Giants 'high' on Shedeur Sanders | Derek Carr Trade on the Table?

[@sherm50599]

Great job guys

[@NewYorkGiantsBlood]

I'll cry if we get Carr

[@MezSimmons]

In a good or bad way?

[@cochisecarter6298]

It wouldn't be tears of joy either 😅he's always hurt!

[@Amber-ed3vd]

Agree with Alex on bridge qb

[@Oneshotdee]

Shedeur completion percentage is 75% that’s astronomical numbers in any sport .. that’s high efficiency the man accuracy and ball placement is elite… he throws the ball downfield.. he progresses through all his reads .. he does all this with a poor o line.. he has all the traits you need in the NFL.. yalll want a shiny toy cam ward is that example but his play style don’t work in the league in less you are Lamar Jackson Jayden Daniels or Josh Allen ..and these guys had way better traits coming out of college

[@Boogiesu12]

Yes, especially against teams that couldn't pressure. Once he was pressured or faced better comp that number went way down

[@Harker911]

There are 2 things I think will determine if Shedeur can be a franchise QB from what I am reading: 1. Can he improve his pocket presence (cause he has a habit of holding onto the ball too long and losing huge amounts of yardage), 2. Can he improve his ability to anticipate throwing windows (this is a massive need for a guy who doesn't have an elite arm or legs) I think he processes well, passes really well and he's tough, clutch and poised. But the above two are non-negotiables if he wants to become a franchise QB.

[@jtrails694]

Thank you cuz someone had to say it. You would think folks watching Tom Brady the goat they would learn that you dont need flash to do your job at an elite lvl

[@jaymanjay3.0]

Why should they trade for a bridge QB when they can sign Russell Wilson straight out of free agency and give nothing.

[@mattw5371]

They burned bridges with Wilson last year.

[@jaymanjay3.0]

@ I doubt that money talks and he has wanted to be in any for awhile. It was about not guaranteeing him a chance to compete for the starting job and they didn’t want to do it because of Daniel jones smh

[@jeffreyworthy5384]

@@mattw5371how do you know they burned bridges with Wilson…..we don’t know they burned the bridge but I am pretty sure if the Giants want him and Sierra wants to be in NY he will sign with the Giants

[@mattw5371]

@ you are right. I don’t know for sure. But I do know that they told him he would be backing up jones and not competing for a starting role.

[@kamalhillard2974]

Desmond Ridder, Jarrett Stidham, Zach Wilson or Justin Fields should be smart bridge QB options!

[@DUTCHDILLIN]

Nope on used Cars 😂😂😂😂😂

[@mailepors]

the more I watch Shedeur highlights the more I want Travis Hunter. I'm looking for a throw with anticipation (DJ never did it either ), he has none-- he loves throwing into coverage so TH can bring it down.

[@collusion-d4n]

maybe you need to watch more, bc that's not true at all

[@Amber-ed3vd]

Lol, he also had LA johntay look at it too. Shedeur actually throws with anticipation most of the time

[@Buckwheat56]

Enough with D. Carr. My lord. From the guys who hated DJ.

[@VadaFly]

Fans rooted for Daniel Jones for 6 years but hate Sanders. Comical 😂

[@SuperPick12]

Man I don't get it

[@Buckwheat56]

I rooted for DJ for 6 years. I also knew we wouldn’t get better by releasing him and I was right. But I love Sanders. Hope we get him at 3.

[@jamesmccracken2542]

GET SANDERS!!!!

[@nicholasbraxton1342]

I like Shedeur a lot, I think he will be a better pro than he was a college player. I believe his processing and, anticipation will get better in time. I love his accuracy, ball placement, poise and, toughness. If he reaches his peak I believe he could be like Matt Ryan

[@dblack-qd8kw]

I'm finally with Alex. I definitely don't want an aging quarterback for that amount of money. Winston would be the ideal bridge for Sanders. At a much cheaper price tag.

[@davissinclair4945]

I'm on board with Jameis Winston or Justin Fields.

