Ghamidi: A Bridge From Orthodoxy to Modernity

[@asadkn0555]

I attended your session at LUMS and asked the final question. I also mentioned that I had traveled 300 kilometers to be there. It was an excellent session, and I gained a lot from it. Please continue organizing sessions like these.

[@medusaachla]

Nice, i am following you, plz have a discussion with shehzad salim saheb, he is also a member of ghamdi group, he has written books, his thesis on preservation of Qur'an is an excellent thesis. Do a program in English plz.

[@AryaArsh]

2 Things That Was Most Suited For South Asia - Ixlam (For Unity) & Communism (For Poors) But See, We Misunderstood Ixlam, Used It As A Political Tool For Personal Gain. Similarly, Our Communist Leaders Misunderstood Communism & Used It As Religion. We Wasted 2 Wonderful Philosophies Of The World.😢 Bandar Ke Hath Me Coconut.😢 DNA Me Hi Problem Hai.👍

[@TheExistenceClass0]

Such a Stupidf Thing You Did ,by Wasting your Time, Money and Attention ! You Could have Travel 300 Kilometers with Friends On a Trip And Dance There

[@VictimHood-qv1hx]

You should drank beer and watched pawn instead.

[@TheExistenceClass0]

@@VictimHood-qv1hx ok Miss Victim Hood ! Now I Must Say, that What He Did is Faaar Better and good Than What You are Advising him ideas To Do !

[@sultanali9604]

The bridge between "orthodoxy and modernity", what a meaningful thumbnail and Excellent analysis. ❤

[@AKumar-co7oe]

yes he asked for non Muslims to be driven out of arabia

[@ElayatBacha]

No one can reach the wisdom of Ghamidi sahb in the current era. This man is a gem

[@AryaArsh]

He's Dellusional.

[@madmax5756]

Jabse ustaz ghamidi ko sunna start keya ha lagta ha asal me to ab ilm ka safar start hua ha❤

[@sanayakoob-k5x]

sach kaha aapne

[@riprip2649]

To understand Ghamdi, first we need to be out of all kind of prejudices. No luv for Imran khan or Nawaz…I believe that Ghamdi is this century No. 1 Islamic scholar.

[@MuhammadAli-pp8gq]

Plz read hafiz Muhammad zubair and watch mukalama

[@azhariqbal1390]

I disagree with your comment, "no lov for Imran Khan or Nawaz Sharif". I have heard Ghamidi Saheb criticizing Imran Khan many times but never heard a word against Nawaz Sharif or Zardari. Why?

[@mujahidhussain6264]

Ghazmdi sb is against political Islam and Imran khan, Nawaz Sharif, Asif zardari are politicians so your answer is irrelevant

[@machnumber8900]

@@azhariqbal1390 Maybe because Ghamidi sb was one of the founding members of PTI and he got great disappointment in it. Maybee...

[@one-system]

Where people do not even have basic knowledge of religion, it is easy to mislead people. That's why you gave him the title of best scholar. Because if you've been sit with true Ulma then you will never say this. And as an individual we don't work hard to learn deen as we do with our degrees, and we need deen only on KZbin so this comfort is keeping us Far from real deen and real people.

[@omerbayern]

Ghamidi is the GOAT of all scholars!

[@Fusuoy_enbi34]

Tb bhi rehy ga janwar

[@I6eeikahdu38]

Hes not only a guide for Pakistan hes also a lighthouse for many Indians who don't know about islam too much & they get trapped in mullas haram halal concept.

