Holocaust Survivor Tells Piers Morgan Why He’s Not A Zionist

Novara Live broadcasts every weekday from 6PM on KZbin and Twitch.
Episodes of Downstream are released Sundays at 6PM on KZbin.
__________________________
Can you help fund people-powered media? To be ready for next year, we need 5,000 of you to join our regular supporters and back our work.
Donate one hour’s wage per month, or whatever you can afford at novara.media/support today.

[@mmmfahmy]

What angers me is that Dr. Mate and Professor Finkelstein are looked down upon by their own people for just saying the truth and having a conscience.

[@johnwright9372]

Netanyahu's regime has banned Prof Finklestein from visiting Israel for 10 years.

[@SmithyD86]

They call them self hating Jews, it's a real slur. Horrible.

[@llkoolbean4935]

Criticism isn't looking down

[@maazkalim]

The phrasing is fair, attacking with buzzwords - ​"@@llkoolbean4935".

[@Kayzef2003]

​ Calling them Self-Hating Jews is looking down on them.

[@damirjalali]

" The truth has no defense against a fool determined to believe a lie. " --Mark Twain

[@jutswheezie]

quoted by a fool?? amazing 🙂

[@robertschweppenhauser9891]

Yes 😅😅😅

[@craigcanning5836]

@@jutswheeziei guess it's better to be thought a fool and say nothing than to say something and remove all doubt

[@Barisdagame]

​@@jutswheezie the difference between a fool and a Wiseman is but only the width of a finger - Diogenes

[@jymmydkid5633]

That isn't what it says​@@jutswheezie

[@MizanZerangue]

Mr. Gabor is just extremely compassionate and knowledgeable. God bless him.

[@ronstephen-wy4ib]

Imagine knowing him and even thinking he's self hating. 🤡

[@johnathanwalker7781]

I highly encourage anyone interested to read/listen to his other materials, immensely valuable.

[@SubvertTheState]

His son is much like his father, Aaron Maté. He's a journalist for The Grey Zone and has broken many incredible stories. Makes the bought and paid for journalists bad.

[@scroopynooperz9051]

Dr. Mate has been around and studied serious trauma all his life - it's no wonder he would know compassion. Aaron Mate being the thoughtful, principled journalist he is (one of the last REAL journalists we have left) is 100% down to the towering influence of this man. Bravo Dr. Mate

[@Ratgodx]

@@SubvertTheStateAARON MATE IS DR.GABOR MATE’S SON? OH MY GOD 😭 a family of men doing the lords work

[@lynrondeau4332]

Gabor is not a psychologist. He is a physician (MD) with tremendous insight, compassion, and wisdom.

[@Tonymontanayayo]

He is both, a psychiatrist, a physician that specializes in psychological problems... not to be confused with a neurologist... a physician that specializes in disorders of the brain.

[@QUINTUSMAXIMUS]

He's a psychiatrist. A psychiatrist is an MD.

[@alenoo]

they are synonymous

[@ghexaier]

a psychologist is not an MD, a psychiatrist is an MD

[@WendyJoseph-ww8ws]

@@ghexaier That's why a psychiatrist can diagnose and prescribe where necessary, but a psychologist can not.

[@eliakimbenishchayil]

Finally someone has said the Palestinians have the right to to defend themselves

[@victormeidan1062]

Narnians and Lilliputians also have the right to defend themselves.

[@springwood1331]

How is harming innocent people, children even, ever helped resolve anything though? Nothing to be proud of really

[@hotmess9640]

@@springwood1331you’d kill someone’s kid to defend your kid from being killed

[@michelelindor]

@@hotmess9640Yeah, sure but you wouldn’t bomb the entire school for that one specific kid. get real. israel is committing atrocities and the us backs them.

[@puput7290]

​@@victormeidan1062I never see infant death in narnia befor ??🤨

[@user-wd6ni4xu4n]

God bless you for telling the truth. I’m Greek Orthodox and I cry every time I see a mother holding her dead baby. I cry when I see documentaries with holocaust survivors. How can a people treat other people like the current regime in Israel is doing. And the west allows it. Where has humanity gone.

[@mahatabdiabdullahi5527]

When the name "Islam" is heard humanity disappears ! Investigate deeper why?

[@bulentosmane]

You are not alone in your humanity. ❤

[@felixmoyoedonmi]

Humanity has gone with extremist ideologies. The list is endless. That which is one has been completely fragmented by philosophical, religious, racial, nationalistic and all sorts of nonsensical ideologies. Zionism is one of these cancerous ideologies that has been destroying our collective human dignity and decency.

[@juliewake4585]

I’m not religious at all but I agree with you.

[@dissidentleathermonster]

If you are crying while watching propaganda, then you are the fool they are targeting.

[@uuubeut]

Love Gabor Mate - He is a truth warrior !

[@khaledabunahel3368]

Occupiers do not have the right of defence but the native people do have the right of self-defence and resistance to get their rights back.

