Had Modi Acted, 13 Million Cases, 1 Lakh Deaths Could’ve Been Averted in 2nd Wave-Bhramar Mukherjee

[@TheWireNews]

Join The Wire's KZbin Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. kzbin.info/door/hWtJey46brNr7qHQpN6KLQjoin

[@pranabkr.bhattacharjee6729]

I am amazed at my advanced age to see how brilliant Karan Thapar sir is. He has in-depth knowledge of every subject. He listens to his interviewee so keenly and retells the viewers so clearly . Simply wonderful to hear such programmes. Very enlighening. Thank you Wire thank you Karan Thaparji and those experts. Must watch and a Treat for us .

[@nishantnimish7825]

Is he aware that health comes under state and not federal

[@anshulkawatra]

@Best Hope andhbhakt have passed covid, even if some of them have lost their family members to covid they don't care .,...all they care about is supreme leader ...it was nature's way of testing there gullibles and they are true slaves ..👍

[@bazlur-Vancouver]

He has a degree in Economics and Political Philosophy(Cambridge) and a doctorate in International Relations (Oxford). so he doesn't hold a bogus certificate from Noname universities.. Most Indian politicians are from the dark age and illiterate or half-literate and were goons in their young ages.

[@siddharthmanumusic]

One of the best in the world today.

[@deekay5992]

O God! His mind works just sooooo fast & he's so thorough in presenting an analytical & comprehensive interview every time. Treat to watch!

[@saamarthyadav8674]

A timely lockdown would have saved 98% people from dying. This hits hard when you have lost 2 of your family members.

[@ytadltspv]

if u've lost ur famly mbrs due to this, so sorry for ur loss. we all grieve for the laks of lives lost for the most atrocious reasons-lack of infra and decades of system failures catching up. most of us got a very faint idea of the impending doom when our own fly mbrs got affected but thankfully, survived. our lives will never be the same. but not so for prev govts or modi and his imbeciles. they dont care.

[@anshulkawatra]

@@ytadltspv Fake, Feku, Fekuism . This is new India for you . Sorry this is Bhaktland

[@Sarthakkumarpal]

This is a clear case of government and all its apparatus conniving to commit a criminal negligence.

[@tusharpotdar5762]

All bhakta, modi lover bashing & blaming kerala, but they don't understand that kerala is doing more testing, and also reporting honestly that's why kerala covid number look large, on the other side state like UP & HP are carrying less number of test and manage to report low number of covid cases. And people in that state are in fool's paradise

[@DT-mp2gf]

And that basta*d yogi Adityanath has the audacity to say UP did a good job in controlling covid.

[@parakkalashokn]

I truly agree. But I must add that kerala is equally responsible for the deaths and cases that happened since March of 2021 just like other governments.

[@faisalahmadi9118]

She doesn't has much to say on Sonar Bengal misrule. Typical Bengali!!!!! Bengal me they are silent Bahar me violently intellectual. Courtesy TMC and Leftists Gunda। Maar maar ke bengal me bhusa bhar dega।

[@sterlingtech2714]

Kerala testing rate is actually lower then UP,I can’t recall full numbers but I believe Kerala stands at 50000 And UP at 3 lakh

[@faisalahmadi9118]

@@sterlingtech2714 I have seen leftist misrule in Bengal. No one can beat leftist in misrule plus hiding thier blunders in well orchestrated manners by thier comrade.

[@snigdho642]

This show has 45K views, honey Singh songs have more than million views.. this is how our people prioritize..

[@fsckool6894]

So does everywhere...

[@rk95]

Bjp and accountability, expect more from them. Pegasus

[@nishantnimish7825]

Health is a state subject. Now tell me which state performed worst

[@anshulkawatra]

@@nishantnimish7825 Everyone knows UP

[@gurnekbariana2802]

I. Wish this could be aired on Godi media. With anjana om ksshyap . That’s a wild dream 😴

[@Saukingalpha]

Lol wire the liar is best media as per you??😂

[@shivprakash6427]

@@Saukingalpha lol thousand time better than godis

[@itsaashish]

The problem is Modi doesn't care for anyone. Time to throw out BJP.

