8 Times The Straw Hats KILLED People

[@jaohonaxa]

I feel Oda's always done a good job of portraying all the straw hats as characters who don't try to kill people but also don't try to not kill people. Like if they're in a fight they do all they can to win, and if their opponent(s) wind up dead, that's just what happened.

[@weedman0824]

In other words, Stawhats go by the motto, fuck around and find out 😂

[@HarryCline11]

Fr😂

[@jasonnoregretes491]

Early luffy straight is surprised when Don krieg isn't dead. He was going for blood

[@fluffypinkpandas]

Thats what it means to be a pirate i believe one of luffy's episode 1 lines are about "and if I die doing what I love, i wouldnt have it any other way" throughout one piece hes kinda wanted to impose his code on what a pirate is to other pirates. with kuro, with aarlong, and so on

[@jaohonaxa]

@@jasonnoregretes491 yeah, but I mean my point is Luffy isn’t the type of person who’s gonna hold back in a fight, but he’s also not the type to go and step on the other guy’s neck after the fight is definitively over.

[@kasendaniel3896]

The fact spandam and black maria are somehow alive honestly is even more terrifying, cause to me that means robin somehow knows the exact place to snap someone’s back like a snickers and not kill then

[@silverkuroma]

ah fuck now i cannot unsee that in the scenes when i will rewatch them eventually

[@berlinglasgow9585]

she was a pro assassin

[@animesticl9202]

Wait black maria is still alive ?!! I though Robin butchered her body in two parts. In spandam, though his bones were broken in two segments but i thought black maria was butchered in 2 parts

[@dark7element]

Nobody will ever convince me that Yama from Skypeia isn't fucking dead. Even if Robin's other opponents somehow survived, he got his back broken before landing HEAD FIRST on the ground from a 500 foot drop. And his upside down body is completely motionless afterwards in the anime - no twitching, no groans of pain, nothing. AND this was after Robin specifically said that she wouldn't spare him.

[@jlieben6369]

Theyre pirates. They’ve killed on screen more than that unless you assume normal marines survive that shit. They just dont AIM to be genocidal but if push comes to shove…

[@RedYDG]

Straw Hats, you stand accused of committing murder. Most of the crew: "Probably." Robin: "Professionally." Zoro: "Recreationally." Usopp: "I'd like to introduce my lawyer, Lawyerking. He is NOT, in fact, me wearing a mask."

[@dark7element]

Nami: "😋Nyeh~"

[@Unpurelight]

I need this filler episode! 🤣

[@13vatra]

Zoro has definitely killed more people than were mentioned in the video. He's a swordsman that worked as a bounty hunter for pirates. Pirates tend to get "dead or alive" bounties so Zoro really had no reason to hold back and try to keep them alive. But of course, this is One Piece, so Oda is never going to focus on that aspect.

[@WhydTheyChangeOurNames]

He also begins off as a world renowned "Pirate Hunter" which is crazy impressive considering he never left the East Blue. He also already had a bounty upon him and was set to be executed by the Marines. The only examples we have of Marines executing people has been if they have killed, if they threaten the World Government, or for social political reasons such as Marineford. They stand nothing to gain from killing him for social or political reasons so we can rule that out, he also didn't and doesn't care about the World Government and again hadn't left East Blue yet so zero threat there, and thus the only explanation is that Zoro had killed people before; likely a good number of people in order to gain the fame he had. His bounty just remained smaller than others we saw as he wasn't yet a pirate, worked alone, and had no ambitions of leaving his little section of the world.

[@1001011011010]

​@@WhydTheyChangeOurNames He was set to be executed because he killed Helmeppo's pet when it attacked a girl

[@luppy777]

Robin is ded assasin

[@leooivio]

Sure, but hasnt Luffy killed most people from the strawjats on screen atleast since fodder probably gets killled by the crew all the time.

[@WhydTheyChangeOurNames]

@leooivio nah definitely still Zoro. Most attacks by Luffy would be non-lethal punches and kicks whereas Zoro is slashing people with incredibly sharp swords

[@GRBLIN]

as someone who has worked with the one piece wiki, the reason why the article about zoro and Mr 7 may not be so direct with what happened to Mr. 7 is because even though it’s all but said by the manga - it is not said, so to avoid any chance of saying something wrong, all information is vetted and stated in this way. a lot of in-fighting happens regarding this kind of stuff, more drama on that wiki than you’d think.

[@m1bl4n]

You're still One Piece fans after all. Infighting is a given.

[@ChefMonke07]

That's... Actually kind of a good reason for wording it like that.