[@avalanche9026]

God bless dr Gabor. He speaks the truth. This is the man you want for Israelis PM. Not a psychopath Nentanyahu a war criminal

[@flimsyjimnz]

War criminal? I know he's facing serious criminal charges -to the point where he's taking advantage of Oct 7.

[@orvarino]

You're right. A trial in The Hauge, as one example, would see him violating Protocol III (on the use of incendiary weapons) of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCCW). There is clear evidence that white phosphorus has been used in heavily populated areas in Gaza inflicting casualties and immense suffering to a predominant under age civilian population in that area. Video documentation and witnesses would have him sentenced in Day 1 if needed. This is just facts.

[@knuckles543]

@@orvarino also in as part of the coalition to help quell the rebels to assad's rule in syria. IDF jets came in and dropped a couple bombs of the stuff

[@carcav13]

If he became PM how long would he last, he would be murdered within the week.

[@hallohallo1332]

When the rest of the world finances the existence of Israel and all that it's responsible for, I doubt it would back anyone with any shred of integrity to take charge. That's not to say I didn't like your suggestion. We can but hope for the future.

[@Mirpurmad]

only a Jew can openly and honestly speak and tell us how Israel is founded at the cost of Palestinians.

[@peterhall3405]

That is not true. Anyone can talk about it openly and honestly.

[@YallNotWhite_YourPINK]

​@@peterhall3405lay off the meth pinky

[@bepitan]

@@peterhall3405 ..they can but they will be cancelled.

[@felixmoyoedonmi]

​@peterhall3405 Yes, you are perfectly right, but it brings tears to my eyes when a Jew can appreciate the atrocities of zionism. Just like when a white man in South Africa can appreciate the atrocities of the apartheid regime.

[@cehaem2]

​@@peterhall3405it's difficult without being hit with the antisemitism stick.

[@anisaamin1554]

Respect to Dr Mate , Piers full of himself was not expecting such honest and compassionate replies

[@unaerasmus4276]

Pierce must really go study history and stop just harping on October 7th. Every interview he has he is only stuck on 7th October.

[@aniqabano1582]

Respect to Gabor for raising voice and stand with the truth

[@bevhills4877]

It’s odd that people keep saying Israel has a right to defend “itself” .. itself is stolen land.. how do they have this “right”?

[@Neddy540]

Exactly, great point

[@empireoflightz]

so do you think Israel should be destroyed? do you mean you think 100% of it is stolen land, or just the parts that it is occupying that acording to the 1947 resolution should belong to Palestinians?

[@conniekabasharira7084]

​@@empireoflightzwhoever decided to ship them from Europe, displace Palestinians and give them land that belonged to Palestinians should plan for them again wherever he sees fit, but not on stolen land. Except for the ones that were already living in Palestine, after all, jews, Arabs etc were living side by side until someone decided to ship people from another continent and displaced the already existing populations

[@shelbzillathrilla]

@@empireoflightz Israeli politicians want all of Greater Israel. They don't care if they have millions of vengeful neighbors or thousands of dead children under their holy land.

[@pirbird14]

@@empireoflightz The Israeli state was created by a stroke of the pen; and, it can be undone by a stroke of the pen. The majority of Jews in Israel are from the area, not from Europe. They have a right to keep their land. The UN resolution gave 50% of the land of Palestine to 6% of the population. There is no way under the sun that this is just. The indigenous Jews and the Palestinians are both treated as second class citizens by the European based minority. There should be a one state solution, with all citizens treated equally. The European based minority would be free to stay or leave as they please. But they would no longer have political power.

[@sistermaryfrances4480]

This is the first time I've seen Piers Morgan speechless and that's a good thing

[@Swisser70]

And he didn’t ask his stupid question do you condemn Hamas 😅

[@dan-bz7dz]

Israel is losing the propaganda war

[@arzamas1826]

What a pure and honest man. Thanks for staying a human being and sharing so much compassion

[@lapharmacie98]

What a brilliantly compassionate and brave man. Love Dr Mate

[@theprophet489]

The truth is hard to swallow 80 yes forgotten but October 7 is the big story

[@Dogboy73]

Gabor mate is one of the greatest human beings alive.

[@erictread]

Word

[@jennyeyles9596]

Yes, he is!

[@josho5860]

He is even holds up to some of those that are no longer alive. His insight into our collective humanity is unsurpassed. Wonderful human being!

[@MeMe-bg8ci]

💯

[@byrospyro4432]

Don't want to come across as being rude, but how is he a holocaust survivor when he was born in 1944, 3 years after the holocaust happened?

[@mahatabdiabdullahi5527]

MORGAN asks how to get rid of Hamas , but why not ask how to get rid of the invader (Israel). He is concerned with the security of Israel, but why not the security Palestinians.

