"Has the Constitution Failed Us, or Have We Failed the Constitution?" |Central Hall with Kapil Sibal

[@RajamaniMuthuchamy]

Dushyant Dave is outstanding.

[@LoveAddiction16]

Such discussions r not less than the Crores of Rupees,which we r getting at very lest costs. It's blessing. Thank u sir,keep this all continue...

[@AJ-ld1mi]

Mr.kapil this discussion is outstanding but I think this should have had done before the parliament session started so that the Congress and the India alliance and opposition could get ideas from here

[@vedpal8683]

Actually sir we have failed to follow the constitution... because the person who has resources doesn't want to share with the underprivileged.

[@felixnayak6317]

The judiciary has major share for the utter failures of the country

[@madhubalasharma2822]

Excellent 👍 presentation.Very true to present scenario.Sad story of Indian politics.

[@sureshharinathbabu9717]

Huge respect ❤❤❤❤ to dushyant dave you are a great person

[@trafixcal]

Kalyan da very bold in his approach...

[@radhakrishnadevaraju7327]

Judiciary has become the ' B ' team of ELECTION COMMISSION.

[@achalkumarsharma1240]

The latter is more true than the former. We have proved unequal to the task of acting according to the constitution . We have regularly tried to twist and maul the constitution as per our whims and fancies.

[@Ranjit-Sidhu]

wow! 4 great truthful personalities on one platform, Though they are Lawyers still I am calling them truthful

[@beerbudera2086]

Excellent👍👏😆👍👏😆 Very useful conference 👍👍👍Budera beersigh. Ex. President student union HNBGU srinagar gadhwal. Uttrakhand.

[@BhaskarKarajgar]

Thank you

[@kalaimani5424]

Both are the Great personalities ❤❤

[@radhakrishnadevaraju7327]

EVM failed the constitution because the citizen can witness the choice of his party after pressing the button. But while counting his choice of symbol slips not to be seen is unfair, not transparent & not free.

[@ramavtarjousha7002]

Really we need this type conversation

[@sarojsidhu5517]

This person is speaking the hard truth.

[@BhaskarKarajgar]

valuable conversation my sincere Salute healthy democracy Judiciary must be independent

[@adarshmahajan3938]

Mr. Dave you are right to say that opposition is not able to educate the people that institutions are not working. But for that you need to have an honest independent media which is almost absent today.

[@ASHOK-dn4st]

Judiciary has failed the Common people of India...

[@bheemachandrasekar5423]

Respected sirs very good discussions went on ,One old story in my mind .A bird in a cage saying freedom freedom freedom ,one day a trveller passing that way listened and open the gate and freed the bird but the bird did not come out , why because if it fly in the sky there many problems in the out side like big birds,hunters,no security in fetching food etc. The bird accustemed to take timely food from her owner and security from foes .people who want freedom should be brave enough to sacrifice .In those days people wre brave enough to sacrifice so only they brought indipendence. We are living in a cowered society sir. I may be corrected if it is wrong

[@radhakrishnadevaraju7327]

🗳 BALLOT BOX IS TRANSPARENT EVM IS OPAQUE .

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Is the public interested in the political leaders HMV (his master voice)???? Is it good for the democracies nations /people welfare?????

[@manjula2084]

We hv failed to follow the constitution, no respect fr individual who enter bbmp bwssb bda office, delay in justice, public struggle, high influence failed our Constitution 🙏🌼

[@trafixcal]

Mr Dave's views are very true...incompetent people on important post...

[@sheilarebello763]

This has been a brilliant conversation but I wish the powers that be would listen to all you wise men who want a vibrant democracy and not an autocracy. This beautiful country is going down a rabbit hole and if brilliant men like you allow this to happen, we are doomed. All of you are parliamentarians except for Mr. Dave whom I have the most respect for, should take this up on a war footing to save our democracy n the secular fabric of this diverse country. God bless

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Can Washing machine theory reduce crime rates in the democracies World????? Is it true or false?????

[@KrishnaKumar-so6gr]

एडवोकेट दवे साहब की जितनी तारीफ की जाय उतनी कम होगी। हीरे की सोंच वाले व्यक्ति को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम। 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 long live sir।

[@sivasankaranav6104]

Who failed whom is irrelevant but failure is a fact & it's time to march ahead, correcting the efficiencies, instead of lectures & philosophies by those who made a fortune out of misery !!!

