Reacting To The WORST Harry Potter Theories

So what do you guys think the worst Harry Potter Theory is? Ronbledore? Snape is Harry's father? One I didn't speak about today? (bonus points for anyone who says one of mine) Let me know in the comments section down below!
I spent quite a while on this video and am really happy with how it came out, so if you enjoyed it and want me to bring back debunking videos make sure to leave a like and comment some theories you'd like me to debunk!
Patreon: / seamusgorman
MERCH: teespring.com/...
THANKS FOR WATCHING!!!
SUBSCRIBE!!!
For Business Enquires: [e-mail]
Twitter - / gormanseamus
Instagram - / seamusgorman4
#harrypotter #theories

[@VortexTraveller]

Theory: Umbridge is secretly a Dementor, cause both immediately suck all joy out of any room they enter ( highly implausible)

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

(Highly plausible)

[@emmamichelsohn7515]

Vortex Traveller. Yeah, but like actually.

[@arandomuser9459]

I mean your not exactly wrong.

[@abigailgrelis4528]

Hehe one time I was chanting with my friends (at age 11) "UMBRIDGE IS A DEMENTOR"

[@skywalkblue8583]

That aint wrong

[@aleafyluna]

I have a theory Hermione is Aragog.The proff is that i don't remember them being in the same room ever.This theory is real.

[@TheSpencermacdougall]

except that they were in the same room...well same forrest clearing.

[@TheDanishGuyReviews]

@@TheSpencermacdougall Not a room! Still counts! /s

[@pieterhanhart4740]

(Highly plausible)

[@ayzecknozniksid3126]

@@TheSpencermacdougall Hermione actually wasn't there when they went to see Aragog: she was petrified at that point.

[@liathedoll]

@@ayzecknozniksid3126 That's kind of why Harry and Ron were meeting Aragog at all. They were missing the brain of the group.

[@zigyzagy2dios823]

Bad theory makers: I am inventible Seamus: and I am a proper theorist

[@SeamusGorman4]

*snaps*

[@ronwevsleys]

@@SeamusGorman4 *all* *theorists* *dies*

[@kayleegirard9231]

*all BAD theorists die

[@ronwevsleys]

@@kayleegirard9231 yeah.. we want supercarlinbrothers

[@kayleegirard9231]

@@ronwevsleys Exactly

[@r2ube]

Here's a better theory than all of these- Harry's great grandfather had 12 teeth. And his middle name is Franklin

[@arandomuser9459]

:Dillon Wingull Sure. I’d rather believe this than any of those.

[@Jaydonutalt]

Yep and they called “12 toothed Franklin”.

[@cryptidliam8452]

Yep there’s tons of evidence uhhh coz they’re dead and we don’t know they’re namessjuaixxisiow

[@paigejohnson9201]

😂😂😂

[@happymilk7433]

He passed down that gene to Harry

[@luxx4]

OMG BELLATRIX IS TIME TRAVELING LETA BECAUSE THEY HAVE THE SAME LAST NAME🥴 *mindblown*

[@luxx4]

OMG MALFOY YOU ARE SO RIGHT

[@kamimwahd7702]

TheFluffyUnis ! 🤯

[@fasterthen5gaysnails650]

Dude Hermione is time traveling Bellatrix cuz they both exist

[@arandomuser9459]

Or could they possibly be *Related?*

[@tombullard123]

TheFluffyUnis ! Ngl i did find it a bit odd that one of the proudest pureblood families would marry into a black family and its never addressed. Especially with the themes of racism and elitism tied with “purebloods”

[@user-qq9rh]

New theory: Ron is an every flavour bean

[@racingfuel28]

EZhistory evidence? He eats one lol

[@buckleys1729]

🤫 *we’re not ready to tell the public yet*

[@lana.notdelray_dh]

I laughed much!!🤣🤣🤣🤣 you made my day

[@marioreoo]

evidence: you are wat you eat

[@amalkaraly]

B E A N W E A S L E Y “ makes sense “

[@vivienneq2556]

Theory: Harry and Hermione are siblings because both they’re names start with H and they both exist

[@oddlynicole16]

Don’t forget that R is the third letter of both their names.

[@bneisasmiler4942]

That's the best evidence I've ever heard I'm convinced

[@TheDanishGuyReviews]

That reminds me of a theory that Donald and Daisy were related because they both had the name "Duck". A debunker said something like "Duck is a common name in their universe. If your name is Johnson, are you related to every Johnson you know? No, l didn't think so either."

[@akninja2399]

That's... That's amazing. I've never heard a theory like it.

