Her Dark Obsession that Led to Murder: Shirley Goodnight

[@BooksWithCarah]

This is one of the most horrifying cases I’ve ever heard. The obsession with Shirley is so eerie. I can’t imagine the fear she felt that night. Rest In Peace Shirley.

[@receescocopuffs]

same i usually don’t have trouble watching theese vids but damn

[@z95zzz]

such an awful and sad case :( she should've never been persuaded to drop those charges against marlene in the first place, irvine obviously did not have the situation under control :/

[@samih5916]

I was thinking the same thing.

[@yelhsasokolova8561]

Yeah, I was wondering how different things might have turned out if she had gone forward with pressing charges

[@graceyoung3771]

Wonder how many other things he covered for her?

[@chelscara]

Honestly. He straight up aided her in her murder and he should at least have a civil suit against him by the family. His “I can deal with it, grumble grumble I’m a man” and then just fucking leaves anyway. He was a cowardly asshole.

[@penskepc2374]

@@chelscara no, he didn't. Getting the police involved is almost always a mistake and besides it wouldn't of stopped her anyway.

[@brentmartin1981]

I laughed out loud when she was describing that brunch incident, can you imagine how awkward that would be to have been the waiter and having to go up to their table like, "Ummm, you're wife is over there in all black with her face behind a menu, and she is just staring you guys down creepily."

[@atomickitten4648]

How annoying, but I must think about how even weirder it get when he found out that she commented murder. 😲

[@KiranKlayPetrova]

@@atomickitten4648 OMG seriously, you know that waitress had to have chills knowing what transpired just a couple years after that, it’s too bizarre.

[@zoej1498]

o😊

[@yogirlmayoheyo1180]

I always prepare myself to sing along when she says “All things spooky scary SkElEtOnS” and feel weird when she doesn’t 👁👄👁

[@maninthebox3654]

same XD

[@juliabohemian]

I miss it

[@gabbyb9418]

It was fun but a little disrespectful to the victims of these stories. These aren't spooky and there are no funny dancing skeletons. The only accurate part is "scary". Hailey has moved from more conspiracy/paranormal centric videos to videos about real life crime. I believe the tonal shift is appropriate & it took some guts to completely 180 and shows how much she's grown in only what, like, a year? I respect it.

[@bobynn]

@@gabbyb9418 Thank you! I'm sick of all the comments about how they miss it :/ There's no room for jokes when it comes to the life of people. Huge props to Hailey!

[@leahbess4]

Well she used to do less murder videos and a lot were like conspiracy theories, so it was appropriate then and people from the beginning just miss the normal starts to her videos. I can understand that.

[@taylorellinger3995]

How sad…Shirley seemed like she lived such a compassionate loving life, and didn’t ever deserve this kinda shit. So devastating.

[@chloesmith9690]

How are private investigators legally allowed to stalk ppl like ??!

[@LaMishiMish]

I mean, they ARE investigating. You can't be caught when doing that kind of stuff. You can't tell me you would never hire one if you thought your significant other was cheating on you, cause no one is ever going to admit that they are unless they're caught in the act. It may sound wrong, but it IS their job. Besides it's not like they're doing it out of malicious intent, they're just there to see if any claims by their client is true. But I DO see where you are coming from, it is a lil unnerving to think of someone watching your every move to see if you're doing anything suspicious at all.

[@TailRotorMafia]

For the right price… anything is possible. Especially considering she had plenty of her inheritance money to blow. What an insecure wench.

[@onemillionpercent]

fr, like the drones ?! the DRONES and being able to give someone the information on every second of your schedule? like oh fucking god wtf imagine

[@strawberrycakeland]

I think they should have limits on the information they provide to clients. Smh.

[@strawberrycakeland]

@@LaMishiMishYeah, but all extra information they by give to clients is unnecessary. No reason that she should have known the times Shirley was alone, how far her garage door opened etc. Those details are pointless to the investigation itself.

