"Help! I'm Having Doubts About the Faith Due to Specific Hadiths..." | Ask Shaykh YQ EP 245

[@vita.1517]

I went through this phase but crying and praying to Allah to help me believe really helped me. At that time even when I read the Quran meaning, because I don't know Arabic I only come up with doubt and more doubt and I believe that was shaitan. So I prayed to Allah to strengthen my iman and help me believe I prayed Tajjud and I would just cry because I know I want to believe but I just didn't, but now I have no doubt I dont even know when that doubt vanished. Another thing that also helped was that I decided to "hear and Obey" and not Question anything anymore, that really worked. Also going through the Seerah of the prophet (SAW) increased my Love for Islam. I feel so much peace in my life now that I feel fear in the mere thought of losing my Islam. And Also doing alot of Adkir worked so much for me. I pray Allah (swt) remove doubt from the heart of us all.

[@nazirwaroich1662]

Masha Allah; Subhan Allah, Alhamdo Lillah, Allaho Akbar.

[@jesan733]

*"Another thing that also helped was that I decided to "hear and Obey" and not Question anything anymore, that really worked."* I can imagine. Actually, I think that's the key. Those who think critically apostatize.

[@AhsanHaji]

​@@jesan733 I think this comment needs clarification. Islam teaches us to think critically so we should absolutely think critically. The problem here is that after accepting Islam and coming to the conclusion that Allah is the creator and the Prophet Muhammad SAW being the last messenger, then one should do as you say: Listen and Obey.

[@jesan733]

@@AhsanHaji so what you're saying is that islam teaches non-muslims to think critically, but teaches muslims to just listen and obey?

[@seraph8293]

You should all continue to think critically, if the Quran doesn’t make sense without a sheikh the so be it since it is “the perfect book” and it is “understandable”

[@Xorgot]

I am thankful for the doubts I've gone through alhamdulillah. My iman matured aa a result and I much stronger in my conviction and I can help those who have struggled with their faith as well. It's all about building foundations and being persistent and sincere in the process.

[@justCommando]

Brother Yasir Qahdi, I don't care what they say about you, you've delivered such a good and sincere answer, may Allah bless you in this world and the next, and your family as well. Ameen. And thank you.

[@malikmuhammad8399]

Smh

[@chehrazadeesmey8399]

I am so used to the quality of the Shaykh's lectures that l such a brilliant answer sounds so natural to me 🙂🙃🙂

[@rahatibnemushfique1989]

Thanks a lot for being sensible approaching this! I wish many of our Shaykhs had this type of understanding! May Allah help you in your good deeds.

[@musthaf9]

When I have doubt, I just remember the Shirah. Imagine a man that is so noble and kind and trustworthy, he never lied, his people love him, and then one day, suddenly he said that he was sent by Allah. Imagine this person goes to all those suffering and struggle to remain consistent with the message, even after the Quraish compromise and offer riches. Imagine this person who has no history of poetry at all, yet suddenly manage to "write" the Quran. Imagine again that this person, after gaining victory near the end of his life, still lived a very simple and struggling life. The prophet's kindness is his miracle. The chance that a person like this telling a lie for 23 years just so that he lived pretty poor until the end of his life is practically null. And about the "science" part, well sure, modern science can't prove God. But, absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. These atheist who are so sure that God does not exist are themselves unscientific, because the evidence of said absence does not exist. if they stay true to scientific thinking, they should at least be open minded.

[@rda4140]

Well said

[@jesan733]

You're accepting a self-glorifying sectarian narrative as historical truth. Why? Because in your sectarian environment, you've convinced each other that the sirah couldn't have been substantially sugarcoated, because you tell each other that your early sect members were so truthful and noble so they would object to inaccuracies rather than loyally add on and retransmit sugarcoatings. The problem is not absence of evidence. The problem is that if you take a birds-eye view on the evidence that is the quran and on then sunnah, the vast amount of inaccuracies, moral failings, ridiculous mythologies, self-serving verses and so on, the picture that emerges is that M made stuff up as he goes along, often self-servingly. Mind you, I'm not saying he's all bad by any means. People are complex, and it's fully possible to have a lot of good in you and still be a sect leader who makes stuff up.