[@idkwhatimdoing1713]

WOW! This is the best theory I've seen all day, and such conclusive evidence!

[@retrogradedly]

This video is basically “Reacting To Pothead Harry Potter Theories”

[@stefan6347]

That pun, I like that

[@arandomuser9459]

Arwan Shrivastava Good title.

[@lahlybird895]

Hacting to harry pothead theories

[@ceilingsintheireyes6288]

Pothead Potterhead Theories? Pot(ter)Head Theories?

[@eliraeclipse2435]

Pothead is a potterhead in a nutshell.

[@raticoochiesmith9819]

The worst Harry Potter theory is the one about Credence being Dumbledore's brother, that sounds SOOOOOOOO STUPID. *Oh, wait*

[@SeamusGorman4]

you made me lol

[@finnflix8464]

@@SeamusGorman4 how your day going?

[@ronwevsleys]

Am I the only one who have know clue what your talking about ? ( yes, I know fantastic beasts )

[@doubleflores8350]

Serpentine Hufflepuff seriously Crimes of Grindelwald was so terrible.

[@arandomuser9459]

Serpentine Hufflepuff I mean. I would agree..........

[@Jaydonutalt]

I’ve got a theory, Harry Potter is a centaur. You wanna know my evidence? Harry talks to some. Lol

[@cupofries]

Harry is a special type of centaur. He is half human, half human!

[@eliraeclipse2435]

@@cupofries whoh I've never seen a half human and a half human before

[@GreetingsFineCitizen]

@Arthur Fretheim That is the best thing I've ever heard

[@elmoisacocainaddict557]

Lavender Roselinda 1D well don’t forget his 3rd leg ;)

[@NitroIndigo]

@@cupofries "I'm half-human. On my mother's side."

[@katiek8899]

New theory: Seamus IS ACTUALLY Tom Riddle Evidence: have you ever seen them in the same room at the same time? I didn’t think so.

[@lilybush7106]

Good point lmao

[@lahlybird895]

Seamus gornen, or Seamus Finigan? Also, both are gryffindors

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

😮

[@fightingfaerie]

@@lahlybird895 Is Seamus Gorman a gryffindor? the hufflepuff pillow behind him seems to suggest otherwise

[@lahlybird895]

@@fightingfaerie he used to be a hufflepuff

[@laurengrace71]

Harry Potter theory: The fat lady ate voldermort

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

😮

[@casualgnome]

(Highly plausible)

[@munjee2]

Theory :they are called death eaters cause they feed all of their victims to the fat lady (*which is why she is fat , you see*) and death eaters is a much better name than death feeders [HIGHLY PLAUSABLE]

[@mrsdog6242]

GUYS 1TS TRU3 D1D U N0T S33 SH3 G0T F@TT3R!!1!1!1!1!!111!

[@lana.notdelray_dh]

This made me laugh the hardest I've laughed in months!! Thank you for making my day! Have a blessed, safe and great day!

[@h3nder]

Ron is James Potter. Need proof?They both married a girl.

[@eliraeclipse2435]

OMG I LOVE GHAT THEORY!

[@slytherinpride1291]

A muggle-born girl at that!

[@h3nder]

@@slytherinpride1291 Yes, they are the same person.

[@audreyk1889]

....does that mean Ron is Harry's dad.....

[@audreyk1889]

@@blue9291 Of course, of course. And Scabbers wasn't actually Peter he was Lucius Malfoy.

[@lilianafranco8423]

Theory: Jessie from Toy Story is a Weasley Actually this isn’t a theory, this is a fact because I say so and no one can tell me otherwise

[@lordgradious4370]

i cant disprove it do it must be right

[@sdmartell22]

Red hair

[@gabyh566]

Seamus: Snape tricked Lily into thinking he was James! Seamus: Coincidentally on the night they conceived Harry! What are the chances of that?! Me: well if Snape were Zeus, I’d say pretty high

[@86upsmaya]

Well,if there is any magic to assume an identity, its Polyjuice potion, pity there was no potion master around Snape.😆

[@86upsmaya]

@@blue9291 hey,the theorist believes Snape is Harry's father, do u think he will stick to FACTS? yes, legilimensy is more like reading thoughts, it basically means u cant be lied to, not to manipulate minds, thats what Imperius curse is for

[@l.c.8475]

What about polyjuice potion... Ikr I'm a genius, that's why harry looks like James, fixed that theory... NO! just no.

[@engagingathena9965]

I enjoy the link to one of my other passions Greek Mythology Now is anyone up for linking that to Marvel?