[@khanjehangir60]

I havn't seen any other Islamic scholar closer to Ghamdi sahib. I feel so lucky as I hv been following him for years ❤❤❤ and ofcourse you Dr, Taimur Rehman also❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@naseer-ul-ganiwani3685]

Those who follow & understand ghamidi sahab will love islam, Allah salaamat rakhey

[@sanayakoob-k5x]

true

[@hassanrashid8741]

We, as Muslims in general and Pakistanis in particular, should realize that we have a great contemporary scholar amongst us who is trying his best to enlighten us with an unadulterated version of Islam. All it takes before listening to him is to put our preconceived notions, misinformation, and prejudices on the side. It takes an open mind with an honest intention to learn from his teaching. And if at some point you don't agree with what he says, then one should do research to counter question him. All in all, it takes some level of seriousness and an open mind to learn from Ghamdi Sahib. I personally thank Ghamdi Sahib for teaching me unbiased and purified version of Islam as it was meant to be from the time of its revelation over 1,400 years ago.

[@w95987]

MashaaAllah great explanation Dr. Sahb. In fact, Ghamdi Sahb is a blessing. Great respect for him

[@mohammedanwar5175]

Ghamdi sahib Meezan and short version Al Islam is a master piece. Entire deen is wel explained and easy to understand. His message is spreading with an unprecedented pace, and no one can stop it. This is the issue with most of the so called islamic scholars.

[@khaleeqahmad5134]

Taimur SB Ghamidi SB py baat krne py apki jurrat ko salam...ap jaise logo ki hi itni Himmat hai...solute to u

[@saddamulhaq9635]

He is the greatest scholar in the Islamic world.

[@theguyver4934]

I agree 💯

[@craaazy-bm8se]

Or Sari islamic world in se bezar hy

[@naqashlatif9153]

Good ​@@craaazy-bm8se

[@kubrab2617]

Allah aap se ye nahi puchega ki aap ne logo ke greatest scholar ko follow kiya....balke puchega ki kya aap ne sahi scholar ko follow kiya...yad rakhiye jab bhi koi deen ka muslih dai uta loog hamesha uski muqalifat karte rehe aur yehi haal nabi aur rasoolo ke waqht bhi hua..

[@mujahidhussain6264]

Marvelous, Sir stay blessed

[@mha8252]

According to Ghamdi sb, there are two independent sources of islam : 1- Quran ( in the form of text) 2- Sunnat ( in the form of practice) Further, he said that "hadees o rawayaat" is not an independent source of islam. He makes , and various scholars from past, also make clear distinction between Sunnat and Hadees.

[@HamzaKhan_HK]

In the 21st century, how can one differentiate between Sunnah and Hadith? Just asking.

[@rumz345]

@@HamzaKhan_HKsunnah is practical practice of whatever Quran says Hadith is literal word/advice as easy as that

[@HamzaKhan_HK]

@@rumz345 Ok. Stick with what you just said and prove 5 timings of Salah from the Quran. When we are supposed to perform Fajar, Zuhur, Asar, Maghrib and Isha. If Sunnah is the practical of the Quran then the Quran must have quoted the timings of each Salah somewhere.

[@rumz345]

@@HamzaKhan_HK i don’t get your point bro Quran orders you to pray namaz and Prophet pbuh by his sunnah told us and timings are also in hadith as ordained in quran

[@AmmarMalik93]

​@@HamzaKhan_HK that is where you have gotten it wrong. The timings and methods of salah (like other sunnah) has been mass transmitted from one generation to another generation. Now you may ask why is there difference of opinion in these matters if it was mass transmitted. So, the answer of this is actually not easy to be explained in just a comment. Ghamidi sahab himself has addressed these questions on multiple occasions. You can easily find his responses on KZbin or in his writings. You are free to disagree with his opinions but it would be very good if you first atleast try to understand what he says as how he says.

[@syedmustjabhaiderbukhari2728]

Ghamidi sahab is the genius man of this era

[@dervaishkhanofficial]

I have learned so many important things from Ghamidi Saab. May Allah bless him.

[@nasirmustafa2492]

Ghamdi sahib is.a great scholar and you have fully assimilated and presented his understanding of Islam. I totally agree with Ghamdi sahib. Ghamdi sahib and Maulana Waheed ud din are two erudite intellectuals.

