Has the war in Ukraine changed Russia? - BBC News

As Russia prepares for the New Year holidays, the BBC's Russia Editor Steve Rosenberg takes to the streets of Moscow to see how the invasion of Ukraine has changed Russia in 2022 and to consider where the world’s biggest country is heading.
Please subscribe HERE bit.ly/1rbfUog
#Russia #Ukraine #BBCNews

[@IFOLMUSIC]

I, as a person living in the province of Russia (the city of Chelyabinsk), can say one answer, many brands, a lot of clothes, furniture left Russia, but in Russia there are always similar brands, though not always the best, the price of food has increased, from 10% to 200 %, but life in Russia has not changed significantly. I wish that all the troubles that began in the world, in 2022, end in 2023 and that people begin to live like in 2019, even before the coronavirus and war! :) Happy New Year! Happy 2023!

[@spammerscammer]

You are so smug you piece of sht. I hope those patriot missles make it to your neighborhood.

[@paulmasterson386]

Happy new year to you,too!

[@bardgold4553]

@@paulmasterson386 your country needs to learn from China and focus on economy, not having a dick measuring contest in syria and urkaine.

[@yaboidre5672]

Happy New Year! Hang in there, Putin will get what's coming to him. The history books say so. Regards from the States!

[@april3022]

but it will change soon - we hunger you out !!!!

[@Immortal-Daiki]

"But we're peace loving people." Meanwhile sends her son to fight in an criminal war

[@albertalberto9988]

So sad

[@kenlompart9905]

Brainwashed.

[@McSonR]

I believe she didnt; those who sent and got them back in plastic packets changed their opinion about the government and this war

[@YagrumBagarn]

That's rich

[@noone-ug8eg]

well to you thats criminal war, to her it is not...And for me it's just a regular war

[@TimohaNorveg]

As an ethnic Russian who’s living in Norway since childhood, I feel horrible about the thing’s happening in both Russia and Ukraine. I have close family members in Russia and a lot of both Russian and Ukrainian friends…and I can’t see and meet them because of this brutal, devastating and stupid war. Hope that 2023 will be less bloody than the previous year, and that this war ends as soon as possible. Happy and peaceful New Year to everyone 🙏🏻

[@ender_cp8918]

where were you for 8 years while the Ukrainian military shelled the peaceful cities of the DPR and LPR?

[@Silk_WD]

I have a russian coworker that grew up in Sweden. I also have an ukrainian coworker. The situation seem to be quite tough for both, though of course for slightly different reasons.

[@SAGAWISIW30]

Blame uncle SAM and West they let brothers hate and kill each other

[@TheDarkAKA]

@@ender_cp8918 why was Ukraine bombing their territory? Could it be that there was a special operation under way since then?😆

[@aizenmorningstar]

@@SAGAWISIW30 imagine blaming the west to excuse the actions of a Russian dictator. F'off loser.

[@avaoliver6691]

Compliments of the season to everyone reading this...but the most important thing that should be on everyone's mind should be to invest in different sources of income that doesn't depend on the government expecially with the current economic crisis around the world...this is still a good time to invest in various stocks,gold,silver and other digital currencies...Despite the price fluctuations in crypto am still earning weekly profits investing under the best trader in the world Mrs Mary Nicholls,she has the best trading strategies.

[@lucywilson4046]

I've tried this some time ago but it wasn't successful, but I do get positive news about how it has elevate people financially. Please how do I invest with crypto currency? legit platform, please

[@Jamie-ly6gc]

Mrs Mary Nicholls remains my number one broker for life,I invested $7500 with her and I was credited $45080 in a 7days interval.Mrs Mary Nicholl's is a teacher not only a broker...

[@johnnyfrank2328]

Wow, I'm so happy to meet with Mary Nicholls again,she was my good broker some months ago and we did nice business together, I never regretted investing with her.

[@ramseycollins3177]

Does this work perfectly? I do hear of crypto currency everywhere, and I'm kinda interested Please lead me to the right platform.

[@benlucas6000]

Having a coach is the key in this volatile market...my advisor is Mrs Mary Nicholls, you can easily look her up,she has years of financial market experience

[@rodrigoff7456]

1:57 That is a very macabre look for someone saying "we are peace loving people"

[@fintonmainz7845]

She believes what she is saying.

[@alexanderpepkin4110]

We are peaceful people but our tanks are always ready

[@Randomstuffs261]

She's delusional

[@briancarno8837]

@@alexanderpepkin4110 with snakes like the US in your back yard.. they would have to be

[@fanielmaria3621]

She is absolutely brilliant yes look Iraq, lybia, Syria, Afghanistan those are victim of USA

[@jamiedunham6759]

I'm United States born and I want peace with both Ukraine and Russia. I don't know you person to person but fighting just produces more suffering, on everyone parts, I don't want anyone to suffer so much as they did in the past, I just want us to work as a team and work together to make things better for everyone. Much love from over here, I hope it reaches some of you. I DO NOT WANT A WAR WITH MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS! 🇺🇲🇷🇺🇺🇦🙏📿✌️☮️

[@bobdown1720]

Thank you Jamie.. Have a peaceful and happy new year 👍

[@Iridescent_Astraea]

If Russia wants peace they can leave Ukraine. But it appears they are more interested in conquest and acting like they're still the Soviet Union/Russian Empire with an army of expendable serfs to march off to die.

[@underdog.1]

Hi Jamie, I'm from Russia, Saratov city I absolutely support your words, despite this video, I know for sure that very, very many people are against this war, and we know that we will ultimately defeat our own rulers and zombified fellow citizens

[@stanleypomogiti8633]

@@underdog.1 amen my fellow Russian brother!

[@_v_5931]

Stop sponsoring terrorists in Ukraine and stop sending weapons to kill Russian people.

[@kristinameln9427]

Stalin once said:"I always thought that demicracy is the power of the people, but comrade Roosrvelt clearly explained to me that democracy is the power of the american people".

[@pro61ema]

but you don't understand that Russia is like the Nazis in '39? there are such sick people, they support killings, they say how they want to destroy everyone, especially America, and this is what ordinary citizens say

[@yanasonina]

I'm surprised you showed the shops full of food (it's true) usually western media show that Russians starve (not true). But the video itself is about nothing - winter and sad music. If you apply here Jingle Bells song this video will immediately look happier. The video is about nothing because there's really not much changed, prices are maybe +5% , some of them got cheaper. For me the most important change is a difficulty with payments while traveling ( I had to make another bank account and it's harder to get money from abroad)+ some flights became longer + I often got banned because I'm Russian. As for those who really fight in Ukraine: if you talk to real people who just came back from there - they'll tell you who they were fighting. There are proves, videos, photos that its not Ukrainians. You know it, dear BBC, but you'll never show it we all know that. "Russia's victory in the war against Ukraine will be a defeat of NATO.”: Stoldeberg, NATO secretary

[@LongMax]

- How much sad piano music do you want for this video? - Yes.

[@sarfaraz.hosseini]

The video is about brainwashed Z Zombies like you and your Neo Imperialist Nazi ideology. Let's hope your students get a decent teacher and education one day. Like Germans after the defeat of Nazism. Most Russians don't live in Moscow or St. Petersburg. They live in abject poverty. Enjoy your stolen washing machines.

[@glebkomentator]

@@LongMax )))) And of course... - How many dialogues with russians do you want to include in the video? - There can be only one!

[@MRRJ6549]

Well since the price of food isn't what the west focused on with the sanctions why is it the only factor Russians mention? How about the microchip ban? How about the industrial equipment that your entire economic output is based on can no longer be repaired? The price of food, for a country that produces a lot of food isn't going to change with trade sanctions why even mention it

[@Tonik-13]

@@MRRJ6549 The West has focused its sanctions to kill the Russian economy. A destroyed economy will necessarily lead to greater inflation, including for products and basic necessities, even if they are of domestic production. 25 years ago there were no destructive Western sanctions, but there was hyperinflation. We in Russia suddenly discovered for ourselves that Chinese cars are no worse than Japanese ones...

[@senadmarovic3530]

Humans never learn from their mistakes we are our own worst enemies

[@Oriares]

Humans are literal cancer on this planet, causing destruction and spreading rapidly

[@delightfullynot7220]

@@aimlessdrive8723 that's coming soon, if you have a gauge on the fake reality they have as a smoke screen of your existence. And you will believe it when it comes.

[@Crabbyfeet]

The only thing that we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history.

[@saccorhytus]

@@aimlessdrive8723 but even after that well easily be able to go back to war, and it’d become even more devastating with alien tech

[@luisbetebcourt]

tell that tpo the clown...

[@MultiSciGeek]

I'd like to see a more in depth analysis though

[@ltipst2962]

I don't think we could have a better analyst. He's there all the time. Must feel daunting walking around Russia when you know everyone around you wants you dead, obvious or not.

[@johnmandiram]

Provide Security Guarantees to Russia & never include Ukraine in NATO & the War ends & Stop "Inflation".................

[@mikesamovarov4054]

It's a pathetic news channel, what did you expect? 😂 They just repeat each other, nothing original ever. I can tell you as a Russian speking Westerner, Russia is full of conflicts and paradoxes. You'll never get clarity on reasoning of their nasty behaviour. In general, it's a rotten culture with no morals, respect, value for human life, no loguc, no heart. therefore, no future. Whatever little spirituality they had left from the pre-Soviet era, - it's all gone. They are isolated, angry, bitter, suspicious, negative...etc. I do not see any way out for them in the next 100-200 years, minimum.