[@geroffmilan3328]

The correct corollary for "Hamas" here would be "Israeli far-right government", not "Israel". Remember that hundreds of thousands of Israelis were protesting in the streets for months against Netanyahu prior to Oct 7th. A large chunk of that population do not want him - they want him in jail for corruption. For comparison, as a portion of population, that would be like *millions* of people in the UK out in street protest against our current government.

[@erictread]

Because he is an empty killer looking for money and a side to get paid from.

[@samara6041]

@geroffmilan3328 They weren’t protesting him because they cared about the Palestinians, they couldn’t care less. So your point is irrelevant.

[@MusMasi]

@@geroffmilan3328 they were protesting his corruption not Israeli Treatment of Palestinians and the Occupation.

[@sean668]

@@samara6041They were and are. Jews and Muslims have been uniting in mosques in Haifa calling for a ceasefire since the beginning

[@leoniesamuels62]

Media has ensured that citizens of most countries do not know their history. Dr. Gabor thank you for publicly acknowledging this aspect of “nationalism”.

[@mervekarpov7305]

I think he doesn't understand that people know, and they prefer to "exist" instead of being a good person.

[@annalisavajda252]

Yes well apartheid and colonialism is relevant also.

[@zzzbyyy]

It takes a lot of courage to speak the truth especially against your own people ... huge respect.

[@theprophet489]

Jesus said speaking the truth shall set you free

[@user-jc7ep2xp1c]

@@theprophet489He is speaking it for his people and all people.

[@WendyJoseph-ww8ws]

@@theprophet489 Um. No. What he did say, was "...the truth shall set you free." Nothing to do with speaking the truth, but plenty to do with the discovery of truth.

[@kathryncole1314]

For once Piers Morgan is made to see the absolute truth how can you not hear this

[@erictread]

He knows. Rejected it a long time ago.

[@Dragoon91786]

Now, to see if that truth sticks.

[@SourceAwareness]

Piers already knew the truth. *He is paid to uphold a narrative.* Therefore, he will never admit the whole truth while on his show, because he wants to keep making that good money.

[@someoneIikedyourcomment]

he press reset button each time he sleep on the night after the interview. the next morning he repeat the same rhetoric. "do you condemn hommus?" holy amnesia indeed

[@ThePrinceOfNigeria]

Baseem, Finkelstein, and Mate are just a few people that have spoken sense to Piers, but he simply asks his next interviewee to condemn Hamas after this people have made such sense and you think he has absorbed it. He clearly already knows the truth but the truth doesn't matter.

[@susanharrisdemorales3446]

He is authentic and extremely empathetic. No innocents should suffer.

[@brandonbakhtiar7451]

Agree. All the abuses on BOTH sides, as Dr. Mate states in the video, would likely not be happening if support for occupation was not happening nor support for the counter efforts. Bottom line is differences should not be hashed out by violence on civilians. A truly advanced society would form a world treaty, like a global NATO promising to support against any violent infringement by any group. Rather than armies or rockets hurting civilians, especially my heart breaks for children in all this, …those feeling their excessive testosterone should be able to sign up for a Hunger Games type of competition or better some kind of a agreed soccer game with the winner of the game getting what they want rather than using bombs to blow up needed apartments & infrastructure while traumatizing & killing children.

[@JosedeJezeus]

But the Jews are gods chosen people..... 🙄

[@Kiarinadia]

@@brandonbakhtiar7451 don't you think you could have written a shorter comment if you had just assume HAMAS ?

[@stretchy2688]

@@KiarinadiaWhat do you mean “…if you had just assume HAMAS?

[@Koloviv48i]

Izraehell MUST STOP the occupation , period. That's the root cause, If the Honourable people of Palestine are free, Izraehell will be free too.

[@Najda007]

Dr. Mate is such an admirable person, he manages to disolve anger and evokes understanding of the situation. That's a rare quality in the world where most people think the highest achievement is to shout over one another and inflate their egos.

[@domteneglia9121]

What a hero, there is a difference between our government and the people. Thank you Dr

[@bhupendraparekh6225]

Dr Mate obviously has morals and ethics, his humanity shines through as always. Piers is like a broken record, he doesn't listen and is unable to learn anything, lost his morals a long time ago.

[@MusMasi]

when you wake up piers wants to know do you codemn hamas? When you sit on the toilet do you condemn hamas? Before you go to bed do you condemn hamas? will you use your dying breath to condemn hamas? because piers is obsessed with it.

[@rjung_ch]

Even before he was on the 'The Celebrity Apprentice' show?

[@ro55reel5]

Even before he ran a gossip column?

[@stephenbroadhurst7653]

Dr Mate is too good for the western ideology that’s built on power and profit he is a living saint.

[@jimbo_1312]

As if Piers ever had Morals.

[@asmazak]

Netanyahu applied for the job of Grim Reaper but was turned down for being overqualified.

[@Cnichal]

Henry Kissinger got the job.

