How Darth Vader Remembered Choking Padme and His Thoughts About Mustafar - Star Wars Explained

In yesterday's video we went over Vader's thoughts and analysis about Order 66, his betrayal of the Jedi, sacrificing Mace Windu and killing the Younglings. Today's video is in continuation of that passage where Anakin goes over his thoughts during Mustafar in Revenge of the Sith where he sees Obi Wan on Padme's ship and how he wished it went differently.
Facebook Page - / starwarstheorytoos
What if Order 66 Failed? Star Wars Theory
• What if Order 66 Faile...
The Story and Reason Behind Darth Maul's Double Bladed Lightsaber
• The Story and Reason B...
Count Dooku's Reaction to Qui Gon Jinn's Death
• Count Dooku's Reaction...
What If Qui Gon Jinn Trained Anakin Skywalker?
• What If Qui Gon Jinn T...
What if Darth Maul Trained Anakin Skywalker? • What If Darth Maul Tra...
What if Padme Survived?
• What If Padme Survived...
What if Mace Windu Killed Darth Sidious?
• What if Mace Windu Kil...
Music - William Maytook

[@Boofus90]

If Obi wan wasn't trying to look badass by coming down the ramp very slowly then maybe the Galaxy wouldn't be so bad and I would have an actual family!

[@ellabreannamusic6239]

Darth Vader lol yeah

[@ellabreannamusic6239]

obi wan lol

[@ryanharrell8866]

Darth Vader this is a amazing comment section lol

[@BlackStar-kt9ji]

Darth Vader true

[@thepuglord4903]

I'm not your enemy. I'm a Sith myself.

[@kwames.8411]

Skywalker: My power has doubled since we last met! Dooku: 2 times 0 is still 0 Palpatine: LMAO dude

[@fooberdooge3103]

Jimmy Hall he's gonna need a lot of water, and a new suit and limbs

[@apoorna5302]

Excellent XD

[@derp8632]

Star wars tricks

[@itzspicey7173]

0 times 2 isn’t 2 guy

[@skasktheslod924]

There’s isn’t a suit good enough for that burn

[@Jowali]

What if Anakin did not jump, after Obiwan got the Highground?

[@darthultor6365]

Jowali he would have drifted of the lava waterfall and died

[@ary5368]

true

[@Oridan1]

couldn't he have manouvered the cart using the force?

[@RequiemPoete]

darth ultor: Or he could have directed the droid to the other side of the lava river, or to a place he didn't have to leap to get on the ground.

[@galslovveme]

The lava ground HISHE

[@Lfrohawker]

What I wonder is if every force choke after Padme caused him to feel that rage and internalized self-hatred. Did it take him back to Mustafar and that fateful action that arguably sealed Padme's fate? When he kills people with his force choke, does he reexperience killing Padme?

[@cesmatiq5180]

LukeFrohawker Probably yes especially since his Sidious even told him he killed her and we all know she died of childbirth but he thinks he killed her so yea.

[@aggarius2944]

iiCustomHD she didn't die because the childbirth, she could have lived, but anakin and the fall of the republic destroyed her will to live

[@cesmatiq5180]

Christopher Huffman Ok

[@RequiemPoete]

Christopher Huffman: The whole "will to live" thing is idiotic. I like to think that Vader, during his surgery was inadvertently broadcasting his pain and self loathing to Pademe' till her body couldn't take it. The droids would have no answer since they can't feel the Force.

[@isthatjackson]

I line the idea that Palpatine used his Sith alchemy to drain her life to fuel Vader

[@A-man-Capitals301]

I never thought of him as whining but as conflicted and overwhelmed by so many emotions and memories almost constantly on a daily basis that drove him madly insane

[@cassandrabelyeu2419]

Traumatized war vet who wasn't allowed to feel his darker emotions. It'll make you go insane. And when he was seeing loved ones die, Yoda just told him to be happy about it. Not seek psychiatric help for seeing things and PTSD.

