Snow Blower vs. Front Loader Time Challenge - John Deere 755 Compact Tractors Go Head to Head

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks for posting a comment below! Please note that in the name of science and to conduct a good experiment I was trying to keep the competition fair by just removing the same area of snow from both driveways and ignoring the fact that it was a driveway. I meant to disregard the end of the driveway as to not to introduce so many variables like traffic, the road already being plowed, etc, but alas - it seems that too many folks want to point out that I left a pile and that the job was not complete. I'll try this again this year and include the pile at the end of the driveway and the blower will win hands down I'm sure! Thanks for checking this out and be sure to check out my other tractor videos! Neil

[@TheScientistHayFarmer]

As I was watching I took many exceptions to your study design and conclusion criteria ;)

[@piercedtiger988]

The pile at the end (and really, any place I can't just push the snow into a pile and leave it) is why I finally got a blower. Fighting traction loss when pushing with a bucket or loader mounted plow drove me nuts for years. Especially the sidewalk in front of our house where the road plows dump salty, sandy slush over everything. I've resorted to scooping and dumping more than I'd like to admit, and if we have over a foot that means backing up and dumping it further from the road. Not enough traction to pull off to the side of the sidewalk for dumping. Now with the blower I can just throw it 10-20 ft in one shot and be done with it! It's so nice to not have to move snow 2 or 3 times like before just to get it out of the way. Or having to guess how far back I need to push in prep for future storms. Or having to break those piles/berms up later to push further when I realize I didn't leave enough room for the current storm.

[@john8crase]

I understand, I just vented a issue I have with so many folks always wanting to push snow outward to and across the road leaving a mess in the road, building piles so you can't see traffic and spending extended periods of time screwing around in the road. If folks would simply push from the road and pile the snow in the yard. Nothing on you bro I understand the experiment.

[@CapeAnnImages]

Backing up is a waste of time & effort, when you get to the end turn around and clear the next row! That's how I use a snow blade. Nice video!

[@digdrivediy]

You got it! Just did this for the video. Normally I go around both driveways in a racetrack pattern and never even turn around on the ends! Appreciate you watching.

[@1h2-f5n]

you could of just turned around ....for this driveway...only...bad comparison

[@noahweberding9337]

Agreed

[@peteharder6325]

@@digdrivediy you would have burnt more time drinking around doing a 3 point than just reversing on such a small drive way.

[@blendpinexus1416]

also how i use a snowblower

[@kenuber4766]

Personally, I think the blower wins hands down. The loader not only took longer just to clear the driveway, but then you needed to clear the entrance too. so more like 20 minuets if you include the entrance as well. IMHO

[@digdrivediy]

Very true. The blower is the champ in this case. I was just trying to even the field a little, but the loader didn't have a chance! Thanks Ken!

[@robertwilson1714]

If the loader had a plow blade it might have won

[@HiddenValleyHomestead]

I agree

[@sean7119]

I have a 6’ plow on my 650 and it moves light snow easy and fast but it makes large piles that don’t melt fast and looks messy compared to snow blower. Wet and heavy snow is tough to push and is tough on the tractor.(ramming piles at speed in an 8x2 trans) I wish I had that front snow blower. Thanks for the video!

[@onemansideas5787]

The blower wins hands down. Plus when it snows next time your piles will drift in even deeper.

[@rayanderson4119]

I used to use my bucket all the time. Then I bought a blade. For 0-6 inches, the blade is way faster. But the combination is really great also. I used the bucket and swung the blade way over to 1 side to catch the spill from the bucket. Then the next pass really does clean things up quite well and you only have 1 side to worry about. You can travel way faster with either of these than the blower. But the blower ( mine is a 3pt 56") gets rid of the snow and you never have to worry about that particular volume ever again.

[@Tractorman-xj4gt]

Tractor Time With Tim brought me here - I live in Maine - have a 1025r - turf tires, no chains or ballast to speak of - 300' driveway on a slope - 54" snowblower will handle 4' drifts no problems - thanks for the video !!

[@digdrivediy]

Glad to hear from you Tractorman! Sounds like a nice setup. I'd like to visit Maine someday. I don't think I'm gonna worry about the ballast on my blower anymore. Thanks for watching!

[@domenicmaiani3795]

Thanks for a great video! It is my opinion that moving the pile of snow from the loader should have been included inthe FEL time because the blower didn't leave the snow in the way!

[@digdrivediy]

Very true. I was just trying to make the amount of snow removed the same but you have a very valid point. I knew the loader would lose for sure though if I had to do that! Thanks for the great feedback and thanks for watching!

[@HiddenValleyHomestead]

I agree

[@danmcbride6258]

The trick is getting to the Snow early. Even with a blower it’s necessary to get out early when wet snow is building through a storm. My preference is always a blower. Nice competition.

[@koryleague8833]

Great comparison. They both have advantages and disadvantages. Your lucky to have both options. Thanks for sharing.

[@digdrivediy]

Appreciate it Kory. I do feel lucky to have both and it was a fun day to try them out. So glad to have you watching too!

[@beckyriddell7949]

We have a 955 with a loader but we like to use the snowblower But the loader comes in handy When we pile snow

[@pbaddict1a]

The blower would have worked even faster if you had blown on the way back too instead of backing up(a quick sharp left at the end of the path). A push blade is definitely faster in 6" or less (I have a 1023e with both options) but anything more and the blower is king, and the snow is completely out of the way... No piles to speak of. Great video! I enjoyed it

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks so much. Yeah, the blower can be even faster. When I'm not making a video I just run both driveways in a circle pattern and never stop or even turn around. I'd love to try a push blade. thanks for checking this one out!