[@alexanderpepkin4110]

Search for “travelling with Russell” on KZbin. He is Australian who’s been living in Moscow for 8 years

[@peterwallis4602]

Try Anna Politkovskaya, A Russian diary. Anna worked for Novaya Gazeta & was poisoned & assassinated for telling the truth. Putin took care of any opposition & closed down all free press including Novaya Gazeta. Other young investigative journalists were also assassinated. Another good book; Killer in the Kremlin by John Sweeney; 'The explosive account of Putin's reign of terror'. (2022).....including first -hand reporting from Ukraine.

[@user-vo2gj4di2f]

Words said but that woman is not only Russians thoughts. "Russia's victory in the war against Ukraine will be a defeat of NATO.”: Stoldeberg, NATO secretary

[@KyCTaPHNK]

Всем желаю добра и позитива, надеюсь что в мире когда-нибудь будет мирный мир :)

[@sansara2511]

Пока есть НАТА покоя не будет

[@user-vy4fe6xr3j]

Мир наступит, когда не станет сша...

[@gorant_2575]

@@sansara2511 Кид, пока такие люди как путлер будут жить, то и мира не будет

[@sansara2511]

@@gorant_2575 ок ЦІПСО

[@MRRJ6549]

We wish you well here too, it isn't the Russian public's fault your political leader is a murdering madman

[@123slither]

Peace and democracy for Ukraine and Russia

[@uw0tm838]

Nah, screw Russia

[@jakexgold3879]

LOL! The human rat race is art! For a fully effective sanction on Russia, it would mean to destroy Russia as much as Russia are doing it to Ukraine, this means to destroy another biggest food basket of this planet, since Russia already destroyed Ukraine the big food basket, then to make the sanction on Russia successful, the world needs to the in the seat of the devil and destroy or partly destroy Russia. So the conclusion is that Putin already had this theory in mind, he pretty much knows too well himself is the devil to start it all with! So much source of food and oil and supplies for the world would be destroyed when the world takes war on Russia, over 700 millions of people would die, this is what the stupid Russians are saying “The sanctions ain’t working, because NATO and UN are too soft and too much humanity! we as the Russians are the pure evil and knows too well how to kill populations off this planet!”.

[@123slither]

@@uw0tm838 You won`t get peace in Ukraine until there is peace in Russia

[@gilh3947]

@@123slither most Russians are perfectly happy in their dictatorship. They are now fighting a near holy war against NATO in their minds

[@dukenukem8381]

@@123slither its a colonial empire

[@Ahero0fAfrica-6789]

“There is no single model of democracy, or of human rights, or of cultural expression for all the world. But for all the world, there must be democracy, human rights, and free cultural expression.”─ KOFI ANNAN was the 7th Secretary-General of the United Nations, from 1997 to 2006

[@janari64]

What is cultura?

[@beautifulempatheticliberal5204]

The BBC are getting desperate. The truth is that the world despises liberalism

[@gavinreid2741]

Neo Euroasianism is worth studying.

[@hasanamir132]

The late Koffi Annan lectured nonsense During his admin in UN the hardest n sufferred people on earth is the Palestinians The weakest leadership who sided the ONLY WEST

[@gilh3947]

It is best to add how you want to apply this on the current situation.

[@0nich]

Фраза про мобилизованные новогодние декорации так-то является хорошей шуткой, но при этом подана под такую грустную музыку

[@klausko5682]

Даже в таком красивом городе как Москва, чудесно украшенном к новогодним праздникам, Вы увидели только горы снега, символ z и бедно одетых людей. К счастью, в интернете много других видео о Москве и России, не все люди на Земле поддаются проамериканской пропаганде! Всё у нас в России стабильно, магазины полные разнообразных товаров, люди верят нашему президенту Путину и желают ему крепкого здоровья и долгих лет жизни! Не получится западным руссофобам уничтожить Россию! Россия жила, живёт и будет жить! Мира и счастья всем хорошим людям во всех странах мира! А западных поджигателей войны ждёт божий суд, честный и справедливый! Если бы НАТО не обмануло Россию, не расширила свои границы вплотную до России, если бы Америка не устроила цветную революцию в Украине в 2004 и 2014 году, не накачало Украину оружием, не разжигало руссофобию, не сделала из Украины анти-Россию, то войны бы не было. Украина должна быть нейтральной страной, не входить в милитаризованный блок НАТО. Ведь в наше время НАТО служит не только для защиты, но и для нападения, установления прозападных режимов по всему миру. Россия никогда не будет американским вассалом, как европейские страны! Мир должен быть многополярным и учитывать интересы всех стран. Только мир нужен на нашей планете, чтобы наши дети и внуки были счастливы, чтобы люди из разных стран боролись только на олимпийских играх, устанавливая новые рекорды.

[@ekaterinasanko8180]

Поддерживаю 👍🏻

[@tati_tanusiya]

Солидарна. 🫶

[@saharow]

Отличный ответ, выражает точку зрения большинства Россиян из провинции

[@ekaterinasanko8180]

@@saharow это сарказм? Тогда поделитесь своей точкой зрения

[@unknown-x-1777]

That lady was so smug, she'd have a different look on her face if the war was at her doorsteps.

[@moiseshuerta3984]

War is at Russias doorstep. Ukraine is sending missles to Russia. Turn on your tv. Watch the news.

[@maxibalkan1578]

That lady was tipycal example of russian mom they are all like that bad people you can feel her voice the way she talks. Can wait for summer when all russians come to my coutry for the sea season to spit on them.

[@moiseshuerta3984]

@@maxibalkan1578s Stop with all your HATE SPEACH. "Spitting at Russians"??? Go spit at a mirror.

[@maxibalkan1578]

@@moiseshuerta3984 😀😀😀 you got angry , it is nonsence to speak to people and tell them what do to the fact that you do it speaks about your capacity

[@moiseshuerta3984]

@@maxibalkan1578 More like appalled.

[@centurionzen1005]

When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace.

[@mirola73]

I.e. never, be realistic.

[@elementoneutr0]

Love has no power in geopolitics

[@animalia5554]

We have the illusion that if we have power we can protect the things we care about, but the truth is that our abilities are limited. Still this is always something hard for us to accept, hence why we keep needing to relearn the same lessons.

[@user-zh6ot4nx2e]

As Russian, I can name few changes not mentioned here. Russia did changed a lot as HUGE amount of people, especially males left the country. This change can be noticed on the streets, in the bars and restaurants. I work in IT, and the job market changed a lot too. Some companies has been closed, the noticeable shortage in open jobs happened. Also the salaries in IT, which were enormous comparing to the country average wage, has shortened or at least stopped growing. Some of my very educated professionala friends struggle to find a job, and I need you to understand, it was not a thing in Russian IT field for last years. Also the atmosphere itsrlf has changed. Everyone is now expecting more shit to happen. Everyone feels helpless and see no efforts can change anything. For some, the problem of "father and son conflict" can be very noticeable, even "touchable in the air", as older generation falls for propaganda more, and younger generation less. But there are changes rising inside minds, I did notice that on my parent as well as my friends. The older generation begins asking questions.

[@thaitraveller9756]

Do not follow the western path russia wants to steer clear of the west which is so corrupt Your countries leader stands up for its people the west are just greedy,well I'll say western governments but the worst is america Alot of people in a america living on the streets no health care but they can give billions of dollars to Ukraine you've got to ask why because the governments don't care about the people Russia needs to stay strong or be ruined All these job shortages in it also happening in the west too its called progress especially in ai

[@Zaultek]

Что изменилось так это то что дерьмо называющее себя интеллигенцией сбежало из страны и раскрытие кто есть кто, ты такой же кусок дерьма

[@user-or7og3eu4g]

Не нужно говорить от имени ВСЕХ русских!!! Такие как вы МЕНЬШИНСТВО!!!

[@Zaultek]

@@user-or7og3eu4g А таких как вы? Давайте попробую угадать к кому вы относитесь , наверное к моральным уродам как Невзоров ,Гудков , Навальный , Галкин , Латынина , Собчак ? И сколько вас было на всю страну ? Миллиона три с натяжкой . Вы агрессивное меньшинство , предатели своей страны и народа, кто идейный , кто за деньги одним словом гниль.

[@user-or7og3eu4g]

@@Zaultek сейчас не поняла вообще- это вы мне ? Это я за Собчак со компанией ? Прочтите внимательно комментарий " товарища " айтишника на который я ответила Это у него в стране" Фсё плохо" У меня в России ВСЁ замечательно!

[@gregory1492]

I live in Novosibirsk. In the first months of the war, advertisements from billboards disappeared throughout the city. The whole city was in military posters, public transport in military stickers. There were also flags with a military theme on the squares.