[@michaelslegofilms4984]

What if Anakin was granted master in Revenge of the Sith

[@swrewind]

It would only delay the inevitable. Granting Skywalker the rank of master would slow his progression to the dark side but it would not stop it. Sidious would have to rework his plan to seduce Anakin, but I'm sure he could find another way to continue pushing him down the path to the dark side.

[@michaelslegofilms4984]

The Star Wars Prequels Channel yeah but then he would lash out at a completely different time with a different scenario

[@swrewind]

Exactly.

[@jedione8767]

he already did that

[@JonDoe-fo3kl]

He wouldve credited sidius

[@StarWarsTheory]

Hey everyone!! How are you all today? Ready for a Fan Fiction tomorrow? What if Anakin Never Killed Dooku in Revenge of the Sith? Let me know your thoughts :) Thanks so much for watching, I'll see you all in the comments and on fb. Have a great day and May The Force Be With You!!

[@darthmarr3948]

Star Wars Theory Ready as ever my lord!

[@serter4545]

Star Wars Theory yeah that is a good idea.

[@homiedoor5716]

Star Wars Theory what if jabba The hutt survived ep 6, what if luke, han and chewie was thrown into the sarlacc Pit in ep 6

[@serter4545]

ASMR JUNKIE why? what if dooku killed anikan?

[@serter4545]

homie door yeah

[@351cleavland]

WHAT IF Anakin's mother had given him, as a child, a sandbox????

[@apoorna5302]

Sandakin is a ship...?

[@cassandrabelyeu2419]

She'd just give him a box. Then tell him to wait....

[@Pxl8d]

But Tatooine is already a huge sandbox...

[@goldenhd9656]

NOOOOOOOO NoOOOOOOOo IT CANT BE

[@Farenil_Silverhair]

What if watto realized qui gon cheated the cube?

[@AndrewMRoots]

I know this comment is three years old but what's he going to do against a Jedi Master*?

[@gedovrit]

@@AndrewMRoots fr

[@isuckatmath5750]

What if Anakin liked sand?

[@monkey9208]

I Suck At Math lol

[@callmewitcher5069]

best comment ever :)

[@sirbigbeard6177]

If he did, it is likely he would have searched tatooine for Luke and Obi wan

[@makeatwerkvideotwerk6769]

I Suck At Math What if anikin always identified as a female. And was trans.

[@isuckatmath5750]

+Jose Portillo "The dark side of the force is a pathway to many abilities, some considered to be unnatural"

[@itsnotamankey]

if the jedi temple had the sith power under it which sidious used to cloak his identity, why didn't obi-wan and anakin sense that palpatine was a sith lord on grievous' ship?

[@darthdestroyer11]

thats a good question

[@jacstark3148]

ItsNotAMankey that's is a very good question

[@sethsims3717]

Fairly certain it was the sith sorcery he used to conceal himself and the dark temple to cloud the jedis vision of the force it self thus clouding their judgment.

[@Lfrohawker]

Consider the fact that as Palpatine, he did not have the full amber and flame coloured eyes until the duel with Windu just as Anakin did not truly become Vader until getting chopped up by Obi-Wan. If we use that as a gauge, Palpatine arguably could turn on and off his use of Sith powers at will.

[@dilandesai5084]

ItsNotAMankey good question, i think it was not that he cloaked himself but they couldn't sense anything at all from dark side in temple

[@Wyte-noyz]

What if Anakin choked padme to death, killing luke and leia along with her.

[@Nelo_Wolf]

then the universe is fucked

[@Dd-qz4ym]

Hi

[@chriscull743]

damn man I'd pay for audiobooks read by you. you have a talent for storytelling.

[@kez3811]

Agree!

[@ThatAltBitch]

Exaacylyyy

[@theredfish6258]

"Obi wan would be on Coruscant sitting with his wife" Wouldn't it be fun to see Obi wan and Satine with Anakin and Padme after the war, talking about life.

[@palindromie8441]

Y'mean in the afterlife, laughing about how dumb Luke is

[@205mohamad]

This video made me remember, in Revenge of the Sith on ps2, the very last level is an alternative fight with Obi-Wan, you play as Anakin and at the end of the level you stab Obi-Wan in the back (literally). And the final cut scene is the Emperor giving Anakin a red lightsaber, after Anakin swings it a few times he stabs the Emperor then declares himself the Emperor. Doing this mission unlocks the death star stage with Ben Kenobi and Darth Vader, and a bonus mission of Ben vs Vader.