[@harleedav]

Hello Neil, great video .. thanks for taking the time to put it together. I am in Northwest PA .. snowbelt region with lake Erie close by. Can get 100+ inches in a snowy winter. I have a JD 2720 with a 54 inch blower and love it. The one downside is if the snow is wet .. clogs the chute and not much that I can do .. but with a regular snow it is great. I have a narrow road coming into the Farmhouse which is atop a hill .. about 1/2 mile in. The blower is great getting the snow up and out. Thanks again for the video .. really creative with the drone views .. Bill

[@digdrivediy]

You've got a nice setup. Thanks so much for watching Bill!

[@teamfishon361]

Very entertaining!!! I admire how organized your shop always looks. Good work! Thanks for the content.

[@digdrivediy]

Appreciate it Tony. Keeping the shop tidy is something that I struggle with it seems. I'm always working on something and the cleaning is always an after thought but I try. Glad to have you watching.

[@karlk6860]

I figured this one 25 years ago and my solution has ALWAYS worked perfectly for me! My tractor has a 70" snow blower on the back and a loader on the front I have never fount a snow bank that I have not been able to handle! I suggest others do the same.

[@digdrivediy]

That's a perfect combo!

[@krankie49]

just some observations. 1.) if you were to use the snowblower in both directions - time should decrease. 2.) If you use the bucket down the center to begin with then the outer paths and use the windrows to contain your bucket full - time should decrease. 3.) if it is a winter that has a lot of snow, more than likely with the blower you will create a berm that could cause more severe drifting across the driveway. 4.) the longer the drive the more favorable for the blower. Yes, the fastest method for a long(er) driveway would be an angle blade but even that has limitations

[@digdrivediy]

Good observations. Thanks Jim.

[@Frontpagefab]

I agree with you Jim A. I have tried all 3 tools over the last 30 years, including a loader mounted blade and a frame mounted blade. My personal choice is a frame mounted frame blade. I do a mix of long and short drives and gravel and asphalt/cement drives with my Deere 2305. I find it is easier to adjust to the different surfaces with the blade. Also, a heated cab is a must,

[@krankie49]

@@Frontpagefab Heated cab? Now there's a luxury LOL. I couldn't agree with you more. I used to have to clear a 2 acre parking lot with a bucket equipped 8N. 5 hrs out in the cold and wind was definitely NO fun.

[@deksea]

Jim A, Good comments, agree completely. Ive got a blade and a blower and until things start getting really deep, the blade wins every time.

[@percyfaith11]

3 is wrong. A snow blower disperses the snow in a wide area there is no berm that is formed. It's the plows and buckets that make the berms.

[@aecox1265]

Well done. Even comparison always help show the differences without bias.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks so much. Tried to be fair.

[@paulnieuwlandt2149]

Snowblower is where it’s at. Remember I switched when I gave you that 318 JD blade, weights and chains. Switched to grasshopper 4’ blower. No need for weights or chains. Less time mounting and throws the snow away from drive.

[@digdrivediy]

Cousin Paul!!! Yeah, I'm a convert now. That snowblade wouldn't stand a chance against a blower in this snow. I should have taken a clue and got a big blower way back then also! I still have the blade but it hasn't been used in a long time.

[@UncleWillie]

That is a great comparison. I am just glad I live where a broom usually gets it done.

[@Iowaflyboy1]

Neil, I recently found your channel and appreciate the great videos you put out! I grew up in Iowa but left after high school to pursue a career in aviation. October 1st I retired after 40 years of flying for a living. I missed living in a small town and my wife and I retired to 108 acres in N Idaho. I’m sitting here watching it snow and watching your video. We have a John Deere 4044, Bobcat E-35 mini ex and a JCB teleskid. I am blessed to have a contractor friend who owns literally over 40 attachments for tractors and skid steers. We are constantly testing different attachments in different conditions. Mostly logging and digging applications but a fair amount of snow removal.. we live close to the Schweitzer ski resort! Deep snow our skid steer hi-flo snowblowers hard to beat but 3-12 inches I prefer my 96” Quick Attach hydraulic snow plow. We bought that out of Minnesota this winter.. controlled by a hydraulic shuttle valve I find it super versatile for moving snow. Just the lane to our house is 3/4 mile with a good elevation change (hilly 😎). I also put snow tires on my JCB skid and the results have been stupendous. I learn a lot from channels like yours and really appreciate the work you must put in to keep it interesting. Thank you Tom

[@digdrivediy]

That's good stuff Tom. I am grateful for you finding my channel and watching along. You have what sounds like a terrific setup for a guy like me and you! I have used a plow as well and could be just as comfortable with one under most winters here. Biggest thing I deal with is plowing up stones and the shoes on this blower have been really good for avoiding stones. I love hearing from guys like you that have some miles under their belt and have had great experiences. Thanks so much for the kind feedback and don't be shy. I'm still reading all the comments just taking me longer to respond nowadays! Take care!

[@henrycarlson7514]

Thank You , That really makes me want a front mount blower for my 855 , and the cab too. Thank You

[@WTFMIKE]

I almost a year late but I didn't know those little 755 were four wheel drive. I'm impressed with that blower for being stock. Put a impeller kit in it and she'll really thrown some stuff. Great video

[@digdrivediy]

Oh yeah they're great. The 655, 755, 855 & 955 all came with 4x4 optional. Pretty cool. Thanks for watching!

[@outdoorswithcorbs9231]

I have a 2017 1025R with 54” Blower. Fricken love it. Good video. I don’t have any weight on mine either.

[@digdrivediy]

I got to play a bit more this week and the blower was my favorite over blade or bucket.

[@Its_just_Dave.]

Awesome video 😎 👍 I love using my blower attachment. Throw that snow as far as possible so there aren’t huge piles building up all season. Eventually with a bucket the piles get to big, but not with a blower. Only downside to a blower is you can’t back drag from tight spots.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks so much and very true. The blower was fun this year for sure. Now to see if I use it again in the next 5 years! lol

[@dfarmer_]

And no piles! What will the kids sled down?