[@Agent_Cross]

I think he'd fit in great in NY. That team needs a spark, and Carr can provide that

[@davissinclair4945]

I would rather go with Jameis Winston. He is fearless and would push the ball downfield to all the Giants receivers and tight ends. Also, Jameis Winston is a couple of years younger than Derek Carr.

[@HKWOMACK]

Some of us old timers love that the NFC has more Super Bowl wins then the AFC and that the NFC East leads with SB wins and still the only division that all teams have won a SB

[@chuckbartlebaugh5069]

I'm a Carr fan but I would not take on that contract unless the saints take some of it too.

[@Sublight77]

CAM, the dude is humble and hardworking, hes gona get better man, hes raw but... CAM WARD

[@jonaseybolt3010]

Why are you so big on Jameis winston...I would rather have Justin Fields

[@TrollKing2781]

Thinking Fields will have better situations to choose from than the Giants.

[@davissinclair4945]

Jameis Winston is a fearless gunslinger who would do well with the right supporting cast. He is absolutely in line for career resurrection like Geno Smith did in Seattle and Baker Mayfield did in Tampa Bay. Jameis would be exciting to watch having Nabers, Slayton, Hyatt, Wan'Dale, Bellinger and Theo to catch his passes.

[@Magiknyg]

Carr? Wtf u 2 r smokinnn

[@wayneschofield1886]

If I was a bridge QB wanting to keep my career going, I think coming to a team that has a true stud of a wide receiver and a 1000 yard rusher, might be attractive.

[@jonaseybolt3010]

Word last year was Giants weren't a great place for free agents, but we still signed a few good ones... hopefully again this year

[@lonniemeeks3852]

Carr would put them in Cap hell.

[@glock718]

No team will trade for car when they essentially have to cut him cuz they’re over the cap

[@TrollKing2781]

Carr makes about 30 mil. Giants ain't trading for Carr. This is BS.

[@Foxy-ob9oe]

Finally positive video on Shedeur 🔥🔥🔥

[@thisisgunnabeachannel362]

Ikr I don’t get what took so long …

[@thunder3878]

Dj will be a free agent again will be cheaper and knows the offense lol

[@Michael-bl3vi]

Carr wasn’t playing that before he went out

[@itsabulldogsworld]

Getting dc and his contract would be the dummies thing they done since signing DJ

[@kandyman2705]

Why don’t we just forfeit 2025 right now. Carr??? All that money?? Plus he sucks. Yeah this would be a great move.

[@davissinclair4945]

Why don't we just stay patient and keep rebuilding this team right with out bondo?! Focus on BPA in the draft and fill this team with young playmakers.

[@TrollKing2781]

Not sure it's the "High" that everyone thinks if it's Sanders & Carr on the Giants radar. Might be the other "High".

[@LarryJ602]

A no trade clause doesn't mean a player can't be traded, according to NBC Sports, Diarios AS, and the NFL website: An NFL no-trade clause (NTC) is a contract amendment that prevents a player from being traded without their consent. Players with an NTC can block trades to any team or a specific number of teams. So if Derek Carr accepts, and NO wants him gone, it can work. And that's what I've been saying all this time, who would want to get crushed for 2025's brutal season, only to be tossed out like garbage in 2026 for the rookie? IMO, it would HAVE to be a guy in the twilight of his career just happy to be playing another year. Also, Jordan Raanan pronounces as "Rah-non" whenever he says it in his podcast.

[@jjarvicious]

we should sign Justin Fields

[@ToneFury]

I thought we had close to 60 mil in cap space?

[@moneygrip602]

That's what I thought and how it get to 32mill and we didn't get anyone yet

[@gabriellay9627]

That might be without dead money. The dead money hit for Jones next season is around $22M and Darren Waller's is around $5M.

[@phillipjordan7338]

Will Howard is by far and away my favorite Qb in this class. Sanders will be a good Qb in a west coast dink and dunk offense but when the weather gets bad and the wind is swirling in MetLife late in the year he is going to struggle to complete passes. I’ve watched him now for 2 years in Colorado, I live in Denver. His arm strength leaves a lot to be desired.

[@TrollKing2781]

So because Howard & Ohio State won. You jumped on his Johnson now.

