How Did We Get Here -- The History of the Israel / Palestine Conflict

[@carolinegeis7092]

This is the MOST VALUABLE CONTENT ON YT right now ! Everyone should hear this because very few understand this history!! Thank you ROY 😘🥰🙏🕯️🌍🕊️ THIS NEEDS TO BE SHARED WITH EVERYONE

[@tinakohf]

FYI, Roy, I love your calming voice. I never tire of it.

[@TheDomiDiamond]

Thank you Roy for making a video about this topic. My heart is so broken about the situation right now😢💔

[@Nicole_Marie_]

Thank you for doing this, Roy. I’m sharing it.

[@sr.saramariebelisleosf246]

Roy, your knowledge is amazing and so helpful. Prayers for you as I head off to a Holy Hour and Vespers. I don't know how many times I have given your testimony to family and friends...but every time I turn on one of your "current" talks I am so edified by your faithfulness and ability to teach us. God bless you a thousand-fold.

[@margaretscharff7792]

Thank you for this thoughtful history. I am an American Jew, and the way you tell the history is the same as my understanding of it. I think more people should hear this presentation of fact. Thank you!

[@myrzasabas5946]

Thank you very much for this presentation. This is my first time to see your site. I am a Filipino Catholic. Very much confused about all this violence in the Middle East. I have been trying to understand this situation, from the historical point. I would love to have more views on these.

[@deirdrefleming9935]

Half way through and finding this fascinating, thank you!

[@francesrosecarmel]

Thank you for your video today. Very informative. Many things did not know. Who knew there was no peace treaty (yet!). Your presentation much appreciated as to why there is such unrest even today...and continues. So sorry for all that has happened. Most people will not be even basically knowledgeable about the issues within the last century much less the last 2000 years. Hope peace comes for all the population there!

[@Razor-l8r]

This presentation was very informative, thank you! The Catholic bishops have asked the faithful for a day of prayer and fasting on Tuesday, for peace. 🙏🙏🙏

[@cristinamz2137]

will do. Thank you. I'll offer up my days for this cause.

[@gemmabienGo4100]

Thanks for shedding light on this complicated topic.

[@joanofarc6402]

Hello Roy. Long time no see. I still enjoy and appreciate all your teaching. 😊🙏🏻🙏🏻😇😇😇

[@namapalsu2364]

A Catholic take is what I've been waiting for in decades.

[@chuckincharlo]

Thank you for the presentation

[@jr4746]

How grateful I am .... Thank you so much 🙏

[@tony-gb5ub]

Very enlightening. Thank you.

[@kathleen2596]

Thank you. It was very informative.

[@mulipolatuuumataafatiufeaa4964]

This weekend's Office Psalms. Antiphons and Prayers are all about King David and Jerusalem even this 28th Sunday of Ordinary Time. I just finished praying it here from Samoa.What a Plan of God. God bless Israel..

[@cristinamz2137]

Amen!

[@GL-bd3kn]

I also pray the Office even though I’m not a religious.

[@fritula6200]

Bless you Muli...

[@dolphinm3639]

Very interesting. I know in Scripture the Lord gave the Jewish people the Land of Canaan which is Israel. God bless Israel. Thanks again.

[@lauragolini3442]

Thank you. Such a complicated issue!!

[@reneefornshill]

Thank you, Roy.

[@Stardust475]

It would've been good if you showed the Peel Commission partition plan for context and Arab violence in 1920s and 1930s. The Palestinians had many opportunities for a state

[@MHester-m3f]

Thank you for this. I could watch more from the Babylonian exile to present time - with maps, of course. Actually, I could watch a lot more, but am narrowing it down to only a few thousand years.

[@silviaibarra6771]

Everyday praying for Israel and the liberation of hostages.❤Thank you for this teachings

[@ElizabethKautzmann]

Best closing…. “Come LORD, JESUS… 🙏🏼🕎📖✝️… Hosana!

[@robertobeck1]

Thank you so much very clear exposition may I ask you where I can get the maps? RB

[@JewishCatholic]

The maps themselves come from various places. The geographic boundaries are not really disputed, just the demographic distributions. For the underlying demographic data, I recommend Joan Peters' "From Time Immemorial".