[@mohammadsiddiqui4267]

Acknowledgment of a great scholar of our time The Ghamdi Sahib by another highly knowledgeable scholar like Taimur gives a boost to both in scholarly circles and bring teachings of Ghamdi to mainstreams. I think it is high time that we understand the Islam as Allah and Holy Prophet intended and not through the eyes of historians and scholars of early era of Islam for their era. Humanity has progressed massively in last two centuries. Muslims needs to revisit lot of new era phenomenon in every walk of life if they ever have a chance to stay in any meaningful competition in the world society. Without this intellectual evolution we risk getting extinct. We need people like you to show us light and enlighten us.

[@omarkhan3256]

So if in this evolutionary process we discover that Islam was only a man made attempt at organizing society and is now obsolete would you be able to accept it?

[@bilalzaheer6535]

Excellent analysis thoroughly enjoyed it..Brilliant thanks for sharing it...

[@NaeemKhan-ud1vw]

Ghamidi sb is the one who saved me from indulging in bloody atheism.

[@craaazy-bm8se]

Deen se itna taaluq ni hy isi liy ghamdi sahab smjh aarhy hain

[@AliNaeem-t3g]

مجھے الحاد سے بچانے والا شخص الحمد للّہ ❤

[@TahirKhan-ln2im]

کون سی سپیچ سن کر مسلمان ہوے مجھے بھی دکھائیں

[@affiliation-official]

Same mujy b..

[@irfact398]

Ghamidi akhiri line hai naram islam ki uske bad atheism shuru hota hai

[@craaazy-bm8se]

​@@affiliation-officialaplogon islam se ky barey ma itna ilm nahi tha isi liy ghamdi sahab achy lag rhy hain

[@uptowner524]

True Depiction and excellent elaboration of our thoughts. I am one of the students of Janae Javed Ahmad Ghamidi.

[@taibanasir]

Thank you for this enlightening summary. Those who use their mind, heart and soul understand the religion well, while the rest simply mould it according to their own whims and suffocate others. Ghamidi sahab, Hasan Ilyas sahab and Nouman Ali Khan are the best scholars of this generation. May they and you live a long, healthy, content and happy life. Amen

[@Engr.OsamaMahmood]

Hope you All Fine & good. Great point highlighted by Taimur Rehman sahb 😅😅

[@razikhan1497]

Mashaallah Taimur Sahib! I salute to your courage and determination. You’re really doing the right jihad. To bring the awareness to the people who are living in confusion and ignorance is the real jihad. I pray for your success and safety!

[@TA-lq7cb]

Sir thanks a lot for the summary. May Allah be pleased with you for your efforts.Keep enlightening us. Regards

[@Mooneypilot101]

It is always good to keep an open dialogue and respectful opinion. Debating and understanding the other side goes a long way to under the opposite views.

[@syed1559]

As a shia I have viewed Ghamadi Sahab with certain biases but after learning his reformists views, especially the ones on the separation of state and religion, I am quite impressed.

[@ZS0719]

Excellent Scholar! Brilliant and amazing understanding of Islam 🙏🏼 Thank you Ghamidi Sahab

[@adfarshah8898]

The "reconstruction of religious thought in islam" is described well by jenab javid A ghamidi. Ur analysis is nice one n needed well

[@KAMALK320]

Very appreciable..a good snapshot of sir Ghamidi's religious phliosophy with a short comparative description of western religious thought and its evolution .

[@iramnabj2928]

I simply admire your effort and effectiveness while spreading and explaining the Ghamidi sahib vision on deen e islam. Only one thing i would like to express is that Ghamidi sahib, on many occasions, strictly expressed his viewpoint on "ism" he is against any sort of isms yet alone he or his team promotes Ghamidism. He time and again expressed that none can be permanent or indispensable. Thank you Great piece of work as always. I am one of your regular followers. God bless you.❤

[@nizamsolangi4915]

Javed Ghamidi one of the Muslim greatest thinker and intellectual.

