harry potter canon tier list

Get this video to 10k likes and I will release the Harry Potter watch-through!!
So what's everyone's favourite part of Wizarding World canon? Make sure to let me know where I went wrong on my list in the comments down below!
Also make sure to leave a like for more Harry Potter videos in the future!
Patreon: / seamusgorman
MERCH: teespring.com/...
THANKS FOR WATCHING!!!
SUBSCRIBE!!!
For Business Enquires: [e-mail]
Twitter - / gormanseamus
Instagram - / seamusgorman4
#tierlist #harrypotter

[@cherrypuddles]

I was thinking "Why isn't there Cursed Child?" but I realized this is a canon list.

[@Mayonnaise_man35]

*insert uncle Vernon ‘justice!’ Meme here*

[@silvermoon4068]

Wouldn't even deserve a 'troll' on my list

[@rosewheeler1458]

Ouch 😆

[@harveywallace6035]

The sofie and snape fan fictions are more canon than that trash

[@canofpizzasauce667]

When is fanfiction ever canon?

[@mdr11]

I love how the Cursed Child isn’t even an option for Harry Potter canon

[@youtubelife921]

Cursed Child? What is that?

[@Moonlight-wy7vc]

Oh you mean the fan fic that does not fit

[@Dylexis]

Molly Robinson what is the cursed child?

[@reagancallahan4307]

What’s cursed child? *glances around* {whispering}:we don’t talk about that...

[@jazz300]

Why would he rank fanfiction?

[@singandcoco4332]

In my opinion, I really like the relationships in the books, and I don’t mind the movies focusing on them sometimes (Ronmione and Hinny) BUT I SWEAR TO FREAKING GOD WHO THE ACTUAL HELL CARES ABOUT LAVENDER AND “WON WON”

[@parkerdinhwilliams15]

Sing And Coco They tried to make that movie a romantic comedy, which really didn’t work. It should have been a dark film with some romantic angst in the background. This was romantic angst and then sometimes the actual plot moved forward. The only scene I really enjoyed was Harry high as a kite on that luck potion.

[@KookyVT]

I'm a sucker for that kinda stuff, but still, my favorite scene in Deathly Hallows Part 2 was when Lavender died. (That's s joke don't come for me)

[@barney3463]

I think lavender and ron is better then "shoelace" *reaches down and ties shoelace

[@parkerdinhwilliams15]

@@barney3463 I also prefer a major infection over a rotten tumour.

[@KookyVT]

@@barney3463 👏

[@D0MiN0ChAn]

6:48 Our boy out here slamming my favourite book of the entire series. I especially liked it *because Voldemort wasn't in it* for once. It felt cozy, yet still threatening and the whole time-turner thing was super interesting to read (at least for me at the time when I was also around 13-14 years old). For me, PoA is also the year where nothing and everything happens in a weird way. The series just wouldn't be the same without Sirius and Lupin. Also, the dementors had me shook!

[@darthgriffin7741]

D0MiN0 ye, it’s tied with goblet for my favorite for me currently, though I still love the idea Voldemort had to try three times before he finally got like fully revived for more than 2 seconds.

[@questionsxxquestionsxx776]

Yes it's my favourite one

[@someanimal3506]

Prisoner of Azkaban is the best time travel story, change my mind.

[@-Gamerly-]

YES, although OOTP is my fav

[@someanimal3506]

Gaming with Elziah My favorite too!

[@bleumki]

His hair is magic, it’s confirmed.

[@nopeerror8758]

So true

[@greenlaneelm4939]

He's a wizard!

[@3myr08]

Yer a wizard Seamus.

[@ChpplJuc]

it’s because he looks like tom riddle

[@c4leb472]

Rapunzel?

[@katyadeykley8086]

I don’t know my sexuality or race because JK Rowling hasn’t told me yet

[@starbittenpixieboy]

Same bruh

[@PhilBagels]

As long as you know which house you're in.

[@MyKoira]

I thought that was a part of the new sorting quiz, have you checked your new results yet?

[@MAndSquared]

You can’t be gay, Dumbledore’s gay. However, Rowling never thought of you as having a specific race /s

[@harrypotterfandoms5971]

If she’s deciding u ain’t being trans

[@ren55mira57]

"nothing really happens" = the movie where Harry meets three of his dad's best friends, meets his supposed murderer of a godfather, finds out the truth and who was actually responsible for his parents' death, puts a dude in debt for saving him which proves very useful in the future and time travels and saves Buckbeak which is very important

[@beccasheikh5296]

thats my fave movie

[@landlighterfirestar5550]

Eliza Becker really? Nothing happens related to the overall plot? Nothing like a servant escaping that ultimately results in the resurrection of the person that created all the conflict in the first place?

