9722 That’s one of the reasons why I’m against illegal immigration. People are putting their children in terrible situations, but did you ever think that the father decided that taking the chance of dying for freedom was better than dying at the hands of your own country? Just saying.

[@ryanlake9722]

@@chopper5245 Based on my travel experiences, I don't think China is as terrifying as he says. This father has an overly idealized view of America; he thinks the land is paved with gold and that people can prosper without working hard. Sadly, given his current abilities, I believe his life in America may turn out to be worse than it would be in China.

[@chopper5245]

@@ryanlake9722 Possibly so. I was just going by what he said. I have no proof if he’s exaggerating or being truthful.

[@tdq007]

Wei du is so calm , this documentary is difficult , balanced and dangerous

[@singaanom3305]

Their sponsors are in the USA which will facilitate them if they have entered the territory of the USA. What is the benefit of the sponsors is that they get permanent workers with low wages or workers without wages, they are only given a place to live and eat for free after that they are worked until they die, it is impossible for them to socialize with the people of the USA because they do not have official documents, they are imprisoned because they do not know that there is a crime against humanity, namely slavery, behind illegal immigrants there is human trafficking.

[@popcorn6931]

blind like a bat, can't read the situation

[@classickdramaclips]

Heart-rending story…Wei Du…please - follow up story on the gentleman from Honduras…I am in tears…

[@joannalee1190]

Du Wei's documentaries are amazing

[@charlieyoung1492]

You really have a extremely good reporter, thank you❤

[@ArceusRiver]

great reporting!!

[@roaldhanewald]

As I watch this, I can't help but be very grateful for my German citizenship. This Reisepass is my greated wealth. It far surpasses the value of all material wealth one can ever possess in a lifetime.

[@estheffanie4649]

this is nice. i thought it only takes 1hour documentary for this. watching it from TV not knowing that there are part 2 and 3

[@melwee8511]

Salute Wei Du and team for undertaking such a dangerous mission. The real and raw coverage of the desperate Chinese family and other migrants of other nationalities moved my heart. I can only wish them all the best to make it alive and well to America.

[@cohendarwin5365]

They're really working hard to life. Not like any moslem group who only has a hidden propaganda agenda.

[@honeywest990405]

They need to stop at the first country they come to! We are not the world free shelter and soup kitchen. We’re taking care of Americans right now. We are celebrating an historic mass deportation of illegals to begin January 20th. The US cannot continue as everyone’s destination. We must put our American citizens first and the wellbeing of our country as well. There are many countries you people can go to. Try that.

[@divinaflamingarrow9556]

This and other videos are quite the education about the world! There is No American dream left folks. The struggles are growing now in the US. More US citizens cannot afford the average rent in their local communties now7/2024. We all need each otherand to live in Love Peace Harmony and freedom equality. ❤🙏

[@caonimacao4630]

True frontline journalism!!

[@ricodinerosmm2528]

Once she made that phone call to that so call south American government official, he gave the heads up of her appearance and film crew

[@hanguo133]

杜唯辛苦了！ 保重自己

[@leslieang6422]

Very good documentary week done . Just Hope they won’t regret when reach US and see so many homelessness….

[@HelloKit-nc9gj]

I hope they don't take the benefits from the homeless...financial, social, medical, food, shelter benefits.

[@honeywest990405]

Why don’t people understand we are not in a position to continue supporting the world! We are not the world shelter and soup kitchen. We have our own citizens and our very country to consider and protect above all others.

[@Clamlifenc]

Thank u for lol the hard work that the journalist been through, it’s not safe and a lot of sweat for us to see the truth!

[@rr2b]

The Chinese in the story clearly are pretty middle class and probably had a good life in China. Not sure why they choose to come to USA. It’s very different situation from the South American countries where the poverty and violence is very high. So I don’t understand why they are coming here . They clearly had a good life in China

[@honeywest990405]

Are they already here? They should be deported according to what I am seeing as the goal of ridding our country of illegals.