[@nyreebaldwin1642]

Hey Hailey, this is my second attempt at trying to acknowledge this but could you perhaps try covering some Black and Brown cases?? Alonzo Brooks, Jelani Day, Kenneka Jenkins, just to name a few. We don't get a lot of coverage in the media so please don't forget about us too! I really enjoy your content, thank you!

[@kyiahloveshobi]

yesss i second this !!

[@waterloo5555]

she has done some black and brown cases. they’re from a while ago, but i agree there definitely should be more covered c:

[@jerzievap]

i definitely agree!

[@juinjones1080]

yes absolutely! Jelani Day was a student in my town and it's so heartbreaking that his case was just given up on, especially since it's so sketchy. All the families deserve the justice they deserve and I would love to see one my favorite content creators spread more awareness about these cases.

[@kyiahloveshobi]

@@juinjones1080 yes his case is truly heartbreaking :((( i hope he's resting peacefully 🤍

[@sharyebethancourt3660]

I really want Hailey’s confidence when she completely makes up a word. I need that in my day to day life. I can’t believe Marlene’s obsession! This was like a movie!

[@nicholasschoonbeck6866]

Its crazy that she was so on top of Shirley's life & never caught her husband there, & still believed it.

[@pizzaraccoon8202]

she sounds really mentally ill and paranoid, maybe if she’d been sent to a psychiatrist then shirley would still be here. it’s so incredibly sad

[@onemillionpercent]

complete fucking delusion, straight up mentally ill. insane

[@maameyaaadu-donkor4679]

Why would she kill the supposed woman her husband was having an affair with and still leave her husband. She could have just left the marriage if she felt he was cheating

[@beautyguru4you1]

Jealousy is a powerful thing

[@editzmadebyme2967]

are you planning to do more conspiracy theories soon? they were amazing!! but i love all your vids, keep up the great work

[@jameeselah9728]

I miss her makeup videos

[@saintessa]

@@jameeselah9728 maybe she could do 1 for nostalgia of the good 'ol days

[@astralyns]

@@jameeselah9728 sameee

[@graceyoung3771]

Never heard of this one. I'm curious to know if the murderer ever had an MRI when her obsession began since her husband claimed she was never like that before. Perhaps she could of had a brain injury, sometimes even small ones can make a profound difference, or maybe she might have a brain tumor that has contributed to her behavior. Something provoked a strong reaction of jealousy in her when before there was none or else he was covering up for her like he did when she attacked the victim in the parking lot. I've noticed that in some culture's, especially southern US people will leave out prevalent information trying to be polite and God fearing when in reality all they are doing is harming a situation.

[@chelscara]

I no, you don’t get it, he had it “handled” 🙄🙄🙄 Irvine seemed too into himself being the hero at that point than actually being fucking helpful. In the end he just abandoned her. He was just a coward in the end.

[@babyerin]

I wondered when she attempted suicide and had quite a severe change since..

[@moiralyn23]

I was wondering about this too, if she had some kind of injury or something. If she really wasn't like this before then something had to have happened. It's really too bad Irvin wouldn't admit/didn't realize he didn't "have it handled". If she was that obsessed and harassing, something should have been done with/about her long before this. :/

[@ChristinaChillis]

It probably was an effect of the medication/treatment she had been given. Medication is supposed to balance certain chemicals in your brain, and it probably enhanced her dopamine (just a guess) which caused her to become overly obsessed with Shirley. Her doctor probably misdiagnosed the medication or something and probably effected her brain in the wrong way.

[@nellievaughn7755]

This is a lie. Chemical imbalances aren't real. This isn't some deep web, conspiracy theorist, paranoid opinion. From the very beginning, the chemical imbalance theory, was just that. Psychiatry has a history of doing immoral and/or irresponsible things to attain legitimacy. In this case, "going to bed" with pharmaceutical companies who marketed medication as a cure for "chemical imbalances." Something that continued to be pushed until 2011, though occasionally you'll still come across some psychologists and psychiatrists who really don't want to let this die, despite, again, it being no more than a theory. One that has been thoroughly disproven.