[@nalinthakar7059]

He is not interested in hearing the voice of conscience; but more attuned to voices of CON-science.

[@rogerwalter2500]

@@nalinthakar7059 what a COiNcidence, he heads science and technology department too

[@Saukingalpha]

What bullshit from a Dr? Most cases were from Maharashtra and kerala..u don't say bollywood CM and commie CM doesn't care for anyone. How the hell are you a bloody doctor?

[@Alex-yr3zu]

Saukingalpha watch the recent interview with Dr Gangdeep ,she said Kerala model is the best.

[@nalinthakar7059]

@@Alex-yr3zu sir, you can not teach Logic & reason to WhatsApp university graduates. Dr Gagandeep Kang has very lucidly explained. Incidence of COVID in a community is very difficult to control. In terms of response of the administration, Kerala beats all other states.

[@gurindersingh8109]

Prof Bhramar understands her subject very well and also radiates that scholarly streak of confidence of her discovery. Karan as usual has that air of calm, incisive and analytical scholar. Thank you Karan.

[@somnathghosal6954]

Sardar ji what is the issue in discussing Jab chiraya choog geyi khet?

[@gurindersingh8109]

@@somnathghosal6954 Be on guard , third wave could arrive and hurt us bad again.

[@somnathghosal6954]

@@gurindersingh8109 l lost my father due to covid 19. He and my whole family maintained covid norms. But, unfortunately he got the infection from the indifferent crowd and lost his life. People are behaving same after the 2nd wave and that may be reason behind the precursor of 3rd wave. I know that you are a sensible person but, l just made a satirical remark.

[@subhasisghosh66]

When are you going to Afghanistan O Brave One? Why are you hiding?

[@kevincastelino3209]

The fact is eventually each and every person will be infected with the virus at some stage. Hence to be vaccinated is the best chance we are giving our immune system to fight. How the body and psyche fights is probably roll of dice. Elon Musk says he won't take vaccine because he is not in high risk category. Can't comprehend his argument.

[@jobytalk]

This answers Why Kerala gov gave monthly food kits to all Keralites not just BPL families...

[@thesaint9286]

Maharastra with a population of 15 crores does 30,000 tests, UP with a population of 25 crores does about 8000 tests a day and Kerala with a population of 3.5 crores does about 2 lakh tests per day. Which state government cares for its people????

[@Bella-nj5ys]

This is such a revelation and so distressing!

[@amitabuch]

She's being decent enough to generalize things

[@akz2251]

Brilliant interview

[@NilotpalBhattacharyya]

Great interview and share of knowledge. Thank you.

[@easyeconomicsprofsubhashini]

It's a treat to watch such an ace interviewer and a professor working in the field of data .such a lot of information being shared .

[@samueljoseph2821]

The government can take so many positive guidelines from this interview. This interview is really fantastic. Great salute to both of you participants.👃👃

[@prabharao1950]

Individuals need to take responsibility and follow covid appropriate guidelines. State Governments in India wanted powers about lock down.

[@cbvinod]

Prof. Bhramar has responded very professionally to the provocative questions

[@errolgonsalves8850]

Pray that this discussion reach the people advicing the Central and State government be seriously considered in view of the 3rd wave hitting the country by end August.

[@sivaramanmudaliar9728]

Under disaster management act the principal responsibility i that of the union government

[@AMUabdullah]

She's marvellous in her thoughts. Why these experts go to USA. Just brilliant. Extremely crystal clear thought delivery. No bakwas any seconds.

[@AMUabdullah]

I'm going to find her email and send a thankyou note.

[@sonusingh-zr6xw]

Thank you Mr. Karan Thapar. Karan Thapar is the youngest child of former Indian Chief of the Army Staff General Pran Nath Thapar. He has made his father proud. There is another journalist who also a son of an indian army officer but has made his father embarrased. His name is Arnab Goswami.