[@MusMasi]

@@Cnichal 🤣

[@qyu...976]

😂😂😂

[@kumstuke]

​@@Cnichalat least no more wasted oxygen That man was a monster

[@barefoot6745]

Overqualified. 😀😄😁😆😁

[@nominecognomen736]

Don’t forget to mention David Adler. Such a well articulated, deep and honest commentary on the questions. Very brave, intelligent and informative at the same time. Shalom my brother in humanity, from a muslim from Azerbaijan.

[@SeanCrosser]

"fragile coexistence" One where one side is "mowing the lawn" and one side is "the lawn"

[@dh914]

"They don't know the history". That statement reminds me of a book title" THE AXE FORGETS BUT THE TREE REMEMBERS "😢

[@vau_st]

Powerful thought

[@OzAbi]

Gabor Mate, Ilan Pape and Norm Finkelstein are the most reasonable voices that have a chance to be listened to from the Israeli side.

[@jacqdanieles]

And Gideon Levy

[@rjung_ch]

@@jacqdanieles ever so right!

[@MusMasi]

@@jacqdanieles gideon is funny sometimes

[@ahmedabdulsamedbhuskhaw8903]

Also The Generals son(Miko Peled) and Finkelstein.

[@historiaeresistencia832]

100% true.

[@MeMe-bg8ci]

Gabor is an absolute gem of a human being.

[@Truth-Seeker420]

Rise above hate. Respect this guy

[@kathyborthwick6738]

Dr. Gabor Mate is an incredibly intelligent and very caring man! His work on trauma has helped thousands and thousands of people and as well as being a Clinical Therapist, a Lakota Oglala Elder and interestingly enough am now a Microbiologist as well is all due to applying Dr. Gabor’s work!

[@sarahhopeful6683]

We thank you and him for your support of the oppressed Palestinians!

[@007nadineL]

Amazing 🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@pologoone6639]

I discovered gabor mate whilst in rehab, his compassion for addicts in vancouver and the empathy and kindness i received from the staff at the rehab i attended are largely what moved me left. If i can benefit from people's kindness and understanding i have a duty to pass that kindness and understanding on.

[@matp5760]

you're a fucking chad mate. wish you the best of luck

[@user-mj7cw1vu7u]

Поддерживаю

[@negril7446]

How can Palestinians be anti-Semitic, when Palestinians/Arabs are semitic. When Is rea lis... Many are from somewhere else. Like Europe, America and even Africa.

[@Uneekname]

compassion is where it's at

[@unixtreme]

Good job doing rehab I hope you are doing well.

[@gennarinabyrd1402]

Always love the sound of truth being spoken ...even if it hurts or I may disagree... thank you Gentlemen ❤😊

[@eblanco2172]

2:24 What Israel faced on that horrific Oct 7 is what Palestinians has faced for +60 years.

[@circular_entropy3455]

*75+ years

[@myrar8708]

lmao nope😂

[@deltafire5058]

They have been doing it to each other. True ignorance is taking ether side.

[@user-vb4wi4nh4x]

My fellow Canadian Dr Mate is a beacon of what humans should be - humane empathetic intelligent ethical - I could go on and on but just seeing and listening to him tells me what a great man he is. Thank you

[@careydepass130]

He has more sense than the present Canadian government.

[@sophiarevel6952]

Gabor is a good man.

[@justanothernick3984]

That's why the message is harder to sidestep. Tate said a similar thing but he has lost his credibility and he hasn't got any merits to speak about the issue in the first place. So this is why the messenger is also important when delivering the information and it's not as easily opposed. He seems to be a good man.

[@sophiarevel6952]

@@justanothernick3984 reputation matters!

[@halifaxeh]

@@justanothernick3984He’s an incredible man. He has changed countless lives including mine. His work on trauma is so compassionate and empathetic because he truly gets it from his lived experiences. He’s not flawless but he admits his flaws and works toward being a better person. He’s a legend!

[@Healingflower313_]

Dr. Mate has been an incredible asset to the trauma research and community. He has helped millions. Please society do not cancel this man.

[@breathnstop]

David Adler not every American was on board for Iraq. And not everyone thinks criticism of Israel is antisemitism.

[@juliandarch9278]

I'm starting to think Piers is discovering a conscience, he's actually muttered the word "occupation" a few times in the last few days.

[@thehellyousay]

he needs to be force fed his own teeth.

[@truthseeker0987]

@@thehellyousay 💯

[@prsimoibn2710]

No, he is as corrupt as he always been

[@kenny832]

No he knows how this will look in history & is giving voice to the opposition while still towing the genocide apologist line

[@juliandarch9278]

@@kenny832 will forever be known as "Piers do you condemn HAMAS Morgan"

[@belladonna6624]

Well said Dr Mate - whilst many people are pro Israel, Mate is quite right in pointing out you have to look at both sides of the story and most people do not!

[@user-mf6li4sw6n]

Religion and ethnicity have been the hugest detriment humanity has created for itself.