[@user-mx4is4fx3c]

People probably think that because Voldemort isn't in the movie

[@masongarrod6681]

@@landlighterfirestar5550 that's one important thing, the others have tons

[@dog-md7wh]

*nothing really happens - in relation to voldemorts plan*

[@christopheryoung4563]

The fantastic beasts books were a “cash grab” but for all the right reasons. The three big warts textbooks were originally released to raise money for comic relief around 2007.

[@kianwilliams1152]

+

[@suorastas1]

It was in 2001 actually but I think every re-release has still been for charity.

[@someanimal3506]

IKR. It pisses me off when he kept calling them a cash grab.

[@tendyboiz1046]

Raising money for something is still a cash grab you idiot

[@Abhishek-tw8fr]

@@tendyboiz1046 but it was for a good cause soo...

[@SuperMustache555]

“It could really easily be the worst one if it wasn’t that good” (7:16) Great observation Seamus

[@thedoodlebugg1337]

It could be the worst one if it wasn't that good. Hmm,yes... the floor is made out of floor.

[@benraber2793]

Emerald Block I was gonna say that lol

[@r2ube]

Seamus your hair came back. I mean this could’ve have been pre-recorded but I’d rather think it came home Toy Story style

[@candlelight5376]

Or Harry-Potter-when-the-Dursleys-cut-it style

[@bloodmoonsims]

Candle Light yes

[@peppypigeon]

Pingu

[@thomasdumont3826]

His attempt at a beard is gone too.

[@lyndsaybrown8471]

Can't wait for Pixar to make a movie about it

[@beasanguino2824]

Why isn’t A very potter musical here, smh

[@andrewnebz]

would be too unfair, having that trilogy in a category of its own above a power-gap above all other tiers.

[@bi_cycle]

Say it with me folks, okay is wonderful!

[@eloisefishman6422]

thanks Hermione

[@elizahamilton7319]

How daaaare you!

[@thebananaowenslippedon7095]

I FIND this sad

[@katie-wi6yw]

When he didn’t put POA in top tier I was so annoyed especially the book it was so good-

[@yeetri1034]

same

[@patsykiniry3564]

i like the book a lot and it was the first one to really get into the lore and not just be about a boy with dead parents who gets into mischief at school

[@htsbrickreviews]

My soul dropped when he didn’t put OOTP in top tier.

[@tomwork2894]

YES

[@tomwork2894]

@@htsbrickreviews Same

[@nothingtoseeherefolks6911]

Seamus says: “A lot of you really seemed to enjoy it” Seamus means: Screw you haters

[@annabethchase2261]

YES. a Harry Potter tier list, I didn’t know I needed this

[@uraloser23]

I didn’t either but I’m loving it

[@cr4zy_cycl0n3]

Annabeth Chase Wait a mother-f*cking second. ANNABETH?! Yo, how’s Seaweed Brain(even though I don't ship y’all)?

[@THEchrisse95]

You wouldn't need it as you probably are gonna read every book +watch every movie

[@fandomtrash8823]

Kokichi Ouma Idk if you're being serious or not, but I've never met someone who doesn't ship Percabeth. There's nothing wrong with that cause I hate people who ship shame but that's just very interesting to me

[@milesdrake7514]

Just a quick note about ‘Quidditch through the ages’ and ‘Fantastic Beasts and where to find them’. You suggest they are money grabs, but when they were first released in 2001 they were done in support of Comic Relief, in fact checking my copies they both say that at least £2 from the sale was going to Comic Relief, each book was £2.50 (or 14 sickles, 3 knuts). So perhaps you were being a little unfair.

[@devanshraniwala8509]

Yeah, it kind of hurt when he kept saying that it was cash grab when it is actually for charity. Not only comic relief but Lumos as well.

[@Framlii]

Do are much more expensive now and i didn't see anything about money going to charity from newer prints

[@hiieposti4168]

yes, because some nerds like to actually learn the subjects of hogwarts.