[@prayas420]

Such a disgrace that chief of army staff has a traitor born in his house.. his soul will be so disturbed to know his son is sold prestitute.

[@sonusingh-zr6xw]

@@prayas420 Alfred Tennyson, English poet was born today on 6th August 1809. He is the second most frequently quoted writer in The Oxford Dictionary of Quotations, (after Shakespeare). Tennyson wrote a number of phrases that have become commonplaces of the English language, including "Better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all", and "Theirs not to reason why, theirs but to do and die". Happy Sir Alfred Tennyson Day to you.

[@PS0-y4x]

Very informative and accurate analysis of what we are facing - Professor Mukerjee and Karan I look forward to hearing from you both in coming days.

[@tusharpotdar5762]

Karan Thapar #karanthapar is the best, always. #thewire very nice

[@mathewkl9011]

Very interesting and useful information Madom. Excellent interview🙏

[@biswadipde3413]

Excellent interview, A lot of things to learn. Thanks.

[@gopinathnambiar9707]

Great Privilege to hear from BM.

[@utshachatterjee2366]

I was waiting for this interview... ❤️

[@mary-rj3df]

A brilliant and amazing interview Sir thank you🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@innayyareddy9926]

This discussion to be translated into all languages such that people all over the country get the reality of the problem and who are responsible for all this.

[@anuragdandekar6064]

People not wearing masks and not following social distancing rules is govt responsibility.. slow claps to your logic

[@Saukingalpha]

Hello dumbo, people in Kerala and maharastra ans govt should read this..

[@bazlur-Vancouver]

@@anuragdandekar6064 if you fine or punish them, they will do and deny them to shop or ride transport or going somewhere without masks. everything will be ok. The mask and distancing problem in most of the countries. Where the people most disciplined suffered less death and cases. example: Vietnam, Taiwan, even China.

[@yoginion]

Such an informative & insightful interview.

[@madhavam3207]

Critically analysed...Very thoughtful interview...🙏🙏

[@asathyamurthy2481]

Modi govt is not keen on vaccinating people fast enough maybe because this way people are prevented from organizing mass protests against his bad rule. It is too much to expect him to remember that fast mass production of vaccines in India is cheaper than hospitalization because of infection. Learning lessons from the past is the last thing the Modi govt will do.

[@RajuGogul]

A non-listening attitude can never afford the luxury of learning and become wise, alas!

[@sumansaha2151]

As always superb interview 👍👍👍

[@ARUNSANKER]

I don't know how a data analyst can predict or suggest a solution without the availability of a true data😐 Apart from the state of Kerala, I am afraid of the available data. That's actually scary when you talk about the third wave! I think India remains a time bomb, as it is so unpredictable due to the lack of true data

[@Spinko7128]

Yup everyone is lying world over

[@raviadireddy505]

Brilliant interview with data analysis by professor mukarji on covid 19 issue . Thanks to Karan for hosting the interview with her.

[@jobytalk]

Exceptional interview...

[@rogerwalter2500]

One death is a tragedy, a million deaths a statistic- Stalin

[@npd9758]

Are you quoting Stalin, who by the way committed massacres which were worse than Holocaust.

[@rogerwalter2500]

@@npd9758 the statement is valid, even if it was made by any other personality, if not Stalin. People quote Churchill too , infamous for Bengal famine which killed way more people than Jews during holocaust.

[@npd9758]

@@rogerwalter2500 The statement is valid when the actions of a perpetrator like Stalin is taken into consideration as well. Churchill was always anti- India whom he considered them as 2nd class citizen. But the collective no of massacred people were more than the combined number of Holocaust or Bengal famine

[@rogerwalter2500]

@@npd9758 no death toll which is on a massive scale is expressed in exact numbers eg 5,987,452 deaths (in words = five million nine hundred eighty-seven thousand four hundred fifty-two deaths ) instead it's conveniently rounded off as 6 millions deaths , robbing off the dignity of any individual's tragic loss of life . Which brings us back to our current discussion, .... A million is a statistics

[@npd9758]

@@rogerwalter2500 And the communists are expert at hiding them.