[@adrianasantana865]

This conversation is so mind openimg, thank you, thank you, thank you❤

[@Drenicite]

I never used to like Piers but he is clearly making a point of bringing on and allowing Pro-Palestine speakers to talk at length, with minimal interruption and just make their case. It's far more than we get from other MSM sources.

[@koalabrownie]

Yes on other MSM sources the people challenging Israel's narrative are being cancelled, like Mehdi Hasan.

[@celestialnubian]

After years of hackery, he's trying to be a real journalist now... except when the story is about Megan Markle. LOL

[@anshumanbose5132]

​@@mayonaraI think that's because he realises that he's gonna get the same treatment as Mehdi Hassan if he's too outspoken. Which is why he lets his speakers do the talking for him.

[@smoothmove5250]

​@@anshumanbose5132 Piers would never be too outspoken in favor of Palestine.

[@jeschinstad]

You mean _American_ MSM. Why not diversify your news sources?

[@roxannamarinak3156]

Thank you Dr. Gabor for telling the Truth! Please continue to speak out on what Zionism is doing to the Palestinian people and its inhumanity !

[@DulceN]

I am glad to hear Dr. Mate’s opinion on this subject, I respect this wise man whose work helped me overcome awful lifelong trauma. I visited Israel in the Spring of 87, during a truce of an entifada, and was able to observe and learn first hand everything Dr. Gabor is describing. My opinion of the state of Israel was forever changed after that trip.

[@asherroodcreel640]

What was it like

[@halifaxeh]

That’s amazing! Dr Mate is a legend. He also changed my life through his books and KZbin content!

[@equilibrium2426]

Piers and his views “ Israel has the right to defend itself “ ……….. yup Piers ….” A rapist has the right of having sex”

[@hashimrahman51]

Not a good analogy. A better analogy is a victim fighting back against her rapist, and the rapist beating her in response and claiming that he has a right to defend himself.

[@WendyJoseph-ww8ws]

Oooohhh... Great analogy!

[@rafikbaladi6555]

How eloquent and judicious you have proven to be, Dr. Gabor. Truly, a man of intellectual integrity.

[@giselealmeidavellozakildai3335]

I cannot bear seeing what is happening in Gaza. Every day it gets worse! It's a genocide and disgrace as the world does nothing. Palestinians are human beings and deserve respect, freedom and to live as well.🇵🇸 Thank you Dr Mate, you are a beacon of hope and voice of reason.❤

[@juliasimpson774]

Bless you.

[@nosuchthing8]

Excellent post

[@everythingyousayiscorrect]

But it’s really their own fault There are consequences for one actions

[@Skans-Gustav]

Fin beskrivning av denna fruktansvärda situation. Det är klart att man måste se hela situationen för palestinierna och vad de utsatts för under de senaste 80 åren.

[@dan-bz7dz]

As a Jew growing up in Sweden I was subjected to a lot of racism. But not for being a Jew. Just because I looked like a foreigner. I can only recall one time an Arab in a bar in Barcelona asked me to leave or else. That was it. The only time I have ever been subjected to "anti-semitism". I told my friends we need to leave and that was it. Nothing happened.

[@elizabethflynr7561]

Thanks Dr. Mate’ for speaking the truth.

[@michaelfung4629]

Poor piers Morgan, he’s getting a lot of news he doesn’t like.

[@user-tm6gk2vs8i]

This reminds me of Rashid Buttars' interview with Anderson Cooper! Rashid died soon after!

[@OmegaWeaponR]

Gabor is a man I can listen to knowing he will apply a fair and unbiased logic to any topic which cannot be said for the majority of contributors to such sensitive and emotional topics. It requires you take the time to understand the other rather than simple branding them with the words of condemnation.

[@halifaxeh]

Exactly! He’s an incredible human and a legend. The world needs so many more people like him!! His books, podcasts and videos have changed my life!

[@TheGbelcher]

He should advocate for Canada to give its land back to the indigenous people. But that’s probably different because he lives there.

[@Dave183]

Gr8 to see Piers re-inventing himself- being fair and open in his interviews... ...we live in a new world- a full world- with many many things to unravel, and put right.

[@sarahjaneross2918]

What an example of humanity he is... if only politicians were so wise.

[@Gelicaa.2]

For decades the world has been like this. Man made war, we actually need to question the human race and why man create wars in the first place.

[@Gelicaa.2]

And unfortunately you have nations created off of war greed and lies even early times in the bible of family members brothers jealous of each other. As long as there are men in high power and ego theres going to be craziness. And anyone born and raised in the west can't really speak for Palestine nor Israel because those are deep rooted issues that we do not know

[@adamevert1618]

They are politicians, they are not supposed to be wise and have the highest occurance of sociopaths between them.

[@rodytan6832]

Politician are wise to receive the so called white Envelopes nothing more

[@zedwolf1589]

I really don't care much for Pierce Morgan but I have to honestly say I'm quite surprised at the guest he's had on discussing this uneven war. He's had crappy right wingers on his show but there's always seems to be someone to push back and tell the truth.

