Gigguk REACTS to His Old MAL Page

[@YokiraOkada]

Dude, I read it as "his old man Mal" and was so hyped thinking his dad actually has one and he's gonna review it.

[@marcuszeus5552]

10:21 Damn even MAL calling out on Garnt's obsession with incest anime's

[@LoliPolice-bf7mw]

5 incest animes too lmfao

[@mviouscosplay]

Garnt's haircut went from Naruto/Shippuden Gaara to Boruto Gaara

[@xjayzayumu7054]

Fate Fans:Debating what to watch first. Me:Starts fate by reading doujins

[@Pathetic-Ali]

Damn

[@saahilsinha2003]

Garden of sinners being brought up ... already makes this PEAK !!!!

[@PurpleRupees]

Immediately forgiven for any Fate opinions. He's right where it matters most. I think Garnt would like Tsukihime.

[@Shiki0828]

Let’s go 🗣🔥

[@saberbestgirl20]

​@@PurpleRupees "GIGGUK!! DO A REVIEW OF TSUKIHIME AND MY LIFE IS YOURS!!!11"

[@pougetguillaume4632]

Knk is the best anime ufotable has ever made, that 5th movie was the stuff of legend. This show is what convinced me that being a fate fan is dumb and that being a type moon fan was the real big brain move

[@DrJones0801]

Now I don't understand why it wasn't on his 3 by 3

[@basilisk069]

chop chop time stamp boy already 2 minutes

[@annonymously331]

Hey it’s a not compulsory for him to do that, at least be nice about it

[@TheTickyTickyTicky]

@@annonymously331 beta take

[@DragonOfDestiny1]

He gave psycho pass season 1 a 7...

[@SilkSonic-c9z]

Never choose an Asian teacher The marking will be brutal

[@TalkativeMole]

Should be lower

[@SilkSonic-c9z]

@@TalkativeMole psycho pass s1 is easily a 9 or 10 Makashima feels at johan level in some scenes

[@TalkativeMole]

@@SilkSonic-c9zYe ur right I was just kidding, but it just didn't click with me

[@scottgimple8107]

@@SilkSonic-c9zjohan level I mean in terms of character writing? I wouldn’t go that far

[@sonnyman4545]

We need Garnt to review our MAL accounts next

[@lucckyZ]

Ngl, Garnt needs to re-watch Your lie in april, the first couple episodes they hard hint at Kaori being sick.

[@IrrelevantGuy]

At that point it's not even hinting, they are straight up telling us lol

[@user-lh5my4ws8j]

1:55:35 - People who say Gigguk didn't ruin Re:Zero reputation or he isn't Re:Zero hater should watch.

[@deadline6149]

can't even take that rating seriously ngl🤣

[@sanaswift3154]

Good take tho

[@Forsen807]

@@sanaswift3154 he literally recognized he gave it a lower score than it really should have gotten

[@dumbledore_loves_anime]

Without any bias, Re:zero till S2 is already a 9 atleast. After S3, it's gonna be an absolute 10/10.

[@zekron1718]

Re zero till season 2 is 8/10 after Season 3 it will be 9/10

[@basilisk069]

video starts at 0:01

[@MUSICIANPSAADR]

my guy

[@DrJareld]

Super helpful thanks

[@Raquya]

Bro?

[@SilkSonic-c9z]

Video ends at 2:14:54

[@shapalapa2373]

This gotta be the stupidest trend

[@keinboesewicht]

1:42:14 „Time has aged well“ ~Grant

[@richard488]

1:31:46 peak mentioned. a 2007 anime that has animation better then most of anime in 2014 - 2024 kara no kyoukai is peak

[@JVPlayz96]

Garnt looks like an anime character in that MAL profile pic

[@_simon.s_]

I like how in Trash Taste they complain that the entries are written in romaji and not in English then Gigguk proceeds to call A Lull in the Sea, Nagi no Asukara lol

[@diamongameri5004]

Rewatch Parasyte keeping in mind that the show questions who the parasite really is between migi and protag forgot his name honestly. Watched the show twice and the first time I appreciated the action more probably, the second time the philosophy.

