Glee - Rachel and Brody break up 4x17

[@maurafaith8795]

none of this would've happened if Santana hadn't stepped in. Breaking up Rachel and Brody was the best thing Santana could've done for Rachel.

[@SilentGamer1108]

Yeah I agree. I didnt like Brody and Rachel dating. It felt like they were jsuy trying to write Cory out of the show.

[@ava5647]

That’s why she’s my favorite!

[@maxdai8487]

But they were not right for each other, even if Santana stepped in.

[@daniellesmith3026]

@@maxdai8487 that might be true but Santana wasn't going to sit there and watch Rachel get hurt

[@ElizabethhWatt]

Who cares about Santana!? Why does everything always have to go back to Santana!? Let’s just say fuck Santana and take a second to admire the great acting skills by these two actors and how they are fucking bad ass at portraying their character.

[@caseyjl949]

you know what I just noticed? Rachel dated three guys that sang in the shower. Finn, Brody, and Sam. Weird, huh?

[@itsemi2286]

Pianist with Attitunes CJ Lynn when did she date Sam?

[@luna160881]

Season 6

[@bellayang2047]

Pianist with Attitunes CJ Lynn she never dated Sam she just kissed him that it but she thought it was real date but no

[@alondragil3986]

Pianist with Attitunes CJ Lynn she also dated Jesse lol.

[@kwonmunsu]

Pianist with Attitunes CJ Lynn does puck sing in the shower?

[@plasmatic210.]

Brody: “Seeing you is going to be hard.” GLEE: “no worries, you disappear after this song.”

[@potatopotato3257]

wow he flipped the table and made it seem as if she was the only one in the wrong

[@makaylastokes6473]

Hi 😘 😘

[@12TurtWig]

Something my boyfriend always does lmao fml gtg

[@twistedbliss58]

@@makaylastokes6473 lmao no he didn't you people always want females to be innocent victims he simply pointed out that she was in the wrong too

[@OMGiGi]

• oetori • no Rachel was wrong too but the argument wasn’t about that! If it really pissed Brody off why did he not say something about it until she calls him out on his job choice?

[@PrincessStephanieell]

@@12TurtWig gaslight is not cute sweetheart i hope he's not your boyf anymore

[@brib9015]

I'll admit I hated how Rachel judges him for the job he has, because he's right he doesn't have the luxury of having someone pay his bills like Rachel does. But I do believe he should have told her that was his job from the beginning as shameful as he thinks his job is. But that's just my opinion

[@HS-jz4op]

But prostitution is illegal.. Get a real job, not some sleazy job where you can get super stds

[@jesusgarcia5197]

Prostitution is illegal, he should have gotten a real job.

[@cutienerdgirl]

Well, he never told her so therefore he was cheating. Is she supposed to dout on him and possibly compete with other girls?? Plus, highly likely she would get an STD.

[@CorneliusHDybdahl]

He should have told her for reasons of safety from STDs.

[@stephanieka23]

Bri B agree

[@mehdigeek]

Finchel were endgame...

[@seniorqueen08]

+mehdigeek- They were supposed to get back together, but then Cory died.

[@aru6917]

*toxic

[@missbazel3224]

they we supposed to get back together and then have a scene where Rachel came back to Lima and said “i’m home” but Cory died😭💔

[@caccq2524]

@@aru6917 right

[@shallonmcgowan669]

Yes they were

[@HP1818]

“Not everyone has dooting daddies to pay their bills.” That line though. And he’s right! I will never judge anyone who has to do what they need to in order to eat.

[@gianidentini]

But to prostitute yourself isn’t the way either

[@danielbalderas9796]

I will if they're sleeping with me while being an active s3x worker and not telling me about it wtf

[@ultimxtemiracxler]

that wasn't the issue tho, it was about honesty in a relationship...

[@riele-z7l]

you totally missed the point. there’s no problem with being a sex worker if you need the money, but that fact that he’s had sex with strangers WHILE sleeping with her without telling her is the ISSUE. she could have gotten an std for his carelessness about her health.

[@briesullivan883]

That’s not the issue. The issue is that he put her health in danger since he didn’t tell her the truth.