[@rachelvendemia7803]

Shirley has THE BEST NAME. If I was her friend I would tell people "Oh, it will be a 'Surely Goodnight ' if you were hanging out with Shirley Goodnight!' ". (I love bad jokes) I hope she rests in peace.

[@nayaabshah1155]

I find female murderers so intriguing and I love that you make so many videos over them! It just shows how evil comes in both genders and that society still seems to not comprehend or explore it.

[@zombikite]

it’s always sad to hear about these sort of stories where the victim is an extremely nice and caring person

[@brooklynlineback9795]

you're seriously one of my most favorite KZbinrs right now🥰 thank you for consistently uploading and working so hard!

[@britt9861]

@peter it's just some cooking video that's "finally here", please stop.

[@johnlemon5227]

@@britt9861 it's a bot don't pay mind to them just report 🪳🚶‍♀️

[@carow6244]

Always interested in all true crime on a Wednesday Hailey 🙂

[@evandaila8752]

Even though you’re literally talking about murder you’re so calming. I think it’s your voice and vibe. I dont know but I love it

[@nikkiwest3964]

REALLY miss the true crime makeup that you used to do. Those were the best.

[@sawdustandiamonds]

me too 😭

[@pen3475]

same

[@nikkiwest3964]

😢sucks those videos did so well. I wish she would still do them.

[@haley3748]

I still watch them sometimes just for some background noise, I’ve watched every video she’s posted cause I need stuff to watch lol but I miss them.

[@sawdustandiamonds]

@@haley3748 lol i do the same

[@MeadowSongs]

I feel sick and congested and my whole face hurts and I have to work and somehow these videos make it all hurt less 😭 I don’t know why. I think you just have a comforting voice/vibe.

[@o.siouxsie]

I hope you get better soon :

[@wearelove8025]

Hope you feel better soon dear! ❤️

[@jerzievap]

i hope you’re feeling better!!

[@isabelp187]

Hailey!! helloooo! Your voice is truly so calming and empathetic, I would listen to anything you talk about, even though these stories are just horrifying..I can imagine you could make some money narrating children's books or something because you really have a voice that people like to listen to

[@SunniDae333]

Wow, murdered for absolutely nothing. RIP Shirley

[@maverickdornberger]

i’m literally obsessed with your room i can never stop looking at it every time i watch one of your videos

[@lieslschenke9681]

no bc me too i need to know where she got her posters

[@royroyalu]

Thank you for everything you do. I love how grounded and just “normal” you are despite being a huge force on KZbin! Thank you for all you do :)

[@olive-gy2rt]

she’s literally just talking about a murder case

[@miguelconamor6687]

I hope you're taking care of yourself Hailey! I appreciate the weekly vids, but prioritize yourself if need be

[@delaneyreyes8995]

EXCUSE ME?! I live in Mooresville! This town is literally never talked about!! You should also look into the case of Misty Witherspoon. She killed her husband who was a cop for the insurance money.

[@Livingwbralana]

Ik I’m not famous but I’ll definitely look into that! I hope her husband rest in peace ❤️

[@eveningowl9443]

im interested now

[@Kunstenaarus]

This is so sad. It's literally terrifying how you can be doing nothing wrong at all and someone can be so mentally gone and obsessive enough to actually kill.

[@MariaIsabella0411]

I love how straight forward you tell these stories without the extra dramatic reaction towards things in the stories

[@StrawberryMatchaTea]

Thank you so much for always being so respectful! It’s so hard to find true crime KZbinrs that are just that, and you’re one of the rare gems I dug up

[@belindarocky961]

Sameee. That's why I like Hailey too. Kendall Rae & LordanArts are both super respectful too if you're looking to add to your true crime collection 💕

[@StrawberryMatchaTea]

@@belindarocky961 thank you so much for telling me about them! I will go search them up right now

[@sseonghwaa7076]

Also look into Danielle Kirsty and Bratterstein if you don't mind makeup and true crime. I'm assuming you don't mind since Hailey also used to do it before the podcast but I know some people don't like the combo.