[@user-qc9nn2pm8u]

Привет с мжк, земляк)))

[@lmnk]

Ага, помню, были зэтки на каждом, ска, автобусе! Правда, часть уже поотколупали. А ещё довольно много антивоенных граффити, которые, правда, оперативно закрашивали. Сейчас поменьше стало, но все равно приятно, когда куда-то идёшь и вдруг видишь зелёную ленточку, или корявое "МИР" или "35" маркером на столбе)

[@pro61ema]

but you don't understand that Russia is like the Nazis in '39? there are such sick people, they support killings, they say how they want to destroy everyone, especially America, and this is what ordinary citizens say

[@ferouu]

Согласен, привет из прокудского, недалеко от НСК, это ужасно

[@gregory1492]

@@pro61ema I talked about the appearance of the city. you accuse me of misunderstanding. I am a liberal with an excellent education and I will not kowtow to you on principle.

[@victoriaporozova]

As a Russian, yes, it has. I can confirm that this alternative pov is widespread :( "although we are peace loving ppl" hits me the most

[@NaZelensky]

Alternative is sarmat to Washington?

[@gagogagic4807]

SLAVA SLAVIA!

[@asdadadsaasd]

Stay safe in Russia

[@gagogagic4807]

Srbija turšijo!

[@CheeseBae]

@@NaZelensky a nuclear strike on the USA would result in a full scale nuclear retaliation by the USA. There will be no Russia or Russian people after we respond. Be careful what you wish for.

[@TheFlyingEpergne]

I'd like to have seen a documentary with a bit more substance, this felt very surface-level. Interviewed 1 woman, looked in some shops, said "this feels weird lol"

[@davidtwittey4613]

I agree it was a good opportunity to look back thru' 2022 & the perceived perceived in Russia but one interview is unusual. Maybe Rosenberg interviewed more and it was cut to fit a news program? A longer piece 40mins or an hour would be welcome. As someone has already commented I am surprised the regime that now puts the 'Z' symbol on the New Year decorations ie. has that control over minutiae lets the BBC free press commentate?! Perhaps that is the answer. There were more interviews but The Kremlin screened it and allowed only a pro-regime cut to be released?!! Who knows but we need more with balanced reporting ......

[@talaris-uk]

Completely agree

[@Welldone7742]

the journalist's face is like an alcoholic's. 3

[@Welldone7742]

Everything is very good in Russia 🇷🇺

[@oldbloke135]

@@Welldone7742 You mean everything is very good in Moscow and St Petersburg. It's probably not so good in the regions whose men have been thrown into the meat grinder. Away from the protected big cities, a hundred thousand families are facing a very bleak new year.

[@theredsamuraiAlbion]

I can say it changed how the world saw them.

[@user-cn6is2ln4e]

Не понятно чему тут удивляются.То есть ,если по всему миру транслируется повестка от Украины с поддержкой НАТО это считается нормальным,но если в России по своему пропагандируют это уже ненормально.BBC раньше нормальными были но уйдя в политику скатились.

[@moisieiev7124]

Нет свободе слова врагам свободы слова

[@user-cn6is2ln4e]

@@moisieiev7124 а кого ты относишь к врагам свободе слова?

[@moisieiev7124]

@@user-cn6is2ln4e госпропаганду РФ. Дай им право голоса, так они сразу запретят всех тех кто с ними несогласен

[@kidnamedfinger6323]

1:53 defend from what?????? No one was attacking Russia! The Russian victim complex is truly something to behold.

[@In_Cor_Cadit]

Victim complex? You've probably never heard of a country like Poland

[@aderachmat5163]

"If there is a country that has committed UNSPEAKABLE ATROCITIES in the world, it is the United States of America. They don't care for human beings." - Nelson Mandela

[@karenhedger8504]

Take good care Mr Roesenburg and thank you for your updates. Happy New Year....

[@Cristinamair]

Concordo inteiramente : se trata de uma guerra entre a Nato e a Rússia e em última análise, entre USA e Rússia . Os Russos são um povo admirável , independente e que não de curva

[@drakehonest2]

Hey how are you doing…?

[@pro61ema]

but you don't understand that Russia is like the Nazis in '39? there are such sick people, they support killings, they say how they want to destroy everyone, especially America, and this is what ordinary citizens say

[@indetermite]

MEAT RIDAAAAAAAA

[@ivanpaniagua6914]

Sim, são pessoas admiráveis.

[@user-fv4vt9pb8e]

You are crazy, girl

[@schmetterling4477]

Intelligent men and their families are leaving by the hundreds of thousands. Does a country get changed by that? Of course, just not to the better.

[@Ihatehuman666]

Millions of intelligent men and their families stayed though

[@cougars_3471]

@@Ihatehuman666 you mean the one who got drafted before they can escape?

[@schmetterling4477]

@@Ihatehuman666 Only idiots are staying. Many of them will pay with their lives for that stupidity.

[@arina7444]

You should know that the war in Ukraine was not started by the legitimate President Turchynov in 2014. On March 16, 2014, he sent tanks to unarmed people in the Donbass (East of Ukraine). On March 16, 2014, there were no volunteers from Russia in Ukraine. Girkin-Strelkov arrived in Slavyansk only on April 12, 2014. Tanks have been crushing unarmed people in Donbass since March 16, 2014. On March 20, the first participants in a rally against Turchinov and against the Nazis were killed in Kharkov. On May 2, 2014, the Nazis burned peaceful Ukrainian protesters in Odessa. In the Donbass, Ukrainian planes bombed parks and houses. Civilians died there. The war in Ukraine began on March 16, 2014. Putin ends this war.

[@XigH-uu6eq]

@@aizenmorningstar Чем лучше ты?

[@VladislavDoroshuk]

Попытка создать ощущение депрессии на ровном месте, с помощью съёмки и музыки. Живу в России, для меня не изменилось ничего. Под грустную музыку лучше покажите толпы бомжей в Калифорнии.

[@miklukhomaclay7621]

Based

[@grifonguitarast1874]

Очередная жертва пропоганды. При чём тут бомжи в Калифорнии еблан?

[@VladislavDoroshuk]

@@grifonguitarast1874 тут только ты eблaн. Какой пропаганды, я жил в Калифорнии. Пусть свою парашу покажут под депрессивное музло

[@user-px8eu1ev7o]

Для теья ничего не изменилось на россии? Асё так же стдишь на продавленном диване..в коммуналке, с бутылкой пива и смотришь передачки про вяличие россии и русофобию всемирную? Всё поддерживаешь старого поца путина? Работаешь охранником в Пятёрочке! Ну что же может по сути измениться в твоём Зажопинске? НИЧЕГО Ты не соврал

[@VladislavDoroshuk]

@@user-px8eu1ev7o ты описываешь какой-то свой опыт? Что это?

[@sunseeker8457]

From what I understand. A lot of the brands have NOT left the Russian market at all. They have just been re-branded and are STILL selling in the shops. Even the shop names have changed a little, but selling the original brands that we have been told have been brand. The Russian market is big business and companies would lose a truck load of money if they really pulled out!

[@XigH-uu6eq]

Так и есть, еда просто изменила свои названия, но вкус остался тот же. А брендовые вещи завозятся из соседних стран, например Казахстана

[@wilhelmu]

the brand left, the infrastructure remained.

[@sunseeker8457]

@@wilhelmu kzbin.info/www/bejne/eZ6yaHWIlLmkZpY

[@prettylittleliar9701]

​@@XigH-uu6eq Especially McDonald's and Starbucks

[@XigH-uu6eq]

@@prettylittleliar9701 Насчёт старбакса не уверен, он действительно закрыт. Но Burger King, KFC, McDonalds(tasty, thats it) работают. Но появляются новости что KFC закрывается на ребрендинг

[@johannes1498]

So horrible that the war is just not ending, thank you for this video!

[@hyy3657]

Dilemma. Totally dilemma. Seems like Russia still have the ability to fight and honestly, that is not the good sign. But people should not suffer either, very mixed mood IMO.

[@williamplayfair364]

it is just starting

[@abdulimraan2706]

Budapest Memorandum - Wikipedia The Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances comprises three substantially identical political agreements signed at the OSCE conference in Budapest, ... Russia argued that the United States broke the third point of the agreement by introducing and threatening further sanctions against the Yanukovych government.

[@abdulimraan2706]

Newsweek WORLD Russia Inflicts Heavy Losses on Ukraine as Battle of Bakhmut Rages-Report BY BRENDAN COLE WORLD UKRAINE RUSSIA WAR Moscow's forces have inflicted heavy losses on Ukrainian troops in the battle for Bakhmut in eastern Ukraine, according to an assessment that comes as NATO warned the war could escalate into "full-fledged" conflict between Russia and the alliance. The Institute for the Study of War (ISW) said on Friday that Russian forces had conducted assault operations in Bakhmut itself and to the north and south of the city in the Donetsk oblast, which is the center of fierce fighting.

[@ianjohnson3770]

@@abdulimraan2706 and how does that relate to Russia invading Ukraine?

[@EdwardLawrence-12345]

🇮🇷 ✊🏻🌺 You are delivering a powerful message that injustice should not be tolerated. There are surely difficult days ahead, and our hearts go out to those who have tragically lost loved ones in Iran. But we believe that the future will ultimately belong to the young women and girls of Iran who are refusing to be silent

[@os-vp1hv]

Ha ha

[@farukkalgo4590]

😂😂😂😂 stupid dumb

[@tigertoo01]

Injustice is everywhere. This is one injustice you are taking notice of.