[@generation-gu5iz]

I can imagine there's plenty

[@patrickstar5136]

At the risk of starting that whole debate again, that kinda makes me curious why the Wiki didn't go the safe they/them or the even safer aviod pronouns route with the entry for Yamato.

[@musismail9491]

So at what point can something be confirmed without it being explicitly said

[@Phyrrus]

Zoro did not kill the Child and Nun in Whisky peak, he said they should "thank the lord" cause he used the dull side of his sword

[@grimprime6451]

You know that could still be fatal

[@symphomaniac]

​@@grimprime6451they specifically used that line to confirm he didn't kill them

[@k2geekd]

@@grimprime6451😭 yea but the dull side of a blade is literally used to not fatally injure people

[@darknesswave100]

​@grimprime6451 the opposite side of a katana is blunt. For it to be fatal he'd literally have to beat them to death with it

[@gmoney9469]

The time Luffy whipped a bunch of Impel Down guards into the lava always stood out to me.

[@yaqbulyakkerbat4190]

No worries, it was actually salsa

[@fakenamerson1693]

In the anime, they very carefully avoid showing any of the Impel Down guards actually falling into the boiling liquid. It tends to make it look like they got sent flying straight up and them fall back down on the bridge.

[@bkgraphs1810]

When I first rewatched OP I also counted for fun how many potential kills have our strawhats. We can agree Zoro's most slashes and Robin's neck clutches are fatal for enemies. Even Sanji sometimes could instantly kill (do your remember bouncy guy in skypea? And unluckies from BaroqueWorks?). Robin's brutally punishing skyea's big fat dude should be reminded too

[@cassiusfelix2805]

Yup

[@Soullessgingerftw1]

Unluckies canonically survived

[@faedragonlucy]

@@Soullessgingerftw1 Pretty hilarious considering Sanji literally snapped Miss Friday's neck in the anime (I guess animals don't qualify for chivalry)

[@Dee-nonamnamrson8718]

Lots of people survive zoros slashes.

[@t.i.o.l.u]

Àà

[@Nothinmuchbaby]

I remember thinking Zoro killing the magistrate in Wano was a funny reminder that he does indeed kill people. We were so used to not seeing that and then BOOM, he just slices a guy in half. With that being said, I feel like only named characters are safe from being killed by the Straw Hats. Zoro does most of the slaying, but they all have some pretty lethal attacks that they unleash on some relatively weak opponents. I mean no one really bats an eye at Ussop releasing poison gas and Franky shooting lasers, or Brook freezing people solid and Nami shocking them with lightning. There’s no way in hell a normal person is surviving a Gear 3 attack, and Sanji indiscriminately throws kicks that are strong enough to shatter bones at his opponents skulls. Jimbei might be the only one who legitimately doesn’t kill anyone, but he is directly responsible for some of the most bloodthirsty and cruel Fishmen, so who knows what he was doing in the past. All in all, their collateral damage has to be responsible for at least a few hundred deaths, if not more.

[@ashrunblader1648]

1

[@Polo-he2ih]

Zoro had the most kills I think

[@Lucky-km1nt]

Him or robin

[@pat1r1ck]

I say brook since he had the highest kill count in Whole cake by releasing the homies

[@Twenty_Hundred]

The darker the better

[@yuvrajganguly]

I still don't think he has killed those Fishmen.

[@getgoodwifi4623]

You could see blood on some of them tho, so the "He didn't cut them doesn't apply"​@@yuvrajganguly

[@jatin368]

It is funny that Kalifa managed to survive, cause Nami literally struct a thunder bolt tempo through her heart (there was smoke coming from her mouth and her eyes went blurry afterwards)

[@Andmau2552]

Huh... Every encounter against Enel survived so I'd say in OP electricity is not fatal

[@TahudisMulti69]

Yea💀

[@MarcoD.Pineapple]

or everyone is just incredibly durable, everyone seems to get up after an attack like 10 minutes later, even some normal citizens.@@Andmau2552

[@hgirjiofebunsjbk]

@@Andmau2552on screen you mean its stated that he kills ppl

[@urtoryu_dy_althraidn]

Next time you take a bath, remind yourself that One Piece thought you about how soap is resistant against lightning. It might save your life.

[@arnieXD]

I don't have any close friends that follow one piece. You are like that friend that knows way too much about something kinda geeky, but is still somehow the coolest guy in the group. Suddenly felt like sending you something out of appreciation

[@tadelagahan5825]

@GRANDLINEREVIEW YOU HAVE TO SEE THIS!!!!!! 😊

[@BottleBoundRogue]

It's hard to think that all the marines that Franky has gunned down at Enies Lobby survived the spray of bullets.