[@SweetyBean]

How convenient you upload as I have to make schedules, you’re such a doll♥️♥️♥️

[@leeleeanna1999]

Really loving that profile pic

[@That_Girl_In_The_Car]

Love your channel but wanted to make a correction regarding a reference you made to the Borden case. Lizzie’s stepmother Abby was struck 18 times, not 41. Additionally Lizzie Borden was found not guilty and acquitted.

[@alpii_3254]

She has a video with that case too. It’s one of the conspiracy theory videos and covers that one and princess Diana’s death.

[@kyoka1528]

She probably mistook it because of a nursery rhyme that says Lizzie whacked her father 40 times and stepmother 41. Apparently used to jumprope to. While Lizzie was found not guilty, it's still very suspicious and most people nowadays think she did it. It should have been mentioned that Lizzie wasn't found guilty in the video but, she does have another video on her channel discussing the case, as someone else said.

[@mafer_lopezs]

So I recently saw a video of them kzbin.info and they say that Lizzie didn't do it but she was kinda the master mind in the killing, you should watch them

[@drelle504]

An unarmed man named Jayland Walker of Akron, OH was shot 60 times by cops. THAT was overkill.

[@kamisntreal]

im from kannapolis and kinda remember when this happened. i was still a kid and vaguely remember my parents whispering about what happened because things like that don’t generally happen in our town. unrelated to the case, i think your pronunciation of Kannapolis is very interesting. we say it like “caan-app-polis”. because literally no one knows about our town it was kinda weird hearing someone talk about it lol

[@XxSmitty89xX]

Me too

[@callierevans]

i live right outside of greensboro and in salisbury (divorced parents) and i also vaguely remember my family talking about this case. it’s always weird listening to people talk about where i live. listening to her pronunciation of kannapolis and greensboro was so funny but cute lol

[@baileywright3113]

Cann-aPOlis

[@zarahuffman6809]

haha im from salisnury and this is the comment i was looking for I've never heard kannapolis pronounced like that before, but also no one knows about it

[@stardressedsky3872]

Hey girl hey. KZbin randomly suggested one of your videos to me (princess die from Aug2021) and OMG I’m freakin in love with your vibe. Like. Seriously. I’ve been watching these kinds of videos for years but no one has your vibe. I adore you!!!! Thanks for your channel and your content. I’m so happy yt suggested you - just wish they’d done it sooner!!

[@liv8532]

These people who completely fabricate reality despite the literal actual truth staring them in the face are so scary. There was never any evidence of her husband having an affair and yet she convinced herself otherwise to the point of murder???? Insane.

[@johanna-ir2bx]

you should make the title “The Obsession that Led to Her Murder” cause the rn title seems like Shirleys the one w the obsession

[@malcommarcone2559]

I think that's her point...to not give away the punch before watching the vid.

[@LangkeeLongkee]

Tbh your suggestion sounds more like Shirley was the one with the obsession.

[@michelleback5648]

I am absolutely in love with your channel I've been watching you for a while! I love true crime and everything that goes along with that! I really like the soothing sound of your voice as well I listen to you when I'm getting ready for work and just wanted to let you know I love the way you're so compassionate to the victims and all your information although some of these stories are very sad or no justice I like how you put it out there so they're never forgotten! Thank you for every Wednesday I absolutely love your voice is very soothing and I love your content so thank you very much for making my day go smoother ☺️

[@vampiredrive]

THANK YOU FOR UPLOADING I WAS SO BORED I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS !!