[@padmashankar5571]

Very informative interview. Thanks.

[@jomat6151]

I'm karanataka, here all local shops, the people are not putting masks. It's very difficult to tell these uneducated people to wear masks. They just ignore on hearing this. It's really terrible to see people without masks. I'm thinking, third wave will be too sooner.

[@shivamanand3908]

IDK, I got worried when she said she's currently in India. Yaha gadi kabhi bhi palat jaati hai.

[@paulnk968]

A very valid and judicious discussion, highly informative and knowledgeable.

[@harshas7265]

Love the discussion

[@jmodi8087]

Kerala is the favorite state the SANGHIS target.

[@likithstochastic]

"In order to model this pandemic accurately, you really need four components. The transmission process, The viral mutation process, The human behaviour process and The policy interventions. So it is really a string quartet".

[@ramaswamysavadaya1790]

A wonderful interview with professor. Blunder falls on the Centre in terms of governance. Scientists and Medical advices must be heard by the Govt. in true spirit. Govt. must own its responsibities against deaths caused in the past as well as wide spread in cases .

[@vksharma7956]

With known renowned face, introduced by Mr Karan Thapar himself, as guest scientist, viewers must have been inquisitively expecting more valuable revelations and course correction on the past experiences and future probabilities about Corona Pandemic which is wholly justified. When comes to reality, Mr Karan Thapar like his outspoken guests doesn't hesitate to raise finger against anybody or authority howsoever big.

[@bhushanwagle5098]

This is a revelation and a slap in the face of all those bhakt?₹ds and Hindutvawaadi 'scientists' trying to belittle Kerala all the time

[@JavedAnsari-vt8yf]

Very nice show Thanks for both of you

[@akshat9731]

An amazing interview. I love the professionalism

[@wendyv8497]

"Had Modi taken timely action" would suit the subject better rather than "Had Modi acted ......" since he is always acting only! He was on stage busy hooting "Didi...... Oh Didi!"

[@happygolucky4350]

Thanks for this discussion. Could you add the reference to the papers you discussed in your description?

[@Matkartik-yz4vs]

Had states also acted this disaster could have been prevented. Don't just blame one person. It's a collective short coming including of the general population who were out partying and had forgotten all precautions. Just like now

[@riteshkumar2686]

Very informative discussion

[@satishnarayan4992]

Its a tragedy...that the same sets of ppl who had lost their loved ones would defy all logic and rationality during elections and vote of the same leaders in the name of caste & religion...sad but this is the truth...we live in today, dont learn from the past & dont plan for the future.All that our leaders care about is how to win the next election through any means. And more than our parents & family, we cult workship these leaders & blindly follow & believe what they say without ever questioning whether it makes sense.

[@ankitranjan5755]

Will of the people is never wrong bro....... N we cant say that same set of politicians are always reelected otherwise we could not have different parties rulling us in these 70 years....people who were voting congress earlier have themselves elected other parties now.... So its not about caste n religion only .... Its mostly about same interests.... People very well know that .... somebody's bad performance in certain area ....... doesn't Make the other someone better... People always measures someone based on their aligned interests The more the number of interests getting fulfilled....more is the chance for the party.... So its more about better options n not only caste n religion If the party wants to be the next option for the nation or the state they have to show the potential by doing their best for the society even if they r not in the power..... by merely pointing out someone's lacking will not make them better option .... Opposition is already there for this .... N they being in opposition speaks all. So if people are voting bjp.... Its not the public or bjp lacks .... Its the other parties which lacks.