[@ChrispyNut]

It certainly is quite puzzling.

[@kenny832]

He knows how media presenters are going to look in history so he’s giving voice to the opposition while still towing the genocide apologist line

[@erictread]

It's the only way for him to retain any cred, so he must do. Like when Nuland went to Niger. Even when you steel a job to make sure it doesn't get done you still have to do it sometimes. That is Piers - A Trojan horse trap talking it's self up some more time to hide. @@ChrispyNut

[@erictread]

It's the only way for him to retain any cred

[@MusMasi]

@@erictread he give 0 pushback to the rabid right wingers, most of the time when you has Pro Humanity people on he wont shut up about condemning Hamas and that takes up most of the show.

[@ThunderHOWL16]

i admire people with the strength to do the right thing even after being raised their whole life to do otherwise

[@ChrisAlbertH47]

Piers and the western talking heads keep saying that Israel is responding out of a sense of trauma that they've experienced on Oct 7th and that the overreaction stems from that (some have even called it justified). But have they ever asked what the Palestinians must feel like? Having experienced what Israel did on the Oct 7th many times over throughout decades? Why is Israel allowed to be angry and wipe out an entire region out of that one incident, but Palestinians can't fight back? they can't be angry? Why are they supposed to take the humiliation and oppression lying down?

[@MusMasi]

Its the European Colonial Mindset, its all the same, when the vietnamese wanted their independence, Algeria, India, Zimbawe, South Africa, Haite, they get demonized for resisting. Or when there was slave revolts in the Americas.

[@samara6041]

THIS 👏

[@GeteMachine]

@@MusMasi Demonized for resisting, should be a question against all colonial western countries. Because Americans hated the opposition to the Vietnam war as well. The what did the US do? Agent Orange. Caused those people generational health defects on some Vietnamese people. Nixon wanted mass arrests for liberal opposition then too.

[@GeteMachine]

He is still on the weeks old narrative that, ignores what we know now. The trauma they were caused, came from the IDF, killing those people and Netanyahu not caring about those people in the line of fire, but used it to escalate a notion for genocide, the western media went in lockstep with and defend every fucking lie Israel puts out. They're never challenged at all. He also just seems so biased to make it seem like only Israel has a legitimate right to feel anything about this, when Israel killed 10x more people, most civilians, most intentionally and anyone speaking up for them gets arrested, cancelled or fired. Gazans don't have the media defending their humanity. All the corporate western media was saying killing them is fine.

[@green_forest]

​@@GeteMachineAlso, Mohammed Ali, the boxer was imprisoned for resisting the army's recruitment to be part of the offensive against Vietnam.

[@alaidearce1591]

LoL he's nos a psychologist, he's an MD. But he IS one of the most compasionate and wisest people I know of.

[@halifaxeh]

And a family practice MD at that. Most of all, he understands humanity. He’s a legend.

[@mehdideihimi9057]

This is the only guy making sense. I hope they listen to him and find the right solution.

[@patrickgrove3469]

Nelson Mandela rejected the premise that freedom from Apartheid could be accomplished without violence.

[@FreePalestineStopTheGenocide]

Because he would have spoken and they would have laughed it off.. and even would have killed him then what? Sometimes you have to physically fight to bring about the change..

[@fairuzhafizahatan7750]

Michael, you're an amazing journalist. And i applaud what novara media strives to achieve. I just hope that novara media can please start calling the arabs as semitics too. By acknowledging that arabs are also semitics will help educate the mass that Jews are not exclusively semitics. And this war is not about being anti semitics. Keep up the good work novara media team.

[@joewoodhead7026]

I had no idea that was the definition of Semite, thanks for informing! This should be reiterated

[@leon3589]

Holy shit mate. Thank you. You just opened my mind. I had no idea of the actual meaning of the word. Props to you, mate. For being educated.

[@hakimlharrachi5801]

It all make sense now. Thank you!

[@consuelopaz401]

Thank you Sir!

[@RobPerreault]

Gabor Mate is a true legend. I was able to see him and buy his book "hold on to your kids" and got him to sign it... Great speaker. Very hurtful situation.

[@elizarehan2309]

Thank you so much Dr. Gabor for speaking the truth. May God reward you 🤲🏼

[@osamashatat]

Piers Morgan is one of the few with a huge audience that allows the truth to be expressed and exposed

[@alphajackal6648]

TBH this is more of an outlier than anything. Piers does not have a history of integrity and thoughtful journalism. Still, it's good that these people get to speak.

[@osamashatat]

@@alphajackal6648 agreed

[@themissingpeace7956]

It takes a lot of courage to speak the truth when the society you live in is against the truth.

[@douglaspouch5313]

It's rarely asked "how should a people respond to 75 years of dispossession and occupation?". Self-defense does not apply to an occupying state’s wars against those it occupies. This is almost never stated.