[@kiaralewis4641]

I want you to know that i binge watch all your videos no matter what i’m doing. Making bracelets, giving my dogs a bath, doing dishes. I have literally watched 5 of your videos in the past 24hrs, Elan School, Junko, Michael Wallace, The teen mom killer, the Chris Wilder. I’m literally like “damn… next video.”

[@cryingontheclock]

I really appreciate the professionalism of your videos. That being said, I do miss some of the silliness and personality that you brought to your earlier videos

[@deebo429__]

You should do a collab video with Wendigoon, not sure how one would facilitate that but y'all seem like you could vibe well.

[@johnlemon5227]

Oh my god I'd absolutely love to see that collab✊😭

[@nbdjz1058]

that would be so legendary omg

[@z95zzz]

ooh, that would be neat! both of them discussing an iceberg about true crime or conspiracy theories together

[@kayliemccarty9533]

At this point I'm just watching to see how you're doing bc watching your videos feels oddly comforting despite the dark topics you address

[@OnlineElizabeth]

I could never imagine people waiting for uploads or turning on notifs till I found your channel. For the first time in my life I'm turning on notifs

[@Tiffany-yz1iu]

The only KZbinr i’ll listen to when doing my homework…..like something about her voice is just so soothing and makes me really interested in the stories she tells.

[@rosyvilla6141]

I’m so mad Irvin did nothing to stop that lunatic. He knew she was nuts and covered for her, even after being abused, and someone innocent and loving paid for it with her life.

[@stasiyaxo]

you’re the best. thank you for sharing these stories and being who you are!❤️ praying for her family and friends, this story is tragic☹️

[@amberrodriguez5697]

When I first moved to IL years ago, I moved to a small town a couple hours from Chicago called Princeton. There was a high school girl named Christy Doyle that was killed. To this day everyone thinks her relative Wade did it but was never arrested. Might be a good one to look into.

[@Livingwbralana]

That’s super interesting! I’m definitely gonna look into that I hope she Rest In Peace 💕💗

[@katekimrey9148]

Heyyyy! I was born and still live in Mooresville! I actually was just born in 2004 so I didn’t know this case. The way you said Kannapolis threw me off a bit because people around the area can like Can App oh Lis. I’m also going to college in Greensboro, which is often pronounced as “Greensbero” but that may just be the accent. but it’s weird to hear about my own home in one of these videos. Also, there are so many racecar things around here it didn’t even like stick out to me lmao

[@leighannfowler9687]

As always, a well done and informative story! Thanks so much.

[@analegon5739]

You voice is calming and great at explaining the stories ❣️ 💯🎯📍

[@megcarter4773]

so weird when i go to watch one of your videos and it’s local!!! thank you for covering this!

[@hacapu]

I listened to this on Spotify but I came here to tell you thank you cause this one was SO. GOOD. They're all so good but seriously this one, you're amazing. Was literally yelling "Who tf did it??" in the car by myself because your story telling is an art. Thanks for making the 3 hour car rides bearable ❤

[@critterchild]

the way i was just listening to this video as I prepared my dnd campaign and I heard you say "charlotte motor speedway" I shit you not I live 2 minutes from the speedway, I could literally walk to it- I got shivers

[@lacinunn3518]

I’m from Kannapolis/ Concord area and it’s so weird hearing it be talked about. And Kannapolis is pronounced Can-app-polis, super weird we know😂. Love hearing your story’s. Try to watch all of them during my free time. Kinda miss your makeup vids though💞

[@chrisXlr8r]

She also says Greensboro funny. But her pronunciation makes more sense.

[@chrisheamassey6508]

Right, when she first said Kannapolis I wasn’t sure if it was the same city lol. Kinda shocked me at first too

[@candace2903]

You read my mind with the pronunciation 😅

[@sarandipityinthestarssarah4076]

I grew up in Gastonia (Gas-toni-ah) and never heard this story. Thank you for covering it.

