HOKA ONE ONE MAFATE SPEED 3 REVIEW | The Ginger Runner

[@andrewschorn9221]

It would be great to see a review of the differences between the Hoka trail line up. 👌🏼 so many options 🙈

[@MatthewTaylorTV_Newsman]

Texas runner who did Bandera 100k and Grasslands marathon in these shoes. Very different terrain for those races but the shoes performed well in each case. Ethan is right about break-in ... I had toe bleed at Bandera from shoe wear but honestly didn’t notice it until the finish. Now they are exceptionally comfortable and my go-to trail racers, currently with about 200 miles of use

[@michaelcaricoo]

Hoka is releasing so many in the same category of shoe (and shoes in general) that you need a flow chart

[@pauvela9526]

Great review! I've run 180 km with them and I 100% agree. The adaptation time is not a great deal if you don't compete with them and they are very comfortable since the beginning. But I'm a bit biased since these are my favourite trail running shoes.

[@JamisonMichael]

It looks like it has a nice pull tab. I might cop

[@thesii213]

Really pleased to hear about a more adaptive fit on Hoka model! Also Hoka's colorways have just been incredible in the last years. Consistently the best color and design in the industry IMO.

[@LifeInTheLongRun]

Nike have the most beautiful colourways. They pay more for design color upper.

[@AnthonyConstable]

Really appreciated the comment about the 2s needing some breaking in. I thought it was just me.

[@tfxcShoes]

Crazy to think that the Mafate was the first shoe Hoka made, and now seeing the Mafate Speed 3, Hoka has come a long way. Great review as always!

[@johnpickens3070]

Love my mafate 3’s….best trail shoe I’ve ever owned

[@rostislavv.3162]

My first pair lasted 735K. I've got a second pair and will probably stick to the model for now. Totally agree with dislikes - took me one week (70K) to break and it's heavy... After breaking, it's really comfortable and an amazing fit for highly technical trails.

[@roustabout4fun]

Interesting shoe....hope to revisit this shoe in maybe 2 or 3 years....I like the fade off sunset (color) The EVO was a good fit but I usually go back to my Goats for WA area runs.

[@ngdawgs1]

Glad HOKA fixed the upper mid section from the Speed 2. I had to return mine right away because of the lacing system. I’ve now had the Mafate Speed 3 and the Evo Mafate 2. Both amazing shoes, but the inside of the Evo 2’s is softer, so I’ll likely stick to those (plus the lower price now).

[@jamesalbritton2149]

Update… Good news! Hoka gave me a choice to replace the same shoe or choose another. I went with EVO Speedgoat for different sole construction. Needed to pay a little difference for this higher priced model. Thank you Hoka, good customer service from my perspective. 2021 Mafate One One Speed 3, Less then 20 kilometers in 3 trail runs and sole cracked in forefoot area. Specifically inside the deep groove which allows sole to flex laterally. Cannot post photos here so hope this description helps. Took shoes back to retailer who said they would send to distributor for warranty evaluation. Waiting. Hoka warranty is 1 year and if they agree with your claim offer a credit for another Hoka product.

[@steve22ss]

Thank you so much for this review, I am in Australia so import tax is a little high but I managed to get a pair they added free shipping plus 10% off so in US dollars that's about $145 it actually worked out cheaper than the speedgoat 4's I was looking at, thanks for helping me decide. Now to start training from road running to trail.

[@hayabusa27]

That thing is a beast! Is the grip better than the Speedgoat 4??

[@gregvogel9859]

The Evo Mafate 2 is my goto Trail shoe for any distance. Planning on running Cascade Crest this summer in the shoe. The $170 price point was initially intimidating, but after giving it a shot after using a 20% off REI coupon, I wouldn't hesitate to spend the money on my next pair. I've probably put 300-400 miles in them and they are still working great! That being said, based on the review, looks like I'd still lean to the Evo over the Speed. Another call out with the flexible upper, is that it is very forgiving as your foot swells some during ultras.

