GH 04.20.98a - Arguments over Robin's testimony

[@brynne77]

I was SO glad Jason took up for Robin when Carly asked if Robin was jealous of Carly's baby because Robin and Jason couldn't have sex. 1. Carly was WAY out of line to even bring that up! It is NONE of Carly's damn business that Robin and Jason weren't able to do things the normal way. Carly had a LOT of nerve bringing that up. I would have yelled at her if I'd been Jason, but at least he said something, then basically told Carly to leave after she said a few more things.

[@tiyabear]

Robin's known Tony her whole life and used to babysit for Tony's kids. It makes sense she felt for him.

[@leanadickey9939]

Robin knew that Tony had a break down

[@lindadowns230]

Robins Right💯

[@BLTKellys]

Robin grew up with Tony as her extended family. Anna and Duke would have wanted her to defend him.

[@brookerhinesmith6168]

Robin was right. Carly/Sonny/Jason leave destruction all around. They stole Michael from his family. Look at Carly she is not good mother material. Michael has been a pawn since before he was born. Bobbie is only worried about herself, She knew what Carly was doing to Tony, now she is going to defend Carly. Bobbie is a nurse she knows what a breakdown is, oh only Carly can have a breakdown.

[@rhon715]

Good for Robin calling Carly out on her deception and foiled plans.

[@sandrajohnson4778]

Some of y’all won’t like this……it was not Robins place to let Tony off the hook……he kidnapped a baby……he should of at least spent some time in jail because he knew full well that Michael wasn’t his……his justification for kidnapping Michael was bull crap and if it was anyone else Robin would of made sure they were jailed……..Tony wasn’t a helpless man…….he had enough time to reconcile the fact that Michael want his a to try and get over it…….but instead he chose to do harm.

[@myview65]

I actually understand Robin's testimony about Tony. Her point was simply that Carly lied about the paternity of her baby therefore Tony bond with unborn child of another man. It does not justify a kidnapping but lying about the paternity of child does leave the expectant father damaged. This was also more difficult because his other child died a few years earlier.

[@onelifetolive107]

Oh please Robin was right about Carly all the time.she was not a b for what she did.

[@lexi1793]

This is Carly's fault. Robin told the truth.

[@desireeboone3631]

No this was Tony's fault so carly is a bitch however that didn't give tony the right to kidnap her son. So Tony gets a free pass because robin has known him for a long time and he's a friend please. Its testimony like Robin's that left people off the hook when they are guilty of sin. Tony got off basically because robin who gets on my nerves doesn't like carly. Please

[@sandrajohnson4778]

Now watch something…….Robin gave Tony a pass……but she showed Carly no mercy when she sold her out to PJ.

[@desireeboone3631]

If I was carly i would've punch robin in the face, she knownTony for a long time and she hates carly, so tony gets a a free pass. Robin needs to mind her own damn business. She condemns carly, but sonny and jason are mobsters? Okay

[@sandrajohnson4778]

@@desireeboone3631 well Desiree we can see it's biasness here....and you know Robin had no beef with Tony....her hate was all for Carly.....who got Jason to lie for her.....lol.....and for me....she was just plain wrong here....everyone thought she was an angel....but she was just as mean and vindictive as any female....worse than Carly for me.

[@desireeboone3631]

@@sandrajohnson4778 robin just get the on my nerves, she always in people's business, or judging them. Especially in this case, I don't care how long she had known Tony. He should've been sent to prison, then robin blaming carly because tony was attached to the kid, so that gave him the right to steal her child? Please, she testified out of spite and who is she to judge she obviously made a bad mistake herself and she gets sympathy. Robin was jealous because Carly could give jason the kind of relationship that she couldn't. I only wish that carly would've shot the both of them

[@CrooklynKnight]

We will never get a good confrontation like Sarah's Carly and Robin EVER again. Those two were must see TV.

[@CAM8689]

that's because Not only has Robin known Tony a long time longer then Jason or Sonny by the way but she cared for him deeply and wanted him to get help her throwing him under the bus because of this ugly episode would be out of character.

[@camm8642]

its funny ppl complain about the Q's buying judges etc and being above the law but in the scheme of things in the last 2 or more decades its pretty much the axis of Carly,Jason and Sonny(I used to like Sonny but it is what it is) pretty much driving the narrative and everybody else just has to fit into it or get the short end of the shaft...I think that hurt the show and damaged many longtime favorites....The whole MIchael storyline was written so biased in favor of them it was laughable

[@tiyabear]

Thank you! I’m so over people acting like familial dysfunction and alcoholism is so much worse than the freaking mob.