[@davidfisher69]

Great video, first time I've used my snow blower in 6 or 7 years here in Randolph County.

[@digdrivediy]

It's nice moving snow when it is only once in a great while 👍

[@southernyankeehomestead3230]

I will say this video does highlight an important issue that's not mentioned. In snowier states you need a lot of space if you're pushing snow. Whether it be piling it or just getting it out of the way. The big benefit of a blower is you're putting the snow on top of the snow away from where you want clear. So on snowy years you don't have to spend between storms moving snow to make space for more snow. Just change your chute angle and you can pile higher or further away.

[@digdrivediy]

Very true!

[@russellbelton8213]

I think the snow blower was awesome you fixed it up really good. Glad you had chance to try them both out made for a great video 🇬🇧😘

[@digdrivediy]

Always appreciate it Russell. I was impressed with how well it did.

[@simongingerich4524]

I live in central Iowa and my method is a Ventrac 4500Z with the 4’ blower attachment. It does a great job!

[@digdrivediy]

Those Ventrac machines seem like awesome tractors. That would be a cool setup Simon. Thanks for sharing and appreciate you watching 👍🏻.

[@calvinjohnson7806]

Loved it thanks for taking the time to do the video

[@digdrivediy]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@johnhamilton9229]

Nice comparison Neil. I think the blower wins, volume and time aside I say the the wind curtains on the cab are the determining factor. Nothing to die with time just comfort.

[@digdrivediy]

I tend to agree John. That enclosure makes all the difference as you say!

[@waltmooredanwilson8754]

Great video. Thanks for sharing. I wish you the best. Take care and God Bless.

[@ryanshadders750]

I definitely enjoyed this video. I'm personally I'm bigger fan of snow blowers than plowing because they just do a neater job. I also have quite a collection of old Ariens walk behind snow blowers ranging from 6 hp to 8 hp all from 1965 through 1975. Biggest problem I've had with them is connecting rods go and some can be hard to find. I keep them all for parts though. Once I get my 84 John Deere 318 restored I will definitely be seeking out a snow blower for it

[@digdrivediy]

I'm becoming a bigger blower fan every year. Just quick and easy. I have a 49" blower for the 318s but haven't had it out in years. It always worked really well though.

[@davep6977]

definitely the snow blower. It just managed the snow better +it had the cab

[@hconnellraate2474]

I have a JD x 585 (25 hp) with a 47 inch blower mounted on it and we live on the Eastern end of Lake Ontario, noted for "lake affect" snow. I bought this unit new in 2001 and now have over 800 hours on it. Our driveway is 600' long, a real challenge for snow removal. According to our local weather men we average around 240" (20 feet) of snow every year. Now lake affect snow is a very light, fluffy, snow, but sometimes we get a "nor'easter" which is nothing but heavy, wet snow. When we get lake affect snow the blower has NO problem removing if in around 40 minutes, and if we get a "dump" of snow 18" and up it takes me around 1 hour to clear every thing out. Now a nor'easter always takes more time. 1 hour if it's 6" to 8" and up to 1 1/2 hour if over 1 foot. The only problem that the blower has with the heavy wet snot is the blower will plug up if I push it too much, but I would take the blower eny day over the loader. Thanks for putting up this video.

[@digdrivediy]

Great comment! Thanks for sharing your experiences. That's a heck of a lot of snow!

[@TermiteBenny]

Nice things about a blower is, one pass and it’s done, no piles, and no larger windrows along the sides to help create deeper drifts. Plus when the snow starts to melt some and gets wetter then refreeze it basically turns into rock like material and will destroy your car if you accidentally bump into it. Snow blowers are so much cleaner. I will say it also depends on where your moving snow at also, not every place is suitable for a blower. I plow some parking lots in the city that have only one place to pile snow and it would be risky with a blower not to break out some windows doing it. Definitely out where you live with the wind and drifting a snow blower is the best.

[@digdrivediy]

I agree so much! I wasn't a blower person before but I'm slowly loving this thing more and more after every use. Truth be told I only got the loader out for the comparison! But, actually the loader did work nicely when getting that snow out of the area in front of my stove. Thanks for supporting the videos so much. I really appreciate it.

[@doughadley9448]

i have a 3940 Kubota with a 5 foot front mounted snow blower, the thing I like best is there is no pile in front of you when you are done, and unlike a plow, I don't have to push the snow way back to be sure there is enough room for all winter,enjoy your videos!!

[@digdrivediy]

I agree! I'm liking the no piles from the blower. Thanks for sharing your setup.

[@texasgilley9533]

Great video I live in West New York where we get a quite a bit of snow I use my ATV to plow my driveway

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks so much. Great to hear from you up there in NY. We were lucky to have this much snow for once. Appreciate you watching!

[@mikeb9634]

I’m in Houston,TX. Can’t imagine a scenario where I would need to do either of these but was absolutely transfixed. Snow is a nice treat here. Love snow videos!!

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks a lot Mike!

[@t23001]

Great video with all the shots from above. Every driveway is different. Right by the garage doors and at the street can be time killers. It’s great that you have two machines and two drivers!

[@nhbiker1961]

It does make a difference how wet the snow is. I have a rear-mounted on my tractor. I use the bucket for 80% and then clean up with the blower. If the snow is powdery, I might use the blower more.

[@digdrivediy]

For sure John. The snow type can play a huge factor.

[@bradley3549]

The amount of power you have at your disposal makes a big difference there too. My 955 with a 59" doesn't care much about how wet the snow is, but it has ~35% more power than a 755 for the same size blower.

[@nhbiker1961]

@@bradley3549 I have an older 4100. So the power at the 3 point hitch is limited. The snowblower has its limits.

[@bradley3549]

@@nhbiker1961 I bet that's really one of the few times you feel the lack of power with that machine.