[@bricktopgaming5750]

Akame ga kill was peak and you cant change my mind first time i realised that just because you love a charachter and you're invested and they're important doesnt mean they're safe from dying horrifically.

[@MesaPrime25]

Space dandy at 6 is straight up evil😭😭

[@NuukaYT]

47:16 Another anime that have similar trajectory as Charlotte is Brynhildr in the Darkness. From really good and promising early episode, to messy second half and speedrunning last episode.

[@Snzn_7]

I actually liked the 2nd half better though. Episode 1 was really good but most of the following episodes in the first half don't really go anywhere. (That usually isn't really a bad thing, bit for an anime that only have like 12/13 episodes. They good have sped things up in the first half so the last arc don't feel a bit to rushed and abrupt.

[@tuminhthien8074]

26:38 anohana using many “cheap trick” to make u cry but some how it work. The story isn't particularly touching, but the great music and voice acting that builds up towards the climax at the end makes you suddenly emotional. Idk man, i like slow burn story that build up emotional than a climax focus type

[@Snzn_7]

I wasn't really hooked on Anohana by the tear jerking moment. The ending never really hit me in the tears department like how the internet defines Anohana as I am more so look at the show as people moving on from setbacks/hang ups they have in life. I also like the more rural setting in general and how they tied the setting to tell the story. And how one event effect the characters "differently". Which is why even if "I don't cry" in my rewatch, I still enjoy the show.

[@FlimKlim]

6:20 yea srsly, i dont get people with

[@marcuszeus5552]

Would like to see the Boys reactions of The Anime Man, Anime Zone & Sebastian's MAL list on Trash Taste

[@bigbidnessborsalino]

im pretty sure they did that already

[@Bruhmoments0225]

They did that a few years ago on the episode where they shared their 3x3's

[@lucckyZ]

Nah, bro gave eromanga-sensei a 10

[@Bradum]

I didn't know it was the same person that did Angel Beats and Charlotte... All makes sense now. I also gave them both a 5.

[@fullmetalbleachnote]

Wack

[@OtakuLolicon]

Angel beats is one of the best early 2010s anime wtf are you on about?

[@cowclucklater8448]

6:00 also, you generally try to watch shows you know you will like

[@keigod2105]

Charlotte changed my brain chemistry, I was like 13 when i watched the final episode, and for the first time in my life watching anime i uttered the words "This is total fucking garbage"

[@baconmon]

Same I was 12 or 13 when I watched it and even I recognized it was major ass

[@yoral]

I was 14 and lowkey I still enjoy it 🙏

[@archeremiya5292]

FSN VN elitists and shirou worshippers are gonna kill him for saying that he still prefers fate zero more.

[@pyronado4320]

Zero feels like a web series and after that going to other fate anime just doesn't hit the same.

[@richard488]

6/10 for UBW are fair tho. The anime is quite bad if you want to know the story. Some of the fight scene are masterpiece some of it are bad

[@beratokun]

Based ratings tho

[@saberbestgirl20]

that's what happens because he didn't read the VN can't blame him he did not read peak

[@Snzn_7]

​@@richard488nah, that is just how people don't understand how things gets adapted to another medium.

[@sharebear421]

Railgun is a banger ain’t no way the isekai trash man himself gave it a 5, AND AIR GEAR ONLY A 6. Get backers a 6 too?? Oh man

[@MikoYotsuya292]

yeah Railgun > Index, for the most part...

[@воваомелюх-к8о]

Like a enjoer all toaru anime franchise i may say, i understand this. First season of Railgun was kinda boring/too slow sometimes.

[@_simon.s_]

​@@MikoYotsuya292You wouldn't be saying that if they adapted Index properly. The LN is peak fiction but it got the short end of the stick in adaptation.

[@fahim0650]

Damn i remember loving Rumbling Hearts

[@nado911]

54:11 ngl, Sydney's Adam Sandler impersonation is spot on.