[@m.fawadkhan9753]

Ghamidi is great. Thanks to Taimur Sahab for arranging the session

[@fjs921]

No one is perfect. Sane voices help everyone improve, bring peace! May your efforts bring positive effects. Regards

[@sada-e-aam908]

تیمور صاحب آپ نے بہت اچھا خلاصہ کیا ہے۔

[@nsm1091]

Wonderful work Taimur. We all need to talk and think . And be open to challenge our belief systems

[@Hahahaha33489]

Ghamdi sahab is one of the greatest scholar of all time.

[@YTaahmed45]

Many thanks for this excellent analysis and presentation. May Allah Subhan e Taala accept your effort and grace you with HIS eternal Rahmah. Aameen.

[@smnimtiaz]

Excellent Analysis! I have never found Ghamidi sb. to be irrational. His views are well researched with references. The orthodox thinking also declared flying in airplane and loudspeaker haram! Time will come when they will understand the true meaning and interpretation of Islam.

[@SalmanMalik-kt7co]

شکر الحمد للہ غامدی صاحب کی وجہ سے میں شعوری مسلمان ہوں

[@Robert12366]

اپنے ایمان کی فکر کریں ۔۔۔۔اگر عامدی کے نظریات تم پر خاوی ہو۔تو

[@imranahmad360]

Me too, Alhamdulillah!

[@abiyaiqbal3325]

100 %صحیح کہا

[@Robert12366]

@@SalmanMalik-kt7co sood halal Parda nahi Dari nahi Movies songs halal Bus Bina Kisi mehnat k seedha jannat.. Khuda pe yaqeen rakhnay wala sub jannati koi hindo ho esai ya yahodi ya qadyani doesn't matter sub jannat me jaingay ...q k wo Khuda pe yaqeen rakhtay he

[@Robert12366]

@@SalmanMalik-kt7co hadiths ka inkaar ya shukook o shubhaat Sunnat ki koi ehmiat nahi ......Jo baat aor ebadat Karna mushkil ho uska inkaar ....aray Bhai Islam kia he phir ...

[@faizirajput231]

excellent analysis❤love for you and ghamidi sahb

[@mshirazbaig6055]

Taimur, you are great. In fact YOU are my guide from orthodoxy to modernity. BTW I do not call it modernity, I call it reality. I respect Ghamidi sb for his very realistic ideas about Islam. He is my guide to Islamic matters as compared to Dr Israr and Molana tariq jameel and other ulemas. I also respect molana Ishaq in religious matters. But of course ghamidi is my main guide...... I also love to watch your videos on history and philosphy. I am happy enlightened people like you live in Pakistan. Thanks for being what you are.

[@mushtaqjan1]

Ghamdi Sb can be termed the reformer of Islam in the present century. His lecture on the topic " The Reconstructed Religious Thought of Islam" on KZbin negates many myths prevailing in orthodox Mullahism.

[@anayaji]

Gainfull and mature analysis that’s what we can expect from Dr Taimur Thanks

[@jammalook5665]

Thank you dearest Sir Taimur. Such a beautiful and informative lecture.

[@craaazy-bm8se]

Bachon keliy ye hi informative hosakta hy

[@khadishah3566]

The best thing I liked about this explanation was u didn't distorted a single fact and said what ghamdi sahb said about all these points. I don't know why people label u with different names but u always talk sense and never claimed yourself as atheist or agnostic. Keep up the good work❤.

[@bedarbakhtkhan3650]

Great Ghamdi GOAT of all scholars!❤

[@KhursheedAnwer360]

شکریہ جناب ، اس سے زیادہ آ سان لفظوں میں غامدی صاحب کے بارے میں بیان کرنا ممکن نہیں ۔

[@haiderkhagga]

It's always refreshing to hear you, Taimoor sir. ❤❤❤

[@shankhan-ry7qn]

Very Good Job Dear..!!!