[@Doctor_Straing_Strange]

Yeah, and Quidditch through the years was enjoyable

[@devanshraniwala8509]

@@Doctor_Straing_Strange Even the tales of Beedle the Bard

[@AutumnLikesElephants]

Prisoner of Azkaban was my favorite! I was so happy Harry found more family and Voldemort didn't show up for once.

[@Virginny]

Harry and Voldemort not having their final battle in front of everyone in the great hall was perhaps one of the only issues I had with DH pt2.

[@idekathispoint8668]

Virginia Harp and mcgonnagal fighting with harry for a bit

[@isabella-bh2zp]

There were small changes and the book is significantly better than the movie but that is mostly because the saddest and most heartbreaking parts of the book would be hard to show in the movie.

[@PuffyCloud10]

I thin k that is so true I LOVE DH P2 it’s probably deserving outstanding in this list that shamus made in front of goblet of fire and behind the book itself or maybe one before that spot because well goblet of fire is well goblet of fire the best of the best HP book soo don’t hate

[@PuffyCloud10]

A

[@ohmygodimonfire4]

For me having Voldemort like dust away into ash Infinity War style was weird and disappointing. In the books he just dies and his body lies there. That was his whole thing, he hated the thought that he ultimately was, just a man. Seeing him die just like any other man was such a sweet moment for Harry(who knew this about him) and the reader.

[@samanthasilver264]

Who else would watch a word for word film adaption of the hp books?

[@Abigail-bi6qw]

MEEEEE!!!!!!

[@lolin6379]

Even if it was six hours... YES!

[@shwetadoorwar5697]

Imagine if the order of the phoenix was adapted like that We’d all be dead by the time it was over

[@LeaF-vo2mx]

Yes, but Lee Jordan asking "Is that a crime now? Getting mail?" would be SOOO funny!

[@btcxwxy]

MEEEEEE

[@abigailprice1753]

I love how the hp fandom has collectively chosen to forget about cursed child.

[@SigmundOrthodoxy]

We haven’t forgotten about it, we just make fun of it, he was mocking the cursed child by putting “canon” in the title.

[@meias.]

The what? I have never heard of that

[@lckittyqueen]

@@meias. don’t worry, you’re not missing out. in fact, you’re at an advantage

[@scombs6543]

Unpopular opinion: Order of the Phoenix is my favorite Harry Potter book, very close tie to the Half-Blood Prince. It's also my favorite movie.

[@kaenachoo4783]

Scombs 654 Same. I love how long and interesting order of the Phoenix is. For some reason everyone usually says it’s the worst book of the series.

[@scombs6543]

@@kaenachoo4783 fr, people say that it's too long and has unnecessary fluff, but I like it that way. 😂😂

[@iam._.lou7877]

Me too

[@korgaupisc129]

Yessssss absolutely. It's a masterpiece!

[@htsbrickreviews]

OOTP IS THE PERFECT BOOK.

[@annadilley934]

JK Rowling's twitter account is in T because she's literally trolling everyone with her tweets

[@fleetstreet11]

Jo and her twitter account are actually in O. Seamus is just jealous.

[@aeronhoare7706]

@@fleetstreet11 Nah. We just hate transphobia as we do other forms of bigotry

[@fleetstreet11]

@@aeronhoare7706 "Transphobia". Another word for adherence to objective reality. Men are not women. Men can never be women. Men will never be women. Best you get used to it.

[@maddiea-f]

@@fleetstreet11 please do research into what you're talking about, trans people are supported by science

[@fleetstreet11]

@@maddiea-f "Science". In this case it means ideological nonsense designed to make TRAs look good.

[@randomcow3710]

“It could easily be the worst one if it just wasn’t that good” Thank you Seamus for that ground breaking analogy.

[@Joe-fy9uy]

stolen

[@janiholtshausen13]

lmao

[@alicenoronha6873]

LMAOOOO

[@shadybeashooketh1911]

do you mean analysis skskjdsn

[@riyamaster342]

@@Joe-fy9uy hi !! You are still alive !! I thought Harry killed you?

[@michaeldezell171]

they should make a "fantastic beasts and where to find them" documentary that's actually about the beasts

[@JonathanSmith-ge4pi]

We need it voiced by David Abbotbrough.

[@bobthebuilder8110]

I feel like if it was made satirically, it would be so funny, like if they got Morgan Freeman to voice it.

[@midnightmadness4353]

Seamus: putting CoS in the first tier Me: hitting that like button

[@midnightmadness4353]

Come on, Deathly hallows p1 is no way better than CoS and PoS...