[@DarkyBoy]

Considering Garnt said he didn't understand the whole ToAru universe I can see why he'd give railgun a 5/10. After he uploaded his video about the series I have to wonder if he's ever read the light novels past the anime or if at all

[@_simon.s_]

Tbf as a diehard Toaru fan (I've read upto GT), S1 of Railgun is my least favorite in the series. It has its moments, but it's nowhere near as good as season 2 or 3. I can see the reason why he gave it a 5.

[@DarkyBoy]

@@_simon.s_ I completely agree with you on that one, having recently caught up to GT 1 myself, Railgun s1 is indeed just really trashy (has been my thought for a while too). Though I mean people that have only watched the anime do prefer Railgun

[@Snzn_7]

​@@_simon.s_ nah, if you watch Index season 1 then watch Railgun. Railgun having better quality animation wise and depicts events from s1 better visually elevates Railgun S1. It shows how the animators cared more about Railgun than Index

[@zezanje1]

respect for mentioning planetes in the video and giving the show some more publicity, by far the most underrated and overlooked anime of all time indeed. a masterpiece that is only discovered by people who have watched hundreds of shows so they are willing to watch something that sounds as stupid as that. the premise seems stupid, but the show is so much more than that.

[@X-Elay]

11/11/2007 Gigguk created his myanimelist meanwhile my parents were celebrating my second birthday loll

[@keithtestaverde3712]

Garden of Sinners is incredible and 100% deserves more attention. Happy to see it gets the praise it deserves

[@Sharyf]

7 score is ok, people select better than average titles to watch.

[@critical_6164]

dawg im so cooked, ive seen more anime than garnt’s old mal page 😭

[@Lavachai]

Bruh I’m just trying to listen to this in the background but there’s ads like every 2 minutes

[@moreserana]

THE SERAPH OF THE END SLANDER :( didnt even explain his atrocity

[@Snzn_7]

To be fair seraph of the end anime never actually even reached the point where the manga has its really parts. Also gigguk just don't like most stuff that is mostly "vampire" centric story

[@newbie4789]

38:14 My hand was on the back button if it was anything below 8 🗿 Bro says Evangelion is deep and then rate monogatari 7/10😭

[@Fei_Kyubei]

Nisemonogatari was the only reason i kept watching monogatari series

[@MysticHoraa776]

The stereotypical first one 🙌

[@trevor245]

My mean score for manga is 6.2X and anime is like 6.4X. I do think a shift away from the average is justified since you pick shows and manga that you think you'd like when picking what to watch/read. That being said at some point you also start to adjust your rating scale to your personal average. It depends on what it is but if I think a piece of media is mediocre relative to what I have consumed in a similar genre I will give it a 5 or 6. The average isekai manga is a 5 on my list, even if some might argue that the average for an isekai manga would be like a 3 or 4 compared to other manga genres. Yet the average for romance is also a 5 or 6 to me even if some might argue it should be higher. I don't particularly care about people having high means but I do think it leaves too little room for the actual highlights. I already feel this way with the 7,8,9 and 10 range. Also interesting to see how few manga Gigguk has logged on his MAL. I understand it is old but still. I have 50 days of anime and like 170 days of manga IIRC.

[@TuffLP]

"Young Garnt", my man, you were 27 when you made that list

[@eroused6708]

U saying he watched everything on here in 2017 😱😱😱

[@DavidGunnarsson-gy9ml]

Ive rewatched Anohana 4 times, still one of the goats.

[@ChunkyKong-47]

I get garnts point about the phase of anime fans being super pretentious and that definitely did happen but honestly I think the overall community has over corrected and gone too far the other way. Obviously you still have your basic shounen bros but now it feels like more than half the people you see online only care about fan service and “cultured” anime. Like I had to stop watching chibi because I got tired of coming on KZbin and having him putting ecchi girls in my feed basically everyday

[@YamiAi]

My mean score is about 5. That's only because I pick up too many anime each season. If I cherry-picked only the anime I was sure I would enjoy my score would be far higher. At the same time, I would miss out on a few hidden gems that way. So I'm fine sitting through a lot of mediocre anime to find a few good I would have missed otherwise.