[@iantaylor7786]

Do a "if Obi-wan never went to Mustafar" fan fiction!

[@12FRIDOLIN12]

What if Anakin and the son escaped Mortis.

[@wolfsbanealphas617]

Eckharts Ladder hasa video on it

[@M.W.K6996]

"What if Count Dooku mastered all seven forms of the lightsaber?"

[@M.W.K6996]

Alex Ward So what?

[@aidana11168]

Alex Ward yea

[@theodoreboomgarden6981]

okay ive been watching your videos for a long time and I'm going to be honest you are single handedly changing how everyone looks at star wars you have made this story more than books and movies. I'm a huge fan. thank you.

[@eddiemunson1211]

Your videos really give this franchise more depth and gives the fans more vision on it and motivation Keep it up!

[@LightsaberAddict]

really enjoyed this and all your videos. Well thought out and very interesting to think about. Very rare that I disagree on your thoughts on the topics. Keep up the good work and have a great day.

[@_chew_]

What if Obi Wan never had the high ground?

[@galslovveme]

TheShadowOfMadness the original version of the duel would have shown him sliced in half regardless

[@mysteriev7071]

He always has the high ground, it's very rare force ability, which even yoda couldn't achieve.

[@RDavisLink]

Then it would be the alternate scene from the video game Revenge of the Sith.

[@captainobvious7441]

in star wars rebels there is a scene where vader is riding on top of a tie fighter so he now carries his own personal high ground

[@vladtepes3176]

This was a brilliant explanation! So well detailed! Thank you!

[@joeylankhorst4638]

This is the best Star Wars channel out there! Keep it up man!

[@hazardtmvine404]

This video was really good

[@StarWarsTheory]

Thanks!!! Appreciate the comment!

[@herrwagnerianer1739]

Yes, it was, but I'd be quite happy if you could make a video replying to my question: why did Vader stick with Sidious? Wouldn't he, if your explanation were fully true, have left him quite early? But he stays and becomes a loyal henchman of the Empire. His portrayal in the original trilogy shows that he believes in what he does.

[@frankludwig4268]

I think the best would be if our Obi Wan was not there at the Mustafa

[@nenan3540]

Padme would have never agree to become a dictator, to kill people and children in some bloody rituals in a hope that would give her immortality (and probably evil face like Palpatine’s), she would understand she needs to leave Anakin as he become twisted by the dark side. (She was already moving away). Angry Anakin, mad with the lust of power and obsession to posses her wouldn’t let her leave and would imprison her. In his twisted mind he would hate her believing that she wants to leave because she betrayed him and fell for Obi-Van, but he wouldn’t let her. Perhaps he would even torture her for her “betrayal”. Then there are different options, she kills herself before she gives birth or gives birth on the red planet...

[@kameleonls1]

I love this book and the series of videos you're doing about them. Great job on breaking down some of the passages.

[@JakeMcBoss]

Loved the picture of plaguis at the end, nice touch!!

[@Tyrodin]

Fuck dude I love your videos! I am a massive Star Trek fan! But seriously brother, love the channel and love Star Wars! Huge love and respect man :)

[@fusiontoa18]

fukin trekie

[@honokakazuno]

Tyrodin TYORDIN, SENPAI!!!!

[@victoriajames8871]

star trek its not star wars

[@williamjameslehy1341]

I'd been a Trekkie all my life, but now prefer Star Wars. Everything Trek-branded that's come out since the end of Enterprise has been a giant middle finger pointed directly at the fanbase. Whereas the Clone Wars series brought a level of depth and breadth to the Star Wars Universe that had previously been impossible with just six films to go off of. While Episode VII and Rogue One were far from perfect, they were vastly superior to any of Abrams' Trek films, or the utterly contemptible disaster that is STD.