[@satishnarayan4992]

@@ankitranjan5755 when BJP was in opposition they had the media with them...their voices were heard...can you cross your heart & say the same about the media now.I watch all media channels & the level of reportage.The very same channels were sending reporters overseas to unravel congress scams such as Augusta westland etc...no one is doing that now...even if someone dares, the are out of the channel or cases ate slapped against them so they are intimidated & their peers are also intimidated.You may not agree that the juduciary is unbiased, sealed envelope , fast tracking of cases, casesbeing rostered to specific benches...Adani's cases going to one specific bench headed by Mr. Mishra...you know the outcome of all those cases..if not please make an attempt to find out...then about other institutions...least said the better...with all these backdrop...you still believe opposition lacks the spine or are not doing anything to inspire confidence in the people therefore ppl voting for bjp...well...there is fault with opposition but larger fault lies with ppl...Indians have mediocre expectations of their leaders...achieving prosperity is impossible therefore compromise on that...and happy with a temple or mosque or church. We need to change our mindset...try to dig out the truth with the media istrying to hide...question our leaders - congress or bjp or sp or bsp....hold them accountable.

[@lucianisaac2982]

Compulsory Vaccination, lockdowns etc, reminds one of the Compulsory Sterilization, illegal arrests of the Infamous Internal Emergency days. However the government should continue to give tax funded (wrongly named as free) vaccines to all Indian🇮🇳 citizens who Choose to take the vaccine voluntarily. Liberty, Freedom & Right to Choose is the essence of a Free Democracy and should be cherished above Life itself.

[@chenk2106]

Agree and I’d like to reiterate specifically on “tax funded” instead of “free”.

[@swapanmukherjee7978]

Very nicely reported madam. Thanks

[@yvonnepereira9249]

Please, please keep an eye on Goa too, as we are stuck between these big States and because of tourism we are having an influx from all States. Too scared to have to go through what happened in May again. Deaths are 3146.

[@suryaprakashcheppalli2052]

Excellent information and analysis 👌🏼👍

[@independentnationalist1740]

Had the govt acted ? Govt should have imposed the lock down at an earlier date . Yes , I agree. In Aurangabad Municipal Committee meeting , lock down was being discussed . After a stormy meeting it was decided that lock down will not be imposed. People took out a procession to celebrate the decision of not imposing the lock down . Professor Bhramar Mukherjee is staying in USA and knows nothing about Indian conduct . When the lock down was imposed - people were on streets without masks , for the purpose of seeing how lock down looks like .You tell some one to put on the mask , he is going to yell at you . This is our India and this is what we have made it out to be . Same guys when affected by COVID were the first to blame govt for apathy . With such irresponsible public , how do you expect that govt servants will be efficient when they also come from the same society . Simple solution - Blame each other . Now , is the time to take care - third wave is coming , each one is requested to take care because no body is going to help us . This battle can not be fought in hospitals.

[@rochenruyi6547]

Kumb mela and election escalate covid 19 in india

[@sushmitajha7615]

Excellent discussion

[@rkroy6267]

Karan sir, absolutely delighted thank you & many thanks to your guest. Exellent interview like always.

[@jmodi8087]

MOTA bhai response to this interview will be to revoke Prof Bhramer's OCI. This GOVT is very vindictive.

[@suffoftrading455]

Ye bandha Ek time me ,Feku chacha ko paani pilayata 😆😆😆😂😂😂

[@navintiwari112]

The State governments were well placed in authority to declare lockdowns in their states, as and when, and in whichever districts, towns or localities they wanted too... Did Dr. Mukherjee know this????? Let me summarise this whole interview for you: lovedei kei channel pei lovedei ka ptarakar lovedei kei expert sei charcha kar rha hai...

[@suffoftrading455]

@@navintiwari112 copy paste 😆😆😆😂😂2Rs ka answer 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍😂😂😂

[@ankitjha596]

Aur ab woh feku chacha is karan Thapar or iske poori jamaat ko paani pilaye huye hai. You must have read Thapar was even ready to apologise to Modi Post 2014 just to get access to him and his party.

[@sajalsen3624]

@@ankitjha596 jhoot bolne ka seema hoti haai

[@suffoftrading455]

@@ankitjha596 🐒🐒🐒🐒 feku chacha ki jai

[@barunmitra8778]

Hindsight is 2020! Dr Mukherjee acknowledges the number of uncertainties in the models, and most models around the world have failed to predict the progress of the pandemic. Yet, she goes on to project from her models based on the the number cases and deaths during the second wave, which could have been avoided if a moderate lockdown were imposed in India in mid-March 2021.