[@mikl4545]

Novena for Peace in the Holy Land Day 3: For those Fighting to Defend Life Let justice and mercy direct military leaders and protect innocent Muslims and Christians living under Hamas, as well as innocent Jews.

[@patricknovak3408]

Thanks for this show! Dont know who to believe

[@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw]

ברוך אתה, ישוע ה נצרי מלך👑 ישראל, אדונינו ו מלך 👑 ה עולם, כבד אתה. 🇻🇦✝️🇮🇱

[@JewishCatholic]

Translation: Blessed are you, Jesus the Christian King 👑 of Israel, our Lord and King 👑 of the world, honor be to you.

[@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw]

@@JewishCatholic Toda, Reb Shoeman. Is ינמי '- Yeshua (Ha) Notzri Melekh (Ha) Yehudim / Jesus (the) Nazarene (King of the) Jews.; as an acrostic. Is not the 'נ' for Nazarene, correct as 'נצרי' ?

[@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw]

@@JewishCatholic Ps: I know we Christians are referred to as 'Notzrim' pl. ie 'Nazarenes' rather than Meshikhim - Messianics by rabbinic authorities; but doesn't 'Notzri' translate into English as (the) Nazarene as well as 'Christian' ?

[@Chrisneryfisher5452]

Thanks, Roy.

[@edwardmarculewicz5140]

Bless you Baruch Ha Shem!

[@icxc88]

1st, thank you for this valuable lesson in history. I have ascertained much information governing my own Jewish Tribals' situation; Ruben, it appears we have completely lost our lands to the East of the Salt Sea (Dead Sea) to Jordan. 2ndly, Someone please advise me what to do as a wandering Jew. Thank you, very kindly. X

[@cristinamz2137]

Well..... what CAN we do? Perhaps do like they did in the old days.... PRAY and FAST...and maybe tear our clothes and cover ourselves in ashes...? I'm not Jewish, but I'll accompany you in prayer and supplication to our Lord that He will intercede YET AGAIN. Or who knows, this is perhaps His will.

[@johnroetzer2068]

I’m curious. How do you know you’re a Reubanite? I thought all the genealogical records were lost with the Temple.

[@icxc88]

@@johnroetzer2068 Ancient Jewish Secret.

[@soulabear9146]

​@@johnroetzer2068Lost. Destroyed. Scattered.

[@holyfamily8635]

A pointer. Will be great 👍

[@getsavedtoday8208]

Jewish catholic? I never saw that combination before; first time. Wow, excellent geography lesson. I have dragged for years trying to connect the dots between then and now of the biblical what, where, and whys of this history. History and geography were never my strengths and making sense of it was a struggle; and your presentation put the puzzle pieces together. Thank you. Are you a Rabbi or. a Father? Meaning, are you a Jewish Priest, or a Catholic Rabbi; how is the connection? Lately, I’m tracing, or rather following the journeys of Paul on my study Bible maps. There’s nothing like the visuals.☺️

[@cristinamz2137]

Jewish priest... Catholic Rabbi ... 😄 I like it.

[@eabm1984]

Our founders were primarily of Jewish heritage. There have ALWAYS been ethnic Jews as part of our Christian heritage/history.

[@paulasmalley1215]

You should watch his testimony

[@caliburnblade7895]

If i remember correctly St. Peter was the bishop of rome so jewish catholic is the default.

[@la.x-neverthedodgers]

He isn't the only one, i'm following at least three Jewish Catholics online.

[@jitiy3642]

Read Zechariah chapters 12 & 14, and Revelation 16. In relation to what’s going on now.

[@prarieborn6458]

Thank you !!

[@Lambsown1]

Thanks so much for this amazing video. I don’t know if you will see this comment as I am watching this 1 year after you did the video. Could you please comment on the Christians of Palestine? Where did they come from originally? Are they of Jewish descent? Or were they Arab Christian immigrants?

[@JewishCatholic]

Most of the Ottoman empire had significant Christian populations. Plenty of Christian Arabs, as well as Muslim ones, migrated into Palestine from the rest of the Ottoman empire .