[@ShatabdaRoy115]

this vid is about russia not iran.

[@bbcisaids6727]

Baaaa

[@bookman5430]

This is pure drama, the way music is used to build to a crescendo, the intonation in the actor's...I mean journalist's voice, the way he widens his eyes to emphasise his exaggerated phrases, bravo sir! You have truly honed your craft. I can't believe that a vast majority of the British public listen to this and actually believe this to be real, it's very worrying the propaganda that is staring you in the face. Please wake up people!

[@ReneMedia]

Journalist: It feels really strange Russia: *same as always*

[@mashapetriva5386]

Мы понимаем, что вы хотите увидеть более удручающую картину, но даже грустная музыка не помогла испортить картину

[@Lisichkin_Topishe31]

@@user-su6ib7te7p База

[@_CatBug_]

Something I fight everyday as an American vet, is we basically did the same thing in Iraq under the guise of WMDs. Was their leader genocidal and were there terrorist networks? Yes but we really had no business being there at the time in the grand scheme. We were there for oil control and to get a foothold which served it's purpose for Afghanistan. Seeing the change in Russia reminds me of how everything changed in the US when we entered our 20+ year on terrorism.

[@mariosefardi-casella2730]

Really?? The US has annexed Iraq, right???

[@akiogood4712]

the americans were a genocidal and satanic force that murdered more than a million Iraqis. I'm glad that the Talibán defeated the usa

[@andrezcabara2774]

Big difference, though. The USA has not annexed portions of the country or targeted civilians. Oil control? If so, where's that control now? The USA was attacked on 9/11 and responded. Yes, it was unjust, but without 9/11, and without "informers" lying about the existence of WMD, there would have been no invasion into Iraq. 5000 people lost their lives on 9/11. There was more to come. Something had to be done. Russia was not attacked and there was no NATO threat. 9/11 was real.

[@akiogood4712]

@@andrezcabara2774 I'm very happy that the Talibán defeated the genocidal savage americans who murdered more than a million Iraqi civilians. plus, you should get a life because obviously, you're an incel with no life

[@andrezcabara2774]

@@akiogood4712 Are you happy that the Taliban now tells your women they can't go to school or work or drive a car?

[@VitalityMassage]

Did you think it would last forever... especially with the internet connecting everyone?

[@cikorasikorskiy1486]

Этому вещателю нужно было найти в Москве стройку и вещать от туда. Чтобы совсем всё казалось ужасным...

[@fleshka4903]

🤯To be honest, I was shocked when I heard some of the answers from the inhabitants of my country. Sometimes it is unexpected to find out that someone's opinion is different from yours ... I am confused and sincerely hope that everyone will be fine. Rush you and be happy!❤️❤️

[@leonbeaufort7660]

My thoughts are with the innocents that suffer at this time.

[@ShadowKari]

There are no innocents in russia.

[@Oresei]

@@ShadowKari after mobilization, 60% of russians support peace

[@HeadsetHatGuy]

@@ShadowKari 🤡

[@ShadowKari]

@@HeadsetHatGuy 🤡

[@Iv40]

@@ShadowKari ooo just don't cry much 😢😢😢

[@Elmachable]

It's hard for western people to understand how russian mindset works even harder for russian to explain it .

[@zaenkmus]

Yes good comment.

[@d4sp1d3r]

They are better educated and informed, not so easily manipulated by emotionally potent over-simplifications.

[@kentonian]

State run media peddle lies constantly so even if Russians don’t fully by it their is still some mind rot

[@chrisj2502]

Western people wouldn't care if America had invaded Ukraine and that's the truth

[@NameRiioz]

You can try to explain, they'll call you a brainwashed Russian bot. That's the whole dialogue.

[@seriouscandy8791]

Without the piano music this would just be a regular vid, piano can make things so much sadder, sneaky news

[@elenadrachyovs4151]

Could you please put better music in background and tell about how much prices increased in UK for food, services etc? Also, please tell how many UK citizens fighting against me and people alike myself??

[@Yeosprings]

Would be good to see more videos from the BBC from a street perspective, perhaps slightly longer though and interviewing more people.

[@stephenhill545]

Rosenberg does good reports. Old school balanced journalism.

[@bastiendezutter]

Check out channel 1420, that’s exactly what you’re looking for

[@dulsinea958]

I'm from Moscow, 95% ppl agree with that women 👍

[@bobdown1720]

They probably did interview more people but didn't get the answers they wanted?

[@leoh6596]

@@dulsinea958 count me in😀

[@leeselset5751]

I feel sorry for the people there who are going to come to the same realization about this as I came to about Iraq, that the war is not just, and is costing them a massive, horrible price while giving them nothing in return.

[@nick_no1]

Russians will never admit to having realized that they have collectively been brainwashed

[@TheGesox]

War gives massiv Returns just not for ordinary people

[@morho9422]

while you watch blair getting knighthood. the same blair who got re-elected after he invaded irak.

[@biggusdickus5986]

@@morho9422 He should be locked up and Bush.

[@coffeelink943]

but Russia is just trying to prevent a World War 3 from happening. If Ukraine approved and join NATO then NATO will have control of Ukrainian nuclear power plant which will have foothold into Russia boarder. Why can’t the west at least try to understand Russian point of view? It’s the same thing how American feels with the Cuban missile crisis

[@melanapana9783]

Очень забавно наблюдать, какое большое количество в комментариях жалких и ноющих людей, а так же пугливых патриотов и айтишников, которые любят Родину оттуда, где жопа в тепле. Наши войны сейчас защищают интересы России, а вы себя вот так ведёте, ноетесь, жалуетесь, противно смотреть. Не хотите чтобы ваша жизнь была таким дерьмом, помогите людям Донбасса, дончанам и луганчанам, нашим новым соотечественникам. Эти люди заслужили нашей поддержки и любви. Как только вы увидите, в каких условиях эти люди жили, работали и воевали, Ваши проблемки с покупками айфона и уехавшими айтишниками будут уже далеко. А так же меня поразило обилие людей, которые считают, что старшее поколение наелось пропаганды, а мы, молодое поколение, уже не "хаваем говно из теленовостей".... Господи боже, если ты подписан хотя бы на 1 телеграмм канал с военкором, новостями или блоггера, поздравляю, ты хаеваешь пропаганду :D Просто шутка в том, что тебе кажется, что раз ты согласен с этим чуваком, то это и твоё мнение тоже. Так и работает информационная война. Старшее поколение хватает одно, мы хаваем другое.

[@user-ev7xh5xx6q]

Полностью поддерживаю комментарий! Мне 23 и я не понимаю своих сверстников. Все как стадо баранов восхваляют Навального (хотя я не понимаю за что) и им бы дать повод полить грязью все связанное с Россией.

[@trainerred6990]

Это не наши войны в Украине, это позорники. Во всей этой ситуации главные виновники это основатели этих недо-республик.

[@dimadear]

he's forgotten to show the original Coca-Cola from different countries imported to Russia and you can find it in every grocery store literally (even in small ones) I do not like BBC for understatement that makes people think differently. but I like some documentaries though

[@CookRacingUK]

I really feel sorry for that lady, completely brainwashed. It shows for a functioning world, media *must* be free of government or business control. Objective journalism is more important than ever before. We may scoff, but alarmingly there are smaller parallels with what's been happening in the UK!

[@titteryenot4524]

Translation: she disagrees with me.

[@dannggg]

@@titteryenot4524 yes she disagrees about peace and ending the war.

[@kirikoo9981]

Why you hate Russia so much? Are you brainwashed by the western world? You think war should be wagging by you and your friends on poor nations like Iraq, Libia, Afghanistan, Africa, Yemen. You think you are exceptionalism to bring wars to other nations while sitting drinking your hot cup of coffee.

[@adrianlloyd6403]

'Media must be free of government or business control'.....good luck with that piece of idealism.

[@dalecrocker3213]

But she was speaking the truth. Are you so far gone you can't recognise truth and honesty when you hear it?

[@nada5039]

Happy 😊 New year for all your team.🥳

[@estoupaa]

This video is so well done. The guy managed to make a precise analise of how is Russia today, without bias of being a UK news video (BBC). My friend in Russia used the same arguments that that lady in the begin of the video.

[@user-nm5wt1yl1c]

Вам повезло с другом. Он, к счастью, не глуп!

[@algu4118]

We all have this argument

[@lidiarapp7232]

Надо ещё было показать рестораны на Патриарших, все жрали и плясали как ни в чем не бывало

[@mayaram2411]

If that wasn’t clear since February 24th, 2022, it should be now.

[@drakehonest2]

Hello how are you doing…?

[@user-qp8js5ps5c]

From 21 April and nazie terrorist attacks at peaceful Donbass people.

[@Larsino2000]

we´re peace loving people. *starts the biggest war since WW2*

[@moestietabarnak]

say the Washington neo-con

[@Larsino2000]

@@moestietabarnak funny how people instantly think youre american. On a british channel with the name lars. It confirms youre unable to use logic.

[@WiseMan22]

Somehow everyone is concerned about Nato in Ukraine, and no one is concerned about Nato in Finland. Same Nato, just a few hundered miles apart. The reality is that this has nothing to do with Russias security, and everything to do with restoring the USSR. This is not gonna happen, sorry.