[@lalbobby]

Vastly underreported numbers ... The catastrophe is biggest in independent India after the great famine of Bengal during the British Raj Intentional genocide charges should be brought against the rulers

[@xarup]

Fascinating

[@senguptasayn]

While tv is impossible to watch. It's a blessing to have online platforms for civilized and informative conversations.Many thanks team Wire. As for accountability, well..by now all those NOT BLINDED by godi know exactly what to expect from this crew of pathological liars!

[@Pravasi-tm1tx]

In order to win the state elections Modi didn't listen to the scintists and went ahead with big rallies. At the and he couldn't win either the elections or save the country from a teriffic human trajedy ....

[@sklarik888]

Thaper sir, thank you for changing background from white to black. It looks fantastic now.

[@narayananramachandran533]

Karan you forgot oxygen drama and deaths because of that.

[@anilkumar-ks8zb]

There are no deaths due to oxygen crisis as per Govt.

[@MsEternalpeace]

Did you just say Drama? It was a nightmare for people to see their loved ones struggle to breath and suffocate into death right in front of their eyes. Please do not speak so casually of such a tragedy

[@thomasmathew8790]

Very realistic assessment and opinion

[@hhhooott]

No doubt Modi is responsible but were all the states converted into union territories. Aren't the Chief Ministers responsible too. What about those people who were fuelling vaccine hesitancy ?

[@navintiwari112]

The State governments were well placed in authority to declare lockdowns in their states, as and when, and in whichever districts, towns or localities they wanted too... Did Dr. Mukherjee know this????? Let me summarise this whole interview for you: lovedei kei channel pei lovedei ka ptarakar lovedei kei expert sei charcha kar rha hai...

[@ashutoshdevgire5591]

Vaccine hesitancy pe baat mat karo,nahi to lala Ramdev ko hi pehle jail me Jana padega

[@navintiwari112]

@@ashutoshdevgire5591 yaar vaccine hesitancy failane wale tumhare Pappu bhaiya aur Yadav bhaiya bhi hain.. Ramdev kei saath vo bhi nikal lenge.. 😂

[@cbvinod]

@@navintiwari112 lol

[@hhhooott]

@@ashutoshdevgire5591 Sir everyone who was spreading fake information regarding vaccines are responsible including Baba Ramdev. Even few BJP politicians were doing the same and not following CoVid appropriate behaviour. But we expect better from the non ruling parties and their top leaders.

[@hashack7243]

Kerela - no talk on why the surge in kerala ( allowing eid celebration) no discussion that positive rate is 12.5 percent in kerala in-spite of double the testing numbers of tests compared to the rest of the country in which case it should be much lower. No talking about terrible comments and actions by opposition governments. Only one narrative blame Modi. Shameful its not as if modi is clean but thappars single minded motive is to put all blame on the government . He wants to create a narrative.

[@piyalbandyopadhyay7012]

Absolutely right your observation s.Mr Thapar had exposed himself as a biased journalist

[@AshutoshKumar-wo3zr]

Karen excellent man

[@kiranshekar2744]

They acted in first wave promptly and enforced early lockdown .. seeing the responses to this from opposition and people ,they took a once bitten twice shy attitude during second wave and didn’t lock down -

[@sam83santy]

Will only your own death by COVID stop you from voluntarily apologising for a useless govt?

[@kweshuzolomakrishu7521]

We can see the Professor being rigourously bombarded with very critical questions and cause helplessness . Only the brave can face and answer Mr.Karan Thapar.

[@Subh8081]

Modi as much guilty as Mao.

[@avijitbandopadhyay6555]

The discussion did not bring out failure of Government in respect of vaccination.

