No video

Why I Switched From Modo To Blender

  Рет қаралды 113,935

HEAVYPOLY

HEAVYPOLY

Күн бұрын

As a Modo user and instructor since 2010 I've gotten some questions asking why I recently switched from Modo to Blender. Let's talk about some pros and cons. Hopefully this video will help you figure out which is right for you.

Пікірлер: 583
@lawrencedoliveiro9104
@lawrencedoliveiro9104 6 жыл бұрын
8:15 Don’t forget, the trial version of Blender is only valid for ∞ days. After that, you have to pay $0 if you want to continue using it. You can pay for the entry-level activation licence, which gives you only 100% of the features, valid for a further ∞ days, for a fee of $0. Then for an additional $0, you can activate all the remaining features, valid for another ∞ days. Note that this licence is only valid for installation on ∞ different machines for ∞ different users at once; if you want more than that, you have to pay another $0 fee.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Hahah better start saving up
@oalfernandes
@oalfernandes 6 жыл бұрын
That's the perfect world! So I contributed money to Blender because I think the project can not stop.
@jamesprakashjc
@jamesprakashjc 5 жыл бұрын
Best comment about Blender ever!!! lol can't stop laughing!
@MAGAMAN
@MAGAMAN 5 жыл бұрын
Crappy software is still crappy even if it's free. This is why linux still has no desktop market share, even when windows has turned in to a complete pile of crap.
@jamesprakashjc
@jamesprakashjc 5 жыл бұрын
@@MAGAMAN but Blender is not crappy, so...
@khj5582
@khj5582 4 жыл бұрын
You never explained why you switched from Modo to Blender. All I heard you say was how much better Modo is than Blender.
@Imperfectlink.
@Imperfectlink. 4 жыл бұрын
Vaughan, I'd like to see your 2 year update on this topic.
@yash1152
@yash1152 4 жыл бұрын
yeah.... me tooooooo
@NuclearSnailStudios
@NuclearSnailStudios 3 жыл бұрын
BUMP
@UP-zq1ml
@UP-zq1ml 3 жыл бұрын
Bump
@Pewi73
@Pewi73 3 жыл бұрын
Bumpin' that too. Especially since now there's 2.9.
@que_dijo
@que_dijo 3 жыл бұрын
@@Pewi73 Me as well!
@DrTheRich
@DrTheRich 6 жыл бұрын
Actually the blender development team is mainly based in Amsterdam. They work together with an animation team, and they develop blender while it's being used for real projects. They have been doing this for years and that is basically why it has come as far as it has been. (it's called the Blender Institute)
@user-cz5fm2sp3j
@user-cz5fm2sp3j 6 жыл бұрын
Yes)
@amannin1
@amannin1 4 жыл бұрын
I'm currently transitioning from Modo to Blender as well and I 100% agree with everything you said. Though, aside from some really cool features (e.g. eevee), it's the thriving global community that has really drawn me in. There's an energy in the air and it's getting me fired back up and passionate again!
@cuoreribelle4584
@cuoreribelle4584 Жыл бұрын
you don't understand anything about 3d programs, 2 programs are professional, 3ds max and The Foundry MODO because they make your job easier, and if you know how to use them you do truly extraordinary things, maybe you like blender more because it's a free program, but I assure you that you can't compare blender with 3ds max or blender with The Foundry MODO because blender can't compare with programs like 3ds max and The Foundry MODO they are too professional.
@hfranke07
@hfranke07 6 жыл бұрын
I just love Modo.... modelling and animations is great. What through me os is the Shadertree. I NEVET got the hang of it. The Shadertree made me fight my designs instead of just making them. I had scenes with 200 items and lots of shaders, and everything went well,- and then I changed ONE shader and the whole scene screwed up...... I HATE the shadertree, but the modelling and animation is great. And the fact that Modo is a member of The Foundry is great.... but no. Now I am a Blender user.... and the new UI is doing me very good.... and happy. Great video, thanks for sharing. If you need a great video editing tool I can recommend DaVinci Resolve 15 to you. It is free and a great app.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the recommendation! Love DaVinci and glad that it's free :)
@aronseptianto8142
@aronseptianto8142 6 жыл бұрын
i've started in blender i haven't really touched any other program i heard Modo is awesome thing is i'm *usually* just a one man team and having all the tool in one place is freaking awesome for a one man team
@rdileepkumar4898
@rdileepkumar4898 5 жыл бұрын
Yeah blender is for one Man army guys haha
@_Romulodovale
@_Romulodovale 6 жыл бұрын
I like the way we delete vertices, edges and faces in Blender, sometimes you only want to delete faces without deleting edges and vertices, sometimes you just want to dissolve something, this is really good for me.
@remon563
@remon563 6 жыл бұрын
you have my severe gratitude for the hard work you did with your custom Blender UI. It really made the switch to Blender 10x easier. I recommend it everyone !
@DisgruntledPigumon
@DisgruntledPigumon 3 жыл бұрын
Where did you get it?
@HannesGrebin
@HannesGrebin Жыл бұрын
m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/ioOohICLmtOrl5o
@macrumpton
@macrumpton 3 жыл бұрын
Even in 2020 with all the changes in blender, it still feels a bit overwhelming and less intuitive than it could be to me. I wish there were a way to fully contextualize the interface, so options that are not applicable are invisible, to avoid the clutter and make things more streamlined.
@feitingschatten1
@feitingschatten1 2 жыл бұрын
I was like you, then in 2006 I sat down and read the manual. Every single day for 2 weeks, 30 min to an hour of reading, then another bit of turning everything into rote-memory. I practiced everything I learned for at least 30 min before going to bed. Now, 15 years later, I can still use it. Unfortunately some really handy philosophy was scrapped, like left-click being finalize instead of selection... but it's still pretty cool. Anyway, if you're still having problems, and for anyone like you, I'll try to list out some techniques to "get familiar" assuming you've just opened it up. You'll see a giant cube in front of you, and you wanna select it. Select it with either mouse button. Hit tab to enter Edit mode, hit tab again, that's object mode. Hit tab a bunch more times and say "edit, object, edit, object". Do this trick with everything I'm about to say. Shift-A is add (unless you changed it on purpose to spacebar when first started) MIDDLE MOUSE button is your navigation. Hold Shift to pan. Mess with ctrl, alt, and shift, and press the middle mouse. Every 3D software uses this except Modo for some reason. Bottom bar, just below viewport has Edit/Object mode, then axis (Global, local, pivot, etc), to the right is vertex, edge, face select. Select the face button, then pick a side on cube. the A button is "ALL" for selecting. tap it twice to deselect all, or try combinations of alt with A if you have issues. Press W for an all-around tool to subdivide. If you can't find it, hit F3 and search, it gives shortcuts for specific ones. 2 divisions, 3 by 3 is what you want (for practice). Now here's the tools you'll use most of the time. G for Grab. Select only the middle face and move it outward. Fun, huh? But you want more control, so here's a present: hold the Control key for unit-based movement. It will only snap one unit at a time. Move it around this way using the arrows. Put it back (if you want) and hit E. You'll notice this extrudes it. Be careful, if you don't move it, then you have an extra set of verts. Move this thing using Control for snap to units, but shift is for precise moving. Even more precision uses Z toolbar. Hit Z for the toolbar, wow, you can now move things specifically where you want. Let's get some more advanced. (B) Bevel edges after selecting all the edges with shift or ctrl. Selecting the wrong ones? Well check out that square with 8 mini dots next to it on the selection bar area, it's called Backface culling. Turn it on. Now you can only select what's visible. Handy. But you want more precision, so you've decided to only make visible the area you're working on. Alt B to draw a border around it, then Alt B again to see the rest of the world. Ok now that you've gotten the hang of some basic stuff, let's give you a shortcut. When editing something with the tools, hit middle mouse, and it will only rotate around the axis that you moved closest to. Hit the button again and/or move the mouse before hitting it to lock it to the other. Combine this with what you learned above for hyper precise movement. This also works on faces, verts. Speaking of verts, Weld, Join and, the F key for Faces are going to be your friends. Go look them up. Ingrain them into your muscles before much longer. Ctil K is (K)nife cut. Use it to split edges into things. Merge/Weld will undo and remove duplicates. Facing the wrong way? Look up Normal tools to see and change. Don't forget (I)nsets for when you need to extrude something but keep the bevel in it. That should be just about everything until you get into material, lighting, and more advanced stuff. After over a decade, those haven't changed. And I forgot one last thing, you can (S)nap the cursor to the grid if you wanted to move it, however hold Shift and hit S. That is one way to ensure the cursor is placed where you want new object.