[@siir3659]

same

[@shannonjay9964]

When JKR’s twitter is more canon than The Cursed Child 😂😂

[@andicarusfell8387]

I dunno man.. it’s pretty fucked 😂

[@randomusername429]

@@andicarusfell8387 Exactly

[@pinkpastel751]

WE DO NOT SAY ITS NAME!!!!!

[@andyrevan]

Have you heard of death of the author.

[@Cllocopine]

Well that’s kind of a tricky one because if Rowling’s Twitter is canon then so is the cursed child since Rowling once said the cursed child is canon.

[@Toby_Price]

2:24 No. That's not an excuse. You can buy audio book versions. Go listen to those instead.

[@u.s.e.r.2.3.4.]

Some children already have the books from there parents so they won't want to spend more money but a child could be dyslexic meaning they would struggle to read. So for some kids the movies first is the easier option until they are a bit older

[@jowarren1558]

Toby Price sorry I can’t read write am deaf and blind, thus cannot read oh and I am dead

[@kelvinmaldonado4540]

Toby Price that's like trying to speak to an only Spanish speaker in Hungarian

[@sarthakgupta1853]

10:37 Did anyone realise that the cover of the half blood Prince fits with the cover of goblet of fire (Dumbledore's wand's fire and the dragon breath fire)

[@DriverHenryWho3245]

Oh my, that's amazing!

[@MakimasGoodBoy]

The fact that Dobby is only in two movies makes them rank lower for me 😔

[@bobthebuilder8110]

If only the movies got a bigger budget....😢

[@thehufflepuff5941]

he thinks all comments are hate comments, all comments are about his hair

[@marciaosullivan3200]

Sex is real

[@EvilDoppleganger]

@@whenyournameisduoduos1282 reproduction isnt real

[@AdiM-lq4bp]

It's funny how The Half Blood Prince is his favorite book and his least favorite movie

[@anitaposa9164]

It's same for me. Mostly because the film is literally just a commercial for the book, as it shows very little of crucial things from the books, imo anyway.

[@paulgrotebeverborg1119]

Same with Goblet of Fire for me

[@anitaposa9164]

@@paulgrotebeverborg1119 those two films(GoF and HBP) are BY FAR the worst in the entire franchise. Interestingly enough, many people who haven't read the books say that goblet of fire is their favourite film. I find that very interesting.

[@paulgrotebeverborg1119]

@@anitaposa9164 the film is not terrible, but if you have read the books, it only leaves you with disappointment

[@hannahgrace1790]

Anita Posa I think it’s because the idea of the plot is so good and original and that’s why non book readers like it, whereas because the book was SO good and the film cut out so much it’s very exasperating to watch it knowing full well it could have been so much better

[@catherineandrew7741]

Finally, someone loves the chamber of secrets, it's one of my favourite books and everybody says it just blends in

[@crocuslament9680]

"Other than the whole Sirius and Wormtail side of it, you won't really have missed that much." Remus Lupin. Expecto Patronum. James Potter. Animagi. Buckbeak. Hippogriffs. Hagrid teaching. Azkaban. Dementors. Boggarts. Hogsmede. More information on how Harry's parents died. Werewolves. Some of these are incredibly important, some of them serve to flesh out the world and give us more context on other things later, but both categories are worthwhile. It's like saying the Chamber of Secrets would've been worthless if Tom and Mouldy Voldy were different people.

[@Katielovegood44]

For me, prisoner of Azkaban will always hold a soft spot to me. First time I was introduced to multiple twists.. such as Sirius black! And also my intro to time travel :) it was so fun to read! It truely blew my mind

[@grace-eq5ge]

Same

[@D0MiN0ChAn]

Same here! 🙌

[@sansgirlfriend]

I actually dislike PoA a lot-

[@Vanilla-Suite]

@@sansgirlfriend its treason then

[@dajax1996]

Omg spoilers

[@maddiestumbo3482]

"that everyone can read, well unless they cant read......"

[@munjee2]

Audiobooks are a thing

[@maddiestumbo3482]

@@munjee2 Seamus said it

[@fran-ow4iq]

hI iM jArED iM 19 anD i cAN't rEaD

[@DarthBagel]

I can’t do math either

[@maddiestumbo3482]

@SuperSansCraft 1212 watch the language, can't forget about the inevitable wave of 12-year-olds scrolling through the comments

[@toozeep]

I wish he included Harry potter and the portrait of what looked like a big pile of ash

[@wyldegi]

HAHAHAHA

[@nanuqo2006]

it's a LARGE pile of ash. Get your facts right, fake fan.