[@NTK2A]

Because it is Carly's fault. Carly willingly, purposely and knowingly told a lie because she KNEW the truth would affect people in unfavorable ways. Unfortunately for her, that lie imploded and the damage was far greater than Carly realized. Everything spun out of control. Robin understood that. She empathized with Tony. It's not pathetic. It's human. It's compassion. Understanding that the sum total of Tony wasn't defined by an action which probably never would've happened if Carly hadn't lied.

[@teresafaulkner4874]

Robin is so wrong here shes doing this to torture carly

[@batwoman4487]

I didn't originally like Carly but she became a good mother. Robin was right in her defend of Tony.

[@brynne77]

Uh, NO, Diane, she did not become a good mother. She spent much of her time chasing after Jason's girl friends than actually looking after Michael.

[@elizabethsimpson827]

Just because Carly lied to Tony, SO WHAT....yes lying is always wrong but he was a grown man, older then Carly so I feel nothing for him IN THIS CASE. DO NOT get me started on Robin, she can hate Carly all she wants but this is about a kidnapped baby...I have no use for a self righteous witch named Robin

[@desireeboone3631]

You damn right this was about a baby being kidnapped not what carly did or didn't do. So tony is off the hook because robin didn't like carly. That's all it was and it was pathetic I'm was so glad when carly shot tony and she should've shot robin too

[@sandrajohnson4778]

Robin was so so so wrong here.

[@sandrajohnson4778]

All of the points robin is making is none of her business……..yes Carly was a liar but she was sick.

[@brynne77]

Carly knew EXACTLY what she was doing when she lied to Tony about the baby. What is your problem?? But I partly agree with you, Carly is/was sick and probably needed to locked away in jail.

[@sandrajohnson4778]

@@brynne77 so Carly lied to Tony......big deal....he allowed himself to be taken in by a young woman and he was a married man with a family.....and I can understand Carly lying to him and PJ.....they were both vindictive....everyone in Port Chuckles lied....Robin was a self righteous b×÷+h here because.....she couldn't get what she wanted.....if things had gone differently she wouldn't of ran and blabbed to PJ.....and when I said sick I meant she needed psycological help....what is my problem.....nothing.....what's yours?.....you seem a bit aggravated 😉

[@CAM8689]

lol at Bobbie defending Carly considering the choice words she had for her not to long ago concerning her scheme which is the reason Carly didn't even want AJ knowing he was the father in the first place...Go Robin

[@lindadowns230]

Why do you keep defending Carly Bobbie? Ugh makes me sick!!!! What if it turned out that Step Daddy Tony was the baby’s actual biological father?

[@desireeboone3631]

Bobbie is defending carly because that is her daughter and she's right about robin and her testimony now if robin had a child and it was kidnapped she would want justice to robin only testified to stick it to carly

[@brynne77]

But this whole situation with the baby escalated out of control BECAUSE Carly let Tony think the baby was his. That is very wrong to do. Bobbie is basically a big enabler to a liar, which is Carly.@@desireeboone3631

[@ashiraami9320]