[@TheBully911]

I Believe Sanders is Good Enough to play if we need to get a new Coach and GM

[@chrisswords8278]

Get Winston, we're gonna need some comedy with next year's schedule.

[@derikclose1421]

If we trade for Carr and that shit contract and then draft Sanders. I will seriously rethink my fandom of this organization. Even if we only got one or the other. I want neither. We draft Hunter or Carter look for Dart in round 2. If you can get Fields on reasonable 1 or 2 year deal I'll take that but QB should not be our pick at number 3. Most preferred trade Hyatt and a late pick for Joe Milton

[@TrollKing2781]

I think out of all your rambling. Your best idea was rethinking your fandom.

[@dreworiginals]

I agree with you guys on a lot of issues, but bad take on David Carr. There is literally no excuse to trade for him… it would be managerial malpractice on all levels.

[@gabriellay9627]

For sure, especially considering he retired from the NFL in 2013.

[@yungincome]

Here go Anthony again disagreeing with Alex just to disagree. Alex, you’re making solid points. I’m with you my guy.

[@davissinclair4945]

Their differing opinions and the respect they have for each is what makes their board a good one.

[@davissinclair4945]

Nice work guys, but I would rather spend the money on Justin Fields and/or Jameis Winston as the bridge QB over Derek Carr. Heck, I would sooner send the Patriots a draft pick for Joe Milton. Both Fields and Winston have the potential to resurrect their careers like Geno Smith did in Seattle and Baker Mayfield did with Tampa Bay. As for the draft? Get Travis Hunter if both QBs are gone and look seriously at drafting Jaxson Dart or Jalen Milroe in the 2nd round.

[@gabriellay9627]

Hunter and Sanders will both be there at #3

[@thunder3878]

Same staff that passed on Barkley to pay dj you trust to evaluate a incoming qb?

[@jacinto-eh7oq]

Still only 15 TD's

[@daviddaniels3471]

Question: what if we draft a rookie and he outplayed the bridge like Daniels did in Washington?

[@pcarlson214]

While not a huge Derek Carr fan, he us young enough and durable enough to be a 2-year bridge. No guarantee that the Giants are within a year of having a young franchise QB. Also - yes, the Giants may have been interested at Sanders in the 2d round...not the same as what they might expect at pick 3 in the draft.

[@gabriellay9627]

It would also make the Giants the only organization in NFL history to have rostered both Carr brothers.

[@jaymanjay3.0]

Let’s Remember folks. Mel Kiper who is telling us that Sanders and Ward would not be drafted in the first round of last years draft also though Daniel Jones would be a great QB. He is never held accountable for how many bust ratings he gives. He just moves on to the next year. And let me tell you Mel Kiper has a lot information than any of us and he gets it wrong all the time. So it just so interesting how normal fans can be so certain that Sanders is a bust.

[@xrzee1130]

If Sanders came out last year, he would be the 6th best QB on the board, if that ... i dont see him as a frachise QB (imo), but time will tell. Could trade back and pick up some depth and ammo for next year's QB class. Giants arent a QB away.

[@billavoider6076]

I can't take alexs' negativity. Quit bitching. Positive look forward to the draft. You're like the depressed, negative person that nobody wants to hang out with.

[@davissinclair4945]

A whole lot of Giants fans are negative, but, not without good reason. This proud franchise has been bad for quite a while now. The way they treated Eli his last few years is part of the negativity. I have already accepted that we need to stay patient and rebuild this franchise properly. No more half-assery and patchwork bullshit.

[@Im-wd6tx]

always liked Derek Carr, liked him at Fresno State, liked him with the Raiders where he had some Pro Bowl Seasons, at 33 still has plenty left IMO was having a excellent season with the Saints before he got injured he is a more than a Bridge IMO more of a quick fix while you still draft a young QB at some point to sit behind him for a couple of years

[@TrollKing2781]

Still has plenty left at 33. 😂😅😂😅😂. That's a good one.

[@Ianslattery_]

Ik it was like a 3 game sample size but Derek carr before his entire Ol got hurt and before he got hurt this yr was ballin

[@TrollKing2781]

What about Carr's 10 year sample size besides those 3 games.