[@gentblue]

Bullets are only lethal at point blank range, fired by pistols in One Piece.

[@Eiddez8]

Also the bullets are round so you have a much better chance of serving

[@dreamzoe957]

Franky literally shot one in the air with a rocket 😭

[@whatever_hi_in_spanish_is]

they probably got treated before they bled out (Or just tanked it)

[@dark7element]

Well, on the one hand, the guns in Franky's arm are air-guns. But on the other hand "air" is ridiculouly destructive in One Piece, since apparently kicking can create blades made of air that cut through freaking walls. Not to mention Franky's own 'coup de vent'.

[@AJAlkaline]

Worth noting that we often see observation haki users refer to sensing someone's presence as "hearing their voice", so when Law says he doesn't hear Luffy's "voice" he's probably referring to his observation haki and not to the Voice of All Things.

[@IAmDaJar]

You mean like mantra on skypiea?

[@TanJHshorts]

@@IAmDaJar i think he means mantra is observaiton haki

[@zayah0815]

Luffy definitely killed people in Impel Down by knocking them into the boiling liquid.

[@glowstonelovepad9294]

You could probably find more times that the Straw Hat Pirates killed other characters in filler and movies. It's a rule in most anime that the main characters kill more characters in filler and movies than in plot.

[@jaysylvester7973]

12:26 so here’s the thing. When people read law and momo saying “I can’t hear luffys voice” their not using voice of all things, people are forgetting that it’s not voice of all things that hears another human. What they are using however is observation haki, when a person becomes unconscious in any way, to an observation user’s perspective they describe it as “their voice disappeared”. This example was shown a thousand times by both enel and aisa from the sky island arc who said this about a billion times when they think someone dies despite the fact that no one died in the entirety of that arc just became unconscious. Thus luffy did not die in his battle with kaido he only fell unconscious and his voice disappeared from observation user. And this is further proven when you realize law and momo are observation user while law is not a voice of all things user

[@Ekh001]

Luffy died. He wasn’t just unconscious. His heart stopped and everything

[@joshualynn6459]

I don’t know if anyone else has mentioned this but Luffy has one more FOR SURE kill under his belt, however it was also in a movie. In the movie Dead End Adventure he bazooka’d Captain Gasparde, who was a devil fruit user, directly into a hurricane in the middle of the sea…that dude is 100% a goner lol

[@cassiusfelix2805]

Has to be

[@yashwanth5674]

movies are non canon

[@truffle6082]

Luffy killed a lot of the guards in Impdel down level 4

[@PurpleLionRs]

Luffy knocked countless amount of people into the lava during impel down. Well you prob could count it if you're inclined to.

[@Ragnay977]

The only real argument I have is against the 'Toy' murder. Your example is Kyros losing a leg before transforming but we see a ton of broken or torn up toys in the dump that presumably return to their normal human selves once Sugar is beaten since we see a lot of people leave the dump. We even see the guy who constantly gets his arm torn off by a dog as a toy get his arm magically fixed once he returns to human form. So I think any damage done to people as a toy doesn't seem to transfer to their real body, assuming they don't get completely disintegrated I guess.

[@Peksisarvinen]

I would say that Robin probably killed Black Maria. It was at least heavily implied that she's dead as hell.

[@nightmare348]

And if she ain't dead, she's at the very least paralyzed, since Robin Bane'd her while in that kick ass demon flower form

[@shubydoobydoo3212]

I mean she broke Spandam and half and that dudes still alive and kicking

[@tureytayno3154]

@@shubydoobydoo3212 Well, probably, not kicking because he got paralyzed from the waist down

[@christianvondruska8244]

​​@@tureytayno3154 No, he's perfectly fine in present day, probably through medical care

[@francessf74]

My heart goes out to all the people who died before finding out what the one piece is, Happy New Year.

[@greefro7075]

What do you mean by that?

[@francessf74]

I mean actual people that watch the anime lol.@@greefro7075

[@ΚρανίΩ]

@@greefro7075i guess he says rest in peace to everybody who died in 2023 because they could not see the end of one piece

[@midas7719]

@@greefro7075It was probably obvious they’re talking about how some people unfortunately lost their lives before finding out what the treasure is.

[@0-M72-0]

What.