[@empireoflightz]

It's a bit more complex than that though, what if the occupying state doesn't actually want to occupy but feels it has to only to protect itself, because whenever it starts to deescalate its occupation horrible attacks begin to happen? Because the organsiation governing the occupied state has its stated target to completely destroy the occupying one, and has never been interested in peaceful coexistence? Does self-defense also not apply in that situation?

[@susanbajjada2960]

​@@empireoflightz Millions squashed into a tiny strip of land. Full control of water, power etc. A huge ugly wall built to imprison & intimidate. Constant presence of armed soldiers.Does that sound like Israel wants peaceful coexistence? They took the land forcibly in the first place. You might need to read some history books. Did you really listen to Gabor?!

[@empireoflightz]

@@susanbajjada2960 you're confusing the current situation as if that's how it always was. Most of Israel is currently very much uninterested in coexistence as you say, and the exact same applies to most of Palestine. But 20-30 years ago things were very different on the Israeli side, there was a strong left and many, many more of us wanted peace and a two state solution, at that point Palestinians refused multiple offers of going back to the 1967 borders and started the second intifada and suicide bombings, and then both the peace process and the Israeli left died 😥 if you're not aware of that maybe you should read some history books? Your claim the land was "stolen" is also a one sided and very oversimplified way of looking at it. Please have a read about the 1947 resolution and the 1948 and 1967 wars and try to see things from both perspectives, any hope we have of peace depends on being able to come to a mutual understanding of the situation rather than each side digging further into their one sided reality (which is currently happening on both sides)

[@jutswheezie]

1947, 1993, 1995, 1998, 2000, 2008 many chances for peace but obviously they choose to live like this play the victim and get a lot of money for it so the Hamas billionaires do not have to work a single day in their and live in palaces in Qatar and elsewhere. They are the true oppressors of the GAZAN people

[@ntombimasikane8988]

Hallelujah, Dr Gabor Mate is such a great hero and may he not be wavered against telling the truth!

[@lish1150]

This is extremely informative. Thank you for sharing with us.

[@pennymayphilip9646]

So very tired of being told that criticism of Israel is anti-semetic.

[@James-oj8kq]

he speaks so calmly and beautifully

[@halifaxeh]

When I’m feeling anxious, he is my go-to. I search for podcasts or KZbin videos of him to hear his voice. It’s so soothing.

[@tobiramasenju5878]

Respect for Mr Gabor and many other Jews for standing up for the truth. Free Palestine

[@jasnaljubonjic7103]

Dr. Gabor Mate is a very smart man!

[@theshadow5800]

Nice to have a guest not incessantly interrupted by or talked over by Piers.

[@anonymouse740]

The thing that puzzles me about this whole conflict is that apparently you're antisemitic if you speak out against the Israeli treatment of the Palestinians. When I was against the US and UK going into Iraq did that make me anti-white?

[@shaami8622]

Yes. How dare you oppose the spread of "freedom".

[@Kayzef2003]

Being called anti-semitic these days is just a slur to shut down opinions.

[@Bz626]

It’s a just a weak retort used whenever they’re losing the argument and have nothing to stand on. You’ll be labeled antisemitic for driving a German car these days for fucks sake lol

[@nikolamilicevic1040]

if you was for dismatnling usa and shipping back anglos into europe you woudl be called anti anglo or anti whtie as angklos consider themsef as true whites.angklos are collonisers both in uk and usa.

[@kw267]

Much RESPECT Dr Gabor Mate.....You have seen the Light, Praises to The Most High....❤️NZ

[@user-le5to3kd3g]

Michael Walker, you are a good man . Thank you for being a man of truth.

[@redmed10]

When people are attacking you, you've got to at some point ask why they are attacking you.

[@erictread]

Apparently not. See how they run.

[@redmed10]

@@erictread what's that supposed to mean?

[@David.attenbruh]

@@redmed10I think he’s quoting the “three blind mice” rhyme

[@redmed10]

@@David.attenbruh hello again bruh. I've learned my lesson. Not really a fan of your takes. Plus I'd rather let people speak for themselves.

[@erictread]

yep@@David.attenbruh

[@jenskarlsson4744]

defend them self against kids Piers ?no one is under attack now! only civilians !

[@moderneurope]

Amazing level of empathy and understanding.

[@burtgrabmore2972]

How is the fact that the Palestinians have been; robbed, occupied, tortured, kidnapped, locked into a concentration camp, and suffered and are suffering the most barbaric treatment, not a justification for Oct 7th?

[@whereammy]

Just like how America was totally randomly attacked on 9/11 without any rhyme or reason /s

[@antonio.nirta8821]

@@whereammy vogliamo parlare di come gli usa hanno preso le loro terre 💀

[@geralvon]

Where's the evidence that the Palestinians have been mistreated prior to Oct 7th? Why was the state of Israel proclaimed in 1948 by the US and UK? Wasn't it the diaspora after the end of WWII? Didn't they say those Jews had no home? What are you supposed to do when a flood of people want to go back to their original home? How was the confiscation of Palestinians' properties justified at the time? Did the Palestinians at that time have a government of their own? Palestine was a ?protecterate (like a colony?) of Great Britain? Now I hear that the Palestinians have representatives in the Knesset. To understand what is really involved there boggles the mind. What are you supposed to do with avowed terrorists? War is Hell - can it be made nice? They say Nice Guys don't win ball games. I seem to recall that in ancient times, the people of conquered nations were made slaves, and for people to be made freemen, they had to fight for the nation that had conquered them. How it all applies to what is happening today - I don't know.