[@Ianslattery_]

@ don’t forget his mvp candidate year. Your acting like he hasn’t been a borderline playoff contender almost every year. How about you bring back jones for a 7th yr then

[@Ianslattery_]

@ problem with giants fans , will roll out jones for 6 but don’t like a legit QB

[@TrollKing2781]

​​​@@Ianslattery_ Carr is definitely better than Jones. Not really a big achievement. Rather spend 5 mil on Preacher Winston or 10 mil on Fields than 30 mil on an injury prone, broken down Carr.

[@Ianslattery_]

@@TrollKing2781 10 mil on fields 😭

[@Oneshotdee]

Sanders is the guy period we been saying that

[@SosArchive]

i'll take Carr as a bridge to the rookie

[@collusion-d4n]

we better not trade anything for carr unless its a 7 and even then

[@JJG86]

I’d recommend the Giants decision makers do the complete opposite of whatever they think they should do.

[@TrollKing2781]

You mean the complete opposite of what you would do.

[@JJG86]

@ No, what they would do. You know, don’t pick the likes of Thibodeaux or Neal.

[@darksimmie2572]

How can you say they love Sanders with 100% conviction, but they're willing to sit pat and hope he falls to them at 3, teams don't do that. They wouldn't risk letting a team jump them. If they love Sanders they're going to have to trade up to get him.

[@jaymanjay3.0]

Listen I’m not sure what the big hate is on Sanders. I’m not sold really on any of the QBs not because I don’t love them but because I am happy to admit that nobody actually knows what they are talking about. I just saw someone on here post that Sanders doesn’t throw with anticipation? Really because that seems to be what is a plus for him he is the most accurate passer in the draft and also does not throw interceptions so how exactly is that like Daniel Jones? The biggest knock I have hear and read about Sanders is first he doesn’t have the natural size and arm talent and legs that other modern QBs have and Second he took a lot of sacks. Let discuss these two concerns. Physical traits. Im done accessing QBs based on physicals. I’ve seen Doug Flutie, Brees and Russell Wilson play fantastic at QB and I’ve seen DeMarcus Russell completely bust. Taking Sacks, there are two ways to look at it. If you want to be negative you can say he doesn’t make quick enough decisions. Or you can say his teams OL wasn’t that great which it wasn’t and he choice not to make costly throws. Also tells you how tough he considering the hits he took.

[@christineenna5167]

Our cap space is egregious but we should have kept Barkley and McKinney and Julian Love. Do you understand how to balance a budget? Do you understand if we kept those players we would have no cap space?

[@Boogiesu12]

Pretend you like Sanders and drive up the price for a trade. Another reason they should have taken JJ last year who is much higher rated and would have been the clear number 1 pick this year.

[@user-sr4cl4rr4m]

The same JJ that wasn’t trusted to throw and just handed the ball to the running back.

[@CFlame20]

Jordan Ranaan is pronounced Rah - Nahn

[@wagnercharles7909]

Lord forgive me but I’m about to agree with Alex. Shedeur accuracy would help Wan-Dale

[@firesidegiants]

😂😂😂

[@darksimmie2572]

But it is a Myth. The Saints are 50.mil over the cap today, and they will push the money into 2029, they don't care. They will do cap gymnastics and have 40 mil in cap space by the time the league year starts. They do it every year.

[@wayneschofield1886]

If this team trades up and takes Sanders, I will become a jets fan. That will be the worst thing for me. Not saying he is bad, but don’t want to give up anything for him.

[@richhicks1290]

Yeah I’m good on carr … rather have fields and sanders or trade for joe Milton

[@davissinclair4945]

I agree with you on Justin Fields. I also like Jameis Winston as the potential bridge QB. Other than those two, I would be calling the Patriots and asking about Joe Milton.

[@Drop_Takers_Golf]

If Brown gets the Raiders job you think he jumps the Giants to take Sanders since he probably has a high grade on him also.

[@TrollKing2781]

Brown didn't get it.