@DanielKim3D
@DanielKim3D 4 жыл бұрын
Reasions I can't leave MODO 13 for Blender 2.8: Powerful modeling tool, Navigation and UI, UVmap tool, Powerful Rendering Reasons I am learning Blender 2.8 for future: Eevee, low cost memory, many addons for easy process, node base material editing, rigging addon Reasons I can't chang my tool to Blender: Bad modeling tools, Bad selection options
@Wstyle
@Wstyle 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for this, I'm switching when 2.8 comes out (and will do your tutorials to learn)
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Nice, that would be good timing.
@wedge_one
@wedge_one 6 жыл бұрын
If I were you I'd learn 2.79 now and feel right at home when 2.8 comes out. There's a 2 hour free tutorial on Udemy for beginners which is the best tutorial to get started.
@deuswulf6193
@deuswulf6193 6 жыл бұрын
A lot is changing with 2.8 as well. It might not be good to get used to a keymap and control scheme that is in the works. 2.8's "beta" is supposed to be out this year though, so the wait won't be that bad.
@wedge_one
@wedge_one 6 жыл бұрын
The basic keymaps won't change at all. What's changing is actually getting improved, not something you'd have to learn from scratch if you're coming from 2.79. So there's really no point at all in waiting, and you can also go ahead and download the dev build of 2.8. Really, give yourself a head start, you won't regret it!
@deuswulf6193
@deuswulf6193 6 жыл бұрын
Sort of, they will retain a basic legacy keymap.. however Blender's keymap is quite bad and has very little compatibility with the industry standard choices. Thus its not good to build up habits around it. I suppose the OP could use the Maya keymap that is found in Blender as it is now, but still one will have to adapt again to some changes with 2.8. See: developer.blender.org/T54963 ^its better to hold out for that. Additionally, if the OP is already using software they are familiar with then there really is no rush to jump to 2.79 when 2.8 beta is around the corner. This is just my opinion though.
@makanansari144
@makanansari144 6 жыл бұрын
I'm really happy to went with Blender! it's amazing program! I love open source projects, I'm glad you liked it too.
@theversatileartist6446
@theversatileartist6446 6 жыл бұрын
I'm a concept artist and I gave blender a shot, couldn't be more pleased, the results are amazing and the usability is great. I can do any thing that keyshot or any other $1000 software can do and for free!
@josephbrandenburg4373
@josephbrandenburg4373 5 жыл бұрын
Have you seen the new Grease pencil tools? I wish I was a concept artist for the sake of using those.
@RonnieMirands
@RonnieMirands 5 жыл бұрын
Sometimes we just ~change~ cause we are tired of the same, so we try to find reasons that justify that. But Modo is much superior than Blender in modelling area, in many ways. No doubt!
@DisgruntledPigumon
@DisgruntledPigumon 5 жыл бұрын
Sadly the reason I’m still using the paid app MODO is that its interface makes sense. Blender is a MESS. Actually blender is like Maya. It’s very engineer friendly, not artist friendly. I love the idea of Blender, but every time I download it it’s like walking into a nuclear power plant and trying to figure out how to do one thing. You’re just standing there and "whaaaaaaaaat"?
@mustafaozturk3343
@mustafaozturk3343 5 жыл бұрын
Just check 2.8, it is completly different now. Actually Blender 2.8 feels like Modo.
@YardenRaveh
@YardenRaveh 5 жыл бұрын
@Darren Munsell 2.8 IS still in beta though, not ready for production
@cgmalayalam3386
@cgmalayalam3386 4 жыл бұрын
Check bforartist. It is blender but with more customized ui
@eternalguy6023
@eternalguy6023 4 жыл бұрын
Now blender has best ui, try it
@DisgruntledPigumon
@DisgruntledPigumon 3 жыл бұрын
I saw that Blender has revamped everything, so I’m giving it ANOTHER go. And there seem to be TONS of tutorials on KZbin now which could make all the difference. :). Even Flipped Normals is in on it. And some new guy Josh Grambel (?) has been pumping out insane tuts I’m actually excited this time!
@timotmon
@timotmon 4 жыл бұрын
I wish modo was strictly a modeling program again with a cheaper license. They tried to turn it into a full production software and it's just not working. The UI needs to be updated to 4K .. it's so awful looking on my screen. But It's still one of the best hard surface modeling programs out there.
@jones1351
@jones1351 6 жыл бұрын
I'm a noob to 3D, modeling etc. A year ago I was interested in animation and 3D enough to dive in, but I didn't have a couple of grand just laying around, so - Blender! The first year was a little bumpy as you can imagine but I'm starting to get comfortable with it. So, so much to learn. Which brings me to my major point - all these amazing features for free. Mind blowing.
@chillinator
@chillinator 6 жыл бұрын
Yes - it *IS* mind-blowing. Stuns me every time I use it, actually. Once the word gets out that the UIX isn't that clunky 2.4 version any more, I think a lot of people are going to jump to Blender.
@federrr7
@federrr7 3 жыл бұрын
Switched from Modo to Blender cause is Free, I'm not able to pay a Modo license, so i used cracked version and was a headache do the installation of each update. Blender is continuously being improved Also there is a bigger community, and you can find solution to any problem and tutorials of almost everything. Also any addon is easily install
@MattMeersbergen
@MattMeersbergen 5 жыл бұрын
Fair enough. I started out in 3D studio max, worked in that for over 10 years and then found Modo. I use it a lot for animation, motion graphics and really love it. I see a lot of new stuff in Blender 2.8 which looks awesome too!
@tomh.6261
@tomh.6261 4 жыл бұрын
Sorry for the necropost. This just popped up in my feed. I started on modo 302. I ended at Modo 10 when the when to the new subscription plan. Modo went downhill when Brad Peebler left. I am having a hard time switching platforms. I just need to sit and noodle around for a while. I just hate feeling like a newb again. lol I loved your modo vids, and now I'm loving your Blender vids! Thanks, Vaughn! I'm always happy to throw money at you for any sci-fi related vids! :D
@Balabok
@Balabok 5 жыл бұрын
Thank you for all your hard work in getting the workflow up there where pros can jump in and start making cool stuff. I use pie menus all the time in Modo and marking menus in Maya.