[@SigmundOrthodoxy]

“Ron immediately began to eat hermione’s family”

[@berengustav7714]

BEEF WOMEN!

[@samanthagreen576]

You forgot the most important piece of Harry Potter canon: My Immortal

[@rowanbrynn2080]

Face it, Super Carlin Brothers are the most reliable source of canon.

[@isabella-bh2zp]

Rowey Bryn yes

[@FBA1]

@@Sean5067 yeah he's amazing

[@FBA1]

Nicholas Cottrell canon basically means the original source material so the books are the main source of material but the movies changed alot of things so they are not a reliable source and i've just realised i've wrote a whole essay 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@FBA1]

Nicholas Cottrell No prob ;)

[@videostarpro9268]

Leanthomly movieflame is the best

[@gagemcneece3955]

People who arent harry potter fans: where is the cursed child Me: shut up now

[@jorgeazem9511]

Cursed Child never happend, it was a collective delirium.

[@corneliu8827]

it's just a mandela effect, it never happened, but somehow everyone who aren't real a harry potter fan thinks it did.

[@FunnyGirl-jw8bh]

It was alright, the plot could’ve been better. But the play was amazing because of the magical effects

[@mattisbby6]

IT happened. I SAW IT. IT was amazing!!!

[@abiclarke8152]

@@mattisbby6 There was nothing to see. People cast a hallucination only Harry Potter fans could break.

[@fiver2543]

I was expecting The Cursed Child and then I realized "oh right, this is for Canons"

[@JonathanSmith-ge4pi]

Yeah, my personal favourite canon is the one blackbeard used on his ships, it was a really good canon, sad he never got to use it.

[@adamczekalski8561]

"The goblet of fire is the best book" Me: how dare you disrespect the best book, the prisoner of azkaban

[@maggies.camera]

Thats actually my least favorite book no tea tho i respect ur opinion🙃

[@bucksmentalstability69]

eXACTLY THE PRISONER OF AZKABAN IS THE BEST

[@kingdomscollided4842]

Prisoner is best book (and movie)

[@maggies.camera]

My fav is the order of the Phoenix and my favorite movie is the deathly hollows part 1 but I still haven't fully watched the second

[@shortbookworm481]

adawg Czekalski that’s what I’m saying!! When he said that no one likes it I was offered a little.

[@s.l.thecoffeeaddict1657]

"I'm going to stop pointing at you because it's making me uncomfortable." You? What about us - ?!

[@theforbiddensauce]

I punched my phone when he didn’t put POA top tier

[@Jettus]

Same mate

[@ollywa]

me too, that would’ve easily switched places with COS for me. i found that really boring ;-; prisoner, while not really important to the plot, was actually interesting and didn’t include a death day party.

[@theforbiddensauce]

Purple Pants I didn’t mention a hole

[@theforbiddensauce]

Arcana IX Yeah but I’m still mad that he put COS over POA

[@caidendonovan5607]

The Lone Penguin sorry I misread the comment I was trying to make a joke

[@bmaida2778]

The breaking of the Elder wand always crushes my soul.

[@GraceDeDalache]

I guess the cursed child felt left out, because an ad for the play appeared, when I clicked this video 😂

[@izzygrooves2514]

YES THE HALF-BLOOD PRINCE IS SO FORKIN' GOOOD

[@kasperhansen7854]

True!

[@GreetingsFineCitizen]

Yes! Thank you! It is my favorite book!

[@lucymckain834]

Best part of HBP though is - “pincers” 🕷 😂

[@littlesunshine1111]

lucy mckain and high harry😂

[@ashlynann1709]

but I am the chosen one *smack*

[@isabella-bh2zp]

They still didn’t do sassy Harry justice. Such a shame.

[@thriftqueen1621]

Haha yes😂

[@chancecarlson2023]

I love HBP, was my favorite

[@yeetri1034]

"It could easily be the worst if it wasn't that good" Isn't that how's it supposed to work?

[@Eevee860]

One of the books literally describes hermiones skin as white, none of jk Rowlings twitter counts as canon

[@bobthebuilder8110]

*P👏🏾R👏🏾E👏🏾A👏🏾C👏🏾H*

[@tropicalsunday3743]

the 1 dislike is from Seamus bald head.