[@bajula4444]

@@86upsmaya To pretend to be someone else, well and convincingly, is possible by careful observation of that person and his mannerisms. Snape might have read Lily's memories about James, Polyjuiced himself, became a convincing James Potter, and raped her.

[@spencerd6126]

Some of salazaar slytherins accomplishments: Creating the baskilisk Seeking immortality Inventing quidditch The great vampire massacre Being the first wizard ever Inventing the iphone

[@PerovNigma]

♦ Discovered nargles ♦ Only wizard to have a beard until Dumbledore ♦ Once chained upside-down via his ankles by Filch ♦ Was actually gay the whole time ♦ Had a passionate relationship with the stained-glass mermaid in the prefects’ bathroom (yeah, that contradicts the last one, but who gives a toss?) ♦ Invented the trick step that always gets Neville ♦ Father of the Fat Lady (both the woman and the painting) ♦ Created the spell that doesn’t turn rats yellow ♦ Was the real playwright of _The Cursed Child_ all along ♦ Used by Bertie Botts as the model for their earwax flavour ♦ Was an animagus, and used his snake form as an excuse to fuck snakes ♦ Gave Dumbledore his glasses ♦ Once had a fight with Chuck Norris ♦ Was the first person to open the Chamber of Secrets after he left the school and died ♦ Designed Hermione’s dress for the Yule Ball ♦ Ran around Diagon Alley in a snake suit, beating up criminals ♦ Successfully patented goblins ♦ Was the first person to ever enter a room, forget why he entered, and leave ♦ Told J.K. Rowling to throw in vampires, despite the conflict of tones with the rest of her world ♦ Decided that wizards should just shit on the floor and then vanish it away ♦ Rigged the vanishing charm so it would actually send the shit to Godric’s room ♦ Made the first centaur by doing things with a horse ♦ Invented sherbet lemons ♦ Invented stairs ♦ Invented dabbing ♦ Cyborg I can do this all day! 😂 This could be a try not to laugh challenge!

[@tanukimika]

@@PerovNigma I'M CRYING OH MY GOD

[@adamk.3118]

He's currently married to Dumb old door *Dumbledore

[@bjornjohansson7907]

he wHAT-

[@bekiboo9]

😂 invented dabbing got me

[@sophiafox9643]

I’ve got a theory: Hermione is Snape’s daughter because they both have hair

[@JosephTaberner]

New theory Newt is Ron and he timed traveled to become Newt I know, I know, mind blown

[@unicornsprinkles3277]

Tabby Bricks Productions and ginny is actually Tina’s mother

[@Damarcus123]

@@unicornsprinkles3277 sweet home alabam

[@kaylabettina5363]

woah🤯🤯

[@nolanmcbride6846]

Ron is the young version then Newt, then Dumbledore

[@kyischaotic]

I raise you, Newt is Charlie Weasley. They both have red hair. They both work with animals. Boom. Theory confirmed.

[@StottOnTheDot]

I thought by the thumbnail a theory was suggesting baby Harry was Harry’s father and that REALLY piqued my interest.

[@EmMakesMusic123]

Stott On The Dot same lol

[@jostewart3192]

Time Turners get messy

[@eebertdeebert]

Same

[@Gameryukii]

People be thinking all snakes look alike. RACISM or should I say SNAKECISM!

[@eliraeclipse2435]

Well I think all the bts members look the same. I guess it's kocism.

[@kpoptrashemotrashhumantras8929]

#StopSnakecismToday

[@DAVI19100D]

It would flow better as SNACISM... but isn't as clear about what it is. Oh well xD

[@aunnobiitsu]

Lavender Roselinda 1D & HP but.. Rm...

[@SakiBlablabla]

Lavender Roselinda HP & 1D ...nan that is just racism or blindness !

[@emilyingram6053]

I know nagini and the zoo snake are different and I was really annoyed at those comments too... But are they all just imagining that jk said they were the same snake? No. Of course they’re not. That would be stupid they can’t all be making it up. What I think is more likely is that Snape used legilimency to make them think it was jk telling them on Twitter because he wanted to divert attention from the rapidly spreading truth. That Snape is Harry’s father. (They couldn’t put it in the film because it’s not PG).

[@bjornjohansson7907]

Oh look at that, i was fooled to think you actually believed this for a second before reading it again.