[@baqirali2661]

one sitting with Ahmed Javed Sahab, one more different philosophical perspective of the bridge you'll find surely.

[@arslanamjad24]

That's a great analysis 👍

[@WaqasAhmed-v2v]

Javed ahmed ghamdi always my favourite, very intellectual personality

[@ABDULRAHMAN-nz3dn]

A beautiful and meaningful programme...

[@mushtaqjan1]

The West suffered through the same dilemma of Religion controlling the State three decades ago. Thanks to the scholars of the 14th century, they broke away the State from the chains of religion and got set on the road to progress. However, we are still struggling with this dilemma, and it requires a significant effort not only on the part of present-day Islamic reformers like Ghamdi Sahib but also the general public to change their mindset by rejecting centuries-old myths.

[@fareedhussain59]

It's a real treat. You've beautifully summed up the gems uttered by Javed Ahmed Ghamdi. Only a nation saturated by ignorance and bigotry can force an intellectual like Ghamdi to take his abode to another country. Most civilised countries would give an arm and leg to have someone of Ghamdi's calibre amongst them.

[@malik_e]

An excellent salvo! Pithy encapsulation of a deep intellectual tradition, important as it is, however comes at the expense of nuance. It is nonetheless a great pointer to those who would choose to study the Farahi thought and Janab Ghamidi’s sterling contribution to the development of that thought. Indoctrinated with what you describe as dogma and habituated to terms that ease reception of apparently new ideas, it is easy to describe Ghamidi sahab’s thought as radical. It isn’t. And this is the most outstanding feature of his scholarship. While standing firmly within the parameters of scripture, he has forensically exposed the errors, fallacies and fancies that have grown over the centuries around the core normative values of religion. Feeding such invented fan fiction at the threat of eternal damnation has ensured perpetuation of clerical authority so much so that it is well nigh impossible for most to shed their respective confirmation biases. The parallels you have cited were the forerunners to the Reformation - there were quite a few others as well. The key difference is that these were attempted push backs to the growing oppressiveness - of thought and action - of the Catholic Church. Emphasis on ‘sola scriptura’ might give that impression of a parallel. However, in the Farahi school it is how that scripture unfolds over time and space to irrigate the landscape and the depths of human imagination and conduct. When that begins to happen, the vanity and pettiness of our conflicts, angers, accusations, frustrations, persecutions, agitations and false egos recedes into oblivion.

[@ssingha2071]

Stay blessed. Stay safe. 👍🙏

[@commonsense5193]

"Only God or the Prophet PBUH have the right to say that someone is a non-Muslim". Really. So there must be another super power that has informed us, the public, about this fact.

[@HikingAdventurer-ge3sx]

Actually there seems problem when Muhammad as political leader as reformer although much impressive,but now today followers are creating disturbance 😅

[@HikingAdventurer-ge3sx]

Actually I think this all misunderstanding due to Muhammad political life not spiritual life

[@HikingAdventurer-ge3sx]

I am actually contextual Muslim and value core teachings of islam,we should see Muhammad ambitions which are actually compatible for humanity, but still today humanity view is subjective and there is facing problem about permission of particular thing having positive and negative impacts 😅

[@HikingAdventurer-ge3sx]

Like people say gay right are compatible for humanity but some say gays people are challenging traditional marriage procedure and society structure,I am surprised how Muhammad would deal with such people,but I still know Muhammad had great emotional intelligence,he would not be hateful but want to care about that people although if disagree about LGBTQ, Yeah that's conclusion if actually Muhammad teaching, using teaching not to create hate and dominance of own but for welfare of all people, because humanity is complex,I am impressive to philosophical teaching of islam like mutazille

[@gmdkhm675]