[@kenzieskye3053]

Finn and Rachel were a forever couple 😢

[@darcyearp5150]

Kenzie Skye they suck as a couple Finn and Quinn were way better facts

[@kenzieskye3053]

Spacebounty 2474 Okay, well first of all, how about you use some punctuation. Secondly, that is an opinion and considering Lea and Corey were engaged, I'd say my opinion is much more factual than yours.

[@norellazuniga6801]

Spacebounty 2474 are you crazy ?

[@teresavacarr7851]

Cory and Lea weren't engaged

[@pinkteezpov]

+Teresa vacarr yes they were

[@dietdrpepper15]

The danger Brody put Rachel's health in the bad part, not the job itself. The reason that it's NOT the entire discussion is because the episode/show mostly is written by men.

[@alexaalfaro9264]

tbh this plot line was terribly written... like I get why he didn't tell her right away. But after getting serious he should of told her the truth cause health reason and if they had a talk about being exclusive. Also they way they kind of shamed him was also wrong (aka having the mains look down on him)

[@Ehjsididud]

sex workers have to get tests done for their job. he wasn’t putting her in danger.

[@dietdrpepper15]

@@Ehjsididud Yes he was, because she didn't KNOW she was sleeping with a sex worker.

[@ellahickle5530]

This has nothing to do with male and female. Stfu

[@quinncalista2204]

@@ellahickle5530 it really does

[@EMkim-lk4sj]

I miss Finn soooooooo much..😢

[@nuzhathnima6978]

E.M kim t

[@zyriaxox9118]

Omg the fact that Finn went all the way to New York just to defend Rachel is so sweet 😍😂😄💕👏

[@athenapetrova3383]

Several comments say that Rachel cheated on Brody, but she didn't. Weren't these two in an open relationship?

[@assyrianprincess3]

Karen Petrova-Laufeyson Ikr Brody was cheating on rachel the whole relationship

[@HonorWillow]

The condition was that they were honest and she wasn't so it's cheating. You can still cheat in open or polyamorous relationships

[@Bloooo95]

Yes. It was an open relationship. However, Brody should have been honest about his exploits. They had a policy to be open about who they see.

[@alanabrown5427]

Athena Petrova yeah

[@lucyg4532]

HonBon96 If that’s what qualifies cheating then Brody did too because she didn’t know he was sleeping with all those girls for money.

[@wolfie8227]

Gotta love Santana. She can sense bad guys from a mile away

[@EveningFantasy]

Her built-in gaydar also doubles as a douche-detector

[@ikogarcia8122]

She couldve just confronted him and not mock him with that stupid cash stunt. That was completely unnecessary and degrading.

[@SuperPianogirl123]

Rick H But that wouldn't be Glee, we need to degrade everyone because then they can sing about it.

[@Chrjstheshadow]

Rick H You mean as degrading as knowing your boyfriend's been acting as the town bicycle behind your back?

[@ikogarcia8122]

Chrjstheshadow well, if you think about it, he may not told rachel he was a prosti and of course that is never right, but don't you think Rachel's just being so extra about that stupid stunt? I understand both sides and they're both EQUALLY wrong.

[@Chrjstheshadow]

Rick H Extra? Sure, that slap in the face with the money was definitely over the top. But I have no idea how they are equally wrong here. That's saying that making a crude prostitution 'joke' is equivalent to having sex with dozens of women and exposing yourself to countless stds behind your partner's back. They're not the same, they're not even in the same stratosphere. Even if you add in Rachel's indiscretion with Finn, by sheer numbers alone Brody would be way ahead of Rachel

[@ikogarcia8122]

Chrjstheshadow I'm not going to argue with you over a show that has been off the air for more than a year now. Sure, having sex with Finn because you want to is the same with having sex with people because you need money to survive. Sure, I'm wrong, you're right. Let's just leave it there. Geez.