@RobotJeeg
@RobotJeeg 6 жыл бұрын
I'm a Modo user and I'm studying Blender. Some things in Blender are so slow and boring to use that I immediately feel the need to make my own shortcuts, piemenu etc. But I'm not able to do it in Blender. Is there somewhere a buch of scripts to make Blender a little more "Modoish". For example the Spacebar to change selection mode...it's something I cannot live without. Blender has a menu to choose the selection mode...wow...slow as hell since you change mode every few seconds. This is just an example but lots of things are slower to use in Blender and I hope some guys will try to transform Blender in Modo (shortcuts and piemenus I mean). The other features of Blender looks awesome but honestly as it is in default configuration modeling is too slow! But I want to say that also Modo is becoming slower! The introduction of "mesh operators" in Modo for example is awesome but the implementation is very slow! The user is forced to open a few palette and click a lots to use it. This is weird for an application that has always been fast! Just to say that every application is fast in something and slow in something else. I'm sure that if Blender can be transformerd in a sort of Modo will be awesome!
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Check out this video, there's alot of pies and custom scripts that do the stuff you're talking about kzbin.info/www/bejne/rKrGmad6fZh3qNk
@RobotJeeg
@RobotJeeg 6 жыл бұрын
I'm already watching it. Thank you.
@deuswulf6193
@deuswulf6193 6 жыл бұрын
Also wait for 2.8 to roll around. This: developer.blender.org/T54963 Will give Modo users a more familiar approach to working with Blender. There is also a new feature that lets you right click on just about anything and make it a quick access item within a pull up menu. It will be a lot easier to get Blender to act similar enough to Modo in that regard, especially the 1-3 component selection.
@RobotJeeg
@RobotJeeg 6 жыл бұрын
I started learning Blender because of 2.8! I saw a video about 2.8 new features and I was happy to see that lots of things finally are "common to other applications". What I mean is that finally I saw behaviours that are similar to other applications and that almost stantard nowadays! For example in 2.8 if you click a button the command doesn't start immediately! It start when you click! I was very impress because this is common in every application except Blender. I hope they get rid of the right click for the 3d cursor and stuff like that...Blender users are used to that but a newbie find those things annoying. I cannot wait to see 2.8 and to learn hot to create piemenus and shortcuts.
@mustafaozturk3343
@mustafaozturk3343 5 жыл бұрын
@@RobotJeeg Now left click is default in Blender 2.8
@SarahIngleOfficial
@SarahIngleOfficial 5 жыл бұрын
The thumbnail! 🤣🤣🤣 I was going to add this to “Watch Later” then I looked closer at the thumbnail and decided I’ll go ahead and watch it now. 😁😂
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 5 жыл бұрын
mission accomplished :)
@MAGAMAN
@MAGAMAN 3 жыл бұрын
Modo was just lightwave 2.0 It still had most of the same problems as lightwave and after using it a short time, I moved to softimage. Softimage was quite amazing, but when it was bought out by Autodesk, it's development was stalled, and then eventually it was killed off. At about that time I switched from working as a 3d artist to becoming an editor for the company I worked for. Doing 3d work for a living kind of killed off my desire for 3d and I did not want to spend the time learning a new package. I did spend some time with Blender, but the current version was still a mess. Many years later, I have recently had the growing desire to get into 3d as a hobby again and downloaded blender 2.9 from Steam and the latest changes seem to have improved the UI a bit to the point where I can use it, but it is still far from great. I am cautiously optimistic that I will be able to use it to get the results I want, but I am probably going to have to customize the interface a lot to get an acceptable workflow.
@incaroads001
@incaroads001 6 жыл бұрын
20 year LW 3d user. They were a day late and a dollar short with their last update. And they treated me like a guest who had overstayed his welcome when I questioned them about it. I made the change to Blender last year and I haven't looked back. You are making the move at exactly the right time. ;)
@hasanhuseyindincer5334
@hasanhuseyindincer5334 6 жыл бұрын
After I used lightwave and modo for years, I went to blender. I am very pleased.
@craysiswanted
@craysiswanted 5 жыл бұрын
Merhaba.Yaklaşık 1 yıldır modo kullanan birisi olarak özellikle ülkemizde Modoya kıyasla daha çok tercih edildiği için Modonun yanına Maya programına yöneldim.Fakat maya her nekadar kaliteli olsada bana çok yavaş geldi.Şuan EEVEE ninde etkisiyle blender bana çok cazip geliyor fakat zamanımıda boşa harcamak istemem.Modoyuda kullanmış birisi olarak kıyaslıyabilirmisiniz.Program hızı,modelleme ve kalite anlamında Modo mu Blender mı?
@iberiuspred4906
@iberiuspred4906 5 жыл бұрын
I think that if you truly work professionally, the upfront cost of the software is not the most important factor to consider. Lets say that Modo costs say $1500 or whatever it is while Blender is free of charge; and you have a situation where using Modo means a much more efficient workflow then Blender and you get a lot more stuff done within a given period of time. If this is the case, then Modo will be a lot cheaper for you than Blender even though it is expensive to buy. Now, I'm not saying that this is the case with Blender vs Modo but I just want to illustrate that when considering using FOSS it is a bit myopic to merely look at the upfront costs of acquiring the software.
@HelloFabs
@HelloFabs 5 жыл бұрын
This is such a good point... I' have license of C4D, and with this new release of C4D and Blender... I am thinking if I should fork over 1500 just for an upgrade price..Im a bit angry about that.. but at the same time, I work so fast in C4D, I've been working with it for about 10 years.. and with Blender, I feel its a lot clunky in several places... So, since I make money out of a 3D software, I feel that C4D will pay for itself very shortly, whereas It would take me 4x to achieve the same thing in Blender, at least for the first year of use.
@dixie_rekd9601
@dixie_rekd9601 6 жыл бұрын
I started with a program called anim8or back in 2000 ish when i was just 15 :) then i went over to maya, which was great but i felt was lacking in some aspects, then i went to blender which i have been using since 2.49a ive tried other softwares like 3ds max and modo, but idk i just feel blender is my go-to tool :)
@StrongFreeLovin
@StrongFreeLovin 6 жыл бұрын
For somebody that just starts his journey with 3D, Blender is heaven on earth. It was like this for me, now after 2 years I pretty much mastered it and I don't really need Maya or ZBrush (I know about advantages) because it let's me do what I want, pretty much (and if it's not it's probably because I don't know about certain feature that's hiding somewhere, there's a lot of them and they're very cool, ex. drivers) With upcoming improvements Blender will win the industry.
@oalfernandes
@oalfernandes 6 жыл бұрын
Blender is free, but the team needs continues the work. So I contributed money to Blender because I think the project can not stop
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
agreed, blender cloud is a great way to support!
@nykytakudrya7741
@nykytakudrya7741 4 жыл бұрын
Unfortunately I think blender foundation is richer than most of us anyways!
@danylbekhoucha6180
@danylbekhoucha6180 6 жыл бұрын
Quick answer: since The Foundry (aka Autodesk bis) has acquired Modo they have doubled his price and haven't released any major update yet, they just have included MeshFusion and incremented the version number (and today we use the Bevel shader and it's available in Blender). The sofware is dead.
@gidkideon
@gidkideon 6 жыл бұрын
While the speed of development isn't what you may want, or in areas you want, I wouldn't spread misinformation like this. Mesh ops came after Mesh Fusion for instance. I'm not going to try and defend the development cycle of MODO in terms of pace, but just saying it stopped at Mesh Fusion is just wrong. Before you get all upset, don't think I don't like blender too. I have my little USB rocket right in front of me on my desk. What I don't like is people just spreading BS without checking on their facts first.
@danylbekhoucha6180
@danylbekhoucha6180 6 жыл бұрын
Anyway the new price that has doubled for no other reason than milking it, the lack of development and his competitor Blender that is free and evolves quickly will slowly kill Modo and the size of his community. And since Modo is acquired by a profit only corporation I don't really care about the future of the software, I am just sad for their users but maybe they will feel comfortable with Blender if they give it enough time.