❤❤بہت خوب بہت خوب میں اپ کا نام تو نہیں جانتا لیکن میں اپ کی اس کاوش کو بہت سراہتا ہوں کسی بھی معاشرے میں تبدیلی فرد لے کے اتا ہے اور فرد کی تبدیلی سوچ کی تبدیلی پر منحصر ہے اور پاکستان کی اکثریت کی سوچ دھکیانوسی ہے اور اپ سوشل میڈیا کے پلیٹ فارم سے اس تبدیلی کو لانے کی کوشش کر رہے ہیں اس کوشش کو جاری رکھیں اپ نے نہایت اسان زبان میں غامدی صاحب کے افکار کو بیان کیا ہے جو کہ قابل تحسین ہے ❤❤

[@abdullahbhatti543]

ماشاءاللہ بہت خوبصورت باتیں اللہ سب کو سمجھنے اور عمل کی توفیق دے آمین

[@khalidmustafa7844]

My belief is no one's business Simple words great message 👍

[@altafkumail904]

غامدی آمید کا کرن۔۔اللہ سلامت رکھے استاد محترم ❤❤

[@abidullah4813]

Good to hear ❤

[@Mir2591]

This for second time I listen to you. First time I heard you lecturing on the history of philosophy. Interestingly, I am a student of Philosophy so I enjoyedyour those lectures. And even more intrestingly, I have been a student of Ghamdi Sab, in Civil Service Academy, Walton Lahore so I enjoyed your this lecture too. Where I admire Ghamdi Sab there I do not go along with him on many issues. The recent one, when a pig heart was transplaned in a human, the first response of Ghamdi sab was that it was haram/ not allowed in Islam. I immediately commented that to save human life everything is allowed. Am glad after few days he reviewed his position. On the five topics you mentioned there is lot of room to differ with him. A faith is not suspended in the air, it reflects in people, who follow it. Hence the religion too is known through it followers. For instance India is a Hindu country and Pakistan a Muslim. A mere land without people is no country. Antarctica though a land but no country. If in future a majority Christians settle there it will be a christian country and both pork and wime will be legal served there. Allah has given laws parallal to human made laws. If a country is implementing those laws in their system that will be an Islamic country. No other religion has that comprehensive laws and that is why the Islamic state is debatable. Ghamdi Sab is trying to improve the packing of Islam to making it more acceptable, hence he is giving different explanations. In some cases he sounds correct but not all the time. Islam is giving a comprehensive way of life and any state following those laws will be an Islamic State. So how he can say a state has no religion. Any state implments human made laws will be a secular state.

[@esolpk]

Please note the significant religious discord regarding Sufism, which is seen by Ghamidi sb as a parallel religion to Islam. This has fueled the animosity of Barelvi and Deoband scholars towards Ghamdi Sahab. Both of these schools of thought have foundations in Sufism, tracing their lineage to Shah Waliullah and further back through centuries of Sufi tradition. As a result, followers of Sufism find it very painful when their beliefs are criticized.

[@tahirkorejo-m4o]

Matchless scholar of modern islam

[@khuramshahzad3992]

I always feel curious about those books behind you

[@panwarg6156]

He opened the gate for ummah revival.

[@bashirahmad7827]

Absolutely

[@rambo7890]

there is no such thing as ummah. u would belive that it exists but reality is that most muslims dont even think about it they way pakistani does

[@madmax5756]

Love for ustaz The Great Ghamidi❤

[@zeeshanrasoolkhan2953]

I love your conversations and broader perspective. Live long

[@musheerahmed7427]

Excellent Interesting knowledge

[@qazisulemanzai9320]

Good. Taimoor Sb. Welldone ❤❤❤

[@arjumandminai281]

Good presentation. Valuable insights from the history. I have a different perspective. History should be used to learn and break the shackles of history. We, however, use history to justify the present. What I call Prisoners of History. Ghamidi sahib generally has the right approach. I read and listen to him regularly. However, I do have few difficulties in understanding his thoughts on how to achieve the goals of what he profess to be the true essence of Islam. Purpose of Islam is to achieve salvation in Hereafter, according to JAG. But the road goes through this life. The real issue is how to lead a life of purity, or tazkiya, without focusing on the community at large. Individually I might be doing everything right, but the society, which constitutes a country or state, has be governed by similar values and principles, or there will be huge conflict, like the one we see today. How to bridge this gap is the missing part.