[@Andrew-vo9ev]

,I use a snow blower and a 27 inch scoop /sleigh for my driveway but u guys have a farm to do and that's a big difference! Good VDO! 🚜

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks for watching and sharing!

[@dtman66]

The blower is best attachment for removing most snow. On warmer when the snow is wet, not so much(I usually wait till the sun goes down and the temp drops on days like that). You can put the snow wherever you want it. You can clear piles of any size. You can even move the frozen piles of snow. The loader is awesome of getting that hard pack snow/ice off the pathway. Moves slush excellently too where the blower is pretty much useless.

[@digdrivediy]

Great points! I've been enjoying having the blower this winter. Just had the perfect snows for it. Now I gotta figure out where I'm gonna store it! Thanks for watching.

[@lynnkporter]

Another great video. However I Love The Little short Adds on's after you say "Good Bye".

[@tonynieuwlandt1290]

I would lean toward the enclosed cab hands down

[@digdrivediy]

No argument there Tony! I wasn't looking forward to the loader run to be honest!

[@edweirdmassey]

I agree! I don’t have one and any breeze requires goggles

[@caleb2187]

This is what i need to watch at midnight living in,a state were it hasent snowed in,at least 3 years

[@digdrivediy]

Sounds like a plan to me! Thanks for watching Skooter!

[@caleb2187]

@@digdrivediy thanks for makin the videos : )

[@albertbuikema4451]

I do snow clearing for a living. Loader can absolutely be faster with a different approach. Your method definitely left a much tidier result. Blowers only come out in significant storms. That said , I have a completely different approach to snow removal than the average person

[@digdrivediy]

I'm sure there are folks that are way more efficient than me at this. I was just making a fun video. I am thankful to not be plowing snow commercially any more. I never would have had time to screw around and do stuff like this back when I was plowing commercially. Thanks for watching Albert!

[@jackbegley8573]

I use a 47" blower on my X534. After the 1st winter we we're in our house outside Delphi, IN, it became clear I needed to be able to manage the snow when I cleared it from the drive. Had used an ATV with a blade that year and battled the snow drifting. I agree the other comment that the cleaning of the pile needed to be included. Keep up the good work.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks for sharing your setup. I debated on whether or not to include moving all the snow out, but knew it would be an extra 10 minutes. Maybe next time! Thanks for watching Jack!

[@sassafrasvalley1939]

What do I use for snow removal... most of the time it is my aluminum grain scoop and sunshine. However, if my boss determines it isn’t melting fast enough... I use my BX23s and bucket loader. Coincidentally, I addressed that issue just yesterday. It finally warmed up to where I wanted to leave the cocoon like warmth of my shop. (Being out of firewood there plus, a mild dose of cabin fever might have contributed also.). The 10” of snow had dwindled to just 4”-5”. It was time to get outside and deal with it. I went to the barn, warmed up the BX and mounted it to do battle. I had a few things on the list... scrape the snow from the apron leading into the garage, bring in firewood, clean out the bluebird houses and turn the compost pile. I didn’t know if I could finish all of them in the allotted time. So I established priorities: Firewood, driveway, compost then bluebirds. Two of those got completed. You see, as I was on my way to the woodshed, the compost pile beckoned. And, how can one resist a 6’ high by 12’ diameter mass of future garden soil? Especially when it is thirsty and shivering beneath a blanket of frozen water. Well, I detoured around the woodshed and aimed my bucket loader at the compost pile. You know Neil, some guys love their pickups. Others their guns... but me... WAIT... composting isn’t that high on the list. But, I do spend a bit of time with it. I mentioned before that I live in an oak, hickory and walnut forest. (Don’t get me started on the squirrel wars... even though I live in their world...). I also have no topsoil. My TracVac makes building compost piles a breeze. My Loader on the BX turns them without me breaking a sweat. The missing ingredient is moisture. A pile of bone dry oak leaves will not compost. The nature of oak leaves is such that they repel moisture. As a result, rain and snow just penetrate the top few inches and then the remainder runs down the pile. If you don’t move that wet layer inside the pile it will pack down and dry out leaving an even more impermeable layer for the next rainfall. Turning the pile while the outside is wet works the moisture inside. It also opens up the overcoat so the next rain can creep inside. Failure to take advantage of the environmental bonanza of snow or rain seems, to me, to be a negligence bordering on criminal in scope. So, I chose to do it first. It took about 15 minutes. Right next to the compost pile is a bluebird house... cleaning it was on the list... this shiny object moment caused my priorities to shift once again. I cleaned it out while I was there. But, then I faced a crisis... time was slipping away. Do I go around and clean the other 15? Or, do I get back on track and grab that firewood? Neil, you’ll be proud to know that I squelched my desire to follow this detour. I mounted the tractor, loaded the bucket with firewood and headed for the shop. After unloading it, I drove around to the front to clear the snow from the garage apron. To my surprise, a vehicle was blocking it. My sister had come by for a visit. When I went inside to get the key and move her car... she insisted that I sit and visit. Although I enjoyed the chat and sister/brother bonding... my eyes were watching the light ebb away through the picture window. And, I must confess, my ambitions shrank with them Regrets? Not really... but I do wonder which decision would have made the day more productive. Should I have grabbed the firewood and cleared the driveway before my sister got there? Should I have gone ahead and cleaned out all the bluebird houses while I was on that track? I wonder... The one thing I don’t second guess was my decision to turn the compost pile.... it is a given... that was a WIN! Well sir, that was a long winded answer to your question... but after seeing all the thought, prep, freezing and filming that you put into this excellent production... I felt it only proper to answer truthfully and fully. Stay warm... I have another story vid coming out tomorrow. It is a summertime memory that might help you do so.