[@geodude9537]

lol, jews have been there since 1200 BC , well documented, All Palestine people are squatters and always have been since Israel let the first of them move onto their land,

[@matthewkuboushek1614]

At some point in the future could you explain the expulsion of the Jews from Spain and the inquisition? Why did it happen?

[@JewishCatholic]

I would like to.

[@lida8433]

Thnx proffesor. Finnaly I get the ruth cause ...

[@justiceforallcreation]

I think this video is going to get a lot of traction, be prepared for that.

[@DAmend3]

There are no "Palestinians"; there are just Arab Isreali squatters that were formerly known as Syrians, Egyptians, and Jordanian Islamists. The Romans changed the name of Judaea province to Palestine in order to erase the Jewish presence in the land.

[@cslewis1404]

Can you go over Old Testament prophecies of Jews returning to Israel ?

[@tiger.wolf.2033]

Gad was also in Spain in the time of Jesus and recently an archeologist proved Jesus might have been in Spain too, and visited the Gad community too. It was a very interesting documentary to watch. And we must not forget the Jews were also in India, in Manipur and other areas, what makes me believe Jesus might have visted them too in his lifetime.

[@annemorton4731]

This video is not showing properly - frustrating!

[@Phoenix8Rising]

I knew that zionism was brought about, but did not know the idea originated in Russia. Fascinating history..🤔

[@anthonytan7134]

The tax called jiyziah, by muslims to unbelievers

[@luhoffma8836]

Jesus said he came for the lost tribes of Jerusalem.

[@josmith5419]

Why do you keep on saying “Palestine” throughout the whole video? I thought Palestine was officially named that in the 1900s.

[@JewishCatholic]

The geographic region (not a country or an ethnic group, but a geographic territory) was named that by the Romans in the first century, and it has been called that most of the time since.

[@josmith5419]

@@JewishCatholic Thanks so much! That helps a lot.

[@paulasmalley1215]

I love Harpa Dei.

[@Trenttrumps]

WWI ended with an armistice; treaty of Versailles stacked against Germany, who was winning the war.

[@comentedonakeyboard]

Perhaps it would be more acurate to say: the crusaders fought against the Jews, and the Sunnis and the Shiites and even local Christians (showing a rather obvious lack of political Skill)

[@ilonkastille2993]

What about the time BEFORE they were exiled to Egypt?

[@JewishCatholic]

"In Josephus's history, it is claimed that, after Ptolemy I Soter took Judea, he led some 120,000 Jewish captives to Egypt from the areas of Judea, Jerusalem, Samaria, and Mount Gerizim. With them, many other Jews, attracted by the fertile soil and Ptolemy's liberality, emigrated there of their own accord." They were eventually all enslaved to work for the Pharoahs.

[@lidiasoares5675]

Someone said that the evil Roman emperor, hated the Jews so he changed the name Israel to Palestina!!

[@Etnomotos]

Is Ezequiel 38 and 39 telling us what is happening in Israel right now? Is this war gonna last for 7 years?

[@la.x-neverthedodgers]

More so, 2022 - 2029, at least that was one out of many revelations given by the Blessed Mother to a Brazilian Priest.

[@realitywins9020]

From my research, I believe that Magog and many of the other nations mentioned in Ezekiel represent modern Turkey. There was a king called Gyges who ruled Lydia in Western Turkey. His name was pronounced Gugu in Akkadian the language of Babylon and he lived just before Ezekiel was writing. Turkey was the heart of the last Islamic caliphate and has murdered more Christians than any other nation in history. Erdoğan wants to revive the Islamic Ottoman Empire and is positioning himself as a protector of the Palestinians

[@johnmann8659]

@etnomotos Most likely the war of Psalm 83. Ezekiel 38 and 39 war will come further down the road. 👍

[@poorbanishedchildrenofEve]

Do people actually say there were no Jews in Palestine until the 1940s? Or are they saying there was no Jewish state known as "Israel" until the 1940s.