[@newbie4789]

1:45:54 after watching Oreimo, yeah this checks out. Bro was right when he said it's fun without the climax

[@atharvatripathi9919]

damn even if he stopped updating his mal list 7 years ago it is kinda still crazy that I have more watch time than his profile, him having 125.6 days of watch time while I have about 180 days of watch time I really should start touching grass

[@deathlydashi]

When did you start watching anime?

[@atharvatripathi9919]

@@deathlydashi a little over 4 years ago

[@areebsiddiqui758]

@@atharvatripathi9919 That's actually crazy. At this point you don't need grass bro, you need the whole forest.

[@zypher4139]

Ive watched anime for about 6 years and only have 94 days total lol

[@Outplays_]

​@areebsiddiqui758 he probably started watching anime during lockdown. You couldn't touch grass because of well COVID was going on. Same case with me I am a new gen fan, I started to binge everything in Netflix's library.

[@fedotttbv]

59:09 Сообщение в чате на русском, ура, товарищи, мы обязаны увековечить это в истории!

[@_STRAIN_]

Поддерживаю

[@naga__sawa]

сам оставил?)

[@fedotttbv]

@@naga__sawa, ну нет, я бы в комментарии о таком сказал бы. Имхо, самому попасть на стрим и отметиться там на руссоком куда приятнее, чем просто заметить такое сообщение уже в записи.

[@zekron1718]

For me Anime completed :68 Anime dropped: 8 Anime on hold: 2 Plan to watch:2 All anime that i completed were rated 7.2 or above except 2 anime that i dropped

[@perogun]

1:55:41 rave master as a 5/10? fair, the openings and the endings were good though and the manga

[@XenosZombie]

I have a 5.31 mean score on MAL. 4 and lower means I finished the show to completion, but usually means the ending was pretty poor/disappointing. 5-6 are for shows that I've finished to completion, but nothing memorable. It will be very unlikely I will remember any plot details after a few months/years. 7 is where writing quality matters more. It's when I typically look forward to the airing day for the weekly episodes. The main thing is the story can be cliche but executed very well, or not cliche but the execution is a bit shakey. Typically I would remember bits and pieces of the story and characters since it's either not generic, or generic but the best at it that i remember. 8 is where the anime I rewatch to some degree. Just something griping about it that I wouldn't mind searching for a particular episode for a particular moment, or watch the series after a few years and it still holds up. 9 and 10 is basically shows that gripe me at my core, shows that that give me emotional punches and memorable moments, that I just sometimes think about in the day to day. What differentiates them is just me comparing them all tbh. The main thing is in an anime season, there's tens of shows. Of which I can only watch a small chunk of them. And it's usually becomes 0-4 shows are 7s and higher and the rest are just 6s and lower, typically a 5 if it was just something that enabled me to pass the time.

[@Haigen6]

My anime count is 1,300 anime complete. Wtf am I doing. My mal user: Haigen, I joined mal in 2021 but watch anime for 7 years.

[@Wisewolfholo4]

me too.

[@thebeautifulandthedamned572]

yo dude, wtf? how's ur social life dude? i watch 269 anime since 2014, and it's a lot to me, my friend even told me i'm a degenerated that's crazy

[@gokuisthe1]

@@thebeautifulandthedamned572don’t listen to your friends

[@minhdang142]

wth man? 300 anime in 5 years are like a lot for me though

[@soulblade3291]

Bro. Been watching anime for 10 years already and barely got over 200 😂

[@re.liable]

44:38 this bit made me think i was going insane. checked my messages but have not received any

[@nedeemmalik]

Parasyte is my most hated anime and im very happy to see a six

[@DragonOfDestiny1]

5:52 bro just called me out

[@suehiro_bsd]

garnt calling out joey once again for k-on vs bocchi the rock (recently in that reddit top 100 anime list also) 😊

[@myrmidonmamori]

I don't think you need to worry about when you rewatch Anohana. It does the cry porn stuff, but it makes it work. You compared it to the start of Clannad here, but I watched Anohana pretty much immediately after Clannad, and I adored Anohana but thought Clannad was boring af.