[@digdrivediy]

Your day sounds about like any given day of the week for me. The shiny objects of distraction are all over the place and usually, I have about 10 things I should be doing rather than what I'm currently doing. The firewood has to be a priority for me or Mama gets upset. Cool air blowing out the vents is a tell tale sign that the fire is week. Happened just this morning as I didn't time my refill intervals properly. I always favor the chore that involves the tractor, so I think you're on track with the compost churn. That's something you have to do with the situation is right so sounds like a wise choice. That snow will melt eventually so the sister chat was probably the better choice as well. I'll be looking forward to that next video. I'm heading to the UP of Michigan tomorrow for a week long snowmobile trip so I'll have plenty of time in the truck to give it a thorough listen. It will be odd to think of summer while in route to a week of snow play, but I may need those thoughts come mid week. Appreciate you watching and commenting always.

[@sassafrasvalley1939]

@@digdrivediy snowmobiling is a pleasure I’ve not experienced... unless you count sliding down the hill in a hay bunk behind a Farmall H. The tractor didn’t have good brakes so the hay bunk pretty much set the pace. At 14 I lived the ride. My dad, trying to keep the narrow front end of the tractor downhill, didn’t seem to get nearly as much fun from the ride! Enjoy your snow trek and stay warm.

[@DesertJacks]

Love that tractor. Far more versatile than I would of thought. Great Video!

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks! Yeah, I think these tractors are great :)

[@doomman700]

Loader mounted pusher(with back drag) and rear mount blower. I don’t like buckets because they need dumped pushers you lift and run.

[@digdrivediy]

I'd love to try a pusher. Never had one before.

[@ZenRebel33]

Love the vid. The one comment I have revolves around the timing. You cut off the timing on the front loader without removing the pile of snow. The pile alone wold take a great deal of time that the snowblower does not need to compensate for. While I get your point with the bucket, I just don't believe that there really is a valid comparison between the two. Snowblower wins all day long. Now if you are going to talk about say a wet slushy snow, that would be interesting test.

[@digdrivediy]

The challenge was just to remove the snow in the box. Pretend the road wasn't there and imagine the snow to be removed was somewhere else. That was the idea anyway. Everyone agrees with you though so I was wrong to not clear the road. Loader doesn't stand a chance in that regard as you say.

[@puddlejumper3534]

I wonder if a snow pusher would be faster the the bucket and blower

[@digdrivediy]

I think it would be pretty fast. I would love to try a snow pusher someday too!

[@MrTs7520]

I think it would be close but you would loose time cleaning up the parts that fall off the edges. Not to mention the benefits of a blower if you get lots of snow over the winter. You can throw it out of the way

[@cwolf8841]

Depends on the kind and amount of snow and what you're plowing. Almost anything is better than a bucket. Pushers are good for parking lots. If a deeper snow, it just starts flowing around the pusher. For a long driveway or road (especially if wet, heavy snow), blades are IMO best. Rear blades if offset tend to cause crabbing. I wish they'd offer gauge wheels on front blades. If it's a high volume snow area with powdery snow, then a blower is best. There are front-mounted snow blowers if your tractor has a mid PTO. My experience with a snow blower with wet snow was that: (a) I got snow/ice blasted if windy. Very painful (no cab) (b) the blower bogged down to a crawl with medium depth wet snowfall (depends on your tractor size) and (c) the discharge chute would constantly freeze up.

[@tedmusgrove8394]

@@cwolf8841 I've seen them add a rubber end on them to keep the snow within. But ? not sure how. Have a good day.

[@cwolf8841]

@@tedmusgrove8394 Yes, both pushers and plows can add on right angle pieces on the ends to try & control snow flowing around. They generally bolt on. A pusher tends to be more vulnerable ......

[@rodneysweetnam8653]

Hi Neil - it's Big Rodders in Ireland. I'm not sure why I watched this as I will never have your challenges of snow management here. I have zero experience or knowledge of the subject but I lean towards the blower as the end results appear neater and more controllable. However, I'm sure both systems have their benefits. An enjoyable watch.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks Big Rodders! I appreciate you watching even if it isn't in your wheelhouse. That's always my goal is to try to interest the uninterested! The snow blower is the clear winner in my mind also.

[@ejkjr.4694]

Snow blower is great, we haven't had enough snow to justify me getting one I'll just use the loader

[@digdrivediy]

I honestly thought I would never use this one either. Got lucky this year now it will likely set for a few.

[@bhall9537]

The 55-series tractors were probably one if the best lineups John Deere ever made

[@digdrivediy]

They really are great tractors for sure!

[@supertrooper7403]

I send my 2 sons out to clear the driveway.

[@digdrivediy]

Haha! Hey, that gives me an idea... I have two daughters and two tractors...😎

[@piercedtiger988]

@@digdrivediy One of my daughters has been asking to learn how to plow, and now that we have a blower it's even easier for her. She had fun trying it out the day we got it.

[@digdrivediy]

@@piercedtiger988 That's awesome!

[@piercedtiger988]

@@digdrivediy I actually just posted a couple short videos of her trying it out too. I like how the day after I get it, I see your video comparing the two. haha

[@snoozieq4584]

My grandpa had a John Deere with the snow blower, mower deck and a snow plow/blade. He lived in Conneaut, OH, right on Lake Erie at the end of the drive. I don't remember which mower he had, but it was huge for an acre and a half. We had four other neighbors that shared the drive. Grandpa Meinke was a super popular guy when he'd plow/snow blow the drive and everyone's driveways. He would also make sure that downed limbs and other debris was removed from the drive. He was just that kind of person. Wouldn't take money from anyone either, not even if he mowed your yard for you while you were vacation. I miss him so much. P.S. The snow blower works a lot better when you don't try to bum rush a snow drift. Low and slow. Also, you may want to blow the snow in the same direction the wind is blowing. That way the snow blower isn't fighting the wind too. LOL

[@digdrivediy]

That's cool Susan. Your Grandpa sounds like my kinda guy!