[@Ni1zz]

just bought speedgoat. And I see your point about the fit. Speedgoat has durable but not stretchy body material, so it makes not good looking wrinkles when you tight it up

[@JavierISampedroTNF]

These look sweet and I know few people who have bought them. After have used the Speedgoat 3 and currently using Torrent 2, I am intrigued. I did not have complaints at all for the width while using those other Hoka models, but is good to have a roomier option for technical trails. Maybe if the price drops in the coming months :)

[@adiefowler]

loved the review thank you. loved the first version of the mafete. upper a disaster in the second. also love the torrents and ordered torrent 2's to try. long ultra coming up so looking for more cushioning again. Thanks again, Ade

[@davidrowe9402]

The Mafate Speed 1 was my equal best-ever shoe. So sad when it lost the berserk cushioning and went all trail with the Mafate Speed 2. Please come back ??!!

[@outofoffice4757]

You nail the review. I wanted to love the speed 3, I didn't make it though the break in and sent them back.

[@CSLee-yu6ht]

Love the Mafate line, it’s my number one hiking and trail shoe. I own the 2’s and 3’s…. 🎅🏻🏴‍☠️🏔

[@enkidu2562]

I think the colors for these are so great...!

[@BennyRhymes]

Thanks for the great reviews! I have been watching a long time and I try not to miss one. Love the new "Shoe Showcase in the Wild" at the start. I am interested to try these and the EVO Mafate 2. I already have the Torrent and the EVO Speedgoat and like the Torrent, love the EVO Speedgoat and think I would go with the EVO Mafate 2 over these if I was buying a third pair of trail shoes. Hoka seems to work for me so I am not messing with the good thing I have going!

[@tobyestler9399]

Did you find yourself buying the same size in Speed 3 as you did in Evo Mafate 2? (I sized down a 1/2 size in the latter compared to most other shoes). I'm waaay behind and just learning no more Mafate 2s available. Tears.Thanks for a helpful review!

[@andrewsilva7635]

I really love your videos not only for the content but all the footage you take! Brooks or Hoka should pay you to shoot commercials! Thanks for the video!!!

[@tonygross8106]

Thanks for the review. I have been waiting for a good review of this shoe. Loved the Evo Mafate 2 until a major ankle sprain in them. I still say the Evo Speed Goat is the best thing Hoka has going. I just got my second pair of those. I’m curious what their plans are for the Evo shoes? I hope there will new versions.

[@Isabella-kv4sh]

Just got them today! Seems very promising to me, I am hyped to test them on technical trails

[@ivanilic1806]

Your video is coming right at this moment where I'm hesitating between MS 3 or EVO 2.. Until now, I had Mafate Speed 2 (prefered much more that the Speedgoat), but wanted to know what will be your suggestion between new one, Mafate Speed 3 et and EVO 2. I guess after your review and few comments below, I will give a chance to EVO 2..

[@jp05598]

Ethan “it’s a solid try” Newberry

[@TrailrunnerTroy]

Thanks for your review! Never warmed up to the Mafate Speed 2 even after the lengthy and unpleasant break-in period. The Evo Mafate 2 is better in every respect. The weight of the Mafate Speed is noticeable. Yet the Craft CTM Carbon Ultra is vastly preferable to the Evo Mafate 2 on more buffed trails and asphalt, especially for 100 K and longer distances; the Hokas do better on more technical trails and less than 100 K.

[@69leehammond]

Great review, will be sticking with my EVO MAFATE for this years Ultras :-)

[@thesrabbit]

My favorite trail shoes ever are the EVO Mafate 2. Can't get them anymore, at least not in my size. Will the additional weight of the Speed 3 be awful? One of the great things about the Evo Mafate 2 is how much shoe you get for the weight. I've done 3 100's in them and never been disappointed or felt like I needed a shoe change mid race. Just did a hard mountain 50 in them a couple weeks back and they were awesome there as well. UTMB coming in 4 weeks. Do I just roll with my my last pair of Evo 2's that have 200+ miles on them? Or take a chance on the Speed 3? The pair I have still feels pretty good underfoot, though the traction isn't what it used to be.

