holy musical b@man! songs ranked by voting

[@Chris-on2xv]

Unpopular opinion: I really like Robin Sucks

[@martaborgegard3922]

I LOVE IT!

[@jess1ca547]

Little rant here but to be a man is one of the most underrated starkid songs ever like it’s so funny and so good and barely anyone appreciates it

[@weirdflexbut2018]

tbh the entire soundtrack of hmb is gold but to be a man must be one of my fav

[@moe-gy5se]

It got almost four stars, we all love it we just let it get overshadowed by the other songs :((

[@SophieHeflebower]

i agree i agree! it's my favorite to rewatch

[@sophiet2849]

Actually surprised Super Friends didn't make number 1, it's like... THE Starkid anthem

[@izzy1221]

Wouldn’t that be Back to Hogwarts?

[@sophiet2849]

@@izzy1221 I'd honestly say both apply, both represent Starkid perfectly

[@EuRoWeIrD]

The most liked Starkid song seems to be “Kick it up a Notch” or “Show Stopping Number”

[@FloreMar-yp3iz]

I was like "Why is (x song) so low?" And it's because all HMB is absolute gold But Yeah, Robin Sucks not having at least 3 stars is a hate crime

[@HS-lo8ex]

Right I was upset Dynamic Duo only made 7th, but it still had over 4 stars

[@inerciasart]

American way and to be a man deserved WAY BETTER

[@whatisthisbusiness4681]

I think that the entire soundtrack is so great that even really great songs that everybody loves have to be placed at the bottom.

[@SeaSparklesLP]

everything except robin sucks had at least 3.89 stars, proving that they are all bangers in their own right

[@SamVargo]

I am OFFENDED by Dynamic Duet 😔 My favorite song lol

[@keysersoze4685]

Same! They did the best songs so dirty!

[@kingbaco1233]

looks like IM the outlier for liking to be a man and the duet

[@radxianixe]

they were done dirty, we're in this together

[@EvangelinaGrey]

IKR? That song is better than the entirety of BvS

[@diamondbright7327]

I like those songs too so you’re not the only one who likes those songs

[@joshuasgameplays9850]

I also like being a man.

[@kingbaco1233]

@@joshuasgameplays9850 it's always a fun time! 😎

[@evievalerierogers5246]

joe singing ‘robin you parted the clouds’ in the dynamic duet is enough for it to be number 1 for me

[@qwertyqwerty-jy9fc]

Unpopular (?) opinion i actually prefer the reprise over the first rogues are we xd

[@ceruleanhearts7604]

SAME

[@defectivetictac6103]

me too

[@emmamajury9032]

Sameeee

[@inerciasart]

I found my people!!

[@hannahmurdy8902]

Oh yes!!!!

[@fruiteend]

The ending really confused me because that's my actual ringtone and for a second there I thought someone was calling me

[@abhiramiprabakar7067]

omgggg i want it in mp3 format please wow

[@alyssamonkey]

That must go over well at family parties.... 😂

[@fruiteend]

@@alyssamonkey I once got a phone call during a driving lesson... And I obviously couldn't turn it off because I was driving, so that was fun 😂

[@annikak.1554]

I honestly like the Reprise of Rogues are We better than the original and I'm surprised at The American Way's placement

[@hitmonkey3602]

7/9 over 4 stars, HMB really does have the best soundtrack

[@bluebirdie2011]

I think the fact that everyone wants certain songs to be higher just shows how awesome the album is.

[@rain9601]

As it currently stands: HMB = 4.08 Ani = 3.90 Black Friday = 3.85 AVPSY = 3.85 Twisted = 3.73 TGWDLM = 3.70 TTO = 3.61 Firebringer = 3.56 I worked out the mean score of each musical so far, I'll try to do this for all of the future rankings

[@ceruleanhearts7604]

deserved

[@banana-xj6yk]

I hope AVPM gets the best score it’s so good

[@mollywhiteman8956]

Murrold this is nearly the opposite of how i would rank the best to worst music wow

[@HS-lo8ex]

Molly whiteman I would guess this method isn’t perfect, for example, HMB has 9 while FB has 17.

[@mollywhiteman8956]

H S oh i didn’t think of that that makes sense

[@beefstroganoff1774]

Unpopular opinion (maybe?): I like Dynamic Duet, Holy Musical B@man, Super Friends, Dark, Sad, Lonely, Kinght, and American Way better than Rogues are We

[@keysersoze4685]

I'm with you! Those are the songs I never skip cause they are frickin bops! I was so shocked each one kept popping up so low on the list.

[@thatonestarkidfan3918]

I don’t even know why people don’t like Robin Sucks, it’s actually quite good 🤷‍♂️

[@lucyaddison3524]

No one is surprised about Robin Sucks being last anymore.