[@andreadecarlo6016]

I discovered you not long ago and now I am s constant watcher! I love your videos and your calm and cool demeanor!❤️ I haven't watched the last few yet because the sound is super low and I can't hear it very well on my phone. I am busy busy so I usually watch and listen on my cellphone. I'm not sure if it's a new thing or I am just now noticing it since I was watching your videos before on my t.v. but does anyone else have this same problem? I just wanted to bring it up just in case. I hear everything else just fine on my phone and it's only Haley videos 😭

[@SuperAmp18]

According to the nursery rhyme “Lizzie Borden took an ax gave her father 40 whacks when she saw what she had done she gave her mother 41” however Andrew was stuck 11 times and Abbie was struck 19 times.

[@DeniseM9077]

But her point remains that even then it was overkill.

[@betty3tes]

The make up session concept was epic while story telling😊captivating and unique!

[@rendezvous18.6yyy]

hey hailey i just wanted to tell u i love u so much especially these videos and your conspiracy vids(id love to see more of those) plz keep it up ur videos always make my day!

[@jn5769]

You are my favorite KZbinr ever. You’re such a comforting person and your voice is so calming :>

[@Rash_cookie]

Such a crazy story and I always enjoy listening to your content. A little to close to home but kanapolis is about 30-40 min away from mooresville with traffic!

[@allisonboggs568]

I just wanna say that I love your channel! you are very talented and I love your style of explaining things!

[@savannabrooke_com]

Been a chaotic day. Thought “I need something calm and peaceful” Hailey uploads 👏🏻 somehow your videos on literal murders calm me 😂

[@35yoglenmckenna31]

Me too ! I think it’s the way she speaks and articulate

[@llllllllllllllllllll241]

i love her voice sm

[@shantecarter172]

Not me waiting for you to post so I can finally eat my Qdoba and drink my iced chai😬😂

[@Quandalius.Dingleberg.III.]

Nice 👌

[@abbaerich]

yesss I’m living for all these uploads queen

[@nicolelamprecht5551]

Was wondering when the next video was and boom you're here. So happy 😊

[@jn5769]

every Wednesday she uploads :)

[@nicholasschoonbeck6866]

I was fb friends with a woman several years ago, & we would talk in comments on her posts or my posts. She was very secluded & some of her situation seemed strange, which was confirmed one day when she sent me a private message telling me she had to unfriend me because her husband read all her online interactions, & he was very suspicious of the social media world & when I called her "hun" once (which I stopped doing altogether in life after), he decided I was trying to seduce his wife. Never heard from her again.

[@hannsolotx8568]

Poor Shirley!! AVOID SPOILED BRATS as partners. It never ends well.

[@sandis700]

I love that judge!!!!!!! Nicely done!!!

[@lanecorby4927]

Omg the judge was ruthless, love that

[@pilotofthemothership]

i still hear the “spooky scary skeleton’s” in the back of my mind sometimes

[@halliehauer9895]

Off topic but I love the way you speak Its pleasing to my ears

[@Ruriko.Y]

this Marlene woman reminds me of a case in South Korea, of a mother-in-law who suspected her son-in-law cheated on her daughter with his younger cousin. she hired people to follow and stalk the poor girl around for two years and finally the girl's family filed a restriction order. but that was when the old woman decided to hire someone to kill the girl. such evil, evil woman.

[@nooriyahxo]

what's the name of the victim? I'd love to look into this case

[@Liz-hl7yh]

@@nooriyahxo kzbin.info/www/bejne/j6CaonSLeryriLs

[@getschwifty7966]

hailey posted , my life is now complete

[@mickistover4118]

Gives Good Night a whole new meaning

[@chrisheamassey6508]

The fact I’ve been in Kannapolis my entire life and never heard of this case.