[@boxertest]

Zoro does not cut to allow for EMS, he cuts to send the enemy to the morgue

[@BenCarmichael0]

I read EMS as eternal mangekyo sharingan 😂lmao I gotta stop smoking

[@jessiehogue.]

@@BenCarmichael0 Same and I don't even smoke. What am I to doooo?!

[@juanfallas7402]

Well it's basically cannon that Zoro got the sharingan during the timeskip xDD

[@jessiehogue.]

@@juanfallas7402 He was Roronoa Zoro Uchiha all along...

[@kjmanwi2517]

@@jessiehogue.I mean there is a scene that looks similar to a Naruto one

[@coSocks]

5:30 if luffy was a killer I’d say that drowning a fish man is something he’d probably try to do rather than zoro lol

[@KaizokuJoe]

didn't Sanji cover a Fishman's gills in the Arlong arc?

[@coSocks]

@@KaizokuJoe damn i don't remember that, that's pretty brutal though if he did

[@johnyshadow]

@@coSocks He did something like that. The fishman survived tho.

[@TyBeyonce8]

agreed

[@shawngrauer7896]

Yes. He blew air in his gills and that started to drown him.

[@one_of_many_fans]

I feel like usopp weirdly has a lotta kills considering he is the sniper, his hits are directly in very weak spots and with lead, fire, carnivorous plants, he has a good few kills under his belt fo sho

[@purplebackground]

All his ammo in one piece don't really seem like they can kill one piece characters. Only inconvenience them or ko them

[@BaldorfBreakdowns]

He burned the Fishman he fought to death.

[@symphomaniac]

​@BaldorfBreakdowns it's not confirmed that Choo died.

[@BaldorfBreakdowns]

@@symphomaniac Choo was cooked more thoroughly than Ace.

[@symphomaniac]

@@BaldorfBreakdowns Hey Pell showed up to his own grave after tanking a nuke.

[@IllusiveMindsHD]

Let’s not forget when they dropped all those people to their deaths in enies lobby 😂

[@leyte68]

Oh right, the bridge of hesitation, maybe some of em’ can swim as the whirlpools are gone(someone prove me wrong)!!!

[@BlackLegNami]

Not to mention those whirlpools were specifically caused by Sanji. That said, based on the logic used in the video we can’t assume those Marines all actually drowned.

[@promiseland6920]

They have gone to the Laugh tale probably)

[@AfroX-StayLegendary]

Zoro with the Fishmen could’ve been him using the back of his blades, which he does quite often when he doesn’t want to fully kill someone, which leaves you on the floor extremely beat up. Hatchan could have just thought they were dead and overreacted.

[@AadheeshGoyal]

But mr7 my guy

[@Deveshkha]

"Nobody dies in one piece except for when they do" "They're never killed by our innocent protagonists except for when they are" 😂

[@thomasdahlberg5920]

I think Robin definitely killed the chief guy on Skypiea. The guy had like 10 axe dials on his sash and she flipped them around on him. I also don't think we see him again.

[@BRINKS400]

Yes i just commented mentioning Black Maria but definitely forgot about that guy. Him too!

[@dark7element]

I think the strongest evidence Robin killed Yama is that she specifically says she won't spare him before she does it.

[@miers2002]

i feel like robins killed anyone who heard her say "clutch" 😭😭 like bro you cannot survive with ur neck on the wrong side 😭

[@FatBadgerStudios]

Nami fired the buggy canon after zoro flips it... Considering its power i am 100p sure some of the clows kicked it.

[@mohamadnasser7070]

And if I didn't remember wrong wasn't the money she collected to buy the freedom of village covered in the blood of people she steal it from in the anime so I do think it's fair to say she killed more people than said in the video

[@Khaisz.]

Lawyer: Judge, My 3 Clients may have killed people, but it wasn't canon to the Mangaverse, so they should be free to go. Judge: I see nothing wrong with that logic.

[@rexlumontad5644]

Luffy spares his enemies because he see it more fitting they live to see their dreams crash and burn after he beat them.

[@EA-pc3ek]

I’ll never forgot that one part in Eneis lobby where luffy threw like 50 marines off the island

[@noctonistis]

12:32 Isn't that just Observation Haki? If I remember correctly, both the girl from Skypiea and Koby described Observation Haki as hearing other people like voices, and those voices vanishig when they die.