[@toddhoward841]

nahhh lmao not him tryna claim he's a fate fan while putting zero at 10 and saying "yea this one's my favorite by far" 😭

[@rizamanchu]

I finish a lot of bad manga simply because of how fast i can read it but for anime my average is a lot higher

[@يحيىوائلثجيل]

The IGN anime list

[@jakehsenpai5238]

Your Lie in April is peak, and you know it...

[@zekron1718]

Yeah

[@tuminhthien8074]

When i saw Air gear only 6: man u not a real anime fan Then i saw akamega kill with 4: oh no, maybe 6 is not that bad 😂

[@sanaswift3154]

Who is yungunt? Im so lost the entire VOD? Is that his nickname?

[@NuukaYT]

His name is Garnt, and he said "young Garnt" as he's showing his old MAL when he was young.

[@denzelmedes1780]

The familiar of zero maybe a 6 out of 10 for garnt but it does have a good isekai ending so its alright 😂

[@halkun7191]

If a 7/10 is mid to Garnt, Garnt just lost some cred

[@NuukaYT]

320 shows is like the total amount of 1 and a half year seasonal anime.

[@Aman_Mondal]

6th I will add Timestamps 😂 for some of the war crime atrocities he committed towards the Monogatari fans and others 😂

[@velfare]

Everyone has their own dark history 😅

[@AnimeWorld-sb]

giguk tastes arre alwaays supreme

[@spearki]

my average is like 8.05 it would probably be higher if i rated every show i watched i dont see a problem i only watch anime i know i will like so anything getting 7/8 are just bc its a genre i like generally but 9's are peak for that genre also rumbling hearts should have been like a 9 not a 7 fight me i gave like charlotte an 8 even tho i hated the ending the overall show was good imo and i didnt think cutting more pts off from 1bad eps ruined the whole show

[@brunomenezes9011]

29:45 - Nisemono-fan

[@FrierenAza]

31:41

[@MysticHoraa776]

the profile picture is fire 🫡

[@RAGEN99]

No genshin playthrough?

[@androognoix1685]

10:00 1:11:57 2:04:20 24:15

[@newbie4789]

1:38:59 Not 11/10??? Outrageous

[@aaaaanh]

orange is the new black 7 is the new mid

[@AdBlock-xl3tt]

I feel like Ghibli haters are generally a lot more pretentious than anyone rating the movies highly honestly. A lot of it comes across as people just not wanting to be seen as "normies" rather having any actual grievances with the movies themselves. It just seems really performative a lot of the time.

[@oshiso750]

sasuke ahhh hair

[@newbie4789]

1:48:07 Kuroneko?🗿

[@воваомелюх-к8о]

24:37 - i just watched Anohana recently and this anime was really mediocre. It is really just cry corn and strongly forsed drama, like camon this girl is already dead many years so why they reacting like this happened few days ago?))

[@naga__sawa]

bro this new garnt twitch streamer is cooking every stream btw you're right about clannad tho, its really boring for a good part unlike anohana! and i've watched after story (it does become better ofc) also i think it would be quite funny to watch this list in order of addition, like, to see the evolution and arcs

[@l_abrar_l]

Is it a coincidence that garnt joined Mal the day I was born? I THINK NOT ✊✊

[@ABVTC]

This dude gave FMA a 4/10, but school days a 9/10... #TrashTaste

[@danieliacomi5411]

Imagine giving MHA 8 and Naruto a 6, and still thinks he had good taste 6-10 years ago. PS: Naruto fillers were terrible indeed, felt like torture tbh.

[@sorakara_tokido]

12:30 D: Fake Toaru fan

[@DarkyBoy]

DD:

[@archangelarielle262]

You think you were being conservative with your ratings before, when I think you were far too generous with your scoring. My mean is like a 5. People seem to think a 7 is not good enough, when barely anything should be above it, otherwise you just dilute what it means to be amazing.

[@AdBlock-xl3tt]

Your mean score says very little about how generous or harsh your scoring is. My mean score is 7,5 and I still gave Demon Slayer a 4/10 for example. My mean score is just indicative of that I'm selective about what I watch. Since I only seek out things I either know for a fact or have a pretty good idea I'd enjoy, anything lower than a 7 is going to be an outlier. 7/10 is certainly good but plenty of things should be better than just "good". If barely anything of what you watch is more than a 7/10 it just means you're either bad at finding things you thoroughly enjoy or don't actively try to do so.