[@MaddAce100]

Hay man you should talk about How Quigan Jinn taught Darth Vader how to become a force ghost. Or how Vader found out about it

[@MaddAce100]

Sorry you already did it

[@shademoreno6729]

madd ace I want to see that too. which video is it ?

[@joshuanaranjo5296]

madd ace what video?

[@TheMasonAguilar]

discovered your channel about a month ago right before this video dropped, its now the channel i watch and keep up with the most. good shit dude.

[@pedropascalfan03]

Thanks for a great Video again!

[@joeyp9524]

“You will not take her from me !!!” “Oh I *THINK* so” “You will try”

[@Foretelling]

Yes! Do the fan fiction of if Obi Wan never showed up

[@aleksandargeorgiev811]

Man how much has this channel grown i'm really happy that you have such a success

[@Innavata90]

One of the best videos. Its so entertaining to have videos like this that say: "Their thoughts on.." Keep making videos like this.

[@coreymckee4844]

do a "what if obi wan never showed up on Mustafar"😀😀

[@sosaix3545]

My favorite "What if?" - what if Mace Windu had insisted on Anakin accompanying him to arrest Palpatine? Would Palpatine have resisted with Anakin present? And if so, would Anakin have felt a need to defend Palpatine once he resisted and took down several Jedi before getting his ass handed to him by Windu?

[@valeanstefan7504]

200k subs omg 😱😱😱 ur awsome dude i'm rly happy for you 🙌🙌🙌

[@baller15g]

This is your greatest video! Thank You.

[@prestonspicer]

I would love to see you explore, in more detail, what would have happened had Obi Wan not been on Mustafar in Revenge of the Sith.

[@rustyshackelford3590]

I see the end of revenge of the sith where padmae and obi one go to Mustafar to talk sense into a anakin as an intervention gone wrong.

[@troyflorian8060]

Thanks for doing the video, and tomorrow's sounds like a great idea.

[@pierce708]

Hey man I love you videos every time I watch one I get goosebumps and if i'm a bad i just come here and watch some of your videos. keep up doing what you love and well all be here with you and supporting you.

[@cammiehalliday757]

Hi I love these videos but I only subscribed yesterday

[@serter4545]

Cammie Halliday i subscribed three days ago i think.

[@StarWarsTheory]

Welcome to the channel Cammie!!

[@StarWarsTheory]

Welcome YTSX!

[@serter4545]

Star Wars Theory thanks

[@cammiehalliday757]

Star Wars Theory thank you may the force be with you

[@acethegray]

What if Greedo shot first....

[@acethegray]

btw great vid :)

[@sonicbralaunik9671]

Ivoman Palushev I don't mean to crush your dreams but Han would have survived still and Greedo would die. I believe that Greedo shot first in the first edition but not sure though

[@acethegray]

He never shot in the original

[@lapplandkun9273]

@@LegendaryFrost mate wtf? Go to fanfiction if you want to see that

[@JohnDoe-wz3jq]

Fantastic video, and may the force be with you as well! I'm a huge fan, a daily watcher of your videos!

[@datboibiz1]

awsome video dude !!

[@serter4545]

i think you just got 3,000 more subscribers.

[@sephrosemary]

Please do a theory on what if vader recieved his suit in episode 6, before when he saved luke, i think he would have survived the fight?

[@andreigoia7021]

Really love your content. Keep it up!

[@stilth60050]

I really enjoy your videos thank you

[@digital_wilson]

Qui Gon would have been a better mentor for Anakin. I think he could have kept him in the light. Or better yet both of them get fed up with the order and leave. lol.

[@cassandrabelyeu2419]

Qui Gon couldn't join the Jedi counsel because he wasn't a true Jedi. He was a Grey Jedi, open to new ideas and his own emotions. I think he and Anakin would have done very, very well.