[@chrisbea49]

It is impossible to prove the non-existence of something that does not exist. Can you prove a purple elephant isn't flying above your head right now? You would tell me there isn't one but I can always say you just can't see it. In all probability it isn't there. God is the one topic humans make an exception for to suspend reason.

[@kishwerislam4646]

AAmiin ya Rabb! SubhanAllah!So beautifully explained!May Allah subhana wa t'ala help n guide this brother n all the others who have doubts,may He forgive n guide us all too!Aamiin!🤲

[@Travellahh]

Well said brother

[@rda4140]

SubhanAllah. The example example of Abu Bakar and the Mirage was very logical.

[@usmanhannan5675]

Dear Yasir Qadhi, I strongly recommend you start a detailed series just focusing on analyzing the problematic hadiths, confusing hadiths, Orientalist's/lslam-basher's darling hadiths, and weak/false hadiths that are getting unworthy lime light . This is your forte, and many will benefit from such analysis, amidst all of those websites that you are aware of.

[@hamzakhan9045]

Yup

[@MuslimTeenGuide]

Sapient institute - on KZbin answer many of the questions that the non Muslims raise against islam.

[@MuslimTeenGuide]

kzbin.info

[@PsychoStueyHappyKittens]

As a western convert, I’ve come across a few issues here and there that made me wonder or doubt, but I’ve also learned to give Islam the benefit of the doubt.

[@Styrophoamicus]

Same. Alhamdulilah I always found the answer eventually, even if it took time.

[@fa-cx7qz]

Jazakomollaho kathira shaikh for such an detailed & encouraging explination ..the key is to remain firm and have yaqeen and say "wallaho aalam" and remain on basics.

[@gummybear2227]

My answer to this issue is if there is no God and there is no one that we are accountable to, even in that case we don’t loose anything by believing in God. I also sometimes want to see God in physical sense, but then tell myself whether He is there or not I will abide myself to the holy texts because don’t want to take the risk of making my life hell after leaving this world.

[@martinr4549]

I’ve come across a couple hadiths that frankly, I don’t believe, such as the one about dogs used to urinate in the masjid and no one would pour water on it. Doesn’t mean I ‘question my faith.’

[@Citizen052]

thanks Shaykh. Your solid knowledge is helping others.

[@mok8591]

May Allah protect your knowledge and give you a long life. Ameen

[@MostafaMansoori]

Nicely answered with much clarification, jazakhala khair brother Yasir, may Allah swt keep our feet firm and guide us to the straight path, ameen. 🤲

[@adianqureshi9058]

This guy is leading to a bigger game beyond our reach , it’s not a coincidence someone ask this watch where you it leads to!!

[@shalizalacombe6330]

If you ask us what we think...our Lord loves us so much that...He gave us all of our books and avenues...to reach Him, the cosmos, and the truth...despite the fact that we as human beings have chosen to separate and divide ourselves hence having different religions...thinking one is more better than the other...keep seeking to strengthen our belief and truth that is already there...and do not follow mistranslation, misguidance, fear, and evil...always look for the good in everyone and everything...if we ever get confused about our path🙏❤🤲🙂

[@truesay786]

My sheikh said Islam is like a beautiful and perfect Garden but with some perceived worms in it. If one keeps digging for the worms one will eventually forget the quality of entire garden it’s shade it’s trees and all it’s wonderful and nutritious fruits. When I reflected on this it helped me to realise the certainty of Islam prayer charity heaven hell the 99 names of Allah is too much to ignore.

[@jesan733]

But heaven is an immature male fantasy and hell is not justifiable. What if the garden isn't that beautiful, what if its fruits give you a bad stomach?

[@hylianlegends]

@@jesan733 Heaven is real and hell is real. The garden is beautiful, and you'll never get sick.

[@jesan733]

@@hylianlegends no, they're not real, they are just memes designed to control you.

[@fahadusmani2184]

What an excellent explanation 👏 👌 👍🏻 ...... proud to be Muslim 🕌 🕋 ☪️ 🕌

[@DesertVox]

Watching SPEAKERS CORNER strengthens ISLAM's position vis-a-vis others. No comparison. Every time it's an imaan boost and I feel thankful for the pure monotheist faith.