[@gracetalbot]

Ok ok i was one of those comments and i am dumb i believed tumblr waaaay more than I should've. On behalf of all those comments, I apologise for being stupid

[@amypattie7004]

Legit though I have a memory of JK in a Twitter comment replying to this theory positively, years ago, when we still trusted her

[@selobee4831]

@@amypattie7004 She probably did, and that's why we don't trust her anymore lol

[@cygnusalton9207]

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Order of the Phoenix, Half-Blood Prince, Deathly Hallows part 1 and Deathly Hallows part 2 are rated M, if that theory about Snape being Harry's father is true they would put it in Deathly Hallows part 2 when Harry looks at Snape's memories right after Snape dies

[@emmabussolotta4243]

Seamus sounds like an English teacher grading a paper in this video. All jokes aside, I love these types of videos.

[@bakaichigo]

As English tutor, I can agree with this and do.

[@kamimwahd7702]

Don’t worry, I read your tweet and noticed the great editing at 0:43

[@SeamusGorman4]

AHAHAHA THANK YOU

[@Spooky_l3xxi]

Ayyy same i saw the tweet and I was like damn that EDITING

[@annahs.channel]

2:38 sorry this is just so i can look at that

[@danimations1440]

Oh my god it’s Draco omg I hate u

[@tinfoilmoon6556]

@@danimations1440 mines exactly the same as yours if i correct it to.... *corrects hate to love* there! now it's the same

[@dylansproat2654]

The ‘Dumbledore made a horcrux’ theory is still the best Harry Potter theory I’ve heard. Just sad that JK said it was wrong

[@beccag2758]

Dylan Sproat I agree!!!!! Even if it isn't true it's still way better than any other theory I've ever heard, Potter or otherwise!

[@atharvavadeyar5157]

Yeah JK says a lot of things... Not all of them are...sane

[@adamk.3118]

You make a horcrux by seducing your murder ... DUMBLEDORE HAD SEX WITH HIS SISTER'S DEAD BODY?

[@adamk.3118]

Unknown Human But the bodies were intact READ HALF BLOOD PRINE AGAIN. There was nothing wrong with the bodies apart from the fact they were dead -J.K Rowling

[@pollygotacracker9396]

Adam K. Ik. There are lots of theories for how a horcrux is made. But no one apart from jk Rowling and the director of the movie (I don’t remember which one) know. So all we can do is guess. As for your theory that’s not as inhuman. It’s technically rape which has been normalised rn. Whereas cannibalism is d finitely something that could have happened. Also for some of his horcruxes he would’ve had sex with people such as a tramp and other things and Voldemort wouldn’t stoop that low. Plus I don’t think he has a dick since he did undergo a lot to get horcruxes

[@HiBye-bt7qk]

Here’s a great one. Draco is actually Buzz light-year because they both wear green 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@cygnusalton9207]

All Slytherins wear green, does that mean they're all Buzz Light-Year

[@LadyMythos315]

@@cygnusalton9207 whoa so am part buzz light year? Wow

[@namelessperson4600]

How did not notice it's so clear

[@angeladavidson2350]

I used to believe the Nagini theory I'M NOT PROUD OF IT

[@bluessbelles]

I used to think that too but in my defense i was like 12 and my thought process was “big snake, big snake. Same,”

[@angeladavidson2350]

@@bluessbelles Same. I was younger and less wise then 😂

[@eliraeclipse2435]

My sister who when she was 15, a potterhead who read some of the books thought that the snake Harry let out is nagini. I'm dead.

[@gracetalbot]

Neither i got it off of tumblr and was like "oMg iTs fRoM TuMbLr iT mUsT bE TrUe"

[@fasterthen5gaysnails650]

I also believed coz oh they are the only snakes ever shown

[@newsiesforever208]

And Newt couldn't be the Professor Pre-Hagrid as Professor of Care of Magical Creatures either, because Professor Kettleburn exists (in the books anyway).

[@paigestubbs9718]

and what about Grubbly-Plank??

[@newsiesforever208]

@@paigestubbs9718 Grubbly-Plank was the substitute teacher for Hagrid. She might have been for Kettleburn.

[@zanonymousruiz9697]

Well that’s in the bOoK cAnOn, we’re talking about the mOvIe CaNoN

[@oapf0536]

Best part kettleburn was mentioned in the film at the feast at the start of the prisioner of Azkaban

[@elfology]

So glad to know i'm not alone in thinking these theories are RIDDIKULUS!

[@eebertdeebert]

@@dakotablount251 Riddikulus is the joke- unless I'm missing out on some reference here

[@thatoncergirl2011]

Is no one going to talk about how the snake from the zoo blinked!? Snakes don’t have eyelids.

[@86upsmaya]

Well,u are asking too much from people who think a male boa constrictor is a female viper.😆

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

😮

[@masha7377]

That's because it's not a real snake, but a maledictus, duh! More precisely, Merope Gaunt. Proof? She died. And her mum was long dead, too.