[@russorpcom]

Another thoroughly enjoyable video. I know you put thought and effort in your posts. I have both types of snow removal, but use the snow pusher (and a small snow blower) more because of conditions I have. I have often wondered, when you have to continually snow blow the same snow, does it change and become more work (like not throwing as far) for the machine? I guess its more of a problem for the smaller blowers. Thanks again for taking the time to setup and video this post (I look forward to watching your videos on Sunday mornings)!

[@digdrivediy]

You don't know how much it means to me for you to say that Richard, so thank you. I would really like to try a snow pusher as well as I think that would be an efficient system as well. It takes all types for different situations. Appreciate your viewership very much sir. Have a great Sunday!

[@ssu7653]

9:20 perfect example for where each is the best option. Front loader pull snow from a closed off area, while the blower removes it on a more open area :)

[@joshuaaldrich1540]

Which was more fun to use? I use my bucket. Like to see how high I can get the piles

[@digdrivediy]

I like using both but since the snow blower is new to me and I've got to run the loader on lots of other projects I would say the blower wins in the fun department. Seeing it throw snow across the yard is cool! I love stacking piles though too! Thanks for watching!

[@michaelgeneau2089]

Same Joshua Aldrich

[@jonway7845]

I've used a John Deere X300 with a 44" snowblower for 15 years and got a John Deere X350 last year. It's never let me down and does a great job removing snow.

[@digdrivediy]

Can't go wrong there for sure. The blowers are the way to go if you've got big snow. Thanks for watching Jon!

[@captainedc]

Great comparison I've always wondered about. For most of the 90s I had 15 driveways I did in the winter with my 2 JD-140s with cabs. One with a 49 blower and one with a 54 blade. Right away I saw the advantages of each. The biggest advantage to the blower was getting it out of the way and not having it accumulate at the end of a run like you did at the street. Especially if there is already snow there and you had to deal with traffic. Sometimes I got lucky and dad or a friend ran one machine. Otherwise I just picked one or the one that was running good. I don't miss sucking up the occasional PHONE BOOK though with the single stage blower.

[@Vulcan650Vampire]

🤣 yup..the 90’s

[@charliewatt3218]

I use a John Deer GX345 with chains , wheel weights and a 42" snowblower . I always help neighbors in big snows to dig out, and clean the ends of our driveways after the snow plow goes by.

[@nicholbr72]

Grizzly 700 with 60” warn blade. Would do well in the test, not so well on the close quarters 2 ft drifts

[@digdrivediy]

Those Grizzlies are nice machines. We have some of them at work and they are super reliable. That would make a nice plow vehicle. Thanks for sharing Brad and appreciate you watching!

[@trentwheeler6161]

Yeah, ATV plows have surprised me in the past for how small they are. Loads of torque. Theres a guy on youtube with a Boss brand V plow. It's incredible how well it works.

[@lauderdalechad]

2015 2032r with front mount 54" blower and a 60" 3pt rear blade... Best of both worlds 👍

[@digdrivediy]

Nice setup!

[@haroldgrzywa2445]

I’ve been using cub cadet snow blowers for 50yrs right now I have a cub cadet 3225 with a 45in two stage blower no rocks in the grass and no piles love the blowers.

[@digdrivediy]

You've got it figured out Harold! I agree 100%!

[@shanesherwood343]

I have always used a walk behind Ariens snowblower this is gonna be my first year with my 3033r and a loader mounted snowplow hoping I get a storm like that to test it out in great video kept me and my daughter very entertained keep up the good job

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks Shane! That's an awesome tractor you have. Beat of luck this year I hope we get a biggie! Appreciate you and your daughter watching.

[@nicholasstark414]

Here in central New York. We have two trucks with plows , one John Deere 345 lawnmower with a snowblower and a John Deere 2032r with a front mount snowblower. Dealing with lake affect snow like we do here in central New York. We have to ready quick and have to move snow fast.

[@danielmarcotte1022]

Great video, personally I like using my bucket for the front and rear drop plow.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks Daniel!

[@benjamingibson4720]

I've loved this video, it's always interesting to see the high snow fall other people get compared to us in the UK, the toughest tool I have to use is a hand shovel to shift snow. Benjamin Cleveland uk

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks!

[@danmcgivern1345]

I agree when you said that it all depends on the type of snow that falls. Our last storm here in Ohio I used everything I had to clear the snow. 10 1/2 Western V Plow on the F450, New Holland with a front mount blower like yours, Walker Mower with a font blade, small snow blower, and a shovel.

[@digdrivediy]

No kidding Dan. You might have seen the backhoe in the background? Yeah, it helped out too! Sounds like you have a nice collection of tools, er toys as well!

[@danmcgivern1345]

@@digdrivediy Nice! Yes I am fortunate to have some cool toys. Keep the awesome videos coming.

[@crslyrn]

Pretty good comparison of the two options to use for cleaning out the driveways. I use a John Deere 4600 compact tractor with a John Deere 460 loader & a 3 point McKee Econo Plow 6+6 snow blower. I really like how the snow blower neatly disperses the snow off of the driveway in to the yard or field. One of the downsides of the 3 point snow blower is having to sit twisted in the seat to look behind you as you're using the snow blower. Thanks for sharing your comparison results.

[@digdrivediy]

You bet Ron. Sounds like you have a nice setup there. Thanks for watching and the thoughtful comment.

[@lowellgates5652]

Nice video! I'm using a Frontier loader mounted 5' blade on a 2016-2025R. In the past, I used a 1953 JD-40S with 5' Ford front blade, before that JD garden tractors with both blades & blowers. Both units have their place!

[@digdrivediy]

Nice setup Lowell! Yeah, there is certainly use cases for blades and blowers and loaders. Best thing to use is what you have handy and available. Thanks so much for watching!