[@genuineidea6043]

How is he so understanding unlike others 🤔

[@iswallbanoo9843]

Salaam only one God and it's Allah SWT love here from South Africa Johnessburg pray 5 times a day

[@luvingashik361]

This video really helped me a lot..

[@fathimashanaz4412]

Jazakallah khair Sheikh

[@taustyz5875]

I went through this same thing when I was arguing with ex Muslims and I was shocked at first. Before I wasn't that religious but once I started finding out about "problematic" Hadith and verses and looked more into it it strengthened my Iman. Enemies of Islam spread falseness

[@jesan733]

It's called the backfire effect. It's a psychological phenomenon where, when you're presented with true information and debunkings regarding a phenomenon you want to believe, the strength of your false belief is increased. So in your case, you being presented with information from outside your sect pushed you further into it. It's sad but common.

[@taustyz5875]

@@jesan733 lol, Ex Muslims clearly present false information regarding Islam. They misquote verses and use da'eef Hadith.

[@jesan733]

@@taustyz5875 of course, sometimes, but they also often correctly quote verses and use sahih hadiths. Everybody makes mistakes, but an assessment of the best arguments clearly shows that islam is made up.

[@farhan00]

I went through periods of extreme doubt, specifically in the 2010s when there was a lot of atheist content online - this was twinned with some personal life issues. I came out of it with time and learning deconstructionalist arguments against atheism in particular. I became a bit more of a critical thinker. Spiritually, my orientation changed too, a LOT...Generally speaking, I see atheism as pretty backwards and obviously wrong. But that understanding took TIME and suffering. For this specific question, it seems that someone can modify their orientation, typically philosophically or social. In the realm of science, I learned about Scientific Realism vs Scientific Instrumentalism and how that is a tool to understand the natural world...there's more, but this is the comments section :)

[@jesan733]

It's fairly ok to be theist and view atheism as wrong. However, why see islam as true? If you're a critical thinker, you should see that it's obviously made up.

[@farhan00]

@@jesan733 what makes you say that? You're also assuming critical thinking has only one conclusion. Could it be that you only think this way due to your upbringing, culture and societal indoctrinations?

[@jesan733]

@@farhan00 it's because of my absence of indoctrination into this particular religion and also the huge claim your scripture makes for itself. The quran is supposed to be god's unaltered words so if there's any undivinity in there, then it's all made up. And the quran is rife with signs of human origin: scientific errors, moral failings, immaturity and how it doesn't have a place in abrahamitic religion. Of course, since "scholars" have had 1400 years to make repairs and find excuses, all of this criticism has been answered, but anyone who is intelligent and takes a birds-eye view on it all will see the obvious.

[@chehrazadeesmey8399]

@@jesan733 You are absolutely right to put your exceptional intelligence and your unique morality with its wonderful sense of respect far above the intelligence and morality of almost two billion people.

[@jesan733]

@@chehrazadeesmey8399 your bitterness is irrelevant. Fact remains, your religion is obviously made up and smart people tend to see it and apostatize. You can join them and be the hero that frees your lineage, or you can stay in the sect.

[@386max1]

This whole things arise because it is the business of faith, of believing, it is not seeing.

[@sammu]

I am trying to be understanding and may Allah forgive me if I am being rude and insensitive. However, if someone is doubting the truthfulness of Islam over vague and symbolic ahadith that have been explained multiple times, they may have other primary reasons they are not disclosing. This was also the case for the Ya'jooj Ma'jooj video. May Allah help this person stay away from the shahawaat of this world and guide them back to the Straight Path.

[@sayangsayonara]

26:40 THESE ara the greatest tool to brain wash your mind,your logical thinking proces. Blind faith after reasoned belief is the ESSENCE of ISLAM we believe, because We know it to be TRUE . Once We believe there must be a leap of faith, you are not expected to answer every single missunderstanding of hadith in order to achieve certainty.

[@elvinuo]

Wouldn’t it be better if All scholars gether together and cleanse all corrupted hadith from Muslim books?