[@midas7719]

But momo shouldn’t be able to use observation at least not controllably

[@chiefdenis]

Observation is also known as the voice of all things or mantra

[@bigboloroger5001]

@@chiefdenisobservation haki isnt the voice of all things, otherwise rayleigh wouldve heard the sea kings talking when we flashback to rogers adventure to fishman island, only oden and roger had the voice of all things, allowing them to hear the sea kings (rayleigh who confirmed has observation haki couldnt hear them)

[@chiefdenis]

@@bigboloroger5001 i remember seeing it explained somewhere as advanced observation haki, I'll have to look for that

[@rexlumontad5644]

9:29 Nami knocked Eric the Whirlwind into the sea and the latter is a Sickle-Sickle Fruit user. He drowned and his Devil Fruit goes into circulation to another fruit for someone else to eat and gain its power.

[@sophykeosuncheng5952]

That was a filler character in a filler arc

[@johnyshadow]

@@sophykeosuncheng5952 Still dead tho.

[@dark7element]

The cherry on top is that Nami specifically says "Don't forget, he can't swim. That motherfucker is dead, lmao" right after she does it

[@seththornton9968]

I feel like the whole section of Marines in Enies Lobbies are just straight up gone lmao.

[@saucekay6793]

7:28 “yes she admitted to it” The judge: “yea sorry fam that’s not enough evidence to convict her”🤣🤣

[@BigFootFan64]

When the strawhats got seperated by Kuma And Robin went to that jail (can’t exactly remember the story)when she was escaping lots of guards tried to kill Robin,she then snapped their necks and they all fell to the ground immediately,I’m pretty sure she killed them

[@meenalmishra1804]

Spandam survived

[@Lothiril]

Spandam survived it, and it's only shown in the anime, isn't it?

[@dogf421]

a person can actually survive having their neck snapped depending on how its done, but its definitely not an injury you would want. its also actually a really bad and fucked up way to die because it doesn't actually kill instantly, you asphyxiate over several minutes while being unable to move your body, likely conscious for at least half of it

[@Cipher_Paul]

​@@meenalmishra1804 Spandam survived having his *back* broken, not his neck

[@cassiusfelix2805]

Dam that's violent

[@rexlumontad5644]

Straw Hats: "We do not kill people." Also Straw Hats: *kills a lot of mooks, be they Marines and other pirates*

[@rfreixo815]

Conclusion: mooks are not people.

[@Pillarofcreation1]

I think Law was just using sensory Haki similar to the type Koby awakened to at marineford, as it lets you sense people's locations and even mental states.

[@stellaviewer9849]

I think Luffy might have killed Arlong. When Luffy turned Arlong park to rubble, who got up? Not Arlong. After that, we never see Arlong again until Fishman Island, but that doesn't count since he was only in a flashback. Luffy even goes to Impel Down where the Marines would have possibly locked him up but no. Arlong is also absent during the Impel Down arc.

[@TB11484]

Not to mention 1 hit K.Oing a Celestial Dragon by punching him in the face

[@darkblack3320]

He was said to be captured and put on impel down as said by hachi and hordy in fishman island implying he is alive and with his absence in the arc he was probably in level 3 as what would be more torturous to a fishman than to go into a desert devoid of water and he really wasn’t strong enough to be deeper if he didn’t get executed by someone like shiryu

[@stellaviewer9849]

@@TB11484 The Celestial Dragon punch doesn't count as a death because he reappears in Mary Geoise during the Reverie arc.

[@stellaviewer9849]

@@darkblack3320 Thanks for sharing that bit of context. Saves me the trouble of REWATCHING THE ENTIRE ANIME just to find one or two lines of dialogue to prove or disprove a point.

[@RaptorGeorges]

@@darkblack3320 IIRC, it is specifically stated (maybe in a SBS) that he was NOT sent to Impel Down but another Marine prison, perhaps due to the agreement they had with Jimbei back when they first liberated Arlong.

[@DoubleDragon-ks2hk]

One thing is for sure is that the straw hats especially luffy and zoro have body count in the thousands, you can not tell that the fodder marines and pirates survive their attacks and I am pretty sure each time zoro or luffy sink a ship at least the quarter of the crew drowns instantly

[@Doodlebug-lv2kx]

I ADORE the vids! They helped me through a tough time lately, so always a pleasure to see a new one!

[@FlorianNexuzZ]

❤❤ much love to you

[@Densuii]

Only in One Piece would you get a not guilty verdict because nobody saw a corpse, even though the victim got pushed into magma.

[@Jolfgard]

8:30 Ah yes, she holds a grudge against the guy who shot her mum in front of her when she was like 6 or something and who held her under his thumb using sheer force, while holding everyone Nami cared about as hostages. That she thinks about killing the dude clearly gives her the profile of a murderer.