[@shadowX9365]

There is no justification for October 7th. They killed innocent children and raped women. These are civilians that have nothing to do with the conflict. It’s unacceptable. However Israel’s response in my opinion is even more unacceptable cuz they went even further with the whole Palestinian population. Trying to justify October 7th is never a good point to make cjz it’s horrific what they did. HAMAS makes things so much worse for the Palestinians. The point is that Israel went a step further and did worse things. Two wrongs don’t make a right. They’re now commuting a genocide

[@gedertonfc]

Both are equally as bad, but not every Palestinian is Hamas and not every Jew a warmonger it is just a select few disciples of the Devil.

[@federalreservewolflegend3523]

There is a great meme going around where Pierce is asking a crying baby (surrounded by the Gaza moonscape) "But do you condemn Hamas?!!"

[@MusMasi]

apt

[@HARRi81_UK]

I was first introduced to Gabor years ago when watching Peter Joseph's films - truly a wise fella.

[@ellyfish13]

That's when I found him too, long time follower! Whatever happened to Peter Joseph? Mate's latest book the Myth of Normal is awesome

[@HARRi81_UK]

Not sure really. I was thinking of buying that book soon, you'd recommend it then?@@ellyfish13

[@kathrinalicedellorusso7493]

one of the best I have come around in the topic. thank you very much! Everybody should hear this clear analysis! 🙏

[@maryannmattia3560]

thank you for interviewing Mate Gabor He is an amaizing human being, he is not worried that people will stop him by anything that has been done to others that have called out the crimes of the Israelies . thank you Dr. Gabor

[@stephendoherty981]

Douglas Murray would call Gabor Mate a 'psychopath' just like he did with Norman Finklestein. Yet, the contrast between the quiet wisdom of Mate and the bitter hatred of Murray is so stark. Why won't Murray debate with Mate and Finklestine? Does he think he'll be found out?

[@shaami8622]

I bet hed also called him a "H-event" denier as well...

[@stephendoherty981]

@@shaami8622 And a 'self-hating' Jew.

[@maazkalim]

Why does it sound like you all considered him a level-headed person all these years?

[@g.pmoore4293]

There is something bitter and twisted about Murray.

[@exanimo11]

Murray has lost the plot

[@alvodin6197]

Just a minor correction Michael: Gabor mate is an MD but not a psychologist,.nor a psychiatrist( thank God). He is a very important speaker in these disturbing times...Thank you Novara Media for including him in your program!

[@maazkalim]

Why “thank God”?

[@noidontlikeu]

​@@maazkalimlots of people don't trust drug based methods of treating mental illness, psychiatrists perscribe those drugs

[@asherroodcreel640]

A lot of them like spread sheets more then people and people is their jobs

[@grandsome1]

​​@@asherroodcreel640Most psychiatrist and other psychology specialists are overworked and overburdened, it's a miracle some still get people to get better in those conditions especially given how sensitive their patients are.

[@halifaxeh]

@@maazkalimBecause psychiatrists rarely get to the root of the problem. They never met a problem they couldn’t address with drugs rather than compassionate understanding of the root of the problem.

[@Elicalledtrans]

Dr.Gabor’ account is brilliant. Adlars analysis is so important and so brilliant. Great video, Free Palestine

[@mohamedaityoussef9965]

I'm on the verge of tears listening to DR Gabor Maté speaking, it's quite moving, and it is the compassion we desperately need in the world right and forever for that matter

[@matthall1934]

And Piers will forget all this tomorrow and ask his next guest "do you condemn hamas?" something about Oct 7 and "how else does Israel deal with Hamas other than how they are?"

[@bahialynch3037]

Wow so powerful speech. Thank you.

[@mohammedmazahir1888]

Thank you for the interview

[@eloiinvestigates]

"When the Body says No". Awesome book, Gabor. Truly awesome book. It needed to be said, from a medic's perspective. Well done for authoring such an important book, Dr Mate.

[@MJ-zv2sd]

❤ Gabors Maté work, Books & Podcasts! Thank you for speaking out the truth ✌️

[@JoseManuel-jd1yr]

💯❤️❤️

[@hollies5841]

What an incredibly astute man. I wish people like him were world leaders, he is so well informed and articulate.

[@firdoshvirjee3592]

I agree with you 💯 and he should be given noble award

[@user-ds6ov8jr5n]

Such informed and intelligent speakers. I have listened to so much and this is very valuable.