[@TheBigBlueMarble]

I think I have seen you on the Section Line Trail. Yes?

[@silviugg4364]

Hello guys, which pair from these shoes you will recommend for Camino de Santiago, 1 week of walking, about 150km : 1. Salomon Sense Ride 3. / 2. Hoka One One Challenger ATR 5 / 3. Trail Nike Wildhorse 6? Thanks in advance 😄

[@saragonmcenany6229]

Hoka are rocking some bold colours a bit like the Saucony Perigrine. Brookes Cascadia looking like possibility for me they don't need breaking in and nice uppers. A rotation segment on trail shoes would be a good video (hint!) BTW - Ethan I just downloaded GR tracks from for running music - my favs Stow Away, Slop Wash - sounds great with John Digweed Quattro II album if like you techno flavours.

[@googletookmyoriginaluserna4182]

Here's a thought - maybe R&D investment is a factor in pricing? It shouldn't be, but unless you're a fly on the wall in the Deckers Boardroom you don't know...

[@irunovermountains]

Used to love the Mafate Speed 2 - that shoe lasted fooooreeever.

[@gregprevite8548]

The mafate speed 3 is 1/2 ounce lighter than the mafate speed 2. So weight is trending down

[@DanRuns]

I’ve just bought my seventh pair of ATR Challenger, but these look ace!

[@jp05598]

Seventh! You must put in a lot of trail miles

[@DanRuns]

@@jp05598 over the last 12-18 months I’ve done a few :)

[@Vultoor]

What’s your opinion on this shoe vs the Nike Pegasus 3 gtx? What would you go for?

[@uniteehumaine]

great review!

[@jackash1975]

Colorway looks like the Cotopaxi collaboration Torrent 2. But Mafate is soooo expensive. Hoping you will review the Topo Mtn Racer 2 someday🤞

[@jp05598]

Seems cool, I just need to research the different tasks this is for vs the torrents vs speedgoats. Like why one over the other?

[@samcantrell7057]

Ethan, I appreciate this review. My question is where does the Evo Speedgoat fall into your analysis. It’s got the stretchy vamp which helps with width that’s lacking in the Speedgoats, 5mm lugs, tough upper, and it’s a lot lighter than this Mafate Speed 3. Anyway, just wondering your thoughts on it. Thanks, as always, for your in-depth analysis.

[@listertheblister]

Evo speedboat is such a good shoe

[@snowbdr89]

How does the 3’s fit compared to the speedgiat5’s?

[@peterrosario1141]

Great review. Disappointed to hear about the weight since I loved the EVO Mafate but thought it got heavier over time and went to the Olympus 4.0 which has a better lockdown. Curious to how you would compare the three to the Olympus.

[@terencetan236]

Where did you get those socks? They look great

[@lancevoelker7932]

Can’t wait to buy these

[@karmaforgotme]

Right now I’m stuck waiting in hopes the Speedgoat 5 is better than 4 (cut weight slightly & more comfortable upper please) or an EVO Speedgoat 2 or just buying another another pair of the og EVO SGs. Just curious are you testing the Nike Terra Kiger 7? It sounds like they finally added some cushion to it and I’m curious if it can finally become a long mileage shoe. I need a cushion long mileage shoe to pair with Brooks Catamounts since my EVO SGs midsole died at 300 miles.

[@davidtfrederick]

Lone Peak 5 review coming soon?

[@paddywiggle]

It’s the bees knees. Get it

[@alexpretorius92]

Do they drain well? I know the speedgoat 4s don’t very well but the evo speedgoats do.