[@ArunKumar-iz3do]

We together have failed pur constitution...we cud not protect it in any form..it has become just a piece of paper

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Is the Publicity/marketing good for the democracies political leaders??? Is it a business?????

[@sultanaram8095]

कार्ति चिदंबरम पूर्व वित्तमंत्री के पुत्र हैं।

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Do the Unskilled political leaders control entirely administration in the democracies nations???? Is it good for the welfare of the public/nations???????

[@robinreshmi6948]

Nowadays the Democracy alives for only BJP spotters not others.

[@george561]

I have a different point of view. Constitution was not a distilled version of the existing reality of the Indian society. It was a hope; a dream of a successful future nation that we wanted to build. The constitution has not failed us on most counts, but it couldn't carry us to our dreams in one single area and that is communal harmony. The two main communities are irreconcilable. Hindus do not proselytize and proselytizing is very high on the Muslim (and Christian) agenda. Muslims also dream of capturing political power. This naturally irks the Hindus and they express their resentment through their political choices. Their political choice goes beyond government formation and makes inroads into the working of constitutional bodies. If Muslims voluntarily abandon their desire to convert Hindus, eschew any idea of seizing political power and leave their isolationary habits (like the nakab), our constitution will survive and serve as the engine of progress. Otherwise we will be forever ruled by the Hindu fundamentalists and the cauldron of communal divide will be kept burning so that their regime can come back to power again and again. The responsibility rests on the Muslims and to a tiny extent on the Christians.

[@adamsinghlealadhar6234]

The problem is, even if a cm of a state sticks his neck out to improve things, he ends up in jail. If a police officer says the truth , he is sentenced to life in jail, if a judge tries to find the truth he loses his life in suspicious circumstances, if a young University graduate tries to talk against injustice , he is sent to rot jail without any charges or court hearing. These actions are not there to serve justice. They are not there to terrorise people but are publicised heavily by the subservient media so no one can raise his or her voice.

[@2shivanand]

Why people in India are to be still spoon feeded regarding what is right or wrong

[@sundarikalyana8121]

Because the politicians are not honest, judiciary is not honest,ECI is not honest.

[@burridevavaraprasad3787]

The opposition didn't go into public and fight on behalf of the people for the last ten years. Only at the time of elections, they come out to the people. But they should continually intouch with them fighting for them. This is the only thing left over for them now. If they start the fight, people will also join them without fail. Now people have understood about media, judiciary and election commission, ED and CBI. All these lost the faith of the people. The only thing the people are looking at is opposition. If opposition also fails to fulfill that gap, the people have no other option leftover except for looking to sky.

[@bennydsouza876]

In the parliament only only person are criticized or attacked instead discussing issues of people n country.

[@surendrakumarsingh4921]

What to say of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the guardian, interpreter and the protector of the Constitution. The democracy herself is ashamed of..

[@bennydsouza876]

This has to be done by all the opposition parties n regional parties. Only then we can save our constitution n country.

[@bennydsouza876]

U r right congress has to establish social conversation with the people throughout not only during election. They have to talk about n arrange talks to the students people youths our rights provisions of the constitution privileges n importance of the constitution of our country. Only then we bring a positive revelation all over the country.

[@sultanaram8095]

कल्याण साहब का तो कहना ही क्या जब संसद में सभी सदस्यों को कह कहा लगाने को मजबूर किया । दो सौ चाली😂😂

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Hindi songs " Insaan kaa kafan bechne walo " Seen in some criminal political leaders in the world????? Is it true or false????

[@HarminderSodhi-sd3sb]

Dear Mr. Sibbal , I would suggest yourself to do these types of programs in Hindi so that the valuable views Penetrate to larger audience of our Society . Thx

[@sreekumarvelupillai6266]

Ordinary people are frighten by stics and the powerful are controlled by carets. .

[@fazlulkarim9123]

Lack of diversity is the main hurdles to protect constitution. All the institutions are heavily loaded by certain castes only. Media is a glaring example of dominance of certain caste only. But when NDIA alliance had taken up the issue of save the constitution it had to depend on the masses who are poorly represented in the institutions.