[@ultonian63]

Absolutely spot on. Also, NATO already borders Russia in Norway, the Baltic states and Poland. So the argument that Ukraine joining NATO represented a new threat to Russia was BS, even if there had been any likelihood of it happening. Of course, it is much more likely to happen now!

[@moestietabarnak]

They are not cultivating rabid russophobia in Finland or have a NAZI Regime ... and are not oppressing/killing their ethnic-Russian population. Which Ukraine was doing in the Donbass, and they had 60k-100k troops ready at the border of Donbass to do a PURGE when Putin decided that enough is enough and decided to preempt the UFA attack.

[@Haegemon]

The credo is that Ucraine belongs to them and that fantasy justifies anything. Then they're are talking about nazis with an army which uses rape and extermination as common strategy. Fun fact is Ukranians are indeed russians but russians are not. Moskovian Tzars self-claimed russians because its mythology was more appealing.

[@ultonian63]

@@moestietabarnak only a moron would claim that Ukraine has a Nazi regime. Don’t expect anyone to take you seriously if you spout that kind of nonsense.

[@sergeybebenin]

It's actually worse than that. It's more like what they did to Novgorod in the 16th century. Trying to expand the empire by wiping out nations on their path... Basically a bare land grab.

[@YourDetector]

When the correspondent did his best to find any consequences of the sanctions, but failed..

[@kimmanning2913]

They should've never been forced to fight this war alone.

[@dobriyranok7]

Well, the big difference is (still) open borders: if in the Soviet times it was very difficult to emigrate, for the past 30 years- fairly easy, and resulted in huge brain drain.

[@Grimeyhoob]

Almost every Russian person I know in my industry has either escaped or spoken to me about wanting to escape Russia with their families. The Putin administration has destroyed Russia completely from the inside out. They are a pariah terrorist state with no international reputation left. Only idiot trolls from Africa, China and Russia blindly support the Kremlin like unquestioning parrots who repeat what they are told to say. No respect for Russia. Down with Russia - let’s hope they are fully destroyed soon. No one wants a world of Russians and Chinese - both are sewage and toilet 🚽 feeding dictatorships.

[@mxrsExe]

@J Vlk probably early January when a new mobilization wave begins

[@alexanderpepkin4110]

In order for brains to drain somewhere, they need to exist or develop first. Either you have it or not. In case of Russia this resource is limitless

[@stephenhill545]

Putin just made a law which taxes russians working abroad more. This is a typical putin way of restricting choice without making it thst obvious.

[@stephenhill545]

@@alexanderpepkin4110 oh yes, I forgot. You not only have the second best army in the world, you are also the cleverest. That new subject patriotic military studies must be working wonders. Just don't mention Narva, Tannenburg and Kyiv to them.

[@YorkshirePork]

Got to be one of the best journalists on the bbc 👏🏻 keep it up Steve

[@sepxviii731]

If only he wasn't under the party line...

[@hungbbc]

Lol

[@jdoyle6821]

See if you can find some video,of Steve playing classical music,he's a really great pianist,I can't believe he's survived in Putins RUSSIA for so long,without getting the boot.

[@sepxviii731]

@@jdoyle6821 Putin likes him and often congratulates him for how well he speaks Russian. I think the reason he likes him is that he consistently steam rolls him in the interviews. Rosenberg seems like a good guy but he's not very smart, as proven by this video where he actually proves that life in Russia goes on pretty normally in spite of 6000 sanctions.

[@thaitraveller9756]

bbc have got no journalist they just say what there told to say if you want to here the proper story look at independant journalists like eva bartlet that are on the ground there everyday saying what they see the west just gives out properganda

[@komentator7284]

USA has started it all! Support to Russia!

[@Hjw511]

explain how

[@LordLebu]

How's the firewood situation in London ?

[@nobodyherepal3292]

Pretty good. How’s the fast food situation in Moscow?

[@LordLebu]

@@nobodyherepal3292 less crowded queue than in the NHS.

[@nobodyherepal3292]

@@LordLebu probably because there’s a lot less Middle Aged Russian men around these days to take up line space 🥴

[@Doctor_umaev]

Good journalists Steve Rosenberg 👍🏻

[@ruckus181]

Rather amazing that Putin is actually letting BBC report on the war from Moscow

[@Dungshoveleux]

And RT is banned in the UK to prevent people seeing the other side's point of view.

[@ltipst2962]

We both know he wouldn't let this man survive if he was reporting what all these traitors keep saying, "genuine Russian views" - which are drunks, wanting everyone dead.

[@lashlarue7924]

They need the BBC as a conduit to report things to the West, that's why they permit it to exist. BBC isn't a threat to the throne like a domestic opposition channel. RIP Anna Politkovskaya.😢

[@user-cg2tw8pw7j]

@@lashlarue7924 Haha, the slaves are talking about who will pay the full salary to the lying politicians, you

[@gerristaples3595]

RT and Russian news outlets are being shut down all over the world. Just let the BBC run the soft propaganda for the Kremlin They’ll be employing Skaybeyeeva next (or however you spell it)

[@maxwebber4586]

What music was being played in the background? I wanna give it a shot on piano 😋

[@towet4147]

At last I can see a really good video about moods in Russia. Everything what is shown is absolutely true and people feel exactly like that.

[@Silivrina]

He talked to only one woman, as a woman of a similar age living in Moscow, I can tell you that many Russians feel differently. Namely those who do not watch tv propaganda and think for themselves

[@lmnk]

@@Silivrina they will likely not agree to comment on such questions.

[@user-ds8wv2tk4y]

@@Silivrina как русская женщина проживаюшая не в Москве могу сказать, что абсолютно подавляющее большенство людей поддерживают свою страну вне зависимости смотрят они тв или нет,. Так же могу сказать за себя, я живу на границе с Донбассом, у меня подруга с Макеевки, я не смотрю тв(меня бесят все политические передачи) и никогда не голосовала за Путина и критикую его по сей день, поддерживаю спец операцию, потому что вижу своими глазами, слышу своими ушами, меня научили зрить в корень, видеть причинно-следственнве связи и понимать что если произойдёт это и это, то придётся столкнуться с этим и тем. И да я поддерживаю СВО!!

[@rammohammadsinghazad1744]

@@user-ds8wv2tk4y 👍

[@charlotteforever7442]

@@user-ds8wv2tk4y те, кто поддерживает СВО либо мрази, либо умственно-отсталые. Либо все вместе. Вы к кому относитесь?

[@josef9253]

Estonia is nato member from 2004, so im not understand that older lady with nuclear weaponary speach att all.

[@michaeldy3157]

The russians are a brainwashed people

[@alexanderpepkin4110]

Population of Ukraine was 40 mil, they’ve been brainwashed with Russophobia and have territorial claims towards Russia. Do you want me to explain the difference further? Or is it clear?

[@josef9253]

And the Russians are brainwashed into thinking that NATO is somehow bad, aggressive and other shit. Look at Estonia, 19 years of NATO membership alongside Russia, and nothing has happened. Territorial claims? Ukraine only wants what is internationally recognized as theirs and nothing more. If Ukraine wanted to expand, it would have probably already done so when they recaptured Kharkiv from the Russians. From there it would have been easy to advance to Belgrod, when the enemy ran away.

[@tomn8276]

You can't buy education!

[@NoName-md5zb]

"nuclear things"

[@frederickjonsson6651]

=Nuclear weapons

[@cikorasikorskiy1486]

Красивая снежная зима в этом году. Редко такое бывает...

[@jaylagan5899]

For goodness sake! Was that a news story or was that a TikTok video?! The “journalist” seemed more concerned with either giving his opinion on what is happening (rather than actually asking people) or doing long shots of people walking by or Christmas lights with maudlin music in the background! The only thing in that 4:59 video that was of any value was the interview with the Russian lady and even that I question if he took her out of context. Utter shite!

[@China-129]

For democracy to thrive, we need to tell better stories about ourselves, and how we can live together despite our differences. 😷✌🏻

[@iddy2122]

The West killed democracy in Russia, years before Putin.

[@michaeldy3157]

Russia is a brutal dictatorship where the tyrant has you murdered if you oppose his crimes. He stole 80% of russias wealth. He murdered opponents. The russians are brainwashed

[@thomasfookingshelby8194]

Ni hao

[@beautifulempatheticliberal5204]

"Muh democracy" lol

[@ltipst2962]

@@beautifulempatheticliberal5204 you can tell you believe everything you read on the internet. You little basement dweller

[@AinzWoolGown]

01:43 The white cap lady is for war. Her son probably not in frontline. The red cap lady is against this war. Her relatives probably died in this war, but terrified of the white cap lady.🤭

[@_masssk_]

I wish you'd show more how they think and speak about Ukraine and the west.

[@iraira7439]

I live in the south of Russia, on the Black Sea coast. The quality of life in economic terms has not changed, but anxiety, of course, has increased. All my family and friends support our president and will help our country if necessary, because only under Putin we began to live as we would like.I've been to Europe twice in my life. In 2010 in Paris - it was a delight!!! And then, I also flew to Paris, but already in 2016, and it was already a shock!!! Homeless people, dirt, beggars, some tents, garbage, feces... It was disgusting! Especially in comparison with our Russian cities, where every year everything becomes more beautiful and cooler!!!