[@ValleyCustoms]

Front blade (on loader) for back dragging near obstacles and making piles + rear 3pt blower to chuck piles into the yard and distribute the snow.

[@FloridaDeere]

Well, it will be 81 today and 88 both tomorrow and Sunday, so I'm pretty jealous. I was surprised the loader did that well, but the blower shines in the fact that it doesn't require clean-up afterwards. I still remember the video with you picking up that thing, what a great buy and how awesome you can use it the first season. Great video Neil.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks so much! We got lucky on the amount of snow we got this year after I just happened to buy a snowblower. My neighbor keeps cussing me cause I bought that blower and made it snow! Thanks so much for watching!

[@KzCreations]

good job. I automated my craftsman tractor snow blower and I have felt it was the way to go for over 25 yrs.

[@digdrivediy]

For sure Keith. Thanks for watching!

[@ryanpaul5604]

Both worked pretty well. Snow blower takes the cake but the bucket did well too.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks! I thought they both did well too!

[@RogerDiotte]

I'm definitely sold on blowing as for 20 plus years experience on my farm in Northern Ontario 🇨🇦! The bucket worsens the snow mass over a few times in that the edge of my driveway grows due to bucket push build up and every snow storm thereafter fills my cleared path to height of what's now the bucket spill over... my blower leaves minimal banks over time thus only a few inches of buildup on my driveway!

[@digdrivediy]

Perfect 👍🏻

[@greenidguy9292]

I put a glycol tubing system in before I poured my driveway…game changer, but not as much fun as snow blowing. Awesome blower btw.

[@digdrivediy]

That would be nice. I'd be more willing to do my neighbors if mine didn't need done!

[@blackfly29er]

Great video! Blower. Single stage 46" on a Wheel Horse 520 with chains and wheel weights. Reliable and works in all snow conditions. If. Off season touch up missing paint, and wax inside of chute, auger, and blower.

[@digdrivediy]

That's a good tip. I need to paint and wax this one for sure.

[@trentwheeler6161]

I spray penetrating oil all over inside the chute and such and boy what a difference it makes!

[@rjgoniea]

I am a definite fan of snow blower attachments. I only have a 40" lawn tractor mounted snow blower, but it's fine for the smaller driveways I do in town. Plus it's narrow enough to clear a standard city sidewalk. I also used to use it to clear my now ex wife's ~4000 sq ft office parking lot. It was useful there because there wasn't a lot of space surrounding the lot to put snow piles, but with the blower I was able to throw most of it over a 6' tall fence into the backyard next door. Wet heavy snow does slow things down a lot, but not having to deal with large pile ups of snow from a plow is worth it to me.

[@digdrivediy]

Blowers are the way to go for any heavy amounts of snow for sure! Thanks for watching and sharing Robert!

[@davidpalidwor3229]

Good video! One issue using the snow blower is that the grille fills with snow / ice and can cause the engine to overheat even in sub zero. The grille on your tractor is virtually identical to the one on my 430 and after about 2 - 2 1/2 hours (depending on wind direction) it can become so blocked I need to bring it into my shop and use a heat gun to clear it enough that I can finish moving the rest from my yard. I use my blower whenever I can but go around with a blade to clean up after I am done with the blower or use the blade when there is only a skiff of snow and then blow the windrows away with the blower afterwards.

[@karuza82]

Neil great video as always. I've commented on my parents experiences with their 755, 855, 955, gator 6x4, and a Yammaha Big Bear 4x4 ATV. The 855 with blower and snowblade was the first to go thru the ice into the pond and a zero degree turn diesel JD mower went for a dip in the pond one summer. My setup is a free JD LX255 15hp Kohler 42" single stage front blower. 80 lbs rear weights, tractor trunk, chains.

[@digdrivediy]

Man, hate hearing if that 855 going swimming! Thanks for sharing your setup. Free is the best price! 😁

[@jamesjohnson6239]

I live in the snow belt .the snowblower is better as it throws snow clear of the driveway. After several snowfalls the loader or plow has nowhere to put the snow .great video !!

[@digdrivediy]

I agree James. I probably won't get to use it again now for several years I bet.

[@kragfearghal]

Mr.Koch, love your JD tools, I use '05 LT 150 Garden Tractor with Bercomac 42" blower for my driveway/mailbox situation in Maine. Next time if you've not tried, spray blower surfaces with Silicon ,& I guess you may use it on Frontloader too. Helps to keep snow from sticking , plugging blower chut for a while, has to be repeated depending on snow type. Great video btw, thanks for the time you put into this to share with us .

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks so much Mr. Ferrell! I will need to try that Silicon spray for sure. Thanks for the tip and thanks so much for watching!

[@shabadoo24]

They both have their advantages..

[@digdrivediy]

You're right about that John!

[@donnkemp9302]

60" Grasshopper zero turn snowblower, amazing machine.

[@digdrivediy]

I've heard those are really good!

[@jandr72]

Nice video, I love the snow. To answer your question, what do I use to remove snow... my kids ha!

[@curtwhite876]

Very fair and great comparison -- glad the drone is okay... I use a 7' grader blade on my FEL with a 3-point adapter plate to move snow. I had a friend fabricate and mount some custom snow plow shoes so it doesn't move much gravel. I can rotate the blade 180 degrees to move snow from the garage door and I can plow going forward with the blade angled and watch it roll off the end. It is very satisfying. That blower was really impressive. I would want one, but like you said, didn't have to move snow for about 2 years here is southern indiana.

[@digdrivediy]

Sounds like a great set-up Curt. I could use a blade like that on several occasions. Appreciate you sharing the details of your rig. Thanks for watching!