[@josephdavis9234]

Theory: Parseltongue translates gestures as well.

[@racingfuel28]

Well, in the movie’s defense I believe the book actually did say it winked at him. But yeah I’ve always been like has JK Rowling never done any basic studying of snakes? I mean, I learned that snakes don’t have eyelids in like kindergarten😂

[@Lady_de_Lis]

I just found myself thinking, "Snape could've used Polyjuice potion to pose as James, I guess. I mean, he IS a potion's master." And that got me thinking... What *would* happen if a child was conceived while using poly juice potion? Would the child have the genetics of the actual person or the person they were posing as? (What if that's how a metamorphmagus is born? Lol jk)

[@EmMakesMusic123]

KaytOfTheBlackCoats well that might be how a megamophus is born

[@TheTrueSpottedStripe]

New theory Batman is Snape

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

And Dumbledore is Batman. But that would mean that Harry’s dad is... oh no

[@alisont4510]

@@unicornbarfingrainbows7599 Harry's dad is.... Luna. I'm just as shocked as you are.

[@munjee2]

@@unicornbarfingrainbows7599 that's why Harry's grand parents are dead it all makes sense now

[@Carly529]

He kinda is tho...have you seen those dramatic cape scenes in philosophers stone....MIND BLOWN 😲🤯

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

Actually I just concluded snape is darth Vader. Both wear black, are responsible or the death of their crushes, work for old men with secret children, betray same men, are actually the dads of the protagonist (and both protagonist live with their aunt and uncle), and both had bad childhoods.

[@sugandhakohli]

I have a mindblowing theory: Dobby and Tom, the innkeeper is the same person. I mean have you EVER seen them together in the same place at the same time? Like EVER?? I guess not.

[@stanletters]

muggle-born wizards just have a squib really far back in their family history

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

Seth Tan is that suppose to be a joke or fact

[@masha7377]

@@unicornbarfingrainbows7599 fact! :)

[@tapwater9435]

Seth Tan that’s actually really cool, I’ve never thought about that

[@EmMakesMusic123]

Seth Tan propably or just great great great grandparents or something is a half blood that’s what I have thought

[@katarinabrunk8698]

THANK YOU ! 👍

[@tggamez6859]

Theory : Voldemort is harry potter They both exist! They even have the same wand core!

[@hexacle6155]

Wow..

[@bneisasmiler4942]

Well actually the film's did add to the books, HARRY AND HERMIONE DANCED FOR A MINUTE THAT WAS ADDED HA I got you this time SEAMUS

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

You did

[@lana.notdelray_dh]

And also: In half blood prince: The burrow burning down Ginny feeding harry a cookie Ginny trying harry's shoelaces Like..... Many other things. But lol that's not the point he means like, you know, in your heart..... *deep emotional mood activated*

[@beaniechesters5682]

@@lana.notdelray_dh Ginny feeding Harry a mince pie made me so uncomfortable like whos idea was that-

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

Galaxy Cookies it could be worse. Harry could zip ginny’s dress up in front of George. The movies have more chemistry between Hermione and Harry than ginny and Harry

[@magnus_bane]

GUYS: Ginny is Luna's mom: we've never seen them in the same room together and they both liked Luna. So here's what I think: Luna's mom was trappes in an alternative universe with singing bunnies and when she managed to come back she it was 10 years before that and she was a baby so she became Ginny.

[@ronwevsleys]

_No_ _one_ : _Not_ _even_ _a_ _single_ _soul_ : Seamus : *posts* *a* *awesome* *Harry* *Potter* *video* You : it's time to drop everything and watch the best video on internet!

[@05stapj]

What if Sirius Black was Newt Scamander! Newts most defining character trait is his love of magical creatures, and throughout the books we see Sirius forming suspiciously close relationships with Buckbeak and Crookshanks, just to name a few. I don't know guys I think I'm on to something!!

[@neilynalvarez1980]

Theory: Sirius was actually the one who blew up Aunt Marge

[@katarinabrunk8698]

I wish that would have been brilliant on his part 🤔😂.

[@natsch578]

Oh I remember hearing one about about how the founding members of Hogwarts were the main characters from Narnia... and they didn’t address the fact that they have different names... not even once

[@eebertdeebert]

Theory: Luna Lovegood is actually Malfoy’s sister. Evidence: They’re both blonde with grey eyes.

[@arandomuser9459]

ASHmellow I thought Luna had blue eyes?

[@eebertdeebert]

@@arandomuser9459 No, she had silvery eyes, which is close to grey. And wow I really hate my old comments

[@katarinabrunk8698]

Thank God that's not true 😂.