[@zachleathers1821]

I need to address a very interesting topic that i realized during this video that i have NEVER heard discussed. Of which would actually make a very unique and interesting " what if " scenario. Here it is, as mentioned in the video, and based canon dialogue and canon story, Anakin's intentions at the end of episode 3 before obi-wan creates the Darth Vader WE know. Anakins plans were to Destroy the emperor and rule the galaxy. Well...lets indulge this theory, say that after order 66, the jedi are purged as normal. Except. anakin defeats obi-wan and leaves mustafar with padme, and because he is present at the birth and with the best medical facility and droids at their disposal, she survives child birth. Then say Anakin does manage to convince her to remain at his side and ultimately be his queen once he is ruler of the galaxy. With her at his side, safe. Luke and Leia born and safe. The jedi purged and out of the way and anakin drunk on his new found darkside power, decides its time to make his move. Continuing on, Anakin Meets with the emperor in private at his personal estate on coruscant and not sensing his intentions until its to late. Anakin duels and ultimately defeats Darth Sidious making Anakin Skywalker or rather " Darth Vader " the new Dark Lord of the Sith AND in his mind, the new emperor and ruler of the galaxy... OK, now that we have established the events leading to it, here is where we find our problem. Anakin would never EVER become the new emperor. To the galaxy, Darth Sidious, or Emperor Palpatine was known as a regular human. Him being a Sith or a Force user as the general populace would not distinguish a jedi and sith. If a being uses the force and has a lightsaber, the general public will view them as a jedi. Palpatine was strictly known as human. Anakin, who btw is FAMOUS in the galaxy, a war hero used as the poster child for republic propoganda to boost Morale is known GALAXY wide as a jedi. Also remember, in this what if, anakin defeated obi wan, so physically and his appearance is still that of anakin skywalker whom again is so reknown and famous he is only shadowed by Palpatine. Also, the galaxy at large does not know anakin is with palpatine and thus EXCLUDED from the jedi purge. To the galaxy, he is a jedi, and a traitor and to be hunted down. So. with that also made clear. Anakin, after striking down the emperor in his private estate, would not have time to dispose of the body or erase all evidence of his presence where palpatine was to the galaxy, murdered. Whom by the way would be outraged and want justice, for at that short time emperor Palpatine was to the general galaxy, a Hero and respected and adored. And once it was announced that a jedi, who are now outlaws on the run. Murdered the beloved Emperor who ended the war, brought peace to the galaxy and erased the jedi who were not popular at all by the general public. The galaxy at large would demand justice and that anakin pay for his crimes. Anakin spoke of killing the emperor and ruling the galaxy as though hed literaly run him through with his lightsaber and just instantly replace him as emperor because as an individual he would be one of if not the most powerful being in the galaxy. But the emperor who, like he literaly said, " i am the senate ", was not emperor because he could myrk anyone that stood in his path, but because he literaly held all the political power and legally, by law! Anakin has 0 political power, hes not even in a position of any political power. After the death of the emperor, yes there would be a massive power vaccum and there would most like be alot of chaos and power grabs. But someone, probally a Moff, Tarkin perhaps. would assume the mantle and be emperor. This leaves anakin between a rock and DEAD place right? Because i dont care how powerful he is, if he wants to overthrow at this point, the government which is the empire and become the new emperor, he cant cut the head off the snake where the body dies because HAIL HYDRA! kill 1 and 2 more shall take its place. So that would mean hed have to destroy the entire regime meaning destroying the might of the entire imperial military. lol. unless hes got the infinity gauntlet with all the infinity stones, it aint happening...THATS IT! I know i over elaborated/explained however i was merely attempting to cover all my bases and leave no holes in my question/theory/what if/whatever this is. HOWEVER! If the maker of this channel reads this, i believe this would make for a very unique and interesting WHAT IF. How would the story play out, what would be anakins story or end, if he was on the run from the empire after he kills the emperor and is the most wanted being in the galaxy, with the jedi gone, him fully embaced in the darkside. Could he somehow overthrow the empire? Find a way through the force to become God like, as darth vitiate did ages past? or would he just be hunted like a dog to edges of space meeting his doom? God this has some serious potential. you heard it from me first! i need to make my own channel....Thank you for reading!

[@aggarius2944]

Zach Leathers only possible solution for anakin I can think of is if he can find a way to make padme queen. She has potential if sidious were to fall, no-one would have to know anakin killed sidious.