[@marykoch5168]

Great video as usual Neil. I was surprised to see how far the snow blower can throw the snow, and while it would be nice to not have all of the snow mounds, the two "mountains" you and your Dad created over here are a big hit with the kiddos. They'll likely be here for weeks! I was wondering if the girls played on them yet. You boys need to encourage your Dad to upgrade his snow removal equipment. While the Ford and it's big bucket do a good job, he was one solid popsicle when finished. Find him something with a heated/cooled cab. It's long overdue. Thanks for all the help clearing over here. It's been years since we've had this much snow.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks Mom. We need to start shopping for a tractor for Dad. Hate seeing him be a popsicle on the old Ford. Time for an update. Thanks for the great comment!

[@JBacon1698]

@@digdrivediy So, have you got *the old man* a new machine for this year?

[@digdrivediy]

@@JBacon1698 nothing yet. He needs something for sure.

[@TheOldManAndTheSaw]

Good video. Keep in mind that with a snowblower you only need to move the snow once and its gone forever. With a front end loader, I've had to relocate the accumulated snow from previous cleanings MANY times during the season. Sometimes I run out of room for the snow. BTW we get over 180" of snow per year here in Central New York.

[@digdrivediy]

For your kind of snow you would certainly benefit from the blower! I've had years where we only move snow once. Thanks for watching!

[@MotoTexan]

Dang it Neil! I gotta be up at 4am and here I am watching a video about snow removal….. I live in south Texas.

[@digdrivediy]

Ha! Well, that's the best kinda compliment if you're still watching but don't plan on ever needing a snow removal machine!

[@Flyingdutchman586]

Well done. Love the setup. I have over 120hp on a blower and want more power. You'll always want more. How wet the snow is matters sooo sooo much. A loader is great for a quick and dirty cleanup. A combo of the loader with blade and a blower works well.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks so much. I know what you mean. This 755 is just _barely_ able to run this blower. I like having options for sure. Appreciate you watching!

[@MissionRidgeRoad]

Being pro snowblower there is no comparison after three or four snowfalls. You run out of space to place your snow. The snowblower would have been much quicker had it been done more efficiently ie: blowing right through the end of the driveway to the other side of the road - turning around and blowing on the way back to the house. I have a similar driveway and snowblower. Hands down the best if there are multiple snowfalls and snow stays due to temps. Thanks - fun to watch.

[@digdrivediy]

Appreciate it!

[@rakman88]

I run a 4400 with a 59 front mount. Also use a blade, turned around to push, on the back to clean up pavement and concrete, as well as back drag from certain areas. I have a snow bucket for my loader, but I find the blower/blade combo is just so handy and quick. For small snowfalls I'll just go quickly around with the blade, as I can't keep the blower on all the time.

[@digdrivediy]

That sounds like a terrific combo to have Rudy. The blower has been fun to have this winter. Thanks for watching and sharing!

[@scottsoper]

I like to use the snowblower 100% of the time. That pile at the end would have been easier to deal with using the snowblower. If one can angle the blade, one might use it when there is just an inch or two. Or put a snow pusher on the front of the loader. My view is use the snow blower unless the snow is so wet it will not go through. I live in Florida now but 40 years ago I had a JD420 and F930 both with snow blowers. The one like yours on the 420 (garden tractor not the farm tractor) removed drifts from driveways that were as high as the house! Push in, back out, snow drops down and push in again till all the snow is out of the way! Loaders are what you use when you don't have a snowblower and should!

[@digdrivediy]

The blower is certainly the way to go if you've got the snow for it. It may sit a few years now and not see any snow but I'll keep it around just in case we get the "biggy"! Thanks Scott.

[@jdhogyellowhelmetproductio358]

COOL! I use 5083E John Deere tractor with snow bucket and a IH workstar with 10 ft. belly blade and 10 ft Henke front mounted push blade.

[@digdrivediy]

Very nice setups!

[@ritterjon]

💥 Everybody’s situation is different. I’ve got a front blower and a rear blade and that works best for me in MN. I have a BX23S with a cab. *Keep on tractoring!*

[@digdrivediy]

That blower/blade combo is a solid way to go for sure. Seems to be a popular favorite and for very good reason. I've seen that Kubota of yours and it's a nice machine. Thanks for checking out the video Jon!

[@brianjohnston9822]

Snow blower hands down. You didn’t want to include the snow pile in the challenge, but that is the main part of the challenge. The nice part of the blower is that it reduces the banks. The draw back is the wind conditions can create white outs. The other important factor is knowing what is buried. Left behind toys or even ice can create havoc on the shear pins.

[@digdrivediy]

Very true. I'm gonna need to try again next year with another challenge. Maybe include a blade too. Thanks for watching and pointing out some good things to consider.

[@bradley3549]

And unfortunately that 59" blower only has shear pins on the augers and not the impeller. Also, the worm drive box is very expensive I've learned...

[@alleycat.propertymaintenan3821]

Nice test neil i think this was a great way to test both of your tractors.

[@digdrivediy]

Thanks so much! It was a fun experiment.

[@trevorrowe6231]

I use a homemade plow blade on a modified lawn tractor. We had to add a weight bed to hold two bags of grit.

[@digdrivediy]

Whatever works! Beats a shovel for sure. Thanks Trevor!

[@andymehl7994]

I run the little brother to your blower set up. 1989 JD 420 with the 47" 2 stage blower. I prefer a blower because it allows you to get the snow away from the driveways, sidewalks, ect. When using the loader or a blade, you end up with massive snow piles and if you don't push them back far enough at the beginning of the season, they become problematic. My 420/blower works quite well here in SW MI, where a lot of our snow is lake effect, which tends to be wetter and more dense.

[@digdrivediy]

I completely agree. I really like how "clean" everything looks after using the blower. My 10 year old daughters however prefer the loader for the big piles! Thanks Andy!

[@klikliks_service]

I use a 420 with a single stage and cab. I like putting snow right where I want it.

[@louisglen1653]

The beauty of a blower is that you don't make piles of snow. You can have nice big drifts and they just get ground up.

[@digdrivediy]

That's exactly right!