[@alysiamerdavid-wasser9165]

"Went all Frankenstein on me"😂 is one of my fondly favorite descriptors of Finn, that rhythmless, lovable, giant. I miss Corey.💝

[@RespectMyThickness]

“I know you slept with Finn at that wedding.” Yeah and you slept with the dance teacher that tortured Rachel and didn’t even apologize for it so what’s your point

[@zyriaxox9118]

100% agree

[@lulyfreitas27]

Well... They weren’t together back then

[@stephanies3281]

Why would he apologize for sleeping with Cassandra when he wasn’t even dating Rachel yet? Like he told Rachel about it “ this isn’t high school”

[@assyrianprincess3]

Brody slept with half of New York. He has 0 ground to stand on

[@rachelberrythegleequeen.3221]

Exactly

[@harleyquinnfan1012]

Finn and Rachel with always be the top couple in my heart even this they broke up and he died they will always be a couple. Like Finn told Rachel in the show were Finn bought her the star " no matter were I am you can look in the sky and I will be looking down at you...... well if it is night time." Also when mr. Shoes wedding when Emma ran out Rachel caught the bouquet that sue throw and then Rachel caught it and then her and Finn talked then he said this " I do not care were you are or what dope you are shacked up with your my girlfriend I know that you know that" LONG LIVE FINNCHEL

[@seirrasky3581]

When she said *Im such an idiot* and starts crying I felt that

[@Yeerrr31]

The writers wasted too much time having them date for that long

[@Nathan-fo4ux]

I guess it’s a matter of opinion. I never cared for Rachel and Finn. I could say they waisted 3 seasons of their nauseating relationship when they could have focused more time on other characters like Mike and Tina.

[@sofiaguerrero0969]

Noka Reems But the main characters are Rachel and Finn and the story mostly revolved around Rachel’s life. If it had to be anyone, Finn would’ve ended up being the perfect match for her (Jesse st James a close second. I still can’t forgive the egg thing)

[@playfulpippapony]

I think there was nothing wrong with what Brody did for his job, I think the fact he didn't tell Rachel is the unforgivable part. I get it, some people don't have rich families to support them or jobs that pay enough, so for someone like Brody this could be a viable option. I don't have a problem with what Brody did for money, but I hate the fact he didn't tell Rachel about any of it and then goes on about having a completely honest relationship. Brody is a good man, just not good for Rachel.

[@cnty8293]

playfulpippapony so the possibility that he could’ve given a disease to her makes him a good man

[@srhgmrs]

playfulpippapony thank you

[@HS-jz4op]

It's illegal being a hooker is against the law.. And don't get me started on diseases she could've gotten

[@JaneDoeSignedHancock]

@@HS-jz4op being against the law doesn't immediately make something evil, but yes he endangered her by not telling her and *that* was wrong.

[@icantthinkofaname1062]

Jane Doe it’s still illegal and she’s right, he’s selling his body

[@joereltuvalles2078]

Brody was at fault. No Matter how shameful your job was, his gf has the right to know it too. This is the best way to make the relationship grow stronger

[@arthur3609]

my opinion too. can you imagine find something like that out by someone else's mouth? i would feel very betrayed. i don't think you should tell, literally, everything about your life to your partner, but something like that needs to be talked out as soon as possible, because truth always meets the light

[@leena-lb1sx]

They had an open relationship, not bf/gf

[@Kikiricki11]

@@leena-lb1sx Open does not mean secretive. You HAVE TO tell your partner if you work a sex job because you changing so many partners can result in serious diseases which your partner may then also get. You have to be honest. Always.

[@Kikiricki11]

@@leena-lb1sx Oh and btw, an open relationship is still „bf/gf“. You are still in s relationship romantically and you call yourself that. You just sexually are more active with other people.

[@tallygirl8644]

Y'all are saying that Brody is the victim😂 I find it so amusing that even though Rachel admitted what she did and didn't try to justify it like Brody did😂😂

[@angharadr862]

@Annalisa Zucchi Brodys job was illegal and could've given Rachel serious life threatening STI's. According to Wiki they were in an open relationship which means they can sleep around but they promised to be honest with each other which they weren't. Brody was in the wrong way more due to most likely putting Rachel at risk and I'm sure it's also illegal to not tell your sexual partner that you are involved with that type of way and sleep with them especially if he had an STI or STD.

[@rachaeliyunade8947]

PREACH

[@cedricbrame2810]

Brody was literally assaulted lol. They both cheated and lied neither of them are innocent. One just had bills to pay.

[@tacxcat]

@@jen9996 exactly

[@Angelina160]

Finchel forever Rest in piece Finn 👼🏼❤️

[@Meelzdiva]

I never liked Brody anyway. Yeah Rachel has her moments but she definately deserved way better.