[@qstionblomens6138]

Me, usually while watching the community votes: Finding out what the fandom likes best is interesting. Me right now: Oh! This time they all chose to be wrong 🙂

[@superfluousdee6476]

the stark difference in stars between robin sucks and to be a man..... wow

[@whatisthisbusiness4681]

I love partaking in videos like these, it's a really fun way to engage with the StarKid community.

[@ceciliabernal3241]

Unpopular opinion: "Robin Sucks" doesn't suck :)

[@mollywhiteman8956]

Cecília Bernal i don’t get why people hate it it’s catchy

[@emmamajury9032]

Literally the fact that 7/9 are over 4 stars is proof that H.M.B. has one of the best soundtracks

[@sydneestephens8331]

I was disappointed when 2 of my favorite songs Dynamic Duet and to be a man were at the end. Then I remembered that this musical has some of the best music! Like every single song it’s great except robin sucks and even that song isn’t terrible!!!

[@willwest-toebe6287]

The American way deserves to be higher

[@katierisley]

to be a man deserved better

[@kaidou04]

Voting was sooo hard. Every song is just such a bop.

[@annaeichler2707]

dynamic duet is my favorite starkid song yall did it dirty

[@qwertyqwerty-jy9fc]

What do you mean every song isnt rated amazing

[@sophie7780]

idk if this is an unpopular opinion but........batman is joe walker's best role fight me

[@rileyherbig1537]

dynamic duet is one of my favorites and a lot of ppl dont like it as much?? but the entire soundtrack is just AMAZING

[@brooke4502]

Honestly I don’t really like Dark, Sad, Lonely night. I don’t know why

[@micahwilliams1332]

I can kinda relate. It started of so slow to me that I stopped watching for a while. I started watching it again and the song gained my attention. But the entirety of it is not appealing.

[@okonh0wp]

Rogues Are We is my fave, yes, it feels like something the 60s batman rogues gallery would actually do, and it also works on a meta-musical level where we accept its a heightened reality. Who isn't elated by seeing the rogues do a musical number together?

[@LosTrilocos]

This soundtrack is so good, 7 of 9 songs are ranked more than 4 stars

[@andrewhrusovsky9426]

To be a man is the best song, you must open your eyes

[@featherlight858]

For me it'd be: 9. Holy Musical B@man 8. Rogues Are We 7. Rogues Are We (Reprise) 6. Dynamic Duet 5. Robin Sucks 4. To Be A Man 3. Dark Sad Lonely Knight 2. Super Friends 1. The American Way

[@thewoodlandcryptid]

TO BE A MAN DESERVED BETTER that song is legendary

[@maddielancaster2537]

After you’re done with all these videos you should take the average rating of each musicals songs and rank them based on that 😂👌

[@DoMMy627]

American Way actually shocked me

[@elisa8467]

But these are ALL AMAZING

[@smathened]

o p i n i o n s- also, spoilers ahead to be a man should be higher robin sucks should have 3 stars but deserves its spot because the rest of the soundtrack is so good rogues are we isn’t even in my top 5 hmb songs. the reprise, yeah, but the original isn’t the best song in the musical. rogues are we is good but others are just better the american way should be higher like wtf fans and this list having 7/9 songs over 4 stars with one other song almost at 4 stars shows that the songs in this show are outstanding. it’s a really good musical.

[@alyssamonkey]

Question: when you do the songs ranked by voting video for every musical combined will you do sections for each musical or are you doing all of them over all? Sorry that probably doesn’t make any sense but I don’t know how to describe it lol

[@beathecat6604]

To be a man was robbed

[@hpwinxw6098]

The solid star difference between robin sucks and everything else.. that hurt its not that bad

[@katarinarose3379]

The bottom two would be in at least my top four lol

[@SwarmOfBeees]

I was about to be mad at this ranking until I realised that most of them had over 4 stars

[@alexknudsen7103]

Extremely unpopular opinion: I can find at least a few other songs so much better Rogues are We, I know imma get shot XD

[@Donkeyturnip]

What does this fandom have against Robin Sucks???

[@abbygeers4479]

ok sorry but i’m really not a fan of rogues are we and i think american way should have been higher

[@sophiet2849]

How come you don't like Rogues Are We?

[@beefstroganoff1774]

I like Rogues are We, but it's definitely not my favourite from this soundtrack, especially with songs like Holy Musical B@man, the Dynamic Duet, Super Friends, and American Way

[@abbygeers4479]

Sophie T i really enjoy all of the songs on the soundtrack i just think it’s a little overrated

[@sophiet2849]

@@abbygeers4479 How about the reprise?

[@lattehottay3120]

woah really surprised that to be a man is so low?

[@jadziaallright136]

rogues are we is my least favourite hmb song whoops

[@Bookwormia]

i will not stand for this robin sucks slander

[@snarls3760]

Personally i highly disagree with this