[@cassiusfelix2805]

Considering how hard Luffy kicks and punches people I wouldn't be surprised if some of them died. Look at the battle field in Whole Cake Island that is a crime scene.

[@BaldorfBreakdowns]

I feel like Charlos would have died from Luffy's punch.

[@ThatRPGuywithtoomanyOCs]

Onigashima pancake too.

[@dragonninjaghostgirl7981]

0:23 True, The Luffy and the straw hats didn’t become pirates to become heroes and admits they are not heroes . But technically they are heroes well more like anti heroes. Almost like the guardians of the galaxy.

[@garnat7805]

Named characters always seem to survive but nameless marines/pirates is a life threatening occupation, feels like every character has a body count

[@reillycurran8508]

What's kind of dark is that Luffy's preference for leaving his targets alive doesn't come from any moral sense of the value of life, it's because he wants them to have to live with the humiliation of knowing they got they asses beat

[@tess4940]

Chopper drove a man to commit suicide, he’s getting some jail time of his own.

[@tureytayno3154]

I remember how Usop convinced that ghost lady that he was going to kill her. She almost had a heart attack.

[@sonicducktheinoccent]

Wait didn't chopper poison Hiryluk? And did the battle framky fleet kill anyone, because that's like 2nd degree murder

[@Compucles]

Hiriluk killed himself before Chopper's poison could do it, plus he was already terminally ill in the first place. That's why Hiriluk didn't mind taking Chopper's poison "medicine" in the first place.

[@codafett]

One thing I've always wanted in One Piece is a scene of the Straw Hats randomly attacking a civillian vessel and stealing all their stuff. Then if they're ever confronted about it, Luffy just shrugs and says they're pirates.

[@m1bl4n]

"No more people, but a few fish people" Man either didn't read Fishman Island or is part of the World Government

[@brandondallon6203]

Chopper murdered Dr. Hiruluk. Though it was accedential and Dr. Hiruluk knew he was being poisoned.

[@BlackLegVinesmokeSanji]

But chopper didn't kill Dr Hiruluk Dr Hiruluk eat the mushroom then took his own life

[@d370ur]

Luffy murdered that man that spilled the bean soup. If he didn’t die immediately, he definitely died from the brain injuries

[@LowellLucasJr.]

Chopper may not have the highest kill count...but he DID kill a doctor! That fiend!!!!😂

[@dark7element]

Pretty sure the nitroglycerin he drank killed him

[@quanti5]

I'm quite shocked you didn't mention Gasparde in Dead End Adventure. Being basookaed (I guess that's a word) off of a sinking ship into an ocean cyclone as a devil fruit user can be reasonably assumed to be a death sentence. Yeah, yeah, non canon and stuff, but Oda should seriously throw Shuraiya and Adele in a cover story because they're great and deserve canonicity.

[@WatanukiProductions]

In terms of canonizing the non-canon all I want is for Jonathan and a few other G-8 characters to appear in canon. (Though it's been nice having Jonathan show up in the movies.

[@quanti5]

Yeah, when The One Piece reanimation makes it that far, they should just include G8 and make it canon.@@WatanukiProductions

[@HubiKoshi]

Luffy is almost Sadistic with this because it's not that he doesn't kill out of mercy. No, he doesn't kill so the villains can comprehend and experience what's it like when your dreams and ambitions get crushed. Like that's almost more cruel than just killing them.

[@Klaudiuszeg]

What about that guy in wano on onigashima, who spilled the soup and got PANCAKED by luffy into the ground? Nobody could sruvive it.

[@Jonathon-z7d]

I’d say the worst damage robin has ever done with her clutch attack is when she grabbed Franky’s Yknow

[@rexlumontad5644]

It's easy to forget that Nico Robin had been lethal with her enemies by a simple Clutch on their necks and spines. And the plot go out of its way to ensure Robin doesn't instantly defeat the major enemy on spot.

[@Lectrikfro]

Nico Robin is totally just rotating people's necks 90 degrees until they fall asleep, right?

[@Lectrikfro]

@j.b.5422 Ep 455 of the anime was not a flash back. She was holding the them at chin and temple, heads tilted 45 degrees one direction and then to 90 degrees the other way with a lovely crunching sound effect. then everyone decides to take a nap

[@dark7element]

Which gets weird in the lighthearted G8 Naval Fortress arc, when Robin does it to a bunch of marines there, when the whole thing about that arc is that all the marines there are genuinely good guys and it's supposed to be a happy ending for everyone. Johnathan was even going to let Robin go, which I can't imagine he would have done if she had killed like 20 of his men.