[@SeamusGorman4]

James Hamaker I like the bald head

[@dangermenatwork]

I like the bald head :(

[@tk-ol6iv]

@@jameshamaker9321 the bald head is cool

[@dirkwalker9686]

@@SeamusGorman4 It's not bald, it's a buzzcut, and it's badass.

[@myadoesrandomthings]

is there 119 bald head suemuses?

[@VeryViolett]

I love how he thinks the cursed child is so bad he didn’t even include it

[@thibaut040]

The book that must not be named...

[@mdr11]

VeryViolett I mean it’s a canon list for a reason lmao

[@crocuslament9680]

It's on there, you just can't see it because it's waaay off the bottom of the page in a tier named "The result of J.K. Rowling tweeting that Voldemort actually had a child with Umbridge but like the terribleness of the child, its parents and the thought process that went into it merged into one entity that is still far above this tier".

[@archercheney5999]

he has a point

[@olye1958]

The book that died If you dont get it its a pun on the boy who lived.......im funny right

[@camdotcoms]

i completely agree with his explanation on prisoner of azkaban yet it's been my favorite since i was a kid lmao

[@jess.mooney]

Of course McGonagall was perfect, shes played by Maggie Smith. The only actress for the job

[@carolb.3500]

seamus said CHAMBER OF SECRETS RIGHTS

[@mollysmith6604]

"How would Voldemort know how to get into the Shrieking Shack?" *Cough* Peter Pettigrew *Cough*

[@camdotcoms]

the prisoner of azkaban movie is absolutely my favorite by far but i must say that the final shot is just. the funniest thing. how did this make it into the final cut??? i will never understand it's so fuckin weird

[@ianp4352]

My favorite moment is when Hermione clocks Malfoy in the face

[@AverytheCubanAmerican]

Seamus is canon within this universe, and Universal Studios

[@cassielyniw]

avpm deserves to be in this it’s as canon *prolly more*. than jks twitter

[@SeamusGorman4]

true

[@yeetri1034]

what is avpm?I think I didn't get the abbreviation

[@GreetingsFineCitizen]

@vish yetry A Very Potter Musical

[@yeetri1034]

@@GreetingsFineCitizen thx

[@lxlmao]

I love how he didnt put cursed child in there because he would have had a great opportunity to get into an argument 😂😂😂

[@lxlmao]

Lol

[@tomwork2894]

No one considers it canon, soooo

[@frozenweevil4022]

Remember when we had a perfect ending for Star Wars...

[@jaybird6396]

9:03 Thats perfect because T can also stand for Terf!!!

[@Silveraro]

Or transphobia

[@autumn7]

I'm guessing since this is tiers of canon material cursed child isn't involved? If it is I know where it's ranked.

[@laurenann4693]

The7SuperStars we’re pretending it doesn’t exist

[@dylandwhat]

cursed child? is that some kind of food?

[@megssketches]

The Cursed Child? I’ve never heard of it... in fact I don’t think it even exists

[@NirjhorNath]

Lauren Ann pretending what doesn’t exist?

[@c3po_bby796]

We aren't including wattpad fanfiction

[@lukeh8891]

I watched Crimes of Grindlewald in theaters and I honestly don’t really remember any of it. I stopped paying attention like halfway through the movie and by the time I got back into it I had no idea what was going on 😂

[@kanustfbj]

Seamus is proud of himself when someone says “I am starting to hate you.”

[@WhateverPotter]

*The only Human that has the ability to bring his hair back in a week*

[@karatekid202]

Whatever Potter except Harry himself

[@JDB51]

You mean like 2 weeks lol

[@benmyers6948]

2019 Seamus: I’m going to make content I enjoy and not what the fans want 2020 Seamus: Gotta give the people what they want, right

[@eisvogel.1481]

8:52 This is why I liked your video :)

[@camdotcoms]

THE RISE OF SKYWALKER CLIP IN THERE I'M CRYING AKSGGSA YES SEAMUS THROW THAT SHADE

[@juliacortez5516]

If "The Cursed Child" was in this, it would go straight to T.

[@itsamiamia]

Siriusly? Bellow that

[@CRAZYCLOWNTOWN]

Why would you add a fanfic into a canon tier list?

[@wing7320]

At least jk's Twitter account was made and operated by her.