[@imam-_-]

A certain hadith may be problematic to a group of scholars but to others it may not be problematic. And as the Sheikh said there are other ways to deal with a problematic report other than to reject it.So many scholars may choose other method to deal with a problematic report even if they all consider a report to be problematic. So gathering all scholars to reject all the problematic reports is impossible.

[@PeacePaix]

Can you take the top 10 or 50 most Misunderstood Hadiths that cause the most Doubts and Explain them One by One? To the best of your ability. Since, you're specialized in Hadith research. I just heard a well-known scholar say that the Prophet Muhammad's wife Ayesha was definitely not 6 or 9 years old at time of marriage, regardless of whether that appears in Bukhari. It goes against what Allah said in the Qur'an. And that means, that the authenticity of this Hadith has an issue.

[@mnz3671]

Refer to this playlist. This is exactly what you seek kzbin.info/aero/PLE4jCjpXgtqBjST69YeETfCjJLK5AQzNu

[@dradia1983]

And that is why i dont believe in Hadiths that brings doubt in my heart, Allah promised that only the Qur'an will be preserved till the end of times, .. fake hadiths have been around since 1400 years ago, and had been recognized.. but even the SAHIH Bukhari hadiths are not 100% guaranteed genuine despite his tremendous efforts in selecting it.. errors will always occur in man made books.. so, any doubtful or ridiculous hadiths especially that aren't inline with the Qur'an should be simply ignored... its not a sin to not believe the Hadiths because we are entitled to have doubts that goes against our general understandings according to the Qur'an .. not believing certain Hadiths doesn't mean i dont believe the sayings of our Prophet pbuh , but i doubt or dont believe that he ever said that.. Alhamdulillah following The Book of Allah and added guidance of practices from the Sunnah & Hadiths is what we need in preparation to answer Allah in the day of judgment.. InshaAllah.

[@jesan733]

Great, good for you. But what about e.g. quran 67:5.

[@aydinkhan783]

You shouldnt reject hadith that reach the level of Tawatur Mass transmission since the same companions also passed down the Qur’aan in the similar way but the preservation of the Qur’aan is unmatched

[@FarhanKhan-rs9gz]

Very well explained sheikh Jazak Allah

[@sach3656]

If somebody have some doubt about ISLAM just consider what Prophet Muhammad (SWM) got after faced tortured and insult from his own people? Even he didn't build a normal house for him or for his wifes🙄 just consider about his purpose of life

[@lillianbeverly-rosario1753]

What does the Quran say. Allah guides, seek the Guidance of Allah. Insha’Allah You will be successful. The best Hadith is the Ahadith of Allah

[@meghdirlynda5366]

Do the scholars not think there might be some false hadiths amongst sahil al Bakhari? Its not Quran after all

[@corazoncubano5372]

I'm sure they do.

[@hylianlegends]

A few false hadith will not nullify over 300,000 hadith found in sahih bukhari.

[@alpharays5768]

It’s never a good approach to use other approaches to scale Islam or believe in God. We should never use other field in order to scale up or make Islam qualify to that field but rather the opposite. Yes we as Muslims can use this approach for dawah or to soften our hearts when they go hand in hand with what is in the Quran and sunnah and we discard what goes against Quran and sunna. Science in it self is never a fact rather and attempt by humans to understand reality. It’s something that keeps changing and deals primarily with the physical aspect of life, using science to explain the metaphysical life form and miracles is really not a good approach. It’s equivalent to using maths to solve biological problems. Scientific method keeps changing (Uncertainty), using such method to measure up your Fitrah in believe in God is tantamount to failure. May Allah open our hearts and guide us all. Ameen!

[@faizanahmedsaiyed-oldaccou3895]

5:30 That was Deep 28:00

[@adnanadill]

God and religion is very simple The one who initiated creation from nothingness is God that God to proved Himself, should explain Process and methodology of creation as per science. And Allah SWT does this is in very first chapter verse 2:117 / 36:82 / 30:25. He converted energy E=MC^2 into matter. and matter was dispersed to created universe galaxies and star system 51:1-5 / 21:30 Then this dispersing and expanding universes were controlled and organized 41:11 then after billion of selected earth and made changes to support life / 79:28 / 39:6. / 2:29 spin and tilt 7:54 / 16:12. Then sent Iron as meteorites bombardment to establish gravity 57:25 Then Sent waters to cool earth and start life as Meteorites bombardment 78:14 Then Initiated first life from water Initial single cell life 6:98 and mitosis 7:189 / 30:21 / 49:13 Then Panspermia took place 39:6 Then evolution 29:19…….. and there are other details .. comment will go to long Any doubt in understanding verse please ask…. And Religion is identification of that Organized and Disciplined mighty Creator Then contacting Mighty Him and Then taking His dictation and following that dictation So Simple