[@queenjai.k8377]

Lea's acting was so good in this scene omg. Glad these 2 broke up. Finchel forever😭❤️

[@Daisy-yo1di]

Imagine if Finn,Brody,Jesse and Rachel were all in the same room together 😳

[@kp-xm3mu]

I hurt imaging it

[@Yeerrr31]

They dated for 17 episodes smh that’s way to much. Atleast Cory and Lea were dating in real life at the time

[@hiediwood761]

Can we just talk about how his accent came out omg ❤️😍

[@sarah0732]

Yaaaassssss I was waiting for someone else to say this!

[@andreamartires1089]

"seeing you arounds really gonna suck"

[@thatfatginger]

"seeing you around is really gonna suck" and then they never saw each other again

[@AngelicaNerd]

I understand that Rachel is angry at him because he lied, cheated and put her health at risk, but she didn't need to humilliate him by literally throwing money at him, specially at school, where he works and studies.

[@feliciawatson8095]

We all knew he was just a plaster for her wounds. It was clear as day she still loved Finn from the Grease episode.

[@valipazz]

I've never being more happier about a break up

[@avi4875]

Degrades and judges him Gets caught being the wrong one Has him admit he actually loves her Uses him as a therapist Breaks up with him All in 2 mins

[@baloneycarrot1602]

but he's brody

[@Wot0-0]

They were both wrong but he was more wrong

[@jermaineevans2369]

thank you for uploading this

[@elaem6542]

I swear to god Lea is such a cute crier

[@Ros3299]

Rachel DIDNT cheat. I'm pretty sure it was an open relationship and Brody was practically cheating on her the whole time!

[@Ros3299]

@@peachblue8674 an open relationship means you can see other people

[@nataliapaliza5407]

Ok I think here's a lot of (undeserved) hate towards brody and I think this is mostly due to the fact he was with rachel when most fans were finchel lovers, so: - rachel and brody didn't cheat each other, cause they agreed of not labelling their relationship and not being exclusive. - we know prostitution is not legal, but sadly it's a job some people do because they don't have other alternative. And maybe most people won't agree with me but if sex is something you enjoy and are good at why not do it as a job? Most 'real jobs' we get aren't the ones we dream of and we have to suffer anyway.

[@Wot0-0]

He could have told her though because she could have gotten an STD, at least with Finn she probably knew his sexual history and knew he was clean so Brody wouldn't get anything, and besides usually when people are in an open relationship they trust their partner to stay clean, not have s*x with dozens of people and play victim.

[@lex4190]

Rachel didn't lie at all

[@shannonthemustanggirl5877]

I never even liked Rachel and Brody being together. Always loved Rachel and Finn.

[@meemobop]

rachel's not trying to shame him for his job, she's just hurt he wasn't open and honest about his job.

[@marivillalobosgonzales2129]

I knew that Brody wasn’t right for Rachel Finn will always be her true love ❤️

[@baloneycarrot1602]

this was the happiest moment in my life

[@estrellita200429]

I love finn and rachel together

[@imaguy5112]

That’s kinda creepy, because after the story ended with Cory(😢) she really dated a gigolo, and she dated Brody after Finn, this is so strange

[@sophieissac2742]

Finchel 💖💖💖😭🥰🥰

[@nahilsolange1015]

Hi, could anyone please tell me whats the name of the piano song playing at 01:06?? I believe it is the same exact song playing when Finn and Rachel talk at the wedding (and then Finn says they're endgame). I may be wrong but I think its the same piano song. I'm watching the series right now, during quarantine in Argentina (142 days so far). Lea and Cory scenes break my heart and so does the background music. I would really appreciate it if anyone could help me with this :)

[@Percius103]

Ok so he called Rachel a liar for Finn beating him up Rachel didn’t even know that Finn did that and Brody called her a liar for Finn beating him up

[@Matheussandree]

"anything was possible" hahahahah it is impossible not to remember#PLACES

[@littledinosaur4414]

I hate it how Rachel backs down and doesn't stay strong.

[@maravanversendaal3812]

love the Frankenstein reference!!🥰

[@alyheartshoops]

Not y’all trying your absolute hardest to defend Rachel and Finn. Yeah they were in an open relationship,but Rachel lied to him about sleeping with Finn at the wedding,and Brody told Rachel that he was with another girl when Rachel was at the wedding. Then Finn is gonna come to NY just to beat him up for no reason. Brody didn’t even try to start a fight with him,but Finn threw punches first,and called Rachel his “future wife” even tho they weren’t together. The only bad thing Brody did was lie about his job,most likely because he was gonna get shamed for it (and he did). Also he was right when he said he doesn’t have 2 dads to pay for all of his stuff like Rachel did.