[@sivaramanmudaliar9728]

Since Covid-19 was defeated in 21 days in March 2020 there is no need for vaccines -this is written in Charaka Samhita

[@amitabuch]

Karan, you should be asking these questions to the Indian Govt, not her

[@navintiwari112]

The State governments were well placed in authority to declare lockdowns in their states, as and when, and in whichever districts, towns or localities they wanted too... Did Dr. Mukherjee know this????? Let me summarise this whole interview for you: lovedei kei channel pei lovedei ka ptarakar lovedei kei expert sei charcha kar rha hai...

[@tusharpotdar5762]

Neither Modi or any of Government minister don't have courage to face an interview with karan Thapar & Ravish kumar, Once modi try to over smart, and run away for a glass of water.

[@tusharpotdar5762]

@@navintiwari112 when did Home minister given up this authority? There is NDMA is impose, Also don't you remember modi speech in all CM meet, "याद रहे लाॅकडाऊन आखरी विकल्प के रुप मे इस्तेमाल करना है" अगर तुम्हे याद ना हो तो video का link भेज दूं।

[@navintiwari112]

@@tusharpotdar5762 yaar Health ek State list subject hai... NDMA act kahin nahin manai karta state governments ko lockdown lagane sei... Dimwit, thora dimaag pei jor lagaoge to yaad aaega - UP, Delhi, Maharashtra, West Bengal and many other states imposed lockdown in varying measures during the second wave... Search karle agar bhool gaya ho to 🙏

[@sajalsen3624]

@@navintiwari112 same meaningless message you keep copying to post

[@muhammadishfaq6677]

As a Pakistani, I admire your show, the way you conduct show seems like India is first world country...but the fact is that your country general direction is ordinary like any other third world country...anchors like you are stranger...

[@jackripper5054]

Apologies there is no Urdu shows for you illiterates

[@ankitranjan5755]

I think we really are a 3rd world country n very well behaving like it......... But there is always a thing in my mind .... That failed states like syria south sudan Afghanistan n a liitle bettered conditioned pakistan are not even near to us in terms of social indices.... I mean we are world's pharmacy n the biggest vaccine producer in the world bt we have a prblm we have have very large population n we accept that..... Its really challenging bt is way better than the countries i mentioned above ...... So there must be a new category of countries like 4th world countries where countries like Pakistan can be kept Wt do u say.... Isn't it a good idea as these countries r nowhere near to INDIA.🙃

[@manojlds]

If Kerala is catching up to India, why can't it be the case that whatever Modi did, we would catch up to similar numbers anyway?

[@cauliflowerhead2735]

I am so glad we have channels like The WIRE. Such guests who get straight to the point would never be invited on national television. They want garrulous banshees.

[@manojchittayil3326]

well when we had a drastic lockdown in the 1st wave in March 2020 , the grouse was GDP shrinking , lack of jobs , migrants walking ,, if the choice is between lives and livelihood in a poor country of 1.5 billion like our where we were kept poor for 70 plus years , lives dont matter , livelihood is crucial , you and your ilk whose apple polishing to the dynasty continued unabated from the 90s till today , you need to introspect . We decided in 2014, 2019 , and will decide for the next 3 terms 2024 , 2029 and beyond . Much of these lives would have been saved if the opposition played a constructive role in dispelling vaccine myths , getting their states in order with oxygen etc

[@ShahidAli-vx4nl]

This is a very good discussion. The analytics of the scenario makes a lot of sense specially on the current scenario and the apparent ghost of third wave.

[@ShahidAli-vx4nl]

@@HouseOfOptimism India did get 4 lacs documented cases per day.

[@ShahidAli-vx4nl]

@@HouseOfOptimism Well, you know, i said 'documented' cases. But I admit the gap is huge.

[@ShahidAli-vx4nl]

@@HouseOfOptimism Thanks. I admit, You are right here completely.

[@selfaspire.selfaspire.2604]

Great 👍👏😊debate

[@sushmitajha7615]

A minor and friendly suggestion: your expression of keenness to ask the next question by extending your right hand into the screen can be very distracting

[@subhasisghosh66]

Shri Karan Thapar is of the firm opinion that he is the star of his interviews and other person is a mere prop.