@gidkideon
@gidkideon 6 жыл бұрын
Yes, price has gone up. That is true. Not sure blender will be what kills MODO or not. Could happen, but I think other factors are at play too. Don't quite understand though why you hate MODO so much. Honestly Autodesk has done a lot more to damage the CG marketplace than the Foundry ever has.
@danylbekhoucha6180
@danylbekhoucha6180 6 жыл бұрын
Both aim to earn as much money as possible even if it harms the CG industry as long as it is profitable, this reason alone should be an argument to boycott it if a non-profit alternative exist. You will say that it is what most capitalism companies do, but Luxology tried to make interesting modelling tools at least, while The Foundry doesn't seem to care much of his future. I know Autodesk has killed 50+ software and technologies but The Foundry isn't an example too, they never innovated they maintain their high price from their software that were popular in the past before the competitors come out. They do nothing to keep them up to date and be competitive. Substance Painter is much more recent than Mari and is already the industry standard for PBR texturing and they had the time to rewrite it from scratch with their small team in France while Mari hasn't changed since decades and they don't have any plan other than costing 8 times the price of Substance Painter (for a painting tool!) until the software dies. Nuke is bloated and cost the price of a small car for a compositing tool, their past updates were just some performance improvements. The price of Mari, Nuke and Modo and their lack of innovation reflects how greedy this company is, I won't be surprised if a massive lay off is announced like Autodesk did at the end of 2017 after their bad behavior with their customers and greedy strategy. At least artists start to understand that they have been scammed by those companies and their money invested to kill innovations, technologies and jobs. They are giving more time to try Blender. Using Blender isn't just using another software, it is contributing to innovate in the CG field and for a passionate like me, it is important to avoid every corporate CG companies. And I would feel very bad to give them money while being aware that those companies kill software, innovation and jobs that is why I try to stick with FOSS software in my workflow even if the software is limited, for example I stay with GIMP instead of Photoshop and Godot instead of Unreal.
@Endangereds
@Endangereds 5 жыл бұрын
Difference between Blender and other paid softwares is... if you don't like, you pay and get stuck in a loop of subscription with paid softwares. But Blender is something which you will pay out of gratitude, when you start earning. Later if you think you can afford any paid software, you can still have blender as fail safe and reduce production costs.
@PeerlessUtopian
@PeerlessUtopian 4 жыл бұрын
Truth.
@philosoaper
@philosoaper 6 жыл бұрын
I don't use blender despite having spent several hundred dollars on the free blender campaign back in the day. Why? Because I hoped that blender one day might not give me aneurisms by merely opening it. It looks like 2.8 might FINALLY be getting towards that state. Blender has always had lots of great features but wrapped in a user interface and workflow that made blood vessels in my head explode and try to kill me. Looking forward to 2.8 and beyond, a lot. (yes yes shortcuts, but thing is.. peoples minds are differently organized. I'm very visually oriented so a good GUI works far more efficiently for me than a list of shortcuts, I wish people would understand this. I think that's why a lot of people just can't blend. Me included)
@pixelqubed
@pixelqubed 6 жыл бұрын
Couldnt agree more. I use 3ds max and thats a VERY UI orianted software and ive been using that for about 2 and a half years now and I feel comfortable with that workflow but the licence is just ughhhhh. Im considering Modo because it looks to be the closest ive seen to max and that type of workflow but I used blender for 5 mins and I just got frustrated and closed it, uninstalled it, through my hard drive in an incinerator... Basicly all I hear is ``Move to Blender``, ``Screw paid software and move to blender`` and im just sitting there thinking, I dont care if software is paid or not, I want a good UI, something I can migrate easily too and I dont want to pay a TON out for a licence, then I find Modo and i'm like, ``eh is modo any good?`` and all I see is, ``dafq is modo?`` You see my point? People tend to jump on the band waggon without the consideration of other software. Thats what I did with 3ds Max and I think I have learnt my lesson. If blender comes out with a more polished UI and stuff, ill be using that but until that happens, alternitves will be considered.
@josephbrandenburg4373
@josephbrandenburg4373 5 жыл бұрын
Try BForArtists, it's a fork of Blender with the goal of having the kind of UI you seem to prefer. I haven't tried it myself, but I'm one of those people that loves to use the keyboard for everything, and hates to see icons of any kind. I even like right click select! Anyways, I think it will be good for Blender overall if BforArtists is successful, even if I prefer standard Blender.
@Imperfectlink.
@Imperfectlink. 6 жыл бұрын
I'm an ex modo, maya, max user myself. There are many reasons to jump to Blender. Most of which, the other dcc's just can't compete with.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Yup, I guess a benefit of experience with all those programs is you can jump to another one relatively easily.
@deuswulf6193
@deuswulf6193 6 жыл бұрын
Eh depends on what you find value in. For example, if substances are a big part of your workflow, and you need to work natively in your DCC with substances... then Blender simply cannot complete due to its licensing. It struggles with FBX workflows as well. GPL can be a limiting factor as to what it is compatible with. This may change in the future, but for now there are some areas that Blender cannot compete evenly in. Some of it is due to lack of development, the other due to licensing issues. Its a shame that there is truly no one perfect application.
@AsamiImako
@AsamiImako 6 жыл бұрын
Honestly it's the industry's tendency towards patent-encumbered, license-restricted standards and formats like FBX that should be looked at as the issue here. It's one thing to create some proprietary format that's designed to be used only with your application, but for industry-wide interchange formats, an open, freely-licensed standard should be seen as the only proper solution. In that regard, glTF2 seems to be a nice one to aim for, and is thankfully slowly being picked up (UE4 for example is working on implementing support for it).
@deuswulf6193
@deuswulf6193 6 жыл бұрын
+Anthony Flagg The industry goes towards what works and what gets the job done. The ideological equation is not really a factor. There is also nothing wrong with that. In the case of FBX, it had a big head start, with it appearing in everything from C4D, Softimage, Lightwave and 3DS Max. In the usual fashion, Autodesk only became the owner of FBX (film box) after Kaydara sold to Alias, which in turn sold itself to Autodesk. Part of the issue is the licensing for Blender itself when it relates to proprietary file formats. On one hand we have a hard coplyleft which demands everything is open source (GPL) and on the hand we have a copyright which protects closed source. If you want the middle ground where both can play nice you start to look at license types such as MIT and Apache. I agree with you though in that open file formats, while not always possible due to what they are part of, are ideal for the kind of industry we are in. glTF looks like its off to a good start, and there is willingness to adopt it.
@deuswulf6193
@deuswulf6193 6 жыл бұрын
M Hurly I misinterpreted nothing. You seem confused, Open Source is an approach, GPL is the license type. The license type is the problem. Cycles is not GPL. Were you aware of that? It is licensed under Apache 2.0. The most popular Open Source license is MIT. Both of those are considered permissive licenses. It also is considered "CopyCenter", as opposed to CopyLeft or CopyRight. Since Cycles is Apache 2.0, it can be used in closed source, commercial packages. If it was licensed as GPL, that could not happen without the target also changing its license to one that is compatible with GPL. Its for this reason why Allegorithmic cannot create a direct substance plugin (same as the ones that exist in Maya, Modo..ect). Remember, Open Source is a broad category, focus on the licensing and you will understand the inherent problems with GPL. GPL is only one license type (out of many) under the open source category.
@WeatherWonders
@WeatherWonders 5 жыл бұрын
In Blender, right-clicking on a function in a context menu like the deletion one yields the option to add a direct keyboard shortcut. Of course, keyboard shortcuts also have a tab in the user preferences.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 5 жыл бұрын
True, but which would you rather work with: A separate hotkey for each delete type or 1 hotkey which knows what type of delete to use based on what you have selected.