[@hdofu]

4kids:"No one dies... they go away, get sick, or are locked in dungeons forever.... Heck even Gol.D Roger is still 'hangin around the gallows'"

[@garnat7805]

Unfortunately I forget the anime arc, but there is a single line that always stuck with me where the marines are making a report on the crews attack and over a snail say there have already been 2000 casualties

[@GohanTweaking]

Dress rosa?

[@Eldritchinator]

Let's not forget that "WAHOO" was Luffy's reaction to thinking he had killed Don Krieg

[@Yoxiv]

Zoro drawing an arrow aimed at the body? Unlikely. He would somehow wind up on the roof of the building he and Mr. 7 were in, paint the arrow in the wrong direction, then leave the confession note/message on the walls of a house halfway across the island they were both on

[@aevnmanoftru5508]

Every time Robin said "clutch".... She killed someone. That shit brutal 😂

[@lorddarkrai5753]

Love that video , you reminded me of episode 61 before the crew entered the Grand Line where Nami casually drowned Eric Da Whirlwind.

[@jamesm8516]

Remember when luffy completely flattened a beast pirate with gear 3 for spilling red bean soup?

[@SilverScribe85]

I wouldn't consider Luffy taking down Kaido as murder. Yes, he stated SEVERAL TIMES within the Wano Arc that he had every intention of beating down the murderous king. But that's just it...Kaido is a tyrant and when you kill a tyrant, you're basically doing a nation a public service

[@cameronboop1044]

Skipping over the spilling/wasting of red bean soup at the raid of onigashima is crazy, he flattened the dudes skull (anime)

[@DunalGamage-vd9rw]

Well they are 'Pirates' afterall...🗿🤷‍♂️

[@calmuellerWAR]

I always felt like for the most part, the Straw Hats are adventurers that have a conscience with a pirate ship rather than pirates. But King of the Pirates just sounds too damn cool

[@ShaggyDabbyDank]

In regards to crocodile being able to see the failure at whisky peak and kills them all then lies to his subordinate about it, that definitely feels like a reach to justify zoro not actually killing that many people. And it works the same way on the claim that he 'killed' mr 7. Since the wording is vague like 'dealt with' and 'took him out' it's very reasonable that Zoro didn't kill him but instead captured him and handed him over to the marines for the bounty.

[@DaityaGod]

Well it is written by biggest coward writer I can see him pulling bullshit like this after all he forgot the damage Sakazuki caused to Kuma Death is joke in OP more than in DB at least there is plot reason for character not dying Here everytime it's fake out It's like he wants to kill character but is spineless coward to not complete the process As time continue this shit gonna ruin series

[@Meatyysloth3463]

Buggy is gonna kill everyone and become the Pirate god

[@rexlumontad5644]

Zoro the Minority Hunter can't keep getting away from it!

[@bigtony7049]

Luffy doesn’t kill his enemies he only makes them suffer while their dreams gets crushed it’s been stated by Oda

[@Borsalino_538]

Nah Luffy and Nami killed a lot Nami with her Lightning powers. And luffy just punching😂😂😂

[@kingkelz215]

It's not hard to imagine someone surviving a broken back. What is hard to imagine is countless Marines only one power level above that of the guy with the broken back surviving their necks being snapped.

[@riduanaqil1452]

For translation issues, I usually go to the channel Dawn & Dusk for clarification since im pretty sure she is a native japanese speaker

[@talesofgore9424]

is she cute

[@Dopeguy420]

She's a he.

[@t.kersten7695]

this is only based on the Anime, but while watching the scenes i´d assumed that Nico Robin "minecrafted" Black Maria; not just being the fearsome chiropractor she usually is but ripping that spider to shreds.

[@Kiumon-gn6em]

Magma is a (viscous) liquid and Kaido is a devil fruit user so unless a vulcanic eruption or something like that shot him out of there he drowned.

[@owenblount7334]

It’s also fucking magma incredibly hot molten rock

[@dogf421]

i have a head canon that if a goon is punched by luffy and you dont explicitly see them get back up later, they are probably dead

[@PurpleLionRs]

Some fodder "deaths" are questionable. Like i questioned some of those people zoro cut or when robin snaps necks. I always thought the fodder got back up to live another day. That was until impel down. Luffy knocked a bunch of people into the lava. Theres no way they survived that.