[@stuartvandewater6745]

During the break-in period, did you experience significant pain in your forefoot? 3 runs in and am in significant pain by the end of each run. Anyone else?

[@daigerj]

I find that the Speedgoat when running in any rain feels like a wet sponge when running. Does the Mafate mesh upper help w/ that?

[@gagoebel]

What are the main things you noticed after the 70 mile break-in?

[@silviataylor92]

Hi, Whats better option mafate speed 3 or speedgoat 4 for hiking with wet rocks?

[@Draovander]

Still not better than the Evo Mafate 2, but I might be stuck with the extra weight (and less durrable and slower drying upper) since I can't find my size online anymore.

[@BrendanEvan]

That shallow depth of field tho

[@MattRunsColorado]

Have you tried the under armor HOVR machina off road CH1's? Would be very curious to see your input on these!

[@kofuzi]

70 mile break in? thats so much

[@ComputerScienceSimplified]

Great video, keep up the incredible work! :)

[@cpatten93]

Does it have the same tongue as the SG4? Sg4 tongue is uncomfortable

[@RowOfMushyTiT]

Kiger 7 review in progress?

[@gregprevite8548]

Been looking forward to this one. The speedgoat last doesn’t agree with my toesies.

[@BeverG8818]

How many miles a week do you run?

[@IanLoughead]

$210 in Canada. Ouch.

[@Wesz808]

So the new Mafate is cheaper per gram!

[@dewknow1315]

The hoka evo speed 🐐 still the best trail shoe Hoka makes . Change my mind 👍😎🏃‍♂️🏃‍♂️⛰️⛰️🏃‍♂️

[@karmaforgotme]

I agree, but my midsole bottom out right before 300 miles. I am debating getting another pair of EVO SGs or finally giving in to the SG 4s.

[@cordeiropedro]

Totally agree. SG4 is the only one of the line (besides torrents) that allows me to run in Alpine terrain without rolling an ankle. 👍

[@rmsrmsrmsrms]

A No for me: The EVO Mafate is among the 'trippiest' shoes I have -- I'm constantly catching a toe on any trail protrusions in them, and getting rocks stuck in the big holes in the outsole; and this model weighs and costs more? Nope.

[@amiaweng]

evo mafate is much softer musher, they feel totally different

[@timtamothy51]

Wide feet and Hoka doesn't work for you? Enter: New Balance More Trail

[@spotlight761]

The tongue looks very thin.

[@DanCross]

Worst Hoka I've ran in for a while, and I'm a Hoka fan. Would discourage anyone with remotely larger than medium width feet to avoid them. The toe box is too narrow and unforgiving. Ran 80k in them, hoping the upper would stretch and adapt, but it wasn't to be.

[@LifeInTheLongRun]

@Wind Finder I have wide feet. I have the Olympus 4. I was hoping the Speed 3 will work for me. Any tip? I have the 2E Clifton 7 for road. I have been looking for a Hoka trail option to add in my rotation.

[@DanCross]

@Wind Finder Yep. I've tried various lacing techniques, different socks, even different sizes. Still too narrow in the toe box. I get on perfectly fine in the Speedgoats, Evo Speedgoats and Torrent shoes, but I find the upper (particularly the moulded overlays) not as forgiving/adaptive as suggested.

[@DanCross]

@@LifeInTheLongRun If you take a wide Clifton 7, then I would recommend a wide Speedgoat 4. The Mafate line-up doesn't come in wide options.

[@LifeInTheLongRun]

@@DanCross ginger runner seemed to disclosed its an accommodating upper for wide feet.

[@DanCross]

@@LifeInTheLongRun It's only stretchy in the midfoot, not in the forefoot. It's not a good shoe if you have wide feet. If you do, get the Evo Mafate instead with the Matryx upper which is much more adaptable.

[@oldtoad76]

That color reminds me of Ronald McDonald’s shoes.

[@zokizokmann8660]

the worst HOKA shoe, painful feet after just a few kilometers