@franckbirolini4275
@franckbirolini4275 6 жыл бұрын
It's strange, I am an hobbyist, and tried Blender 3 or 4 times; with tutorial, but never succeed in adopting it, to complex, not well thought, even sometime not logical ( according to me of course), but gave a try to Modo 6 years ago, and felt like at home, so bought it and have upgraded every version since. I will definitively give Blender another try, but when UI will be more polished.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
I felt the same way about Modo vs Blender's UI. I spend a few years tweaking the Blender UI to something much more streamlined for modelling, check it out: kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4nFlXiffct-nrc
@YardenRaveh
@YardenRaveh 5 жыл бұрын
try testing testing the new blender 2.8 beta. The UI was overhauled and in my opinion it is awesome, you might like this time. I am not a pro though just an enthusiast.
@SteveWarner
@SteveWarner 6 жыл бұрын
I started with Modeler in the late 80's on the Amiga. That program became LightWave Modeler (which I switched to in the early 90's) and ultimately Modo. I think Stuart Ferguson created one of the best modeling apps in the world, and the success of Modo is a testimony to that. Nonetheless, I switched to Blender about a year and a half ago, and am now thoroughly convinced that it's the best 3D app on the market. I've used LightWave, Max, Modo, and Maya professionally over the years. And Blender trumps them all. Version 2.8 is bringing some much-needed interface and usability tweaks. But even without them, 2.79 is a true workhorse. Earlier this year, I made it the official pipeline app in our studio. I could tell that the Maya, Max and Modo artists on staff weren't sure about the move. But 3 months in, I've had them telling me that they now prefer Blender. It's not perfect, of course. But those who snub it because it's open source are missing out on an incredibly powerful tool.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Congrats on the pipeline switch, that's pretty impressive! Glad your team was able to pick it up
@TheRobaatoChannel
@TheRobaatoChannel 6 жыл бұрын
You're one of the main original reasons I jumped into learning Modo, but you've convinced me to finally take the plunge and switch to Blender after so many tries over the years. I definitely agree with the evangelical views of most Blender users which also put me off LOL, but there's just no denying that Blender is definitely going upward 2.8 and on.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Yup..I'm a little guilty of it too now but ah well. It's a fun time to be 3D modelling in general.
@ARGHouse504
@ARGHouse504 6 жыл бұрын
After having to use Maya for texturing, Modo is thus far my favourite 3D software at all time, great UI, easy to use and learn. I'll probably give Blender a go.
@sat1345
@sat1345 6 жыл бұрын
moved to blender when modo doing subscription, a few days in blender and i find it a GREAT & FREE 3d software
@MAGAMAN
@MAGAMAN 3 жыл бұрын
Subscriptions are killing the paid software industry. Yo no longer own your software and if you decide you don't want to pay monthly, you lose all access to the software. This means that developers can be lazy and only add 1 or two new things to their updates, and you can't say, nope, I'll skip this version, like you used to be able to do.
@geovani60624
@geovani60624 6 жыл бұрын
Blender is awesome, such a powerfull tool open to anyone who dares to create art just blows my mind
@marcotronic
@marcotronic 6 жыл бұрын
I also switched from modo to Blender some years back and never looked back. Also used C4D and Maya before many many years. Each and every day I'm amazed how great Blender is, especially for a software that is completely free. But even if it costed money it would probably be my program of choice. 2.8 is gonna be mindblowing.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Agreed...the $0 price tag is the cherry on top, it's amazing regardless.
@SupSupa10
@SupSupa10 6 жыл бұрын
I jump from Blender, May, MAX to Cinema 4D and Houdini and never com back. C4D + Houdini are 100000 times better than Blender, Maya, Max . VFX and Mograph in Blender is some joke, very bad.
@HannesGrebin
@HannesGrebin Жыл бұрын
Hey just decided to leave also modo for blender today. Is there any chance you make a mate even paid tutorial where you explain all the settings you made setting up blender for your modo experience? Would be very helpful as modelling seems way different and I loved the approach when modelling in modo. Thank you!
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly Жыл бұрын
Yup, check gumroad.com/vling
@lawrencedoliveiro9104
@lawrencedoliveiro9104 6 жыл бұрын
2:44 That’s not quite what Blender means by those options, though: for example, “only faces” means leave the edges and vertices behind. How do you do that in Modo?
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
I think both have the ability to do 'only faces' but how often do you use that in regular modelling?
@lawrencedoliveiro9104
@lawrencedoliveiro9104 6 жыл бұрын
I find all the options useful.
@To-mos
@To-mos 4 жыл бұрын
Blender has come a very long way since I first tried it, I am a hardcore 3dsmax junkie but in the recent years I have very seriously considered changing over to it.
@judemark
@judemark 6 жыл бұрын
Glad you accepted the good news about Blender and now sharing in preaching the message. lol. JW that was funny to me being one by the way.
@lawrencedoliveiro9104
@lawrencedoliveiro9104 6 жыл бұрын
1:35 Unfortunately that game engine has been dropped from 2.8. But there might be more fun stuff coming down the track, later.
@admirnaruto
@admirnaruto 5 жыл бұрын
Good news for your there is a full game engine being made, to have full blender intigration, and it's open source. It's called Armory3D.
@Advection357
@Advection357 6 жыл бұрын
I'm sorry to say this but... after modelling in Softimage|XSI for 17 years, everything is a downgrade in terms of polymesh & hard surface modelling workflows. I've tried it all... Max, Maya, Modo, Blender... none of them have the elegance & efficient setup out of the box that came with Softimage & require more unnecessary mouse/kb steps between modelling operations. In Softimage, everything is 1 key or 1 click away, from menus to various tools... not 2, not 3. Also... F**k Autodesk.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
I've always heard good things about XSI...sad that they killed it
@Advection357
@Advection357 6 жыл бұрын
It is... & the saddest part is they killed it because people & companies that bought Softimage had no need for Max or Maya afterwards... so obviously it was bad for business & Autodesk prefers a segmented market of divided products for increased profits... Softimage was too versatile & it cannibalized other app sales.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Yea...it's gotten to the point where I would love to use programs like fusion 360 but I don't because I don't want to deal with Autodesk.
@Advection357
@Advection357 6 жыл бұрын
You don't have to... I'd just use Dassault SolidWorks for CAD
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Yup...but that's pretty expensive
@volker2714
@volker2714 4 жыл бұрын
I am, or was, a Modo user, have used it professionally (modeling) since version 401, last one I upgraded to was version 13.0. Since they have released Blender 2.8, I barely use Modo at all now. I will continue using Modo occasionally, there are some features that Blender doesn't have (e.g. there is no equivalent to the Modo UV transform operator in Blender, and the workplane functionality is far superior to this poor 3d cursor thing in Blender), but in no way do the features in Modo justify expenses of more than 400€ each year for me anymore. With a couple of (paid) addons, Blender offers all, or most, of the features any modeler could wish for, for almost no expenses at all. It almost feels like a steal to me.
@nicellisbrown
@nicellisbrown 3 жыл бұрын
Which one would you recommend for someone wanting to model and design a modern sneaker?
@lakestones9266
@lakestones9266 3 жыл бұрын
Definitly will work on blender, Since Solidworks just requires and still requiring a lot of software add ons to produce a decent Render o animation, but when it comes to render animations, still has a lot to improve
@revirtv1425
@revirtv1425 6 жыл бұрын
One of the best things I've noticed in blender that I love the most, the devs listen to the community. Been using it for a little over 3-4 years now. I love Blender, and I'll never switch to another program.
@agooodolecoder
@agooodolecoder 3 жыл бұрын
I really liked your modo tutorials. Would have liked to see more of them..but great to see that you can reach a much, much larger audience with your blender tutorials...