I agree with Carly 100%, what Tony did was wrong no questions about it. I understand Tony was lied to about being Michaels father and for months he loved Michael thinking it was his, however loving someone does not mean turning round and hurting them at the same time. If Tony really loved Michael he would of talked to Carly and Jason about some sort of an arrangement where he can spend more time with Michael and be in Michael’s life, but no, Tony went to the extremes of kidnapping a child away from the two people that child is bonded to most Carly and Jason, that is not love, because your causing pain to that child ripping them away from people the child loves to never be seen again. I think Tony was being malicious and wanted to hurt Carly in the deepest way possible only because Carly hurt Tony in the deepest way possible, lying about the paternity. However, I still agree with Carly, because Tony ultimately dumped Carly, and could of easily reconciled with Bobbi, plus that shows how wrong he is because he could of simply not of had a affair with Carly and from the start all the way through continued to pursue Carly, Bobbi unfortunately was married to cheater, because if not Carly it would of been some other younger female down the road, if tony really loved Bobbi he would of just stayed loyal to her, and maybe got a restraining order or court order to have Carly never around him from day 1, so Tony is not so innocent in this, he could not keep it in his pants, I think Tony realized how much of a cheating dog he is and how he destroyed his marriage with Bobbi because he could not control his own lust, then Tony has the nerve to dump Carly, way later, when he as a adult has the ability to of never been involved with her from the start, like honestly Carly did not tie Tony up against his will and make him chase after her, and again I know that Tony loved Michael but if you love someone you do everything in your power not to hurt them, like Tony is an adult, he could of easily just met with Carly and Jason and worked out an arrangement, he knows that, smh... Tony is pathetic excuses of a adult human who tries to act like they are better than others and righteous, and that they can do know wrong, and when they slip up act like it was others who caused it, when in reality Tony is a FUCKING ADULT! hurt or not, i don’t care how in your feelings you are, you step back, take a moment, and say to your righteous self what can I do that is the best for all involved without hurting those I care about. Tony is a loser, and Robin is a mean-spirited bitch, who is upset Jason is not her own personal boy toy anymore, again I agree with Carly and Bobbi, Robin is that single bitch mom’s meet with no kids, and all they have going for themselves is a college degree and that’s it, and they think that gives them authority over other women’s decisions, like sit the fuck down Robin, your not a mother at all in this situation and you do not understand shit, and have no right to tell Carly how she wants to raise her child. I respect Robin for being educated but you clearly are dumb as shit when it comes to handling children, especially ones that are not biologically related to you. And yes, Carly sleeping with AJ and having Michael was a accident, Carly did not plan that, AJ was drunk and forceful in sleeping with Carly, and Carly was very drunk and hurting Tony dumped her, so I would say with the heavy amount of alcohol in play they both were not completely aware of what they were doing, alcohol increases sex drive that’s a scientific fact, and even in that case Carly told AJ NO like 3 times, but sleep with him bc AJ basically restrained Carly due to being drunk and damn near raped her, so yea, and AJ was extremely muscular so..., and I know when your that drunk borderline blacking out, getting a condom on goes out the window, only thing Carly could of done is take birth control before, plus Carly is exceptional in deciding to keep her child, she could of easily said Oh God I am pregnant with AJs baby let me go get an abortion, but no she woman’ed up and decided to keep it, and a woman like her self with no education, and of poor class, she did what she thought was right to take care of her kid, not everyone has the maturity or education or comes from a stable background to make better choices, but I respect Carly for getting help and learning to grow up and mature over time, and keep her child and try to provide the best life possible for it. There is no such thing as perfect parents nor is one parenting style better than another, how one child is raised may not be good for another child, bc ultimately that child will decide that for themself.

[@coleypinkful]

@lexi1793 That's true. Robin did the right thing telling the truth.

[@Rain89Sweed]

I never forgave Robin for letting Tony of the hock.

[@BLTKellys]

Carly and Jason stole AJ's son. They got what was coming to them.

[@desireeboone3631]

@@BLTKellys Carly can't steal her own child. She just didn't tell AJ that he was the biological father and for good reason. Do people forget that AJ was the one who caused a car accident that left jason with brain damage. I wouldn't want my kid around that either

[@BLTKellys]

@@desireeboone3631 AJ had a right to know his son. Carly is an evil psychopath.

[@brynne77]

@@desireeboone3631 Have you forgotten Jason is a CRIMINAL who has people shooting at him constantly?? Or has that little detail slipped your mind? Because I wouldn't want a baby around THAT situation.

[@brynne77]

@@BLTKellys Yes, they did get what was coming to them.

[@derrinballard7239]

But looks like all of her fans still believe shes perfect. Self righteous hypocrites must be popular

[@KJSAFL]

I never liked Robin, she is so self righteous Carly said it herself she will fight dirty to get what she wants just like the rest of them and it was all Tony's fault he is a grown man and makes his own decisions.

[@member00]

Must be fun to be Robin. Never wrong. Post partem only exists when she gets it. Kidnapping is fine if it's Carly's kid. Shes just so obnoxious and everyone defends her fragile self. Its too much She is never wrong.

[@jarlymorgan]

that's why I hate her character whole exists

[@mute9]

This is when I really started to hate Robin. All her stuff about Jason owing the Q's and letting the Q's around even after they tried to kidnap Micheal annoyed me to no end but this testimony was ridiculous. Bobbie was right when she said nobody was testifying for Micheal. Robin was too busy trying to save the kidnapper.

[@bubblezzxxd15]

As far as Robin is concerned Carly pulls everyone's strings and no one is ever responsible for their own actions. Puhleaseee spare me from oh Saint Robin, who then would also have postpartum depression and the shoe was up the other ass. Yet Carly still tried to help her

[@jarlymorgan]

Exactly! I can't stand robore