[@susantajena569]

THE SC & HC MUST FUNCTION UNBIASED AND MAINTAIN AUTONOMY WHICH IS VERY IMPORTANT FOR ANY COUNTRY BECAUSE OF NO POLITICAL PARTIES CAN RULE AS DICTATOR.

[@prakashvenkataramani774]

Heracy - your arguments advanced by Mr Sibal & Mr Dave do not leave room for a future - if change is the need for the hour, new laws would be a requirement - your old views reflect your lack of acceptance towards change.

[@asbmb3332]

Jai shree ram

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Are the Political posting, selection, promotion, transfer etc good for the people/nation welfare in the world?????

[@DineshKothavale-t1b]

By election process we cannot ascertain what sort of person will come to parliament or state legislatures.

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Mind Begs the Question: ▪︎If a PM/Govt ▪︎Reconstitutes Nations Constitution ▪︎Against Freedom Fighters principles ▪︎PM/Govt - Patriot or Traitor?

[@gousebasha7789]

It is very painful

[@DSRao-wu5vp]

How quickly the group , starting from.constitution, converged on Modi !! Amazing - even if Modi or his pic is not there in that room.

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Is the Public charity by the government means TAX money including NRI remittances???? Is it true or false??????

[@dorje4uu]

As on date Union of India has 322 Joint Sectary & Secretary rank officers and if we look in the category-wise breakup are 16 from SC, 13 from ST and 39 from OBC while 254 from general category. What does it tell us about our bureaucracy and what made this regime to induct RSS cadres through lateral entry into our bureaucracy.

[@bennydsouza876]

How to convey this to the parties.

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Is the World Economic indicators for the Indian economy very poor???? Why??? Is it good for the 5 trillion economy targets?????

[@RaimundoSalesColaco]

Thanks Kapil Sir for bringing such distinguish panel for a very relevant SUBJECT to discuss. They really speak from their ❤.🎉

[@AN-yf7sc]

We have failed to follow the constitution

[@J537]

How many promises and rights denied for minorities? Now it’s turn of the majority to suffer under this flawed constitution. It has failed because it was not engineered to recognize the Indian mindset and values.

[@muniswamydayalan4308]

It's pity majority of our people are ignorant of politics and facts, unless you all reach the people with their heart language you may not see the desired results.

[@gopalporuri9685]

Dave says Modi is projected everywhere and it happens in dictatorships or communist countries. What did the Gandhi dynasty do? 400+ institutions, roads, awards and many other facilities in their names. Thats not dictatorship. Art 356 was used by the dynasty about 80 times plus they also broke down govts by hook or crook using methods other than art 356. Judge Bahirul Islam was a HC judge, became a RS member of Congress and then became the SC judge. Kashmiri pandits genocide & exodus cases was not taken by the courts and neither was sikh genocide of Delhi taken by the courts. TN Seshan fought on Congress ticket after retirement. When Congress did all the wrongs and destroyed the constitution and these people take a moral high ground. They are not introspecting what wrongs they did. During UPA time, SC itself called CBI "caged parrots" during UPA. Sickening.

[@dineshchandersharma2451]

They were correct because law is for those who believe it.

[@manojoza2609]

India needs strong but sensible Opposition as true democracy to function. This negative approach and hence counter actions from BJP would only harm the country. All those involved in this process are guilty and need to introspection of their active or passive role. It is need of the time.

[@williamsavim427]

The is hope in Parliament , politicians come and enjoy luxurious life, tell so many lies, they are wasting public money, not all but most

[@jishnubiswas7912]

Opposition parties/regional parties do not have a reaction to the 5 KG free ration to 85 crore Indians by the Modi Govt. Instead, most of the regional parties adopted free bees for voters

[@mohammedarifullah6916]

Sir call Owaisi as well, as he is having a good insight about the minorities.

[@lakshyakumar2707]

Why no such debates have a member of ruling agenda?

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Are the religiously Orthodox democracies nations happy in the world????? Is it true or false?????

[@JackFernandes-h8t]

The Constitution of Bharat / India will be not udestand by Birla and Ranga that’s why they do all the patangad of our country, only Supreme Court is the wright person

[@sm9214]

Be it Partition or separate constitution for the J & K and the NE...... Only the minorities been and continue to be in control. Even now, they reserve the rights. Why do you worry about the constitution which Nehru himself wasn't in control visavis Kashmir or the mutilated India?