[@juliacortez5516]

Seamus exposing Harry Potter crackpot theories for almost 10 minutes straight.

[@jacobaldrich9984]

You should do this with Marvel or Star Wars Theories

[@eliraeclipse2435]

You're reading my mind. Three of my favourite things in the world. Hp, star wars and marvel

[@user-oq9pz6tt9x]

@@eliraeclipse2435 agreed. Also, Thanos is obviously Red Skull. The proof is that they both have abnormal colors of skin (racism, I guess).

[@dartaficial3480]

no No no NO no No nO and NOoooOooooOoo

[@purrito3892]

Omg finally, a Harry Potter video. *should have put his braces back on for this vid*

[@toontownrules413]

I don't know how to tell you that this isn't how braces work.

[@peternoparker]

WolfyGrace r/woooosh

[@toontownrules413]

@@peternoparker considering the fact that there were people genuinely upset after Seamus got his braces off, you really can't be too sure with some people.

[@persona_link3554]

WolfyGrace you don’t need the r/ this isn’t reddit.

[@bekiboo9]

@trixxy pro 77 it's a meme and a joke and @WolfyGrace r/wooosh

[@violajames]

But Seamus! What if Peter Pettigrew was a double agent who was in love with Harry's *father*??

[@Tasha9315]

I think it could be true that Peter was in love with James and was bitter that James fell for Lily instead. Sirius's comment "wet himself with excitement" makes me doubt more, lol.

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

😦

[@arandomuser9459]

Tasha9313 .....what?......

[@jacobparrish4486]

WHAT?!?!!??!!?!!?!!

[@val8869]

in the thumbnail I thought you were saying harry was harry’s father

[@munjee2]

Right !

[@cthonisprincess4011]

I have a theory: What if Seamus Gorman is Tom Riddle’s reincarnation????

[@petapan3914]

I can practically smell JK confirming every single one of these.

[@niaharry7946]

Jaz-Pan Productions i can FEEL the tweet; hmmm yes, Snape is Harry’s dad because PG. am a family woman so this makes perfect sense

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

JKR can have incest, genocide, slavery, and wizard roofie but an affair is too inappropriate

[@astrax2426]

Totally legit theories: 1. Neville is actually Pomona Sprout's son because he is good at herbology and he became a teacher. 2. Sirius is Draco because they are pure bloods. 3. Dobby is actually the king of house elves because has big ears.

[@eebertdeebert]

Ok younger me would've totally bought the first theory

[@Androkles1922]

I think that Ron's parents are actually siblings. Bc they both have red hair. Und who else both have red hair? Fred and Ginny. And what are they? Siblings! BEST THEORY EVER

[@Telodor]

When I first watched Deathly Hallows Part 2 in the cinema with my parents, my dad seriously asked afterwards if Snape was Harry's father. WTF??? Is it not that obvious that he's not?

[@harrietmia]

“Google Tom riddle.” “Okay, I can do that, looks like me”

[@deztineefernandes6278]

New theory: When James and Lily died there spirts went into Harry and Ginny’s body proof is that Harry and Ginny both have the same hair colour has lily and James

[@EmMakesMusic123]

Deztinee fernandes hah lol

[@elenaobradovic4181]

While I was watching this I was scrolling through Instagram and found a theory about how Snape probably taught Voldemort unsupported flight accompanied by just the most amazing picture

[@HikariMichi42]

I saw someone say that in their opinion, Snape was a better father to Harry than James. 🤮

[@carlrood4457]

So the guy who bullied him and only protected him out of guilt about his mom is a better "father" than the guy who died protecting him when he was one year old? I don't think this person knows the meaning of the word father.

[@HikariMichi42]

@@carlrood4457 Exactly.

[@LU-qr3kh]

Early:I think so Is this a great video: Yes Seamus: Cool Am I actually early:Heck no Hotel: Hogwarts

[@finnflix8464]

¿hotel? : trivago

[@stefan6347]

UmH....HogWaRts is NOt a HoTeL tHAnk yOU veRy mUCh.

[@eliraeclipse2435]

You think Hogwarts is a hotel? It's a deathtrap for kids who's becoming a teen because no one likes them.

[@shudahimatsu3016]

AVADA....wait....trivago

[@beansontoast9924]

Don't get it

[@naomi_falk]

Wow did anyone else notice the great editing at 0:42?! Like, he probably spent 2 hours on it! (Just guessing here)

[@filiptalimdzioski7281]

Not 2 hours... those are motion track images and he animated them to go like that. Its like easy to animate but Its awfully hard to be consistent with each image as it goes on. Pretty dreadful

[@814912]

I have a weird theory: Nagini was actually secretly a Korean woman who'd been turned into a snake the WHOLE time. Actually, no - that's just too ridiculous...