[@bloodkinglegacy]

The beggining: People dont die, unless they do

[@JDeTruph]

Kill wise, I would say at the most Zoro, Luffy, and Robin killed at least 1 person. When it comes to Zoro, even if you change the translations, zoro did kill people in his bounty hunter days outside Mr. 7 but in Wano I do believe he was killing some of the people who arrested him after he slashed the Magistrate guy. Robin does have some bodies as Ms. All Sunday for the 4 years, she worked with Baroque works until she met the strawhats. The thing about Luffy is that ya pulled people willingly into lava and they didn't get out.

[@shutyostupidahhup9143]

No Luffy has killed multiple beast pirates with gear 3 and thousands of people in impel down

[@Ussop_the_GOAT]

For luffy that’s not canon.

[@nackle_k]

Another thing with Zoro is the fact that he explicitly states that part of a swordsman's control comes from cutting with the blade only when the user desires it. Often we see Zoro take people out without killing them and that's what I believe happened on whiskey peak as well, where he stated this.

[@reyrey0009]

Didn't Robin kill that one huge guy during Sky Island? Sent him off a cliff edge, falling to his doom and just for kicks used clutch on him and we hear an audible crack and never see him again... but I guess we don't know for sure? But surely she would have done some assassinations for Crocodile to be high enough in the ranks of his organisation. Pretty sure of them all Zoro is the one making kills as cutting is just agreeably more deadly than punching and such. At the very least Zoro has left people to bleed out and considering this can be douzens of Marines, can every single one get medical attention in time? Especially that bleeding out has been issue or at least a plot device during Fishman Island Arc.

[@dark7element]

Not only did he fall like 500 feet and land on his head after Robin used the clutch (and he was fat as fuck, half a ton at least) but Robin outright said she wasn't going to spare him before she did it.

[@zetsevs]

with robin I just imagine its that fucked up scene in invisible "go ahead and kill me!" "oh no I never wanted to kill you" proceed to "mercifully" snap the vertebra just low enough to leave them fully paralyzed

[@WrldFlugence]

The bloody arrow should have been pointing away from Mr.7.

[@TyBeyonce8]

i'd like to mention that luffy punched enel so hard that he had to restart his own heart using his lightning devil fruit, so technically luffy killed enel during skypiea.

[@fightingmedialounge519]

When it comes to nami an interesting line to think about is zoro claiming he didn't think she had it in her to kill. On one hand this was early in the series and he acknowledges he could be worng, yet several scenes dod show she doesn't really enjoy the act.

[@cartoonishidealism582]

GrandLineReview, at some point you gotta do a video all about Simon and the Simon pirates

[@n1hondude]

I think we should all accept a few things: 1) important characters don't die, if it looks like they died, the question we should be asking ourselves is not "did they die?" but "HOW they survived?". 2) whether they're canon or not, background fodder are dead if it looks like they're dead

[@plzhelpireallyneedabettern4065]

Ace 😥

[@_General_Grievous__]

Didn’t Zoro kill like 20 people in Wano with that tiny knife😂

[@064razor]

Are we gonna gloss over the fact Sanji brutally killed the Unluckies, literally splattering them against the walls?

[@Uehahahara]

I have a friend that always have an over reaction when I say that Kaido’s and Big Mom’s deaths are not confirmed. Glad to see I’m not the only one to think that way.

[@owenblount7334]

They fell in magma yeah I’m gonna be real with you they’re most likely actually dead

[@nightmare348]

They got sucked into a magma pit, I'm pretty sure even they became crispy bacon by this point.

[@sephikong8323]

Maybe they could have survived if they were 100% full health, maybe, but they were not, they were both exhausted and took a substantial amount of damage prior. I would find it extremely unlikely they survived, and the Volcano erupting imo is just the way of announcing that they died

[@RedXlV]

Since they're both known to have ludicrously superhuman durability even by One Piece standards, it's not confirmed yet. But they're probably dead.

[@anubis4032]

No body no death

[@Babbleplay]

So, one of the crew with zero accusations of killing is.... their sniper.

[@zeliascrowe]

Correct me if im wrong but i thought Robin killed Black Maria in wano😅

[@rachel_v_k]

I don't think Luffy had fully died. 😵 Otherwise, his devil fruit 🍎 would have been respawned. But, when Luffy is revived, he still has his devil fruit powers -- and more! A person's heartbeat, or even brain activity, can stop, after which the can be revived with no consequences to his health. There have been some amazing cases of people even waking up just as the autopsy is about to begin! 😮👀😢

[@hirudinaria]

They're not above murder and murder is not beneath them. They are firmly and deeply underneath murder and murder is above them 😂😂