[@ImVeraFranco]

My week only really starts when I get the notif of a new video from Hailey ❤️

[@haileybalmer9722]

I feel like others have to have said it already, but what you said about Lizzie Borden is mostly untrue and is taken from a skipping rhyme. There’s a lot of debate about who killed the Bordens, it’s not clear how many times they were struck but it was far fewer than 41, and it was her stepmother who was killed. Granted, she hated that stepmother, and Lizzie is extremely suspicious, but I don’t think she did it. The Lizzie Borden I’ve read about was far too lazy and selfish to axe murder anyone. Did she manipulate the maid into killing her parents? Some people think so!

[@rubberband0808]

i find such comfort in your videos❤️❤️

[@michellecgb]

We love a sassy judge.

[@RT-Vane]

living my best life right now eating some chick fil a & watching hailey 🫶🏼

[@Laney12405]

I love when I know all the cities talked about

[@shmebulockfanaccount5407]

i love your videos, thank you for your dedication!

[@rianbrands5897]

Thank you so much, love from the Netherlands ♡♡♡

[@lavenderixi]

i haven’t seen too much of female killers from many youtubers so this is refreshing to watch

[@SingingCrowie]

Although Marlene is the horrible perpetrator, a lot has been said about her, but I'm also upset with Irwin. If he was going to stand by his crazy wife and willing to plead Shirley not to press charges, how about stay away from her completely knowing your crazy wife is obsessing over her. Like either divorce her or try to keep your marriage at bay and, you know, not dangerous to others. And then of course he was afraid for his life, not hers. I feel like he led Marlene to Shirley in a way, ignored her behavior and put Shirley's safety in jeopardy by letting her get away with the attack.

[@Dyhmyd]

Lmao my BF can’t believe that I actually chill to a true crime podcast, i love you girlll keep going 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻

[@TemperenceTheGinger]

Hailey I am choosing to believe that you were joking about Lizzie Borden. Abby Borden was not hit 41 times with an ax, nor was Mr. Borden hit 42 times. Yes, both of their murders can still be classified as “overkill”. Also, even though most of us believe that Lizzie did commit the murders of her step-mother and father, she was found not guilty in a court of law in Fall River, Massachusetts. On another note, I am so proud of you Hailey. All of your hard work is really paying off! Congratulations on over 800 K subscribers!! That’s amazing. Thank you for giving a voice to those who cannot tell their own stories anymore.

[@baileywright3113]

We love a Hailey upload🙌✨ETA: I’m from here and didn’t even realize this video was from this area.

[@lollygirl420]

That’s my Grandma :/ a lot of my family has trauma because of Marlene. My grandpa is also Ervin.

[@lollygirl420]

Step grandmother if we are being technical

[@Ms1al]

Why am I here this early 😂 Freak occurrence but already liked it because I know it's gonna be good!

[@lsummern2]

i always feel bad for the innocent spouse/ family members of the victims. i cant imagine how chuck must has felt seeing that scene and how devasted he must have felt.

[@emilyvince8504]

The image of looking up from the phone to see a woman you know hates you holding a knife when you thought you were home alone… terrifying

[@mickistover4118]

Omg it’s crazy to have a case happen where I live. It’s pronounced CAN APPLE IS lol and it’s unfortunately not upper middle class it’s a dead factory town not sure how she got such a nice job.

[@MONIMOVES]

That’s so so sad. Thank you for sharing this story. RIP

[@breannahoshnic2274]

I’m currently sitting alone at Olive Garden watching this. Little date night with myself :)))

[@lesaubergines]

Hailey, you should do a video on Lizzie Borden. She was acquitted, super fascinating case.

[@finnomaly]

hiii this is the earliest i've been, love your videos :)))

[@natullie]

*me:* trying to focus on the video *also me:* stares at squishmallow cow in the back literally the whole time o-o

[@Financiallyfreeauthor]

Oh that's so sad. Reminds me of a relative of mine who developed a form of schitzophrenia suddenly in her 40s. She didn't hurt anyone else but she ruined her relationship with paranoid fears and lost custody of her kids