[@angelgirl222]

Happy to see you made another debunking video! Also, any other Slytherins here? 🐍💚

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

Sorry I’m Gryffindor

[@c_savage073]

Here

[@funkmaster2404]

I have a theory.... Harry is a WIZARD!!!

[@iexistyes_]

*gAsP*

[@katarinabrunk8698]

Ow. My. God. 😂

[@bromodragone8405]

🤯🤯🤯

[@hexacle6155]

OMG NO WAY😮

[@TPNsBiggestFan]

HE CANT BE A WIZARD. HES JUST HARRY!

[@arandomuser9459]

6:48 yup definitely look like Harry and Ron right there.

[@bowchickabowwowthatswhatmy3219]

Fun fact: That pottermore article on the Chamber of Secrets is the same one where they stated that wizards shat on the floor before toilets were invented.

[@Purple-Berry-Pie]

Yesterday my mom and I were talking about Star Wars and I mentioned how funny it would be if Voldemort or Snape were Harry's father because of how similar it would be to Star Wars, and then this video pops up in my feed.

[@TheRibottoStudios]

Ok but why does the Baskilisk look like a God damn fire type pokemon that's INCORRECT SIR. He'd be water/dark type thank you.

[@SeamusGorman4]

I was thinking this a lot

[@TheRibottoStudios]

@@SeamusGorman4 that bugged me way more than it should but it just didn't make sense lol

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

Ace Coordinator Mary no poison

[@TheRibottoStudios]

@@unicornbarfingrainbows7599 ohhhhhhhhhhhh dark/poison!

[@ad-sd-vids5332]

Here’s a theory: Millicent bulstrode is actually the chosen one

[@jahsiahbowie1120]

I’m gonna be honest I believe the “Harry freed Nagini” theory when I first got into Harry Potter but I would never understand how Snape is Harry’s dad

[@1tE5o6]

This is probably nonsensical and- okay, I'm not 100% updated on all of the lore, but (probably easily debunked, idk) theory: The pensieve at Hogwarts is a horcrux- not Tom Riddle's, but like. The first, ever. Like. Herpo the Foul, /first/. Think about what the diary was capable of as a horcrux, since it also displayed memories (of sorts) to Harry, didn't it? (Scary note on top of that: imagine the build up of information, spells, emotions and memories.)

[@EmMakesMusic123]

1tE5o6 Hmm good point better than some theories I have heard

[@lunaoak6741]

Okay so I know snape isn’t Harry’s dad but we love some good tea over hear

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

That would be awkward

[@_.Cozmic._.Roze._]

"Its like a fanfiction" OH HONEY! On wattpad alone there are at LEAST 27 fanfictions with Snape as Harry's real father!

[@mintbrownieangelfish-6114]

Ohhh check out fanfiction.net sometime, that's the old Harry Potter fanfiction Capital. I think they have their own community for it

[@CerealcerealcerealDays]

I have MAD respect for Seamus. Not just for making good videos, but for actually finding the right chapters in Harry Potter. That, is impressive.

[@writingpaulina5157]

The last theory is actually quite popular in Germany because of the last movie. Dumbledore says something along the lines of „er hat ihre Augen“ (he has her eyes). ‚Ihre‘ can be read as either her or the formal you, so it could possibly (it‘s still wrong though!) be understood as „he has your eyes“ - which is still a flawed argument because they don‘t have the same eye colour

[@keegan6448]

(Highly plausible) Sure, I believe that.

[@geniusiq.]

Theory: umbridge and a dementor are together *i can not wait for the first kiss* But like seriously there perfect for each other they are both a living fragment of sadness and no joy

[@katarinabrunk8698]

I can't wait for the wedding I can only imagine it The Minister "do you Dolores Umbridge take Demeter to be your lawfully wedded husband" Umbridge "I do" Minister "I now pronounce you husband and wife" Umbridge kisses Demeter and and drops ded, me "ow god I think I'm gonna cry it so beautiful" Seriously there needs to be a fan fiction about this 😂.