[@JewishCatholic]

The claim that is consistently made in the Arab world is that the Jews in Israel are "colonizers" that came in from Europe in the 20th century, and mostly after WWII. There was no Jewish state known as Israel until 1947, when it was established by UN Resolution 181. There also was no other state there -- it was a British territory, given to Great Britain as "spoils of war" after the Ottoman Empire was on the losing side in WWI.

[@Yawnyaman]

28.43 Oh dear, the British mandated territory amounted to about 200,000 Square miles.

[@JewishCatholic]

Oh dear. I can easily believe that I was the victim of a typo in the old reference book I was using. Assuming you are right I apologize to you and all.

[@pilarmehlis301]

It’s fine

[@davidsykes9331]

Remember Gal 3:28

[@mariacisneros6114]

🙏

[@ethiehetherington5086]

Go back as far as in Noah's time when he divided the world to his three sons. Noah gave the whole continent of Asia ( including Isarel ) to Shem. Ham's inheritance was the continent of Africa, and Canaan dislike his lot in Africa and went to dwell in Shem's land (in now Gaza ), and Noah and Japhet did not approve of. Canaan called the after his name. The land of Israel was given to the Jewish people not once, not twice but three times.

[@enriquemrodriguezbalsa2136]

Doesn't the hate between Chiis and Sunnites explain more the sad situation of the refugees than the animosity against Israel?

[@realitywins9020]

I don't think so. The Palestinians are almost entirely Sunni and went mostly to Sunni countries. The only exception is Lebanon which is a mix of Christian, Sunni and Shia. Iran is Shia but its further away and not Arab

[@jr4746]

...The Great Suliman? When Navy Christians were captured & England or killed?

[@patricknovak3408]

Did the name Palestine come from the Romans?

[@chuckyoneill9029]

Yes 70 a.d.

[@janetcohen9190]

Philistine in Latin is Palestine

[@LeutherGreengager-ip1uw]

@@janetcohen9190 Greco-Latin.

[@ruthmaryrose]

@@janetcohen9190 Thank you. I had no idea but it explains everything. I looked it up in the online etymology dictionary. It means unfeeling enemy.

[@janetcohen9190]

@@ruthmaryrose A good beginning! Let's be aware that etymology dictionaries vary greatly from one another. Also. overtime, usage in sales pitches, sports, politics and agendas, via msm to sway ideas and captivate minds, instigate, alienate, etc. Any time one seeks to demonise another, ''It means unfeeling enemy.'' ....becomes useful It's a repeated method and tactic.

[@patricknovak3408]

Hear u fine

[@migueliteux5061]

I read that the terrorists called their despicable attack the ‘deluge of Al Asqa’ because they claim some Jews allegedly went to the Al Asqua mosque to commemorate the Temple there. I always notice that the contention over the Temple Mount is always over Al Asqua as the site of the Temple. Apparently both sides now think the Temple was not under the dome of the rock but somewhere in the plaza in front of Al Asqua . My reading of some archeology there and ancient pilgrimage accounts to Jerusalem has lead me to believe that the rock under the dome wasn’t the foundation stone, but Gabbatha, the judgment seat of Pilate in the Praetorium in the fortress Antonia which overlooked the courts of the Temple. This hypothetical configuration of the Temple makes sense with the historical records like Josephus. Gabbatha then, in that location, also provides the context for the caliph Al Malik’s anti Christian inscriptions surrounding the rock inside the dome. The September cover story of the National Geographic reported that recent mosaic findings under the visible mosaics indicate that the first Umayyad caliph Muʿāwiya had initiated the construction of the dome of the rock which was later Islamisized by ʿAbd al-Malik. Muʿāwiya built other monuments on the Temple Mount during his reign and evidence points to him having been a Christian of some sort. The inscriptions inside the dome surrounding the rock made by caliph Al-Walid according to what is written in them but his father ʿAbd al-Malik may have actually initiated the inscriptions during his reign only to have been finished by his son Al-Walid. The ornate mosaics above the inscriptions are very similar to the ones in the Great Mosque of Damascus which lends support to the theory that Al-Walid had a part in their creation since he built the Damascus mosque over the ancient cathedral shrine housing the head of St. John the Baptist. That’s my theory at least.