[@obohemma1983]

After everything finn came to fight for Rachel honor that prove that finn love rachel

[@naiibellaa]

Idk why I have a feeling she wasn't really mad about the job, like I think if he would have told her instead of her having to find out from other people she might have thought it was weird but understud why he was doing it. At the same time though she shouldn't have judged him the way she did.

[@justsomebread8646]

Some people don’t know how hard things can get on your own. Rachel was in the wrong to do that but also Brody should have confessed. He needed the money to be able to obtain a future for himself, and in the long run, was determined to do anything to make it happen. Rachel, doing that Cash stunt was degrading and awful.

[@angharadr862]

His "Job" is in fact ILLEGAL. I would've reacted the same way. Think of the numerous life threatening or altering STD or STIs she could've gotten from him. I can't get on board behind someone who risks that for his partner.

[@blueambra.1590]

@@angharadr862 WTF do you know that condoms exist right?

[@madyellison]

i don't usually like Rachel, but here I felt like she was so brave. I liked how she stepped up.

[@candacebrushett5651]

I know I am late on this but Santana was actually keeping Rachel from getting anything from Brody that he could of got from someone else

[@clearascrystal2873]

Brody not a best time in your life for a relationship boi. Rachel is in love with Finn.

[@jimmyjerryjr.barbra3527]

Rachel and Finn were meant together 👫😢

[@aliciamata00]

For health sake he should’ve told her he could’ve put her in danger. But she had no right to judge how he gets money bc no one but him is paying his bills. She’s low for that

[@gleeactually]

hot take but I love lea's acting in this scene. "why did you lie to me?!" gives me chills everytime

[@anyaconley1082]

crux of the problem is, of course, how can Rachel trust Brody's statement about his " love" for her being real?? if he lied all the time, why not then?

[@maudiebales2963]

Marylyn Conley and comparing it to Finn's love which is coming all that way to beat him up, loved her since Sophomore of high school and broke up w the prettiest girl in high school just to be w Rachel. So I just think Brody needs to shut up

[@marqjk1478]

I def think they needed to break up cause he was lying but I really hate how it's just been widely ok that Finn assaulted this man. Like cool story line and all but yikee

[@ipostanything.]

hate lea michele all you want but this scene was so good when she starts crying it’s like nina dobrev level of crying

[@savannah8447]

yess exactly

[@MS-cy5rl]

I hate that they invented Brody just to show how great Finn is and that Finn is the only real man for Rachel.

[@kurtlim7]

brody should've told rachel from the start what his job was no matter how shameful it is

[@lizanya6433]

the writers should’ve brought him back after finn died 💔

[@elektracatbro3011]

Wow Rachel should have taken a different approach to the situation

[@madisonsheridan1973]

It’s cute that Finn beat up Brody just to save Rachel

[@Erin-Thor]

Who here when they found out how Brody was paying for college, immediately wondered if they could afford him? 🤣

[@z3nddddd873]

I know a bunch of people are mad at Rachel. But think about it, she just found out her boyfriend has been sleeping with other girls as a job

[@hopelessheathen8190]

It's basically cheating on her by not telling her be honest in relashinships kids

[@alc8842]

I miss Finn

[@zakyrarichardson9451]

Bro I liked him so much he made her be more confident and they were hot together mistake we’re just made, dangerous ones might I add but I liked him this I sad 😢

[@rachelberrythegleequeen.3221]

Rachel is right, he could have found other ways of getting extra cash and be for anyone starts with that well Rachel has 2 rich dads bs she’s supporting herself as a singing waitress while also going to school full time.