[@shaibaltube]

Assalamu Alaikum dear Brother Adil Adnan...thanks for your valuable comment...i would love to have some suggestions from you about some books or any type of source to study...i love the way you explained and i am the type of believer who believes Qur'an has all the solution and it does not change its meaning or meanings of words the way the translators translates... For example: i love to believe the quranic word "sababa" means "portals" in all the places in the Qur'an Please help me study about Qur'an Jazakallahu Khairan

[@adnanadill]

​@@shaibaltube what is the verse of Sa'ba'ba ?? or is it sa'bab سبب like sa'bab of Urdu as reason and cause 18:85/89/92 If you want to learn Quran Learn Arabic there are 100 of arabic teaching classes on you tube as Abdur Raheem or Abdur Rab Pray tahajudd and request Allah SWT to learn and educate you it is very simple and start learning by searching and matching word of Arabic Urdu Arabic English this make learning exiting Eardh = Earth Kfr = Cover (Kafir) Wen = When Shaai = Tea Qhutt = Cut Mitro = Metro / Sub way Miraya = Mirror Qhattan = Cotton Faraib = Fraud Tamer-Al hind = Tamarind Hind = Be-Hind or Hind (India) and Qatal Qaatil Maqtool Qalq Qaaliq Maqlooq Aqal Aaqil Maqool Qubool Qaabil Maqbool Zulm Zaalim Maz’loom Qadr Taqdeer Muqad’der Rushd Raashid Murshad And remember وَلَقَدْ يَسَّرْنَا الْقُرْآنَ لِلذِّكْرِ فَهَلْ مِنْ مُدَّكِرٍ ‎﴿١٧﴾ verily verily verily! We have made Quran very easy for zikr. Is there any one to Muzakkir?? 54:17 and Remember عَلَّمَ الْإِنْسَانَ مَا لَمْ يَعْلَمْ ‎﴿٥﴾ We gave knowledge to man by use of pen 96:5 so keep on writing what you practice

[@shaibaltube]

@@adnanadill Assalamu Alaikum brother... yes i am talking about sabab in surah Kahf 18:85/89/92 The same word is also used in other places like surah Ghafir 40:36/37 In most translations it is translated as "means of access to everything" or "doors towards heaven" I cannot read or understand urdu properly...i can read arabic and understand some of its meanings and started trying to figure out and explore Qur'an as much as i can in sha Allah I can also relate some words and their roots like you shared For example Firdous = Paradise Iblees = Devil As muslim we believe that all the languages came from a single mother language of Adam and over time language changed as human civilisation increased and spread over the Earth. Things that i want to learn more from different authentic sources is about dimensions, portals(sabab/asbab), black holes(ayinin hamiya), nebula, supernova and extraterristorial things that Allah(SW) has talked about in the quran to understand the fitna of dajjal(for example: surah isra, kahf, mariyam) I want to read about Adam(AS) and his 1000 years of life in various earths/worlds, Noah(AS) and his 950 years of preaching, Isa(AS) and his being alive until he comes down to earth again through portal, beloved Muhammad (SM) and the hadith when he(SM) went to jannatul baki and jibrael(AS) came to him and talked about his life on earth coming to an end. He asked Jibrael about his life being 93 years and jibrael told him he spent 30 years during meraj. And as much as i can read about these type of outstanding things that allah talked about in Quran and some other ancient scriptures as well. So i asked for some suggestions about books or other sources. Jakzakallahu Khairan

[@adnanadill]