[@jerome96114]

Oh, that is a cool concept. I'd really like to see this covered.

[@SamCaiman14]

Obviously he would only overthrow Sidious, once he had enough political power to succeed him. Alternatively is quite possible if Sidious intended Anakin to overthrow him, that he had a secret will where he named Anakin as his successor.

[@cringecast5589]

was done in EP. 3 game, he stabs Sidious and becomes emperor, but padme never wakes

[@SamCaiman14]

CringeCast The Ep. 3 ending was non canon and horribly thought out. This is not Riddick. There is no way the Empire would accept Anakin as emperor just because he killed Sidious, he would be labelled a terrorist Jedi and pursued like a dog. His force powers were nowhere nearly as powerful to submit the Empire by himself, it would likely take him many years. Only the hypotethical Dark Yoda had the power at that time to subdue the Empire by himself if he so chose.

[@DevianTrickster]

That was just awesome!

[@mattnivison8566]

This is probe my favorite vide you've ever made!

[@wyattbrown4397]

I don't think that Padmé would be dumb enough to believe Anakin.

[@Ikaros23]

Anakin actually fell too the darkside when he executed all the sand people. women and children, old and sick. Some of them tortured and murderd his mother like animals so he himself became " a animal" and killed them all. Sidius manipulated him do it.... but it was he alone who reacted the way he did, not Sidius. He Choose the Sith Order ( Palpatine told him that he was a Sith and only with him could he get unlimited power and the power too live forever) the time when he was tested. It was when he first helped Sidius kill Mace then, killed the younglings in the temple, then the ultimate sacrifice when i choked Padme ( the sith test) that he was turnd to a sith lord and was granted the rank " darth vader". Remember... the dark side and the sith is not the same. Its like the differnse of a common solidier in the german army and a officer in the SS. The first maby did horrible things in the war, but so did all the other solidier on all the other " teams". Too join the SS is like joining the sith order. Many can become darkside users, and not become a true sith... feelings of love, hate, despair, lust, power, powerlessness, pain... can make them feel the darkside.... and use it... But Sith is something else. Too become a Sith lord means you have too do the ultimate sacrifice, kill a inocent or kill someone you love. Gå from fear-anger-hate--- too pure hate. be more like a animal or a machine. with no real moral code. Just a kode of death and power. Sidius knew that Anakin lusted power and that he was scared. He also knew that Anakin was in meny ways just a boy still and that he knew nothing of grand strategy and that he probably dident know much about the Sith and the dark side. Ore the force ore about life... Anakin was a praktical young man... not a big filosofer... Sidius knew this So he just pushed him, and he himself did the rest. Anakin just knew about power... he wasent as Yoda says " calme and relaxed". The jedi was foolish. they dident se that he was on the dark side long before he killd the young lings and Mace..... Mace himself said " i dont trust him"... Sorry for Mace is that he actually did trust Anakin, and it in the end cost him his life and the end of the jedi order and the Republic. My point is this... Anakin was seduced by the darkside, but he actually made a real choise to join the sith order.... He was a darkside user long before he did the ultimate crimes... and it all startetd bit by bit... a force choke here.... some anger using here and there etch... and it ended in mass murder . All along he broke all the rules... why???. Because they all told him that he was a " demi God"... Vanity and fear, was his motivs .Sorry for my bad english

[@ranibalakrishna3122]

This is really cool!

[@l.s.gordon6867]

Great video! :)

[@beaniebandit4645]

Can you do a what if of “what if obi wan never went to mustafar with padmé

[@StarWarsTheory]

Heck ya man

[@serter4545]

Beanie bandit what would that have changed?

[@beaniebandit4645]

ytsx Franchise because Anakin would have never fought him, would have attempted to turn padmé and he would have been in the darth Vader suit, becoming more powerful in the process. Personally I think this is a good story line. Hence why I suggested it.

[@_vavss_]

He probably wouldnt of choked padme

[@beaniebandit4645]

Bard true but I think he would have also tried to save her after said chocking padmé

[@serter4545]

what if anikan never got rebuilt as darth Vader but still turned to the dark side?