[@zakabouelfaioud7653]

Not neccesarily NYADA would be expensive plus living arrangements in NYU plus clothes plus foods all adds up plus transportation it would be a lot of money

[@rachelberrythegleequeen.3221]

Zak Abouelfaioud i’m sorry but my opinion still stands, Rachelle is right

[@charlene15329642]

They where in a open relationship so technically no one cheated so Rachel never lied but brody did and not olnly did he lie but that lie put Rachel health at risk which to me is all that more worst

[@angelapedrosa8305]

Oh no.😱😢😭😥💔😡😠🤬👦🏻👩🏻🎼🎵🎶🎙🎤🎧📻🎻🪕🥁🎷🎸🪗🎹🪘📱📲💻🖥⌨️🖱💽💿📀🎥🎞📽🎬📺🔊

[@lifeisbitvlover171]

0:45 everytime I watch this scene I'm like 'frankenteen' not Frankenstein

[@3411-q9c]

Rachel is gorgeous 😍

[@christopheradams6786]

I will always love Brody, I know that what he was hiding was really wrong but he loved Rachel, and they could have do something with his storyline, not only put him as the hooker guy. He had feelings too.

[@idc4163]

I hate how all the blame is thrown on Brody. Like yeah, he should’ve been honest with her. It was seriously messed up not telling her, but she literally also slept with her ex while they were dating. They were both awful for each other. I’m glad it didn’t work out.

[@oblivionxzx]

They were in a open relationship

[@idc4163]

Barbie stalker Yeah but my point is that she wasn’t honest with him.

[@AnnJo-gq8gu]

During this scene, alI I could think about were the bills they threw on the floor. I believe none of them picked it up

[@user-kl3mm3qv1x]

YOOO SHE THREW MAJOR SHADE AT THE BEGINNING AHAHAHAH

[@janabelle-h4b]

This was so OOC for Rachel

[@cristinarodriguez1878]

Brody and Rachel. Worst idea ever

[@sevandaloaf6895]

even though i can't stand rachel, i lowkey think she deserved better

[@dietdrpepper15]

The worst thing brody did was put her health at risk! Why wasn't that the issue in this fight? Lordy, glee drops sooo many balls it's insane. And Finn beating up brody isn't romantic its creepy and possessive.

[@MickyR31]

Ok but after corey died, I really wanted them to be endgame

[@bluehop3422]

Creo que estos dos se merecen son tal para cual.

[@cassielcruzchavolla809]

I think the show was pretty cruel to Brody... They framed him as a bad person for being a sex worker and romantized the fact that Finn physically assaulted him for no good reason.

[@humanoide7076]

Finally someone who doesnt think Finn hitting Brody was cute, they had to ruin him in order to make Finn the better choice and Rachel acting like that bc of his job in front of everybody was awful and they werent really dating so him sleeping with other women wasnt cheating, i personally felt like he was a toned down Jesse kind of guy, just a prop to them, this guy deserved better, people can get mad all they want but for me Finchel was toxic af

[@WildHorizon]

I’m going to be honest Brody’s got a fucking point, some people don’t have mommies and daddies that pay for everything okay, some of us have to do shitcwe don’t want to do we can eat ramen that night. Not all of us have people that believe in us so much, and some of us that do, even if they believe in us they don’t have the money to just give us, and we have to do things to stay alive. Everyone is a prostitute for the right amount of money that’s like being alive 101

[@oneonlys]

i cannnnn’t i don’t think i liked brody back then but shaming sex workers and her just venting to him about her ex fiance lmaoooo what is wrong with rachel

[@ericmarshall2991]

ok but Brody being a prostitute was completely fine, what people have to do for money is not something you should judge, it's their choice, the issue is the danger that he puts Rachel's health in by dating her without her about ut

[@priyatrombino5206]

Thank you!!!

[@liyahm9905]

I’ll say this now Rachel is not the bad guy here she isn’t because yeah not saying Brody is a bad guy but he still should’ve been honest to her about his job no matter what he was going through and I get that he might be embarrassed but don’t go trying to make her seem like the bad guy here and she ain’t....🙄😒

[@troyraffin9741]

That outfit is really good for rachel

[@sunnygirl523]

YEAH GO RACHEL AND BRODY I'M SO FREAKIN HAPPY THAT FINN DID THAT TO U 😍😍😍

[@madisoningramvevo8265]

Can you do the scene where santana finds out Rachel's pregnant

[@mylifeasaudrey839]

Who else thinks that Sam and Quinn should get back together???🧐🧐

[@daisycook2366]

I don’t like how the storyline seems to judge sex workers, but he definitely should have been honest with Rachel given the increased risk of STIs etc.

[@aprilr4418]

DOES ANYONE KNOW THE PIANO SONG PLAYING IN THE BACKGROUND