@@shaibaltube Masha Allah you have good knowledge I m just a student but did you searched use of Non Arabic words in Arabic Quran Example God uses dual or double ways to confirm His book and His religion. God gives us these verses of Noah AS and his ship 1500 years back and demand us, to search and find them in present time (treasure hunt) When we find that signs or material, God commanded to search, then that verse or tweet of God is proved. And the book is certified, genuine and authentic. Example Our God said in Quran: Noah Flood started from ""Tanur"" (South India) and the boat of Noah was preserved as his sign on mount Judi (Turkey) And we find ""Tanur"" a town in south Indian coast and the point of initiation of Noah flood/Tsunami. And we found a ship or ark 50 years back by aerial survey, about 1 kilo meter long and fossilized and preserved intact, since million of years inside the Mount Judi in Turkey. Point Two. And the words ""Tanur or Judi or Phoraoh"" are not Arabic words, so Prophet Mohammed PBUH can’t say this by himself. And Prophet Mohammed PBUH, never travelled outside Saudi Arabia in his life......and still dictates about Egypt, Alaska, Turkey, India and Buddha. Tanur verse 11:40 and 23:27 Mount Judy 11:44 And promise to preserve the boat as Living sign 29:15 / 25:37 / 11:49 are not his words. And these discoveries proves Quran the Book of God. This is how God proves himself. Do you have these equal lines in your books?? And there are many other examples like body or mummy of Pharaoh/Firoon. 10:92 Dual sea, Split of moon, and others. 55:11

[@adnanadill]

@@shaibaltube In Ghaifr 36/37 the word Ayath is used as ""signs"" The Mosa AS used to propagate and not tweets or lines of Quran. And Sabab used here is in reference of verse 28:38. Where Pharaoh builds towers to see God...

[@infinto1]

Every movement of every heavenly body(every vibration and motion of all the atoms and sub atomic particles and their existence) in this and in any other universe is due to and is in accordance with the Sunnah(laws, commands) of The God therefore everything in the universe (other than conscious intelligent beings like us) is in a state of continues obedience and prayer. Prostration is the best form of showing our thankfulness and obedience to our lord therefore this metaphor is often used both by God in the Quran and also by our holy prophet Muhammad pbuh. Please try to understand similes and metaphors used in the Quran as well as in the Hadith which has helped and is still helping many human beings from 6th century to this day from a farmer of the 6th century to a scholar of 21st century This metaphor of prostration means that everything in this universe (including the passing of day and night) is due to and is in absolute controle of the God. Reading good classical literature and poetry can rid us of machine like reasoning and thinking (AI) and stimulate our faculty of human visionary reason by which we can easily understand the subtlety of such metaphors and similes.

[@alasheo]

barakalahu fii

[@hasanimam35]

Salams. If there are scientific mistakes in the hadiths despite the rigorous process to preserve the words of the Prophet (S), it only shows the human fallibility. Hadiths May have scientific errors but not the Quran, which is in a league of its own when it’s scientific claims are being confirmed today (or other claims will be verified within a few decades). If anything, mistakes in the hadiths but accurate renditions of scientific facts in the Quran should increase imaan, not decrease it. Humans are fallible, Allah is not.

[@jesan733]

I'm sorry, but the quran is rife with with scientific inaccuracy too. For instance, 67:5 is a pseudoscentific explanation of meteors, and e.g. humans aren't made of clay, we evolved, the embryology is faulty, it's geocentric (e.g. 31:29) and so on.

[@Xorgot]

@@jesan733 there is nothing un-scientific about 31:29 -- it's simply your projection of the Quran coming from a desert Arab.

[@jesan733]

@@Xorgot good that you implicitly acknowledge my other two examples, but if you look a bit more into 31:29, you'll recognize it and verses like it as geocentric.

[@Xorgot]

@@jesan733 @Jesper Antonsson LOL, where and how did I implicitly acknowledge your other assertions? If I say I like cats, that doesn't mean I want to see koalas burn. Anyways, 31:29 states the sun and the moon are in orbit, which is absolutely true. There's nothing scientifically wrong with what the Quran asserts here. It serves a modern understanding of the sun and moon and also the desert Arab's point of view. It's a point of reflection of how God has knowledge has over all things. And to further substantiate my point; the Quran repeatedly refers to natural phenomena in a VAGUE sense to serve multiple scientific understandings -- not to make a scientific assertion, but as a point of reflection: "Have they not seen the birds above them, spreading and folding their wings? None holds them up except the Most Compassionate. Indeed, He is All-Seeing of everything." (67:19) "As for the sky, He raised it ˹high˺, and set the balance ˹of justice˺" (55:7) "He laid out the earth for all beings. " (55:10) "He merges the two bodies of ˹fresh and salt˺ water," (55:19) "The sun and the moon ˹travel˺ with precision." (55:5) All these verses are vague in scientific understanding and are very much compatible with our modern scientific findings. The same can be asserted for 31:29