[@theoneandonlygod]

1900 show

[@lucckyZ]

ok I'm 646 entries wtf am I doing with my life

[@zekron1718]

College?

[@ripamzzkuy9418]

Fontaine arc 3 when?

[@Jctan0424]

he did 3 and 4 in recent vods on twitch and also reacted to demo, trailer and music on that stream

[@creckonic]

shit arc

[@ripamzzkuy9418]

@@Jctan0424 hope he upload it soon and thanks for the info pal

[@RenatoArmas-cf7yc]

Your lie in april its a 5/10 at best

[@zekron1718]

No at best it is 7.5/10

[@Pathetic-Ali]

Lmao rating OBJECTIVELY (ONE OF) THE BEST slice of life anime a 5 is crazy

[@RenatoArmas-cf7yc]

@@Pathetic-Ali There is no objectively best anime unless all anime viewers are agree on that.

[@Pathetic-Ali]

@@RenatoArmas-cf7yc well I agree that there is no objective best, but still majority of the people would agree that it's one of the best. But rating it a 5!?

[@SilkSonic-c9z]

Aot s4- 10 Aot s3- 10 Aot s2- 9 Aot s1- 7/8 S1 I didn't like coz I was oversaturated with shonnen trashy then naruto dbz one piece S4 yes I think ending is easily top 3 or top 5 endings for me in anime

[@Sephirothkingdom782]

ngl s3 is probably the best season. AoT was at its best when not trying to be super massive in scale and lore centric. S3 was mainly about its characters and it did that flawlessly and return to shiganshina is one of the greatest payoffs ive seen for an anime. S4 was ok tbh, it suffered a lot with its pacing and the characters werent nearly as interesting as s3, same with the animation quality. I didnt like s2. Nothing much happens for most of it and its the worst paced season in the show. People mainly praise it because of the one reveal but thats it.

[@SilkSonic-c9z]

@@Sephirothkingdom782 I only gave s3 a 10 coz of the fights S3 is garbage if u look at it plotwise Same old shonnen shhhit good vs evil Aot before s4 was one of the great animes but I personally feel s4 is what made aot the greatest and pushed it above the rest as it showed a mainstream popular anime can think outside of shonnen for once. There was a time I loved shonnen but times have changed ppl have changed that's why jjk is gonna flop hard when it ends coz it's doing the same shonnen shhit brung back nobara bring back gojo in yuuta bring back megumi Absolute shhit

[@Sephirothkingdom782]

@@SilkSonic-c9z what? s3 having to do with good vs evil doesn't make it any worse because it was told really well. s4 is political drama for the sake of making the series less grounded and it didn't work out well for some of it due to how it sacrificed the character writing. Also I couldn't read most of the other stuff u said

[@Pathetic-Ali]

I would just switch season 1 and 2 rating, the rest is the same as my take. And yes aot is my no 1 anime and I believe if not the best then it's one of the best anime/show ever.

[@royalfun1031]

​@@SilkSonic-c9ztf

[@jimsaints]

Bakemonogatari 7/10 is a crime against humanity

[@rendezvousonmemorylane]

It's highly overrated.

[@RicardoSilva-nr8st]

@@rendezvousonmemorylane nop, its just to much for your brain

[@БаццкоБудённый]

@@rendezvousonmemorylane *underrated

[@Pathetic-Ali]

I just watched it and if I keep my recency bias aside, for me it would still be 8 or 8.5/10

[@diamongameri5004]

People who don't rate cowboy bebop a 10/10 are menaces I want to shelter myself from

[@diamongameri5004]

@@vaeIokre you are a menace. Just for fun . Hit me with one of your favorite 10/10 shows :).

[@Catsatemyfamily]

Nisemonogatari better than Bakemonogatari? stop the cap 💀

[@wasteman3259]

2007 is wild

[@RichardsPhoenix]

Williams Anna Harris Eric Anderson Matthew

[@MUSICIANPSAADR]

W

[@pnr2736]

Yooo