[@milindmbart]

Yes sir, This is real agenda of RSS. RSS Hinduism is based on Manusmruti, that is on castisum and in such castisum, Brahmin has been Supremo. Please seriously note.

[@umeshsawatkar8104]

😢 Sushant Dave is a tyalanted to aware the Jurisdiction of India Today around, Since 10 yrs, What is contribution for social responsibility n justice by Modi?

[@AJ-ld1mi]

Maharashtra Reelection should be done again and boycott election commission, you brilliant people should do something, can't give Maharashtra in the hands of Adani( Dharavi and airport land) who's going to rule India, expose election commission doing election research as kejriwal did for Delhi

[@sendhilselvan5009]

Republic must be practiced at the Congress party as well... We have immense knowledgeable guys in India... The top guy.. then why revolve around Gandhi's?

[@subamchoudhury9268]

India despite a secular country has minority commission,muslim personal law board,waqf board i don't know how 🤔

[@kalaimani5424]

No fare election!! ?? how should people show the rejection????

[@surendrakumarsingh4921]

The representatives of the people betrayed people. What a mockery of democracy (the mother of crippled democracy).?

[@dimpu603]

Bring people from both perspectives.....Here we all know your ideology....it like a Monologue or propaganda.... Don't behave like the godi media....Debate should have PPL from both sides and let the audience come to conclusion.

[@hirak47fly]

Kapil Sibal should not be glorified on any media channel

[@kalidasa_in]

Only corrupt Modani should be glorified.

[@sundarikalyana8121]

Andh bhakth 😂😂

[@ParveenKumar-ek7uf]

Very nice Episode, zist of debate we failed constitution, institution politisized, burocracy master's voice, religion spreads inequality. Secularism only saves humanity.❤🎉👍🙏🙌❤

[@KrishnaKumar-so6gr]

स्वदेशी तालिबानी करण।

[@chaudharyramkashyap1598]

MONEY HAS A BIG ROLE, CORRUPTION IS RAMPANT IN ALMOST ALL THE DEPARTMENTS, SO BRIBERY BY ONE WAY OR THE OTHER IS WORKING AND AFFECTING THE LIFE OF PEOPLE. SIR YOU PEOPLE BEING ADVOCATE KNOW BETTER HOW TO DEFEND THE THINGS WHETHER TRUE OR FALSE.

[@adarshmahajan3938]

All the problems start from the very top. Do you realise that?

[@chaudharyashraf4152]

Fragile

[@sendhilselvan5009]

Congress must remove Gandhi's... If not continue to keep discussing topics like this...

[@sundarikalyana8121]

First modani should be removed from India.

[@wokiltiwari4644]

तुम्हारे जैसे बुद्धिजीबी लोग ही फिर से भारत ko बिभाजित karega

[@frederickpicardo6784]

Dawood style of Administration.

[@abhidelight]

Mr Sibal have some courage. Invite Mr J sai Deepak. Also invite 100 of your cabal. One j sai deepak aginst 100 LEFt experts. Jai sai deepak will win easily

[@sauravbehera8364]

peter pettigrew 😂

[@Voguish04]

why just talk, but no work?

[@darshanc.s.4294]

We are great as a Nation..Neither constitution has failed us.. Nor we have failed the constitution.. The matter of fact is you have failed since 2014..😂😂so taking up these nonsense issues for setting narratives..

[@abhidelight]

Mr Sibal why you bother to trouble the people join you in this discussion..you call champions of appeasement politics. It is better that you do a monologue on you tube. That will sufice your requirement

[@angelbaybi997]

The only thing troubling thing today is the J.I.H.A.D.I REGIME...thnx to God you have modi n bjp...they follow the constitution law n democracy...the J.I.H.A.D.I REGIME doesnt...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦

[@r.j804]

Dushyant sir please ek baar...once more once more.😂😂😂

[@advhariomjindal]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/r4abimenmJ14l9ksi=vO-GYaWt08EiQ5N_

[@Samuel-fn2hl]

Corrupt people talking about democracy 😂😂

[@KrishnaKumar-so6gr]

Wrong. Corrupt top politician.

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Is the public interested in the political leaders HMV (his master voice)???? Is it good for the democracies nations /people welfare?????