@f4ust85
@f4ust85 3 жыл бұрын
I dont really think it is (or should be) about the package Modo offers or the modelng toolset these days and how many clicks one makes while doing a selection. The first and major reason many people jump ship and abandon/dont choose Modo in the first place is you and other notable/visible users switching to other software in recent years - theres simply very few tutorials and content for Modo released these days, very little active community, very few inspiring artists I could count on the fingers of one hand, and instead of getting some on their payroll and making Modo look cool again to attract new users, Foundry concentrates on FOOTWEAR DESIGN and releases updates that dont bring anything of substrance, many elementary tools being untouched for nearly a decade. It just doesnt seem very inspiring or progressive to learn Modo these days when you see that theres far more content for C4D or Blender or Max every day. On artstation, theres 20 times more content coming from Blender users than Modo. Its like a nice language nobody speaks, perhaps like Esperanto - the original idea was great, it was sort of ahead of its time and sounded so much promising, but it never REALLY took off and now simply nobody speaks it and books are rare to come by, so why invest years into something that is either getting more and more obscure every year and is eventually going to die off, or you will be on your own, using Modo 19 or 23 where some major features like fur havent been updated for a decade?
@caruya
@caruya 6 жыл бұрын
How about UV mapping? it's unfortunately still very unsophisticated in Blender IMO
@mitthjarta5
@mitthjarta5 6 жыл бұрын
Funny you say that, when i was using Maya (2011 and 2013) it was defacto in the places around me to use Roadkill, if you look into it Roadkill's code was lifted directly from blender, and they even mention as much. it might have fallen behind a tad in the last 2 years or so but before that it was miles ahead for a long time.
@aleph-tav
@aleph-tav 6 жыл бұрын
Agree
@ExacoMvm
@ExacoMvm 6 жыл бұрын
use Unfold3D, literally the best UV unwrapping software.
@Salt_CoffeeZ
@Salt_CoffeeZ 5 жыл бұрын
Dear ,no matter what software you are using.i think the skill is the key!
@kilonaliosI
@kilonaliosI 5 жыл бұрын
Building blender yourself is super easy. Its like 3-5 commands in the command line to setup and from there on is only 2 to update the code and build it. This way you can have a new build every hour, basically each time the code is changed you can make a new build out of it. Modo kinda funny for me, because I consider it one of the best UIs if not the best and its developers used to work for Lightwave which I consider one of worst UIs. Blender UI is definetly not as good, but especially with 2.8 I can finally say its good enough. I am a huge fan of Blender though so maybe I am biased :D
@deviljerome
@deviljerome 6 жыл бұрын
i also switched from lightwave 3d/maya to blender... Blender is awesome
@camtg14
@camtg14 5 жыл бұрын
Modo is so powerfull, I can't leave it
@luqman_azeem
@luqman_azeem 4 жыл бұрын
Isn't it too expensive?
@MetalGearMk3
@MetalGearMk3 4 жыл бұрын
Every modern day software is powerful lol
@DisgruntledPigumon
@DisgruntledPigumon 3 жыл бұрын
Have you tried the new Blender. I think I’m switching. The power is there now.
@1conscience0dimension
@1conscience0dimension 3 жыл бұрын
@@DisgruntledPigumon not under the surface...
@patrickbandau2664
@patrickbandau2664 6 жыл бұрын
you can press ctrl+x while having an element selected and it will be deleted without the popup asking further input
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
This works for dissolve but not for delete...I have a menu that lets you delete faces, objects, edges anything all without any popup...it just deletes whatever you have selected
@patrickbandau2664
@patrickbandau2664 6 жыл бұрын
Yes, right, it´s "just" dissolve. Good that you found a way to make it work for you :)
@mirham3802
@mirham3802 6 жыл бұрын
Same here, came from Max to blender and never regret... BLENDER IS GETTING BETTER AND BETTER.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Yea, it feels like a gigantic snowball at this point
@Pixel_FX
@Pixel_FX 5 жыл бұрын
I started 3D with C4D way back in 2005. when i was 16. then i stopped everything after about an year later. And I started learning Blender in the end half of 2016 and I am still using it. I tried 3D max and maya about 6 months ago but they feel so slow and too many clicks to model just a simple thing. specially 3D max. Interface is a full of buttons clutter mess. But most max users say Blender interface is hard lol. I can challenge to anyone who use 3D max to model anything and I can do it way faster in Blender. You can literally do stuff eyes closed in blender because it has so many shortcuts and hotkeys. With all the addons like Mesh Machine, Loop tools, Hard ops, there is absolutely no other software which can model faster than blender.
@Zhiznestatistiks
@Zhiznestatistiks 6 жыл бұрын
Interesting video. But there is one major difference between blender and other 3d modeling packages. It seems like you're not utilizing it, but whatever works best for you. It's that you don't need to be dependant on gizmo and viewport orientation all the time. I am trying to start modeling inside 3ds'max and modo, but it's so god damn frustrating to always seek and click on gizmo, or rotate view to change workplane like in modo. Blender on another hand can be used without gizmo, and even wtihout rotating the view at all. In blender, you just press the button in any part of viewport and the object is moving, then you press second button and you're moving along one or two axis, or rotating, scaling etc. Just GX and you are moving alonside X. RZ, rotating along Z. Even if you're fastest mouse\tablet user in the west, it's so much faster to not making unnecessary movements. And yeah. Lot's and lots useful features that came with the software. Like F2, Tiny CAD, Bsurface etc, some of which are usually done in other software by people like you, who like to write scripts for themself.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Agreed, the Transforms are one of my favorite things about Blender, especially that you don't have to hold any keys or mouse buttons to move. Modo transforms were pretty amazing too, you don't have to click the axis, holding ctrl would auto lock to whichever axis you dragged. Also workplanes in Modo are extremely useful vs Blender's 3D cursor.
@josephbrandenburg4373
@josephbrandenburg4373 5 жыл бұрын
@@Heavypoly 2.8's 3D cursor can now rotate, there's discussion on Right Click Select forum about creating a workplane feature in Blender using the 3D cursor as the origin of the new workplane. I think it could be done in Python, so if you miss the workplane, you might contact the people on that forum and try writing an addon.
@hagaiitz
@hagaiitz 6 жыл бұрын
I only care about that last part of the video where you model the smooth transition between that spaceship’s body and its engine. Adding this sub d strip on top of the transition looks like a great solution, I would really love to see more of those.
@GerhardAEUhlhorn
@GerhardAEUhlhorn 5 жыл бұрын
Many bugs in Modo are unfixed over many years! This is a huge problem of Modo! So I tried Blender too, but the user interface and the way 3d objects are handled is a horror! And the missing material library ist a no go for me.
@deebee7909
@deebee7909 6 жыл бұрын
2:18 You can delete the geometry you have selected with a context-sensitive dissolve, or Ctrl-X. This will delete whatever you have selected without bringing up a menu.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Ctrl X is good but it doesn't delete verts if I remember correctly, I have a context sensitive delete that replaces X, and can delete everything including objects and stuff in the outliner
@aurecana5233
@aurecana5233 6 жыл бұрын
About the contextual delete , there is an addon called Smart Delete , give it a look
@MarkBTomlinson
@MarkBTomlinson 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for your thoughts on this.