[@christianfliether651]

Reading your post, I can only puke... Slava Ukraini!

[@zzz7103]

As another Russian I should say nice try. Maybe I live in different Russia, but my city does not become cooler every year. Also I've never traveled in my life, too expencive, but I hope people like you are happy that now we lost oppotunity to see the world. Russian 'cool city' is now only option for you too, not only for poor people like me. Congratulations.

[@fedornaymushin]

@@zzz7103 это смотря какой город конечно. Я жил в Сыктывкаре, Кирове, а сейчас живу в Казани. Первые два очень сильно деградируют и во власти одна коррупция. Казань же наоборот идёт вперёд и выходит на довольно высокий уровень

[@futureiscoming5925]

😂😂😂

[@RAWGRIP54]

All countries have the rights to defend itself. But not to invade other countries.

[@kasparsiricenko2240]

I don't believe in this nuclear threat Russia is trying to excuse itself by invading. But if it could be proved truthful, then this is the same as what the USA was planning in the Cuban Missile Crisis. It was planning to invade Cuba.

[@morho9422]

Today ukraine shot a s300 missile into belarus. does belarus have right to defend itself?

[@user-yi8rt5zq9e]

Does Donbasd have the right to defrnd itsrlf?It has been shelled by Ukraine gor eight years Does Crimea have right to defend itself and Russia for help ?

[@luckygjv872]

@@user-yi8rt5zq9e Irina, darling. Please understand that not everything the Russian government says is correct. They lie. All governments lie. Especially the Russian government. Ukraine was a peaceful country before 2014! Who started the war in 2014? Definitely not Ukraine!

[@StrongRespect]

Say that to NATO

[@brianwarburton4482]

I would imagine the Steve Rosenberg has to be very careful about what he is saying. He is clearly engaged in a balancing act where he is trying to keep his western audience accurately informed whilst not getting himself into trouble with the Russian authorities. I would dearly love to know what he would really like to be saying.

[@HG_Budde]

At last someone with a brain, of course he has to maintain a certain speech Codec, otherwise he risks getting arrested, kidnapped or even killed. When a Western journalist uses "Special Operation", all the red lights should be virtually strobing. He's well aware that he probably is on the hit list of every last little russian secret service.

[@abdulimraan2706]

Well all mainstream media tell the same story and lies to their audience

[@sepxviii731]

If he was more honest he would get in trouble with the UK authorities, not with the Russian

[@HG_Budde]

@@abdulimraan2706 Awesome statement, but totally ignoring reality. If you're talking about russian state media, yes, they lie their butts off to keep their citizens in line. But to say ALL media lie, is a typical bullshit statement of right wing politicians, be it some American, Russian or other anti-democratic presidents.

[@ladderssnakes1755]

!!!

[@tektoastium7241]

And the Russian grunts at the start were told it was “just a military exercise”. I don’t know how many of them wanted this fight either.

[@michaela4024]

The expression on the woman’s face wearing the red cap said it all as that other woman told her lies. "We are a peace loving people” yeah right in what universe. To allow one little monster to rule over a nation for so long and play with its people like toys in this day and age is so sad.

[@Mr.m107]

Exact what west done to middle east in last 20 years.russia is doing to Ukraine. West is trying to portray Putin as evil.but if we look at last two decades west's so called war on terror was destroyed many countries and killed millions of innocents .

[@donnaarsenoff8399]

I noticed the look on the other woman’s face. She wasn’t buying what her friend was saying.

[@dougimmel]

yup.

[@Japan-846]

Yes 😀

[@ogor1551]

Look in a mirror

[@fractalinfinity1750]

As a Russian who was born in the province city of Saratov and further migrated to Moscow for studying at the university, I witnessed some changes in the last February after the news about beginning that operation in Ukraine. First of all, the prices on some types of food immensely soared up by 10-30% and continued rising up to 50-70% approximately. As for high technologies such as gadgets and vehicles, they became really expensive within several months and almost unavailable to acquire. Some of my friends were interested in purchasing computers so much that they even made a huge trip to Kazakhstan in order to buy them at affordable prices. Secondly, the number of protests have increased but they haven't influenced anything significantly. Some people were extremely depressed by the news about all these events in Ukraine but the vast majority didn't pay much attention to this information. Nevertheless, despite everything that's taken place in this world for the last year, I still believe that the situation shall improve via people's solidarity and understanding of it. Happy New Year! I wish everyone reading this message strong health, happiness in life, peace and good luck in 2023!

[@randyg4571]

The year ended and a New Year began with your country imposing unbearable brutality on the citizens of its much smaller and weaker neighbor, While Russians are still going about their normal lives, the lives of millions of Ukrainians have been destroyed. Millions of Ukrainians have lost their homes, their careers, their relationships, their memories all due to your egotistical leader and it seems that Russians could care less with their only concern being rising prices which are also affecting the whole world. I could never understand why Russians can claim that they do not pay attention to the news , give me an effing break. If Russians would pay attention to the news and demonstrate that hey are impacted by it, the world could be a better place . There are other places besides Mother Russia, that needs compassion and security.

[@laolao1466]

Russians have always been cannibals. They are used to killing people in other countries. Even in the 20th and 21st centuries they keep on slaughtering other nations. Moldovans, Chechens, Georgians, Ukrainians, Syrians. During the whole history of Russia this country has had only 2 sources of income - war and natural resources. They never change. While killing people in Ukraine, they enjoy the holiday season. Murder for Russians is a routine.

[@fractalinfinity1750]

@@laolao1466 What a load of bullshit you wrote! Have you ever been to Moldova, Georgia and Chechen Republic to make such provocative allegations? Do you understand how many Russians died in the 20th century and sacrificed their lives voluntarily to save their country from the nazi occupation as well as other nations of the Soviet Union? What was the number of Russians who suffered from hunger during the 1920-30s along with other Soviet nations due to the Soviet industrialization program? Several million peasants of different origins across the country were forced to leave their property and donate their money to the government in exchange for poor life without sources to exist. Approximately 26 million Soviets died in the ww2(roughly 11-13 million soldiers only). Besides, from your logical perspective, if we take a look at almost all countries of the world we'll see thousands of groups of tribes and nations exterminated or totally enslaved by more powerful and bigger nations. Does it mean we should call all of them cannibals as well just because of some dark moments of their history when they were ruled by tough regimes? I don't think so. Most of the peoples existing nowadays didn't pop up from nowhere. The territories they live on on a daily basis were somehow conquered and colonized many years ago. To be honest, I'm not trying to coax you into believing my words as justifying bad actions of your nation by giving examples of others doesn't change anything in reality we're all living in right now. However, it's one of the ways to demonstrate some Internet hypocrites like you what humanity have been going through. Have a good day!

[@laolao1466]

@@fractalinfinity1750 I haven't been to all the countries where you kill people. Citizens from all those countries fled to Ukraine when Russian cannibals invaded their homeland, ruined their homes and killed their relatives. Chechens, Georgians and people from other countries invaded by Ruskies found their second home in Ukraine. But in 2014 you invaded Ukraine. Now the whole battalions and regiments of Chechens, Georgians are fighting against Russian cannibals in Ukraine. Have you ever wondered why Chechens and Georgians are fighting in Ukraine against you? Maybe because you ruined their home twice? As for WW2, German nazi occupied only 5% of Russian territory. Most of Russians didn't even see those nazi in their country. Whereas Ukraine was TOTALLY devastated TWICE by nazi - during the offensive and when they retreated. Nazi killed 25% of the whole population of Ukraine and it took 25 years to return to pre-war demographics. The famine you are referring to in Russia was a result of natural causes - draft. Whereas the Famine in Ukraine was artificial. Ukrainians had enough grain. But you grabbed it all. Moscow left Ukrainians without food. That's why millions of Ukrainians died. Not because of natural causes, but because of Russians who left them without food. Of course, in Medieval times wild things could happen. But Russians have not noticed that those times are over. Russians still have a mindset of Medieval Asians or pre-historic cannibals. That's the problem. Nations are changing over time. Russian cannibals never change.