[@cauliflowerhead2735]

He does that to pressurise the interviewees to keep answers short and succinct. This way hee can ask an many questions as possible within a short enough time frame to keep the interest of the viewers. But I agree, it's distracting and causes the interviewee to make haste.

[@akshat9731]

I totally agree. Even as a viewer, it was distracting.

[@manmohanyadav971]

It is easy to generalize after an event and blame game is the norm. This is the first time a pandamic of huge effects has appeared during this generation. The best virologists world wide did not have a clue on its origin and possible effects on human health in the long run. Vaccines was one answer but time was the essence to control it. Whatever steps taken then at start of pandemic were the best under the circumstances and known knowledge then. The rapid mutation of the virus strain could not be predicted but they were more aggressive in transmission. Indians love socializing, celebrating festivals, shopping in numbers and other group activities. Ideal situation for virus to transmit. Moreover the public health system is totally inadequate for the population. For instance all the public government hospitals in Dehli state were built by the British and Indians love giving new names of politicians to them. Dont know why state governments do not spend on providing health facilities. So the rapid spread of virus was inevitable and whatever strategies the Government had taken the end result would have been the same. All this stupid analysis after the event means little but just a political agenda.

[@DrKunwar]

Very nice show...

[@hiteshdesai2102]

“Right policies to heal”. Hope government is listening

[@cruise_control]

COVID is not a national subject, it is state subject. Vaccine Mythri is not national subject, it is a International subject.

[@01shamit]

She's cute! 😊💖

[@rakeshnirala842]

The wire should also make a video on increasing cases of corona in Kerala.

[@trulylogicalmind3645]

you have not watched the video , watch from 3.38

[@navintiwari112]

@@trulylogicalmind3645 The State governments were well placed in authority to declare lockdowns in their states, as and when, and in whichever districts, towns or localities they wanted too... Did Dr. Mukherjee know this????? Let me summarise this whole interview for you: lovedei kei channel pei lovedei ka ptarakar lovedei kei expert sei charcha kar rha hai...

[@ashutoshdevgire5591]

@@navintiwari112 when india was winning against Covid,it was because of centre,when India fail pathetically,it was due to states.hypocracy ki bhi seema hoti hai lovday

[@navintiwari112]

@@ashutoshdevgire5591 arey ab tukh jaise lovedei sei seekhna padega kya 🤣 chal kaam kar...

[@manojlds]

Which is this video. Watch the video first 🤦‍♂️

[@suffoftrading455]

Ghanta Farak padega bhakthoko 😃😃

[@navintiwari112]

The State governments were well placed in authority to declare lockdowns in their states, as and when, and in whichever districts, towns or localities they wanted too... Did Dr. Mukherjee know this????? Let me summarise this whole interview for you: lovedei kei channel pei lovedei ka ptarakar lovedei kei expert sei charcha kar rha hai...

[@navintiwari112]

Yaar jab kati patango ko Nobi kei pedophile hone sei farak nahin padta to Modi supporters ko kya hi padega...

[@suffoftrading455]

@@navintiwari112 2Rs ka answer 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍😂😂😂

[@ankitjha596]

Hahaha. Tumhari toh fati padi hai.

[@DT-mp2gf]

Subramanian Swamy bhi abhi bjp ki mar raha hain.

[@sharusami22]

Have you checked your phone for "the P word" sir?

[@MrVinayakthegreat]

Being anything in these times have been challenging 😪

[@siddharth0401]

Godi media can't get these types of interviews, there is no shoutings

[@parthapratimlala6751]

We are more concerned about "V" for vote & crazy behavior be at a crowded "v"accination centre or a religious event. Death is also a number ❕️❕️

[@Swaminath12345]

Respected sir karan, i expecting the same interview devil advocate and fire question we are waiting every peoples known your identified honesty.

[@deekay5992]

The heterogeneity of sero prevalence (between states, rural & urban areas) confounds matters further!