[@juliacortez5516]

Thank you all for getting this comment to currently 69 likes.

[@PKMNResearcherSkyler]

It would pull a reverse Toy Story and have its own section under everything else.

[@shay.w.5812]

I love how he completely doesn't care about what his audience wants and does what he wants because the originality and authenticity of it is exactly what we want. We want someone who does his own thing, so props to Seamus on that.

[@harshrajsharma5050]

all 7 hp books are going in outstanding for me

[@tomwork2894]

Agreed

[@stichyyy6700]

“This is just a year where nothing happens.” The knife marks on the fat lady portrait was just Mrs Norris don’t worry

[@JonathanSmith-ge4pi]

Yeah, and Filch was just holding a knife at the end of Ron's bed to kill a bug. Also Crookshanks ate Scabbers, end of story. Don't worry about that random Pettigrew fella that suddenly shows up, and is majorly important, and the weird guy who's sending letters to Harry in the next book without any context.

[@willsolacemahsaamini8681]

@@JonathanSmith-ge4pi that's actually a pretty good question. What if an animagus is eaten by another animal or a human?! And what if they turn into a human the moment they enter the mouth?!

[@annabethchase2261]

I’ve honestly never understood why people thought the prisoner of Azkaban movie was so amazing, I thought it was really disappointing when I watched it. They left SO much out from the book, which was AMAZING

[@iplayeddsharpminor]

Annabeth Chase agreed; the tone completely changed with the new director which wasn’t necessarily bad. And it could have been brilliant if they just spent another 5 minutes explaining moony wormtail padfoot and prongs! Unforgivable omission.

[@juliafaith06]

Wait... harry’s hair grew back after his aunt cut it Seamus’s hair is back IS SEAMUS SECRETLY A WIZARD?!?!?!?!?!?? Seamus yer a wizard

[@jashuarai3415]

It would be yer a wizard Seamus

[@brutalthebigone]

mr finnigan

[@carysrw]

why did I think you were talking about Seamus Finnigan and not Seamus Gorman?! 😂😂

[@cryptidliam8452]

Jashua Rai p sure in tue book he says ‘harry youre a wizard’ which idk

[@ashlyndeslatte8585]

No no no your saying it wrong it's yer a wizard seamus

[@scoutdnr]

The books don't say that Azkaban doesn't have walls, they just say it didn't need them. "The fortress is set on a tiny island, way out to sea, but they don't need walls and water to keep the prisoners in, not when they're all trapped inside they own heads." They also say they don't need water in this quote but it is stated at the beginning that it's surrounded by water none the less. It's just saying that it has walls and water but it doesn't need them because of the effect the dementors have on the inmates.

[@nkelly5851]

When you put JK's twitter on Troll I burst out laughing. Good reasoning.

[@kinkykendostick6461]

for saying sex is real???

[@fakename3440]

@@kinkykendostick6461 herd mentality

[@mjfadeaway22]

Seamus: children can read them Me: laughs in almost 900 pages in book 5/7 Guys nvm I finished it in 2 weeks

[@Isaiah_McIntosh]

.... Yeah kids can read them....just takes some time.

[@mjfadeaway22]

Isaiah Mc Intosh I’m speaking as child, I’m not that patient

[@Isaiah_McIntosh]

@@mjfadeaway22 speaking as a person who read the books as a child just keep reading and break it up into manageable segments. Or maybe you just don't like the story?

[@mjfadeaway22]

Isaiah Mc Intosh I love the book it’s just I just find it very long

[@Isaiah_McIntosh]

@@mjfadeaway22 keep reading increasingly difficult books both fiction and non fiction across various time periods and cultures. Alongside well aging the books won't seem that long when you get textbooks nearly that 3/4 the length lol.

[@hat1935]

when was this filmed? your hair is different

[@Neptune7766]

I know that’s the first thing I thought

[@BrownNinja777]

He mentioned this in that break video where he already had videos prepared before he took that break

[@munjee2]

Probably around when he filmed the last one

[@jackysbin3860]

Holcomb Studios he mentioned he had pre-recorded two videos

[@lightomimus1738]

The Goblet of Fire book fits perfectly with the Half Blood Prince at 10:55

[@joeyjerry1586]

Lightomimus, oh, true, I didn’t realize that.