[@fractalinfinity1750]

@@laolao1466 1) Ok, I'll ask you several questions. How many citizens left their countries for Ukraine in comparison to other states? What about those people who refused to leave their homeland and stay home? Most of them didn't migrate and live their lives peacefully in Georgia, Moldova and Chechen Rupublic. If Russians were so horrible killing people nowadays the number of refugees would be larger. Don't you think so? And yeah, how many citizens do Russians kill in those countries? In which parts of Moldova, Georgia and Chechen Republic do they kill them nowadays? Give me the links to your sources of information to prove your statement. 2) The foreign military formations fighting in Ukraine consist of maximum tens of thousands of volunteers fighting the Russian army. It is almost nothing compared to the whole populations of those nations. To be honest, I've never wondered why some people from different nations have been fighting for Ukraine as I knew that there were volunteers on the Ukrainian territory who just wanted to fight for their own reasons such as revenge and fairness. The same took place in Donbass where there were volunteers from Russia fighting the Ukrainian troops for the people living there. 3) As for the hunger caused by the industrialization program, I was writing about the process of expropriation of food and other kinds of property from peasants across the Soviet Union begun in 1929. It was further called "Раскулачивание". Several million self-sufficient wealthy villagers were forcefully deprived of their houses, cattle and were relocated to the East of the country. Thousands of them eventually died during the first years of living in the new places. The famine you've most likely mentioned was in 1921-22. It damaged people's lives in villages of Volga Region. The number of victims who died from hunger was up to 5 million people. The reason for hunger wasn't just a draft or a drought but a number of factors such as economic disturbance, drought, backwardness of technologies, expropriation of peasants' property by the Red army particularly and consequences of the Civil War in general. On the other hand, the great famine lasting for a few years in 1932-1933 was one of the percussions of the Party's policy led by Georgian Stalin. The key task was to conduct the industrialization of the whole country at the highest pace by accumulating all the resources and selling them to the West in exchange for machinery equipment. The hunger and further cannibalism were widespread in almost all parts of the country where conditions were comfortable for conducting agriculture such as the central parts of Ukraine, Low and High Volga region, Kuban region, Northern Kazakhstan, Voronezh region etc. In other words, NOT ONLY Ukraine but other parts of the Soviet Union were also suffering from such brutal actions of local communists gathering bread and other kinds of food by force. 4) As for the devastation of Ukraine and Belarus, it's easily explained. These Soviet Republics were geographically closer to the borders of the Third Reich. That's why they were the first territories bombarded by the Nazi planes and attacked by the enemy's soldiers. Then after the fast penetration of the German army in the Soviet lands they reached Leningrad, Moscow and Stalingrad. These 5% of territories you're talking about were inhabited by millions of people and they were much more significant in comparison to Siberia. The Blockade of Leningrad and Battle for Stalingrad took approximately 2 million lives of the Soviet soldiers and citizens of both cities. Besides, millions of Russians were the largest part of the Soviet army(5 million) and sacrificed their lives as well as other soldiers of different origins including the Ukrainians, Kazakh and others. Millions of Russian women and children were working 10-15 hours a day in factories evacuated to Siberian lands. So, the fact that only 5% of the Russian territories were occupied by the Nazis doesn't mean the Russians didn't suffer compared to others. On the Russian lands the new weapons were getting constructed for the Soviet soldiers who were liberating that devastated Ukraine and Belarus from the nazis! 5) The entire world is living in the 21st century with high technologies and progressive views. However, there're still some idiots starting wars and an ignorant narrow-minded commentator with the nickname Lao Lao who uses the word "Cannibal" in an inappropriate way and doesn't even know the meaning of that word. Keep imagining "cannibals" in places where there are none of them if you like it so much. At least, this is everything you can do here. Have a good day!

[@sanyurych]

I was a military (have not participated in the war) in the moment when it all has begun. If February 24th seemed to us soldiers as surrealism and intense nightmare, do you think the civil society really would be excited to find out about the it? This woman from the video who supported the invasion said not what the truth was about the SMO for her, it's rather what is in haste made up justification to relieve horror in her mind. I live in this society and I understand that people would love to ignore the war, because it's too painful. Uncertain Future, real friends drafted and dead. This is purgatory.

[@mirandatoft844]

I really hate seeing people in both countries suffer. I pray for everyone that peace comes and healing. This is so so so sad. I literally have cried seeing this absolutely horrific situation continue. It must end. Carrying on is torture.

[@liesdamnlies3372]

Then tell your government to send everything to Ukraine that they need to win. Russia needs to be stopped; they’ve been terrorizing people for five hundred years. They’re still backing Assad, they levelled Grozny and Mariupol, they’re still occupying parts of Georgia and Moldova. They are a terrorist and marauder state with a people who have such a slave mentality that they either believe everything their government says or are so apathetic that they won’t take it upon themselves to overthrow the government; they’re content to watch the horror.

[@zoezoejane]

oh poor russians, sure 😬

[@nadiyadanylyuk8701]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aJjGq5dvZdVmaLs Is that a fair comparison really?

[@georgefox4172]

My country, Russia, has fallen into madness like Germany in the 1930s. I can only pray that this bloody aggression will end and Ukrainians will someday be able to forgive us. At least in the distant future.

[@ilsavv]

It will take not less than twelve generation to start feeling that this invasion is far off in the past.

[@wtl912]

My deep respect to you 🙌. Sure, you're not the only Russian against this war. Please keep doing all in your hands so that Russian people stand up against war and Putin 🙏.

[@briant5685]

no Russia has not fallen to any madness, your brain has been bankrupt by the west if you understand politics and all nato's promises of the 90's you will know why putin has reached end of being patient, the old lady merkel is spilling the beans of how the west has been playing russia for years,how would US feel if Russia overthrew a legitimate government in Mexico and placed a puppet government in Mexico who would go ahead to massacre US citizens for opposing the coup..??wake up fool

[@moestietabarnak]

into madness ? ..What I see is YOU have fallen for western propaganda, GO talk to people of the Donbass one-on-one without any 'authority' around if you think they force people to talk their way... since YOU CAN talk to them in their language ! GO!

[@michaela4024]

The first step is to remove that little war monger at the head of the country, he has to go for there to be any chance of this pointless war ending. Maybe if he had a accident and fell from a third floor window.

[@alkante2962]

Happy New Year, Steve Rosenberg! Thank you for this thoughtful report, very telling. Beauty and nostalgia of what could have been if only all men of goodwill were willing to give a hand... EDIT 02 01 2023 Très belle musique, tout à fait parlante. Quant aux deux bonnes femmes du début, si SR a retenu leur interview c'est que celui-ci est représentatif d'une certaine opinion publique russe sous-informée, endoctrinée, intellectuellement de mauvaise foi. Il est symptomatique que des crimes de guerre soit justifiés au nom de l'amour de la paix du monde ruSSe. Cela rappelle les pires raisonnements de propagande nazi ou stalinienne, à croire que la Russie n'a pu évoluer, n'a rien appris, depuis le temps. Quel affreux gâchis... pour les Russes eux-mêmes aux mains d'une oligarchie les menant à leur perte morale et matérielle comme l'atteste le témoignage de cette femme.

[@sedermaza6993]

Even it is a bias report he was allowed to do so. But what we are seen in UK and other western countries you have shut up any alternative news include Russia media. Is it democracy ? Free expression? This double standard must end

[@arina7444]

You should know that the war in Ukraine was not started by the legitimate President Turchynov in 2014. On March 16, 2014, he sent tanks to unarmed people in the Donbass (East of Ukraine). On March 16, 2014, there were no volunteers from Russia in Ukraine. Girkin-Strelkov arrived in Slavyansk only on April 12, 2014. Tanks have been crushing unarmed people in Donbass since March 16, 2014. On March 20, the first participants in a rally against Turchinov and against the Nazis were killed in Kharkov. On May 2, 2014, the Nazis burned peaceful Ukrainian protesters in Odessa. In the Donbass, Ukrainian planes bombed parks and houses. Civilians died there. The war in Ukraine began on March 16, 2014. Putin ends this war.

[@OlyaKeda]

Что за бред ?

[@user-fc7ze9rs2v]

It is ridiculous to hear the characteristics of Russian public opinion from a person who knows absolutely nothing about current events, or about this very opinion of Russians. Get less carried away by your corrupt press. Idiot.

[@user-pu2ug8zs1p]

Военные преступления Украина вела по отношению к своим гражданам больше 8 лет. Где были все журналисты, BBS News тогда?

[@SuperHutomo]

As an Indonesian, i like kremlin's alternative reality more than london's alternative reality.

[@robertsmith8629]

Jelas njir ini skenario US, awalnya kudeta presiden Ukraina pro Rusia 2014 dalang nya Amerika NATO terus presiden Ukraine dibuat anti Rusia semua sampai si komedian zelenky bisa jadi presiden eh mau ikut NATO, dan mengganggu stabilitas Rusia, apalagi klo gk dicegah bisa bisa abis kepentingan Rusia, klo ini bukan skenario as NATO knp mereka gk minta damai malah ngirim senjata terus itu semua utang Ukraine 😂 yg palingrugi ya masyarakat Ukraina 😂

[@VSYAC]

Дар ин дунё фақат ягон гапу кор шуда истоданаш даркор дее, тобаее 😮‍💨. Илоҳо ҳама дар паноҳи Худованд бошад. Ассалому алайкум ✊🤝🇹🇯

[@7u7u7uk]

Чӣ бояд гуфт ва ба кӣ? Чӣ бояд кард? Ба мо бигӯ, эй доно!

[@VSYAC]

@@7u7u7uk Эй, одам. Ту чи гуфта истодаӣ?! 😂 Худатро беҳуда адабча нагир. Маълум, кӣ маънои гапи ман нарафти. Ман гуфтам, кӣ дар ин олам ҳамавақт ягон ҳодиса шуда меистад. Ин чиз, чизи маълум барои ҳама аст. Барои масъала дар ютуб бнавис: "ХАБАРҲОИ ОЛАМ ИМРӮЗ". Кӯр ба ҳасо. Акнун, барои чӣ ту манро доно гуфта истодаӣ?? Оё саволат ишораи бад аст? 🤨

[@dmdm51100]

If it's a war between NATO and Russia, as those Russians think, I'd say NATO should give Ukraine its best weaponry. Tanks, jets, long-range missiles for starters.

[@dalecrocker3213]

Too scared.

[@stefanm5636]

Give them, why do you hesitate ?What is the problem ?