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Yup, hope it helps
@ADreamCalledeternity
@ADreamCalledeternity 6 жыл бұрын
I actually know someone from the Blender dev team, and went to the Amsterdam conference around the time this video was made. They'll be working as a professor at my college this fall as an animator. Glad to see that there are more people learning and getting into Blender. You've got stunning work! ♡
@joeyparenti7815
@joeyparenti7815 2 жыл бұрын
nah youre lying
@ADreamCalledeternity
@ADreamCalledeternity 2 жыл бұрын
@@joeyparenti7815 You're joking, right? lol bc that's literally what happened when I went to college
@joeyparenti7815
@joeyparenti7815 2 жыл бұрын
@@ADreamCalledeternity youre literally lying
@ADreamCalledeternity
@ADreamCalledeternity 2 жыл бұрын
@TreGear Bassam Kurdali! They were so fun to work with, super inspiring and talented!
@BenLe42
@BenLe42 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the video. In your opinion, what are the differences in your day to modelling work-flow? Is it faster? Are you getting to your end product faster? Easier to use?
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Main difference as I said in the video are modifiers and rendering, which makes things faster. I still think Modo wins in the pleasant/easy to use category.
@robyloreto6965
@robyloreto6965 4 жыл бұрын
the best program is The Foundry Modo 13.2v1, but I still haven't understood how uv map is done and how to make the bake, and save the project including textur.
@dirtfriend
@dirtfriend 4 жыл бұрын
modo is a complete non-starter for a hobbyist too. 1600 EUR for a perpetual license is straight up _insane_
@f0rl
@f0rl 5 жыл бұрын
I decided to try MODO for a year. I wanted something with better modeling tools. Big mistake. While the tools really are better, the application is really, really bad. It crashes constantly and I mean constantly, all the time. It can't go through 2 hours of modeling without it crashing at least 4 times. Also I have to delete the user config file regularly because it just gets corrupted somehow. Now I'm just sad that I gave them money. If anyone's reading this, save yourself the trouble and just don't buy it, seriously, you'll be banging your head against a wall if you do.
@plumfun6750
@plumfun6750 6 жыл бұрын
I love Blender...except when I hate Blender. ;) Been trying to wrap my artistic brain around Blender since it was still owned by NaN in the late 90's. So far, Softiamge 3D (and then XSI) have been the easiest 3D programs for me to "grasp", workflow and logic wise. Next is Modo. I love the viewport movements (from Lightwave), with Alt, Alt+Shift, Alt+Ctrl and Left click. But like other frustrated potential-Blender-Users, I'm hopeful that the new 2.8 UI and flow will finally let me "get" Blender.
@damicore
@damicore 5 жыл бұрын
have you made the jump to blender, already? just curious.
@josephbrandenburg4373
@josephbrandenburg4373 5 жыл бұрын
There's BforArtists, it's supposed to have a more approachable UI, but then again, I'm one of those people that prefers vanilla Blender.
@luqman_azeem
@luqman_azeem 4 жыл бұрын
For a game designer who doesn't model 365 days a year, blender is the obvious option right?
@Safetyman99
@Safetyman99 6 жыл бұрын
Can't you hit CTRL + x and delete whatever is selected without a popup menu? The beauty of the Blender way of deleting is that if you have a lot selected and you only want to delete the polys/points/edges you can do that. In Modo, you'd have to specifically select what you wanted to delete, correct?
@tomiviitanen
@tomiviitanen 6 жыл бұрын
I think Blender is kinda hard to learn, but I started 3D with Blender so it's hard to say. After that I've been forced to learn and use Maya and 3Ds Max at my work (they still let me use Blender whenever it was possible, so thats nice of them). Now that I have about 2 years of experience of those Autodesk softwares I can confirmly state that those softwares takes all the fun out of 3D. The viewport is awfully bad in both which really slows your workflow. Other thing is that those are really heavy on your computer compared to Blender. Anyway I have seen some outstanding artwork made with Maya, 3Ds Max and Blender so I guess it just depends on your personal preferences. After you master all the necessary hotkeys in Blender, I feel like modeling is way faster in it compared to Max and Maya. Also Blenders modifier stack is something I really miss while using Max/Maya. First downside that comes to mind of Blender are the simulations at the moment. By the way, if you feel like Blender is hard to learn, just go and try Houdini. :)
@peshangahmed2484
@peshangahmed2484 5 жыл бұрын
btw .. the word "hard" is relative
@orphydiancg7759
@orphydiancg7759 5 жыл бұрын
You miss Blender modifier stack when working with Max ? I Think that just disqualifies your opinions and you're just a fannyboy trying to show an interesting story.
@camelCased
@camelCased 3 жыл бұрын
Yeah, I'm so sad there is no free/cheap 3D software that has Modo-like UI. When I started experimenting with 3D, I also fell in love with Modo because I could intuitively find everything I need without having to look in a manual or on the Internet (and I didn't have Internet when I started working with 3D). Modo was especially great for occasional 3D hobby level mesh editing. If not using Blender for a few months, you can easily forget how to do something. In Modo, it's very easy to catch up. Also, Blender's UI can overwhelm you with functions that cannot be executed in the current context. For example, when you have an edge selected, Blender will not disable vertex and face menu items that do not even work on an edge, and you end up scratching your head "why it doesn't work..." Unfortunately, Modo is too expensive.
@ajgor64
@ajgor64 6 жыл бұрын
Deleting part of model (faces, vertices or edges) in Blender is MUCH MUCH more powerfull tool than in MODO. You can (fe.) delete face, but leave edges belonging to this face, and then extrude them, etc. In Modo You can't do it in that way. Or even You can delete whole model, and leave ONE VERTICE, and extrude it to edge, then extrude it to next edge, and so on to build polygon curve, then extrude this curve, or bridge it to another etc.
@Lymboever
@Lymboever 5 жыл бұрын
Blender is te combination of: Game engine. Software 3D modeling. FX EDITOR. Video editor. CGI animation engine. 2D/3D hybrid animation engine.
@amigarulez
@amigarulez 4 жыл бұрын
Game engine that no one uses. 3D modeling is mediocre at best. VFX no one uses. Video editor for basic editing. CGI animation engine really dunno what that means. Animation tools are sort-of fine.
@belivmi
@belivmi 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for sharing you skill and your choices, really really appreciated
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the kind words!
@educate3d
@educate3d 6 жыл бұрын
Am i the only person who started in Blender and left? But 2.8 wants me to come back. I still prefer Maya when working on a team. Just a better pipeline tool
@JohnGodwin
@JohnGodwin 3 жыл бұрын
So this video is two years old, what's the deal now - has Blender gained a larger gap from Modo, or has Modo come back?
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 3 жыл бұрын
Bigger gap
@yobooboy5591
@yobooboy5591 3 жыл бұрын
I've watched the whole video and still have no clue why you switched.
@allenl9214
@allenl9214 3 жыл бұрын
Dont just watch. Listen xD
@wh173
@wh173 5 жыл бұрын
About deleting stuff being a "1 step process" thats how most 3d software work, not just Modo, Blender is the one with extra steps. Im interested in switching to Blender 2.8 from Max (also worked with Maya in the past) and your videos seem nice, but, I dont like starting out with someones personalized shortcuts. Your videos would probably gain more traction with vannilla settings especially since 2.8 videos are few.
@lawrencedoliveiro9104
@lawrencedoliveiro9104 6 жыл бұрын
1:18 It always surprises a Blender user like me that non-destructive modifiers are not commonplace in other software.
@chillinator
@chillinator 6 жыл бұрын
They actually were - but Autodesk killed the software that had them - i.e. Softimage. In SI, everything you did was an operator - every point you moved, everything you created, every function performed. This allowed you to rearrange the operator stack, or, mute certain functions, or mute entire sequences. It's nice to see that some of the advanced features of SI's workflow are part of Blender. What has always baffled me is that Autodesk bought SI, killed it (after SWEARING they weren't going to) and scavenged the corpse (BiFrost is ICE rebranded, etc). SI had a vastly superior architecture and UIX to Maya - which is a garage sale of crap they've scavenged from other software. After personally paying support for over a decade only to have them kill SI, I refused to go back to the dark side. So glad to see Blender advancing so quickly.