[@darksimmie2572]

Lol @ trades. He had an opportunity to get a slew of QB via signing straight up or trading for. Including Justin Fields for a 6th, sign Russel Wilson for Vet Minimum,

[@TheBully911]

Players will want to come if we get Sanders. NEXT YEAR I MEAN

[@TrollKing2781]

Yea, Shiloh.

[@Supra1997Jp]

Nah I’d rather trade for Kirk cousins.

[@phillipdavis7452]

I rather have Mac Jones and Sanders

[@Boogiesu12]

Mac Jones is not an NFL QB

[@rahscoe3886]

Sign Jameis Draft Shaduer Trade for Carr….huh?? Anthony wth man lol I usually understand your logic but this one kinda threw me dawg

[@vincentdeangelis2558]

We ain't going anywhere next year. This pair of clowns will be gone by this time next year. It's best to keep away from a new quarterback and draft Hunter, Carter, or Mason Graham. That way, the next regime will get to draft their own QB. HOPEFULLY, IT WILL BE ARCH MANNING.

[@crazybluegiant9999]

Yo I do not want Carr. Hell no!!!

[@richmulv]

Carr would be a great acquisition

[@TrollKing2781]

You're nutz.

[@crazybluegiant9999]

Yo Alex most Giants fans were pro Jayden Daniels stop acting like we didn’t want him cause you wanted him and comparing it to Sanders situation.

[@firesidegiants]

lol you didn’t see the crap I got last year for my takes about him

[@ramblingrandomthings]

derek carr is actually awful i'll give up a 2031 7th round pick for that man at the most

[@TonydaGM]

SANDERS will be an absolute bust in the NFL

[@SuperPick12]

And this is why we suck as a franchise.Why would we want sam darnold off one good season...it would be dj all over again...go get Russell or fields

[@davissinclair4945]

Agree with you 100 percent. The same way I feel about Sam Darnold is the same way I feel about Marcus Mariota, Jimmy Garoppolo and Kirk Cousins. I don't want any of them.

[@Amber-ed3vd]

Good to hear. Im all for shedeur

[@Oneshotdee]

If sheduer wasn’t Deion son then people would want him but they’re scared of his dad who’s gonna be too busy coaching another team then to worry about his son .. yall are dumb

[@derikclose1421]

Absolutely not he's just not a NFL QB. Not worth a top 10 pick no QB in this draft is.

[@Oneshotdee]

@ you know more football than Mel Kiper or Adam schefter?? Cause both of them got sanders going top 3.. if he wasn’t a top 10 pick he wouldn’t be going in everyone’s top 3.. ima remember you said this and ima come back to this a year from now .. I keep receiots

[@derikclose1421]

@@Oneshotdee 😂 you do that guy

[@user-sr4cl4rr4m]

@@derikclose1421what doesn’t make him an NFL QB.

[@jeffshaffer13]

Guys, Sanders isnt worth an early first round pick. At best, a late first round/early 2nd round. Plus all the baggage of having held his dad's hand the last 4 years. Id rather take Hunter or Carter and then take Dart, McCord, or Howard in the 2nd round. All this hype around Sanders is some degree of smokescreen.

[@Ty91681]

Im good on both carr and sanders No thank you

[@DUTCHDILLIN]

I'd rather have Sanders over A broken down 🚗 carr😂😂😂😂😂

[@JJG86]

Sanders would be a waste of a number 3 pick.

[@primetime8169]

Says who? I dont listen to nobody talking about draft picks because they all wrong...definitely when it comes to quarterbacks

[@timdejoseph1595]

Maybe. I lean bpa myself. But its worse to pass on a guy that turns out to be awesome than it is to draft a bust.

[@JJG86]

@ He’s not a lock #1 prospect. He’s more hype than anything. Giants aren’t going anywhere soon, wait for a real blue chip QB. Many other holes to be filled.

[@ronwan1408]

I stopped listening to casual Giants fans determine which QB is worthy of a pick or not because most of those same Giants fans were in full bloom love with Daniel Jones & Tommy Devito.

[@JJG86]

@@timdejoseph1595 There are players at other positions that are a much better bet to be really good, ie Carter, Hunter…

[@christianc2901]

joe schoen said he did see the video what are u talking about

[@mackdadaddy9582]

Sanders is not good...