[@JokaInc]

ytsx Franchise I mean with those injuries, he'd likely not of survived lol

[@cesmatiq5180]

ytsx Franchise He would've became the most powerful force user to ever live.

[@SCRaetz]

iiCustomHD He would've been the most powerful paraplegic.

[@colinbrouillette304]

ytsx Franchise he would look like a fucking bizzare burnt starfish. or you can look to the ps2 game revenge of sith ending wh n you play as Anakin.

[@anthonyleramy3612]

also love this stuff thanks for what you do!

[@TEAPLE25565]

SW Theory, thank you! ive finaly getting back to starwars :-) out off all the theroy channels you are defenetly the best. one of the things that are spesial with you is that you are so grateful to your fans :-) keep up the good work, and let the force be with you:-)

[@blackflagsnroses6013]

Once again the Jedi fucked up everything. I love you Obi-Wan, but you done goofed.

[@thecowcanon]

The jedi order did fuck up. But Anakin was the driving force in this whole ordeal. His choices ended up biting his ass in the end. He did what he was not supposed to do. He let his feelings carry his mind and decisions. Even Obi-Wan Kenobi when losing his lover Satine Kryze stayed true to the rules and his character knowing that this would be the only solution, so to not let the evil in.

[@nenan3540]

Yes, they all should hail Anakin and give him what he wanted when he wanted, maybe they wouldn’t “give him” a reason to kill innocent children out of his rage.

[@sarasutaalon4039]

please make the what if video where obi wan doesn't board padmé' s ship.

[@StarWarsTheory]

Absolutely! Thanks for watching and for the request my friend. Hope you are well.

[@sarasutaalon4039]

Thanks for the reply. And keep up with your amazing videos.

[@Zane_Fukkatsu]

The Genocide Legacy in the words of darth sidious" Do it!"

[@nekayamamg2766]

These are really nice to listen to, like short voice books. I wouldn't know 10% of what i know about star wars now if i never started to watch/listen to your videos.

[@johnanus1384]

Congrats on 200k subs👍👍💥🎊🎉

[@thomasfouassier-orsolini8053]

what if Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi never go to Tatooine in the phantom menace

[@jplegend98]

Thomas Fouassier-Orsolini what if watto acepted republic credits

[@_chew_]

What if Jar Jar was the chosen one?

[@sonicbralaunik9671]

TheShadowOfMadness What if Jar- Jar was the true sith lord?

[@libruhmoment6387]

what if anakin turned back to the light when his legs were cut off on mustafar

[@sonicbralaunik9671]

bonkle arple prederctions That's kind of interesting... but ponder this. What if Anakin suffered amnesia after killing the jedi in the jedi temple or killing the leaders of the Confederacy?

[@libruhmoment6387]

Super Sanik now that's interesting, plus he's just pulling a reven

[@jovanrrosalez8542]

been here since 6k sub's love your stuff always makes me happy to watch your vids bast time killer keep up good work

[@ultralungs]

I'm a recent subscriber & I'm loving the videos man, keep up the good work

[@jwoodsonmusic]

What if anikan's mother never died?

[@mssimomeschini3243]

Anakin leave the jedi order because pregnant Padmé. He is raise Obi-Wan junior e Santine junior (it's so salty and sweety for your Jedi mentor) with him husband and "uncle" Ahsoka

[@i.cfidgets1289]

0:01 When my friend tries to take my girlfriend. lol

[@marcovelazquez1052]

really loved it

[@bryanlerma4035]

i just subscribed and im loving your channel👌👌👌

[@thecrowoverlord2463]

What if Grievous survived?

[@swrewind]

Sidious surely would have either used him for something, or would've had him killed.

[@thecrowoverlord2463]

Well Grievous probably would've found out, some way or another, that Sidious was Palpatine, and would just have continued the war against the Emperor.

[@jsharkgamer9733]

Do what if Star killer killed Vader and the emperor

[@_vavss_]

jshark gamer *THATS NOT CANON*

[@DarthSanguine]

+Bard Oh shut up, neither is the book this video is based on. Besides, Legends is way better than all the Disney shite. Episode 7 was just a mash-up of a bunch of stuff from Legends that came out years ago.