@lastone032085
@lastone032085 6 жыл бұрын
The biggest botch AD ever made was killing XSI and keeping MAX.
@orphydiancg7759
@orphydiancg7759 5 жыл бұрын
Not that I treasure too much these kind of workflows but Blender modifier stack is a joke compared to max ones. Same for many modifiers in Blender that are old and bare bones. And non destructivrnes can be handled more elegantly and efficient than through modifiers. Cinema 4d way.
@3Rton
@3Rton 6 жыл бұрын
You can actually use ctrl-x to do dissolve based on what you have selected. It is bit weird that this is not the default behaviour but the modifier one but *shrug* Also I guess it still makes it bit bothersome to do something like deleting faces. (Personally I feel like they should do context dissolve on X, context delete on ctrl-x and menu on alt-x but oh well)
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Yea ctrl-x context dissolve is great, while delete is a menu...these kind of inconsistencies are the 'low hanging fruit' for improving the UI
@Staglaitor
@Staglaitor 3 жыл бұрын
Thank you for precious anylization. Why do you think that 10 programs in oone (blender) is better than focusing only for just one discipline????? I deem that modo can win only in one case: - focusing only on modeling to adjust it to perfection stage.
@MetalGearMk3
@MetalGearMk3 6 жыл бұрын
I'm going all in on Blender(been using Modo for 5+ years). Where can I get your scripts or addon for Blender?
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
This is the latest version: gumroad.com/l/BraunHL70 Good luck!
@gidkideon
@gidkideon 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for making this video! Can't really disagree with much of what you said, as a lot of it is true, but also generalized. I will say that the Foundry does release updates much more often than every year or every half year. They did this even before the Foundry bought MODO. It's no where as frequent as blender, Houdini or even Vray thought. They have gotten better at prioritizing bug squashing at the Foundry, but it would be nice to have nightly or weekly public builds (though one persons fix can be another's break).
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the correction
@gidkideon
@gidkideon 6 жыл бұрын
Yeah, I would like to see nightly or more frequent updates too for small fixes. Since they've got MODO running as SAS (Software as a Service) now you'd expect more frequent updates. Anyway, wasn't trying to detract from the good things about Blender since there are many, just trying to dot the I-zz and cross the T-zz. ;-) Personally I want Blender, Houdini AND MODO to succeed. Anything to help counter AD is a win in my book at least in the near term. That's why I went for the Blender funding campaign and have my little rocket on my desk. Well that and I've used blender on a few paid projects. ;-)
@petterlundh4274
@petterlundh4274 6 жыл бұрын
Could you explain your process for creating the cutlines on the yellow ship at the end of the video?
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Extruded the cutlines then boolean intersect to fit them to the body
@orphydiancg7759
@orphydiancg7759 5 жыл бұрын
@@Heavypoly do you have a short vid for that. I'm not familiar with the Boolean workflow and extending some cut lines then intersecting then with what ?
@STROBdotNET
@STROBdotNET 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks for your vid! I am switching to Blender from max. But I will also switch to Houdini! And for modeling Zbrush is my tool of choice. Houdini also has daylies BTW. Using Zbrush, Blender and Houdini Indie is the cheapeast and most powerful solution. There is nothing you can't do. Soooo looking forward to Blender 2.8 Already testeds hybrid GPU+CPU rendering and it's awesome!
@Heavypoly
@Heavypoly 6 жыл бұрын
Nice combo
@gipen
@gipen 6 жыл бұрын
I haven't seen modo before, now I know where all the UI ideas for bleder 2.8 came from!!
@gidkideon
@gidkideon 6 жыл бұрын
Modo has a great UI over all, and they're doing well with what they've been trying in 12.1. vimeo.com/276195509#embed Still, there is no reason the new Blender UI can't be just as good or better. Nothing wrong with gleaning UI ideas off one another IMHO.
@GrzegorzWronkowski
@GrzegorzWronkowski 5 жыл бұрын
I also switched from Modo to Blender. Feel like more creative now. I didn't want to spend so much for Modo upgrades.
@isurus0
@isurus0 3 жыл бұрын
Did he release the modifications he did to the blender interface to make it more like Modo? Maybe this isn't necessary since this is an older video and the current version is 2.93 with some major UI updates.
@gameman5804
@gameman5804 7 ай бұрын
Modo is just difficult for me to understand, even with the basics of moving around.
@zapfsaeule2
@zapfsaeule2 6 жыл бұрын
Very interesiting and welcome to Blender:) !
@AllThingsFilm1
@AllThingsFilm1 5 жыл бұрын
I am a big fan of Modo for years. Starting with v103. I recently downloaded Blender, and I'm starting to look at it more. If you can recommend good video tutorials for Blender, I would be extremely grateful.
@josephbrandenburg4373
@josephbrandenburg4373 5 жыл бұрын
BlenderGuru is what a lot of us start with, just be aware his videos are full of self-advertising these days (good products, though, so not a bad thing). CGCookie probably has the best mix of quality and variety. Blender cloud has some great stuff, although some of it is outdated (but Blender has stayed consistent, for the most part, and old versions are all available). Blenderdiplom has some good stuff. Gleb Alexandrov, Zachariaa Reinhardt, very talented artists. I think there's CG Geek, or maybe it's CG Master, could be both. There are plenty on youtube, gumroad, etc. The community is pretty open and helpful-- blenderartists.org has some gold you can never find in regular tutorial sites. I'd also recommend reading the blogs of artists that you like, using any software. You'll be able to use the same or similar techniques. I have to use Maya for schoolwork and I can't tell you how much I've been able to bring over from Blender, and the Maya artists are surprised because they never thought to use the software like that. Similarly, learning Maya has helped me in my Blender art.
@Lync1111
@Lync1111 2 жыл бұрын
Heavy Poly - I'm listening to you and it sounds like you are split between the two softwares. I am at this same cross roads and listening to you and would like to speak with you soon.
@brolylegendaryssj
@brolylegendaryssj 4 жыл бұрын
I was debating on whether or not I wanted to make the switch myself. One of the biggest reasons I like modo is the workplane feature. Do they have something like this in Blender that you are aware of?
The Secret Ingredient to Photorealism
31:28
Blender Guru
Рет қаралды 3,8 МЛН
这三姐弟太会藏了!#小丑#天使#路飞#家庭#搞笑
00:24
家庭搞笑日记
Рет қаралды 118 МЛН
when you have plan B 😂
00:11
Andrey Grechka
Рет қаралды 12 МЛН
Touching Act of Kindness Brings Hope to the Homeless #shorts
00:18
Fabiosa Best Lifehacks
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
Мы сделали гигантские сухарики!  #большаяеда
00:44
I Used Blender at Marvel and It Changed My Life
27:42
Blender
Рет қаралды 510 М.
6 key principles for 3D modeling
11:12
CG Cookie
Рет қаралды 1,1 МЛН
Intro To Blender
27:23
HEAVYPOLY
Рет қаралды 17 М.
Why I Ditched ZBRUSH for BLENDER for HAIR
7:47
Danny Mac 3D
Рет қаралды 214 М.
Remaking the Gone Girl home in Blender
28:24
Blender Guru
Рет қаралды 804 М.
Modo | Modeling
5:57
Foundry
Рет қаралды 149 М.
这三姐弟太会藏了!#小丑#天使#路飞#家庭#搞笑
00:24
家庭搞笑日记
Рет қаралды 118 МЛН