[@jesan733]

@@Xorgotit was where you contended with only the point where your scholarly repairs stand even half a chance of convincing someone scientifically literate. But ok, so what orbit does the sun move in? The galactic orbit, right, with a 225 million year roundtrip. So why are the companions rhetorically asked within the same verse to see night and day in relation to these orbits as a proof of god? What "orbit" of the Sun is visible to them and is related to night and day? Why couldn't god say the earth is a spinning ball and that's creating day and night? It's not a difficult concept to explain using a rock at night by a campfire. That would have been a divine easter egg for sure. (Ok, some ancient Greeks did actually understand it, but it didn't get traction at the time, so it would have been pretty convincing.)

[@abdulkayum73]

It’s a shame people want answers to everything without even realising their own understanding is very poor.

[@lillianbeverly-rosario1753]

QURAN

[@lillianbeverly-rosario1753]

It’s in the Quran

[@faizanahmedsaiyed-oldaccou3895]

15:00

[@haroon420]

Lol. So Shaikh, what you’re saying is that the scholars made the rules and only they have the right to change the rules. I thought islam had no clergy-class. When have we become like the Jews and asking imams/rabbis for law. The simple thing is that everything problematic about islam today stems from the books of Hadith and the so called scholars are not discussing/admitting this in public. This is causing ordinary Muslims to either go full beserk (with their understanding) or renounce Islam or those who want a honest review of these Hadith, they’re being silenced and called followers of nafs/Hawa. So disingenuous. Maybe you should do a full lecture about the science of hadith for the public benefit. I was amazed to learn that the Bukhari hadith are considered sound if they have a 51% chance of being quoted by the prophet pbuh. That’s too low in my estimation. We’re basing aqeedah on such hadith!!!!

[@corazoncubano5372]

That Hadith was compiled long after the Prophets death and without a stringent chain of authenticity like Quran leaves room for mis quoting and misunderstanding.

[@thetruth27786]

Theres alot of nonsense in hadeeth that is not the sunnah and dont go back to nabi saw.

[@markward3981]

Wait ...he said if you deny "Qadar " you are still in the fold of Islam, I have to disagree with this. Full Stop🛑 . Denying Qadar is disbelief...the hadith of Jibril alayhi Salam, makes it clear what is Islam, Iman and Ihsan, the meaning is explained in the hadith and supported by many ayat , and other ahadith. May Allah protect us.

[@lillianbeverly-rosario1753]

What does Allah Say

[@nurshatalim5189]

Which hadith is he talking about?

[@corazoncubano5372]

There are numerous.

[@sohailaislam2416]

Well I think - his imaan is leaving him - can’t inject imaan in anybody even he is a Muslim by birth .

[@corazoncubano5372]

Very true, but that is not to say that he will not return to the straight path again.

[@hylianlegends]

someone asks for help means iman is leaving him? smh

[@emenjay0077]

Argument from incredulity….

[@beehivepattern5695]

Im specialist on Scientific error debunk, just ask me.

[@Hamza000h]

Follow Dr Shabir Ally for a balanced approach on hadith

[@jpzadran4774]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/q3m4Zoprirt7obM He often contradicts the scholarly consensus on certain matters. Also, he is not an authority on Hadith, since it is not his field of expertise.

[@markward3981]

@@jpzadran4774 I agree while I respect S. Ally and the current speaker in this video, many are abandoning ijma and rejecting established ahadith, and even doubting mass transmitted interpretation of Quran in favor of a modern paradigm. The large error they are commiting is that so called scientific discoveries change. Science is great but scientists are human therefore there interpretations and them are subject to error. May Allah safeguard us.

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

👀

[@icelerate8141]

Glad to hear your eyes have opened.