[@mujahidhussain6264]

What is JAG?

[@anonymous_4276]

​@@mujahidhussain6264 Javed Ahmed Ghamidi.

[@mujahidhussain6264]

@ Thank you

[@AmmarMalik93]

I watched this video from a critical mindset because the words like "Modernism" etc have caused more damage to Ghamidi sahab's teaching, who himself has never claimed to be a modernist or as someone presenting modern interpretation of Islam. However, I found the video to be very good. Taimur sahab has very nicely summarized the points where Ghamidi sahab's opnion differ with our traditional scholars. And moreover, I felt the word "modernity" was used basically to draw parallel with past history. It was not used to imply that Ghamidi sahab is a "modernist". A word that our orthodoxy uses for him unfortunately in a negative sense. Job well done Taimur sahab 😊

[@taniyamunu]

What a lovely presentation and ghamidi sahebs interpretation Do you think like economy education also has a role for crossing the bridge.

[@zainmaken9980]

Thank you for this, Dr Taimur! Here're my two cents: Islam has a rich history of holding a diversity of opinions, interpretations and arguements that can simultaneously be in service of truth and social good. One doesn't have to like or dislike Ghamidi Sb to accept that his explanations and interpretations have as much right to exist as others. And so the way to engage with Ghamidi Sb's work will not be through ridicule, or demeaning him, but with reflection, reasoning and thought. To operate from a place of intellectual courage, humility, clarity and openness and not let our personal prejudices about a certain person or their 'sect/background' ever discount the merit of their arguments :)

[@aqibshareef2015]

❤ he is really gem❤

[@iqrashah8255]

Very thoughtful lecture I want to add something that in medieval times Christian saints like saint Aquinos, st Augustine ne Greek and Roman mythology ko itna detail s parha tha that they Christianized Plato and Aristotle ar hmare alim ye hi ni decide kar pare k hum musalnon m kafir kis ko ni kehna. If they have common sense ye sawal to marne k bad pucha jata which religion you belong and saza jaza decide hoti but....

[@KhanHassan1977]

Very good debate Taimoor

[@arzishkhan9131]

Javed Ahmed Ghamdi ❤

[@aftabmehmood924]

Keep it up mr. Taimoor. In fact extremism is not only in fake religious people but also in full swing in so called modern as well.

[@omarkhan3256]

yes they lynch people for their religious beliefs everyday in Norway and Sweeden, they just don't let it get on the news.

[@craaazy-bm8se]

Ap quran ki us ayat k bary ma kya kahaingi jis ma allah tala prisoner or war ky barey ma frma rhy hain in sab qatal krdo ky zameen khoon se rang gaey ? Extremism?

[@mujahidhussain6264]

@@craaazy-bm8seAt which sura? Please explain

[@makhanikuan]

⁠@@craaazy-bm8se ye sub bakwaas hai. Allah ne aisa kuch nahe kaha

[@QaimRaza-f3p]

Sir you do podcast with people from different schools of thought, also do a podcast with a Shia scholar. 😊

[@omarkhan3256]

And the with a Ahmadi , Brelvi, ahl hadees and dozens of other useless sects

[@AbdulRehman-y2o2p]

Dear Taimur sir, Loved your lectures on ‘ A history of philosophy” intended for lums course. Somehow, a channel have posted those lectures but they limited to William of okham. Can you please share other videos after that. I really do want to complete that.

[@geoschool5533]

ہم بہت خوش نصیب ہیں کہ ہم دور غامدی میں جی رہے ہیں

[@rumz345]

kasam se

[@jawaidakhter08]

@@geoschool5533 or khod Gandi dosray mulk may jee rahay hain

[@kiqbal85]

A candid analysis. Thank you. Why you did not ask Ghamdi sahb to provide his view (in an interview/discussion) about this parallels? No doubt he is a great mind of modern times. We should benefit from him.