[@litulucas7498]

You are a not okay.. the more you keep praise NATO the more you are praising the war to prolong.. us African we do not want anymore NATO and US support.. US and NATO will finish eating your flash until finishing eating your bones

[@zainzoala1083]

😂😂😂 Who did you think is fighting and belong all the weapons & 💰💰💰 in Ukraine, clown President.

[@vervetech9395]

They already have. There's nothing else in the store room to give. And yes this is a full NATO proxy war (NATO training, weapons, spy satellite intel on Russia's positions, mercenaries, supplies). "Men don't win wars, supplies do". With over 30 countries constantly supplying Ukraine, giving them intel, money and sanctioning Russia hurting their ability to make advance weapons, Ukraine should have defeated Russia completely and swiftly by now but that's not the case.

[@MrTom-kl7hy]

Pootin's war of conquest is so transparent, the entire world can see through his lies. This is a blatant criminal murderous and destructive land grab by the world's biggest thief - Pootin'.

[@chadimirputin2282]

Not very bright are you?

[@eduwino151]

Russian society lives so deep in delusion and lies, when their army implodes in Ukraine by summer next years the societal trauma of defeat is the only thing that will reset them

[@briancarno8837]

@@chadimirputin2282 yeah the whole world can see through his lies except for the 40% of the worlds polulation that supports him

[@psnaris]

The ENTIRE world? You mean NATO and Davos don't you?

[@ebiekem]

Who's the "entire world"?

[@user-od5rj7fz8n]

Moscow so beautiful

[@nadiyadanylyuk8701]

I didn't see anything beutiful.

[@nash_stile]

@@nadiyadanylyuk8701 конечно не увидела, ты же хахлушка, хоть переименуйся что бы меньше палиться в своем злословии

[@texasray5237]

Those international brands are still there, only the names have been changed to protect the profits.

[@esrefcelikcelik8789]

They don't deserve to live in their own egoist parallel universes,as their state is leading an immoral and unjustified crime in Ukraine

[@charlesapana9935]

Those two countries have never been the same since start of the war

[@madhead4529]

The world bro...

[@armadillo9961]

Since the coup

[@vm9464]

@@armadillo9961 since your mama soup

[@isagrax953]

@@armadillo9961 Putin coup correct

[@recordsmanukrnet]

@@madhead4529 the world has nothing to do with this, it’s only russia that invaded Ukraine the world is helping Ukraine just like it did in the 40-s, same amount of countries were in anti hitler coalition as there are today in anti putin coalition

[@MewDenise]

Having military posters everywhere.... yikes. Feels very N.Korea

[@netboyne]

The visual picture and music conveyed very well what I see in Russia. I am from the Belgorod region near the Ukrainian border. Many thanks to the author of this video for the quality content.

[@Pippie5555]

Tell the Russian soldiers to stop fighting for one man's desire. Putin is the new Stalin.

[@thaitraveller9756]

the spin is by the bbc properganda

[@pieter-bashoogsteen2283]

@@thaitraveller9756this person as a Russian doesn’t seem to think so and I suppose they know it better than you do.

[@Alexander_technik]

@@pieter-bashoogsteen2283 he can only see the bad if he wants to. We live the same as before. As long as you believe your channels and the artificially created atmosphere of negativity in the comments, you did not notice how you yourself turned into zombies, which you hate so much and supposedly pity. You stopped noticing duality in relation to different things, you have a selective accounting system of facts. Ваша логика и чувство здравого смысла уничтожены.

[@pieter-bashoogsteen2283]

@@Alexander_technik you’re saying that this persons narrative is less valid because it doesn’t allign with your views? Also I am not a zombie trapped in negativity that doesn’t notice the duality in… something. My apologies but I am not following you and to me it reads like gibberish. Have a nice day though!

[@QuacGiaNgoVietCongHoa]

Russia is still functionning, people working, shop openning, but Russia has more aggression oppression and uncertainty. It is very fair for russia. This comment is also very exact for China too.

[@simonrajan3945]

Try doing the same in the West and see what happens at the hands of the G7 gestapo -Remember Git Bay in the US

[@coroner3164]

中国的未来很清晰，看看钱都往哪儿去就明白。你该多操心下你岛的护国神山搬走了还能有啥

[@holtovhond]

I especially like how they show the normal russian life and tell nothing about rebrandings ♿♿♿

[@RedTitan5]

Yes Z for NaZi

[@dmitrychaadaev2195]

Aggression, oppression, uncertainty - that was his opinion. Where in video he showed that? Also music choice was strange. Everywhere New Year celebration music plays. Think about this - BBC can walk freely in Moscow, take interview and we can watch this. Is it possible that Russian media would do this in Kiev or London?

[@AndreyVisotsky]

I got the impression that the correspondent wanted to show more negativity about Russia, but he did not see empty shelves in stores, protest demonstrations, or homeless people on the streets. Therefore, the correspondent had to insert into the report only his personal opinion that the effect of sanctions will still be there.

[@nickpro8116]

If he specifically wanted to show Russia in a negative light, he wouldn't be reporting from Moscow

[@arvinroidoatienza7082]

He would be arrested by Russian authorities if he did.

[@rossib6974]

@@arvinroidoatienza7082 Where are Russian reporters in West !? Nowhere cos all kicked out and all Rusdian channels are banned including its church .Russia currently is the most Socialy free Democratic country in the World with economic welfare and unified people from 100 plus Ethnics in its federations .

[@Pippie5555]

The reporter lives in Russia. He cannot criticize Russia.

[@Pippie5555]

@@rossib6974 Why don't you check things before you post a comment!!?? You are making a fool of yourself!!! RT News are based in Moscow with a presence in Washington, New York, London, Paris, Delhi, Cairo and Baghdad and other cities. Moscow Times had to flee Russia (to the Netherlands) after they criticized the war in Ukraine.

[@Arwiden]

Лол, музыку погрустнее, побольше символизма с решетками. БиБиСи как всегда. А если серьёзно, то практически ничего не изменилось. Если не читать новости, то вообще все как обычно.

[@popscratchie3985]

“When NATO puts us guns or nuclear things or whatever they are on the border of Russia, we have to defend ourselves “ she sounds well informed😂

[@aormonde]

I believe in equal rights for women so i think that lady shoud be sent to the front as soon as possible.

[@alexanderpepkin4110]

Not sure about your country, but in russia men defend women , not vice versa

[@aormonde]

@@alexanderpepkin4110 that was not a woman that was a naZi ruZZian Zombie!

[@mrkiplingreallywasanexceed8311]

😏

[@alexanderpepkin4110]

I just hate when people hide their comments when responding. Cowards

[@Proletrolliat]

@@alexanderpepkin4110 Hide? i think you mean delete? i dont think you can hide your comment

[@Ahero0fAfrica-6789]

"People of different religions & cultures live side by side in almost every part of the world, and most of us have overlapping identities which unite us with very different groups. We can love what we are, without hating what -- and who -- we are not. We can thrive in our own tradition, even as we learn from others, and come to respect their teachings." ─ 🇺🇳 KOFI ANNAN Former Secretary-General of the United Nations (2001)

[@alicesmith6750]

If only more people would be more accepting of those differences, and gain an understanding that what makes us all different, are things that often make us the same in many ways. Driver's in the UK operate from the right side of their vehiciles, drive on the left side of their roads. We drive on the right side of the road, drivers side is on the left. Neither one is wrong. We just take the wheel from the other side, but we're all trying to get there and back safely.

[@condorX2]

Who want to see BBC do a report on Europe energy crisis and White Supremacists in Ukraine? Raise your hand 👍

[@serkandemir1549]

!!!!!!!!! You have to hurry for gold because in 2023 gold will rise very fast because America spent $203 billion on nuclear weapons war technology Russia Ukraine Europe crisis is growing America can do anything anytime be careful precious metals are the savior stay away from paper money as much as possible by typing this on youtube, nygma Is there a 3rd World war prophecy on the cover of the magazine, research and watch..............................................................................................!!!!!!!!!

[@cheebacheeobusiness3893]

That's a bit on the rose colored lenses - point of view... Just look around the world situation - there's many extremist groups that are getting more and more power... Also it can be seen that the unfortunately religion is still a way to make a separation for many people :(

[@frankcherry3810]

Bad religion is guilty. It supports Nationalism. People of one religion are told to go fight people in another country of the same religion. Both sides say ‘God is with you’!

[@_unknown_channel_]

❛ I may have been a poet, and the following is the first two lines of a poem made about 1260 years ago. ❜ The state has been defeated, but here are mountains and a big river. The castle is in spring, but it is overgrown with grass and trees. ... ーーーーーーー I have a great interest in post-war reconstruction interests regarding the war between Russia and Ukraine.

[@infaskjeeshorts5729]

Russia: " The whole world turned Nazi overnight " makes sense doesn't it 🙂🙃

[@Blanka1100]

It's funny how Russians seem not to remember that USSR was Hitler's ally till 1941 and invaded Poland on 17th of september 1939. They think "they never invaded anybody". They love taking all USSR WWII glory as long as it suits their russian narrative.

[@kirilstoyanov6462]

Rosenberg talking about aggression and oppression while freely reporting from Moscow. That lack of self awareness is mind boggling