[@bellah09]

@@icelerate8141 Lol but the heart is closed unfortunately

[@gummybear2227]

“ Abdullah Sameeda“ you forgot to change your name. Still you are a slave of Allah. Wow what a hypocrite you are! Just for some worldly gains you abandoned your forever life after your death.

[@jvfresh3053]

Thoughts/Feelings on Marvelous Quran YT videos anybody? be rational, please

[@TheGraph89]

Salam alaikum. I did not hear about the channel, or more precisely about Mr. Hany. I did my search to see whether he's got any Islamic knowledge so that one takes his arguments, comments and teachings seriously and trustworthy. However, it seems he is a consultant for companies. Hence, I would not even bother to watch his videos.

[@atique9062]

I have been watching the MQ videos and have even subscribed. Been doing that since the day it just popped up on my screen some 2 months back. Find it very refreshing and insightful, logical and rational explanations using evidence based knowledge from Quran itself to narrate the real stories and parables. I’m very happy and thankful to Allah swt for guiding me to MQ. I used to subscribe to YQ, Shabir Ali, etc but not anymore.

[@jvfresh3053]

@@TheGraph89 Wa alaikum salam, I understand why you feel that way but I encourage you to have an open mind. He uses the teachings in the Quran itself to support his thoughts and interpretations and it truly brings light to the stories and meanings. I'm not saying he is for certain correct in everything he teaches but I'd be interested to see what evidenced based refutations anyone could have when all his evidence is based in the Quran.

[@TheGraph89]

@@jvfresh3053 Let me express it this way. If there are two doctors, where one spent years studying it, having experience, having proper knowledge and other is self-claimed "doctor". For anyone who has no knowledge of medicine, the other self-claimed seem to be actual doctor. As a layman, I would prefer the first doctor, who is well-recognized, accepted and professional. I would definitely stay away from the second one. For me, iman is the most important thing in this life, even before my health. So, if I am that careful of choosing doctor regarding my health, then I will do my best to choose scholars to listen to learn the knowledge concerning my iman and religion. Ignoring self-claimed scholar (who refutes generations of scholars) and sticking with true scholars, is not ignorance, but wisdom. Hence, I do not think that listening to Mr. Hany is open-mindness. If I were Islamic scholar, I would never bother myself to refute Mr. Hany. Whatever I would do, those who wants to listen to him would still keep listening. Mr. Hany is not new or only one saying similar things and he will not be the last one. So, for Islamic scholars would be better to stay away from this fitna, otherwise it would never end. The life is short, time is invaluable gem given to us. We need to spend it wisely. Thank you for reading. Sorry for taking your time.

[@flipperj2780]

You stated Jews and Christian’s version of creation has the earth created on Saturday. According to the Bible that is incorrect you should study the Bible more even if you don’t believe it because even your book tells you to go to the old scriptures when you don’t have answers.

[@felreizmeshinca7459]

A simple Google search I could find a Christian website saying it was on Saturday. You can't blame us for saying what the Christians themselves claimed. So far what I know the Quran only confirms that there were old scriptures but they are corrupted & our scholars only referred to the Quran & Hadiths. If I'm wrong please correct me.

[@corazoncubano5372]

Saturday, Sunday or Monday, it doesn't matter. Days of the week are a human creation to serve a human purpose. Time is fluid.

[@samven582]

can you comment on the age of Aisha?

[@gummybear2227]

Stop, swallow this pill and move on. There are many other things to worry about more than age of Ayesha peace be upon her. E.g. seeing God and answering Him after death.

[@samven582]

@@gummybear2227 disagree

[@gummybear2227]

@@samven582 then prepare yourself for what will follow.

[@dexstar1737]

He has answered this question before. Search Yasir Qadhi Aisha age on KZbin plenty of videos.

[@gummybear2227]

The people who question this issue will never ever be satisfied with any response or logic. Most of these people are just looking for red flags in texts etc and will regard it as a huge problem. From a 3000 foot view and a broader context, Some issues are better to leave as it is. But this will never sink in their minds.

[@ionin3965]

muslims if you are doubting your fate come to Christian Prince. and he is fixing it.

[@justtania333]

No he's not. Have a nice day