[@zalanoor5543]

Ghamidi is the only religious scholar,whose each & every word is there on Internet. Install application "Ghamidi "

[@agar1974]

مذہب کے بغیر اگر آپ کی عقل توازن برقرار رکھتے ہوے زندگی کو بیان کر سکتی ہے تو آپ عالم ہیں۔

[@kakabawani4212]

Salam Taimur Bhai you are doing Graet Job I tell you after listening Muhtram Javed Ahmed Ghamidi Sahab 25 years ago in USA i Made U turn and came Back to Learn more about Islam and now Allah swt's Mercy i found who were Yujuj and Majuj and who are today's Yujuj and Majuj and what was The mision of Cyrus The Great (Dhul Quernain ) Why Allah swt Chose him .Salam

[@craaazy-bm8se]

کبھی زحمت کرکے قیصر احمد راجا صاحب کو بھی سن لیجئے ۔

[@MalikFaisa]

This is an excellent analysis.

[@Shakeelzee1]

Great analysis, excellent 👍❤

[@urmani-w3f]

Bhtren

[@noorimran2179]

Well explained ❤

[@Shah_husain]

Ghamidi sahib is not a bridge between orthodoxy and modernity but rather a presenter of the true face of Islam, that's why is hated upon by both the extremes

[@ahsaniqbal9357]

Excellent thought

[@ahsaniqbal9357]

خوش آئند بات یہ ہے کہ اللہ کے فضل کرم سے ہماری مذہبی فصیلوں میں وہ دروازے بننے شروع ہوگئے ہیں جو اندھی تقلید کے بجائے سوال کرنے، دلیل کو پرکھنے، سمجھنے اور اسپر عمل کرنے کو گناہ نہیں سمجھتے ۔ ہر دور میں آرتھوڈوکس مذہبیت سوچ پر تکفیر کا الزام لگا کر اسے بس اپنے پیرو بناتی رہی ہے اور آج بھی یہی کوشش جاری ہے۔ پاکستان میں تعصب سے اوپر اٹھ کر ایسے برج کو پار کرنا ایک بڑی جرت کا کام ہے۔ اللہ غامدی صاحب کے کام میں برکت ڈالے۔ اور فتنہ و فساد پھیلانے والوں سے ہمارے ملک کو بھی امان میں رکھے اور استاد محترم کو بھی۔ آمین۔

[@afshal_rizvi]

Great ❤

[@theintellectuals007]

sach bolny sy kbhi ghabrana ni chahye. well-done good work keep it sir

[@pooshmati]

He is a self made scholar. As per gamadi: 1. Music is not haram in Islam. 2. There is no concept of pardah in Islam. 3. There is no return of Hazrat esa(r.a) 4. If state has no religion, that means we should accept secularism. 5. Intrest is not haram in Islam.

[@nvherman257]

If you read Allama iqbal you will call him atheist same if you read Sir Syed Ahmad Khan which are true founder

[@pooshmati]

@nvherman257 may be u are true. But for a true Muslim, he has to follow Quran and Hadith regardless of ideology of any person. So hold firmly Quran and Hadith which is the teaching of sahaba.

[@nvherman257]

@@pooshmati yes but also use human intellect in it like slavery is end it doesn't mean you have to force slavery I. Order bring back Quran words we need interpretation in sense of human intellect of 21 century otherwise mullah will rule and push us in stone age and create failed Muslims nation like Pakistan Palestine Afghanistan Iran

[@muneebkarim3738]

bhai ghamidi sahb bas west ko dekh kar apna kaam ki ayat utha leta aur baki sab chor deta. un ko bhi pata ha k taimoor bhai jesa logon na kabhi quran nahi prhna

[@rumz345]

i agree with everything ghamidi says u can cry about it if you like