[@Nelo_Wolf]

+Darth Sanguine true, if they made a book based on what the canon is now

[@Funnotcommitment]

Nothing is more shite than The Force Unleashed.

[@magnussym580]

hey Dude, just discovered your Chanel and I wanted to say that it is really entertaining. So good job and keep it going... greatings

[@justplainyogurt9040]

Just want to say, another awesome video!! And nearly 3000 likes in < 1 day...quite phenomenal!! :) Also, yes absolutely to the proposed fan fiction for tomorrow...can't wait!

[@billgoat1522]

padme: anakin your breaking my heart! anakin: dont be silly padme its pronounced "neck"

[@kakkahomo908]

What if Yoda had went after Anakin and Obi-Wan had fought Sidious?

[@aggarius2944]

T3kzz anakin would have died and obi-wan would have died, padme would still die

[@aaroncannon2169]

Keep up the good work boss

[@easternpower5204]

awesome video :)

[@dearformerself]

Did you read my What If scenario I sent you about Leia???

[@rampantbroadcast5696]

"What If" every non force user grew tired of the jedi and sith dictating the fate of the Galaxy and actually took up arms against all force users and lead a crusade of extermination to all force sensitive beings.

[@TheSkully343]

So basically Kreia?

[@cassandrabelyeu2419]

I think that's what the Force made the Chosen One for. Not to destroy Force-users, but to end the toxic genocidal nature of both the Jedi and the Sith orders. The Jedi must End. So the Force could go ahead with more natural Force-users, who would use all of the emotions the Force gave them. The Force is made up of life, and the constant genocidal conflict between dark and light must have been destroying it piece by piece.

[@Brutallav]

I like how you include pics that help with the story, like Vader in the library.

[@larrykleist1295]

Cool vid. Keep it up.

[@nigelthorn4244]

What if yoda never existed in the Star Wars trilogy?

[@pennywise5135]

Nigel Thorn u said that 3 times shut up

[@nigelthorn4244]

Sorry I must be lagging

[@jaredheath3642]

hi

[@StarWarsTheory]

hey!!

[@jaredheath3642]

Star Wars Theory oh wow you actually replied. anakin is my fav character so glad your talking bout him

[@joshwigmore6657]

This channel is the best the force is defiantly with u xxxx

[@yaboitony3145]

I had a Star Wars marathon for the last 2 days 10/10 successful time

[@davelowe1647]

What if padme never existed?

[@swrewind]

Anakin would've most likely died a slave.

[@loudboy317]

Then, Luke and Leia wouldn't exist either and by extension, Kylo Ren wouldn't have been born. Plus, Anakin would never have become Darth Vader at all.

[@franciscopalacios2330]

Great video!! Can do you please finish some of the what if videos you have created!

[@mcwaltersampson3566]

Thanks for video. I will also need to get that book.

[@phigaro_]

Funny how the first 200 people say ''first' in the comments

[@jaredheath3642]

MrPine - Gaming and more... only 16 people have commented

[@phigaro_]

However there were about 200 views

[@jaredheath3642]

MrPine - Gaming and more... but only 16 people of the time commented

[@phigaro_]

They were part of the first 200 people

[@jaredheath3642]

MrPine - Gaming and more... but you said 200 people said first

[@marwan1414]

Do Jedi/Sith go to the bathroom???? I need to know this...

[@logik316]

Yes, but if need be they can telekinetically evacuate their bladders using the Force so they don’t get caught with their pants down.

[@theburneraccount1715]

Thank You

[@michaelkarimian7538]

Wow, truly a tragic life for Darth Vader. Nice video Star Wars theory, enjoyed hearing Vader's thoughts. If I may offer a few suggestions, could post the names of the music you use at the end of your videos? The music is beautiful. Also in the future do you think you could do SW book reviews? That would be swell if possible? Finally I believe a Fan Fiction about Padme hearing Padme out would be grand. Again thank you for the video and May The Force Be With You. :)