[@yuuna_flower9625]

To thumpnail Harry: Yeah, I would've had this expression when Snape was my father. 😂😂

[@somerandomnerd756]

51 views 71 likes *SEEMS LEGIT* Edit: Three people saying there first *SEEMS LEGIT*

[@mygumshurt5193]

theroy snape had a relation ship with Dumbledore and thus they gave birth to Grindlewald. and since snape was a jerk Dumbledore reset time and had snape die and then brought Grindlewald to another universe and left him there to meet Dumbledore. proof is snape has black hair

[@clodaghmclaughlin8712]

Bad theories: Where invincible Semus: I'm about to end your whole career

[@jacobparrish4486]

NEW THEORY: Harry is a muggle because there is a muggle in the background of the first scene of the first film 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@Jess-eo4xf]

Editing in the Baskilisk had me cracking up 😂

[@td7226]

Ron is Harry’s dad! Ok hear me out. They’re both in the same book series! Bam! What more evidence do you need?

[@BIGDICKWIZARD]

Seamus your British At upload it was 12:30 *British time* seamus seamus SEAMUS

[@cupofries]

*oof*

[@bootsmecat7810]

Like... Newt and Dumbledore are friends. It's not a dumb idea that Newt might visit an old friend. Also, he ends up marrying Tina and living with 3 kneazles in Dorset. I find that adorable.

[@burhanuddinmaskawala187]

Theory: 3:36 Ron does a whole flip by accident over his trolley when I cant even do a cartwheel when i try 🤣🤣

[@charlieandrews-came1392]

Fan theory: vOlDeMoRt iS aCtUaLlY gOd

[@danielabohunicka4604]

*ah yes, voldemort. The best god of greek mythology.*

[@eebertdeebert]

@@danielabohunicka4604 Percy Jackson in the distance: *Ah schist not this guy again-*

[@ishanbhatt1123]

Ok one thing I will never understand is the rules on underage magic. I mean they can detect magic but not who cast it. So pretty much any pure/half blood (or non muggle born) wizard can cast a spell in their house. Technically since the ministry doesn’t know who cast it, a pure/half blood child can cast a spell and blame it one their parents. Can you please explain how this works, because it is confusing.

[@meirashapiro4935]

I really appreciated the censoring of the c*rsed ch*ld at 5:45. Thank you, Seamus, for taking this important issues seriously 🙃!!!

[@NidraxGaming]

2nd Theory: Katie Mosher: How exactly do muggleborns receive magical ability? J.K. Rowling: Muggleborns will have a witch or wizard somewhere on their family tree, in some cases many, many generations back. The gene re-surfaces in some unexpected places. Basically muggleborns are mostly descendants of squibs who married muggles and during many generations forgot about existence of magic, but the magical gene resurfaced back at certain generation.

[@seineevee]

NEW theory (fake): What if... Seamus Gorman is Tom Riddle. My reasoning is.... why not?

[@kalypsos_korner]

Wait I have a theory Ron is actually adopted Proof? Well my proof is that it never says he wasn't so yeah

[@JastoMcJr]

New Theory: Voldemort is actually Umbridge. Evidence: They suck Mind blown

[@morrigankasa570]

Think about this theory; The way purebloods came to be is muggleborn wizards married each other and then had children who "technically" are purebloods.

[@milesaphobic]

Theory (jkjkjk) DUMBLEDORE IS GOD *Boi I wish*

[@fruitygarlic3601]

Tbh, I would be more convinced by a Christian interpretation of Harry Potter than the recent stuff JKR has said.

[@jacobparrish4486]

(Highly Plausible)

[@angeladavidson2350]

6:31 I'M DEAD 😂😂😂

[@limettenkuchen]

I might know where the Snape is Harry's father theory has it's origin. In the German version of the Harry Potter movies Dumbledore tells Snape "Er hat ihre Augen", which is just the translation of "He has her eyes". Now in German "ihre" means her, but can also be a very polite form of you, like that's how you would adress someone you don't know so well or os some sort of authority to you. Dumbledore always used this form of you in the German version when he was talking to Snape, so a lot of people who didn't read the books and only saw the movies in German thought that Dumbledore said "He has your eyes", which would have meant that Snape was Harry's father

[@raginiarora834]

2:25 Bill's expression from the clip HOW DIDN'T I NOTICE THAT BEFORE!!!!!!

[@gollum507]

Here’s a real theory, hogwarts is in Antarctica and the teachers are penguins in disguise

[@CrimesAgainstHuFranity]

Theory: *Harry is a wizard*

[@EmMakesMusic123]

That can’t be true!

[@lucius6694]

The 👏 content 👏 we’ve 👏 all 👏 been 👏 waiting 👏 for 👏

[@LGC996]

new theory: hermione was a ravenclaw pretending to be gryffindor. evidence? she’s smart.

[@christheleavittman7080]

How is it I’m only now noticing the “$1” Forky in the background?