[@DriverHenryWho3245]

Lol so true

[@seithtorres1686]

Yo bro I haven't been to your channel in a minute and when I saw this it reminded me of why I subscribed last time props from the mid west of 'Merica

[@bluejollyrancher9024]

Me: Yay he’s back! Also me: oh it’s probably pre recorded Still love it thou ❤️ hope you’re feeling better seamus

[@stockyschannel9484]

OH YEAH, THE TABLE IS BACK!!!!!

[@lawIight]

I agree with almost everything you said! The Half-Blood Prince is my favorite book, and honestly the best. However, I think POA was a very close second. It just felt really nice. It was almost like a bridge, and it was fun to read. Also- of course, POA was like one of the best films. It was just like- goodness me. Fantastic. Yeah- that's all-. I respect all opinions, and I think yours was great!

[@elizabethjarvis4618]

order of the phoenix took me 3 hours to read which was the shortest amount of time for reading any of the books and i loved it ,the others took me around two days lmao

[@furiousvids7790]

Seamus i absolutely love your personality and i just wanted to thank you for being on youtube because honestly your videos are the highlights of my week. please don't quit anytime soon ❤

[@natalie8640]

You forgot the Very Potter Musical trilogy!

[@starzfromstarland9039]

Did somebody say Draco malfoy?

[@dracomalfoy7409]

_Harry freaking Potter!_

[@eliastta437]

Darren Chris

[@isabella-bh2zp]

Natalie that deserves to be at the top.

[@yourlocaltheatrekid900]

Pigfarts, Pigfarts, here I come!

[@SilverTune]

5:13 omg in my school's library i found a book that was published before the 7th book came out and is a full book on what they think will happen in the 7th book, it is so interesting to read as someone who has only consumed the series as a whole

[@ChrissaTodd]

also in the first film i wanted them and this is just my attachment to the weasley twins as characters i really wanted the gred and forge scene in the book to be in the movie it was just really funny, we know she puts the letters on their jumpers cause she can't tell them apart but they joke about how they can lol

[@JonathanSmith-ge4pi]

I just wished they added more Gred, and Forge in general. I loved all their antics in the books. One that I think goes underappreciated is in CoS when they walk in front of harry jokingly saying he's the heir of slytherin, and he has tea in the chamber of secrets. I just remember laughing at that so hard as a kid.

[@brando_handle]

Its almost as if the cursed child never happened

[@carina_t]

It didnt

[@virginiacanfield2307]

he only did canon stuff haha

[@chemicallesters5433]

The what?

[@thibaut040]

The what?

[@D0MiN0ChAn]

As far as I'm concerned, it didn't. May the nether world have it.

[@elie2368]

Either this was pre-recorded or your hair grows _fast_

[@kestreldragonicesyth8831]

Oh my f-ing god thank you for addressing JK's problems with us T people in the LBGT, I noticed that everyone who do videos on her work completely ignore it, and like even if it's not the focus of the video it's nice to have some recognition

[@berkyumpull1325]

I love how the first 2 outstanding books are my favorites as well in the same order

[@maxobyrne1474]

SEAMUS SAID TRANS RIGHTS

[@HarryPotter-gq1mz]

Max O'Byrne you are a handsome young man what is your age do you have a boyfriend

[@AspienPadda]

Oh dear @@HarryPotter-gq1mz that comment was more than a bit creepy

[@starbittenpixieboy]

@@HarryPotter-gq1mz dude.... Fuck off. That's creepy.

[@fiend-ish1090]

@@HarryPotter-gq1mz oof that's a weird thing to say

[@lankylemon8555]

@@HarryPotter-gq1mz I can't believe Harry ended up as a nonce

[@ryleeprince9185]

"Jump right into the SIRIUS stuff" 😏

[@texaszubes3650]

Thank you so much for putting the half blood prince so high up, it is the most underrated book ever

[@therealliviedawn]

I really enjoyed this video. Well done, Seamus! 👏

[@austindangerpowers8453]

The proceeds made from the textbooks were all donated to charity. It wasn’t a cash grab.

[@hejouxah1269]

Yes, it was. They were grabbing the cash for charity.

[@johnbaker4916]

That’s pretty shagadelic

[@juliannaelwell]

Personally, I love long books and OotP is my favorite of all the canon. I love books that make me actually angry and of course Umbridge does that perfectly.

[@AdenaKaiba]

11:55 "Yes this is shade" Me: Oooooh!! :D

[@willmckinnon5999]

The entirety of deathly hallows part 1 is a vibe. Fight me